Ambyssin
Gotta go back. Back to the past.
Ah, yes, you know you're in for a ride when the 1.0.0.3 update changes the protagonists neutral to wield a Gun™. THEY'LL NEVER SEE IT COMIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIN [glass shatters in the distance]
1
-The opening hammering in our protag is a country bumpkin just brings to mind Best Wishes and that one stupid character who kept calling Kanto the boonies.
-D'aww. Vulpix. :3
-I think, perhaps, in the interest of moving into the heart of the battle itself faster, the expository bits on Brock and Luna could've probably been condensed into a line or two during the fight itself. Like Brock getting Geodude to break out of the attempted glassy prison could get a nod of "As expected from the guy who's consistently top twenty in the PWT." That said, the terrain trapping's a nifty strategy.
-Oh, the irony of throwing a happiny out at Brock's onyx. But also oh no I can't not envision her dying from radiation poisoning with that name.
-The antics are amusing, for sure, though part of me thinks Curie stalling for nine minutes with that is stretching it juuuuuust a bit. The geodude part was longer so you could probably fudge the numbers and nothing really changes.
2
-Oh okay so at least we're admitting early pokémon get eaten in this setting. I'm not sure the exact preparation process needed describing, and that's coming from someone whose job involves slicing and dicing human organs to look for diseases.
-Aww, baited with the ol' "food to buy friendship" capture scenario. RIP sand sanic.
-With a lot of expositing that goes on early here, particularly with regards to the worldbuilding, I'm curious why Marcus devotes one line to mentioning not being able to afford to lose to other trainers. They really have to wager money as opposed to just battling one another in the spirit of competition?
-Rock slides in cave situations seems like a pretty common thing for assorted journey stories, though having one caused by two graveler doing a "just guys being dudes" routine for their species is amusing.
-Turning the silly, cutesy clefairy meteor dance thingy into a "Yeah, no the fae are terrible" was actually just another bait for Marcus getting his ear nibbled by a paras, huh? I'm genuinely surprised the noise from him hitting the ground after falling unconscious didn't alert the clefable and have them do... something while he was KO'd. Especially with how you were playing up sound traveling and echoing through the cave.
3
-So you're very true to form with fearow being irate, angry peckers. I wonder why anyone would choose to catch them in universe? I guess maybe they're considered decently strong if you can tame one?We don't need no stinking BSTs.
-Wow, Gemma's remarkably generous to a complete stranger. I wonder if we'll see her again after she leaves? 🤔
-Misty? Cold-hearted? Did someone Heart Swap her with Pryce?Or Sabrina if we're staying within one region.
-Oh no trainers are glorified influencers here. Time for Marcus to talk about today's sponsor RAID SHADOW LEGENDS
-I'm assuming this caution sign is a follow up to the brief moment where Luna got skewered by a nidorino last chapter. Which would make that moment a nice bit of foreshadowing. That, combined with the title of the chapter, made it pretty clear what was going to happen here, though having the Nidoking leader being in the scrum of it and Marcus not being able to do much until Gemma dropped in (or, at least, her machamp did). Some of the jumping and rolling to his feet made me think of Legends Arceus gameplay.
-"My sister's dead, Gemma." Although I suppose those similarities in their background make them perfect for each other in that sort of twisted, poetic irony sort of way. I wonder if you plan to do anything more with the fact that Gemma sees Marcus as a replacement goldfish for that friend of hers, though...
4
-Gemma has a point, though. It's not like nidorino is a good addition for Misty if she's going to throw out a starmie.
-"Sometimes you just have to TM your way through a fight." And other times you have to PP stall. And other times you have to sac a 'mon to— oh, wait, this isn't a nuzlocke.
-I'm actually glad Marcus doesn't have to resort to throwing hands with Nidorino again. Would've felt redundant and I think the "confused but accepts" approach is good. I wonder if Pride would develop performance anxiety in an actual battle, though. Could be one route to explore.
-Oh, hey, look, that Thunderbolt and command difficulty sure sounds like performance anxiety to me.
-Y'know, hearing Marcus should Pride's name along with a "Let's show them what we're made of" and "Horn attack" is certainly something. Even with context.
-Start of the battle definitely fits with the whole "attack attack attack!" mantra you set up with the scene before. I get the point of Marcus' introspection was to show off his nerves but, like with the exposition for Brock, I think it would've left more of an impact (pun intended) to have cut to the chase with showing Staryu's all out ESP assault and using a line or two about how this lined up with what he'd studied or whatever. It is interesting, though, that the focus was so much on the spamming of a psychic-type move. I swear 95% of Misty battles focus far more on using the pool in her gym and dealing with swimming and underwater shenanigans. So, this is at least quite different.
-FUCK YEAH, SEAK— oh, rip, never mind it's still a goldeen. But even this is mostly focused on horn on horn combat instead of the water.
-"Parry the horn!" has big "Aim for the horn!" energy.
-Tan streak... speeds by.SonicLuna the vulpix. Faster than the naked eye. Luna the vulpix. 🎶
-Finally the water terrain gets used, but it's got a heavy psychic mix to it.Are we sure Misty isn't the psychic gym leader in this Kanto? I suppose Pride getting all three KOs is a heck of a way to introduce it, though that does mean my earlier comments about the whole performance anxiety thing ultimately amounted to nothing. Ah well.
-Also hi Team Rocket. You're not sneaky.
-Overall 7.8/10 battle too muchwaterhorn. See me after class, bub.
5
-Something about the surname "Montaigne" has me feeling like guy's sus.
-Oh, wait, Marcus' last name is Wright? Why is he a trainer? He should be in the courtroom defending people with a spunky female sidekick.
-Practically quintupled in views, eh? Yeah, I guess going from 5 to 25 would quintuple it. 😏
-Yes, Marcus you know how to put yourself in situations to be lucky. We call it "being the protagonist."
-Welp, so much for letting the good times roll. Hi again, Team Rocket. Killing a fearow sounds like overkill for... whatever device Gemma's dad is a part of cooking up. I could be cheeky and say something like the master ball, but it's probably some sort of genetic something or other that's going to lead into Mewtwo? That's how a lot of these sorts of intense Kanto fics end up going, from my experience. Good to know how Gemma has the money, though. Not just a sponsorship, then.
-Ah, yes, explosion right on cue after protecting. Let's see here. Mask? Beard? Scyther and tyranitar? Looks like a winner to me. Hi, IMM. Guess we're pulling from the anime after all. Lot of action, with Marcus trying to run the guy over like you might see in a horror movie.Or GTA. I think, for me, the explosive introduction of Team Rocket loses some merit because the other action pieces up until this point have been similarly violent. Like, maybe if the actual gym fights or even wild pokémon weren't quite so ferocious it would make IMM look like even more of a monstrous force. As it is, it's on par with things up to now, just with somewhat bigger 'mons.
-"Just got out of surgery last night ... Almost didn't make it off the table." No. No, I call hax. Maybe this pokémon world has magitek medicine for humans but if you're that poorly off following surgery you're still intubated and sedated in the ICU to give your body more time to heal.
-I do think from a pacing standpoint you'd have been better off ending this chapter with Marcus going to sleep at the Walker farm then picking things up in the next chapter. Because this stuff with the rabid tentacruel horde could have probably gotten its own chapter. This doesn't seem like some sort of random thing. Gives me Lake of Rage vibes...
6
-So, being a trainer also means you're enlisted in the draft, huh? I'm amazed it remains as popular as it is in this universe.
-Oh, now Marcus is becoming aware of his own mortality? After the IMM run in many days ago? Attention span of a fuecoco, apparently.
-So this whole thing is tentacruel and there isn't a single tentacool in the midst? That really spells Lake of Rage-style shenanigans.
-I guess mowing all the tentacruel down is meant to demonstrate how strong all these high level trainers are when they're not limited by any sort of gym battle restrictions or anything.
-Flowers and electrocution? With blonde hair? Hi, Domino. I'm a bit confused why Team Rocket thinks that Marcus is their in road to Silph. Outside of knowing Gemma, he hasn't even had his contract drawn up yet, so I doubt he's really going to get them the inside edge they're looking for. XP
7
-Interesting capture method. Still boils down to a battle to earn the cubone, but it's more like earning the approval of a very strict parent.
-0/10 Blue portrayal. Didn't say "Bonjour" when he first showed up. But I see he's in the midst of his travels instead of done with them as most OC-centric Kanto fics tend to lean if they feature him in any capacity. And I'm going to go out on a limb and say it was Giovanni who (directly or indirectly) got to his parents. A hit sure sounds like something the yakuza would do.
-Y'know, I think Team Rocket showing up and catching a bunch of pokémon from a secluded area like this is part of how the mewtwo movie opens. Also, I guess this is how Blue's raticate "dies" in this universe. And also also I guess this is how that ghost is going to show up in Lavender Tower, huh.
8
-Oh, hi Professor Oak. Y'know, the situation's rather grim and twisted, but something about Marcus having nearly 30 cubone in need of shelter at Oak's lab just brings to mind Ash and his thirty tauros. It has to be intentional.
-Well, there was at least a bit of downtime for the somber moment of reflection before the Rockets are right back to harassing him.
-Ah, so Surge is, apparently, on the good side this time around. I know he was in Team Rocket in the manga and I think some Kanto fics like to keep that connection. Which, to be fair, you do show him knowing Giovanni, at least. You're also not subtle dropping a few letters from his Japanese name to form his surname. >:3
9
-A triple battle, huh? Well, that's a significant difficulty bump for a third badge. And, yeah, like Surge says at the end, you can definitely feel like Marcus kinda BS'd his way through it and won because of the power of god and anime on his side. Or something. The concussion did seem to make him a bit slower on the uptake in places, I think? I didn't have trouble following the battle, at the very least.
-Oh, hi, Red. I guess we'll be seeing you around, huh?
-No, Marcus. Why would you be going off to get drinks when you've still got the whole Curie situation? (I do wonder if the Rockets having her is setting up for a forceful evolution if/when he's able to reclaim her.)
-Oh, Oak's in contact with Giovanni from the look of things. And I'm guessing he's going to challenge Red and Blue at the hideout under the Game Corner or whatever its equivalent is. There's clearly something bigger™ going on beyond just Team Rocket's usual "All pokémon exist for our glory and let's control the region" schtick.
10
-Oh, no Surge mentorship after all, huh? Something tells me the plot is not going to allow that.
-It was nice to have a bit of a more transitional chapter in an attempt at just calming things down after all the Rocket stuff from the previous few chapters. I say that, but my first instinct when Marcus got injured was that another Rocket thing was happening. It was just a heracross, though. Big ol' bug before the grass gym.
If I had to say one thing, it's that I do like that Marcus is making the most of this unconventional team. He's not getting hand all the frequently used 'mons for Kanto fics (surprising considering you have "Charizard fan" as your title). But they're also not extremely weak (stat-wise) pokémon that, within the confines of this fic's rules, would make it extremely hard for me to buy Marcus' success. So, it does sell the underdog role to a certain degree.
And, yeah, it's been a considerable amount of success over ten chapters. There's been misfortune to counterbalance, too, but the gym fights and the number of important people he's stumbled across sure is something. Along with the offers he's gotten. Guy basically has the means to get his nidoking. Just a matter of time before he figures out how to put it to use. There's continuous growth with each chapter, though I do think the caveat is that a lot of that has come from constant action. There wasn't a single chapter in this bunch that didn't involve some sort of protracted battle scene. Which, I guess, is fair for a trainer fic, especially if the chapter word count is on the longer side. But sometimes it's nice to have quieter chapters that can advance people's arcs in other ways. There are plenty more chapters up, so maybe this is true. So far, though, the quieter stuff amounts to Marcus constantly playing the dead sister card, which leaves me wonder how many times this song and dance of him bringing her up will continue.
I realize that doesn't sound the greatest. Part of it probably boils down to the fact that there's a lot of death for just ten chapters in. And, well, we never had the chance to see Marcus' sister, so the fact that she's gone leaves less of an impression. All the death of random background characters and some scattered pokémon here and there is meant to see the stakes of the setting, but it's always going to be very hit or miss for different readers. My fear is that once the fic reaches a point where a significant character or two does end up dying it's not going to hit that hard because I'll just be apathetic to all the death by then. And, despite your fic's summary, unfortunately this does veer firmly into M territory with its violence level. Marcus is stumbling across corpses and whatnot and Pride basically blasted off Starmie's limbs and speared it through its central gem. That's pretty convincing for me. Again, I cut up organs on the regular. XD
The intrigue is good enough on its own without all the deaths for me. Leaving them at "disappearances" would've been enough imo. But maybe some people do get a kick out of this level of violence and I'm just not one of them. XP
1
-The opening hammering in our protag is a country bumpkin just brings to mind Best Wishes and that one stupid character who kept calling Kanto the boonies.
-D'aww. Vulpix. :3
-I think, perhaps, in the interest of moving into the heart of the battle itself faster, the expository bits on Brock and Luna could've probably been condensed into a line or two during the fight itself. Like Brock getting Geodude to break out of the attempted glassy prison could get a nod of "As expected from the guy who's consistently top twenty in the PWT." That said, the terrain trapping's a nifty strategy.
-Oh, the irony of throwing a happiny out at Brock's onyx. But also oh no I can't not envision her dying from radiation poisoning with that name.
-The antics are amusing, for sure, though part of me thinks Curie stalling for nine minutes with that is stretching it juuuuuust a bit. The geodude part was longer so you could probably fudge the numbers and nothing really changes.
2
-Oh okay so at least we're admitting early pokémon get eaten in this setting. I'm not sure the exact preparation process needed describing, and that's coming from someone whose job involves slicing and dicing human organs to look for diseases.
-Aww, baited with the ol' "food to buy friendship" capture scenario. RIP sand sanic.
-With a lot of expositing that goes on early here, particularly with regards to the worldbuilding, I'm curious why Marcus devotes one line to mentioning not being able to afford to lose to other trainers. They really have to wager money as opposed to just battling one another in the spirit of competition?
-Rock slides in cave situations seems like a pretty common thing for assorted journey stories, though having one caused by two graveler doing a "just guys being dudes" routine for their species is amusing.
-Turning the silly, cutesy clefairy meteor dance thingy into a "Yeah, no the fae are terrible" was actually just another bait for Marcus getting his ear nibbled by a paras, huh? I'm genuinely surprised the noise from him hitting the ground after falling unconscious didn't alert the clefable and have them do... something while he was KO'd. Especially with how you were playing up sound traveling and echoing through the cave.
3
-So you're very true to form with fearow being irate, angry peckers. I wonder why anyone would choose to catch them in universe? I guess maybe they're considered decently strong if you can tame one?
-Wow, Gemma's remarkably generous to a complete stranger. I wonder if we'll see her again after she leaves? 🤔
-Misty? Cold-hearted? Did someone Heart Swap her with Pryce?
-Oh no trainers are glorified influencers here. Time for Marcus to talk about today's sponsor RAID SHADOW LEGENDS
-I'm assuming this caution sign is a follow up to the brief moment where Luna got skewered by a nidorino last chapter. Which would make that moment a nice bit of foreshadowing. That, combined with the title of the chapter, made it pretty clear what was going to happen here, though having the Nidoking leader being in the scrum of it and Marcus not being able to do much until Gemma dropped in (or, at least, her machamp did). Some of the jumping and rolling to his feet made me think of Legends Arceus gameplay.
-"My sister's dead, Gemma." Although I suppose those similarities in their background make them perfect for each other in that sort of twisted, poetic irony sort of way. I wonder if you plan to do anything more with the fact that Gemma sees Marcus as a replacement goldfish for that friend of hers, though...
4
-Gemma has a point, though. It's not like nidorino is a good addition for Misty if she's going to throw out a starmie.
-"Sometimes you just have to TM your way through a fight." And other times you have to PP stall. And other times you have to sac a 'mon to— oh, wait, this isn't a nuzlocke.
-I'm actually glad Marcus doesn't have to resort to throwing hands with Nidorino again. Would've felt redundant and I think the "confused but accepts" approach is good. I wonder if Pride would develop performance anxiety in an actual battle, though. Could be one route to explore.
-Oh, hey, look, that Thunderbolt and command difficulty sure sounds like performance anxiety to me.
-Y'know, hearing Marcus should Pride's name along with a "Let's show them what we're made of" and "Horn attack" is certainly something. Even with context.
-Start of the battle definitely fits with the whole "attack attack attack!" mantra you set up with the scene before. I get the point of Marcus' introspection was to show off his nerves but, like with the exposition for Brock, I think it would've left more of an impact (pun intended) to have cut to the chase with showing Staryu's all out ESP assault and using a line or two about how this lined up with what he'd studied or whatever. It is interesting, though, that the focus was so much on the spamming of a psychic-type move. I swear 95% of Misty battles focus far more on using the pool in her gym and dealing with swimming and underwater shenanigans. So, this is at least quite different.
-FUCK YEAH, SEAK— oh, rip, never mind it's still a goldeen. But even this is mostly focused on horn on horn combat instead of the water.
-"Parry the horn!" has big "Aim for the horn!" energy.
-Tan streak... speeds by.
-Finally the water terrain gets used, but it's got a heavy psychic mix to it.
-Also hi Team Rocket. You're not sneaky.
-Overall 7.8/10 battle too much
5
-Something about the surname "Montaigne" has me feeling like guy's sus.
-Oh, wait, Marcus' last name is Wright? Why is he a trainer? He should be in the courtroom defending people with a spunky female sidekick.
-Practically quintupled in views, eh? Yeah, I guess going from 5 to 25 would quintuple it. 😏
-Yes, Marcus you know how to put yourself in situations to be lucky. We call it "being the protagonist."
-Welp, so much for letting the good times roll. Hi again, Team Rocket. Killing a fearow sounds like overkill for... whatever device Gemma's dad is a part of cooking up. I could be cheeky and say something like the master ball, but it's probably some sort of genetic something or other that's going to lead into Mewtwo? That's how a lot of these sorts of intense Kanto fics end up going, from my experience. Good to know how Gemma has the money, though. Not just a sponsorship, then.
-Ah, yes, explosion right on cue after protecting. Let's see here. Mask? Beard? Scyther and tyranitar? Looks like a winner to me. Hi, IMM. Guess we're pulling from the anime after all. Lot of action, with Marcus trying to run the guy over like you might see in a horror movie.
-"Just got out of surgery last night ... Almost didn't make it off the table." No. No, I call hax. Maybe this pokémon world has magitek medicine for humans but if you're that poorly off following surgery you're still intubated and sedated in the ICU to give your body more time to heal.
-I do think from a pacing standpoint you'd have been better off ending this chapter with Marcus going to sleep at the Walker farm then picking things up in the next chapter. Because this stuff with the rabid tentacruel horde could have probably gotten its own chapter. This doesn't seem like some sort of random thing. Gives me Lake of Rage vibes...
6
-So, being a trainer also means you're enlisted in the draft, huh? I'm amazed it remains as popular as it is in this universe.
-Oh, now Marcus is becoming aware of his own mortality? After the IMM run in many days ago? Attention span of a fuecoco, apparently.
-So this whole thing is tentacruel and there isn't a single tentacool in the midst? That really spells Lake of Rage-style shenanigans.
-I guess mowing all the tentacruel down is meant to demonstrate how strong all these high level trainers are when they're not limited by any sort of gym battle restrictions or anything.
-Flowers and electrocution? With blonde hair? Hi, Domino. I'm a bit confused why Team Rocket thinks that Marcus is their in road to Silph. Outside of knowing Gemma, he hasn't even had his contract drawn up yet, so I doubt he's really going to get them the inside edge they're looking for. XP
7
-Interesting capture method. Still boils down to a battle to earn the cubone, but it's more like earning the approval of a very strict parent.
-0/10 Blue portrayal. Didn't say "Bonjour" when he first showed up. But I see he's in the midst of his travels instead of done with them as most OC-centric Kanto fics tend to lean if they feature him in any capacity. And I'm going to go out on a limb and say it was Giovanni who (directly or indirectly) got to his parents. A hit sure sounds like something the yakuza would do.
-Y'know, I think Team Rocket showing up and catching a bunch of pokémon from a secluded area like this is part of how the mewtwo movie opens. Also, I guess this is how Blue's raticate "dies" in this universe. And also also I guess this is how that ghost is going to show up in Lavender Tower, huh.
8
-Oh, hi Professor Oak. Y'know, the situation's rather grim and twisted, but something about Marcus having nearly 30 cubone in need of shelter at Oak's lab just brings to mind Ash and his thirty tauros. It has to be intentional.
-Well, there was at least a bit of downtime for the somber moment of reflection before the Rockets are right back to harassing him.
-Ah, so Surge is, apparently, on the good side this time around. I know he was in Team Rocket in the manga and I think some Kanto fics like to keep that connection. Which, to be fair, you do show him knowing Giovanni, at least. You're also not subtle dropping a few letters from his Japanese name to form his surname. >:3
9
-A triple battle, huh? Well, that's a significant difficulty bump for a third badge. And, yeah, like Surge says at the end, you can definitely feel like Marcus kinda BS'd his way through it and won because of the power of god and anime on his side. Or something. The concussion did seem to make him a bit slower on the uptake in places, I think? I didn't have trouble following the battle, at the very least.
-Oh, hi, Red. I guess we'll be seeing you around, huh?
-No, Marcus. Why would you be going off to get drinks when you've still got the whole Curie situation? (I do wonder if the Rockets having her is setting up for a forceful evolution if/when he's able to reclaim her.)
-Oh, Oak's in contact with Giovanni from the look of things. And I'm guessing he's going to challenge Red and Blue at the hideout under the Game Corner or whatever its equivalent is. There's clearly something bigger™ going on beyond just Team Rocket's usual "All pokémon exist for our glory and let's control the region" schtick.
10
-Oh, no Surge mentorship after all, huh? Something tells me the plot is not going to allow that.
-It was nice to have a bit of a more transitional chapter in an attempt at just calming things down after all the Rocket stuff from the previous few chapters. I say that, but my first instinct when Marcus got injured was that another Rocket thing was happening. It was just a heracross, though. Big ol' bug before the grass gym.
If I had to say one thing, it's that I do like that Marcus is making the most of this unconventional team. He's not getting hand all the frequently used 'mons for Kanto fics (surprising considering you have "Charizard fan" as your title). But they're also not extremely weak (stat-wise) pokémon that, within the confines of this fic's rules, would make it extremely hard for me to buy Marcus' success. So, it does sell the underdog role to a certain degree.
And, yeah, it's been a considerable amount of success over ten chapters. There's been misfortune to counterbalance, too, but the gym fights and the number of important people he's stumbled across sure is something. Along with the offers he's gotten. Guy basically has the means to get his nidoking. Just a matter of time before he figures out how to put it to use. There's continuous growth with each chapter, though I do think the caveat is that a lot of that has come from constant action. There wasn't a single chapter in this bunch that didn't involve some sort of protracted battle scene. Which, I guess, is fair for a trainer fic, especially if the chapter word count is on the longer side. But sometimes it's nice to have quieter chapters that can advance people's arcs in other ways. There are plenty more chapters up, so maybe this is true. So far, though, the quieter stuff amounts to Marcus constantly playing the dead sister card, which leaves me wonder how many times this song and dance of him bringing her up will continue.
I realize that doesn't sound the greatest. Part of it probably boils down to the fact that there's a lot of death for just ten chapters in. And, well, we never had the chance to see Marcus' sister, so the fact that she's gone leaves less of an impression. All the death of random background characters and some scattered pokémon here and there is meant to see the stakes of the setting, but it's always going to be very hit or miss for different readers. My fear is that once the fic reaches a point where a significant character or two does end up dying it's not going to hit that hard because I'll just be apathetic to all the death by then. And, despite your fic's summary, unfortunately this does veer firmly into M territory with its violence level. Marcus is stumbling across corpses and whatnot and Pride basically blasted off Starmie's limbs and speared it through its central gem. That's pretty convincing for me. Again, I cut up organs on the regular. XD
The intrigue is good enough on its own without all the deaths for me. Leaving them at "disappearances" would've been enough imo. But maybe some people do get a kick out of this level of violence and I'm just not one of them. XP