Spiteful Murkrow
Busy Writing Stories I Want to Read
- Pronouns
- He/Him/His
- Partners
-
Heya, it’s been a while, but I got a prize review for three chapters of OSAS put in my docket as part of RB5 and I figured that you’d been waiting long enough for some signs of life on that front. As I’m sure you’ve seen from my prior reviews, my normal reviewing style is pretty uncompressed, so today I’ll just be covering the first of the three chapters from my end with…
Chapter 3
I mean, considering the competition that Phenac has in Orre for “photogenic towns”... yeah, it more or less wins by default unless you’re just really a ‘tree’ person.
Oh, so Pokémon being named is common in this setting. I mean, I suppose that I already knew that Neo and Novo were named and that literal whos nickname their Pokémon through Nameless, but it’s nice to have confirmation.
Neo: “*I like her, Wes! Let’s bring her along on our journey!*”
Wes: “Oh for crying out loud…”
Huh. I wonder if that implies that as a snagger that Wes was tasked to bag specific species of Pokémon to bring back to Team Snagem, since you’d think that someone who by trade stole Pokémon from other people would be a bit more in-tune with different species and techniques so as to avoid getting caught off-guard.
Novo: “*Also, because we need to do some things differently from the original games, so… yeah, following Pokémon’s as good a place to start as any.*”
Though from what I’ve heard through the grapevine of what happened in Wes’ childhood, I don’t blame him for not wanting to really talk about it.
Given that Wes visibly hesitates before giving his reply to Rui there, I wonder if it’d have made sense to show off a bit more of his internal thought process here, since the dialogue reads as if he had something come to his mind from Rui’s question but we don’t really get to see it.
I kinda wonder if this “making him feel more threatened” would work better as something that’s ‘shown’ more in the sense of what concrete things he feels threatened by. Like is Wes worried about Rui outing his background? Is she getting too close to traumatic life events? Stuff like that.
Boy, Wes’ childhood really must’ve been quite crap if this is the half-truth version of events.
I see that Wes isn’t much of a people person. Or at least not at this point in time. :V
IMO, it might make sense to show off a bit more of Rui’s reaction to Wes here, since I assume that she was probably taken aback a bit by how bluntly he just ‘no’s her question here.
Though I wonder if that inner thought implies something about Wes’ childhood home. Maybe I’m thinking a bit too hard about things, but it almost reads as if he’s saying that the place he grew up from wasn’t all that different from Agate Village.
Ah yes, cue the theme song for this moment. So are they also going to troll the Castform trainer and get him to wait to the point where it looks like his Castform is chasing him around?
I admittedly did a double-take here, since at first I thought that this scene was meant to be written explicitly from Wes’ perspective but we just veered into Rui’s here. Like it works if you’re doing omniscient perspective, but I do wonder if in that case, there should’ve been a bit more of Rui’s perspective earlier on to make it obvious that this isn’t third-person limited narration from Wes’ perspective.
Not yet, anyways. That’s more a luxury Michael will get to enjoy. Though I did always find it weird that you could only get them from that one guy who runs the diner in Colosseum.
I’d make a snarky quip about how Rui really hasn’t gotten around in life, but then I remembered that wild Pokémon are canonically close to nonexistent in Orre, so this is significantly more manageable than one would think for someone who’s lived most of their life in Agate Village.
Wes: “(Actually, on second thought, maybe I can imagine her on the streets of Pyrite… for all of like five minutes before those two dweebs stuffed her into a sack.)” [lyleunamused]
I was joking with that cutaway gag.
Wes:
“Yeah, okay lady, but since we’re on this topic…”
Wes: “... Have you ever heard about this thing called the ‘internet’? You can just buy stuff through it and have it shipped to your door.”
Rui: “Look, the narrative this story is based around was written in the early 2000s, alright? And just how reliable do you think that parcel delivery services are in Orre of all regions?” >_>;
Oh, so we are getting some Spanish/Latino influence in this story. Though I suppose you can’t say that it’s not fitting for the region that mainlines the Arizona vibes.So when can I expect that Día de Muertos special to pop up?
Though for the record, if that’s indeed what you’re going for, unless if you’re very deliberately giving off the vibe of Rui’s grandfather being her surrogate father (since “papí” is a phrase equivalent to “daddy” in Spanish), you’d want Rui to be saying “abuelo” here. Or if trying to preserve the same cutesier vibe as “papi/daddy”, “abuelito”.
Also, nice call forward to XD’s Poké Spots, since… yeah, even if it’s still pathetically limited by the standards of a normal region, there are actual wild encounters in that game.
Wes: “Okay, seriously, you can’t just pepper me with questions and not expect me to return the favor. What’s the story behind why you’re getting these Pokéballs and not your old man?” >:|
Yeah, Rui’s going to get herself into trouble at multiple points in this story, I can already tell. Though I’d recommend chopping up Rui’s paragraph of dialogue here into a few smaller ones, especially since the first part of it feels very heavy relative to the rest.
Wes: “... Okay, let me rephrase that question there…”
Well, at least Rui has a good sense of humor to take these things in stride? Though I suppose it’s a nice demonstration of how her and Wes’ personalities differ from each other.
Wes: “Um… you’re welcome, I guess?”
Well that’s significantly nicer than that little hole-in-the-wall with an entrance jammed underneath an aqueduct he’s got in the official games. Though I wonder if the aqueduct’s still there too in OSAS’ rendition of Es Cade’s house or not.
Oh hey, there’s a reaction image summing up Wes’ general thought process right about now:
Well that one’s certainly new. I think. I’m pretty sure that Es Cade didn’t have a doorman the first time you go to his place in the games, but it makes sense that he’d have on in a more grounded telling of Colosseum since… yeah, Orre’s not exactly a nice neighborhood.
Oh, so that’s the justification for why we never see Pokémon strutting around indoors in Colosseum. It does make me wonder if we’ll see departures from the default depiction for whoever’s in Wes’ team in more homely environments like the house where Rui’s grandparents live.
Huh, it’s subtle, but that’s definitely different from the layout in the games, even if I suppose the original layout was a bit too “video game”y to be present in most people’s houses realistically. I wonder if you also do similar little departures here and there in this story given that IIRC it winds up diverging noticeably from Colosseum’s canonical narrative at some point down the road.
Well, the man certainly knows how to put on a show for guests. Though I suppose that is on-brand for Es Cade.
I went and fired up Bulbapedia to check this since that seemed like a very “actual Orre NPC name” and…
So that’s who the doorman you cast was, and explains why I didn’t remember him from Colosseum. Though I see that there will be callaheads to XD aplenty in this game, though I suppose that the role that you gave him here does seem like it’d give him a plausible path to taking on the role he has in XD.
Huh, wonder what the story behind this surname is. At first I was going to say that the ‘Lin’ was a clever nod to how she hails from a forest, but that doesn’t quite work with the ‘Ever’. I suppose we’ll find out more as this story goes along.
Just saying, considering the vibe of the name and of the neighborhood you’re operating in, you missed the chance to roll ‘Lobo’, ‘Lobos’, or ‘López’ as a surname, all of which carry the same semantic shtick you’re going for with ‘Lycas’ there.
Though eh, I won’t question it. Since while it’s definitely not a surname you’ll run into IRL a whole lot, it does fit in decently well with a neighborhood where mothers think to name their kids names like ‘Es-Cade’ and ‘Eldes’.
Es Cade: “I’d like to think that I’m pretty good at staying on top of things. Including things that the general public overlooks, what exactly is going on here?”
A bit of a stylistic nitpick, but I feel that in this particular case, Es Cade’s line works better coming after his eye-widening moment. Well. Maybe. There’s an argument that I can think of offhand for sticking to your guns here: namely if Es Cade’s reaction is rehearsed and not genuine considering what he ultimately turns out to be in Colosseum, but it’d probably work best if there were other moments during this encounter that helped sell the effect.
Well that’s definitely different from the game, even if it makes more sense than in the game given that if my memory serves me right, you basically strut in and Rui plops “I see Shadow Pokémon” right into Es Cade’s lap without a proper introduction. Though I wonder if we’ll see elements of the original exchange surface at all.
Riley: “Am I a joke to you?” >:|
Wes: “Go away, your game didn’t release for 3 years after ours, and you’re supposed to be up in your snowed-over craphole.” >_>;
Wes:
“... Wait, you’re not laughing her out of the room as a crank right now?”
Es Cade: “Well, Mr. Lycas. When you grow to be a man as old and experienced as me, you learn that sometimes things that sound fantastical on their face are worth hearing out. Really an underappreciated sentiment among the young generation these days.”
It might be worth showing off Es Cade’s reaction to Rui here a bit more. Especially if you want to subtly foreshadow what he’ll be up to in the later parts of your story.
Es Cade:
“With all due respect, Ms. Everlin, but Pokémon trying to kill each other in fanfiction isn’t exactly an uncommon occurrence.”
Rui: “Look, they don’t have evil auras attached to them while doing that normally!”
Korrva SD00573: “*Actually, some of us don’t feel anything at all about killing our enemies.*”
Wes + Rui: “...” O_O;
Es Cade: “... Oh, her. Yes, we’ll just get her out of the room right now where you hopefully won’t be meeting each other for a long, long time in this story. Preferably never, really. (Dammit, I knew that Ein forgot something from his visit to my office…)”
Rui: “... I’m sorry, but why on earth did you have that just-?!” O_O;
Es Cade: “We’re getting off topic right now! Anyhow, you were saying something about ‘evil auras’ or whatnot?” ^^;
Oh hey, it’s almost literally the Batman Beyond gif, just more polite. o<o
Rui: “But you literally just had a Pokémon that was-!” O.O
Es Cade: “Your eyes were just deceiving you, my dear. And if they weren’t, it wasn’t canonical anyways. I assure you, I will do what I can to see that this dangerous Makuhita is dealt with.” ^^;
Wes: “(Yeah, he’s just going to blow us off to go play bingo at the retirement home, I can already tell.)”
Ah yes, a future Cipher admin from XD just casually playing waiter for everyone. I can already tell that he doesn’t acknowledge this menial tasks phase after climbing the ranks a bit more. >:V
Nice little bits of foreshadowing there about Es Cade and the places he’ll be going later in this story if it generally tracks Colosseum’s narrative.
I mean, you’re not wrong there. Especially considering that Es Cade doesn’t exactly have good reasons to want to help out with your request.
I really should be less surprised that Wes is this blunt since… yeah, he kinda vibes as being that sort of character. ^^;
Rui, don’t make me break out the Bender gif again. Though that makes me wonder if her aura-vision only works on Pokémon. Since if it also works on humans... well, a lot of things in this story would’ve gone differently. Especially in this chapter.
They also evolve from Sun Shards and Moon Shards, which appear in your region a couple years down the line from where you and Rui are at and precisely nowhere else in Pokéworld that we know of thus far.
Narrator: “Lol. Lmao.”
Wes: “Hey! What’s that supposed to mean?!”
Neo: “*Oh come on, Wes. Are you really telling me you want to part ways from her? Really?*”
Novo: “*It would be a bit of a short story without her given that this is a Colosseum novelization, just saying.*” ^^;
Ah yes, it’sRiku from Kingdom Hearts Nascour. Pleasure meeting you there. /s
Oh, so Wes himself feels fear at times in this story. I mean, it makes sense, but I’ll admit that I still did a double-take here with how collected he’s normally been in this story up to this point.
And a major boss fight you two are going to have to deal with down the road, but that’s a story for another day.
Narrator: “He will absolutely wind up tangling with that man.”
Wes: “Not if I bounce out of Orre first-”
Narrator: “Wes will absolutely not bounce out of Orre first.”
Wes: “Oh come on!”
Not sure if I want to know what that implies for what Pokémon medical care looks like outside of Phenac in this setting, really.
Ah yes, so we’re going to get to see Wes save his game in this story, too. /s
Huh, that’s definitely a new one. Though I’m surprised that those facilities are remaining open and not monitored or else pre-emptively shut down given that Shadow Pokémon are canonically starting to hit broader circulation at this point in Colosseum, which you think would cause incidents for mixed play areas meant for Pokémon.
Oh, so they have those here too, huh? I guess it makes sense since even in the earliest seasons of PokéAni, there was video calling technology that was widely dispersed.
Neo: “*Oh come on, Wes. It’s literally right there...*”
Yeah, I figured.
Right, Orre and Johto are geographically contiguous with each other in your continuity. That one threw me for a bit, but it makes sense that that would be on the shortlist of places for Wes to head to after bailing on Orre.
Actually, that makes me wonder where Orre is located relative to Johto in this setting anyways. My reflexive assumption was that it’d be northward since there’s a whole lotta nothing that we know of north of Mt. Silver and its surroundings, but the sea in the southwest of Orre kinda throws a wrench into that.
Oh, so Wes finally blowing off Orre in favor of Johto after the events of Colosseum / this story is the reason why Michael had to step in and fill his void in XD / OSAS 2: Desert Boogaloo, huh?
Wes: “Or, I could get onto my bike and ride off into the sunset towards Johto and not stay a moment longer in this craphole. I hear Cherrygrove City’s a really pretty place around this time in spring.”
Narrator: “There would absolutely be more detours before reaching Gateon.”
This IMO works better if Rui has some sort of reaction before she starts speaking, especially if she’s initially pretty shook by how Wes just casually shoots down her offer to go to Agate Village.
Wes: “I mean, recently, obviously since otherwise it wouldn’t be a news story, but let’s not worry about the criminal scum that would bring up awkward questions for me right now, hm?” ^^
I think that we’re missing a bit of context here as to why uncovering Team Snagem’s hideout would be earth-shattering news, especially for readers that aren’t coming in with the benefit of context of a Colosseum playthrough. It might make sense to give a passing mention in a sentence or two of what Team Snagem is known for around Orre such that this is such a “big deal” at the moment.
Wes sure has a way with people, doesn’t he? I can already tell that he’s going to have a lot of lulzy moments like these down the road.
IMO, it might make sense to explicitly assign the middle paragraph of dialogue to Rui, since at first I thought that that was Wes speaking there.
Rui had a Pokémon stolen at some point prior to OSAS’ events, didn’t she? Since that definitely feels very opinionated and venomous there.
Wes:
Rui: “Wes, why are you reacting like that?”
Rui: “Good. You were starting to worry me there for a second.”
Wes: “(Okay, yeah. I really need to blow her off and make it to Gateon now.)”
To clog your cats’ arteries with more bacon grease? o<o
Wes: “(Come on Wes, just ignore it and let her go, it doesn’t involve-)”
Wes: “(Oh dammit. Though I suppose it can’t hurt to at least get her a proper meal first…)” -_-;
Novo: “*Come on, Wes. You know you want to help her…*”
Wes: “(Oh for crying out loud, not you two as well!) >.<
Ah yes, guilt and past trauma. Always good motivators for ignoring that voice in your head that’s going “no, ignore the girl, get on the bike, and keep going until you hit Gateon”
Whelp, I suppose that that’s one way to tell that Wes has had a definitive break with Snagem if he’s just going “no, shut up, old man” to the past wisdom he received while part of it.
Wes: “No, but I also don’t like seeing you like this, and it’s not exactly hard to find a diner in Phenac. So come on already.” >_>;
And no idea what to do with people in general based off some of the interactions we’ve seen between him and Rui in this story thus far. >:V
Ah yes, taking Rui to some dive that Team Snagem members liked going to. What could possibly go wrong with this idea here?
Wes: “... I’m sorry, how long did you say you were in that sack again?” .-.
Rui: “No clue, really!” ^^;
I mean, this sounds like a fantastic way of running into your old buddies from Team Snagem, just saying. Especially if you weren’t the only one from the team who used to go to this dive, Wes.
I’m… not sure if I want to know what Neo and Novo used to eat while in Team Snagem’s care, really.
So… beer or tequila?
Wes: “I was thinking more ‘Everclear’ really, since gods, I really need a drink after everything I’ve been through lately.” >_>;
Could’ve fooled me with your in-game model, lady. Especially since Wes word-of-god is around 17 years old at the time of Colosseum’s events.
Aha, I see that the characters are a bit aged up for this narrative. Though I suppose that it makes sense given that it’s a bit harder-edged than the official Colosseum narrative and… yeah, there’s definitely less suspension of disbelief needed to make some of Wes’ antics seem plausible if he’s not literally a high school dropout.
Yeah, I stand by my observation earlier that Wes is not a people person.
Yeah, I had a feeling that Wes was going to blunder into his fair share of moments like these. Even if I wasn’t expecting quite so many all in this one chapter.
Oh, so there’s our nod to Wes’ canonical age in this story here. Clever tie-in there.
Novo: “*Actually, it’s official game canon-*”
Wes: “Nobody asked you, Novo!”
I mean, if she wasn’t, would you have noticed her in that burlap sack she was shoveled into?
Wes: “(Gods, that trip to Gateon and boat ride to Johto can’t come soon enough at this rate.)” >///<
Wes, just saying, but can you tempt fate any harder right about now?
Yeah, I knew that he was tempting fate there. Though let’s see who he ran into.
Neo: “*Okay, seriously, Wes. The burger was good and all, but what on earth did you think was going to happen when we came back to one of your hangouts from your old job?*”
If these are meant to be specific members of Team Snagem that appear later on in the story, it might make sense to explicitly namedrop / give context as to who these Snagem members are, since it feels a little weird for Wes to go “oh, I know these people” without getting more insight into his thought process about who these people are.
Which is a sign that he’s going to be outed in about a minute from this point, since that’s the way stories generally work. ^^;
Rui: “Um, Wes? Who are these people again?”
Wes: “People we really, really don’t want to get involved with. (Also, hey, do you see where I parked my bike at all?)”
Oh, so there’s our “oh, I know that voice” moment. A part of me wonders if it should’ve come a bit earlier into this sequence, or at least the namedrop portion of it, but eh. It does its job here.
… Actually, wait. Where is Wes’ bike at the moment? Like I know that canonically you don’t have it with you while in Phenac, but it makes me wonder if at minimum it should be a bigger part of Wes’ thought process here since you’d think “dammit, of all the times not to have my bike
” would be on the radar for him getting stuck in the same general vicinity as a very, very pissed Wakin.
Rui: “... Wes, please tell me that these three aren’t the people you have in mind for getting Pokéballs from.”
Wes: “Look, I’ll spot you the money, but we really need to get going if you want to make it. So are you in, or no?” O_O;
Whelp, hope Neo and Novo enjoy sharing a sidecar, since… yeah, I’m not sure if it’s even physically possible to squeeze a second rider behind Wes on that abomination of a bike he has.
Wes: “Technically, it’s more of a mashup of a unicycle and a hovercraft, but look, the point is that it’ll get us to the Pokéball seller and away from these guys really, really fast. So keep quite and follow me.”
Let’s not even get into how he’s got the Snag Machine still on his arm and is dressed like an extra from The Matrix right about now, since… yeah, that’s definitely not going to blend in with a crowd. ^^;
Wes: “Look, I’m not going to call it a ‘unicycle’, okay? That just makes it sound stupid.” >_>;
Cue them getting spotted in 3… 2…
Huh, that went better for Wes than I was expecting, really. I suppose the shoe regarding his involvement with Team Snagem will wind up dropping another time.
Alright, made it to the end of things. I see that we’re still in the slower initial “Hello World” part of the story, but I thought that it was a pretty neat glimpse into your take on Colosseum’s cast and world since your take on Wes and Rui and Wes’ Eeveelutions are pretty fun to see bounce off each other. There’s clearly a lot of attention to detail worked into your depiction, with a lot for people who are into the Orre games to stop and go:
About, and to its credit, almost all of those nods to later events in Colosseum and XD are worked in quite well into the story. Like there’s some parts that are obvious departures from the base narrative, but they’re done in fashions that feel believable and still in line with Colosseum’s broader atmosphere such that it still feels apt to call OSAS a Colosseum retelling, while adding some distance from “literally just the game” since… yeah, people can just play the games for that.
I don’t have too much in the way of criticisms of this chapter, with the bulk of the ones that I do have basically boiling down to disagreements about wording or paragraph formatting here and there. There were a couple spots where I thought that it might’ve made sense to stop and give a bit more description or “narration through Wes’ lens”, as well as one spot where we dipped into Rui’s perspective that felt like a huge outlier since everything else in the chapter’s narration is pretty clearly done in Wes’ PoV, but it wasn’t frequent enough to be really distracting. There were a couple spots where I wonder if you played things a bit too close to the chest in terms of providing details (e.x. the context behind why Team Snagem’s hideout going up in smoke would be a big deal™), but most of those are relatively minor issues that can be smoothed out with a bit of additive editing.
I’m honestly a little embarrassed that it’s taken me this long to come back to this story, since just getting back into this chapter, I remembered why I had a fun time with the first two back in… -checks notes - RB4. We’ll see how well things hold up over the next couple chapters on my docket, but thus far, the story’s been doing a good job at getting me interested in what’s coming next.
I’ll be seeing you again a couple more times in the coming weeks @HelloYellow17 . Hope the feedback was helpful, and I’ll be looking forward to seeing what goes down in your fourth and fifth chapters. ^^
Chapter 3
Sunlight streamed down on the whitewashed streets and sparkling fountains, and there was no respite from the blinding brightness and burning heat as Wes and his Pokémon walked with Rui to the mayor's home. The girl certainly noticed this, as she commented for what must have been the fourth time on how beautiful the city was.
"I haven't been to Phenac in a long time, but it's even more beautiful than I remember!" she said in awe. "It's so lovely!"
I mean, considering the competition that Phenac has in Orre for “photogenic towns”... yeah, it more or less wins by default unless you’re just really a ‘tree’ person.
Wes shot her a look—or tried to, but ended up looking over her head. He had to drop his gaze significantly to actually make eye contact. Arceus, this girl was small. Just how old was she, anyway?
"Not for years," she said. She still wore a small smile on her face as she talked. "I was just a kid the last time I was here." Her attention shifted to the Eeveelutions striding at Wes' side. "What are their names?" she asked lightly.
Oh, so Pokémon being named is common in this setting. I mean, I suppose that I already knew that Neo and Novo were named and that literal whos nickname their Pokémon through Nameless, but it’s nice to have confirmation.
"The Espeon is Neo, and the Umbreon is Novo," he said. She already knew his name, so he figured the names of his Pokémon were inconsequential information to give out at this point.
"They're beautiful Pokémon!" Rui exclaimed, admiring Novo's sleek black coat. Neo looked over his shoulder and chirped happily at the compliment. He was always pleased to be acknowledged.
Neo: “*I like her, Wes! Let’s bring her along on our journey!*”
Wes: “Oh for crying out loud…”
Wes felt a prickle of unease at her comment. He was painfully aware of Neo and Novo's rare species being capable of drawing attention. Fortunately, in a place like Phenac, rare Pokémon weren't an unusual sight; Wes had seen plenty of Pokémon in his days at Snagem, but even he couldn't identify half the Pokémon trotting at their trainers' heels in this city.
Huh. I wonder if that implies that as a snagger that Wes was tasked to bag specific species of Pokémon to bring back to Team Snagem, since you’d think that someone who by trade stole Pokémon from other people would be a bit more in-tune with different species and techniques so as to avoid getting caught off-guard.
Not that showing off had ever been Wes' motivator for keeping his Pokémon out. Neo and Novo were security, an extra set of eyes, and even though Wes hated the awed looks they received from passersby, it was a necessary precaution with Snagem on his tail.
Novo: “*Also, because we need to do some things differently from the original games, so… yeah, following Pokémon’s as good a place to start as any.*”
Neo strayed to a nearby waterfall and swiped a paw through the water before bounding playfully back to Novo, who greeted him with an affectionate headbutt. Rui giggled and looked back up at Wes.
"So...Wes, was it? Where are you from?
"Nowhere, really."
Though from what I’ve heard through the grapevine of what happened in Wes’ childhood, I don’t blame him for not wanting to really talk about it.
"Oh? Did you move around a lot?"
[ ]
"...yeah."
"That's so fascinating! I've only ever lived in the same town my whole life, so I haven't been to many places."
Obviously, Wes thought dryly.
Given that Wes visibly hesitates before giving his reply to Rui there, I wonder if it’d have made sense to show off a bit more of his internal thought process here, since the dialogue reads as if he had something come to his mind from Rui’s question but we don’t really get to see it.
"So was there a reason for you moving so much? Was it for your parents' work?" Those blue eyes sparkled excitedly as she talked to him.
Too many questions. Nervousness flitted about in his chest. She was entirely too curious, and every question was making him feel more and more threatened.
I kinda wonder if this “making him feel more threatened” would work better as something that’s ‘shown’ more in the sense of what concrete things he feels threatened by. Like is Wes worried about Rui outing his background? Is she getting too close to traumatic life events? Stuff like that.
The familiar, growly voice rang in his head again. The best lies are half-truths, boy.
"I sort of...grew up on the streets, actually," he answered hesitantly.
Rui's eyes widened and the brightness vanished from her eyes. "Oh." She dropped her gaze to the ground. "Oh. I'm...I'm so sorry. I had no idea."
Boy, Wes’ childhood really must’ve been quite crap if this is the half-truth version of events.
An awkward pause. Taking advantage of the silence to divert the attention away from himself, Wes curtly asked, "And you?"
"Oh, I'm from Agate Village!" She looked up at him again, appearing relieved to be talking about something else. "It's absolutely beautiful there—have you ever been?"
"No."
I see that Wes isn’t much of a people person. Or at least not at this point in time. :V
[ ]
"Well, you should definitely visit sometime. It's completely different from anywhere else in Orre!"
How would you know?
IMO, it might make sense to show off a bit more of Rui’s reaction to Wes here, since I assume that she was probably taken aback a bit by how bluntly he just ‘no’s her question here.
Though I wonder if that inner thought implies something about Wes’ childhood home. Maybe I’m thinking a bit too hard about things, but it almost reads as if he’s saying that the place he grew up from wasn’t all that different from Agate Village.
He was momentarily saved from the agonizing small talk as they rounded a corner and the marketplace came into view. The place was crowded with people and Pokémon alike, dotted with vibrant colors of foreign Pokémon and their trainers. Open-air shops under white canopies lined both sides of the street and offered a wide variety of products that could be found nowhere else in Orre: fresh fruit, imported goods, and a wide variety of fabrics, amongst other things. Vendors, citizens and tourists alike bustled from one booth to the next, and the air was buzzing with snippets of conversation here and there.
Ah yes, cue the theme song for this moment. So are they also going to troll the Castform trainer and get him to wait to the point where it looks like his Castform is chasing him around?
"Aguav berries! Hondew berries! Come and get your exotic berries here!"
"How much for this bag?"
"Forty Poké? That's entirely too much, I won't go above thirty!"
"...Wow," Rui breathed in amazement. She quietly soaked in the scene for a moment as they walked, and Wes huffed a sigh of gratitude for the reprieve. It didn't last long, however, because soon she was tugging on Wes' sleeve.
"Hey, do you think they'll have Pokéballs here?"
I admittedly did a double-take here, since at first I thought that this scene was meant to be written explicitly from Wes’ perspective but we just veered into Rui’s here. Like it works if you’re doing omniscient perspective, but I do wonder if in that case, there should’ve been a bit more of Rui’s perspective earlier on to make it obvious that this isn’t third-person limited narration from Wes’ perspective.
Wes frowned at her. Pokéballs? This girl was just getting weirder and weirder by the minute. "Phenac doesn't sell Pokéballs anywhere."
Not yet, anyways. That’s more a luxury Michael will get to enjoy. Though I did always find it weird that you could only get them from that one guy who runs the diner in Colosseum.
Rui sighed in disappointment. "They didn't have them in Pyrite, either...oh!" She gasped and was momentarily distracted by a woman who swept past with a sleek, purple-coated feline at her heels. "I've never seen that Pokémon before!"
I’d make a snarky quip about how Rui really hasn’t gotten around in life, but then I remembered that wild Pokémon are canonically close to nonexistent in Orre, so this is significantly more manageable than one would think for someone who’s lived most of their life in Agate Village.
Wes, however, was still fixated on the first half of her statement. "Pyrite?" he asked in disbelief.
He glanced at her outfit: she wore a frilly pink and blue jacket over a dark purple tank top, a white pencil skirt, and pink rubber boots. He had a hard time picturing this girl, neatly dressed and put together as she was, wandering the ragged streets of Pyrite. Not to mention that her bubbly disposition would have stuck out like a sore thumb.
Wes: “(Actually, on second thought, maybe I can imagine her on the streets of Pyrite… for all of like five minutes before those two dweebs stuffed her into a sack.)” [lyleunamused]
"Yeah." Rui clasped her hands behind her back and kicked idly at a pebble as they walked. "That's where I was when those two thugs..." She trailed off, a troubled expression overtaking her face.
"That's where you got kidnapped," finished Wes bluntly. That didn't surprise him in the least. Pyrite was not known for its upstanding citizens, after all.
Rui nodded, her gaze still fixed on the sidewalk.
I was joking with that cutaway gag.
"So, let me get this straight. You're not a trainer. Yet you left your hometown and wandered to Pyrite Town, of all places, to look for Pokéballs...in a region that doesn't have wild Pokémon."
Rui gave a weak laugh and looked at Wes with a wan smile. "Well, when you put it like that, it sounds pretty dumb. But that's the truth, I promise."
Wes:
“Yeah, okay lady, but since we’re on this topic…”
"Well, what in Mew's name do you need Pokéballs for?"
"It's for my grandpa," she said. "He's a former Ace trainer, and he's been teaching some of the kids in our village about becoming trainers."
Wes: “... Have you ever heard about this thing called the ‘internet’? You can just buy stuff through it and have it shipped to your door.”
Rui: “Look, the narrative this story is based around was written in the early 2000s, alright? And just how reliable do you think that parcel delivery services are in Orre of all regions?” >_>;
"Pokéballs are useless if there aren't Pokémon to catch them with," said Wes dryly.
"Well, you see, Papi—my grandpa—he's hopeful!" Some of the brightness had returned to Rui's eyes. "There have been rumors of wild Pokémon sightings around the area up north, so he thinks they might be migrating back into the region!"
Oh, so we are getting some Spanish/Latino influence in this story. Though I suppose you can’t say that it’s not fitting for the region that mainlines the Arizona vibes.
Though for the record, if that’s indeed what you’re going for, unless if you’re very deliberately giving off the vibe of Rui’s grandfather being her surrogate father (since “papí” is a phrase equivalent to “daddy” in Spanish), you’d want Rui to be saying “abuelo” here. Or if trying to preserve the same cutesier vibe as “papi/daddy”, “abuelito”.
Also, nice call forward to XD’s Poké Spots, since… yeah, even if it’s still pathetically limited by the standards of a normal region, there are actual wild encounters in that game.
"First of all, those are just rumors. Second, are you telling me he sent you to get Pokéballs instead of going himself?"
Rui pursed her lips. "W-well. Not exactly."
"'Not exactly?' The hell does that mean?"
Wes: “Okay, seriously, you can’t just pepper me with questions and not expect me to return the favor. What’s the story behind why you’re getting these Pokéballs and not your old man?” >:|
She averted his gaze. "I did volunteer to go, but...Papi wouldn't have it. He said it was too dangerous. But he's not exactly young and spry, no matter how much he might think he is, and it had me worried…” she said, trailing off. “Besides, I'd been wanting an excuse to see the world outside Agate anyway, but no matter what I said, he wouldn't listen, and—"
She stopped short, as if to catch herself from rambling, then scowled.
"So I just went anyway," she said flatly.
Yeah, Rui’s going to get herself into trouble at multiple points in this story, I can already tell. Though I’d recommend chopping up Rui’s paragraph of dialogue here into a few smaller ones, especially since the first part of it feels very heavy relative to the rest.
Wes had no idea how to respond to that. Sure, she'd been stupid and reckless to take off like that, but a small part of him respected her resolve, nonetheless.
"Well," he said after an awkward pause, "how do you like the rest of Orre, then?"
Almost immediately a voice screamed at him inside his head. She just got kidnapped, idiot! What kind of a question is that?
Wes: “... Okay, let me rephrase that question there…”
But Rui didn't seem to take offense. She shot him an incredulous look, then burst out laughing.
Dumbfounded, Wes could only keep walking as she followed, her laughter continuing for a few minutes until, at last, she was forced to catch her breath between giggles.
"Oh, dear Mew," she gasped, "thank you for that. I really needed the laugh."
Well, at least Rui has a good sense of humor to take these things in stride? Though I suppose it’s a nice demonstration of how her and Wes’ personalities differ from each other.
Well. He hadn't been trying to be funny, but rather than tell her that, he rolled with it. "...Yeah. No problem."
Rui wiped tears from her eyes and smiled up at him. "I know I'm an idiot for doing what I did, but thanks for not making me feel like one."
He bit back a snort. Well, at least she was aware that she had been stupid…
Wes: “Um… you’re welcome, I guess?”
He was saved from having to come up with a reply as the mayor's home finally came into view. He nudged Rui with his elbow and nodded, and they made their way up the wide stone steps.
True to the atmosphere of Phenac City, the mayor's house held nothing back in terms of extravagance. While not incredibly large in terms of height, it made up for that by sprawling impressively in either direction, showcasing large, gleaming windows and ornate carvings all over the exterior. The front steps led to a wide porch lined with bright white pillars, and the blue double-doors were a sight to behold. Even if Wes hadn't known this to be the mayor's home, it would have been easy to guess.
Of course, the bright banner that stretched across the pillars and read "MAYOR ES-CADE WELCOMES YOU!" was also a slight giveaway.
Well that’s significantly nicer than that little hole-in-the-wall with an entrance jammed underneath an aqueduct he’s got in the official games. Though I wonder if the aqueduct’s still there too in OSAS’ rendition of Es Cade’s house or not.
Rui looked the building up and down with awe. "Are you sure we can just...knock?" she asked in almost a whisper. Wes merely shrugged. He'd never bothered to visit this place himself.
Rui seemed to take this as a yes, as she stepped forward and knocked boldly on the metal doors. Apparently, her recent ordeal hadn't done much to diminish her enthusiasm.
Oh hey, there’s a reaction image summing up Wes’ general thought process right about now:
After a brief pause, the doors creaked open and a tall, crisply dressed man with fiery red hair stood before them. He looked down at them with a penetrating gaze. "What is your business?"
Well that one’s certainly new. I think. I’m pretty sure that Es Cade didn’t have a doorman the first time you go to his place in the games, but it makes sense that he’d have on in a more grounded telling of Colosseum since… yeah, Orre’s not exactly a nice neighborhood.
"We wish to speak to the mayor, please," said Rui. She met his eyes evenly despite the man's intimidating presence. "It's urgent."
Wes half expected them to be turned away, but the man simply nodded. He eyed the Umbreon and Espeon at Wes' feet. "No Pokémon indoors here. Security policy." Wes begrudgingly returned his companions to their Pokéballs, and they were escorted through the doors.
Oh, so that’s the justification for why we never see Pokémon strutting around indoors in Colosseum. It does make me wonder if we’ll see departures from the default depiction for whoever’s in Wes’ team in more homely environments like the house where Rui’s grandparents live.
The cool air inside was a welcome relief from the relentless desert heat. A sparkling crystal chandelier greeted them from overhead, sending multicolored glints of light off the pristine marble walls. A massive flatscreen TV was mounted above a fireplace to their left, and to their right was a handful of plush couches. Straight ahead was a sleek wooden desk, at which sat the mayor of Phenac.
Huh, it’s subtle, but that’s definitely different from the layout in the games, even if I suppose the original layout was a bit too “video game”y to be present in most people’s houses realistically. I wonder if you also do similar little departures here and there in this story given that IIRC it winds up diverging noticeably from Colosseum’s canonical narrative at some point down the road.
Wes had never seen the mayor personally before, and quickly surmised that he hadn't missed out on much. The man was short—very short—and, like his house, made up for it in terms of width. He was as round as a Jigglypuff, with a puffy mustache and bushy eyebrows to match. His head, though mostly bald, sported two large tufts of gray hair on each side.
"Welcome, welcome!" boomed the mayor. He beamed at them through beady eyes that seemed as though they were stuck in a perpetual squint.
Rui stepped forward and gave a small, polite bow. "It's an honor to meet you, Mr. Mayor."
"Oh, please, call me Es-Cade, my dear!" The man chortled. He rose from his seat and walked around to the front of his desk,gesturingpointing them to the couches. "Please, sit! I insist."
Well, the man certainly knows how to put on a show for guests. Though I suppose that is on-brand for Es Cade.
Rui did as requested and took a seat. Wes would have much preferred to stand, but upon seeing the mayor's inquisitive look, he sat with a quiet sigh.
"Eldes, would you please fetch our guests some tea?" Es-Cade pleasantly addressed the red-haired man that stood stoically by the front doors. The man gave a curt nod and strode through an exit at the back of the room.
I went and fired up Bulbapedia to check this since that seemed like a very “actual Orre NPC name” and…
So that’s who the doorman you cast was, and explains why I didn’t remember him from Colosseum. Though I see that there will be callaheads to XD aplenty in this game, though I suppose that the role that you gave him here does seem like it’d give him a plausible path to taking on the role he has in XD.
"Now, what do they call you, my dear?" The portly man turned back to Rui.
"I'm Rui, sir. Rui Everlin."
Huh, wonder what the story behind this surname is. At first I was going to say that the ‘Lin’ was a clever nod to how she hails from a forest, but that doesn’t quite work with the ‘Ever’. I suppose we’ll find out more as this story goes along.
"I see!" Es-Cade said. He looked at Wes. "And you, my good man?"
"Wes." The mayor continued to look at him, as if expecting more, so he sighed. "Wesley Lycas."
Just saying, considering the vibe of the name and of the neighborhood you’re operating in, you missed the chance to roll ‘Lobo’, ‘Lobos’, or ‘López’ as a surname, all of which carry the same semantic shtick you’re going for with ‘Lycas’ there.
Though eh, I won’t question it. Since while it’s definitely not a surname you’ll run into IRL a whole lot, it does fit in decently well with a neighborhood where mothers think to name their kids names like ‘Es-Cade’ and ‘Eldes’.
"Excellent!" He beamed again. "And to what do I owe the pleasure of meeting you both?"
Rui hesitated. Wes gave her a pointed look. This was your idea, not mine. She cleared her throat. "Well, you see, Mr...Es-Cade, it's not exactly good news."
Es-Cade's smile faded to a concerned frown. His bushy eyebrows knotted together. "Oh?"
Es Cade: “I’d like to think that I’m pretty good at staying on top of things. Including things that the general public overlooks, what exactly is going on here?”
Rui shifted nervously before continuing. "You see, sir, I'm here to report an incident. I was brought to this city because...because I was kidnapped."
"Good heavens!"The mayor's eyes widened as far as his beady face would allow.
"Good heavens! Are you quite alright?"
A bit of a stylistic nitpick, but I feel that in this particular case, Es Cade’s line works better coming after his eye-widening moment. Well. Maybe. There’s an argument that I can think of offhand for sticking to your guns here: namely if Es Cade’s reaction is rehearsed and not genuine considering what he ultimately turns out to be in Colosseum, but it’d probably work best if there were other moments during this encounter that helped sell the effect.
"Yes, I am, thanks to Wes," Rui gave the rogue trainer a grateful smile before turning back to Es-Cade. "But...that's not the whole reason I'm here."
She paused and looked at the floor, as if trying to find the words to continue. "You see, sir, I know this will sound strange and you might not believe me, but...I was born with a gift. That gift allows me to see the auras of people and Pokémon."
Well that’s definitely different from the game, even if it makes more sense than in the game given that if my memory serves me right, you basically strut in and Rui plops “I see Shadow Pokémon” right into Es Cade’s lap without a proper introduction. Though I wonder if we’ll see elements of the original exchange surface at all.
Es-Cade's eyebrows shot up an inch or two, and Wes didn't even bother to mask his disbelief as he stared at her. Auras? That did it. Not only had he happened to rescue the most clueless girl in all of Orre, she was also certifiably insane.
Riley: “Am I a joke to you?” >:|
Wes: “Go away, your game didn’t release for 3 years after ours, and you’re supposed to be up in your snowed-over craphole.” >_>;
"Well, I won't pretend that this isn't...very hard to believe, my dear," said the mayor after a pregnant pause. "Are you certain about this...this gift of yours?"
Rui nodded, her face resolute. "I've had this gift for as long as I can remember, sir. I've always been able to see aura."
"Very well," he mused. He raised a meaty hand and rubbed his chin. "Go on."
Wes:
“... Wait, you’re not laughing her out of the room as a crank right now?”
Es Cade: “Well, Mr. Lycas. When you grow to be a man as old and experienced as me, you learn that sometimes things that sound fantastical on their face are worth hearing out. Really an underappreciated sentiment among the young generation these days.”
"Well, I was traveling through Pyrite when I saw these two men. One of them had a Makuhita and was battling another trainer. I don't know how to explain it, but...there was something wrong with that Pokémon. Its aura was...dark. I'd even say it was evil." She shivered. Her face was solemn and fearful as she recalled the memory.
[ ]
"And you've never seen this, erm, aura before?" Es-Cade asked.
It might be worth showing off Es Cade’s reaction to Rui here a bit more. Especially if you want to subtly foreshadow what he’ll be up to in the later parts of your story.
Rui shook her head. "No, sir, never. I've seen auras of many different kinds, but not like that."
[ ]
"Could it be, perhaps, that you've never encountered an aggressive Pokémon?"
"With all due respect, Mr. Mayor, I've seen aggressive Pokémon before." Rui's voice took on a stern tone as she raised her head and looked Es-Cade in the eyes. "This Makuhita was something completely different. And the way it battled was...horrible. It really looked like it wanted to kill the other Pokémon."
Es Cade:
“With all due respect, Ms. Everlin, but Pokémon trying to kill each other in fanfiction isn’t exactly an uncommon occurrence.”
Rui: “Look, they don’t have evil auras attached to them while doing that normally!”
Wes sat back in his seat, absorbing all this new information. This girl was clearly sheltered—that had been obvious from the beginning. He, unfortunately, had seen Pokémon kill on command more than once. While not every Pokémon was willing to kill, there were plenty more that were either eager enough or desperate enough to do so. It was certainly not unheard of, and something that was all too common in Orre's crime rings.
Wes + Rui: “...” O_O;
Es Cade: “... Oh, her. Yes, we’ll just get her out of the room right now where you hopefully won’t be meeting each other for a long, long time in this story. Preferably never, really. (Dammit, I knew that Ein forgot something from his visit to my office…)”
Rui: “... I’m sorry, but why on earth did you have that just-?!” O_O;
Es Cade: “We’re getting off topic right now! Anyhow, you were saying something about ‘evil auras’ or whatnot?” ^^;
He wondered if the mayor was thinking the same thing, as the man had a skeptical expression on his face as he listened to Rui's story. "You do know that Pokémon can and do sometimes kill other Pokémon, my dear?" he asked gently.
Oh hey, it’s almost literally the Batman Beyond gif, just more polite. o<o
"I know that!" Rui said in frustration. "I do! But they only do so if commanded, right? Well, this Makuhita was on a rampage and was acting of its own accord—its trainer couldn't even stop it!"
"I see, I see," Es-Cade backed down slightly upon seeing her frustration. "That is very concerning, Miss Everlin. I can assure you that I will assign some of my staff to look into the matter—although, if this Pokémon is in Pyrite, there's only so much I can do."
Rui: “But you literally just had a Pokémon that was-!” O.O
Es Cade: “Your eyes were just deceiving you, my dear. And if they weren’t, it wasn’t canonical anyways. I assure you, I will do what I can to see that this dangerous Makuhita is dealt with.” ^^;
Wes: “(Yeah, he’s just going to blow us off to go play bingo at the retirement home, I can already tell.)”
"I...I understand," Rui sighed. She relaxed a little and slumped back in her seat.
Es-Cade seemed to notice her disappointment. "Do you perhaps have a description of the criminals?" he asked kindly. "I can also try to put out a search for them, and see what we can come up with—ah!" His eyes brightened as the doorman reentered the room with a tray of tea. "Perfect timing, my good man! Thank you kindly!"
The man said nothing, only depositing the tray on the coffee table in front of them before resuming his post by the doors.
Ah yes, a future Cipher admin from XD just casually playing waiter for everyone. I can already tell that he doesn’t acknowledge this menial tasks phase after climbing the ranks a bit more. >:V
Wes didn't trust drinks from strangers, so he quietly declined his tea. Rui and Es-Cade sipped theirs as she gave him a description of the two men. Wes only spoke up to give their names and a description of their other Pokémon he'd seen. He noticed the mayor raise his eyebrows as he spoke of the two Whismur; the odd fact that Wes hadn't seen a Makuhita was not lost on him, apparently, and it likely contributed to his doubt. The man said nothing of it, however.
Nice little bits of foreshadowing there about Es Cade and the places he’ll be going later in this story if it generally tracks Colosseum’s narrative.
Once Rui had given all the information they knew, the mayor kindly thanked them for their visit and personally showed them out the door with a smile, promising her that he would look into the case at once.
As the doors shut behind them, Wes couldn't help but feel that they had just wasted a massive amount of time. Rui must have sensed this, too, because he noticed she was staring at the ground with slumped shoulders as they walked to the Pokémon Center.
I mean, you’re not wrong there. Especially considering that Es Cade doesn’t exactly have good reasons to want to help out with your request.
He released Neo and Novo from their Pokéballs. They both stretched and gleefully bounced around Wes' feet, happy to be outside again.
Rui brightened a little at the sight of the Pokémon. She giggled as Neo brushed playfully up against her legs, then looked up at Wes with a sheepish expression.
"You probably think I'm crazy, huh?"
Wes shrugged. "Maybe a little." No point in sugar-coating things.
I really should be less surprised that Wes is this blunt since… yeah, he kinda vibes as being that sort of character. ^^;
[ ]
"Well, you don't have to believe me, but I promise I'm telling the truth." Rui glanced at the Eons walking ahead of them. "For example, I can tell by your Pokémons' auras that they are happy and well cared for. They really love and trust you...and it's part of the reason I knew I'd be safe walking with you." She grinned at him.
Rui, don’t make me break out the Bender gif again. Though that makes me wonder if her aura-vision only works on Pokémon. Since if it also works on humans... well, a lot of things in this story would’ve gone differently. Especially in this chapter.
Wes decided it wasn't worth pointing out that she could have deduced this from Neo and Novo's evolutions—Espeon and Umbreon only got their evolutions from bonding with their trainer, after all. Instead, he shrugged again and said, "It makes no difference to me. You saw something and reported it, and now you can move on."
They also evolve from Sun Shards and Moon Shards, which appear in your region a couple years down the line from where you and Rui are at and precisely nowhere else in Pokéworld that we know of thus far.
Rui bit her lip, but said nothing. Whatever she'd seen in Pyrite—or whatever she thought she'd seen—was obviously weighing heavily on her, and their fruitless meeting with the mayor had done little to help with that.
Not my problem, Wes told himself. He'd done more than enough for this random girl today, and wasn't about to take it upon himself to cheer her up. He wouldn't even know where to start, anyway.
Narrator: “Lol. Lmao.”
Wes: “Hey! What’s that supposed to mean?!”
Neo: “*Oh come on, Wes. Are you really telling me you want to part ways from her? Really?*”
Novo: “*It would be a bit of a short story without her given that this is a Colosseum novelization, just saying.*” ^^;
Wes was about to head in the direction of the Center when he noticed Rui stop short. What now? He followed her alarmed gaze to what she was staring at and suddenly he, too, stopped walking.
Someone was heading their way. Whoever this person was, they were massively tall, dwarfing every other passerby on the street. Wes saw the long, flowing silver hair and initially thought it was a woman, but as the stranger came closer it was apparent by the square jaw and bulging, muscular figure that it was a man. But the hair was not what kept his attention; there was something visibly wrong with him.
Ah yes, it’s
He exuded an air of cold, crisp, precise cruelty as he walked. Wes had seen his share of men drunk with power who thought they had it all—but this man knew he was in charge, and was keenly aware of his own authority. The stranger passed them on the sidewalk, but not before turning his head to glance at them. Wes met the man's eyes for just a second, and felt a chill trickle down his spine; his eyes were red as blood.
Oh, so Wes himself feels fear at times in this story. I mean, it makes sense, but I’ll admit that I still did a double-take here with how collected he’s normally been in this story up to this point.
A cruel smirk played across the stranger's lips before he turned away and breezed past them in the direction they came from, head held high, eyes straight ahead.
Wes felt Rui step close to him. He noticed she was shivering. "He was...scary," she whispered.
And a major boss fight you two are going to have to deal with down the road, but that’s a story for another day.
Wes couldn't help but nod in agreement. He was immensely grateful that such a person was only a stranger and nothing more. He had a feeling he would never want to tangle with that man.
Narrator: “He will absolutely wind up tangling with that man.”
Wes: “Not if I bounce out of Orre first-”
Narrator: “Wes will absolutely not bounce out of Orre first.”
Wes: “Oh come on!”
He shook his head and rolled the uneasiness from his shoulders. "Center's just up ahead," he said to Rui. "Let's get inside." She nodded nervously, and the two set off for the wide white steps leading to their destination.
The Phenac Pokémon Center was an impressive sight, even to Wes. He had only been here a handful of times, and he was always just as amazed each time as he was upon his first visit. His negative impression of Phenac and its population aside, he had to admit: they knew how to treat their Pokémon.
Not sure if I want to know what that implies for what Pokémon medical care looks like outside of Phenac in this setting, really.
The building was a large dome with white gleaming walls and a sparkling glass ceiling. At the back of the room, straight ahead from the entrance, was a marble counter in front of a healing machine and a crisply dressed nurse who chimed a cheerful greeting as they walked through the doors.
To the right, a luxurious lounge for trainers held a TV, plush couches, a small snack bar, and ornate bookshelves adorned with all kinds of literature. A row of video-call booths lined the wall near the shelves.
To the left was an enclosed, glass-walled play area for Pokémon. Wes knew from previous visits that the play area extended through a door in the wall to a larger, fenced-in outdoor area. He'd never used it himself, though—the thought of leaving his Pokémon in someone else's hands was mortifying to him.
Huh, that’s definitely a new one. Though I’m surprised that those facilities are remaining open and not monitored or else pre-emptively shut down given that Shadow Pokémon are canonically starting to hit broader circulation at this point in Colosseum, which you think would cause incidents for mixed play areas meant for Pokémon.
"Welcome!" The nurse smiled at them from her place behind the counter. "How may I help you today?"
Rui stepped forward, hands clasped behind her back as she addressed the nurse. "Y-yes, um, could I use your video phones?"
"Absolutely! Right this way, I'll get you started..."
Oh, so they have those here too, huh? I guess it makes sense since even in the earliest seasons of PokéAni, there was video calling technology that was widely dispersed.
The nurse escorted Rui to the phones and Wes wandered over to the couches to sit and wait. Novo followed, looking around with great interest; he, too, always appeared to be impressed with the place whenever they visited.
"Espi!" Neo pawed at Wes' knee and pointed his snout over to the play area, where an Aipom had its face pressed against the glass, wiggling its tail playfully at the Espeon.
Wes shook his head. "Sorry, bud," he said quietly. "We don't have time today."
Neo: “*Oh come on, Wes. It’s literally right there...*”
Neo sat on the tiled floor with a sigh.
Yeah, I figured.
"Tell you what," Wes lowered his voice even further as he reached down to rub Neo's ears. "When we get to Johto, you can play with tons of wild Pokémon every day. How does that sound?"
Right, Orre and Johto are geographically contiguous with each other in your continuity. That one threw me for a bit, but it makes sense that that would be on the shortlist of places for Wes to head to after bailing on Orre.
Neo pricked up his ears and kneaded the floor in excitement. "Spi!"
Johto. Wes had only heard stories of it, but it sounded like a beautiful place, so entirely different from the sandy Orre Region. He'd heard about green forests that stretched as far as the eye could see, of giant shining lakes, of mountains that stretched so high you couldn't see their peaks. He'd dreamed of seeing it from the moment he first learned of its existence.
Actually, that makes me wonder where Orre is located relative to Johto in this setting anyways. My reflexive assumption was that it’d be northward since there’s a whole lotta nothing that we know of north of Mt. Silver and its surroundings, but the sea in the southwest of Orre kinda throws a wrench into that.
He took a deep breath and exhaled slowly. Soon. Very soon. Just be patient.
Novo hopped into his lap and he idly stroked the Umbreon's head, lost in thought, until Rui returned and sank onto the couch a short distance away from him with a sigh. Novo growled softly at her abrupt appearance, a quiet rumble that only Wes could hear.
"Well, my grandparents are happy to know I'm safe, but that didn't save me a tongue lashing from Nan." She turned to him. "They're so grateful to you, by the way. I'm sure they'd love to meet you if you'd like to visit!"
Wes: “Or, I could get onto my bike and ride off into the sunset towards Johto and not stay a moment longer in this craphole. I hear Cherrygrove City’s a really pretty place around this time in spring.”
"Sorry, I have other places to be," Wes muttered. There would be absolutely no more detours until they reached Gateon.
Narrator: “There would absolutely be more detours before reaching Gateon.”
[ ]
"Oh, I...I figured as much," replied Rui. There was a note of disappointment in her voice. "Well, you're always welcome if you—"
This IMO works better if Rui has some sort of reaction before she starts speaking, especially if she’s initially pretty shook by how Wes just casually shoots down her offer to go to Agate Village.
She broke off suddenly, her eyes fixed on something over Wes' shoulder. He turned his head to see what had grabbed her attention, and saw footage of a burning building on the TV. The words MYSTERIOUS EXPLOSION REVEALS SNAGEM HIDEOUT flashed across the screen.
"What—when did this happen?" She breathed in disbelief.
Wes: “I mean, recently, obviously since otherwise it wouldn’t be a news story, but let’s not worry about the criminal scum that would bring up awkward questions for me right now, hm?” ^^
"You're just now finding this out?" Wes blurted. Surely, as shelteredthoughas this girl was, she'd have heard something about it already. He was certain that news of the incident had traveled across every corner of the region by now. Uncovering Snagem's hideout would be earth-shattering news.
I think that we’re missing a bit of context here as to why uncovering Team Snagem’s hideout would be earth-shattering news, especially for readers that aren’t coming in with the benefit of context of a Colosseum playthrough. It might make sense to give a passing mention in a sentence or two of what Team Snagem is known for around Orre such that this is such a “big deal” at the moment.
Rui surprised him by throwing him a withering look. "Yes, I'm hearing about it just now," she said scathingly. "It's not like I've spent the last twenty-four hours in a sack or anything!"
"...Oh." Wes suddenly felt incredibly stupid. "Right...sorry."
Wes sure has a way with people, doesn’t he? I can already tell that he’s going to have a lot of lulzy moments like these down the road.
Rui returned her gaze to the TV. "I can't believe..." She trailed off and didn't bother to finish her sentence. Wes left her to her thoughts and continued stroking Novo's fur, watching his yellow rings pulse with light.
"They deserve it," she said.
He looked up in surprise at those words. Rui was still watching the screen, but a dark expression had taken over her features. It was a jarring change from her usually smiling face.
IMO, it might make sense to explicitly assign the middle paragraph of dialogue to Rui, since at first I thought that that was Wes speaking there.
"You think so?" Wes asked.
She turned her eyes to his, and he was shocked at the amount of pure hatred he saw there. "Yes," she said quietly. "I hate Pokémon thieves. Snagem had this coming, and they deserve a whole lot worse."
Rui had a Pokémon stolen at some point prior to OSAS’ events, didn’t she? Since that definitely feels very opinionated and venomous there.
Wes:
Rui: “Wes, why are you reacting like that?”
Wes looked at her for a moment before answering. "I agree," he said quietly.
Rui: “Good. You were starting to worry me there for a second.”
Wes: “(Okay, yeah. I really need to blow her off and make it to Gateon now.)”
"Umbriiiiii." Novo's whine broke the tense moment. Wes heard the Umbreon's stomach growl, and suddenly realized how hungry he was, too. He rubbed Novo's ear. "I guess it's time we go, then."
Novo leapt off Wes' lap as he stood. He turned to Rui. "The nurses can help you arrange a ride with someone from here. You should be able to make it back to Agate that way."
Rui stood, too, and bowed her head to him gratefully, hands clasped behind her back once again. "Thank you for everything you've done for me, Wes. Really. I don't have any way to repay you for it, but...I really am gratef—"
Her stomach suddenly rumbled loudly, and she flushed a little in embarrassment. "Sorry!"
Wes: “(Come on Wes, just ignore it and let her go, it doesn’t involve-)”
Wes narrowed his eyes at her. "Did you say you were in that sack for a whole day?"
She shifted a little. "Well, I don't know exactly how long it was, but it was a long time..."
Wes took a closer look at her. For all her smiles and cheerfulness, he noticed for the first time that she was still a little pale, and her fingers were shaky as she fidgeted with her necklace.
"You haven't eaten."
Wes: “(Oh dammit. Though I suppose it can’t hurt to at least get her a proper meal first…)” -_-;
Rui gave him another smile, but this time he was paying enough attention to see how forced it was. "It's fine! You've done more than enough for me today, I can...figure something out..." She trailed off, not looking very convinced at her own words.
Novo: “*Come on, Wes. You know you want to help her…*”
Wes: “(Oh for crying out loud, not you two as well!) >.<
She could figure it out, Wes mused to himself. And yet...he had gone long stretches without food before. He knew firsthand how unpleasant it was, and he was certain that this girl had no means of getting food for herself. There was no way she still had any money on her after being kidnapped.
Ah yes, guilt and past trauma. Always good motivators for ignoring that voice in your head that’s going “no, ignore the girl, get on the bike, and keep going until you hit Gateon”
The low voice came into his head again. Remember this, boy. Don't stick your neck out for nobody.
Anger burned in his chest at the intrusive voice. You don't get to tell me what to do. Not anymore.
Whelp, I suppose that that’s one way to tell that Wes has had a definitive break with Snagem if he’s just going “no, shut up, old man” to the past wisdom he received while part of it.
"Alright," he sighed, turning to leave. "Come on." He gestured for her to follow him.
"What? Where—?"
"We were going to find a place to eat anyway. You might as well come with us." He looked at her over his shoulder. "But after this, you'll really be on your own. Got it?"
"I—what do you—I don't—are you sure?" Rui spluttered.
Wes: “No, but I also don’t like seeing you like this, and it’s not exactly hard to find a diner in Phenac. So come on already.” >_>;
"If you don't hurry up, I'll change my mind."
Rui blinked at him, and for a moment Wes thought he saw tears in her eyes. He turned his head away and hoped to Arceus he was mistaken. He had no idea what to do with people when they cried…
And no idea what to do with people in general based off some of the interactions we’ve seen between him and Rui in this story thus far. >:V
Rui bounced up to his side. "Where to, then?" she asked brightly. Any indication that she'd been teary had quickly vanished.
"I've got a place in mind," he said. And with that, they strode through the Center doors back into the sunlight.
Ah yes, taking Rui to some dive that Team Snagem members liked going to. What could possibly go wrong with this idea here?
Wes couldn't help but feel mildly impressed at the speed with which Rui was devouring her burger. It made him wonder just how hungry she must have been this whole time.
Wes: “... I’m sorry, how long did you say you were in that sack again?” .-.
Rui: “No clue, really!” ^^;
His restaurant of choice was closer to the edge of town: a small, dingy, hole-in-the-wall kind of place that he'd always preferred thanks to their low prices and low profile. By Phenac standards, it was "seedy," but compared to the Outskirt Stand, it may as well have been fine dining. The blue painted walls and tiled floor, though scuffed in many places, certainly made it feel a lot cleaner than the dusty old train car.
I mean, this sounds like a fantastic way of running into your old buddies from Team Snagem, just saying. Especially if you weren’t the only one from the team who used to go to this dive, Wes.
His Pokémon were happily eating their kibble from bowls on the floor. It was no plate of bacon, but it was better than nothing, and far better than what they had been accustomed to at Snagem.
I’m… not sure if I want to know what Neo and Novo used to eat while in Team Snagem’s care, really.
A waiter stopped by to offer drinks, which Wes declined. He'd need to be fully alert for their journey ahead—though after the long events of the day, alcohol was tempting.
So… beer or tequila?
Wes: “I was thinking more ‘Everclear’ really, since gods, I really need a drink after everything I’ve been through lately.” >_>;
The waiter turned to Rui, but she also shook her head. "Not today, thank you."
The waiter left, and Wes narrowed his eyes at her. "Are you even old enough to drink?"
Rui nearly choked on her fries. "Wha—excuse me?" she asked indignantly as soon as she could speak, "I'll have you know, I'm well over eighteen!"
Could’ve fooled me with your in-game model, lady. Especially since Wes word-of-god is around 17 years old at the time of Colosseum’s events.
He raised an eyebrow. "By what, a few months?"
Rui huffed at him. "I'm twenty-one, Wes."
Oh. He was genuinely surprised at that. She was much closer to his age than he'd originally thought, only a year younger than himself. "Sorry. You just look younger."
Aha, I see that the characters are a bit aged up for this narrative. Though I suppose that it makes sense given that it’s a bit harder-edged than the official Colosseum narrative and… yeah, there’s definitely less suspension of disbelief needed to make some of Wes’ antics seem plausible if he’s not literally a high school dropout.
"I get that a lot, actually," she said dejectedly. She picked at what remained of her food.
"It's because you're short," he said bluntly. He immediately recognized his mistake when Rui raised her eyebrows at him.
"Wow, really? I'm short? Thanks for pointing that out to me, Wes, I never noticed," she said with a dry smirk.
Moron. "I—that's—yeah. Sorry."
Yeah, I stand by my observation earlier that Wes is not a people person.
Rui snorted and waved her hand. "Don't worry about it, I get it all the time. And even if I were taller, I'd still probably look younger."
"Well, the pigtails don't help," Wes blurted.
Rui's eyebrows rose even higher, and he mentally kicked himself. Gods. Was it always this hard to have a normal conversation? He grabbed his water and spent a deliberately long time sipping at it, wishing more now than ever that he'd ordered a beer instead.
Yeah, I had a feeling that Wes was going to blunder into his fair share of moments like these. Even if I wasn’t expecting quite so many all in this one chapter.
Rather than take offense, Rui simply gave him a sly grin. "Well what about you, Mr. Tough Guy? You don't look much older than seventeen."
Wes choked and spluttered on his drink. "I—what—seven—?" He stopped short when he saw that Rui had erupted into a fit of laughter.
Oh, so there’s our nod to Wes’ canonical age in this story here. Clever tie-in there.
He scowled at her. "That's not funny."
Novo: “*Actually, it’s official game canon-*”
Wes: “Nobody asked you, Novo!”
For some reason, this only made her laugh even harder and she was forced to grip the table for support. Neo and Novo looked up at her from their meal in alarm and Wes began to feel uncomfortable as heads turned in their direction. Why was this girl so loud?
I mean, if she wasn’t, would you have noticed her in that burlap sack she was shoveled into?
"S-sorry," she gasped as her laughter subsided. "I honestly didn't think I'd get a reaction out of you, with you being so stoic and all, but that was funny."
Wes: “(Gods, that trip to Gateon and boat ride to Johto can’t come soon enough at this rate.)” >///<
Wes grumbled darkly under his breath. Rui snorted and bit her lip in an effort to keep herself from laughing further. Her face held a lot more color now that she'd eaten, and she was, if possible, even more lively than before.
Having finished their meal, Wes stood. "Let's go." Rui and his Pokémon followed him as he paid for the meal at the counter up front and stepped outside.
The sun was horrifyingly low in the sky, and Wes inwardly groaned at the sight. They were behind schedule, but no matter—they'd be on the road soon enough, and all their troubles with Phenac (girl included) would be left behind.
"Briiiii!" Novo yawned and stretched happily in the sunlight, his yellow markings glowing contentedly. Neo padded up between Wes and Rui and let out a soft burp. He blinked sleepily up at his trainer with a lazy purr.
The corners of Wes' mouth twitched into a smile upon seeing them so content and peaceful. For the first time since escaping the Hideout, he allowed himself to relax a little. All that was left to do was stock up on some supplies and hit the road now. It should be smooth sailing from here, he thought.
Wes, just saying, but can you tempt fate any harder right about now?
And then he heard a voice that turned his blood to ice.
Yeah, I knew that he was tempting fate there. Though let’s see who he ran into.
"Keep your wits about you, ya hear? He's in this blasted city somewhere."
Wes swore under his breath and grabbed Rui by the arm, pulling her around the building into a side alley. She squawked in protest. "Wes, what're you—hey!"
Neo: “*Okay, seriously, Wes. The burger was good and all, but what on earth did you think was going to happen when we came back to one of your hangouts from your old job?*”
He ignored her and listened closely. He heard the rough cadence of three all too familiar voices across the street, causing his heart to race.
If these are meant to be specific members of Team Snagem that appear later on in the story, it might make sense to explicitly namedrop / give context as to who these Snagem members are, since it feels a little weird for Wes to go “oh, I know these people” without getting more insight into his thought process about who these people are.
How could he get out of this without raising suspicion? He looked at the redhead. If she found out who she was… He remembered her face in the Center as she spoke about Snagem. The anger in her eyes, the righteous fury. There was no way she would let him off if she knew. Not a chance.
Which is a sign that he’s going to be outed in about a minute from this point, since that’s the way stories generally work. ^^;
"Are we sure he's still here?" another voice drawled from where the first one had come from, just across the street. Wes turned his head to listen.
"Shut your trap and quit whining!" the first voice barked. "The faster we get moving, the sooner we'll find the damned rat."
Rui: “Um, Wes? Who are these people again?”
Wes: “People we really, really don’t want to get involved with. (Also, hey, do you see where I parked my bike at all?)”
There was no mistaking that gravelly voice. Wes had heard it all too many times before, usually before facing an unpleasant punishment. Wakin, Gonzap's second-in-command, had always loved to dole out the punishments himself whenever he could. Wes glanced nervously at the metal sleeve on his arm.
If Wakin found Wes now, he was a dead man.
Oh, so there’s our “oh, I know that voice” moment. A part of me wonders if it should’ve come a bit earlier into this sequence, or at least the namedrop portion of it, but eh. It does its job here.
Wes' mind raced. He scrambled to think of a way to get out of this city without setting off Rui's suspicions. He certainly couldn't tell her what was going on, nor could he merely bolt away—what if she started calling after him? Caused a scene? Drew attention from those menacing voices across the street…?
… Actually, wait. Where is Wes’ bike at the moment? Like I know that canonically you don’t have it with you while in Phenac, but it makes me wonder if at minimum it should be a bigger part of Wes’ thought process here since you’d think “dammit, of all the times not to have my bike
A crazy, half-baked idea occurred to him, and he tightened his grip on Rui's arm as he looked back at her again. She was apparently oblivious to the conversation taking place across the street. She seemed much more concerned with Wes' odd behavior and his grip on her arm. He decided to take a chance on her naiveté.
"Hey. You said you needed Pokéballs, right?"
"Y-yeah?" Rui attempted to tug her arm out of his grip. She looked frightened. "Wes, can you let go of me?"
"Sorry," he said quickly. He released her and took a step back. Breathe. You need to stay calm. He met her blue gaze evenly. "I know a place where we can get you some. I just thought of it."
Rui frowned at him. "You do?"
Rui: “... Wes, please tell me that these three aren’t the people you have in mind for getting Pokéballs from.”
"Yeah, but it's...not here. It's a bit of a drive. But I can take you there." The words tumbled out of his mouth before he even had time to think them through.
"That...that would be really helpful! But I don't have any money—"
Wes: “Look, I’ll spot you the money, but we really need to get going if you want to make it. So are you in, or no?” O_O;
"Don't worry about it." Damn, he was panicking. Stay calm. Don't show fear. "I'll cover for you. But we need to get going now if we want to make it there at a decent hour."
"Are—are you sure? You've done so much for me today already—"
"I'm sure, let's go." He almost grabbed her by the arm again to drag her with him, but remembered the fearful look she'd given him and decided against it. "Come on, I'll show you to my bike."
Whelp, hope Neo and Novo enjoy sharing a sidecar, since… yeah, I’m not sure if it’s even physically possible to squeeze a second rider behind Wes on that abomination of a bike he has.
He stepped cautiously out of the alleyway, looking around for any sign of Wakin and his grunts. Rui stood a few paces behind him, mumbling in confusion. "Bike...?"
Wes: “Technically, it’s more of a mashup of a unicycle and a hovercraft, but look, the point is that it’ll get us to the Pokéball seller and away from these guys really, really fast. So keep quite and follow me.”
"Neo. Novo." Wes kept his voice to barely more than a whisper. They pricked their ears and stood at attention. "Keep a lookout."
He motioned for Rui to follow him, and they stepped out into the open.
Wes was sure that Rui would hear his heart trying to escape from his chest. He hated having to walk in the open, hated that he couldn't move any faster than a brisk walk, but he knew that darting through the shadows would only raise her suspicions. He could not afford to be caught. Not now. Not like this.
Let’s not even get into how he’s got the Snag Machine still on his arm and is dressed like an extra from The Matrix right about now, since… yeah, that’s definitely not going to blend in with a crowd. ^^;
He was grateful that they had at least made it to the edge of the city already for their lunch. They were able to reach the city entrance relatively quickly, and made it to his bike shortly after that.
Rui looked at his monstrosity of a vehicle with wide eyes. "Okay, when you said 'bike', I had a very different image in my head," she said as she took in the massive engine and rusty exterior.
Wes: “Look, I’m not going to call it a ‘unicycle’, okay? That just makes it sound stupid.” >_>;
Wes didn't bother to reply to this remark. He'd crouched down to his Pokémon and was muttering a hurried apology. "Sorry guys, but there isn't room for all of you in the sidecar. You're gonna have to go in your balls for now."
Neither Neo nor Novo were very pleased with this arrangement, but he didn't have time to reason with them before returning them to their Pokéballs. They would get over it. What mattered now was getting as far away from this city as possible.
Cue them getting spotted in 3… 2…
Wes gestured for Rui to get in the sidecar as he slid into the driver's seat. She climbed in awkwardly and nearly fell over in the process.
The engine bellowed as he brought it to life. He thought he heard Rui trying to say something, but couldn't be sure. Rather than wait to find out, he slammed on the gas and the motorbike lurched forward, kicking up a cloud of dust as they flew out of sight and left the blinding white city behind.
Huh, that went better for Wes than I was expecting, really. I suppose the shoe regarding his involvement with Team Snagem will wind up dropping another time.
Alright, made it to the end of things. I see that we’re still in the slower initial “Hello World” part of the story, but I thought that it was a pretty neat glimpse into your take on Colosseum’s cast and world since your take on Wes and Rui and Wes’ Eeveelutions are pretty fun to see bounce off each other. There’s clearly a lot of attention to detail worked into your depiction, with a lot for people who are into the Orre games to stop and go:
About, and to its credit, almost all of those nods to later events in Colosseum and XD are worked in quite well into the story. Like there’s some parts that are obvious departures from the base narrative, but they’re done in fashions that feel believable and still in line with Colosseum’s broader atmosphere such that it still feels apt to call OSAS a Colosseum retelling, while adding some distance from “literally just the game” since… yeah, people can just play the games for that.
I don’t have too much in the way of criticisms of this chapter, with the bulk of the ones that I do have basically boiling down to disagreements about wording or paragraph formatting here and there. There were a couple spots where I thought that it might’ve made sense to stop and give a bit more description or “narration through Wes’ lens”, as well as one spot where we dipped into Rui’s perspective that felt like a huge outlier since everything else in the chapter’s narration is pretty clearly done in Wes’ PoV, but it wasn’t frequent enough to be really distracting. There were a couple spots where I wonder if you played things a bit too close to the chest in terms of providing details (e.x. the context behind why Team Snagem’s hideout going up in smoke would be a big deal™), but most of those are relatively minor issues that can be smoothed out with a bit of additive editing.
I’m honestly a little embarrassed that it’s taken me this long to come back to this story, since just getting back into this chapter, I remembered why I had a fun time with the first two back in… -checks notes - RB4. We’ll see how well things hold up over the next couple chapters on my docket, but thus far, the story’s been doing a good job at getting me interested in what’s coming next.
I’ll be seeing you again a couple more times in the coming weeks @HelloYellow17 . Hope the feedback was helpful, and I’ll be looking forward to seeing what goes down in your fourth and fifth chapters. ^^