Fall 2020 Mafia - Game Thread

[Equitial]

I did but I guess I overestimated the amount of time I had. I also didn't really understand what I doing and I was trying to figure out the game thread.
I guess it is my own fault though and I don't blame anyone for being sus of me.
I guess this just teaches me for if I ever do something like this again

If you saw the warning, you would have gone to your DMs. If you went to your DMs, that probably would have marked you as "In Conversation", even if you didn't send anything.

In the future, if you are a doctor, you can literally just protect anyone and you won't hurt anything. You may protect a mafia, but we apparently don't have a vig (unless it's Fuse). But if you're a doctor and will protect someone tonight, I'm going to be making a list of scumreads for both if DW flips mafia or guilty. Depending on if they on, choose an innocent person on the appropriate list.

 

[DawningWinds]

But if you're a doctor and will protect someone tonight, I'm going to be making a list of scumreads for both if DW flips mafia or guilty.

I'm flattered by the fact that you'll be making two separate lists, completely centered around my alignment, but it seems like you're not quite considering all the possibilities. Yes I know this was I mistake but I had to.

 

[Equitial]

Depending on if they on, choose an innocent person on the appropriate list.

"Depending on how they flip"

actually i think that is because i got the dm via my gmail account and I didn't check my inbox for pings

But apparently, it's still a mystery.

 

[DawningWinds]

Also. Equitia isn't the authiority on your reads, Waffle. Feel free to consider his, but make your own decisions for who you think is what alignment.

 

[Fusion]

I will tell you all, in full honesty, that revealing my role will not clear anyone. At all. I may not know mafia as well as some of you, but even a brainlet like me can take a look at their role and realize that, "Everyone knowing this is less useful than no one knowing it."

 

[Equitial]

I'm flattered by the fact that you'll be making two separate lists, completely centered around my alignment, but it seems like you're not quite considering all the possibilities. Yes I know this was I mistake but I had to.

It looks like you're getting lynched tonight so... Are you suggesting something I'm not getting?

 

[Waffle]

If you saw the warning, you would have gone to your DMs. If you went to your DMs, that probably would have marked you as "In Conversation", even if you didn't send anything.

In the future, if you are a doctor, you can literally just protect anyone and you won't hurt anything. You may protect a mafia, but we apparently don't have a vig (unless it's Fuse). But if you're a doctor and will protect someone tonight, I'm going to be making a list of scumreads for both if DW flips mafia or guilty. Depending on if they on, choose an innocent person on the appropriate list.

oh okay, thanks for the tip

 

[DawningWinds]

It looks like you're getting lynched tonight so... Are you suggesting something I'm not getting?

You said if I flip "Mafia or guilty", completely discounting any possibility of me being innocent. I know this was a mistake, as I said, but it's the sort of joke I felt inclined to make.

 

[Equitial]

Also. Equitia isn't the authiority on your reads, Waffle. Feel free to consider his, but make your own decisions for who you think is what alignment.

Of course make your own reads if you will, Waffle. But if you're not, consider that even DW thinks I'm innocent.

 

[Equitial]

You said if I flip "Mafia or guilty", completely discounting any possibility of me being innocent. I know this was a mistake, as I said, but it's the sort of joke I felt inclined to make.

Oh, typo.

 

[Waffle]

I will tell you all, in full honesty, that revealing my role will not clear anyone. At all. I may not know mafia as well as some of you, but even a brainlet like me can take a look at their role and realize that, "Everyone knowing this is less useful than no one knowing it."

I know how you feel, because that was is how I felt about revealing at first, but it just seems strange because everyone else has

 

[Waffle]

Of course make your own reads if you will, Waffle. But if you're not, consider that even DW thinks I'm innocent.

I really want to see your reads so I can consider them though

 

[Fusion]

Everyone knowing everything is more a detriment to Town than a benefit. It helped in the moment, but now the mafia knows everyone elses roles. Assuming no one's lied, which it looks like no one has? Maybe? I dunno. Anything that a townie can keep hidden from the Mafia is a benefit to the Town. Whether that makes me sus, or gets me targeted by the mafia themselves, that's better than letting them know what my cards are.

 

[windskull]

Fusion. If no one has lied that would me you'd have to be the killer, bc you're the only one that hasn't claimed.

 

[Waffle]

Everyone knowing everything is more a detriment to Town than a benefit. It helped in the moment, but now the mafia knows everyone elses roles. Assuming no one's lied, which it looks like no one has? Maybe? I dunno. Anything that a townie can keep hidden from the Mafia is a benefit to the Town. Whether that makes me sus, or gets me targeted by the mafia themselves, that's better than letting them know what my cards are.

I guess you're right. Its like the wild card the mafia can't prepare for

 

[windskull]

Fusion. If no one has lied that would mean you'd have to be the killer, bc you're the only one that hasn't claimed.

Edit by post

 

[Equitial]

Anything that a townie can keep hidden from the Mafia is a benefit to the Town.

No. No, sometimes the town needs information. The town is all asking you for information. Please give it.

 

[Fusion]

Well, I mean, I'm not.

 

[windskull]

Vote: Fuse

Screw it. I might change it back to DW later.

 

[Fusion]

It was a calculated risk, having my sus meter turn from 5 to like 8 so soon to the end of the day, but I will simply repeat myself and say this is fine. It's not what I wanted things to turn out, but it is in fact how I assumed it would be.

I will continue to hold my claim that my role being hidden is a benefit to town.