[[While I think I can follow your logic, Tetra, I'm not really coming to the same conclusions as you are.
Scenario A: Homestar is town rolecop
In this scenario, he has absolutely no reason to lie about what he saw because if we vote out abrapunk and they turn innocent, it would turn the town on him the next day. And the mafia wouldn't even go for him because he'd be proven a fraud and they'd be able to turn their sights to other players that are either strong or else might have a role.
Scenario B: Homestar is mafia rolecop
He'd have even less of an incentive to lie here, though imo I feel like he'd be better off not saying anything because the mafia could just silently kill of the SK overnight unless the town vote was already headed that direction. Otherwise the read is pretty much the same as A.
Scenario C: Homestar is town, but lying about his role
I could only see this if it was a ploy to try to bait the mafia into wasting a kill/their juggernaught shot on a vanillia townie but considering he called out the role that's the most dangerous to both town and Mafia, that would mess up the gambit pretty bad because being proven wrong would show the mafia he was lying if the person he claimed was SK got killed. Then it would be an uphill battle to prove his innocence.
Scenario D: Homestar is mafia, but lying about his role
Basically same as C, except now he'd almost definitely be voted out next day by the town when he got an innocent killed.
Scenario E: Homestar is the SK:
Basically the same as C and D.
If there are holes in my logic, please tell me.
Right now, I'm inclined to believe his claim, though not necessarily his innocence. With that in mind, I want to put some pressure on Abrapunk/Kent to speak up/defend themselves.]]