• Welcome to Thousand Roads! You're welcome to view discussions or read our stories without registering, but you'll need an account to join in our events, interact with other members, or post one of your own fics. Why not become a member of our community? We'd love to have you!

    Join now!

Pokémon Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Soaring Over Heaven

Umbramatic

The Ghost Lord
Premium
Location
The Yangverse
Pronouns
Any
Partners
  1. reshiram
  2. zygarde
Hi! Here for Review Blitz! Disclaimer that PMD can be a bit out of my wheelhouse (I do have a PMD fic but other than that I am a human-Pokemon focus centrist) but I like seeing what people come up with in their fics and you seemed excited to show me yours, so here we go!

You mentioned Xenoblade vibes. I love me some Xenoblade vibes.

Ah yes, the void. With the voice.The voice that gives you personality quizzes. Though this one seems to mostly have questions and not answers.

And the void spits Maxim out into a fall. Rude.

At the very least a nice Kirila finds him. Also he's a Rowlet now. Rowlet is a good choice for a protag - I just generally like when people give gen seven plus Pokemon big roles in PMD fics because... no PMD game goes past gen 6.

Also the doodle of Maxim looking in the mirror? Adorable.

There is a slightly less nice Meinfoo here. Also everyone is apparently on a skyship. Bros really said "imagine beliving in the ocean."

There's a Politoed here too! I love Politoed!

Always heed the approaching dot. You never know if it's a bird, or a plane, or -

PIRATES

tim_curry_pirate_evil-laugh-muppets.gif

Noivern as a pirate captain is sick as hell. I love this nasty man already.

Of course being a pirate captain he is full of threats. But can he back them up? Can Maxim actually do anything about it? FIND OUT NEXT TIME ON SOARING OVER HEAVEN Z

Really cute start! I like your characters so far in particular. I will hhhhhhhhhhhopefully be back for more!
 

Gyeig

Bug Catcher
Pronouns
he/him
Partners
  1. samurott

Review of Chapters 4 and 5.​


Back again for two more chapters. Two usually covers enough ground for a review, so unless there’s some kind of massive cliffhanger that I have to read more about, you can expect that amount per review.

Anyway, these chapters unsurprisingly continued the trend of the last three - cartoony vibes, a lot of Maxim stumbling around trying to figure being a Pokemon out with some of his fellow privateers while Captain Drake puts on a completely different face talking to folks about Maxim potentially being a human. I’m still curious how the latter goes, especially considering that Drake sounds like an entirely different character behind closed doors compared to how he presents himself to his crew. Is he more than meets the eye? Does he work for someone? Is he a villain? And so on.

One aspect of this fic that I enjoy is the prose being pretty comfortable to read. It’s not trying to wow the reader or anything, but it establishes a vibe in these chapters that just makes for a pretty comfortable reading experience overall. I also like that there’s a pretty clear distinction between the way Maxim’s POV is written versus the short scenes with Drake - clearly, every case of the latter sees the writing take a serious turn that keeps the reader alert. It’s solid stuff.

To narrow in a little more on Chapter 4, it introduces characters outside of the privateers group Maxim has ended up in. Hurik and Celene on the surface look like a pretty typical dynamic - Hurik being the boasty, overly optimistic/energetic type while Celene is there to keep him grounded. One worry I do have is how they fit into the privateers’ dynamic to begin with, given that the ship is going to leave town in a couple of days - that is something I hope you’ve spent time thinking up an answer for, since this fic by nature has an A and a B side to it (on the ship vs off the ship).

Now, chapter 5 is where I don’t just have concerns, but an actual problem - the scene where Maxim finally figures out how to Pokemon and fight back isn’t the best. It relies heavily on a sudden flashback Maxim gets when Rene calls him useless, which brings back a similar memory from a school project he had - IMO, this isn’t elaborated enough upon. Maxim just learns fast from the experience, the emotional link between the memory and the fight now isn’t expressed strongly enough, and it feels like Maxim did one attack, before having a moment of self awareness and Rene going ‘See? I knew you could do it!’. If you ever go back to these earlier chapters, this is something you should work out further.

Alright, enough rambling for now. One last thing I want to mention that isn’t plot related - I like the little drawings you put in here. They’re a nice addition! Thanks again for the chapters, and best of luck with the rest of the fic-
 

Spiteful Murkrow

Busy Writing Stories I Want to Read
Pronouns
He/Him/His
Partners
  1. nidoran-f
  2. druddigon
  3. swellow
  4. lugia
  5. growlithe
  6. quilava-fobbie
  7. sneasel-kate
  8. heliolisk-fobbie
Heya, dropping in with the part 2 of my review exchange for this story, since I figured that this week was as good as any to bump it along:

Chapter 2

“So what’s it gonna be, girlie?”

Rene: “I don’t suppose that you moving that blade-tail away from my eyes is an option-” ._.
Ocher:
bdd.jpg


The pirate captain’s tail blade was only a few inches away from Rene’s skull. Maxim was paralyzed as the amused dragon leaned in closer.

“It’s your life, or your goods. Pick one.”

Okay, two things to get them out of the way since it might also pop up elsewhere in the chapter, but passive voice (“was [X]ing”, “had [X]ed”, etc.) tends to make for a less “active” feeling. Also, as a general rule of thumb, you ideally want details like emotional states to be self-evident through description as opposed to being bluntly told to the audience what they are. e.x. as a throwaway revamp for the underlined sentence:

Maxim stood paralyzed as the Noivern leaned in closer and his mouth curled up into a sneering grin.

Some food for thought, anyways.

Rene and Ocher locked eyes for what seemed to be an eternity, with the wind being the only thing heard between the two. She knelt down and slowly released Maxim. The former human swore she turned back to him briefly before stating her answer.

“You moppet, pick someone to be a bigger tool than me.”

Ocher:
Screen_Shot_2023-01-02_at_2.27.44_AM.png


Everyone on board, from pirate to crew member, glared wide-eyed at the Mienfoo’s bluntness. Even Clyde’s smile had vanished, replaced by a steep frown. Maxim frantically crawled away from Rene.

“Is that so?” Ocher chuckled, pulling back his tail.

Huh, Ocher took that a lot better than I thought he would. Maybe.

Without warning, he slammed Rene face-first into the wooden deck. The weasel let out a yelp as she was lifted up in the Noivern’s claws.

Whelp, spoke too soon there.

“Going to keep that bravado, eh? I guess I’ll do this slowly then!”

Yeah, I knew that this guy was giving me Consul D vibes.

BANG

This time she was Ocher slammed her down even harder, leaving behind visible cracks on the boards.

BANG

Ah yes, starting with one of the cover art characters in the process of getting brutally maimed. Always a great beginning to every story.
698047915079237695.webp


Ocher raised her up for a third time.

BANG

Then a fourth, each impact leaving a bigger dent in the floor. As the crazed pirate pulled the battered Mienfoo up again, she was covered in wood shards and bruises.

Ocher: “Again, girlie. The goods, or your life. Choose wisely.

The Noivern leaned her in close. “Well? Still got that fire in your eyes?”

[ ] Rene tilted her head over to Maxim, then stared directly into Ocher’s eyes.

“Yeah, I do.”

I think that it might have made sense to take a sentence or two to describe how beat up Rene is right about now and any reaction that Maxim might have to it, since it’s a chance to show off their mutual personalities and how they react to things. While I get that Rene’s meant to be a steely and stubborn type, it could be shown off a bit more, while Maxim’s honestly a bit of a blank at the moment that could be filled in a bit by showing his internal thought process a little more.

Ocher: “Well then, I see you’ve made this really easy for me.”

A growl came from Ocher’s maw as the dragon raised his claws to her throat. “I’m getting rather bored of yah! Time to cut the fun and skin ya alive!” He turned to his crew. “What do you say, boys?! Want me to give em a proper show?”

Yeeeeeaaah, that certainly got really dark really fast. I’ll take the under on this guy not winding up dying horribly at some point in the near future.

Roars of laughter echoed. Ocher raised his claws high in the air before coating them in draconic energy. Maxim’s heart felt like it would beat out of his chest.

Thump Thump

Fear coursed through him as his blood turned to ice in his veins.

Wait, is Rene still remaining defiant and unfazed right now? Or is she starting to visibly waver? Since it’s not really clear from the context at the moment.


Rene: “Oi, what are you going on about? You’re not the one about to be skinned alive here!” >_>;
Maxim: “That doesn’t mean that I want to see that happen right in front of me! Seriously, Rene! How are you just this calm right now?!”
554513872514449424.webp


Thump Thump

There had to be something, anything he could do! He tried to pick himself up, but his body refused to move. The dragon’s claws began to race forward to sink into-

Thump Thump

“That’s enough outta you lot! No fun n’ games for yah!”

Maxim: “Oh thank god, that was way too close.”
804848035485450290.webp


The pirate captain paused mid-swing. All attention was drawn to Clyde, who stood with his chest puffed out on stacked boxes. A golden badge, shaped like a crown of feathers, was in his hands.

“And what do you think you’re going to do with that?” Ocher growled, pointing his tail at the Politoed. A Manectric and a Houndour rushed at Clyde, but he jumped high within seconds. Landing on one of the topmasts, he tossed a glowing orb. The object dropped all the way to the deck, shattering into light as bright as the Sun. Maxim reflexively raised a wing to shield his eyes.

Maxim:
giphy.gif


The light faded after a few seconds. Maxim removed his wing to see scores of pirates clenching their eyes and rolling on the deck. Ocher had covered his eyes with his wings, while Rene had buried her face in her free arm.

I was going to ask if that was a Luminous Orb that Clyde threw there, but no, it was clearly called a ‘badge’, so I’m not sure what just happened.

FWEEEEETTTTTTTTTTTT

Shrill whistling came from the sky. Stacks of containers rattled before several silhouettes rushed out in a tide of newcomers. A blue figure blitzed past a row of pirates, knocking them down in a single strike. The blur impacted struck Ocher and pulled Rene out of his grasp. The figure stopped and let her down a few feet away. Maxim took in the newcomer's appearance.

Oh, this is that Quaquaval from the cover art, isn’t it?

A bipedal bird stood arms crossed in front of Ocher. The bird was blue with a yellow bill and a red and blue feather crest on their head. A light blue feather with a streak of white stood out in the center. Covering their torso was a fancy white and blue vest complete with a navy blue scarf on their left shoulder. A name sprung in Maxim’s mind: Quaquaval.

Yeah, I knew it. I’m going to guess that this is the ‘Signal’ everyone was talking about last chapter.

“You really threw me off track showing up this early!” The bird snarked in a deep and suave voice. “Not a big deal!”

A trio consisting of a Cacnea, Krokorok, and Liepard sprung at the newcomer from behind, but the Quaquaval roundhouse kicked them into a stack of empty boxes. “How rude!” He groaned.

Damn, this guy’s got style. And didn’t miss a beat there.

The Noivern’s eyes widened. “What are you doing here, Drake?!” He turned over to the other newcomers, all of them wearing the same blue scarves.

Well, that’s not ‘Signal’ there, though duly noted, even if that’s a fairly on-the-nose name for a duck character. :V

“This is a trap!” The bat-dragon roared, slapping his tail into the ground. “Boys, give em’ all you got!”

Whelp, looks like Ocher and his crew will be getting that BAD END™ sooner than I thought, since… yeah. I’m not holding my breath on them doing well against that.

In a split second, everything went to hell. The Serene Grace’ s deck erupted into a battlefield. Fireballs, spraying water, and even lightning attacks all clashed with each other, cascading colorful sparks and smoke everywhere. Taking advantage of the chaos, Maxim flapped away to find a hiding spot. He only got a few feet before he bumped head first into a black furred Sneasel. The orange scarf tied around their shoulder confirmed that he had made a grave mistake.

Maxim: “Um… hi there. How about we both just pretend we didn’t see each other and move on?”
701630550720512120.webp


“Tsk! I’m gonna pluck your feathers for that one!” The Sneasel hissed, brandishing his claws.

Maxim: “Well, it was worth a shot, at least.”
698047915079237695.webp


Maxim rolled to the side to avoid a claw swipe. He bolted away, weaving through fallen pokemon and flying projectiles. A fireball went over his head, the heat forcing him to dive to the ground. He turned his head at a slight creak behind him, and found the sneasel was still in pursuit with claws encased in razor-sharp ice.

“DUCK, YOU IDIOT!”

Maxim obliged as Rene launched like a speeding bullet into the Sneasel, sending the mon flying across the deck. The Mienfoo dusted herself off before sending a glare toward Maxim. Bruises and messy fur still covered her body, but her fiery gaze remained unshaken.

Oooh, that one had to leave a mark. 4x weaknesses be like that.

“Rene, you’re able to move around?!” Maxim stammered. “W-what’s going on?! Who are these guys?!”

Rene glared back. “I don’t have the time to explain it all, but if you see someone with a blue scarf just know they’re gonna be your buddy! How ‘bout you answer a question for me ?” She leaned forward.

“Why the bloody hell did you run away? At least try to defend yourself!” she barked.

Maxim:
humanrev-gif.28910672

Rene: “Oh yeah, that’s going to get you out of being run through by Ocher. Not. Seriously, look alive out there!” >_>;

The Rowlet shuddered. Fighting against bloodthirsty pirates? He couldn’t even outrun one!

“I-I can’t fight. Not at all!” Maxim said.

IMO, it probably makes sense to differentiate Maxim’s explicit internal thoughts from the surrounding text. A fairly common practice among other fics I’ve read is to handle them in italics, which I’ve suggested here.

“A pokemon that can’t fight? You must be pulling a Wooloo on me.”

A few seconds of silence was her answer. The weasel signed, before turning away. “Fine. That amnesia of yours must be that bad..” She pointed to a stack of boxes. “Do me a favor. Either stay right behind me or hide away. Just try to be anythin’ other than a moving target.”

>stay behind Rene

That… feels like a pretty bad choice for Maxim to make considering how this girl literally refused to back down from a pirate captain who was about to turn her into a fur coat.
1105356025936228434.webp


Maxim considered his options. If he were to hide he wouldn’t have to worry about constantly being attacked, but on the other hand if a pirate found him… He shuddered. Rene began to walk away, forcing him to when he at last made up his mind.

“W-wait! I’ll go with you!” He stammered. “I-I promise I won’t get in the way!”

giphy.gif


I mean, he’s a protagonist, so I’m sure it’ll work out in the end, but still.

The Mienfoo sighed and waved her paw forward. Maxim was quick to hop behind. Right as the two made their way around one of the masts, a massive column of water impacted the ground. As the water dispersed, it left behind a curious sight: a Floatzel with Fraxure headlocked under his arm, with his blue scarf wrapped around the base of his tail. Cuts and scars lined his body, while his face sported a huge grin.

YO , Rene! How are you feelin’?!” The Floatzel said with a deep, bellowing voice.

Ah yes, he’s a bit out of his natural element, but you can’t go wrong with a Float on a ship.
1011010647670149280.webp


Though this is a bit of a funny coincidence since I actually have a pirate and sailor Fraxure and Floatzel myself in one of my stories… even if the roles are a bit reversed here and this axeface is probably going to not going to get much of a billing in the future.

Rene crossed her arms and laughed. “Doin’ good, Conner! I’ll feel much better when this mission’s done.”

The Floatzel laughed back. “Aye! I say we pay 'em back at least twofold for those scrapes!” He brought turned his attention over to Maxim. “What about the little one over there? Ain’t never seen ‘im before.”

Fraxure:
757978476950192229.webp

Maxim: “Um… shouldn’t you be more worried about that Fraxure that you’re grappling onto?”
554513872514449424.webp

Conner: “Nah, he ain’t going anywhere fast right now, it’s all good.”
1011010647670149280.webp


“Oh him?” She shrugged “Says he’s comin’ along. He won’t be much help in a fight, so I guess he’s on cheerleadin’”

The pirate went limp in Conner’s grip. He dropped them to the floor before kicking them away.

“Let’s get a move on then!”

Well that’s definitely one way to drop an opponent. Situational, but I suppose it’s a handy way to not get cut up by those tusks.

A few minutes later, the daring pair of Rene and Conner cleared out any pirate that got in their way. Conner hosed down a group of pirates with a wave of water, with Rene following up with a flurry of kicks. To finish them off, Rene charged energy into her fist, hit the closest pirate, and sent them flying into the group like a bowling ball into pins. Maxim stood in awe behind the spectacle.

This is insane! How are they able to keep up with one another?

I actually wonder if this shouldn’t have been a hard scene cut since:

A: A “few minutes” is a long time when there’s a big ball of violence going on, especially in a cramped battlefield like a ship deck.
B: It makes it feel like we “skipped less” e.x. consider following suggested rework with no scene break, which basically differs from yours by 2 sentences:

The pirate went limp in Conner’s grip. He dropped them to the floor before kicking them away.

“Let’s get a move on then!”

Rene and Conner took off running as Maxim tried to keep up, and much to his astonishment, the pair cleared out any pirate that got in their way. Their strategy played out over and over with surprising effectiveness: Conner would hose down a group of pirates with a wave of water, and Rene following up with a flurry of kicks. Even the latest group proved no match as Rene charged energy into her fist, hit the closest pirate, and sent them flying into the group like a bowling ball into pins. Maxim stood in awe behind the spectacle.

T his is insane! How are they able to keep up with one another?

Since that way, you still functionally have your fast-forward, but it feels less like we just arbitrarily cut ahead in the battle.

His curiosity continued to grow, but first he would need to find a safer spot to observe. Finding a nearby barrel, Maxim hopped inside and peered through a gash in its wooden side. Beyond the duo’s position, the fighting still waged on with ferocious intensity.

Wait, ‘His curiosity’ about what, exactly? How Drake’s crew are battling? Their fighting techniques? It probably makes sense to be specific here.

Close to the ship’s bow, Clyde paired up with a Grapploct, the latter swinging around pirates as if they were toys into each other. The Politoed himself bounced on the head of one pirate, jump kicked into a second one, then froze a third with a beam of ice. Before the Rowlet could see what happened next, he picked up on shouting coming from the middle of the deck.

Yeeeeeeah, looks like Ocher wound up mugging the monster here given how much Drake and his crew are just plowing through his goons. I wonder if that’s deliberate or not, since at the moment, this battle feels pretty one-sided in Team Drake’s favor here when even random crewmembers that haven’t been established as uniquely strong up to this point are dropping multiple randos in rapid succession.

Spaced out enough to form a small arena, Ocher the Noivern and the Quaquaval were staring each other down while carefully moving around in a circle.

“Once I’ve skinned your sorry hide, Drake, every pirate worth their salt is gonna know who the real prowler of the west skies is!” The pirate-captain growled.

He flapped his wings which caused a wave of air to rush like a bullet. Drake twirled to the side to dodge, the attack instead hitting the ground and knocking up splinters.

Oh, so Drake and his crew are pirates themselves, huh? I see that this is a “cutthroat” vs “romanticized” scuffle here. Maybe. I suppose Drake could turn out to also be a total psycho, but he didn’t give off that vibe in his introduction.

“Now that’s the spirit! It’s great to aim for sky high goals!” Drake taunted, waggling a feather. “But if you’re looking for some better rep, you might want to start with taking on someone in your own league!”

I mean, considering how every member of Drake’s crew other than Maxim that’s gotten explicit focus thus far has dropped at least 3 pirates apiece… yeah. Though I do wonder if this could’ve been foreshadowed more, especially in the sequence where Rene’s letting herself get beat up.

Ocher growled before his form crouched to the ground. Violet light coated his claws as they extended into blades. Drake responded in turn by summoning back his a pair a of water sabres, crossing them together in an X pattern. .

“Shall we dance?” Drake grinned.

Ah yes, there’s a song for this general mood right about now:
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0e3_-08CFMg


Within a split second, both combatants closed the gap. Ocher attempted to land the first strike, launching one claw at Drake’s side while his tail zipped in from the other. Drake stepped back and struck the Noivern’s arm twice, leaving a visible cut. With a hiss, Ocher leapt into the air, charged his claws with draconic energy, then dived. Drake raised his water sabres to meet the attack head on.

BOOM!

The clash was strong enough to release a small shockwave that knocked down nearby pokemon. As the dust settled, Drake and Ocher were locked head to head: the dragon’s scowl countered by the grin on the Quaquaval’s face.

I can already see the gigantic troll face on Drake’s beak right now.

“I’ve had enough of this, you damned feather bag!” The Noivern snarled, pressing his attack onward.

“Already? I thought this dance was just getting started~!” Drake chuckled back, his twin sabers still holding the line.

Yeeeeeeah, I’ll take the under on Ocher being relevant as a character past the chapter. Since just saying, this is probably a sign to turn tail and bolt.

The duck’s position slowly started to give, allowing Ocher a small opening. His bladed tail shot forward, causing Drake to veer to the side.The attack landed close enough to rip from the front to the back of his jacket.

“Why you..” He grunted.

Drake swung his leg into Ocher’s torso. The bat-dragon flinched from the strong attack. Drake didn’t waste the opportunity, slamming his foe with flurries of kicks ending with a roundhouse kick that knocked him across the deck and into an unlucky Gabite pirate.

Damn. Remind me to never mess with Drake’s wardrobe. Though is Maxim meant to be spectating this? If so, has he been having any internal thoughts as to what he’s been seeing of Drake’s fighting here? Since it feels like we’ve shifted out of a limited perspective and into an omniscient one here.

Drake took a deep breath. Ice slowly formed on the bottom of his legs, condensing until makeshift ice skates formed under his feet. Ocher rose from the ground. Sparks flowed from Ocher’s maw right before he launched a massive fireball. Drake met the attack head on and cut the fireball in two. Flipping into the air with the ice blade still on his feet, the Quaquaval became a spinning blur. Ocher tried to block using his wings, but the attack broke through before swerving into his side. The Novern was launched away, howling as he impacted hit the ground.

… Wait, as in all the way below the sky? Or did you mean the ‘deck’ there? Since I can’t tell if Ocher just fell to his death or not.
1105356025936228434.webp


Unfortunately for Maxim, the landing spot was right in front of his barrel. He turned back to Rene and Conner’s position, only to see the two had moved further on.

Shit! I need to get out of here!” He panicked.

Maxim: “M-Maybe he didn’t see me?”
701630550720512120.webp


A tall shadow loomed over the barrel. Maxim stared into the bloodshot eyes of Ocher. His heartbeat zoomed as the Noivern split the barrel in two with a tail strike. Ocher's claws seized Maxim, the Rowlet struggling against his tight grip.

Maxim:
770125468800122880.webp

Ocher: “Pipe down before I make you, feather duster.”

The crazed Noivern turned back to Drake. “Now then, let down those blades o’ yours before I squish this little one!”

His claws began to squeeze Maxim, the breath being sucked right out of his lungs. [ ] Tears started to form in Maxim’s eyes.

IMO, you go a little 0-100 here in this paragraph. It probably makes sense to spend an extra sentence describing things hurting progressively more and more for Maxim to sell the sense that he’s getting the life progressively squeezed out of him.

N-no! Someone! Anyone! Help!

Suddenly, a strange pink light enveloped both Maxim and Ocher. The former human found himself unable to move anything beyond his eyes.. Straining them around, he saw that the pirate captain himself was also frozen with his bloodshot eyes darting around.

This smells like a Psychic. Is that Clyde’s doing?

Some of the remaining pirates rushed over to their captain’s aid, only to freeze when a shadow flew overhead. The shadow curved around and swept over the deck, knocking them all down. It back around, this time heading straight at the frozen duo. Like a speeding jet, the shadow impacted Ocher. Maxim soon found himself in its claws.

The Rowlet groaned at the familiar sensation of rushing wind against his feathers. He looked up at his rescuer. It was a Braviary, an impressive crest of white feathers billowing out from their head. Patterns on the crest glowed with pink and violet energy then unleashed an energy wave. The crescent shaped attack slammed into the Noivern’s back.

Ah yes, H-Braviary. I wonder if this is the ‘Signal’ we’ve been hearing about here.

Drake had the opening he needed. He shot into the air, ice energy freezing his legs again. With a yell he twirled into another spin attack. The blow smashed Ocher directly on the head, slamming him face first into the wooden deck. Splinters flew everywhere as the Noivern rebounded onto his back, unmoving.

Maxim: “Whoa…”
684293502049320970.webp


The sharp end of his tail twitched as Drake removed the blade, then held it up into the air. The fighting came to a standstill as friend and foe alike diverted attention.

I actually didn’t realize that Ocher was wearing a tail-dagger at all. That’s probably a detail that should’ve been a bit clearer, since at first I thought that was just meant to be his natural tail there.

- Drake dusts himself off -
Drake: “Well, then. Anybody else care for a dance?” ^v^

Drake took a deep breath, then shouted. “This battle is over! Surrender, and I promise the rest of you will go unharmed.”

Ah, I see that explains the title of this chapter, even if the hunters have become the hunted in fairly short order.

Though I suppose that it’s a good thing that Drake is (probably?) not a state actor, since… yeah. Historically, captured pirates did not have great life expectancies.

Silence passed. Then, one by one, the remaining pirates held up their arms and other substitutes. Maxim let out a sigh, then scanned the deck. He found Rene sitting on a stack of defeated pirates, their orange scarves tossed into their own pile. In the middle of that quelled chaos, Maxim felt a smile creep up on his face. Unpleasant first impression aside, the weas-err Mienfoo was a force to be reckoned with.

Ah yes, atop a pile of corpses fainted bodies. Though I suppose that this is a sign that Maxim’s going to be getting into the deep end very fast given that the crew he stumbled across is definitely way up there in terms of strength.

He still needed to focus on the pressing issue. Despite floating calmly in place, the Braviary still had a strong grip on him. Maxim swallowed the fear blooming in his heart and spoke.

Wait, what pressing issue is that? Since this is a bit vague in phrasing here.

“Uhh hello, could you let me go already?”

The Braviary stared back, then nodded. Maxim dropped down, quickly flapping his wings. The deck approached faster and faster with the Rowlet’s flaps speeding up. The Rowlet shut his eyes tight, then felt himself gently hit solid ground.

Maxim: “Whew. I think that I’ve had enough excitement for one day.”
638558949716787200.webp


Maxim opened his eyes. Pirates were bunched up into tight groups bound by metal chains, while the unconscious ones were arranged into rows tied up with rope. Blue-scarved pokemon went back and forth between the two ships using the tether lines. Maxim marveled at how coordinated the dismantling was. Even with how busy things were, some mons still remained on deck, hanging out and laughing with each other like nothing had happened.

Maxim: “Wait, what are you going to do with all of these guys anyways?” .-.
Rene: “Haven’t worked that one out yet, really. But that’s above my pay grade anyways.”
476581281094828033.webp


How can they just joke around like this? He thought. Just who are these gu-

I take it that Maxim didn’t notice the part where Ocher mentioned that he was challenging Drake for the title of ‘prowler of the west skies’, since… yeah. That would make this quite a bit less mysterious here.

A lone shadow looming over him snapped the Rowlet out of his thoughts. He subconsciously swiveled his head around to see the same Quaquaval. Maxim recoiled back.

“Oh, uhh hey there! Nice to meet you! Drake, wasn’t it?” He laughed, slowly shuffling away.

Drake straightened up and crossed his arms, only to relax with a chuckle a few seconds later. “A Rowlet? Don’t think I’ve ever seen you before!”

Wait, just how big is the Serene Grace’s crew? Since Drake’s line implies that it’s large enough that he’s not necessarily on a name basis with everybody.

A gust of wind passed over the two right as the Braviary landed next to Drake. Maxim took a look at the huge eagle. Small scars and nicks lined their body. A blue scarf remained wrapped around their left leg, the symbol vaguely resembling Drake’s head. Their violet head crest glowed as they locked eyes with the Quaquaval.

The pair locked in a silent stare for a few seconds, before Drake knelled and placed an arm on Maxim’s head. “So you’re the one Signal rescued. Interesting!” He raised his other arm to his chin. “It’s been a long time since I’ve seen one of your kind on this side of the skies.”

Whelp, we’ve got confirmation that the H-Braviary is indeed Signal there.

“Y-yeah, that’s nice... Uhh, excuse me sir, but you’re the captain, right?” Maxim said, recoiling. “The nurse here told me it was a merchant ship, but that’s clearly not what’s going on!”

Maxim: “Because I swear that Noivern said that you were the ‘prowler of the western skies’.”
554513872514449424.webp


The Quauqaval chuckled and rubbed Maxim’s head. “Did he now? Well you see, that was just a little white lie! Good on him for not letting the Meowth out of the bag!” He clasped both his feathery arms together.

Standing up, Drake proceeded to twirl in place, placing a hand on his crest. Sparkles radiated from the Quaquaval’s form, completing the fabulous pose. Maxim nearly fell over from shock.

“It’s true, we aren’t merchants.” He waggled a feather. “I’m Captain Drake, leader of Aqua Step! We’re Privateers! ”[/QUOTE]

Oh, so they’re state-sponsored pirates. Since I certainly know what a ‘privateer’ is. Though yeah, unless capital punishment isn’t a thing in this setting, now I’m really surprised that some portion of Ocher’s crew didn’t attempt to run for it while their own ship was operational, since… yeah. Considering what Ocher was like and how he implies that he’s brutally murdered a bunch of Pokémon in the past, it’d be hard to imagine that he and a decent chunk of his crew wouldn’t be hung or else get stuck with a fate that’d make them wish they were hung after getting remanded into a government’s custody.

“Priva- what?

“Privateers! Nothing more, nothing less!”

Rene: “I’m… guessing you don’t remember that term either from your amnesia, huh?” -_-;

Maxim racked his brain around that word. Privateer Privateer Privateer… I’ve heard that term somewhere before… Think it has some relation to pirates. He paused as a definition came to mind. Privateer - someone with the right to pirate under government rights. In other words-

“Y-you’re pirates too?!” He squawked.

Yeah, I had a feeling that this was going to be a ‘romantic’ vs. ‘cutthroat’ pirate fight.

Drake waggled a feather. “ Priv-a-teers~! Get it right~!”

Maxim slapped a wing to his face. This long day was about to feel even longer.

Well, I don’t think that that’s gonna fly so hot if Drake plies waters under a hostile government, since… yeah, they’re just going to treat him and his crew like any other pirates. Though it’s definitely uncommon to see another story with thief-y protagonists like this.

Elsewhere, in the endless void..

“What were you thinking, letting him drop in without coordination?! Did you want him to die before he could even begin to realize his purpose?!”

Oh, so there’s more than one voice beyond the one that gave Maxim his personality quiz. Duly noted.

“Hmm, I suppose my calculations were off. Nevertheless, giving him a chance to meet another variable is the best outcome for him.”

Wait, ‘another variable’? As in Maxim isn’t the only human in Alrest his present world right now.

“All the knowledge of the world, and yet you failed! How can you even call this the best outcome?”

“Oh dear sister, always driven by your emotions. He is a hardy individual. If you do not believe me, then wait for the next ‘experiment’ to begin. Even our sibling would agree.”

“Hmph, fine! But should you fail to keep it under control… then I shall step in.”

>our sibling

Wait, are these all Legendaries chatting with one another? Since I’m getting that vibe right about now.

Also, I see Drake’s just as dashing in art as he is in the story. ^^

Well, that was quite the ride there. I’d seen a few other reviewers compare this story to Fledglings which I and @Virgil134 work on, and… honestly, I can see the resemblance, even if the cast is quite literally a bit up in the clouds. It’s got that bright adventure-y vibe with dark undertones or implications lingering here and there, which is a convenient mechanism for making things get real™ when the narrative calls for it, which is a surprisingly uncommon vibe for PMD fanfictions in general. Also that chapter art. Mixed media presentations are always rare birds from how much effort it takes to pull them off, but man is it done well here.

As for critiques, the full rundown is in the line-by-line, but beyond the formatting of your TR version being distracting with all the extra newlines that are just there for some reason, the biggest issue that I had was that sometimes the description was a bit lacking and made it a bit hard to follow things, or else felt like it made parts play out a bit faster than they should. I was a little ambivalent about the way Ocher’s crew was handled, since while I can buy the idea that they could be baited into biting off more than they can chew, I have to wonder if their decision-making is fully logical from their perspective. Like if they’re getting wrecked to the point that they’re not inflicting meaningful losses on the Serene Grace after boarding in spite of being dropped by the heapload, you'd think that they’d start being less eager to charge into battle short of it being established that “stay and fight or else” is Ocher’s standard operating procedure for his crew. Also, when Ocher gets dropped and the brilliant idea to raid the Serene Grace goes to hell, I’m a little surprised that everybody on his crew just… gives up there. Like obviously, if their ship just casually gets blown out of the sky or visibly disabled or put in a position where it can’t flee without one of the prior two happening around the time that Drake calls for a surrender, it’d make sense since the alternative is getting beaten into submission. But given that that wasn’t described happening, I’m legit surprised that none of the pirates attempted to bolt to regroup sans Ocher so they could reorganize with whoever managed to get away and raid and loot another day.

But all-in-all, it didn’t take me that out of things, and I honestly probably missed some things in my review thanks to being too busy having fun with the story and how it was playing out. I’ll be keeping an eye on this one, @Z102eternal . I mean, yeah, some of it’s personal bias on my part, but you’ve genuinely got a potential gem of a story here, and I’ll be looking forward to see where you’ve been taking it. ^^
 
Last edited:

Umbramatic

The Ghost Lord
Premium
Location
The Yangverse
Pronouns
Any
Partners
  1. reshiram
  2. zygarde
Hi! Here for Review Blitz! I have returned to your fic for another round.

Last we left off - oh right, pirates. Angry vicious pirates of tougher Type varieties. Hoo boy.

Haha boy Rene is really getting slammed.

But Clyde sticks up for her. Which involves some sort of very bright Orb.

A Quaquaval! And one with style! Knocking over pirates like bowling pins!

"Duck you idiot" no the Quaquaval is a duck, Maxim is an owl.

Lmao Maxim is told to just hide and not get in the way.

Most of this is just one big fight scene so I don't have much commentary but that's not a criticism because you're pretty darn good at fight scenes. I'm envious.

sqeemz the owel

A Braviary! You don't see those in any Pokefic much, PMD or no.

The pirates have been kicked in the booty. All in a day's work.

Maxim is intimidated by the much bigger birb.

Captain Drake SPARKLES, essential for any anime pretty boy, er, duck.

Privateers, pirates, they're TOTALLY different, shut up Maxim, you know nothing you stupid owl

Ah yes. The VOID. There are voices in the VOID. Talking about test runs, and our local stupuid owl being one of the,. They are brother and sister. Probably Legendaries. And they have plaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaans. Excellent, delicious intrigue.

Also very nice art of Drake there.

That was pretty nice again! Again half of it was a big kablooie fight scene but that didn't matter because also again you are good at those. And we are getting into the deeper mystery with Maxim! Yaaaaaaaaaaay! Thanks for posting
 

Spiteful Murkrow

Busy Writing Stories I Want to Read
Pronouns
He/Him/His
Partners
  1. nidoran-f
  2. druddigon
  3. swellow
  4. lugia
  5. growlithe
  6. quilava-fobbie
  7. sneasel-kate
  8. heliolisk-fobbie
Heya, I decided to take advantage of the longer than normal day on my end of things to square away some loose ends for reading commitments, which took me to the last chapter that I hadn’t gotten to as part of our review exchange:

Chapter 3

Also, I’ll get it out of the way, but yeah. Don’t forget to fix the spacing of the TR version of your story.

Privateers, huh?

Maxim pondered over the term. To be rescued from pirates by pirates. Fate was truly laughing at his expense again.

I mean, is that really so unbelievable considering how even normal criminals have a tendency to infight at the drop of a hat, Maxim?
701429736290910228.webp


“So you are all privateers? What does that mean?” Maxim asked.

Drake raised a wing to his chin. “Well, we do a lot of things. Exploration, capturing targets, fighting pirates, you name it!”

Maxim: “... I’m sorry, but Ocher and his crew literally just tried to do that and they’re outright pirates, so what exactly is the difference again?”
916590116670144542.webp

Drake: “We have state backing!” ^v^

The Quaquaval leaned down at Maxim. “I’m surprised you’ve never heard of that term. It should be well known out here in the Southwestern Skies. Are you from another country, perhaps?

Oh, so there’s outright different countries in this setting. Though I suppose it’d make sense otherwise Drake would have a whole lotta nothing to steal as a privateer.

“Well I, uhh, I have a bit of memory loss,” he stammered. I better just play into it for now. Not like he’ll believe me falling out of the sky…

“Memory loss?” Drake asked.

Maxim: “Um… yes? That’s not normal around here, is it?” .^.

The Rowlet nodded. “Yes sir. I remember falling through the sky, then something caught me and I blacked out. When I woke up, I was aboard the ship. I don’t remember anything before that.” Maxim glanced down, unable to look Drake in the eye.

Drake:
992880313871126549.webp

Maxim: “(Oh boy, not even a day in and I’m already getting in trouble.)”
554513872514449424.webp


“Oh man, sounds like a hassle!” Drake groaned. “And going by what Signal told me, you didn’t have a poke to your name either! Do you at least have an idea of what you want to do now?”

What I want to do? Well…

Maxim: “Not dying would be a nice start?” ^v^;
Drake: “Well, you certainly picked the right crew for that, there!” o<o

There wasn’t any sort of thread or established base he had in this world, only some vague idea of his purpose to be here.

Save the world, but from what?

An evil snowflake? I mean, you did fall into the world full-on Gates style, so… :P

“I don’t really know. I do want to get my memories back, but I don’t even have a way of figuring that out. No leads, or anyone I can ask. Nothing.”

[ ]

“How tragic to have to deal with that on your own, with no one to help you out.But~!” The Quaquaval flashed a grin. “If you need a good starting point, have I got an offer for you! How about you joi-”

IMO, this section would benefit from Drake getting some sort of reaction in terms of body language to Maxim where he studies him or something like that, since it just feels like something is missing there.

“HEY BOSS!”

A voice yelled from across the deck. Maxim did a double take at Rene effortlessly carrying a burlap sack twice her size. His shock wore off as she tossed the sack at Drake’s feet, causing tied-up orange scarves to fall out.

The Mienfoo spoke with a smirk. “Deck crew worked extra fast this time! We’ve got most of the raiders chained up already!”

Maxim: “Wait, are all of those pirates you caught just chilling on the deck right now? Isn’t that a serious security hazard for you all?” .^.
Drake: “I’m sure we have a brig somewhere… Probably. Maybe.” ^v^;

Drake returned the grin. “Well done! Bisha might make us a larger quilt this time!”

“Well if she does, she better let us actually fly it like a flag this time!”

“No promises!”

A quilt, huh? Well that’s definitely an unconventional war trophy there. Just how many of those do they have lying around on the Serene Grace anyways?

Watching them going back and forth was quite the surprise. Coupled with how she acted around Conner, the Mienfoo wasn’t much of a grouch after all!

The conversation was finally broken by Drake raising a hand to his beak. “I’m glad to see you in such high spirits Rene, but you look rather scratched up.”

Oh, so she did get hurt from getting smashed into the deck repeatedly. I was getting some mixed signals from last chapter.
827659294400970753.webp


Rene rubbed the back of her head. “That dragon bastard roughed me up a bit, yeah, then his crewmates had to keep poppin’ up like weeds! But no worries, I pulled them out all just the same!”

Ocher Underling #1: “We’re right here, you know!”
Rene: “I mean, you’re the ones chained up right now, so… are you really gonna tell me I’m wrong?”
476581281094828033.webp


“That’s good and all, but I still want you to get looked at before you try doing anything else.” Drake sighed. “It’s no good if my crew members aren’t in top shape.”

“Yeah, Yeah. ‘Don’t overdo it.’ You don’t have to tell me twice. “ The Mienfoo sighed while crossing her arms. “I’ll head to the Med Bay, no worries.”

Which is probably pretty empty given how every explicitly depicted member of the Serene Grace last chapter was just deleting pirates all day everyday, but I wonder if we’ll get to see that ourselves.

She walked off, only sparing Maxim a side glance.

Should I go talk to her? Would she even want to speak with me after being such a burden?

Come on, Maxim, you know you want to…

“Oh I’m sorry we got interrupted. She’s pretty eccentric!” Drake said.

“Yeah, I can tell.”

Maxim looked back at Ocher’s pirate ship. The sails were curled up and blue-scarved mons roamed on board , taking apart pieces of the ship. A group of orange-scarved mons were tied around the center mast with the pirate captain himself slumped over in the center.

Oh, well that would definitely help for handling those pirates without an apparent brig.

Maxim: “Wait, isn’t that ship still flightworthy? How did none of Ocher’s pirates get the idea to try and flee with it anyways?”
401085511176814613.webp

Drake: “Not sure, really. (I suppose I should’ve threatened to blow them out of the sky or something now that you mention it.) But hey, it made our crew’s lives a lot easier!”

“Hey, Captain. What’s going to happen to those pirates?” He asked.

Drake flashed him a grin. “They were our bounty this time, so we’re taking them to Calvin Island, less than a day from here. By tomorrow, we should be there with the bounty in tow!”

Maxim: “That… didn’t answer my question there, Drake.”
554513872514449424.webp

Drake: “They’re more of a ‘law enforcement’ problem once we hand them over, really. Besides, they were all kinda terrible Pokémon who would’ve done terrible things to the crew if they were physically capable of it, so don’t feel too bad for them.”
701429736290910228.webp


[ ]

“I saw they’re tied up, but what if they try to break free and cause trouble again?” Maxim said. He shuddered at the thought of being held at knifepoint by a crazed dragon again.

“No need to worry! Our talented crew is busy dismantling their ship, as you can see! If they get bold enough to break free and try to sail away…”

He took a nearby rock, raised it to the air, and let it drop back down. “Hahahaha!”

This feels like there should be a bit more description from Maxim’s end of things, especially if he’s not finding Drake’s immediate answer reassuring or something like that.

Maxim: “Drake, why are you just this chipper about the idea of casually throwing Pokémon overboard to their deaths?!”
401076862924750848.webp

Drake: “Again, terrible Pokémon who would’ve done terrible things to us if they could’ve. You learn to stop being bothered by it after a while.” ^v^;

Maxim let out a small gulp. “Okay that’s good enough for me!”

Mercifully the Quaquaval moved on. “Now then, back to what I said earlier. I think you should join my cre-”

Maxim: “U-Um! I just remembered that I got scuffed up myself and should go after Rene in the Med Bay-!” OvO;

Again, he was interrupted, this time by Signal’s flashing headcrest. Both of them had forgotten the Braviary had been sitting in place this whole time.

Maxim: “Oh thank goodness, since I’m really not sure that it’s a good idea to get involved with these guys.”
638558949716787200.webp


“Argh! I forgot all about your report!” Drake shouted. “Sorry for getting too carried away!”

He knelt down and patted Maxim on the head. “I’ve got urgent business to handle! Once that’s taken care of, I’d like to have a meeting with you later today on additional topics.”

A meeting? What else could he want from me? Maxim furrowed his brow. “Sure thing, Captain Drake. I’ll see you then.”

Drake: “So… should I take this as you officially having joined Aqua Step?” ^v^
Maxim: “Let’s… not get crazy here.” >v>;

“Thanks! I’ll be waiting for you in my quarters!” He pointed to the end of the ship. A blue door was right below the steering wheel. The Quaquaval took his leave, giving Maxim a bit of space to breathe.

“YO, ROWLET!”

Whelp, so much for that.

Or so he thought. As he turned around he was greeted with Connor rushing towards him, flanked by a Hakamo-o and a Weavile. Before Maxim could respond, the Floatzle kicked a tiny broom his way.

Maxim stared at it with a raised brow. “A broom?”

Maxim: “Also, wait. I swear that I’ve seen those two from Guiding Light before-”
Weavile: “Technically, you’re thinking of a Sneasel and a Hakamo-o. And I’m pretty sure that if we were remotely close to them, we’d be busy in the galley right now.” ^^;

“Yep, that’s right! If you’re gonna just stare around, then you’re gonna make yourself useful and help me brush the blood n’ guts off the deck!”

699082306027126844.webp


I… did not realize that the battle back in Chapter 2 was that violent and visceral, but okay then...

His eyes widened as his stomach lurched.

Conner’s Hakamo-o companion smacked him on the shoulder and gave him a fiery glare. “Oi oi oi, you’re scaring the lad half to death talking like that! Sorry, he’s got a messed up sense o’ humor!”

Oh, well, nevermind then. Somebody’s just a fan of black comedy there. Though it makes me wonder if something like what the Weavile was getting at actually has befallen the Serene Grace at some point in the past.

The Weavile shook her head. “He’s got a point. If you’re able-bodied, you can work. Crewmember or not, we’ll take everything we can get!”

“Well uhh, I don’t remember how to use a broom,” Maxim said. It wasn’t like he was exactly lying!

A snort came from the Weavile as she crossed her arms. “Yeah right, next you’re going to tell me you forgot how to fly.”

Maxim: “Well, now that you mention it…” ^v^;
Weavile: “Yeah, yeah, really funny. Get to work with the rest of us, Rowlet.”
916590528802480208.webp


“Well,” Maxim said. “Would you believe me if I said yes?”

That got the trio to stare back at him. Conner’s jaw dropped. The trio put their heads together, trying and failing to whisper out of his earshot.

“Is he serious?”

Maxim:
589897202890047522.webp


“What the hell happened to him?”

“Did he get hit on the head one too many times during the fighting?”


“Maybe he’s always been crazy?”

Maxim: “Yeeeeeeeah, whoever sent me here to stop the… whatever I’m supposed to stop really should’ve prepared me better.”

Maxim rubbed his temple. “I can hear you three! And hey, I’m not crazy! I just have amnesia!”

Conner: “Wait, you mean there’s a difference?” ^^;

“Amnewha- OH! So that's what Rene was talking about while we were busting heads! Well, you certainly haven’t lost whatever fire you’ve got burin’ inside, grass type!” Conner laughed. The other two joined in.

Maxim took the broom in his talons, quickly feeling disoriented with the extra weight on his foot.

“Ugh! How am I supposed to use this thing?!”

Connor: “You can hold things with your wings, right?” ^^;
Maxim: “That’s not how wings work!” >v<

Tsk! Just try to flap right above ground, then swing your foot from side to side.” The Weavile chimed in, rocking her arms back and forth. “C’mon! Heave! Ho! Heave! Ho!”

Oh, so the Weavile is a ‘she’. Duly noted, then. I can already tell that there’s a couple of characters in my own writing that you’re probably going to like.

Maxim flapped his wings as fast as he could and within a few seconds he was slowly lifting off the ground. Flapping his wings in a rhythm, the Rowlet wobbled in air.

Maxim: “I’m- I’m flying! I’m actually flying!
684293502049320970.webp

Hakamo-o: “Connor, you’re sure that this guy just has amnesia again?”
916590116670144542.webp


“Uhh, what was that you just said? Rock back and forth right?” Maxim said.

The Weavile flashed her fangs in a wide grin. “That’s right! Heave! Ho! Heave! Ho!”

“Uhh okay, Heave! Ho! Heave…! Ho!” Slowly, he rocked the broom back and forth, causing it to brush the ground. The motion kicked up dust, forcing him to angle his wings in a way that blew it away from him.

It’s going to go straight into someone’s face, isn’t it?

“Heave! Ho! Heave! Ho!” She shouted.

His movement slowly became more focused as he relaxed his body just a little t[ ]. The broom swung in a steady motion.

You have a word that’s abruptly cut off here that I’m not sure how it’s supposed to be finished.

The Hakamo-o sighed. “Wow, I’ll be darned. You taught a flying type how to sweep, Silva. That’s an accomplishment.”

“Damn right, Herc! I’m just that good!” She boasted, placing a claw on her hip. “What do you think, Conner?”

‘Silva’ and ‘Herc’, huh? Filing those two names away for the future, since I can tell that we’re going to be seeing more of them in this story.

The floatzel swept his tails from side to side and side. “Well uhh, he needs to work on his technique some more.” He sighed.

“You heard him, Rowlet! Let’s see you move around!” Silva shouted.

Maxim: “Hey! I’m going as fast as I can here!” >v>;

Maxim was reluctant to follow her directions, but he had to show he could do at least this one task. Stumbling forward, he flew in a straight line, wobbling the broom along the path. Small clouds of dust moved ahead of him.

Oh, so this is basically the “Maxim learns to fly” scene, huh? It’s definitely a clever way of integrating it into getting to know other members of the Serene Grace’s crew and actually doing something practical on-deck.

“That’s it! More, more, more!” Silva cheered.

Maxim swept in a calm and steady pace, dust flying everywhere as he pushed forward.. Curiosity started to take over as he wondered how long he could keep this going.

Well, only one way to find out!

Careful what you wish for, Maxim. Especially since if you do too good of a job, you’re probably going to find yourself on deck cleanup duties a lot more often in the future.

Minutes ticked by as Maxim continued to fly and sweep, attracting the attention of several other deckhands who viewed the scene with silent curiosity and amusement. He was trailed by the trio Connor and the rest of his trio continued to trail after him, Silva still coaching him on. Right as he rounded the base of the center mast, a voice cut across the deck.

“Now what are you three doin’! Stop mankeyin’ around and get back to work!”

Maxim was startled and dropped the broom. All of them straightened up as Clyde bounced down from a rope above. The trio of Conner, Silva, and Herc gave him a small salute. “We’re sorry about it sir! We just wanted to have a lil fun with that Rowlet!” They shouted in unison.

Maxim: “Wait, what? But I thought that I was actually doing something useful right now-” ovo;

“Well if yah want to mess around, I guess I can cut your rum rations as a lil payment. How about that?!” He barked.

Oh, so there’s rum in this setting too, huh? Well, you can’t say that it’s not fitting for the vibe of a pirate crew under another name.

“N-NO SIR, WE’LL GET BACK TO WORK RIGHT AWAY!” They shouted before dashing away. Clyde set his sights on Maxim.

“Sorry about that, lad! Those three are good workers, aye, but take your eyes off them and they’ll be up to Arceus-knows-what!” He sighed and crossed his arms.

Maxim: “I’m… guessing that this isn’t the most professional ship out there, huh?” -v-;

“It’s alright, sir. At least I learned I’m good at something here.” Maxim said, staring at the ground. “It was a nice way to kill time before I met the captain.”

Clyde put his arms behind his head. “Drake wants to meet with yah?! I’m surprised. He rushed past me so quickly I couldn’t even tell him hello!”

Maxim: “Why, is that rare on this crew or something? Since he kinda gave off a vibe that he knew just about everybody.” ^v^;

“Yeah, said he needed to talk with Signal quickly, but he wanted me to come by. Not sure what about though.”

[ ]

“Hmmmmm, I can’t either say either.” Clyde said, shaking his head. “ But anyway, before you do meet him, how about you swing by the medical bay? Best to make sure you’re all good to go before that!”

Oh, so we are going to be stopping by the med bay this chapter.

That reminded Maxim. Cecil! I almost forgot! I should go back and see if everything’s alright with him!

I… honestly completely forgot about Cecil myself for a second there. I wonder if there should be a more explicit reminder of “oh right, the Kirlia in the med bay” given that we’re coming back to this after a long, action-packed gap in between.

“I don’t feel like there’s anything wrong. But I guess it doesn’t hurt to check.” Maxim nodded and walked on, searching for the hatch below. “Thanks, Clyde! You’re a really cool guy!”

The Politoed chuckled at his praise before giving him a wave. “No problem, lad! Give the doctor my regards will yah!”

Maxim: “Alright then, let’s see what Cecil is like since… I kinda completely forgot about him in between almost dying multiple times last chapter.” ^v^;

Past the hatch, the interior of the ship was undamaged. The only sign of the pirates’ attack was an unconscious pair of Seviper tied up to a wall. Their orange scarves were torn to shreds. As Maxim rounded the corner, Rene was walking out of the Medical Bay. The Mienfoo’s cuts and bruises had mostly disappeared; instead there were a few bandages around her body and below her right eye. He straightened up as she walked over.

Maxim: “Wait, shouldn’t there be a lot more of those pirates that you all beat up in here? Since some of them kinda got thrown around hard.” .^.
Kirlia: “Nah, terrible Pokémon that would’ve done terrible things to us. I’m sure they’ll make it until we can dump ‘em for their bounties. Also, they’re hostis generis humani, so we’ve got some wide latitude for how we deal with them.” ^^
Maxim: “(Oh well that’s not worrying and dubiously ethical at all there…) But whatever, let’s just move right along into things.”

“Well, you’re just the mon I wanted to see. You look fine, besides a few ruffled feathers,” She said, crossing her arms. “That’s good.”

Maxim raised a brow. Praise? Did some imposter replace her? He decided to roll with it for now. “Yeah, I’m doing good. Can’t say I enjoyed having two heart attacks in one day. But this seemed usual for you and the others. Do you always try and catch pirates like this?”

Maxim: “Since, just saying, if they hadn’t been laughably weak compared to you all when they boarded…”
698047915079237695.webp


The weasel placed a paw on her hip and sighed. “Not all the time. Would have been harder to nail the guy with a good ole fashioned hunt. Certainly not with a ship like this.” She pointed at him. “But if you really wanna know more about us, just ask the Captain! He’s waiting for you anyway, right? Try not to take too long getting there!”

Maxim nodded. “Sure thing.”

Maxim: “Oh, well that was an uneventful visit to the med bay, but whatever. At least Rene’s alright from getting ground into the deck.” >v>;

Rene walked on past him for a bit before turning back. “Oh, one more thing. I guess I got you all wrong back there, yeah? Thought you were a spy n’ all. Wanted to say, my bad.”

Maxim froze. The last thing he expected her to say was an actual apology. “Hey! Wait a moment!” Maxim called out. By the time he did, the weasel had already turned around the corner, long gone.

I take it that Rene isn’t the type to give apologies easily or frequently from how quickly she just ghosted everyone after that.

Well, at least she’s still got plenty of energy in her. He thought, turning back to his destination and heading in.

The overpowering scent of alcohol and other chemicals filled the room. Replacing the dim atmosphere was candlelight from sconces around the room. Several beds were occupied by different mons sporting minor scrapes or bruises. Towards the back, a Sandslash had a black tarp wrapped around their body while a Krokorok had their mouth wrapped shut with white gauze.

Oh, so the pirates they caught are getting medical attention after all. Maybe.

Maxim: “I-Is that Sandslash dead there?”
698047915079237695.webp

Cecil: “Nah, that’s just restraints. If he was dead, we’d have just thrown his corpse overboard. No reason keeping it around stinking the place up.”

Two pokemon were moving through the rows: an elderly Audino wearing small rimmed glasses poking patients with a wooden cane, and the other had mint green.

“Cecil?”

The Kirlia was busy dispensing pink energy to an unconscious Cacturne wrapped up in protective sheets. On hearing Maxim’s voice, he tilted his head toward him.

“Maxim? Oh thank the Emerald Dragon , you’re safe!”

Maxim: “Er… are these all pirates that were defeated on-deck?”
916590486356131850.webp

Cecil: “Yes, and? We do need them alive to get their bounties.” ^^;

He quickly hugged the Rowlet, still managing the flow of energy. Maxim couldn’t help but return it. After the day’s events, the gesture was a welcome gift.

Yeah! I’m glad to be in one piece! When their captain grabbed me, I thought I was going to get skinned alive! But then, I got rescued by that huge eagle. Signal, I think!”

Cecil raised a hand to his mouth. “My goodness! At least he was able to save you!”

Maxim: “Um… just asking, but how often does stuff like this happen to you all again?”
554513872514449424.webp


Maxim avoided eye contact with Cecil for the next part. “Also, I talked with the captain. He told me you knew about everything. Is that true?”

The pink glow faded from the nearby bed as Cecil lowered his head.

Y-yes, that is true. You see, I am also a member of this crew, like everyone else. The operation was supposed to be an hour at least from when you went up to the deck,” Cecil explained. “I figured Rene would have hopefully brought you back in time before things began. But when I saw her again, I knew that wasn’t the case!”

He hugged Maxim again much tighter than before. “It’s my fault you were put into harm’s way! What kind of medical practitioner lets his patient walk into harm’s way?”

IMO, this second paragraph should be divided up into a few smaller pieces. I gave a throwaway suggestion of one potential way of dividing things up.

Aww crap, I didn’t mean to have him break down on me! Maxim thought.

“Uhhh hey, don’t cry! I’m still here, unharmed!” Maxim wiggled a wing. “See? You can scan me like before just to check right?”

Cecil wasn’t described crying or being close to it. You might want to make that a bit more explicit there before this section.

“Yes, but that still doesn’t excuse my poor judgment. What if you had been hurt, or worse?” Cecil said, shaking his head.

[ ]

“Well, it’s good we don’t live in a world where that happened.” Maxim said.

I kinda wonder if Maxim should’ve had more of a reaction to what Cecil said there, since… yeah, that fear of Cecil’s was almost realized last chapter. Multiple times.

“Good for you, but can you two have your little moment outside my operating room?” A deep and gravelly voice said.

Maxim and Cecil turned around to find that the old Audino was glaring at them both. His face was as red as a tomato, and his cane was constantly being tapped into the ground..

“Of all the things to see when I’m having to deal with this many patients.” He grumbled, raising his cane at Cecil. “Boy, I thought I told you to keep your emotions in check while caring for others! You let the heal pulse wear off right in the middle of patient care!”

I mean, on one level, this guy kinda reads like a bit of an ass, but you can’t say that from the perspective of actually practicing medicine that he doesn’t have a point there.

The angry Audino then set his sights on Maxim. “And you! What do you think you’re doing barging in here to distract my assistant? Unless your need for aid is desperate, wait your turn!”

[ ]

“Well sir, I was sent down here by Clyde, the deckmaster. He said that I needed to get a checkup before my meeting with the captain.” Maxim spoke.

Missing some description / internal commentary before Maxim turns to address the Audino there.

The Audino sighed and placed both hands on his cane, relenting his anger.

“Of course he’d send someone down here at the worst possible moment.” He adjusted his glasses. “He picked a terrible time for you to come, let me look at you real quick, boy!”

Maxim: “Um, no, that’s okay, I’ll just go and lea-”
Audino: “I said, ‘let me look at you real quick, boy.’” >:|
Maxim: “Y-Yessir.” OvO;

Before Maxim could speak, the Audino began to move his hands around the Rowlet’s spherical form. Once done, he stepped back and tapped his cane once again.

“Bah! You’re fine! It doesn’t take me examining you to tell that!” He grumbled. “Now go ahead and see the captain already!”

Maxim: “But you just- And- Ugh, whatever, I’m going now.” >v>;

At least he wouldn’t have to worry about following the old guy around. “Thank you, Doctor..?”

“Gerald. And now that I’m done with you, it’ll be back to working on the rest of them.” He tapped his cane three times before raising it at Cecil. “Come along, now! If you’re still feeling guilty, then at least make it up by completing your tasks.” The cane pointed over to Cecil’s previous patient, still tied up under the covers.

Maxim: “Boy am I glad that I’m not going to have to find out what the quality of these two’s care is like.”
827659294400970753.webp

Gerald: “Oi, our quality of care is perfectly fine! Especially when you don’t go and annoy us.”

“Yes sir, you’re right.” Cecil nodded, rising to his feet. “I apologize for letting my emotions get the best of me. I’ll keep them in check next time.” The Kirlia gave Maxim a small wave. “I promise I’ll find a way to make this up to you, Maxim. And one more thing before I go.”

“What is it?”

“I meant every word I said about regaining your memories. I hope you’re able to find yourself again!”

Maxim: “Er… thanks? I just hope that they don’t take too long to come back…” ^v^;

A warm feeling spread through Maxim’s chest. For the first time since coming to this world, he felt a smile tugging at the side of his beak. Now there was only one thing left to do.

Maxim: “Right. Drake and Signal. Though I’m still not sure what exactly it was they wanted to see me for.”

The sun was beginning to set and bathing the deck in orange when he came back up. Maxim made his way to the stern, the area devoid of anyone nearby. Right below the elevated deck was a blue door with wavy gold and white patterns etched along the edges. No mistaking it, this had to be the captain’s door. Maxim held in his uneasiness as he inched closer.

I better not keep him waiting any longer. Let’s see, what if I hopped up here?

You’re sure that you don’t want to go and knock first there, Maxim?

He gently turned the knob using his talons. It was a modestly sized room with almond-colored wood lining the floor and thick wooden shelves covering the walls. On the shelves were various books and souvenirs ranging from the severed tusk of some unknown beast to a sky blue teardrop-shaped gem embedded in a chunk of rock. Towards the back of the room and tucked in one of the corners was a small bed, thin and gray sheets neatly folded on top of the mattress.

>severed tusk of some unknown beast

I can’t tell whether or not that’s a sign that Maxim’s reflexive memory doesn’t work on parts of Pokémon, or if it’s a sign that it’s not from a normal Pokémon.

Underneath the oval windows was the heart of the room itself: the captain’s desk. Wide, glossy, and square, it held stacks of papers and leather-backed books neatly arranged on its surface. A small, yellow globe and a long, thin candle were set apart at opposite ends at the desk. In the center rested a tied blue scarf bearing Drake’s symbol, next to Ocher’s detached tailblade.

Huh, cute doodle there.

The captain was slouched into a leather chair behind the desk, turned away from the approaching Maxim while swirling an empty wine glass in his feathery fingers.

Well, somebody’s got fancy tastes there. Though I suppose Drake really did give off a vibe like he’d be a ‘wine’ kind of ‘mon.

Maxim craned his head up in an attempt to speak. “I’m here captain, right on time. There’s something you wanted to talk about with me?”

His words seemed to fall on deaf ears, as the captain continued his action uninterrupted. Silence lingered in the room for an uncomfortable few seconds, as Maxim felt a chill creeping up his back. Finally, the captain broke the silence with a smooth and deep voice.

“Have a seat.”

Maxim: “Um… I’m not sure if it’s even possible for me to sit down with these legs-” .^.
Drake: “A perch, then. Point is, let’s take a moment to chat.”

Maxim turned to one of chair on his left then hopped into it. Swiveling his chair around, the captain placed down the wine glass on the desk. Compared to the bombastic display he put on during his grand entrance and intervention, this was a complete 180.

“Now then, let’s talk about you .

Maxim:
5f0.gif


The Rowlet gulped as the captain’s gaze dug into him. Both of his feathery hands were folded below his face as he continued.

“So me and Signal had a long chat about things, including how he found you. I’ll admit, I found it a bit hard to believe that you fell from a hole in the sky, but Signal’s someone I’ve known and trusted for years. He wouldn’t fib, not even once.”

He reached under his desk and took out a small glass bottle. Inside was something that resembled rainbow-colored glass shards that shimmed brightly despite the lack of light. Maxim felt a strange pull towards the material, leaning forward, only for Drake to return the item back to its hiding place.

Oh, so those rainbow shards have something to do with summoned humans, huh? Since I saw Maxim’s reaction there.

The Rowlet blinked several times, as if snapped out of a trance. A shiver ran up his back. “That thing in the bottle, just what was that?”

“Oh, it was some kind of material that covered your body when Signal picked it up.” Drake said, combing through his feathery crest. “He brushed it away and kept it hidden in a small bottle he had on him. Pretty convenient!”

Huh. Wasn’t expecting to hear that one. Though I suppose that’s one sign that Maxim didn’t go cleanly from his human world to this one.

Maxim groaned. “He found that on me? Then can you at least tell me what it is?”

“That’s the thing, I don’t know myself.” He shrugged. “Another mystery to add to the growing pile.”

Maxim: “Wonderful. Can I go now?” >v>;

The Quaquaval folded his hands again, and this time Maxim could feel his gaze boring into his soul.

“I know giving your amnesia you probably won’t know what I’m going to mention, but would you like to hear a little…history lesson?”

Maxim: “Do I even have a choice right now?” .^.
Drake: “No, not really. But I figured that I’d be polite about it.” ^v^

Is now really the time for a lecture? Maxim thought. Oh well, I hope this is useful.

“Sure thing, captain.”

Drake cracked a smile before clearing his throat. “Ahem. Quite some centuries ago, there was a skies spanning war, one that saw countless lives impacted and destroyed. It seemed like the world would tear itself apart, until six individual pokemon stepped forth and brought an end to the chaos. These six mons are still somewhat celebrated to this very day. Though there was one that has an air of mystery to them, even now.”

Aha, important war of yesteryear, even if at first I thought that it’d have some relation to how the setting’s world was created. Getting some Aegis War vibes from this one.

Drake loomed over the desk, almost casting the room into the shadow.

“This little lecture isn’t me going off a tangent. You see, the reason why is that this pokemon was said to have been brought from another world, originally a being known as a human.”

Time crawled to a standstill, as Maxim’s heart nearly pounded out of his chest. A human..? Just like me?

Maxim: “(I’m suddenly feeling a lot more worried about the way that Drake was staring into my soul a bit earlier.)” ovo;

Drake noticed his reaction as his grin deepened within the shadows. “It’s said that when they came to this world, the field they appeared in was bathed in a shining rainbow glow, as if a gift received from the gods themselves. I can’t help but see a teeny-tiny bit of similarities, although they don’t mention a hole in the sky.”

Wait, meaning that something happened to Maxim’s arrival such that it went off-kilter? Or is that just folkloric embellishment in action?

He leaned back into his chair, much to Maxim’s relief. “It’s all just a legend, after all. I don’t exactly think you’re a human. But yours is a strange case. Never heard or seen this happen over the years I’ve flown through the skies.”

I take it that the human from legend didn’t have amnesia or else that detail didn’t survive into history, since otherwise, you’d think that the alarm bells would be going off a lot louder in Drake’s head.

Maxim racked his brain around the new information. This has happened before? And somehow he’s right on noticing what I might really be. Just who is this guy?

“Sir, if I may ask? If I was a human, how important would that be for you, or even the world?” He said.

Yeah, you’re not going to like the answer to that question, Maxim. I can already tell.

Silence settled in for a few seconds, then was broken by Drake’s laughter. “Oh my my my! It would be quite the discovery of the last few centuries! There’s plenty in this world that would view you as a powerful asset, or a dangerous tool to their own ambitions. To me, you would be a once in a lifetime opportunity to view!”

I can already see how Maxim is going to have problems later on in this story with that sort of answer.
701630550720512120.webp


“Lifetime… opportunity?” Maxim faltered.

“Regardless of who or what you are, I didn’t want to just pick you apart with my ramblings, I wanted to offer you a spot on my crew!”

[ ]

“Me? Joining a crew of pi-privateers?”

Another spot where IMO, Maxim should get in a moment to react to Drake’s line a bit more explicitly.

“Mmhph! That’s right!”

“But what would you get out of having me?! You must have heard it from Rene and the others right? I can’t fight at all! I couldn’t even sweep right with a broom! I’m just… useless.”

Maxim slouched in his chair, not even wanting to look Drake in the eyes. I bet even the last human was more talented than me. How does that voice have any faith in me?

It’s more faith that you’ll git gud before you’re needed for saving the world, which is pretty on-brand for how most humans come to PMD worlds canonically. ^^;

“Oh? But remember, you’re a pokemon! So what if you’re weak? We have the potential to strengthen ourselves through all sorts of challenges!” Drake boasted, puffing out his chest.

Drake took Ocher’s tail blade in his hand and raised it towards Maxim. “You want to get your memories back right? Then you’ll need to start somewhere. It’s time to make that choice, Maxim!”

Maxim: “Please don’t wave that around in my face, thanks.
916590486356131850.webp


Thoughts of Rene flashed into his mind. From being nearly killed by Ocher, to bouncing back and wreaking havoc on his crew. She had gone through it all without batting an eye. Could he really pull off something like that in the future?

Not with that attitude, you won’t, Maxim.

I hope you’re able to find yourself again!”

Cecil’s words still lingered, driving him to grip his talons into the chair’s wood. He has to do something, anything, to get his memories back! A stranger Drake may have been a stranger, but he was giving him a choice. Pushing reluctant thoughts into the back of his mind, Maxim sighed and made his choice.

“You’re right. Sitting around scared won’t help me. I’m here, and I’ll have to make the best of it.” He stares into Drake’s blue eyes. “I’ll join your crew, and find a way to return my memories one way or another.”

de7.png


Though I suppose that Maxim could do a lot worse given that Drake and the gang are apparently way, way up there in terms of power scaling. Exactly the sorts of buds that you need in a world where you’re weak and have no idea what on earth you’re doing.

It grew silent again as Drake reared back. The Quaquaval reached up a hand to his crest, before bursting into laughter.

“That’s it! I knew you had it in you!” He says in between laughs. “Everyone has that fire within them, even if it’s a tiny ember!” Carefully slipping the tailblade into a drawer, Drake reached behind him and placed a tied blue scarf on the desk. He reached out a hand.

“Welcome aboard, Maxim!”

I mean, I suppose it was kinda inevitable given Maxim’s depiction in the official art, but yeah. Not beating around the bush at all for getting your characters where they need to be, huh? Makes me wonder just how quickly things are going to ramp up plot-wise.

Maxim took his hand and lightly shook it with his own wing. The blue scarf was placed slid neatly into his talons.

“Good, good, good! I think that's about it for now!” Drake nodded. “Only thing left for you to do is to sign one document for me!”

1105355888639881268.webp


Drake, can Maxim even read whatever contract you’re trying to get him to sign right now?

He put a slip of parchment paper on the desk. Maxim’s eyes traced it all the way to the bottom, where a signature was laid out.

“What’s this?”

Drake moved a cup of ink next to the paper. “It’s the legally binding document that ensures that not only will you be a member of the crew, but you’ll be loyal enough to be willing to abide by our ways of living. Once you sign this, there’s no going back unless you choose to leave the crew, or I force you to. Understood?”

[ ]

“Understood.” Maxim said. “Now how do I sign it?”

Ah yes, just casually letting yourself get talked into signing a contract to become a state-sponsored actor with zero idea of what you’re getting into. This can only end well™, I’m sure.

Though I wonder if Maxim should mull things over at all, since he clearly understands what privateers are and why they’re potentially sketch, so it’s a little weird to see him just go ahead and sign a contract without stopping to think at all of what he might potentially be getting himself into.

“Place your claw into the ink and then press down on the signature line. That’ll be good enough for me!”

Maxim nodded and stuck his talons in, then pressed down on the paper. It only took a few seconds for the ink to harden dry and leave a three pronged footmark on the line.

Drake rolled up the paper, then tied it with a red string.

“PERFECT! You’re good to go, Maxim!”

Maxim: “Um… yay? Is it supposed to feel like nothing really changed, or…?” ^v^;

As much as Maxim felt he should celebrate a step forward, there was still lingering worry in his mind. “Okay, so what do I do now, Captain?”

“Mmmmm I suppose it’s rather late. The ‘orientation’ can start tomorrow. In the meantime how about you head to the mess hall and grab you something to eat? It should be right around the time they open up.” He did a shoo away motion with his hand.

Maxim: “Wait, but I thought that the deck cleaning I was doing was orien-” OvO;
Drake: “Ah-ah-ah! Need my privacy right now! Really, go and eat up, Maxim. You’ve earned it.”

The Rowlet hopped down, careful not to track any leftover ink onto the floor. He began to walk off, turning around one more time to see Drake waving him goodbye. Without another word, Maxim went through the door and closed it shut.

“Well, I hope this mess hall doesn’t take me long to find.” He muttered, walking over to the hatch.

I was going to say that the Serene Grace didn’t sound like it was that big of a ship, but… I suppose things have been ambiguous on that front, and Maxim is literally less than 2 feet tall, so it must feel gigantic to him.

“Well, that was quite the meeting…”

Drake sighed as he pulled out a bottle of wine, pouring it into his empty glass. With how well things went for this mission, it should be smooth sailing till the next. And yet…

He pulled out the rainbow shard’s bottle again, gently sitting it front and center. A chill went up his spine as he closely examined the object. By that Rowlet’s appearance, the winds of change would soon blow in across the world, and he might be front and center. Alas, he would have to wait to see what was next.

Oh, so Drake was lying about not believing that Maxim was human. I wonder what his game was there and if it did it to avoid getting into details that would’ve freaked Maxim out, or if there was some other motive in play.

On the corner of the desk sat a smooth gem, resembling an oversized pink pearl. Pressing down on it three times, he waited.

And waited.

And waited.

DINNNNNNGGGGGGGGG!!

Wait, what on earth is that thing?

“Greetings, I see you have something to report to me. I assume that the operation has taken place?”

Oh, it’s a radio. Or a bland name version of a radio.

“Indeed. It’s been done. Ocher’s crew has been neutralized without issue.”

Magnificent! That would be the third one within the last two months! Stellar as always, Captain Drake!”

“Hmph, no problem. Fletchling crews tend to get rather cocky at some point. It took a bit of research, but it was an easy setup. I’ve dealt with worse, you know. Much worse…”

… Do I want to know how politically unstable this world is if there’s just constantly a stream of cutthroats willing to roll the dice with plundering on the high skies?
699082306027126844.webp


Of course. I will make sure to still reward you accordingly! You will be on standby for a little while. I have another mission for you, but it is not a bounty. Of course, I have to keep you on your toes.”

“Acknowledged.”

I suppose the finer details can be handled at the meeting. But before I go, there seems to be something on your mind. What is it?”

Oh boy, time to see whether or not Drake lets slip what Maxim is. Since if his employers find out that he’s human… Drake might have to choose between being a privateer and having Maxim on his crew in very short order. .-.

Drake hesitated for a few seconds, mulling over his next few words carefully.

“En route to the rendezvous point, my first mate came across a peculiar pokemon. One that I think will be of interest to us both…”

994427253242990704.webp


Whelp, no takebacks. Though I’m not convinced that this isn’t going to wind up becoming a massive headache for Maxim in the near future.

Alright, made it to the end. I take it that this was a cooldown chapter after two chapters of things accelerating really fast that basically served to: A: get Maxim able to fly around, B: get Maxim better-acquainted with the crew and especially with Drake, C: establish that humans are SRS BSNS in this world and tee up hints of future conflict and intrigue. To that end, this chapter did things quite well. The characterization was also fun to watch, with Conner and his buddies being the main standouts along with Drake, while the others were unfortunately a little too hi-bye to make a firm additional impressions, but I suppose we already got to see them a bit more earlier on, so getting little wrinkles added wasn’t the end of the world.

As for criticisms. The number one flaw that I see with this chapter is that you have some spots that are cut at little too far to the bone in the interest of having a short and snappy chapter where description would go a long way towards setting a scene or more importantly, getting into Maxim’s head and showing off how he’s ticking as a character. I kinda also wish that we’d gotten to see a bit more of some characters, especially Rene and Cecil given that they appear to be set up to be pretty important from the supporting art to this story, but I suppose that there will be more opportunities for that in the future. There were also a couple of quibbles that I had regarding the logic of how Ocher’s pirates were dealt with, but those are largely carryovers of issues that I had in Chapter 2, so I won’t harp on it too hard.

But all-in-all, I thought that this was a fun chapter, and basically a cap on the introductory arc to the story. Or at least I think it was. I’m really interested in seeing where things go from here, @Z102eternal , and even if this is probably it for the story on my end during Review Blitz, I’ll be looking forward to seeing where things go from here in the future.
 

Gyeig

Bug Catcher
Pronouns
he/him
Partners
  1. samurott

Review of Chapters 6 and 7​


Yup, doing another one of these before the end of the Blitz. Going to go over another two chapters real quick, shouldn’t be too much new in these but we’ll see.

Pretty much all of the same things I said in the previous reviews still applies here unsurprisingly, so I won’t bore you to tears by just restating the exact same points I made there. Going to go over some chapter specific things this time around.

First things first, Hurik and Celeste are antagonists! That was a twist I wasn’t expecting. Sure shows how gullible I’d be if I ended up in this world somehow, haha. Anyway, that addresses the worries I wrote about earlier of how they’d fit into the storyline and the whole privateers dynamic - they’re the baddies. Plus, they’re working for someone bigger. Gonna be real interesting seeing how that develops in the future.

Other than that, not much else to say story wise that I haven’t said already. Doing a good job on that front alright.

With that said, I’ll bring up some points which I think you should have a look at, since they can be a pretty big deal for some readers.

First, the prose gets pretty damn repetitive at times. Either it’s stating Maxim’s thoughts out loud in a way that’s already implied from dialogue, or it’s just plain edging towards verbosity. An example from Chapter 6 would be this tidbit near the start:
>"Maxim groaned and rolled out of his hammock. The start of a new day had arrived, and with it, another jolt out of bed."
This was prefaced by a character doing the Loudred “UP AND AT ‘EM!” bit a moment earlier, so it’s necessary to state again. Now these kinds of individual examples are all small beans, but the small adds up to something bigger. Best to nip it in the bud before that happens.

Something else I want to comment on is the introduction of the ghostly figure in Chapter 6 - Granted, you know far better than I do how important this character is to the overall plot, but I’m assuming it’s pretty important given the drawing of this character that is given after just the first paragraph. IMO, the text doesn’t convey their importance all that well, and it feels somewhat glossed over. Even moreso given that Maxim probably isn’t used to seeing ghosts, yet here he looks to see one suddenly staring at him out of nowhere. Should elaborate on it a little more.

Finally, Chapter 6’s opening has some inconsistent spacing - can’t remember exactly if I saw this more than just at the start of chapter 6, but it’s worth doing a quick editing pass over these chapters just to check for other spots where it’s off. Not the most thought provoking comment, but still.

Alright, I think that covers just about everything I wanted to mention. Some interesting developments in these chapters for sure, especially around Hurik and Celeste. Still enjoying this fic a lot, keep up the good work!
 

Kiba Makuro

Junior Trainer
Pronouns
He/Him, They/Them
Chapter 11 Invitations.

Howdy there Zee, I’m here for Diners new fangled P-Wheel, I’m offering up 10 GBs of RAM this time.

I read this chapter when you posted it awhile back. Unfortunately my memory is laggy, either way, I really enjoyed this chapter. Maxim and Rene feel more actualized here, with their emotions, thoughts, and actions.

Alongside all the colorful characters, improved descriptions really highlighting the new vessel. All the new environments we passed, be it the clouds, the various ships. The quick incentivizing action we got near the end Pidgeot with the fake letter was fun.

We get introduced to quite a bit of new characters. So much so, I don't know if I'll be able to talk about all of them in detail.

Let's start with Katsumi. Love the Hisuian mon agenda spreading with this bloodthirsty Sneaseler. She has a strained relationship with both Captain Drake and Rene, both which were fun to see. Katsumi brings some interesting implications between the two, but more importantly leads to a whole new bunch of characters.

There's the navigator, Hypathia, who's quick to lament her energetic captain, (how did I not see/remember Katsumi was the captain).

We got introduced to quite a few, changing our point of view to a Scafty and Smeargle of Team Pathfinder 1, and the lore and mystery surrounding them is pretty cool.

We swing over to another after a bit and get introduced to The Lucky Star Pirates. With Alan as our POV. We’ve got some potential rivals to Maxim and Rene with the Charmeleon, Frogadier, and Grovyle [hey wait a minute, are you almost copying me/j], While the Lopunny and Tsareena are fun and interesting co-captains, not afraid to show off their strength. And these guys are heading to Aquarius Island just like Maxim and the crew.

From the last chapters you've improved your prose. Now unfortunately, there are some areas where you slip back into old habits. It’s okay, you did work on this before and while I sent my last review covering the issue of epithets instead of name or species name so it makes sense you wouldn’t have known to tone it down.

Here's some things prose wise I haven't mentioned before.

One sore stop was introducing the Espartha, I know it's to hide species but I think it'd be better if you didn't lead with “A female voice spoke in a deadpan tone” it's very clunky. Instead, perhaps try something like “The Espartha said, rolling her eyes/ with a grimace/ eyes narrowing. The action to just imply the tone of voice, using the she to save words.

Another awkward area is paired with otherwise good dialogue and conversation. Having two characters with two separate actions in the same sentence and then having one of them speak in one paragraph adds an action from that same character and more dialogue in another paragraph. I think it would be better if you split the actions of both characters into two different sentences and kept the dialogue from the one character in the same paragraph.

For example when Maxim raises a brow at Drake and he decides to start explaining himself. That sentence got a little clunky and there are some others that have similar problems.

Aquarius Island is bound to be a place with treasure and tribulations alike, from the offer Katsumi hands Drake from the governor. After Calvin Island's excitement, I am excited to see what we have in store here. This world of Soluna, filled with these pirates, privateers, and explorers is pretty big. It can get a bit overwhelming, especially when there’s so many new characters and factions going in. Hopefully we can get each their own chapter to shine, and get an easier look at.

Overall, a nice chapter, whatever you do with your story it's okay. Be it a new chapter, or just focusing on art it'll be okay.
 

Spiteful Murkrow

Busy Writing Stories I Want to Read
Pronouns
He/Him/His
Partners
  1. nidoran-f
  2. druddigon
  3. swellow
  4. lugia
  5. growlithe
  6. quilava-fobbie
  7. sneasel-kate
  8. heliolisk-fobbie
Heya, sorry for keeping you waiting, but as a fellow author that missed the boat for Diner’s latest P-Wheel I figured that it was about time to deliver on that review exchange that we had going on between us:

Chapter 4

With the smell of fresh bread as a guiding arrow, it didn’t take Maxim long to find the mess hall. The expansive room was full of simple tables and chairs made of tanned wood. Windows lined the wall, a sliver of indigo sky visible through each. Ceiling lamps hung down like fruits from a tree. A singular chandelier dangled above the room’s main draw: a lengthy wooden station stacked with bread, soup, and other food Maxim couldn’t make out.

Cue the theme music:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mc9umKcoOOk


Though I’m surprised that Drake splurged this much on interior decorations for a ship that regularly gets fired on. Those privateer contracts must be quite generous to occasionally replace these swanky fixtures.

A long line extended from the station all the way to his position at the door, right to his position. He sighed as he realized he would have to wait for his meal. Within a few minutes, the line had steadily advanced. The Rowlet tried his best to keep from nodding off in line, looking around for some kind of focus to keep awake.

Hrm. I kinda wonder if it should’ve been indicated somewhere earlier that Maxim was feeling drowsy when coming to the mess hall, since this is admittedly coming a little out of left field right now.

“I see yah tryin’ to cut in line!”

“Cut in line?! Says the lying arse who’s trying to skip ME!”

Right ahead was the perfect distraction; a Crocalor and a Timburr at each other’s throats. The latter’s face was as red as the Crocalor’s own scales as he continued to lob insults.

Ah yes, firmly displaying how one ‘mon’s ‘privateer’ is indistinguishable from another’s ‘pirate’ in terms of manners. >:V

“Has your own heat roasted your brain, you lug? Don’t try and pass me then pretend I’m the one causing the problem! At least own up to it!”

The red gator spat out a small ember. “Bah! I’m no liar! You were the one oversteppin’ your boundaries especially with that oversized plank o’ yours!”

Maxim: “I’m… just going to take a step back from these two before the burny one sets the mess hall on fire.” ^v^;

“Oversized plank?!” The Timberr growled, raising said object at him. “Try saying that when this thing bonks you over the head, you moppet!” The Crocalor shot steam out of his nose, as heat began to flow from his maw. Before the two could come to blows-

KABOOMM!!

A purple projectile struck the floor near the arguing pair, shooting splinters and dust into the air. When the dust cleared, there was a hole burned into the ground by a slimy purple liquid. The crackle of dissolving wood was enough to make the duo jump back.

Ah yes, Sludge Bomb. Or at least I think that’s a Sludge Bomb. Definitely one way of getting your underlings’ attention.

… Even if that makes me wonder what on earth the repair bills for the Serene Grace are like after every mission. :copyka:

“Whoooopppssss~! My bad!”

A deep yet soft voice came from behind the countertop. The source was a pink and violet colored slowbro wearing a blue apron. A stubby arm rubbed the back of his head, while a strange, spikey shell covered his other one. Even from far away, Maxim could make out what looked like eyes at the base of the shell.

Maxim: “Yeah, that was totally on purpose, I can already tell.”
747664615328055367.webp


“No fighting, okay?” The slowbro said, waggling a finger from his normal arm. “It’s hard for others to eat when it's too noisy!”

The pair straightened up and quickly nodded. “S-sure thing, Hyde! We’ll get along!” They both said in unison before getting back in line.

Oh, so the cook has a name. Guess that’s one way to tell that we’re going to see him again in the future. Noted, then.

Thankfully, the line continued to move without issue. When the time finally came for Maxim to get his share, he took a closer look at the food selection. A thick block of cheese had been cut into many pieces, some placed on small metal plates. Stacks of rolls were placed beside a massive pot of stew being stirred by the Slowbro with another mon, a Grafaiai, perched on his shoulder.

>letting Poison-types handle food preparation

Sounds like a recipe for bad things winding up happening, but I’m going to assume that Hyde and his assistant know what they’re doing here.

“C’mon, you gotta stir it faster than that!” The simian spoke in a light, but aggressive masculine tone. “

“Uh, excuse me?”

Huh. Maybe I got it wrong as to who the cook and assistant were of these two.

The pair froze and glanced down at Maxim. The Rowlet weakly waved to them. “I was hoping to see what was being served here?” He said.

I just realized, but what is going on in Maxim’s mind all this time. Since he’s waving weakly here, but I didn’t get a firm sense of what his inner thought process behind the mess hall and its occasional bouts of chaos was, which might have helped contextualize his reaction here a bit more.

Both stared silently before the Grafaiai tapped his partner on the shoulder.

“Well, whatardya waitin’ for? Give the kid some grub!”

The slowbro poured some soup into a wooden bowl, then handed it to Maxim. The Rowlet looked over the soup with curiosity. “Huh, what type of soup is this?”

“Tamato Soup! A beloved special from yours truly, Cardin!” The Grafaiai said before taking a mock bow. “One taste and you’ll be knocked into the stars above!”

It probably would’ve made sense to take a moment to describe the appearance and texture of the soup, especially if it’s something that Maxim found alien and not reflexively tasty-looking.

“Heyyy, I helped too…” His Slowbro coworker sighed.

I don’t know how much crowd control really impacts the quality of your cooking, buddy. >:V

Cardin rubbed the back of his head. “Oh yeah and Hyde too, don’t wanna forget that! Anyway, enjoy your food! I’ve got to mark Hyde’s ‘accidental shooting’ tally again…”

Maxim: “‘Tally’? As in he does this on a regular basis?
747664615328055367.webp

Hyde: “They’ve been getting less frequent?” ^^;

Maxim looked back at the still-boiling hole in the floor and shuddered.

Maxim: “I should probably get in the habit of asking others to get food for me here in the future.” .^.

An unoccupied table in the back was the perfect spot for him to eat. Pokemon around paid him no mind, instead focused on celebration celebrating their recent victory over Ocher’s crew and chatting with friends. All the joyful energy in the air called to a familiar yet far away memory. Friends, had he done things in his previous world? Did he even have friends in his previous life? He pushed away those feelings of loneliness before they took root.

IMO, you should be a bit more specific about that ‘celebration’ there, especially for readers who are coming back to your story after a bit of a break, but that’s just me there.

It’s alright. I can worry about making friends later.” He thought. “ Besides, if I stare any longer my soup’s going to get cold.”

Lol, bold of you to assume the story’s not going to foist them on you nice and hard, Maxim.

He looked down at his meal. The orange colored broth had chunky bits peeking out of the surface, and a rich, earthen aroma radiated from the bowl. He took his first sip, and his world exploded into a mix of bitter, spicy and savory flavor. Again he took sip after sip as a hunger-induced trance took over. By the time he finally looked up from his bowl, it was practically picked clean.


They weren’t kidding! This is amazing!” He thought.

Oh, so there’s our description of what Tamato Soup looks / smells like. I do wonder if some of this should’ve been frontloaded to when Maxim gets his portion of soup for the first time, but it’s very nicely done in terms of helping to imagine what the soup is like.

With that satisfying dinner out of the way, Maxim only had one more thing to do: sleep! Arrows and signs helped to guide him down the hatch to the barracks floor, the day’s final stop.

Huh, so the signage of the Serene Grace is interpretable by Pokémon that don’t necessarily know how to read. I wonder if that has any implications for what literacy in this setting is like.

The gargantuan room stretched on and on, filled to the brim with hammocks strung between interlocking beams. So many of them were locked into a diagonal position it caused the room to resemble a maze of silk. Pokemon of all shapes and sizes were either adjusting their hammocks, talking with neighbors, or fast asleep. Larger mons, like a sleeping Tangrowth, easily occupied three hammocks by themselves. And yet it all happened without a care in the world.

I’m honestly surprised that nobody opted to heap up some straw on the ground to try and ensure that the floor was also used for sleeping accommodations. But I suppose that that’s where everyone keeps their personal effects.

His eyes drifted over to a currently unoccupied hammock next to a wall. The perfect place for him to nap. Maxim silently made his way over, looking from side to side to make sure he wouldn’t run into anyone. Hopping into the silk, Maxim turned on his side away from a group playing some kind of card game. Their frenetic whispers were easy to hear, but thankfully not enough to distract him. Amidst the dimming glow of candlelight, Maxim felt his eyes grow heavy.

Huh, so the hammocks are straight-up made of silk, huh? I wonder if that means that there’s some sort of spidermon on the crew that does the honors here. Also, odds those sailors are playing TCG right about now?

Here’s hoping tomorrow is a smooth start… He thought right as sleep overtook him.

Aaaaaaand Maxim jinxed it. I can already tell.

#########################$#$#$$$#$#$@@@@@@@@@$@$@$@$@^&*^**^*(&^(*

F453ITEGH

FSHEGH

….

Let experiment number ^& commence!

Waaaait, if this meant to be Maxim’s memories, I wonder if it really makes sense to do keysmash characters. Since how on earth are you even supposed to say that out loud? .-.

Like if the idea is that these are supposed to be garbled voices, part of me wonders if it’d have been better to just described incoherent voices in Maxim’s dream or the like.



……

…………

……………….


“Well done! It was a success! Congrats all around everyone!”

I wonder if the ellipses here would’ve worked better with one longer set being used, since this admittedly feels like we have a bit of wasted space for text at the moment.

CLAP CLAP!

“Well, done Maxim, well done!”

congratulations-evangelion.gif


CLAP CLAP!

“It wouldn’t have worked without your quick thinking Sa*$*#! “

“Hehe, if it wasn’t for your suggestion, I wouldn’t have figured out how to adjust the power source! You really are your- $@$^

Oh, so the garbled text is meant to be blanks in Maxim’s memories. I’m not fully sure if I see eye-to-eye with how it was done, but I get what you were going for here now.

MAXIM!

<><><>

BAAAAAAAAAARIIIINNNNNNNNNNNNNGGGGGGGG

BARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRINGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG!!


“RISE AND SHINE, THE WINDS OF TOMORROW ARE BLOWIN’ IN!”

Maxim was jolted out of the hammock by the loud noise. As he scrambled to get off the floor, he looked around. Daylight peeked out of small circular windows while pokemon rose up ready to meet the new day. Turning into a sizable crowd, they began to pour out of the room. He sighed and put on his scarf, trailing behind the rest.

I’m… not sure what point in this sequence is meant to be the break between Maxim’s dreams and reality, but it probably makes sense to firmly mark it with a linebreak. My assumption was that it was before the alarm noises started happening, but that might have been off.

One by one the crew members came up to the deck, forming an unorganized crowd. In front of the crowd was Captain Drake, with Signal on his left and Clyde on his right. The Quaquaval stood straight, arms crossed dramatically in the blowing wind. His eyes remained closed as one feathery finger tapped on his arm. Once a few minutes had passed, his posture relaxed, only for him to let out a mighty yell.

… I’m super slow, but I just realized that name-wise the Serene Grace is basically led by ‘Captain (Male) Duck’. Makes me wonder if there’s other subtle groaners for names in this story.

“GOOOOOOOD MORNING MY LOVELY CREW~!” He bellowed. “Best be well rested, because Calvin Island approaches!” He turned around and pointed to the distant horizon. Sure enough, an island was slowly getting closer. He turned back to the crowd.

‘Calvin Island’, huh? Just filing that one away, though I wonder if that also implies that these islands are named after specific figures from the past or the like.

“Once we get there, it’s time to drop off this bounty, and claim another hefty reward. What do you all think about that?!”

“YEAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!”

Maxim: “Wait, what is going to happen to all those pirates we caught, anyways?” .^.
Drake: “I mean, knowing the norm for pirates, they’re probably all going to be hung by the end of the week. But let’s not think too hard about the little details and think about the things we’re all going to do with that bounty money!” ^v^;

The crowd erupted into cheers, forcing Maxim to put his wings to his head. I can’t blame them after that ferocious fighting, but this is gonna take some getting used to.” A small sigh escaped his beak.

Maxim: “... Also, are all those pirates still right here chained up on the deck at the moment?”
-
Ocher:
757978476950192229.webp

Maxim: “Oh… that’s just… peachy. I really did not need to know that, thanks. (Seriously, don’t you have a brig or something for ‘mons like these, Drake?!)”
747664615328055367.webp


“I hate to dampen the mood, but I have some bad news to share. You see, the crew of Blue Horizon suffered an unexpected delay which means it will take them roughly three whole days at least to make it to the rendezvous point. As such, we will be staying on Calvin Island for the meantime.”

Maxim: “... Don’t you all basically have radios? Why wouldn’t we just arrange a new rendezvous point?”
916590116670144542.webp

Drake: “Because the implication is that we had trouble getting in touch, and also, taking a break is good for crew morale.” ^v^

All the cheering shifted into groans as a somber mood descended. Maxim was only confused at the news.

Drake remained unfazed. “No matter! This is a great opportunity to take a good break after a long month of work! Calvin Island’s a simple location, but a peaceful one. Enjoy yourself at the local stops, just don’t get drunk enough for us to leave you on the island!”

… Aren’t you all basically pirates contracted by a state actor? Just how drunk do you have to be to be left behind by a crew like that? ^^;

Laughter bursted out as Drake puffed out his chest for another yell.

“AND REMEMBER, MOVE FORWARD ONE STEP!”

“AT A TIME!” The crowd returned back.

Ah yes, so the crew has their own equivalent of “Smiles go for miles”, duly noted.

“DISMISSED!”

The crowd slowly began to disperse, leaving Maxim to decide what to do next. Before he could come up with a plan, Drake appeared in front with Clyde in tow.

“Ah yes, Maxim, just the mon I wanted to see!” He grinned, before nodding at Clyde. “Let’s get things started shall we?”

… Right, that Politoed. I think it might have made sense to do an explicit species mention somewhere in this block, since for a second, I was blanking on who Clyde was since it’s been a while since I saw him.

Maxim fidgeted in place. Ahhh yeah, the “orientation”. Hope they won’t put me through hell.

Clyde cleared his throat. “Ah hem! Now then, since you’re now a new crew member, that means we’ve got to lay out some ground rules for ya!”

“Err, ground rules?” Maxim gulped.

Maxim: “... Wasn’t this something that you should’ve gone over with me yesterday?” .^.
Clyde: “I mean, we had a run-in with pirates about ten minutes after you showed up, so that kinda derailed things there.” ^^;

“Aye! Our Crew Codes! Every new crew member is required to know them by heart, and you’re no different!” Clyde grinned. The Politoed took out a small navy-blue booklet and began to read aloud.

inb4 it’s a Xerox of the Salvager’s Code from XB2

“The Crew Codes are to be followed at all times! Breaking them leads to a punishment reflecting the act! To start:

  1. Every crewmate is entitled to their own business and affairs, provided it doesn’t affect another crewmate or the crew itself.”

Maxim nodded, pleased that the crew wouldn’t bombard him with a bunch of questions without his permission.

Maxim: “... Wait, what exactly is the punishment for breaking these again?” ^v^;
Clyde: “We’ll get to that later, just keep reading for now.”

“2. Every crewmate shall work for their daily poke! This includes labor, raids, exploration, etc. Otherwise, no pay! Non-negotiable!”

Your formatting for this second point is inconsistent with the first one at the moment. You probably want to also add [ LIST ][ /LIST ] blocks around this one, too to keep it visually consistent with Rule #1.

Also:

Maxim:
laughter-worried.gif


Does being a flying feather duster count? Surely being good at sweeping is worth a few.. Poke or whatever money is called here.” Maxim mused.

Yeah, I figured.

“3. All crewmates are to be vigilant at all times, even when resting! Anyone caught slacking or goofing off at their post is subject to punishment, so no Horseaing around, got it?!”

>Horseaing

That one was painful. But fitting.

A certain trio came to mind, but Maxim chased the thought away.

Maxim: “... I mean, I suppose that’s a sign that enforcement isn’t super strict, so that’s a good thing, right?” ^v^;

“4. The most important one! A relationship between crewmates is built on trust! Therefore, you must swear that you will remain loyal to your fellow crewmate through thick and thin, and never leave the crew to dry! Anyone caught deceiving or betraying the crew’s trust for their own gain is to be kicked out and marooned from the crew! No ifs, ands, or buts!”

Definitely wouldn’t have expected that one from a privateer crew, though I suppose that the Serene Grace is very firmly on the “idealistic” side of piracy/privateering, so it checks out. Even if that could potentially get :copyka: pretty fast depending on just how broadly ‘deceiving or betraying the crew’s trust’ is defined.

Though that now makes me wonder if Drake ever recruits from the pirate crews he busts up. I doubt he found anyone worthwhile from Ocher’s crew in particular, though this code does seem handy for keeping recruits you don’t fully trust in line…
636782104289476608.webp


Clyde shut the book with a mighty clap then placed it back into the bag around his hip. “Well that about covers it! Now then, since you’ve already signed the paperwork I think we can move onto the next step. Ain’t that right, Captain?” He winked at Drake, who nodded back.

Maxim: “Wait, what? That entire book seriously only had four rules in it?” .^.
Clyde: “Oh no, there’s a whole bunch of others, but these four are the ones that are most important to lay down first.” ^^;

Reaching into his bag again, Clyde took out a small sack, the clinking of coins giving way its contents. The bag landed at Maxim’s feet.

“Money?” Maxim said, cocking his head to the side. “Would this be my first ‘paycheck’ on the job?”

“Yep! 500 poke! Nice little starter bonus! Shame you joined the crew after we knocked down Ocher, else you would have gotten more than that!” Clyde grinned.

Maxim: “... I’m pretty sure that you just scammed me right now when that bat almost murdered me yesterday, just saying.” >v>;

Maxim scooped up the pouch and carefully tucked it away in his scarf. “Well thanks. I guess pay is pay.”

[ ]

“So what do I do now?” Maxim asked.

You’re missing some sort of action or reaction here to act as a bridge between Maxim’s lines. Alternatively, you could conjoin them together and axe the break between.

“Calvin Island is coming up soon. So while your partner gets ready, why not kill a little time on the deck?”

“Sure thing, I guess. Don’t have much else to do.”

Maxim: “... Are you sure that you all don’t have a brig where you stuffed those pirates? Since I’d really rather not hear death threats snarled at me while walking around on the deck.” .^.
Drake: “... If you don’t see anyone from Ocher’s crew around, then we probably have a brig somewhere below deck.”

Maxim wasn’t sure how much time had passed as he watched the island grow closer and closer past drifting clouds. Eventually he could make out several features: Forests and grassy plains stretched over the land, while at its heart was a town complete with a harbor filled with docked ships. Near the left edge of the island was a tall forest packed with strange, dome shaped trees. A simplistic yet diverse island, and a welcome place for the crew to stop by.

So… it’s Gormott, but not on a giant giraffe? /s

The ship slowly eased into harbor, careful to squeeze through the gaps provided by other docked ships, finally coming to rest in an open space between two smaller galleons. A loud clack followed by a jolt on deck occurred as gigantic metal rings clasped the ship’s side. Now that the ship had docked, Drake called out from the main deck.

Huh, I really am getting some Gormott vibes right about now. Though so that’s how docking works in this setting.

“Alright everyone, feel free to disembark!”

With another set of cheers, the crowd of privateers disembarked, only a few staying on deck. Maxim walked over to the ramp, but Drake’s leg stopped him.

“Oh hey! Don’t leave without your partner!” He chuckled before clapping his hands together. “Hey~! Over here!”

Maxim: “Wait, my part-?”

“Alright, Alright! Gimme a sec!” The voice from a very familiar weasel echoed. Running towards them with a bag in hand and scarf missing was Rene, a visible scowl on her face. Her gaze softened when she looked at Maxim.

The weasel placed a paw on her hip. “I’m not that good of a teacher, y’know! You remember how the last time went, yeah?”

Maxim: “Wait, she’s my partner?!”
747664615328055367.webp

Rene: “Yeah? Got a problem with that?”
826550123924029450.webp


Wait, she was going to be his partner? Maxim turned to Drake, who nodded in return.

-snerk-

Yeah, I had a feeling there.

“Indeed! It’s been a while since poor lil’ Rene here had a partner, and I feel a fresh recruit like yourself should at least shadow under one of our best solo members!” He shot a wink at Rene, but the Mienfoo only shook her head. “She’ll whip you into shape in no time flat!”

Maxim:
laughter-worried.gif

Rene: “Okay, first rule. No reusing reaction memes in the same review.” >_>;

Well, I’ll give it a shot, Captain. As long as I’m not launching myself as a living cannonball like her.” He thought.

He’s totally going to get launched as a living cannonball at some point, I can already tell.

“Yea, yea, yea! I know I’m awesome. Let’s just get this going already!” The Mienfoo groaned. She pulled out an aged piece of paper, slowly unraveled it, and presented it to Maxim. The Rowlet found himself face to face with a map of the entire island.

Calvin Map part 1


20230324_204116.jpg

Your links from Discord there are dead thanks to that purge they implemented a while back of external links that are more than about a month old. I gather that these pictures added a lot to the experience, so you should probably consider rehosting them on someplace like filegarden.

“Here’s your own copy, don’t let it go flyin’ away from you. See yah outside the ship.” Clutching her bag tightly, she slid down the ramp.

“Have fun you two! I’ve got business to attend to!” Drake chimed in, pointing down at the dock.

[ ] A group of armored pokemon wearing light blue scarves escorted the pirates off their ship one by one in chains. Then came Ocher, with the dragon held his head down and ears flat as his once proud form was cuffed to a wooden box. One of the armored mons, a spindly Watchog, pulled Drake to the side to talk with him. The two became locked in conversation as Signal watched from a few feet away.

I feel like you’re missing some sort of transition into the bit with all the prisoners, even if it’s something as simple as “Maxim (and Rene) looked over and saw [...]” or something like that.

Maxim: “... Wait, where on earth were they all this time anyways?”
401085511176814613.webp

Rene: “Hell if I know. Though are you really upset that you didn’t have to hear them all full of piss and vinegar on the deck earlier?”
476581281094828033.webp


Upon hopping off the ramp, Maxim was taken out of further observation by a quick tap on his head. Rene stood right behind him, tapping her foot on the ground.

Shit! I better get a move on!”

He gulped and picked up the pace, not wanting to delay his partner further.

Maxim: “Just as well, since hearing death threats from a dozen angry Pokémon isn’t my idea of a good time.” ^v^;

Right before leaving the dock, a wooden sign stood next to the town entrance with letters painted in white.

WELCOME TO CALVIN TOWN - Where The Gentle Breeze Blows!

Wow, this place really does feel like Gormott right now.

“Well come on, we ain’t got all day!”

Maxim held in a sigh as Rene fussed for him to follow around. The Mienfoo was dead set in getting him acquainted with the town, three day stay or not. Each building in town was constructed out of wood and stone, the average building no higher than two stories. Combined with the simple cobblestone streets and thin metal street signs, the area reminded him of an 18th century village in his original world. Pokemon peeked out of the open windows to sightsee and more at the streets below. He let out a small yelp as a bucket of paint crashed into the street below, a painting Smeargle above slowly waving a paw. A steady stream of pokemon flooded into stores and alleys, forcing Maxim to keep close to Rene.

Oh hey, I found a picture of Calvin Town:

Case_of_the_Crane_rahim_2.jpg


“The first major stop is just right around this corner!” She called out.

Maxim flapped his wings to keep up as she ran down a narrow street. His novice skill at flying was a bane that forced him to swerve around signs and hanging lamps. The street emptied into a much larger road with a beige sign with faded letters painted on it: Merchant’s Road .

Sure enough, rows of wooden stalls, tents, and stands dotted both sides of the road. Maxim looked around. A Mismagius selling various glowing orbs, a Typhlosion running a box opening business, and many others took up shop. There was even a Pikachu with the number 1 on their scarf selling… home insurance? From the surge of pokemon that blew through from store to store it was easy to see that this was the lifeblood of the town.

Ah yes, Ichi from DLPP has a location here. Or at least I’m pretty sure that’s supposed to be a cameo of Ichi from DLPP.

I’m honestly impressed that this world has a functioning society. But then again, things are crazy enough for this to be sane to me.” Maxim thought as he looked from side to side.

Well “““functioning”””, since they do have pirates just prowling around the skies at the moment, so that implies that state-level governance isn’t exactly the strongest in this world.

There was one location that really caught his eye, a rather lavish red tarped tent covered in vivid golden floral patterns. Right above the entrance was an arrow shaped sign with the title: Boniface’s Breathtaking Bazaar!

Rene had noticed the store herself, and stopped walking as stared at it. She turned around to Maxim and beckoned him forward. Once he got close enough she looked around before leaning in.

Huh, wonder if that’s a sign that Rene’s been here before in the past.

“There’s more to being a privateer than just plundering and exploration. Ya got to be clever and think on the fly!” She whispered. “So I’m not just gonna teach you how to fight, you’re gonna learn another key skill: barterin’!”

Grinning, Rene crossed her arms and nodded towards the tent.

Maxim: “Wait, you all straight-up plunder-?
698047915079237695.webp

Rene: “Not in friendly ports! Though come on, I’ll show you the ropes here…” ^.^

“What? You want me to talk them down for prices?” Maxim whispered back.

“Yeah! That 500 poke of yours is gonna go fast otherwise!”

Yeah, Maxim’s doomed. I can already tell.

Maxim raised a wing to his temple. “You do have a point. I’m no finance expert here, so I’ll follow your lead on it for now. What’s the plan, teach ?”

That got Rene to flash a wide grin. “We’re going into this fancy tent and givin’ the owner a hell of a price shakedown! C’mon, lets go!”

de7.png


Rene dragged him through the tent’s entrance. On the inside, rows of scarlet covered shelves held many items from strange, oversized seeds, to glowing disks and a bag full of pebbles.

Oh, so there are TMs in this setting. Or at least I’m pretty sure that that’s the implication there with the “glowing disks”.

“Hellllllllllooooo~~! You come to buy Boniface’s goods, yes?” replied a slightly shrill male’s voice.

Maxim glanced up to see a giant walking, talking mushroom walking towards them. Gold jewelry lined the top of the mushroom’s cap while a lime green scarf wrapped around their neck. His biggest draw was the shining gold badge attached to the top of his scarf, shaped vaguely like a diamond. The Shiinotic waved at the pair before speaking again.

Maxim:
chikorita-cute-dream-world-nightmares-the-internets-6158081792

Rene: “Keep your wits about you, Rook. He’ll walk all over you while bartering if you can’t keep your nerves.”

“What brings you here, friends? Do you seek goods, services or perhaps guidance?” He raised the orb in his arms forward, slowly rubbing the top with thin fingers.

Oh, so Boniface dabbles in information brokering. I suppose that would explain why he’s apparently a known contact to a privateer crew, since knowing what’s on the up and up among shady characters would definitely be a positive for that line of work.

Even with his friendly attitude, Maxim felt creeped out by the pokemon’s unmoving grin and vacant stare. It was as if he was staring through them. If Rene was also unnerved she didn’t show it, instead crossing her arms with a smirk.

I was joking about that Chikorita reaction image.
662499150147092533.webp


“Goods? You know it! I can tell from a small gander that this place is legit! And that scarf and badge o’ yours is nice too!” She cheered.

The Shiinotic clapped his hands together. “Ahhh thank you! Boniface works hard to establish this branch of his growing merchant empire! Many have come from different islands to have a taste of the exotic goods here! Now then, what are you interested in?”

So Boniface is a third person person, and apparently the equivalent of the stock PMD Kecleon in this setting. Duly noted.

Rene picked up a shining orb, then presented it to Boniface. “A Rebound Orb! And its nicely polished too! How much for this one?”

“400 poke! In good condition too!” He beamed. The smile on his face deepened when Rene placed a paw on her temple.

I went and looked this up on Bulbapedia and… yeah, that price is a scam. The level of egregiousness boils down to if we’re using Super or DX’s pricing.

“400? That seems a bit much, don’t you think? It seems in mint condition, but wouldn’t it be easier to sell at a lower price?”





Boniface nodded and spoke.“Ohohoho! You have a wonderful eye! Valuable indeed. But Boniface’s prices are right as rain. That item is worth every penny!”

Maxim: “... No, I’m pretty sure that I read a guide somewhere that said that the fair price for these was 150-”
916590116670144542.webp

Rene: “(Maxim! Don’t open with what you know the price ought to be! It doesn’t give you any room to negotiate!)” >_>;

Rene [ ] “I suppose. But this kinda orb ain’t super rare either! Not saying they can grow on trees, but orbs show up often enough!”

I think that you’re missing a couple words after “Rene” there that got cut by accident during editing or something.

[ ]

“Then if you can find another orb like this in a nearby dungeon, that would prove me wrong. Surely that is easy task for privateer, oui?”

Rene was left at a loss for words. “How did you-?”

I didn’t realize that Boniface was meant to have a French accent to his speech. I wonder if it’d have made sense to hint at that earlier on when he was being introduced. Also, I kinda feel like it makes sense to show Boniface reacting to Rene’s initial charge a bit before he turns the tables there, since it’s a bit hard to get a feel for his intended mood at the moment.

“Many faces come through here. Easy to read, easy to know and learn. You’re no different!” The Shiinotic taunted. Rene gritted her teeth as she raised a paw, but that just made him wag a finger.

“Ah ah ah! No more fooling moi! Either pay proper price or Boniface charge you extra premium!”

Maxim: “So… 150 Poké-?”
720106605982646283.webp

Boniface: “It’s 500 now. Now pay up or get out.”
826550123924029450.webp


Biting her lip, the Mienfoo hesitated for a few seconds, before reaching into her pack and presenting her poke. Boniface nodded before accepting.

Merci! Pleasure doing business with you!”

Well, that tutorial at bartering went well™. >:V

He turned over to Maxim. “Hello, friend! Do you need goods too?”

“I-I’m good! Thank you!” Maxim stammered before skittering away behind Rene.

I kinda feel like we’re missing some thought process or reaction from Maxim here. Like he just watched Rene saunter up to try and teach him to haggle and then got rolled right in front of him. Does he have any thoughts about the episode? About Boniface? I dunno, it just feels like we’re missing a step here before his flustered/nervous reaction.

The two said nothing between themselves as they walked back through Merchant’s Block. Rene kept walking forward without turning her head back once. As crowds of pokemon began to flood in, the pair continued to silently travel.

After a few minutes of walking, Maxim worked up the nerve to speak to her again.

“Hey Rene, are you okay?”

Rene:
337f8a7c5a87794fe479bf89407b39fa6eb32f0b.gif

Maxim: “Er… yeah, sorry for asking.”
747664615328055367.webp


The Mienfoo stopped, sighed and then tilted her head back. “I’m fine. That guy was just too damn tough to crack!”

[ ]

“Are most merchants hard to deal with like him?” He asked.

[ ]

“N-no! I promise I can find another one to demonstrate on! That one’s just a fluke, is all!” She said, crossing her arms. Before they could scout out another merchant, the pair received an unexpected interruption.

A couple more spots where taking time to describe reactions or thought processes would go a long way to filling in some blanks. Like I gather that this would probably be a funny moment were this a comic, but it’s a bit hard to visualize stuff like the pair’s reactions without provided descriptions.

Rmmmmb

[ ]

“What the? You good, shorty?” Rene said, raising an eyebrow.

Maxim looked down, too embarrassed to look her in the eyes for his next words.

Okay, so I gathered that that was Maxim’s stomach rumbling, but I do wonder if there should’ve been a bit more description to tip the readers off about it. It might be a stylistic difference thing, but it was something that stood out to me.

“I.. may have forgotten to eat anything this morning. Slipped my mind.”

Several seconds passed before Rene howled with laughter, nearly falling over in the process.

“Hahahaha! You forgot? There’s no way!”

Wait, did they even have a chance to eat anything? Since Maxim more or less went straight to the deck for the crew’s assembly after waking up… unless he slept in a bit before the alarm.

Maxim rubbed the back of his head. “I got carried away between everything that happened so far today, sorry.”

This is going to happen a lot to him in this story, isn’t it? o<o

“Bah, don’t apologize. Least you can do is go fill your belly on some grub.” Rene said. She pulled out her town map, took a glance, then pointed in the direction of a nearby street. “Map here says there should be a stack of restaurants down there. Go and eat somethin’ there.”

She began to walk off in another direction, catching Maxim by surprise. “Wait, you’re not coming with me?” He said.

Rene shook her head. “Nope! You’ve got to be independent! You don’t need me holding your hand for this!” She clapped her paws together. “Plus, I ain’t hungry anyway! I’ll meet you down there later!”

Rene, don’t make me break out the Bubsy reaction image again. Like you are aware that Maxim is an amnesiac with zero idea of how your world works, right? Right? :copyka:

With that, the Mienfoo was gone, leaving Maxim by himself. His stomach rumbled again, giving him the motivation to get going.

“I better make this quick.” He whispered as he flapped away.

Maxim: “... I mean, at least I’m able to fly consistently now? So… progress?” ^v^;

The good thing was that the road was nearly a straight shot. Maxim weaved in and out of traffic by flying, cutting down the travel time as the road crossed into a circular plaza. The wonderful scent of baked and steamed goods taunted his nostrils, only making his growling stomach more weary.

The Rowlet came to rest on a bench and took in his surroundings: all around, vibrant buildings held restaurants galore. Some, like a sharpedo shaped shack, had a visible kitchen, while a Pidove shaped diner had tinted windows shielding obscuring the inside. Maxim’s attention hopped from place to place, until he set his sights on a peculiar one. On the plaza outskirts was an oblong shaped building painted a vibrant blue. On the top of the building was a sign shaped like a Wobbuffet holding a bowl captioned Hideki’s Noodle Shop .

Noodles?” He thought. “ Sounds simple enough for me. Here goes.”

Your first paragraph had a number of very short and choppy sentences in it that were arguably incomplete fragments. I provided some suggestions of how to rearrange and reflow things a bit.

Also, ‘Hideki’s Noodle Shop’, huh? Does it also have a bopping soundtrack inside?

Past a silk curtain, purple colored walls led to a line of seats and tables spaced out on a polished wooden floor. Floral themed lanterns hung from an open ceiling. The menu was displayed behind a counter run by a sulking Sandshrew.

“Ugh, what are yah orderin? Don’t spend too long staring up there, okay?” The Sandshrew said with a weary tone.

Oh yeah, I can already tell that the customer service here is nothing short of world-class. /s

Let’s see… Oran Berry Noodles, Colba Berry Slaw, Tamato Berry Bisque, Rawst Berry Ramen? The more items I look at, the more confused I get!” Maxim thought. “ Alien world equals Alien food, that’s something to remember!”

I can’t tell whether or not it’s funnier to imagine Maxim as being tripped up by the names of the different berries or the different types of noodles offered on the menu. I kinda gather the intent is both, since if not, you’d think that ‘Tamato Berry Bisque’ would’ve at least been recognizable to him. :V

“What’s the matter? Confused, little buddy?”

A voice called out from right behind him, that of a gentle masculine tone. Maxim turned around to come face to face with a large bipedal chicken he recognized as a Combusken. A silky white scarf with a golden badge that glimmered in the sunlight was attached around his neck. The pokemon sported a wide grin with his arms crossed behind his head.

There’s like a dozen ‘cock’ jokes that I could make right about now about the self-roasting chicken, but I shall defer beyond noting that that’s some nice character design here. Though I assume that in the grand tradition of PMD shop architecture, that this guy isn’t Hideki here.

“Honestly if you ask me, you should go with the Oran Noodle Special! It’s calm, refreshing, and tangy! Just the way I like it!” The Combusken beamed. Maxim swore if the bird’s grin widened any more it’d be brighter than the sun.

Maxim: “How on earth are you even doing that anyways? I thought that you needed teeth to have a gleaming smile.” .^.

“But not too spicy?” Maxim asked.

“Nope!”

Your dialogue here is a bit ambiguous, even if I assume that Maxim is meant to have the first line.

“Well, I’m hungry, and I’m not one to be picky, at least I hope. Hello, one order of the Oran Noodles please!” Maxim said.

The Combuskin chimed in. “Make that two orders please!”

Maxim: “Um… okay? Though, uh… who are you again?” ^v^;

Both pokemon paid for their meals, then went to look for a table. One touching the wall caught Maxim’s eye, but he wasn’t the only one interested. He hopped into a seat only to find the same Combusken facing him.

“Hey there! Hope you don't mind me sitting here too!”

Maxim: “... Is it normal here to just hang out with strangers that you haven’t introduced yourself to, or…?” .^.
Combusken: “I’ll just go ahead and take that as a ‘yes’ there.” ^v^

Maxim was questioning why this mon wanted to take with him so badly, but it wasn’t like he wouldn’t mind some company.

That’s fine, but just who are you?”

With a brush of his head feathers, the Combusken puffed out his chest. “Oh me? My name is Hurik, Gold-Rank Explorer!” He pointed to his badge. “Yeah I know, cool right? You can save the praises for later!”

Oh, so there’s the chicken’s name.

Maxim:
giphy.gif


[ ]

“I see, that’s interesting. But what’s an adventurer?”

That question left the Combusken at a loss for words, as his eyes widened and his beak hung open.

I see that Maxim’s off to a great start for a first impression there. Though I kinda wonder if we should’ve seen a bit more of his inner thought process about “... who is this dork again and why am I supposed to care?” or whatever before he answers Hurik.

“Wha-wha-WHAT?! What kind of question is that to ask? Have you never seen an adventurer before?”

Maxim rubbed the back of his head. “Err nope.”

[ ]

“You’re joking, right?”

“No.”

[ ]


“Are you sure?”

“Yes.”

This sequence strikes me as potentially having been a lot funnier if you took the time to stop and describe some of the reactions / thought processes of the characters, especially if Maxim is getting increasingly befuddled at why Hurik’s making such a big deal of things.

Absolutely sure?”

“Uh huh.”

I see Hurik isn’t one to give up easily. Getting some Zeke vibes from him right about now.

Hurik reclined back, rubbing his claws over his face. A few seconds and some low whispers later, and a grin flashed across his beak.

Well okay, I’m not sure where in the skies you’re from, but I guess a little history lesson wouldn’t hurt, would it?”

First privateers, now adventurers? I’ve got to keep tabs on these second-nature jobs.” Maxim thought.

Maxim: “Uh… sure? This isn’t going to turn into a giant exposition dump, is it-?”

He nodded to confirm. The Combusken sat up straight, then adjusted his badge. A fiery gleam shined in his eyes. “Alright, listen up Rowlet, because Hurik here is gonna give you a crash course on being an adventurer!”

>dat scene cut

I’ll admit, that’s a pretty convenient way of dancing around an exposition dump there.

Just outside of town, a party of armed guards had escorted Drake and Signal to an isolated location. The plain white walled house with a blue roof was a shockingly simple place for an important meeting. Suspicion began to creep up on Drake as he realized the place was devoid of security. It even lacked a fence!

“Not exactly up to snuff for such a formal meeting.” Drake said to the armored Watchog leading in front. No response came back.

… I just realized, but it wasn’t described all this time as to what the armor of these guards are wearing looked like all this time. Like are they plate mail? Chainmail? Are they painted a specific color? Perhaps those two broken images provided a bit more detail that’s presently missing, but from the text itself, it’s a bit hard to visualize what’s going on here.

One of the guards, an Aipom, scurried up to the door and knocked five times. A few seconds later, a soft female voice answered.

“Hello! Please come in!”

The guards parted, allowing Drake and Signal to pass. Drake inwardly groaned at the gesture. He had a bad feeling about who was waiting for him beyond that door. Signal only stared back at him with a sheen in his eyes.

I take it that whoever’s on the other end is a bit less sweet than that tone of voice indicates if Drake’s reacting like that, but I suppose we’ll just have to wait and see.

With a gentle turn of the knob, Drake opened the door to the sound of a crackling fire and the smell of warm tea. The inside was just as simple: plain walls, with a pair of tables and chairs placed neatly in the center. The lit fireplace coated everything in a yellow glow, including the mon sitting at a table. Drake’s grin completely evaporated as he laid eyes on his “host”.

A female Indeedee, wearing a golden scarf with a platinum badge attached, sat cross legged with a tea cup in hand. Her almond eyes casted a warm glow as she waved at Drake.

“Matilda?” He murmured. “He sent you?”

Oh, so these two have history with each other. And not a wholly positive one judging from Drake’s reaction right about now.

A small nod answered him. The Captain almost wanted to swear. Titling his head back, he spoke to his first mate.

“Signal, leave us. Wait for me by the door.”

The Braviary nodded, leaving the house. Once the door shut, Drake took a seat at the table. Matilda poured a cup of tea and then slid it towards him, a light smile on her face. Drake’s frown refused to vanish however, as he glared at her shimmering badge.

“So why did the Governor send you? Hasn’t he been keeping good enough tabs on us?”

Oh, so Matilda is basically their handler. Or at least I think that that’s where this is going right about now.

The Indeedee said nothing, only taking a small sip of tea after mixing in a cube of sugar. Seconds seemed to stretch for an eternity as he waited for her answer.

“Your tea is getting cold. I suggest taking a sip to ease your worries.” She said, placing her empty cup down.

Drake: “(... I shouldn’t have dismissed Signal, since now I’m starting to get worried about if I should have this tea taste-tested first.)” >v<

Drake sighed and took the cup in hand, allowing himself a small sip. The sweet and silky drink went down easy, but did little to help his mood. “Now will you answer me?”

With a small nod, the Indeedee straightened up. “I suppose it was my turn to check on you. Stellar work as always, Captain Drake!”

Whelp, I suppose that confirms that Matilda is indeed Drake’s handler. Or at least one of them.

“Could you get to the point already?” He said, crossing his arms.

“My my, so blunt! I was just passing by when the Governor gave me the order to meet with you!” She giggled. “I promise there’s nought an ounce of ill will by me coming here!”

796822964019527760.webp


Okay, now that you’ve gone and said that, now my sus-o-meter is blipping hard.

Matilda reclined back into her chair, crossing her hands in front of her face. “Besides, I wanted to hear all of what you’ve been up to since last we met. The last three missions specifically. And of course, the human you found.”

Ah yes, there’s our ulterior motive there. Especially since it was already implied a couple chapters ago that humans were SRS BSNS in this story’s setting.

His grip on the teacup tightened as he tried to maintain a steady pose. Keeping his thoughts clear was key around a psychic type.

“Hmm, he told you a little bit about our conversation yesterday, didn’t he?” Drake sighed. “Surely nobody else knows.”

The Indeedee’s smile grew larger. “To my knowledge, he has not. I won’t ask you about that subject yet. After all, we still have some catching up to do beforehand!”

You have a small typo there.

Ignoring the sensation of an oncoming headache, Drake nodded.

Um, Drake? Given that: A: you’re in the room with a Psychic-type, B: you’re accepting tea that you didn’t see prepared in front of you, you probably don’t want to just be brushing off sudden headaches like that. [fearfullaugh]

“Yes, yes we do. How about I start with Gearly Island?”

Well, that felt a bit sudden for an ending. I do wonder if a better ending note would’ve been some sort of internal
590253472188727333.webp
reaction from Drake as he dreads a bit as to how this is going to go or something like that.

This was a bit of a slower chapter than the past few ones, though I suppose that that’s just as well since the chapters up to this point have had a lot happen in a very small amount of time. I thought that the main highlights of the chapter were simply showing off the characters and Calvin Island a bit more, and there’s definitely some memorable interactions among them. I wonder if Calvin Island will be serving as a hub of sorts for the Serene Grace, since it would be a shame if Boniface and especially Hurik were one-arc wonders, since the two had fun initial impressions.

On the more critical side, beyond the presentation quibbles like the borked spacing and the dead Discord-hosted images, I noticed that you had a couple typos and abruptly terminating sentences here and there. I also noticed that for whatever weird reason, there were a few points in the story where you were very sparing about description, especially as rendered through Maxim’s thought process, at times when delving into them would’ve helped a lot for getting a firmer read on things that were going on and Maxim as a character that as a result made those sections feel a bit rushed or hard to conceptualize. After all, you rolled a third-person limited perspective for this story, and at a time when both we as readers and Maxim as a viewpoint character are experiencing something brand-new, taking the time to slow down and smell the proverbial roses can go a long ways to making things more vivid or memorable.

But altogether, I thought that this was a pretty good chapter, and I’m definitely looking forward to seeing more of Calvin Island and this web of intrigue that Drake is apparently wrapped up in. Best of luck @Z102eternal , and I’ll be looking forward to coming back to this story sometime soon. ^^
 

windskull

Bidoof Fan
Staff
Partners
  1. sneasel-nip
  2. bidoof
  3. absol
  4. kirlia
  5. windskull-bidoof
  6. little-guy-windskull
  7. purugly
  8. mawile
  9. manectric
Hey there! I was looking for fics to review for TR’s annual review blitz and thought I’d give this a shot. I’ve been meaning to check it out so this seems as good a time as any.

Before I get into the review proper, I noticed that there’s a significant ammoutn of space between paragraphs, what looks to be like about 4 lines of space. I don’t think it’s intentional and I don’t know if it’s something you want to bother fixing, but I did want to mention it as it is a bit distracting/means I can’t see much on my phone before I have to scroll. It’s less distracting on desktop.

Okay, time for the proper review.

Chapter 1
You waste no time with introducing characters and an inciting incident. By the end of the first chapter, we’ve already been introduced to three of the four characters from the cover. Maxim falls out of the sky and wakes up on an airship, which is raided by pirates before he even has a chance to get his bearings. I would say the first chapter makes good use of its space.

Each of the main trio feels distinct. Rene is skeptical and a tad hot-headed, Cecil is a voice of reason, and Maxim just feels lost and done.

I’ll wait until I read the next chapter before giving thoughts on the pirates and plot.

I do have a couple of line edits to point out:
Rene took a step back and looked between Cecile,
Misspelling of Cecil here.

I got to admit girlie, the average mon would have ran with their tail between their legs at the site of Blade Tail Ocher starin’ em down.”
Correct word should be “sight,” not “site.”

Chapter 2
Chapter two focuses on the fight between the pirates and the crew, with the big reveal at the end being that the merchants are not merchants at all, but instead pirates privateers! There’s enough in the text to hint that something is up; In chapter 1 when they notice the oncoming ship, Rene says something about how they weren’t expected yet. Yet, being the key word here. Then it comes up again in this chapter as well.

And then there’s the fact that Ocher recognizes Drake and didn’t expect him to be there. There might be a few more hints that things aren’t quite as they seem here, but those are the ones that I noticed.

I think you have a pretty good grasp of writing fight scenes. Everything feels snappy and fast paced, a trait you want in most fight scenes. It feels chaotic, and while the main focus is easy to follow, everything surrounding it generally is too hectic to get a good grasp. I think that’s intentional and it works well since it keeps the fight from being too bogged down on the small skirmishes.

The short scene at the end is intriguing, but at this time I don’t really have anything to say about it as there’s not really enough details to speculate.

Chapter 3
Just as a quick FYI, it looks like the image for Drake’s desk is broken.

The doctor's name is Gerald. I’m sorry I have brainworms. My brain immediately goes to Sonic. Dosen’t help that I just saw the third movie.

Than diatribe aside, let’s talk about the content of the chapter itself. This seems like it’s probably the last of the setup chapters. Maxim spends most of this chapter hanging out with the crew and getting to know them, then ends it by speaking to Drake and becoming a member of the crew himself.

Then we get that scene at the end where we linger with Drake’s point of view and he calls to speak with someone. Unsurprisingly, he has his own agenda at play here. Whether or not he knows more than he’s letting on, however, is yet to be seen.

I did have one typo I wanted to point out for this chapter.
His movement slowly became more focused as he relaxed his body just a little t.
Typo on the last word here.

It looks like this is a pretty good spot to wrap up my first review. Within the first three chapters, you’ve managed to introduce the main cast, create an inciting incident, and get a bit of worldbuilding in as Maxim sets off down his path as a privateer. Your word economy is really good; with only about 12k words, you’ve accomplished plenty. The pacing seems to have hit just the right spot.

The only thing I might critique is that there were a couple of typos here and there, maybe a couple of sentences that could have been worded better, but in general the prose is nice and flows well. I’d definitely like to come back and read more of this later. But we’ll end things here for now. So until next time, take care.
 

Spiteful Murkrow

Busy Writing Stories I Want to Read
Pronouns
He/Him/His
Partners
  1. nidoran-f
  2. druddigon
  3. swellow
  4. lugia
  5. growlithe
  6. quilava-fobbie
  7. sneasel-kate
  8. heliolisk-fobbie
Heya, I'd had my eye on trying to make some forward progress on this fic during Review Blitz, and this week felt like as good a time as any to get a foothold in in case I had time to come back later on:

Chapter 5

Just getting the obligatory reminder to fix your newlines on your version here on TR.

“My, My! Quite the little adventure!”

Matilda placed her tea cup down and clapped. Her thin smile only made Drake grip his own cup tighter. Not once during him recounting the crew’s journey did she say a word, instead only responding with small nods or a wave. Every now and then, she would scribble on her little notebook.

Neat art there. I assume that Matilda’s meant to be an Indeedee?

“You put even a veteran navy officer to shame with your efficiency. We’re lucky to have such a talented captain in our service!” She giggled. “Now then, about that human?”

Drake sighed and placed his cup down. “Well, there isn’t too much to say about him. We’ve only recently met, mind you.”

“That’s alright. I just want to know about some of his qualities!” Matilda said.

I take it that humans must turn up in this world often enough for there to be a standardized “what’s the human like?” checklist to go through. Just making a mental note of that there.

Reclining back into his seat, Drake raised a hand to his chin.

“Well now, if I had to describe him…”



“...And that’s the basic history of Adventurers! Exciting, right?”

Oh, you tease. Guess whatever the deal is with humans and why they’re important in this setting is a story for another day.

As if on cue, Maxim snapped out of his trance and glanced up at the Combusken. Despite the long explanation, he managed to take in the main points. Adventurers were a task force spread out across the skies. Under the service of a guild, they would go around handling all sorts of tasks including rescue missions, bounty hunting, item retrieval and more. Each job would vary from island to island, meaning that an adventurer had to stay on their toes.

Despite the risks and hard work involved, Maxim had to admit it did sound rather exciting for a fantasy world job. However, Maxim couldn’t shake the feeling on how close the job seemed to overlap with the basic descriptions of privateers.

Oh, so they’re basically Mercenaries from XB2. Since… uh… yeah, they basically did a lot of the same things that we as the party did, just offscreen and with a bunch of timers involved.

Part of me does feel like this paragraph is long enough that it’s probably worth dividing it up into two smaller ones here.

I wonder if there’s some kind of innate link between them. Well, it wouldn’t hurt to ask, He thought.

Maxim shrugged. “It’s cool, I guess.”

So… were you actually going to ask that question there Maxim, or…? ^^;

Hurik raised a brow. “You guess? I’m surprised you’re not over the moon after that. Oh what, does your country or whatever have an even cooler job?”

How many countries are there in this setting anyways?

“Uhh no, I just thought it sounded similar to how Privateers operate.” Maxim said. “Well uhh, without the guild and all.”

Hurik’s eyes darkened while his head feathers glowed, a small wave of heat emanating from his form. He quickly relaxed and rubbed his head.

Well, Hurik obviously didn’t like hearing that. Wonder if there’s a rivalry between the two.

“Privateers, huh? Funny how you're familiar with them and not Adventurers. But anyway, yes the two do share similarities, but with several key differences,” Hurik explained. “For one, guilds don’t function like a crew. Most adventurers are on their own or with a partner or two backing them up. Also, adventurers aren’t given nearly as free reign as privateers are to handle their business, not to mention the entree fees.

[ ]

And one more thing, adventurers don’t handle some of the more… darker jobs their counterparts do.”

I mean… that does sound on-brand considering how Drake and the gang are basically just a gang of pirates with state backing. I wouldn’t be particularly shocked if there were others out there whose M.O. was quite a bit closer to Ocher’s.

Maxim: “(... Oh my god, what did I get myself into?)”
1212913559567343706.webp


Hurik winked at the last point, causing a shiver to roll up Maxim’s spine. “D-darker jobs?”

Hurik nodded. “Well privateers can be considered to be pirates on a leash. And anyone can tell you how the average pirate operates.” A grin creeped on his beak. “Just think about it, having the ability to use troublemakers on your beck and call when needed. Sowing a little chaos here, exploring dangerous islands over there, who else is more useful than those who throw caution to the wind?”

And disposable, too, if you’re not too picky about how you source them. So what are the odds that a bunch of Ocher’s crew skips the gallows in favor of being used as cannon fodder for jobs the local government doesn’t want their fingerprints on anyways? (Or Ocher himself, for that matter.)

Hurik’s grin instantly vanished as his eyes dimmed.

“But keeping pirates on a leash? That’s kinda careless if you ask me. What’s keeping them from cutting ties and going off on their own once they get bored of dancing to someone else’s tune? Well, several things, but that’s besides the point.”

Nothing unless if you’re prepared to shoot them out of the sky. Just like how mercenary revolts were just an operational risk for the polities that dealt with them throughout history IRL.
476581281094828033.webp


Hurik sighed and reclined back. Maxim swore he could see a tinge of sadness appear on his face. “Not much chance of being a free spirit with that arrangement. I don’t agree on how some pirates can be willing to do that. Trading freedom for so-called benefits. Hmph.”

Oh, he’s an ex-pirate, isn’t he? Since I can see that expression there.

Though yeah, I frankly will be more surprised if a decent chunk of privateers in this setting aren’t recruited through “do jobs for us, or you’re getting a free skydive”. ^^;

A few seconds of awkward silence passed. Just before any of them could break the mold, a massive shadow engulfed them. Standing by their table was a Nidoqueen wearing a white apron stained with grease and other liquids. A tray holding two striped bowls was in her hand.

“You boys order the Oran special, ya?” She asked with a noticeable accent. Both nodded in response. She placed down the bowls before waving and leaving.

Maxim: “Um… I’m sorry, but what exactly did I order again?” ^v^;

Maxim looked down at his bowl. Floating around in the thick broth was an entanglement of blue noodles with meat and strange vegetables finely cut on top. Triangle slices of a blue fruit floated in the center, completing the dish. A sweet, orange-like scent came from the steam, adding to Maxim’s hunger.

Maxim:
simpsons-dreamy.gif

“Though wait, what is this meat in there anyways?”

A fit of laughter erupted from Hurik as he crossed his arms across his stomach. “You’re just drooling at that dish! Can’t blame you though! It's good stuff!” Hurik chuckled, before grabbing two wooden sticks. “Sorry for going off a tangent, I get kinda heated sometimes, but it’s all good now!”

Aha, chopsticks. Didn’t peg the local island as having an East Asian-vibing culture, but duly noted.

Hurik pointed the chopsticks at Maxim. “Now then, feel free to dig in while it’s hot!”

While he dug into his meal, Maxim adjusted his posture to take into account his size and the bowl’s placement. [ ] An awkward minute of shifting around later, Maxim took his first bite.

He was blown away by the sweet and tangy taste of the soft noodles. The broth’s slight bitterness balanced out the taste while the chopped meat and vegetables stood out with their spices. Combined with tender fruit, the meal was perfect: neither too mild nor spicy and blended wonderfully into a hearty dish.

Wait, Maxim was able to use chopsticks with those wings of his? Or did he just lower his beak down and eat straight out of the bowl? It might make sense to be a bit more explicit about that, especially if you’re playing up the bodily dysphoria angle. ^^;

“I could cry, it’s so good!” He thought. This was only his second meal in this world, he never would have imagined such a strong first impression!

Can’t tell whether everyone’s just a good cook in this setting, Maxim’s starved, or he has just had the good fortune to not get stuck with hardtack and Nomel Berries yet.

Just as Maxim finished slurping up the last of his meal, a shadow approached. Both him and Hurik turned to find themselves face to face with a new visitor. Black fur covered their body from head to toe, only broken up by circular neon-blue lines. A silken white scarf with a golden badge identical to Hurik’s was around their neck. Their yellow eyes are narrowed into thin slits that glared daggers towards Hurik.

Your image link is dead there, but I assume that this is supposed to be a Shiny Umbreon.

“There you are! Do you have any idea how long I’ve searched for you, only to see you lazing on your ass and stuffing your face?!” The Umbreon snarled, her voice deep and raspy. She brushed at her ears waiting for Hurik to respond.

Aaaaaand confirmed.

The Combusken stared back, only speaking after setting down his bowl. “Traveling around the entire island works up quite an appetite! What better way to satisfy it than with a nice bowl?” He shot a wink towards Maxim.

Maxim: “Oi, leave me out of this!” >v>;

After looking over Maxim, the Umbreon let out a snort. “Who are you supposed to be, Hurik’s little lunch buddy? Did he bore you to sleep with his stories yet?”

“No ma’am, he didn’t. I enjoyed the discussion!” Maxim said. “I’m curious. Are you and him part of the same adventurer’s guild? You have the same badge and everything.”

[ ]

“Hmph, he’s more than that, he’s my partner! One that decided to go and goof off in town instead of helping me with our tasks.” She scoffed, brushing her ears again.

Probably makes sense to dwell on Celene(?)’s reaction there a bit more. e.x. if she lightens up a bit, if she remains firmly standoffish, etc.

[ ]

“If you don’t mind me asking, what is your name, miss Umbreon?” Maxim asked.

I think that we’re missing some thought process here from Maxim’s side to get him interested in poking and prodding at what’s going on here.

Her body relaxed as she tilted her head away, anger replaced by an unenthused stare. “Celene. Part of Team Pale Moon along with him.” She flicked an ear at Hurik’s direction, causing making him to wave.

If I had a nickel for every time I saw a sardonic and catty Umbreon character paired with a chipper, happy-go-lucky partner in a PMD fic, I’d have two nickels.

Maxim raised a wing to his beak. “Partners? Were you two sent here on a mission, by chance?”

“Yep, for survey work.” Celene snorted, before shooting an icy glare at Hurik. “At least we were, until my partner decided to cut his work short. I’m not letting you off easy!”

“Okay okay! I finished my meal anyway, so I’m happy to get back to work!” Hurik grinned, sheepishly rubbing his crest. He placed his bowl on the table before he got up and walked off with Celene. Before he got too far away, he cocked his head back.

“Hey Maxim, it was nice talking to you. Hope we can meet again before we leave!”

Maxim: “Um… sure? (Boy I have no idea how he’s going to react to finding out that I’m an active privateer…)” ^v^;

“Yeah, it was nice! I hope the same!” Maxim called back.

With a thumbs up, the Combusken ran off to catch up with his partner. Left alone, Maxim sat and tried to collect his thoughts, only for the arrival of a third, familiar visitor to interrupt him.

“So I find you chowing down at a noodle place, eh? Not a bad choice.” Rene spoke with her arms crossed.

Rene: “Though who on earth was that cad earlier? And why didn’t you let me know what was up?”
916590528802480208.webp


“Ah, Rene! G-good to see you again!” Maxim stammered. “What have you been up t-to?”

[ ]


“Well, I went around asking the locals about the different sights and places around here. I learned about a few cool places. Then, I found you before you could get lost, which didn’t take me long. After all, a Rowlet’s pretty rare in this part of the skies.”

Probably make sense to emphasize Rene’s reaction a bit there.

She placed a paw on her hip and sighed. “Whew! You should have seen that Umbreon that left here just now. I bumped into her by accident and she gave me a crazy killer stare! Talk about having a stick up your arse!”

Celene put two and two together about Rene being from a Privateer crew, huh?

Maxim gave a nervous chuckle as he thought about Celene’s aggressiveness. While Hurik was nice, he wouldn’t mind missing out on his partner.

TBD how much of that will go out the window once Hurik figures out what Maxim’s day job is, but let’s think positive here.

“What’s with the other bowl? You meet some new buddy or something?” She teased.

[ ]

“Uhhh, it’s nothing to worry about. Now, about those sights, Rene.” Maxim deflected.

[ ]


“Hmph. Follow me!”

With that, the two slipped out of the restaurant and onto the open road.

A couple more spots that IMO would’ve benefitted from showing off some more character reactions here.

Maxim trailed her Rene all the way to the town’s outskirts. Cobblestone gave way to unkempt dirt as they entered a forest trail. Thin trees and shrubs dotted both sides and it was quiet save for the chirping around them.

“Hey Rene, where are we going?” Maxim asked as he flew level with her.

The Mienfoo smirked. “You’re about to see in a moment. Be patient, will you?”

Maxim: “Uh… could I at least get a hint? Since I get the distinct feeling that I don’t know what on earth I’m doing here and I know that I’ve almost died on multiple occasions so far.”
1212913559567343706.webp


Sure enough, over a small hill, a strange landmass came into view. Carved into the side of a small cliff was a cave resembling a monster’s open maw.. Its eyes were overgrown with vines dangling from them while the teeth were stalagmites and stalactites. A wooden sign with faded black words hung haphazardly from a rope.

GLIGAR CAVE - en of B n its

Oh, it’s like Sharpedo Cave. Just a lot more bug-y.

Maxim was puzzled. This place was marked on his map but it didn’t look like a featured landmark. The dilapidated state made him wonder if the residents were simply trying to forget it existed.

“This isn’t exactly a sightseer’s dream.” Maxim sighed. “You certainly didn’t drag me out here just to take a photo, I’m guessing.”

[ ]

What the hell is a photo? I brought you here so we can train!”

I’ll admit, I didn’t see that one coming with how there’s bootleg radio in this setting. Though this is a Mystery Dungeon, isn’t it?

“Don’t worry about it, just was thinking of something from- Wha? T-t-training?!” He stammered. “As in, fighting?”

A wide grin spread over Rene’s face as she clapped her palms together.

“That’s right! Part of my role is to get you up to speed in combat. And what better place to do that privately than a dusty old cave?”

Maxim: “... I was hoping to start out with static targets on some sort of practice range, really.”
916590486356131850.webp


He gulped as he remembered his promise to Drake. He did want to grow stronger and he would need a good base to start. That didn’t mean he wanted to dive into some run down cave with little more than a torch guiding him!

You have a typo there for ‘cave’, since I doubt that this place sells coffee to visitors.

“W-won’t it be too dark to try and fight in there?”

“Bah! Don’t tell me you’re scared of a little darkness!” Rene scoffed. “Besides, there’s going to be plenty of times you fight with poor vision. Best to learn the basics now than to pay for not knowing later!”

That actually makes me wonder if anyone on Drake’s crew rocks an eyepatch, since those used to be used precisely to allow pirates to quickly adjust to going around below deck in darkened environments with the eye that was kept shaded all the time.

[ ]

“I suppose…” He groaned.

[ ] Heading into the cave, Maxim realized that he could see well even without relying on Rene’s torch.

You never explicitly mentioned that they set off into that cave, just saying.

“Huh? I better chalk it up to my new body I guess.”

I mean, you’re an owl, so…

Strewn around were the remnants of wooden minecarts and steel rails. What must be pickaxes and hammers embedded in the walls were coated in rust. Large pillars of soil mixed with pebbles rose from the ground. The air was cold and dry, making Maxim hug his scarf closer to his body.

Oh, hello, Ether Mine stand-in.

“So this was a mine?” Maxim asked.

Rene nodded. “Yeh. Supposedly this was some mystery dungeon ages ago that eventually transformed into a regular cave loaded in minerals. The locals pretty much mined it out and then bandits turned it into their hideout. But that’s all history now.” She kicked a rock further down a corridor. A small echo of its impact could be heard a few seconds later.

So, what’s the over/under of this not all just being history at this point?

[ ]

“A mystery dungeon?”

[ ]

“Oh right, your amnesia.” Rene sighed. “Mystery Dungeons are weirdo places that generate all over the world. Every island has at least one that pops up, teeming with mindless pokemon we call ferals, or wildies as far as us skymen go.”

Well, that explains where they got the meat from. Though I’m a little surprised that they call themselves ‘skymen’ and not skymon’ even if it’s certainly fitting for this setting.

Her head swiveled from side to side right before she leaned in. “Then sometimes they just… stop being mysterious ‘n all like this place. The wildies inside all disappear and nobody’s sure if they just left or straight-up go poof. I don’t care either way!”

[ ]

“That’s nuts!” Maxim said. Just how much crazier does this world get? Floating in the sky, talking animals, and now this? He really wanted to groan.

Another spot where it probably makes sense to show off Maxim’s reactions and inner thoughts off a bit more, especially if a part of him is meeping a bit at this place being less dusty and abandoned than initially presumed.

Past a tight tunnel, the pair entered a clearing. Light beamed down from a hole in the ceiling, allowing a good view without a torch.

Withered fabric and rotted wood littered the ground, the remains of tents and minecarts piled up along the walls. Scorch marks of a lit campfire were still visible, though most of the remaining ash was long gone. Boulders strewn around had strange symbols carved into them, only adding to the archaic visage. Rene seemed indifferent to all of it, given how she sat down on a boulder and tossed her torch to the ground.

inb4 that turns out to be human script or something.

Guess this is the bandit’s camp. Ah well! This’ll be a good spot to train in! No distractions, no nosy onlookers, just us and this dusty old cave!”

Oh, so this really is the Torigoth expy island of this story. Since that’s definitely a thing I remember from it in my XB2 playthrough (granted, there was less mining equipment around).

Leaping into the open campsite’s remains, she raised up her fist and assumed a fighting stance. “C’mon, C’mon! Don’t be a hatchling! Face me!” Her paw waved back and forth.

de7.png


Maxim sighed and fluttered down on the opposite side. He sure as hell didn’t know how to assume a fighting stance, so he tried his best to give her a cold stare. Seconds passed without a word between the two. Within the blink of an eye, Rene crossed the gap. Her raised fist slammed into the ground in front of Maxim, kicking up dust. He jumped back only for Rene to swing out her leg. The impact sent him skidding across the ground. There was little chance to catch his breath as Rene leaped into the air and slammed her fist down. Maxim rolled away at the last second.

Rene: “Um… Maxim? Not that I’m complaining, but aren’t ya staying a bit close to the ground right now?”
916590116670144542.webp


Soon, the spar had devolved into a game of cat and mouse between the two. Rene stayed glued to the Rowlet, hitting him with punch after punch. The blows were meaty and knocked him around, but left him with a stinging sensation at worst. In vain he attempted to claw at her with his talons, but this did little to dissuade her. As he tried to fly up to escape her, Rene landed a mean right hook to his back. The Rowlet slammed into the ground and struggled to get up.

Cute illustration there.

Maxim: “... Ow.” XvX

[ ]

“What is WITH you?!” Rene hissed. “Fight back! You’re a pokemon, for Arceus’s sake!”

Maxim strained his head to look at her, a weary sign escaping his beak. “I know that! I just can’t get anything to happen! It’s like a mental block!”

Rene:
how-are-you-not-dead-how-are-you-alive.gif

Maxim: “By running really quickly and hiding while the rest of you did all the fighting?” >v>;

The Mienfoo raised a paw to her temple, then began to charge energy into her fist. “You know I’ve been holding back on you! I thought you’d get it by now! But still nothing! Why are you so weak, Maxim? You’re useless!”

[ ]


“U-useless?” He stuttered.

Shots fired. Even if I suppose that in the end, it’s better to be cruel upfront to Maxim in the hopes that he gits gud or drops out versus going through another pirate fight having to hide in a corner again.

“Yeah that’s right! You want to be a part of this crew and you can’t even throw out a basic attack? You’re useless! Best you could do is be a cabin boy!” Rene crouched low to the ground, preparing to rush again. “And now, I’m gonna knock you down!”

That word bounced around in his head as he gripped soil with his talons. Useless, useless, useless. This wasn’t some spur of the moment decision, he’d do anything to recover his memory and humanity back!

[ ]

“Even if I don’t have any powers, that doesn’t mean I’m going to just give up and leave the crew!” He yelled back. “I’m not usel-”

IMO, the ‘Useless’ reverberation should be formatted as an internal thought on Maxim’s part there instead of as normal narration. Though you probably want to describe Maxim getting a bit more openly testy with Rene there instead of leaving it wholly implied.

…!

A piercing ring echoed in his skull as he felt another memory bubble to the surface, this time allowing him to picture the scene.

A wooden desk was in front of him, with a figure sitting behind it. A stack of papers was laid out before him, with only the figure’s smile being a visible detail. The figure then opened their mouth to speak in a garbled tone.

Maxim: “Um, not that it’s not welcome to have some memory back, but Rene’s not about to punch me right now, is she?” ^v^;

“I’ve appreciated your effort up to this point, but I’m sorry to say we have no more need for you. Effective immediately, you’re to be removed from the project.”

‘Project’, huh? So someone sent Maxim here from the other side?

Maxim slammed his hands, human hands onto the desk. “What? How can you do this to me? After everything?!”

The figure flashed a smile that extended from ear to ear. “Thanks to arrangements, you are well… unnecessary, unneeded.” They leaned over the desk, towering over him. Void-colored eyes burned their glare into Maxim’s own.

“Useless.”

Oh, well. Looks like Rene hit one hell of a nerve there. .-.

Pain coursed through his skull as he covered his head. It felt like his head was going to split apart. [ ]

“Huh, what’s wrong?” Rene asked, cocking her head to the side.

You probably want to provide some sort of brief acknowledgement that Rene is stopping and getting weirded out or something.

“Just leave me alone!” He roared. “I’ve dealt with enough already! And now you want to take this away from me too?!” A green glow enveloped Maxim’s wings as he raised them at her.

Rene: “Hey! That’s more like it! See, I knew you were able to atta-!”
916590509810679808.webp


“I’m not useless!”

Three feathers launched like arrows, coated in green energy. Rene, startled, lept back right as they impacted the ground. Again, Maxim shot another set. Rene swerved to dodge then pressed on her attack. Motivated by an unknown instinct, Maxim charged at her and slammed into her chest. The Mienfoo froze for a moment, only to backhand him away.

Rene: “Geez! Alright! Alright! You’ve made your point there! Don’t take things so personally!”
401076862924750848.webp


Both of them paused, Maxim letting out small gasps. He shakenly looked down at his wings. A strange feeling of relief came over him, as if he’d climbed a cliff all by himself. He summoned a loose feather again, closely examining it, and threw it at a nearby rock. The resulting impact shattered it into dust.

Maxim: “... Wait, my feathers can do that?”
684293502049320970.webp


“This is my own power?” He marveled. Razor sharp feather projectiles? This new body truly was a wonder. He turned back to Rene, who had relaxed her stance and crossed her arms.

“Heh! I knew you could do it! All you needed was a little roughing up, is all!” She grinned. “Think you used another move when you slammed into my chest. Since it sure didn’t feel like a regular blow.”

Wait, so he used a chain attack, or…?

Maxim nodded. There was a certain feeling he got from using both attacks, which made him wonder if it really was a natural instinct.

I can use more than one attack, right?”

I’ll take that as confirmation, even if I didn’t pick up on that from the provided description right away.

Rene snickered, “Of course you can! Up to four moves at a time! And of course, there’s only one way to figure that out.” She charged energy into her fists. “Cmon!”

I’ll admit, I’m not sure how I really feel about a hard move limit in-universe, but I suppose I’ll reserve judgement until I see more of how it works and the lore behind it.

The thought of getting pummeled again by her without holding back made him shudder. But there was no point in bowing out now.

“Alright, l-lets do this! For real this time!”

Don’t make me break out Bubsy again, Maxim.

The Rowlet rushed forward, this time with a nervous grin on his face.

Yeeeeeah, there’s no way that he didn’t get ground into the dirt there.

“And... that’s it for now.”

Drake crossed his arms as he waited for Matilda to finish writing down his report. The Indeedee had not moved her sight from her notepad. Seconds trickled into minutes before she spoke again.

Huh, wasn’t expecting us to cut back to Drake like that. Though I suppose that’s one way of skipping to the good stuff on his end of the plot.

“Again, I thank you for providing me with such wonderful information! This concludes our meeting!” She reached into a bag and handed him a beige envelope. Gold trimming lined its edges and a gold, three-leaf symbol was stamped to the back. Drake placed it into his vest pocket.

“So what will you do now? I suppose you will have to report to the Sol Knights about our little chat as well?”

Just filing that name away for later mentally.

“If you think we will take custody of the little one, then you have nothing to fear. He can stay with you for now.” Matilda said.

>for now

1220916380468117705.webp


Oh yeah, that totally bodes well for later on in the story. /s

Drake flicked his crest. “Hmm? I’m surprised that you would trust a no-good pirate like me. What’s the catch?”

Oh, so Privateers are seen as sketchy types by the average normie in this setting. Duly noted.

For the first time since starting, a frown replaced Matilda’s smile. “The Knights will be watching you closely. Should we deem you inadequate for holding the human, we will confiscate him from you.” Said frown vanished as she put on another smile. “I have faith in you, however! Do continue to impress the governor and myself!”

Well, that was certainly… forward.

Drake rose and gave her a small nod. “If we’re finished here, I’d best be on my way then!” Before exiting, he turned around to see Matilda giving her a small wave. With that, he was finally done with his business here.

Just outside the door, Signal silently waited for him. The large Braviary levitated off the ground and took to the skies, flying in an arc. Drake made sure to put as much distance between him and the house as he could before letting out a hefty sigh.

Whelp, time to see how Drake really feels about Matilda and his state of affairs.

“Well that was an annoyance. To have a Great Knight meet me at such an ill moment.”

Does he mean to test your loyalty? If so, how much does he suspect of you?” A deep voice spoke from high above. Drake looked up to see Signal’s crest pulsating with pink light.

Suspect of you’? Drake, what on earth are you up to right now? :copyka:

“It was most likely out of the governor’s hand. The monarchy’s been getting anxious to stay on top of things lately. Me and him are on the same page, so no need to worry.” Drake said.

Ah yes, political talk. Though I smell skulduggery right now.

Signal’s crest gleamed again. “ Fair enough. Shall we return back?”

The captain straightened up his vest before raising a hand to his crest. He swore he could hear a sigh from Signal’s end.

“Indeed! Let’s go back home, first mate!”

Whelp, looks like that ended nice and tidily. I take it that we’re going to check back in with Maxim right about now.

“Max..!”

“Maxim!”

“Hey, Maxim!”

Okay, yeah. Maxim got clobbered fighting Rene, I can already tell.

Maxim groaned as he slowly opened his eyes to light. Moving his body around, he could feel the softness of grass beneath him. As his eyes adjusted, the sight of orange sky and treetops greeted him. He rose up in confusion. How did he get outside of the cave? As he looked to his side he found Rene staring back at him.

“Took you long enough!” Rene said, arms crossed. “I didn’t think I hit ya that hard!”

Maxim: “I think you have a bit of a skewed perspective there, Rene.”
1105356712292130856.webp


He groaned and rubbed his head. “What happened? Last thing I remember was us clashing blows.”

“Well I may have struck you a little harder than I realized and plain knocked you out. My bad!”

Get used to it, Maxim, since I can already tell that this is part and parcel of being a privateer.

[ ]


“Did I at least unlock a new move?”

This feels like another spot where it’d make sense to show off more of Maxim’s inner thought process here.

“Uhh, well you growled at me. Guess that counts.”

[ ]

“Growling is a move?”

“Yeah!”

Maxim: “... Fantastic.” >v<

Maxim blinked in response. He had a lot to learn about move diversity, it seemed. Turning back to the cave, the location glowed in the light of the setting sun.

[ ]

“Hey Maxim. I hope you didn’t take those words of mine to heart too badly.” Rene sighed, rubbing the back of her head. “I just wanted to get you riled up in battle, is all.”

Another spot where it makes sense to stop and elaborate on the characters’ reactions. Especially Rene if you mean to hint at anything about her for further down the road.

Maxim looked off into the distance. He thought about the word “useless” again and that painful memory. He couldn’t help but stay frustrated, not at her words, but at himself. How come his own personal memories could only trickle back into place but concepts were no issue? No doubt that voice had a hand!

“Yeah, it's no problem. I just wanted help knowing what my body could do.” He looked down at himself. His feathers were ruffled and his scarf was nearly tattered. Rene had really done a number on him. “I was a bit worried you got put off by my freakout.”

Can’t tell if Maxim is genuinely okay here or if he’s just saying things to go along to get along.

“Nah! It’s been too long since I got someone riled up. Bound to happen sometime!” She snickered, causing Maxim to sigh and roll his eyes. [ ]

“Pretty peaceful place, eh?” Rene said as she took a seat on the grass. “Haven’t been to an island like this in a long time.” She reached inside her bag and tossed over a small, spherical blue fruit with small pores. Maxim realized it was the fruit from his earlier meal.

Maxim: “What on earth are these things anyways?” Ovó;

“Don’t tell me you’ve forgotten what an Oran Berry is! Eat it so you’ll get healed right up!” She teased.

Maxim swallowed the fruit, its sweet and tangy flavor delightfully familiar. A refreshing feeling rushed over his body and he felt rejuvenated enough to move around.

“Wow, this feels great!” He exclaimed.

Maxim: “So the freaky blue oranges heal you in this world. I think I can live with that. ^v^;

The bliss coursing through him was enough to make him twirl in place. As he looked at the forest around, a nagging feeling crawled up from behind. Far away past a row of trees, he could make out shadows moving around. He rubbed his eyes only to see they had vanished, but his uneasiness was only growing.

“What’s wrong?” Rene asked.

Maxim: “I swear for a moment that I just saw someone over there…”

“I dunno, felt like someone was watching us for a second,he answered.

Rene got up and walked away, swerving her head from side to side. “Hmph, could be some curious villager, I imagine one of them may have noticed us passing through. I guess we should head back for now.”

Narrator: “It was not just a curious villager.”

“Seconded.”

Maxim followed closely behind, not wanting to stick around to find out. Rows of trees came and went with no sign of movement. Only a few minutes later the pair found themselves staring at a curious newcomer. In front was a spherical blue pokemon identified as a Marill.

Gauntlet-covered paws held a small wooden sphere, while a blue scarf was wrapped around the base of their tail. A frown was on their face and their body trembled every few seconds.

Maxim: “Oh, so we were being watched. OvO;

Though you probably want to give Maxim more of an explicitly described reaction to all of this.

“H-hey! What do you t-think you’re uh, doing out here?!” The Maril stammered in a young male’s voice. He raised the spear at both of them, gripping it the best his trembling paws would let him.

You probably want to fix the ‘sphere’ in the prior block, since that’s very different from a ‘spear’ there.

Rene walked up slowly and placed a paw on his spear. “Ease up, you big baby. We’re just checking out the cave here. Heard it’s a neat local attraction!” She winked at Maxim, who gave her a hasty nod back.

The Marill shook his head. “Famous or not, y-you shouldn’t be going in there! It’s dangerous and unstable f-from years of u-use! You could uh, g-get hurt!”

Rene: “(... How on earth did these local ‘mon not get their town sacked and burned to the ground back when those bandits used to be around?)”
916590116670144542.webp


“And who are you supposed to be, my dad?” Rene scoffed. “Aren’t you supposed to be patrolling the city or whatever your lot does?”

[ ]

“I’m the o-one who should be asking t-the questions here!” The Marill barked back.

She released her grip and began to walk off. “Eh don’t worry about it, we were leaving anyway. Have fun with your patrol!”

inb4 the Marill’s five much tougher and more composed buddies burst out of the foliage in two seconds.

With that, the pair continued on their way, ignoring the guard.

“Don’t you ignore m-m-me!” He hollered, hopping up and down. “T-treat me with some respect!”

Rene:
Creating_Bugs_Bunny%27s_%22No%22.jpg


I can’t imagine a guy like that could sneak around so easily.” He thought. Turning back one last time, he saw nothing moving around in the forest, and that nagging feeling of his had vanished. “ Whoever or whatever that was must have left already. Glad they did, but I still feel uneasy.”

His thoughts would circle between his newfound powers and the strange encounter all the way back to the ship.

This isn’t the last time that we’re going to see that Marill, huh?

It’s been far too long since the last time I was in this story, but getting there little by little. I take it that this was essentially a warming up chapter given that the main things that happened were essentially Maxim meeting some Adventurers and getting to find out about some different ways of life, Rene helping him to suck a bit less at battling, and a glimpse of Maxim’s past as a human… oh, and the whole cloak and dagger business with Drake implying that thar be political shenanigans in this story that will likely be unavoidable for Maxim, even if they haven’t come out front and center just yet. The world feels charming and alive as always, though it has some implied harder edges, not wholly unlike Alrest which I'm pretty sure was explicitly mentioned as being one of your story's bigger sources of inspiration here, so you’ve got me paying attention to see where that goes.

Aside from the obvious of the paragraph spacing being wonky and that one dead image link, there were some issues here and there that I noticed in the chapter. There were some typos and paragraph formattings that I didn’t agree with, but the much bigger issue was that I noticed a number of places where you passed up opportunities to either set the surrounding scenery a bit better, or make exchanges between characters more animated by describing their reactions or their inner thought processes. I’ll leave it up to you as to how much you want to patch that in after the fact, since I understand that rewrite-itis has a nasty track record of derailing fics in this scene.

But altogether, I had quite a bit of fun with this chapter, @Z102eternal . You seem to be teeing up a lot of little hints and teases about a much bigger world of adventure for Maxim and the gang to get lost in, and even if it might not be during Review Blitz due to a full reading plate, I’ll be looking forward to seeing where they go.
 

Spiteful Murkrow

Busy Writing Stories I Want to Read
Pronouns
He/Him/His
Partners
  1. nidoran-f
  2. druddigon
  3. swellow
  4. lugia
  5. growlithe
  6. quilava-fobbie
  7. sneasel-kate
  8. heliolisk-fobbie
Heya, it’s been far too long since I last crossed paths with this story. But with Review Event going on in Diner, I figured it was as good a chance as any to poke my head back in to a few stories that I didn’t get quite as far into as I wanted to back in Review Blitz and this was one of them.

Anyhow, let’s see what Maxim’s up to this time back in Not!Alrest:

Chapter 6

Orange skies gave way to violet starlight as the first day on Calvin Island drew to a close. Thankfully, there were no further interruptions once the two came back into town. Maneuvering through the emptying streets, the pair finally reached the docks. Fellow crew members were boarding the ship, with some carrying crates, bags, and other stored goods. One pokemon, an Ambipom, wobbled up the ramp before falling backward. Maxim rushed over, worried, only to see them snoring.

Can’t tell if the Ambipom’s been working hard, or if he’s just lazy there.

A nearby Heracross snickered at the sight. “Queen’s gown, what a lightweight! Told him he’s got a lot of practicing to do before he can drink with the big boys!” The Heracross slung the unconscious mon over their shoulder and leaped onto the deck.

… Or he could be drunk off his ass. That works, too. Though I see that we’re also doing queen-related minced oaths like in XB3. Makes me wonder what the queen in this setting is like.

[ ]

“Is he gonna be alright?” Maxim asked.

“Eh, he’ll live. Some of us think we can outdrink the other and then this happens.” Rene sighed.

It might’ve made sense to show a bit more of Maxim and Rene’s presence and reaction to this before he started speaking up again. Also, that makes me wonder just how frequently members of Drake’s crew have liver failure from the way they go through alcohol. ^^;

Back on the ship, the two went below decks to the mess hall. Like the day before, a massive line stretched from front to back, with the pair barely out the door. The line moved without confrontation, and Maxim soon found himself in front of a familiar duo.

The Grafraiai and Slowbro were hard at work moving dishes across the counter. While his much taller partner turned potatoes over a small flame, the Grafraiai handed out meals to everyone.

Oh right. The two Poison-types in charge of making food for everyone. So how often do cases of food poisoning even happen on this ship anyways?

Noticing the Rowlet, Cardin presented a plate to Maxim with a gleam in his eyes.

“Hey, Rowlet! Ready to get your pallet blown away by another Cardin and Hyde specialty? This time we’ve got oven-roasted potato slices coated with a zesty glaze made from ground herbs and nomel berries! One bite of this and you’ll weep of joy!” The tiny chef flexed his thin arms. “I’d like to see one of those local joints match this! One bite of this and you’ll weep from joy!

Some suggestions for tweaking Carlin’s line a bit. Though as morbidly hilarious as it’d be to have an Emetater episode, these two seemed pretty competent as cooks last time, so Carlin just might live up to this boasting after all.

[ ]

“I think that one Heatmor’s dish had our number, chum.” His Slowbro companion sighed.

“Hey hey hey!” Cardin growled. “Just you wait, that guy’s flame is gonna be a candle in the wind to our inferno!”

Hyde rubbed the back of his head. “Yeahhh, sure thing.”

Maxim: “Um… can I have my food, please?” ^v^;

Maxim took his seat at an occupied table, then jolted a bit when Rene sat down by him.

Maxim: “Okay, seriously! Stop sneaking up on me like that!”
554513872514449424.webp


“Reservin’ a table, eh? Isn’t that nice of you!” The Mienfoo laughed.

“Oh, I- uh, I was just trying to c-chill out of the way, you know, uh.” Maxim stammered.

She lightly tapped him on the head. “Relax, I’m just teasin’ yah! Good eye to pick a spot out of the way!”

Maxim: “But this was supposed to be where I’d get to eat in peace and quiet.” ·v·
Rene: “Well, now you’ve got peace and quiet with company!” ^.^

All around them, pokemon were chatting away or messing around with their fellow crew mates. The two dug in, eating their food without a word passing between the two. Between bites, Maxim broke the awkward silence.

“Hey Rene, I’m surprised you wanted to sit with me. I figured you probably had others that you’d hang out with.”

Maxim: “Since I could’ve sworn this story mentioned that you had friends with other crewmates in earlier chapters…”
916590116670144542.webp


“I’m not a big party gal. There are plenty of days where I'm happy to sit by myself.” She said, puffing out her cheeks. “Plus I’m your partner now, gotta keep an eye on yah!”

Maxim: “P-Partner?! When on earth did you ever become-!” OvO;

Maxim couldn’t object to that. The two continued their meal in silence. But he had to admit, having someone to spend time with was giving him a slight fuzzy feeling inside.

I kinda wonder if this whole “fuzzy feeling” moment should’ve been expanded on or else have Maxim’s thought process explored in a bit more detail, since this feels a bit “informed attribute” at the moment.

BARRRRRRINGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG!!

“UP AND AT’EM, THE WINDS OF A NEW DAY ARE HERE!”

Maxim: “MY EARS!”
663472556124405770.webp


Maxim groaned and rolled out of his hammock. The start of a new day had arrived, and with it, another jolt out of bed.

It’s going to be a long time before I get used to this. He thought.

Maxim: “Possibly ‘never’ at this rate.”
916605476437909534.webp


A quick stop by the mess hall and a breakfast of roasted bread gave him a morning boost. Squeezing through the crowded halls of crewmembers, Maxim went above deck. The dull thumping of shuffling boxes and moving pokemon was the first thing to greet him. Most of the crew were busy sweeping the deck, lifting cargo, and other tasks. [ ]

Even first thing in the morning, the crew’s got the ball rolling! Talk about no effort wasted!

Wait, are they still at the docks at the moment? Since you’d think that they wouldn’t need to be moving cargo around in the open skies unless they’re fishing stuff up from whatever lies below the clouds. Also, does whatever’s down there look more like it does in Skies of Arcadia, or Xenoblade 2?

Though it probably makes sense to elaborate on Maxim’s reaction or thought process a bit before he gives his thought commentary there.
While his gaze wandered over the deck, he felt a strange sensation nibbling at the back of his mind. The feeling led him to look up at the bow, leading him to a curious sight. At the tip stood a figure covered in a long billowing green cloak. Through an opening around the head, a ruby-colored eye peeked back at Maxim. Despite the figure’s small stature, the other crew members were ignoring their presence. Maxim rubbed at his eyes with a wing only to see that the figure had vanished.

Oh hey, neat image you’ve got accompanying this. Even if I’m not quite sure who this is supposed to be. Watch as it turns out to be that swordsman Meowscarada you’ve got art floating around for.

“What in the-”

His gaze darted from side to side, scanning for any other sign. He looked towards the stern. There the figure was, sitting on the deck above the ship’s wheel. It waved a dark blue arm, as if beckoning Maxim over.

Well scratch that about it being the swordsman Meowscarada. Though who are you anyways, buddy?

[ ]

This is ridiculous! Am I really the only one who can see this happening? He thought. Taking flight, the Rowlet soared just over the heads of his fellow crew members and landed directly in front of the steering wheel. This time, the figure stayed in place and waved back.

“Hey! Just who are you?” Maxim yelled.

A silent shake of their head was the only response. Bright pink energy coated the figure’s form before they vanished into light, leaving Maxim at a loss for words.

And the plot thickens. Though I’m just realizing between that eye color pattern and the color of the exposed arm that that was consistent with a female Meowstic. Which would also explain the pink energy that we just witnessed.
Maxim: “... Wait, so did that all actually happen, or am I going crazy right now?”
554513872514449424.webp


Just what the hell was that?

Like 99% sure that that was a Meowstic in a cloak, Maxim. Even if I’m not sure just who that’s supposed to be.

He wouldn’t have the chance, as a large shadow loomed over him. Maxim twisted his head around to see a massive bipedal pokemon standing with their arms crossed. Their jet black body was covered in armor-like scales, scars, and cuts. A pair of axe-shaped tusks sprouted from their snout, the left one’s edge chipped and broken. The blue scarf wrapped around their neck indicated they were a crew member. But that did little to assure Maxim, who was frozen with terror.

Oh, hello, battle-scarred Shiny Haxorus.

Maxim: “AAAAAAAAAAAAA!”
770125468800122880.webp


“H-h-how are you doing Mr. Ha-Hax-Haxorus, i-is it?” Maxim said with a poorly feigned smile. The dragon type stood statue-like as their red eyes bored into Maxim. A few seconds passed before the Haxorus relaxed.

How do you feign a smile with a beak anyways?

“Why are you snooping around my quarters, Rowlet? Are you looking for something?” Spoke the dragon type spoke in a masculine tone. His voice was deep yet smooth and commanded enough energy to make Maxim straighten up.

I mean, I’d straighten up too in the presence of a crabby living battleaxe, just saying.

“S-sorry sir! I didn’t mean to intrude!” Maxim apologized, rubbing his head. “I didn’t know this was your area!”

The Haxorus let out a small sigh. “Don’t look at me all scared. I’m not going to bite,” His tail gently slapped the wood floor. “As long as this ship is docked here, I don’t have much else to do but stare.”

Oh, so the ship is still docked… yeah, that wasn’t exactly obvious earlier on from the presently provided description.

Maxim sighed in relief. [ ] The last thing he wanted to do was push the crew’s buttons.

Well, that’s not a bad thing! I’d rather deal with a slow day than a hectic one like with that pirate crew recently, haha!” Maxim said with a nervous chuckle.

I think that this is also another spot where there was a chance to have some sort of “thank goodness” internal thought process on Maxim’s part there or something like that.

Maxim: “Also, um… how have I never seen you before all this time? Since you’re kinda big and hard to miss.” ^v^;
Shiny!Haxorus: “You tell me, really.”

A smile tugged at the edges of the dragon’s face as he looked up at the skies above. “Aye. You’re not wrong kiddo. I’ve seen enough sunrises to know when to appreciate a peaceful day when I see one. You should as well.” The look in the Haxorus’s face softened. “I suppose I might as well ask. What’s your name, Rowlet? I’ve seen a lot of mons aboard this ship, but not one of your kind.”

inb4 this guy is basically Gramps as a scaly can opener. Since that dialogue’s definitely giving me some vibes.

“Maxim, sir.” He replied.

“Maxim, eh?” The Haxorus raised one of his hands to his chin, causing Maxim to notice said hand was missing a claw. “You new here? Don’t recall us picking up any rookies at our last stop.”

Well then. Someone’s quite battle-scarred, indeed. Though I take it that that’s a sign that Drake and the gang get into bouts of serious violence from time to time.

[ ]

“Yeah, you can say that. I’m still learning a lot about the pir-privateer life.” He stated. “I’m grateful that Captain Drake gave me the chance to be here and stuff.”

“Well, you picked a great crew!” The Haxorus chuckled. “Just make sure to put in work, little one!”

I feel like we’re missing some combination of body language and internal thought process from these two. Like I’m kinda getting the vibe that Maxim is uncomfortably squirming right now and wants out, but it’s not really described at the moment.

“Sure thing, Mr…?”

The Haxorus raised a hand, then pointed his thumb at his chest. “Abel. Just call me Abel. I’m the crew’s helmsmon. Come gentle breeze or rough storm, I’ll get us where we need to go in one piece!”

Just filing that name away. Even if I’d never have guessed he was the guy who steered this ship around. So is there a ‘Cain’ for this guy, too?

“Noted! Nice to meet you, sir!” The Rowlet gave him a small nod, then looked back to the deck. Some crew members were leaving the ship for the day, while others were still busy with daily tasks. “Well that reminds me, I’ve got to get back with my partner. I don’t want to keep her waiting any more.”

Abel nodded. “Aye, good to keep your fellow crewmate in mind!”

Maxim: “I’m… just going to leave really, really quickly now.” ^v^;

[ ]

“Oh wait, one more thing. This might sound weird, but have you seen a floating figure covered in a green cloak anywhere around here? I seemed to be the only one that saw them.”

IMO, this moment likely works a bit better with Maxim being about to leave before having an internal “oh wait” moment and catching himself that should be shown off a bit more.

The Haxorus raised a brow. “Green..cloak..? Hmmm.” He traced a hand around one of his blade tusks. “Green cloak… oh! I know what you mean.” A sigh left Abel as he rubbed at his temple. “Not normal for her to get bored this easily. Sorry if you got spooked, just don’t worry about that. You’ll probably meet her again soon.”

Feeling really good about that prediction that our cloaked figure is a Fem!Meowstic right now. Though she’s also a part of the crew, huh? I suppose that’s a sign that we’ll be meeting her later on in this chapter.

[ ]

“Her?”

He raised a claw to his snout. “Shhhhh, she’ll get annoyed if I talk any more about it.”

Maxim: “O… kay? Though why are you acting like she’ll do something drastic if she finds out about this?”
635663776041140226.webp


[ ] Maxim wanted to protest, but decided he had spent enough time getting sidetracked. “Well alright, I’ll be off then!”

I kinda wonder if Maxim also should have a bit more internal reaction as to what he’s found out about this mystery cloaked figure. Since something about the present “he wanted to protest” feels like it’s skipping a step.

As Maxim flew back to the main deck, he saw Rene leaned against the railing. Her eyes were closed, and she didn’t react when he landed in front of her. Maxim tilted his head and poked her with a wing.

“Hey Rene, I’m here!”

Maxim: “So, uh… what’d I miss, anyways?” ^v^

“Yeah, I can see you,she sighed. “Hope you’re ready for another day, ‘cause you’re gonna have more training to do!”

Maxim: “Pls no.
554513872514449424.webp


“Sure thing. And I’ll try not to get knocked out early on this time.” Maxim said.

Huh, someone’s a bit more chipper than I was expecting with how he was basically a punching bag last chapter. Guess that thrill of battle must make up for it.

[ ]

“Let’s head on, then! I want us to start early today! No slackin’!” She huffed. Rene sped down the ramp, waving her paw for him to follow. He chose to glide down alongside the Mienfoo.

This feels like a moment where it’d make sense to show Rene getting up from the railing and reacting a bit or showing off some body language.

As the two were about to take the main path into town, nearby shouting caught their attention. The source came from slightly further down the dock, where the familiar face of Clyde was focused on a pink humanoid figure known as a Tinkaton. Two pairs of goggles were wrapped above her head and around her neck while her blue scarf was tied around one of her twintails. Despite being shorter than Clyde, the pokemon easily wheeled around a cart stacked with metal and fabrics at least three times her size. Though Clyde’s back was turned, the Politoed’s rigid stance conveyed enough.

“Argh! Now what have yer gone n’ done? I thought you and yer little group already peeled enough off that ship to satisfy yer!” Clyde groaned, crossing his arms.

Oh hi, Tinkaton. So… over / under on her mainlining Sena vibes? Since that would be decently on-brand for this story.
I’m not really sure what the underlined is supposed to be saying. Is that supposed to be something like “conveyed his obvious displeasure” or something like that?

The Tinkaton adjusted the goggles on her head, then flashed him a smile. “That ship of theirs won’t sail again, so I figured they wouldn’t miss it if I took a few parts with us!”

Okay, yeah, I’m feeling pretty good about that throwaway prediction, just saying. Since this girl’s definitely got some gall to her.

“Yer calling that a wee bit o’ parts?” Clyde argued. “Yer bum’s oot the windae! I’ve gotten tired o’ listening to the navy cry and squeal like hatchlings!”

“Meh! By the time those lugs even try to complain, we’ll have already given ‘em the slip!” The Tinkaton said. “Out of sight, out of mind!”

de7.png


The Politoed facepalmed. “By the Queen’s gown, I’ll need to get hammered tonight.”

Hopefully with drinks and not your buddy’s hammer. Though I suppose that either would work decently well at getting you to forget a few things. ^^;

[ ]

“She seemed rather…passionate.” Maxim whispered, turning to Rene.

“Hestia? She’s a wild one. I wouldn’t get too close if I were you. She might try to work ya into one of her wacky experiments!” Rene teased.

Just filing that one away for later. Though you probably want to make it a bit more explicit that either Clyde and Hestia or Rene and Maxim have moved on and they’re no longer in proximity to each other.

[ ] Maxim suddenly felt more motivated to head into town. “We should definitely get a move on now!”

With a roll of her eyes, Rene walked down the boardwalk with Maxim following close behind.

It might make sense to have Maxim more explicitly react to the “experiments” part and squirm / get unnerved a bit here.

The town was more lively today as crowds of pokemon flowed through the streets. A dense herd of four-legged mons like Tauros and Mudsdale forced the pair to hug the street’s edge. Even as they switched to a side road, the traffic refused to thin out [ ]

The chaotic pace and lack of space began to wear at Maxim. His small stature only made things worse. Finally after minutes of weaving around larger mons, he found enough breathing room in the middle of a wide road. His chance to rest would be short lived.

Your first paragraph cuts out abruptly. Can’t tell whether that’s supposed to be the end of the sentence or if there was more that was meant to be there that got cut on accident somehow.

Also, wait, why isn’t Maxim just trying to fly above the passing traffic again? Since you’d think that would allow him to avoid the worst of the crowds of Pokémon going around. ^^;

A figure brushed against his side, and with them the tug of something coming off. He looked down to see his scarf was still present, but he felt strangely lighter . That wasn’t right. A few seconds went by before the realization dawned on him: [ ].

He scanned around to see a black and white blur sped back into the dense crowd.

It might make sense to explicitly state what Maxim’s realization is given that we’re following his thought process through the narration.

“What’s goin’ on? You look pissed!” Rene said.

“My bag is gone! Someone took it!” Maxim cried out.

Oh boy, that’s going to be fun for these two to deal with.

The Rowlet launched into the air, looking for the thief.

Okay, I’m just realizing that the reason why Maxim hasn’t been flying all this time is that he’s been encumbered by that bag… which should probably be made explicit earlier on since that makes a lot of details in this scene make more sense.

“Hey wait up! I can’t fly, you know!” Rene yelled.

She waved to Maxim, but he was already high in the air. From building to building, there was no sight of anything beyond visiting customers or relaxing townsfolk. The crowd began to thin out, but as Maxim passed between streets his target remained absent. He came to rest on a slanted rooftop, taking a moment to catch his breath.

“Shit! Where could they have gone?!”

Rene: “You could start by giving me a description to work with, you know!” >.<

His current position was He sat at the point where the main entrance to Merchant’s Street met another sideroad. The location was vacant outside a pair of passing Furret. Anger building, his claws started to chip into the roof’s tiles.

You’ve got to be kidding me! Only the second day here and I’ve been mugged for my one first day’s paycheck!”

I mean, you basically are working as a legalized pirate, so are you really that shocked that you’re running into rough company, Maxim?
720106605982646283.webp


The rustling of a bush below caught his attention. It continued for a few seconds before the white head of a small bear poked its head out. A small leaf was in their mouth while a crudely stitched together black hoodie draped from their neck.

Oh, hello Pancham. Though I’m guessing that he’s got Maxim’s bag right about now.

A…Pancham? Wait a second!”

After looking from side to side, the pokemon hopped out of the bush. The black hoodie had a cape stitched below the shoulders. Quickly, they dashed across the street and into a small alleyway.

Having wings was becoming a newfound blessing for Maxim, as they let him trail the Pancham without worry. The black and white pokemon skillfully weaved from alley to alley, eventually heading down a long narrow corridor ending in a square shaped clearing. Tightly enclosed by multistoried buildings, it was hard to believe someone would want to bother with a place like this. The most surprising fact would be that the Pancham wasn’t alone.

Can’t tell if this is the culprit or if Maxim’s jumping to conclusions and is going to wind up feeling like smashing his head into a wall in a couple moments.

Two other mons, a Scraggy and an Impidimp had seemingly been waiting for the Pancham. Similar to the latter, they had matching hoods color coated to their respective mons. Maxim slowly touched down on an overhang, leaning in as close as he could without giving away his position.

The Scraggy spoke first in a young female’s voice. “Okay, Rodrick, we got everything together. Now what’s this big scheme o’ yours that dragged us back in here?”

“Alright Addie, you ain’t gonna believe this, but I pulled a fast one just now!” The Pancham grinned. He pulled out a brown bag and presented it. Maxim had to hold in a gasp, for there was no mistaking the sight of his own handbag.

Whelp, pickpocket confirmed. Even if I suppose that the typing and clothes with plenty of space to hide stuff below them kinda gave me reflexive vibes of “yeah, these are probably the culprits”.

“Woah! Did you really go and yank it off some poor sod? I didn’t think you’d go through with it!” Addie marveled, poking at the bag. Her Impidimp companion didn’t share the same enthusiasm.

Oh, this was an initiation, wasn’t it? Since based on Addie’s dialogue, it sounds like Rodrick is new at this whole ‘thieving’ thing.

“Hold up, hold up! You’re saying you stole it, yeah? What if the bloke figures out you’re the one who took it?” The Impidimp whimpered, his tone shrill and nasally. “We’ll get in real big trouble!”

… Maybe I jumped the gun with that read there. Since the Impidimp definitely vibes as not being used to being a thief.

Rodrick waved his paw in dismissal. “Don’t worry ‘bout it! The guards couldn’t find a Copperjah in a hayfield! At worst I’ll just drop it off at their office and claim I found it! Easy peasy!”

Cue Maxim angrily giving away his position in 3… 2…

“As long as you don’t wimp out as soon as you step in!” Addie teased.

“Hey! I told you I’m brave! This bag here proves it!” Roddrick fired back. “Let’s just figure out who’s gonna play what role today! I call being Stacks this time!”

Rodick” or “Roddick”? Either works, but make sure to keep the name spelling consistent one way or another.

Addie crossed her arms and scoffed. “Guess we’re gonna have to be the Gliscor Twins today, since Minnie and Tay are out. C’mon Lars! Get out the cloaks!”

Waaaaait, are these guys shapeshifters of some sort? Since how else do you just be ‘the Gliscor Twins’.

“Oh, alright. I’m better at playing the bad guy than Stacks anyway.” The Impidimp sulked.

He moved over to a corner and pulled out a box stuffed with fabric. Each mon took off their hoods and replaced them with a unique, homemade costume. The Scrafty and Impidimp both wore matching purple cloaks with long slender ears attached on the hoods. Meanwhile Rodrick wore a gray hood with two ears and a paper drill-shaped horn at the top. The Pancham tossed Maxim’s bag over to Lars, who stumbled trying to catch it.

… Or they could just use costumes. Even if I’m a little surprised that others fall for this.

“Oh yeah, let’s go! Now get into place so we can start!” Rodrick cheered.

Oh, so Pancham’s name is “Rodrick”. Duly noted, then.

Maxim tilted his head as he watched them spread out. His bag got stolen by a bunch of kids playing dress up? He’d be the laughingstock of the crew if this got out!

Just saying, Maxim. If Drake’s crew was like that, you’d already be the laughingstock of the crew by virtue of clearly not knowing what you’re doing. ^^;

Rodrick assumed a stance while pointing a finger. “Stop right there you conniving twins! Your misdeeds end here!”

Again, keep Rodrick’s name spelling consistent.

Addie reared back before unleashing a comically over the top laugh. “Muahahahaha! You don’t have a chance against us, Stacks! You may have knocked out our minions, but the two of us alone is more than enough!”

Maxim: “(... I can’t believe I seriously got mugged by a bunch of theater kid rejects. Seriously, Rene, how long does it take to catch up already?)”
803141280380485632.webp


Playfully gritting his teeth, Rodrick raised a fist. “We’ll see, you terrible twins! I’m kicking your bums out of this town! Haaah!”

He rushed forward, but froze as a shadow descended. Maxim dusted himself off before pointing a wing at the kid thief. “Hold, it you three! Playtime’s over!”

… I’m just realizing it, but the past few paragraphs have been written from an omniscient perspective. If this story is meant to be written from a third-person limited perspective, make sure that this whole exchange between Rodrick and the gang is written framed from the perspective of whatever Maxim would see while sneaking up on them, since the proverbial camera defocused from him for a bit.

Addie and Lars shot each other a look. “Who the heck is this? Did you invite someone else over to play, Rod?” Addie said.

“No- I uh, well uh, I dunno who this guy is!” The Pancham stammered with widening eyes.

Maxim: “Nice try, buddy. That’s my bag in your grubby little paws right now. Now fork it over.”
648431671401644032.webp


“You should know who I am.” Maxim sighed. “After all, you’re holding my bag. Or well, the Impidimp is.” Said mon shivered and dropped the bag to the ground. Rodrick’s jaw dropped.

“Ack! No way! I-I was careful and everything! N-no way you caught up!”

Maxim: “I can fly, genius. Also, you were literally running your mouth off about how you stole that bag not even two minutes ago!”
590253472188727333.webp


Maxim frowned. “But I did. The wings really help. Anyway, it’s time you give me that back. Now!”

Yeah, I figured “I can fly” would come up in the explanation. And time to see Maxim beat the snot out of a bunch of ankle-biters.

A few seconds passed as Rodrick only stared at Maxim. Then, the Pancham burst into tears.

“I’m sorry I’m sorry I’m sorry! I’ll give it back! Just please don’t tell on us!”

Can’t tell if real or if Fake Tears. Since just saying, that’s not exactly rare as a move.

“Y-yeah, what he said!” Lars chimed in, holding back tears. All Addie did was scoff and look away.

[ ] Maxim rubbed his temple and sighed. “ Didn’t think I’d feel this bad about stopping a would-be thief.”

I think that Maxim needs a bit more of a transition for his mood before he has an “ugh” moment there.

“Alright, calm down. I just want my bag back. I promise I won’t tell on you to the guards, as long as you don’t do this again.”

Rodrick quickly nodded. In between sobs he spoke again. “I promise!”

[ ] Finally reunited with his bag, Maxim attached it behind his scarf once again. Before he could fly away, his curiosity kicked in again.

I’ll admit, I did see what you kids were trying to do. Some sort of playtime was it? But why steal someone’s bag to serve as a prop?”

It probably makes sense to describe Maxim either picking up the bag or one of the kids giving it to him. Though wait, he could fly with that bag all this time? Why wasn’t he flying to get around the streets from the get-go, then?

[ ] All three children looked to one another. Rodrick waved for the other two to come close, then pulled them into a group embrace. A few seconds of whispering later, and Rodrick slowly approached Maxim.

You should probably mention more explicitly that Rodrick and Lars are calming down a bit more explicitly. Since in their last mention, they were pretty obviously crying, while there’s no real acknowledgement they stopped here.

“You ain’t from around here, yeah?”

Maxim nodded. Rodrick looked over his shoulder before continuing. “Well yah see, there’s some cool things about our island here that we learn from birth. You know that cave up there, just outside town? Used to be a bandit hideout and all, REAL bad guys stayed there.”

“Gliscor Cave? I went there just the other day.” Maxim said.

Cue the [bulbuhhh] reactions from these three in 3… 2…

“Yeah that’s right. Mum told me about how the mine was all used up and vacant, then these bad guys, led by Gliscor twins named Slash and Strike, came on a big fancy ship. They ransacked the town real bad.”

“Y-yeah! REAL bad!” Lars said.

Oh hey, it’s like that one sidequest from Torigoth in XB2. Just with fewer orphans involved.

Roddrick continued. “The governor at the time lived on the island, in a stone fortress just north of town. Of course, the villagers begged the governor for help, but the guy was a dummy! He couldn’t muster up enough guards to fight back! Then the bandits got bored and settled into that cave up there. Once they had their own hideout, they made things even worse by messing with anyone who visited the island! The village suffered a lot, with the bandits constantly taking food and valuables. Nobody was strong enough to tell em off, so things looked rough.” Rodrick’s head drooped down.

“At least until Stacks came in!” Addie cheered.

Rodrick’s dialogue is very, very long at the moment. I’d strongly recommend dividing it into two paragraphs.

Also, wow, this really is that one sidequest from Torigoth in XB2, huh? Since just saying, all of this basically describes how it plays out in the game minus the number of bandits involved.

Maxim raised a brow. “Stacks?”

Roddrick became starry-eyed at the mention. “That’s right! Stacks the Rhydon! He was a passing adventurer who had stopped by on pure chance! He saw how badly the bandits were treating the townspeople, and decided to step in! He kicked those bandits right of town, then rallied everyone to take the fight to the bandits’ hideout! There was an epic battle as Stacks took on the dangerous duo of Slash and Strike by himself, and knocked them both out!.” The Pancham punched and kicked the air.

Okay, so did Stacks sound more like Al Weaver or Fergus O’Donnell when he showed up? Since “actively bullying the main town” aside, this almost literally describes that one Torigoth sidequest from an outsider’s perspective. /s

“With the two of them down, Calvin Village was freed of the bandits for good! Things only got better from there, as Stacks even helped to boot that lousy governor! Thanks to him, Calvin Island would grow bigger and better than before! If you wonder how our ports got to being so active, you can thank him!”

Okay, Stacks is confirmed as the in-setting Rexpy at this rate. Now I’ll have to keep an eye out to see if he got up to exploits on some of the other islands that we’ll see in this story.

So this Stacks guy was a real-life folk hero? Interesting. Maxim thought. I can respect them wanting to keep a tradition going, but did they have to steal my bag for that at least?

Well, that and your writer getting in a few giggles with media references. Probably. Maybe. We’ll see as this story plays out more down the road.

“So there yah got it! Isn’t that cool as all heck? We even made our own Stacks cloak!” Roddrick beamed, holding up the horned cloak.

[ ] Maxim sighed. “That’s nice…but don’t try and get others involved next time! Stealing other’s belongings can get you into serious trouble!”

[ ]

“I told him it was a silly idea.” Addie groaned. “He wanted to be ‘brave’ and prove he wasn’t a scaredy-meowth. Fat lot of good it did us.”

I feel like you’re missing a couple opportunities to show off some character reactions and body language here.

“Hey! So what if it was stupid! I showed you I got serious guts!” Rodrick fired back.

Yeah, no, buddy. I remember how you devolved into a blubbering wreck 30 seconds after getting accosted for that bag, just saying.

“Serious guts? More like foolish bravery! Hahaha!”

The correct term is ‘empty bravado’, just saying.

Maxim flinched at the familiar voice coming from behind him. As he turned around, he came face to face with Hurik the Combusken.

Maxim: “Wait, Hurik? Just how long have you been here?” ·^·

“Well will you look at that? How’s it going, Maxim?” Hurik said.

Maxim nodded towards Roddrick. “Hello! I was just having a chat with these kids about staying away from risky things.”

“Were you now? Don’t worry, I heard everything!” The adventurer cheered. All three children gasped in horror.

Rodrick et al:
401074476474957834.webp

Maxim: “Er… well, I wasn’t the one who said anything about this? So at least I kept my end of the bargain.”
401076862924750848.webp


Hurik quickly waggled a claw. “Ah ah ah! I won’t tell! But you gotta make sure you keep that promise and stay out of trouble, you three!”

“S-sure thing, Mr. Adventurer!” Roddrick stammered. “In fact, we were just about to head back home! Isn’t that right, chums?” His companions nodded back. “See yah!”

With that, the trio shoved their cloaks back into a box and then ran out of the square. Hurik crossed his arms as he watched them slip away.

Those kids sure are something?” He chuckled.

Maxim: “Hurik, why are you even here right now?” >v>;
Hurik: “I mean, you were kinda hard to miss just flying around above the rooftops.” ^v^

“Yeah, you can say that.” Maxim said. “Had to admit, the history behind that Stacks guy did sound interesting. Wonder what became of him?”

The smile on Hurik’s face twisted into a frown, and the look in his eyes darkened. “This town is kind, very kind. But they’re also rather…naive to their own history.”

Well, might have jumped the gun on Stacks being a Rexpy with Hurik’s mood taking that sort of turn there.

“Naive?”

Hurik nodded. “Often over time, history can be romanticized. The tale of Calvin Town is one such example. Stacks did help to save the town, that’s true, but the backstory behind it is heavily glossed over.”

The Combusken leaned in. “You see, Stacks didn’t come here on a whim. He knew the whole time what was going on. The reason why is because he was a bandit himself.”

Well then. Though I suppose that’s one way to get remembered in history better than you deserve to be.

Shock coursed through Maxim. “You’re kidding me!”

“Nope. It’s the truth. You see, decades after the event, a report was dug up from the office of the old governor Karka, who had been sitting in office at the time. Stacks was a member of the bandits who grew dissatisfied with them,” Hurik explained. “Karka, seeking a way to mitigate losses and property destruction, cut a deal with him to help overthrow the twins and run them out of town. Needless to say, it succeeded. However, Stacks would use his popular influence to paint Karka as incompetent, eventually causing him to be removed as governor.”

I mean, just saying, if Karka had to resort to cutting a deal with a bandit to get rid of his bandit problems, he probably deserved that reputation of being incompetent.

“That’s crazy.. How did you even find out about all this?” Maxim questioned.

“I was curious about this island’s history, so I did a bit of my own research. Quite the controversial subject isn’t it? If you tried to give this information to the residents, they’d deny it to the last breath.” Hurik mused. “It’s been a tale of theirs for decades. No amount of knowledge would ever make them change their views.”

I mean, casually blowing up the pedestal that a beloved folk hero stands on does sound like it’d get contentious with the general public. Even if it makes me wonder if there’s other figures in this setting that this also applies to.

Maxim reluctantly nodded. He did have a point, going by how much those three children adored the story. A folk tale ingrained as a child for decades upon decades. No way the residents would change that if a bunch of outsiders told them to.

Maxim: “... Actually, are you an outsider to this island, Hurik? Since I don’t think the story’s ever said that one way or the other.” ^v^;

Hurik placed a claw on his hip. “Ah well, I’m not one to dash the fun of kids, even naughty ones! I’ve got more important business to attend to! Thanks for another chat, Maxim!”

With that, Hurik walked out of the alleyway. Right as he left into the main road, the blue rings of a certain Umbreon peaked just out of sight.

Oh, hello, Hurik’s partner whose name I’m forgetting right now.

Right as Maxim rejoined the main road, Rene caught up to him. [ ] “There you are, you featherbag! What were you thinking just jetting off without me? You got any idea how many streets I had to fly down?!”

[ ]
“Ah, I’m sorry! I really had to get my bag back!” Maxim said. “I promise I won’t ditch you like that again!”

It probably makes sense to show off a bit more character reaction from Rene and Maxim right now, especially since Rene is very obviously crabby at the moment, but it’s very heavily implicit right now from her dialogue.

His apology did little to quell her anger. “Whatever, you can make it up to me when we train. I’m not gonna pull my punches this time!

Maxim let out a loud gulp. “N-noted!”

Live look at that training session later:

7c23fdf66ffee096e314bfa10b499828.gif


After hastily eating a pastry from a local bakery, as Rene didn’t want him to fight on an empty stomach, Maxim found himself back at the cave’s entrance. There was just one problem stopping them from going in, a hastily constructed barricade with a red X painted on wood.

“Tsk, what the hell? Who’s tryin’ to seal off the entrance?” Rene complained.

I mean… you could just break it down, just saying.
476581281094828033.webp


“Maybe the guards are worried about the security of the mines? It’s looked pretty old and worn when we were inside yesterday,” Maxim noted.

Rene scoffed. “Pff. That place is a lot more secure than half of the caves I’ve ever seen. Held up pretty well while we were bouncing around.”

I’d say that the guards put two and two together and didn’t want anyone else to go poking around, but that does seem like a peculiar amount of effort to put into things when they were perfectly happy to leave Gliscor Cave open all this time beforehand.

[ ]

“Well what are we gonna do now?”

Maxim, why are you not just shrugging things off about how you’re not going to be subjected to Rowlet Rugby as Rene vents steam over the way you kept her running around earlier today? ^^;

“I can’t just tear the barricade down. The guards’ll whine to the crew. But…” A smile crept onto her face. “They should ‘av thought long n’ hard about sealin’ the other places!” She leaped above the barricade, grabbed onto a bundle of vines, and vaulted her way up.

Whelp, I suppose we’re going to find out as to if there was a reason this place was sealed off really, really quickly.

Maxim looked on, bewildered. “Wait a moment, what are you doing?”

“If they’re gonna block that entrance, I’m just gonna go through one of the ‘eyes’! Easy peasy!”

Rene, don’t make me bust out Bubsy again here.

She swung her paws in an arcing motion, cutting through scores of vine. Looking down at Maxim, she motioned him to come up. The Rowlet sighed and flew toward her. The upper level of the cave felt tighter to navigate with how small the tunnels were. The air was much colder and drier, causing making Maxim to shudder.

“Looks like they didn’t change a thing! Lazy moppets just put a lock on the door and called it a day! Oh well, let’s get ready to scrap!”

Yeah, I’m not convinced that this is going to end well, just saying.

She raised her fists which began to glow with energy. Crouching into a stance, she waited for Maxim to make a move.

Rene: “Well? Come at me, featherbag.”
1182600698228121661.webp

Maxim:
laughter-worried.gif


“HAAAAAAH!”

Dirt and dust was thrown shot into the air as Rene and Maxim continued their training session. Despite his partner’s aggressive attacks, he was pleasantly surprised to discover he was getting better with dodging. He also was starting to trade blows too, from pecking Rene on her shoulder or flinging more energy coated feathers into her side. Unfortunately, his partner was far more experienced in combat, and had the resilience to prove it. By the time the two had backed away again, he was out of breath compared to her unfazed glare.

I kinda wonder if we should’ve seen a bit more of the “last blow” between these two. Not that it doesn’t make sense to bust out a summary to fast forward the half hour or whatever these two spent throwing down with each other, but things do feel a little “informed attribute” in the absence of concrete examples.

“Heh, you’re starting to get a bit better with this. That’s more like it!” Rene exclaimed.

“Th-thanks, those blows of yours are no joke though!” He wheezed.

The Mienfoo crossed her arms. “Eh, how ‘bout we take a small break? Too early for you to be faintin’, now!”

Maxim: “Too early?! I thought we were almost done!”
554513872514449424.webp


“Thanks!” Maxim said, dropping on his back. “I’m feeling a bit lightheaded.”

He swallowed an Oran berry lobbed at him, a sigh of relief coming out as the fruit’s rejuvenating energy washed over.

That’s the good stuff!” He cheered.

The two rested on the cold cave floor with only the sound of dripping water as company. Then, another noise began to echo from the main tunnel. The sound grew loud enough for Maxim to realize what it was: two voices having a conversation.

Oh, well that’s not ominous or worrisome at all there. /s

“Hey, do you hear that? It almost sounds like-”

He didn’t get to finish as Rene quickly rushed over and put a paw over his beak. Before he could protest again, she dragged the Rowlet behind a jagged rock formation. Her grip was tight enough to render his frantic flaps useless.

Rene: “(Keep your wings still, Maxim! You’ll give us away with that racket!)” O_O;

“Calm down for a minute! You’ll make too much noise!” She hissed in a low whisper. She craned her head around to look through a gap in the rocks. The voices started to get closer and closer, becoming clear enough to make out words.

“Stay.. here.. Long time..”

“Closed cave.. Nobody here.. We’re free..”

“This should b.. the place!”

“Alright, let’s get started!”

Okay, yeah, I’ll heavily take the under on those two being here for legitimate purposes given how cloak and dagger everything is at the moment.

Maxim paused at the last line. The voice sounded very familiar.

“Guess those guards aren’t so worthless after all, if a little rope and wood is a good enough ward! This island’s all too easy to comply!”

“That’s good though! I had my hunch things would work out this way, and they have so far! But let’s not get overly cocky, Celene.

Wait a minute, have I seen that name before, or-

Maxim’s blood froze in his veins. There was no mistaking it, that was Hurik’s voice! Both him and Celene were having a private meeting. The clearing became illuminated in yellow light as Maxim could hear the sound of crackling flames.

Oh. Right. That’s the name of that Umbreon on Hurik’s team. Though what on earth are those two doing here?

Also, nifty art accompanying this moment. Even if I wonder what that banner in the background is.

“Remember, we have to keep things going for at least another day or two. Don’t go blowing our cover, especially with those privateers lurking about.” Hurik growled.

Uh… if they’re talking about a ‘cover’, that sounds like these two aren’t exactly the adventurers they presented themselves to be. :copyka:

Which is starting to give me some ideas as to how Hurik knew that Stacks was a bandit himself.

Maxim could feel the bleeding animosity in his voice, a far cry from the cheerful fellow he talked with only earlier. Just who were these two?

“Just another reason for us to hurry up and finish our business on this damn island!” Spat Celene spat. “I dunno why the captain bothered to send us out here, does he really not have faith in us?”

“I can’t say. Crafty mon, he is. But don’t worry, once we finish this job, it’s smooth sailing from here on. Now let’s discuss what you’ve found out here.”

Okay, these two are totally pirates skulking around in a guise, I can already tell.

Their conversation went on for quite some time. Their voices faded in and out as they talked about different subjects and aspects of the island and its daily life. The conversation then wrapped around to its original subject.

“That about does it. We’ll stay one more day, then report our findings to the crew. I’ll have Morris meet us at Umbrella Forest tomorrow night, and we’ll compound our findings together. Does that work for you?” Hurik asked.

Celene let out a snort. “Good enough. I’ll be glad to stretch my legs anywhere else. I’m not big on playing pretend, and this place bores me to tears! Let’s just make sure that blubbering rookie didn’t go and spill his guts in the soldier’s barracks.”

Okay, yeah, I’m feeling good about that prediction there. Though ‘rookie’? As in one of those kids that Maxim ran into, or…?

Though Maxim and Rene have both been really quiet right now. I wonder if it would make sense for there to be a bit more internal thought process for Maxim wondering just what on earth is going on with Hurik and Celene at the moment since they’re very obviously not who they presented themselves as when they first met.

“Noted. Let’s leave, Celene.”

“Celene?”


Oh, she knows they’re here right now, doesn’t she?

“Hello, Celene? What are you doing?”

Celene let out a few sniffs before addressing Hurik. “You don’t smell that? A fresh scent, like someone’s here?”

Rene: “(Um, Maxim? I think that we should get going now.)”
1182600715890339900.webp


[ ]

“Nope, not at all.” Hurik huffed. “Sure you’re not picking on something from the other day? Think the guards mentioned that some privateers had visited here.”

“I know what I’m talking about!” Celene hissed. “I can tell there’s something here! Just got to find it.”

Maxim’s pulse began to race. He dared not move, otherwise the Umbreon’s suspicions would be confirmed. A wave of dread washed over him as he wondered what would happen if the two found out they were here. Rene had crouched to the ground to minimize her presence. If she was also worried, she was hiding it.

I kinda wonder if Maxim should also have a reaction to the initial “oh, they know we’re here” moment, since you’d think that that would also get him nice and nervous about what’s going on and what’ll happen if Hurik and Celene find them.

The echoing of paws on the rocky floor began to grow louder.

And louder.

And louder.

“CELENE!”

Well, that’s quite a cliffhanger to leave off on there. Even if I kinda wonder if Maxim’s thought process as Celene closes in should be a bit more played up, especially if he’s starting to feel trapped or helpless.

Alright, made it to the end. I’ll admit, I wasn’t expecting things to take that turn towards the end of things given how slow and relaxed the chapter was, but I’m not complaining. The characterization once again is the main star of the show in this chapter, both the new faces that we get to meet like Abel, Hestia, and Rodrick’s gang, along with the older faces we got to find out a bit more about like Hurik and Celene… who there’s no way they’re just normal upstanding adventurers with what we saw of them in that last scene before the chapter outro. The backstory folklore surrounding Stacks was also fun to see, both its on-the-face narrative, as well as the deeper twist that Hurik reveals to Maxim later on. It was a nice thematic parallel to the way that we got to discover that Hurik and Celene aren’t as simple as what their initial story presented themselves as.

That said, there were some areas where I thought there was some room for improvement. Aside from the obligatory reminder to fix your spacing on this version of your story, there’s some issues in a couple parts with information that’s being “told” instead of “shown” and as a result feels like something that’s more of an informed attribute instead of something we concretely see play out. You also have some issues with some parts being underdescribed, which either makes it hard to visualize what’s going on, or else causes major details to wind up feeling like they’re coming out of nowhere later. It’s especially noticeable for moments where Maxim’s inner thought process basically bows out in a couple places where you’d think it’d be particularly active. There were also a couple of moments feel like the logic is a bit of a stretch, the main standout is the moment where Maxim sticks along the ground while following Rene through town… and then promptly starts flying around when his bag gets yoinked. If there’s a reason why he wasn’t just staying airborne the entire time, it probably makes sense to spell out why he did that a bit more explicitly.

But all-in-all, I thought that this was a pretty good chapter @Z102eternal . The earlier parts initially made me think it was a little filler-y, only for that twist at the end to come around and catch me off-guard. I don’t know when the next time I’ll get another chapter under my belt will be, but I’ll be looking forward to it.

Hope the feedback helped, and until next time!
 
Top Bottom