[[Since I'm gonna be busy later tonight and probably not around for EoD, here's my readlist. Spoiler alert, almost everyone is pretty null to me right now.
Antares/Abra: I know I've already said why I feel the way I feel in terms of the Mudsdale comment, but allow me to further elaborate while I'm still stuck on it and why I am still eyeing them as soft sus. Last game, Namo's game, where I was indeed scum, Abra latched onto another very innocent comment I made and casted a vote/sus on me because of, and I quote, "their vibes." So the fact that they went ahead and latched onto ANOTHER innocent comment of mine and tried to see it as something suspicious pinged me because 1.) Felt like they were trying to go at me again for another very very small thing and 2.) I remember Abra's scum play being extremely "jumpy" in Humble Vale, so it really struck me as "Oh I was told to scumhunt, AH LOOK SOMETHING I CAN POINT OUT TO SCUMHUNT AH I'M TRYING TO BE HELPFUL SO I DON'T LOOK SUS AS FUCK." So, hopefully that explains why I've latched so hard onto it for now. But I will once again reiterate that it is mostly GUT VIBES, which is why I'm hesitant to vote on it, but not so much so to keep it in sights, especially given not much else is coming out of today.
Also, might I add that they were just pinged for reads by Jackie/Yellow and all they said was "I have nothing." They were VERY gung ho to try digging into me until everyone collectively told them the line of thought wasn't tracking, but when presented the opportunity to perhaps further scumhunt with a clearer line of thought, they dodged it? Just saying.
Altair/Inkedust: It took Windskull mentioning it, but now that I've gone back and re-read Inke's posts, I've noticed that she hasn't been as...aggressive as I recall her being in the last two games I've played with her. If I remember correctly, in Humble Vale and Namo's Role Overdrive, she was pretty damn on top of trying to keep everyone "on track" and moving forward if the group collectively got stuck on a dead end or on something that didn't really matter. She's been fairly limited with the contents of her posts this D1, and has mostly been sticking to RP. Basically the only thing she's offered so far in terms of "keeping people on track" is "yeah mailman thing is moot" after it had already been decided it's moot. Feeling soft sus right now, but she's since posted more as I was typing this so let me read and revisit this one.
Jet/Chibi: After scanning back through the posts again, I am GENUINELY confused about why people are reading Chibi so soft town when...I don't feel like they've offered much to the discussion aside from agreeing with certain posts and starting the vote on Nefari/DawningWinds. At most they feel very neutral-ish. Idk I usually feel like I see more attempts at puzzling things together from them and I haven't. So the immediate soft town reads from some of the posted readlists are really throwing me. Did I completely glaze over something, or?
Nefari/DawningWinds: While I did mention I was willing to throw in the vote for them due to inactivity, now that they are here and contributing, I don't really think they're very much on my radar anymore. Their annoyance at being vote trained for their inactivity for most of the day (for very valid reasons might I add) seems genuine, and while it in no way is indicative of their alignment thus far, I'm willing to shove them to neutral right now.
Rascal/Flyg0n: Also moderately inactive, and also for very good reason (feel better soon bby). I haven't garnered much from their posts, but I DID like how they pointed out the possibility of a JOAT--strikes me as them at least attempting to be helpful while being sickbrained, and trying to look into facets that other people have not yet. Neutral-ish right now. I need to see more from them before I can be certain.
Archie/Starlight: I love you but you're a fucking enigma to me lol. All I really have from you is that you got a Mailman message about Mr. Roger's Neighborhood. I also have a habit of reading you scum when you're actually not scum, so like. Neutral and I'm not touching you with a ten foot pole until we get further into the game lol.
Jackie/Yellow/Neo/Lurosa: I am getting hella bad vibes from the vote against DW, though that might be my personal bias because I feel like abstaining right now. However, I do see that they are genuinely trying to do some puzzling, and what has really stood out to me is Jackie complaining about the excessive RP--when we were scum together, I very CLEARLY recall Jackie suggesting that scumteam do some heavy RP to stall any extra deliberation on votes and keep people busy. There's a lot of RP happening that I think scum!Jackie would be all for continuing to happen, if I'm on track with my thinking. Very, very soft town right now, I say hesitantly.
Karo/SikeSaner: Extremely neutral right now. I see them offering a little to the discussion about the mailman and whatever, but I don't remember seeing much after. I've never played with Sike so I'm more or less sitting back and letting their posts compile before I really go in for a harsh read. Another person I'm really not touching right now.
Steven/Panoramic_Vacuum: Ehhhhhhhhhhhhhh neutral-ish. Most of their posts are primarily just RP and trying to make sense of whatever is going on, so I don't really have much for them. Kind of like Chibi, I feel like I usually see them being a little more out there with their puzzling of things, and they've mostly just been kinda flail-y/trying to figure things out-ish right now. Could be genuine, could be trying to get the hang of playing scum because I don't think Pano has ever rolled scum? Wary.
Kichiro/Virgil134: Also neutral. I haven't seen them add too much to the conversation much either or say anything that warrants extra looking. I haven't played with them either so also setting that aside until I hear more from them.
Muse/Windskull: Right now, I feel pretty good about them. Fairly soft town feels from their posts, but they are few and far between. I kind of want to see more, but what I have seen seems pretty helpful to start.
May/Dragonfree: I don't really know, I have admittedly only skimmed Free's posts and nothing is striking me as particularly out of the ordinary or weird? Suffice to say that could go either way in terms of her, soooooo I'm neutral until I can maybe read a little more.
Burhalla/IFBench: Not offering much, but playing the same as I've always seen them play. Neutral.
There have been a lot of posts as I was typing this out so some of this is subject to change after going through them and seeing what's being said, but this is where I stand right now. Feel free to combat me because I have a history of Speedreader Syndrome(TM) and glazing over important shit. I am also notoriously bad at getting reads D1 so please donut roast LOL]]