- Partners
-
[[Sorry, had to step away for a minute. Back to analysis.
Shini didn't really make any substantial posts on day one, with the only notable one being their vote. I'm willing to give day one the benefit of the doubt due to timezone shenanigans and new player. So let's just focus on day two.
His first post on day two opens up with the timezone explanation and a few reads. The only one with much information on
More reads, Feels like pano and yellow are town, that uA is suspicious. Is cautious of me but I think it was a misread? I'd said that massclaiming is a strategy but not one to be done at this point.
Is corrected on me here, and starts to second-guess Pano
More reads - what was it about my readlist that made you need more time? Is suspicious of Seren primarily.
Discusses possibilities regarding Tetra.
Posts a bunch of theories here. Could be honest ideas, could be blowing smoke.
I don't have time to evaluate Seren. I know Yellow posted thoughts for them. BUt I needed to be in bed a while ago, and I would like to review Seren's posts for myself. So. Between Yellow and Shini, I feel like Shini has offered less, And while I still think this could be a case of a new player new player mistakes, my earlier theory of the Mafia not being able to communicate privately during the day could also explain things. So while I'm not 100% clearing yellow, I think SHini is the safer lynch.
Vote: ShiniGojira
@Inkedust
Shini didn't really make any substantial posts on day one, with the only notable one being their vote. I'm willing to give day one the benefit of the doubt due to timezone shenanigans and new player. So let's just focus on day two.
His first post on day two opens up with the timezone explanation and a few reads. The only one with much information on
[[FYI, my time zone's GMT+8, so when most of you are active, I'd be sleeping. That and I'm still kinda new to this forum and haven't learn everyone's names yet, like which one is Jackie again? The player pings only list your forum names.
And I still had schoolwork to do so I've been a bit busy.
Anyway, with that being said.
Tetra, I'll admit, I felt a bit sus of them at EoD but to me it felt like it was a bit too early to vote someone out, that and I'm still quite new to the game so I'm still not sure what I was supposed to be doing. Though after reading through their big post, I don't really feel much about them.
Pano, I feel good about them being town. Doesn't feel like they're doing or saying anything too sus.
Yellow's neutral. Not feeling too much about them.
Ua's pretty neutral, again not sure what to feel about him.
The other players, Hmm, I still need time to think about it.
More reads, Feels like pano and yellow are town, that uA is suspicious. Is cautious of me but I think it was a misread? I'd said that massclaiming is a strategy but not one to be done at this point.
Tetra is a bit sus due to all of the things that happened, that and Free dieing. Killer could be trying to frame Tetra or it's Tetra trying to keep Free quiet.
Pano. I feel is trustworthy. Though the idea of revealing our roles seems like a really terrible idea waiting to unfold. (Who knows how it'd go really)
Yellow is the main poker, trying for information and the like. Feels like a town's play since he's asking for people to actually say something.
Ua's inactivity and saying to abstain but votes Tetra does seem sus. But I'm not quite sure.
Minty. A fellow new player but unlike you. I sleep when everyone's active as the place that I live in is GMT+8. The posts I'd made were when there weren't much going on, plus the EoD things happened while I was asleep. But you feel like a townie despite my emotions saying otherwise.
Wind. I feel a bit sus about you wanting everyone to reveal their roles, as that's something a Mafia player would want, seeing as information is key to winning.
Seren. Not much I can really say except for maybe the throwback at Tetra's flavor. Feels like he's been the most quiet so far.
Is corrected on me here, and starts to second-guess Pano
... I misread Wind's post, thought they said it was a better idea to try Pano's suggestion now, rather than later. Sorry.
God, now you're making me double-guess Pano. He definitely poked a lot of people and we haven't really seen what he has to offer.
More reads - what was it about my readlist that made you need more time? Is suspicious of Seren primarily.
Tetra going off the rails and the sheer spam and emotions lead me to believe that she has a 90% probability of being town.
The possibility of a Bus Driver also explains why Jackie got a guilty lead on Tetra, so points to whoever thought of that to save Tetra.
The ones that feel the most town to me have to be Sind and Minty, mostly because I can't really comprehend a time where anyone that's Mafia would put such attention to details in such a small game.
Pano is leaning onto the town side for me, their pokes and providing suggestions and theories is definitely helping their case. (even if one of them didn't sound like a good idea, though that did kind-of work out since we now have certainty on two players being town)
Yellow still feels like a townie to me, haven't done much to make me believe otherwise.
Wind. I was gonna say something about their previous posts but the recent one made me need some more time to determine their presumed alignment.
Seren is doing a lot of questioning to a lot of people's ideas and suggestions. Mainly been quiet but I understand the busy schedule and all that. Though the other posts, to me, feels a bit sus, not sure why though.
Discusses possibilities regarding Tetra.
We have three possibilities if there is or isn't a deflector.
One, this is the possibility where there isn't a deflector and Tetra is Mafia or TP. We get a scum or TP detection from this.
Two, the possibility where there is a town deflector and Tetra is innocent. If we could get their input on who they deflected then yeah we got a scum read.
Three, the possibility where there is a scum deflector and Tetra is innocent, then we have a certainty of scum as deflector. (Can a TP be a deflector?)
Posts a bunch of theories here. Could be honest ideas, could be blowing smoke.
Okay, here's my take, and keep in mind. All of these are based on extremely paranoid ideas, hypothetical instances, long stretches and low probabilities (basically I'mma go full conspiracy theorist mode on) but hey, low possibilities don't mean impossible, right?
(I don't necessarily think any of this is true as some of them could only be pulled off by an emotionless strategist hell bent on winning. This is just an observation made by a paranoid person who knows nothing about the other players.)
I don't have time to evaluate Seren. I know Yellow posted thoughts for them. BUt I needed to be in bed a while ago, and I would like to review Seren's posts for myself. So. Between Yellow and Shini, I feel like Shini has offered less, And while I still think this could be a case of a new player new player mistakes, my earlier theory of the Mafia not being able to communicate privately during the day could also explain things. So while I'm not 100% clearing yellow, I think SHini is the safer lynch.
Vote: ShiniGojira
@Inkedust