~Review of Chapters 1 – 8~
Why hello there
I’m here for the Blec Review Awards, and originally wanted to make this on the 31st, but that didn’t happen so this is a few days late. Sorry :unownf:
I know you’ve been working on this for a while, and now that it has enough chapters for me to get a good grip on everything happening I think I have a good idea of what this fic’s all about! Which starts with all the Final Fantasy references, because there’s a lot.
I think it mostly comes down to names—Yuna, Cid, Seifer, and Bahamut are all FF characters/running names, and I’m iffy on whether Noctum is a port of Noctis or if he’s just that way because his scales are black. And also the legendary birds are named after Guardian Summons. Some components of the plot may also be FF references—You are probably never going to convince me that Horizon Academy bears no relation to Balamb Garden, and I’m pretty sure Polaris/Ether can be equated to Shinra Corp and Mako (Or maybe that globe city thing from FFXIII?). The Aeons could also be an Al Bhed parallel, although that one I’m kind of iffy on. I’m also interested to see if you’ll be borrowing any components from the FF plots to make up this one – does Horizon Academy have a built in defense system like Balamb Garden? The Phantom has clear ties to the Ether—maybe his backstory is similar to, say, Sephiroth’s? I’m like 90% sure those legendary birds the Phantom took over are going to be used like the guardian summons they’re named after later on—will we see something similar from Yuna’s side of the equation, especially considering the character she’s named after?
Also, Nickit Carpaccio and Greedent could have been Biggs and Wench. Big missed opportunity tbh
But past all the obvious references and the fact that Vegna’s class is clearly taken straight from Ace Attorney, the real vibes I get from Path of Valor are Harry Potter. More specifically the Goblet of Fire—rising darkness in the background, foreign transfer students arriving at a magical academy, and a school-wide tournament are all components that this fic and that book share, and IMO the tone’s a bit more on par with GoF than it is with FF… if you ignore that it’s clearly high fantasy with fictional creatures in a world where this is the norm, but the vibe isn’t really FF to me is my point. Probably didn’t help matters that when we got to the opening event of the Crowne Cup, it was a maze just like the finale of the Triwzard Tournament. Granted, a much less eldritch maze, but even so
But tbh I think the Hogwarts vibe really works for Horizon Academy. I’d like to see all the ways a pokemon-run magic academy would differ from ours—more creative classes like Vegna’s, more petty dragon VS fairies rivalry, more interactions with other students like Yuna and Shimmer, etc. I’d also be interested in seeing more named students. Even if they’re one-note and don’t really do much outside of exist (like the ones in Harry Potter), it’d go a long way in making the academy seem lived in. Since right now what we have is pretty much Yuna, Chiaki, and Nikki VS Shimmer, Xander, and that other flunky I can’t remember the name of now. We need set extras!
If there was one thing I had to ding Path of Valor for, it’s that I’m very much more interested in one plot than I am the other. It’s like reading two separate books: On one side we have this small school drama thing where it’s Dragons VS Fairies and the stakes are winning or losing a sports competition, and on the other hand we have this epic plot with distortions, ether, political unrest in the Fairy parliament, and a mysterious Phantom wreaking havoc on the borders of both kingdoms. The school plot is mostly what I’m here for—Partly because it’s the A plot, but also because it has all the interesting characters and a conflict that I can attach to. Yuna is a fish (dragon?) out of water in a place she isn’t wanted, and there are kinds of personalities around to coax out the conflict surrounding that, as well as worldbuilding tidbits and plain fun scenes. The phantom plot is filled with assholes like Seifer, mysterious enigmas like Chancellor Vortex, and the Phantom and his flunkies haven’t done enough here for me to take an interest in his apparent villainy yet. It also clashes a bit in that we can jump from Noctum and Baraz being discriminated against and then having to fight off a distortion monster to Yuna and Shimmer being paired together for a cartoony ace-attorney class assignment. That’s not to say that they’re completely distilled, though—there’s very clearly larger darkness floating around in the schoolyard plot, and everything that’s going on in the Phantom plot is directly related to Horizon Academy, so it’s clear that you’re planning to merge the two soon. I just think that they should be blended together a bit more smoothly going forward/merge somewhat soon.
I’d also be remiss if I didn’t address the Crowne Cup! To be completely honest, for something that’s been built up as a big thing, I felt like the first event came pretty quickly and then was a bit of a letdown. I’m also not really clear on the details—how many events are there going to be? How many teams are there competing? I do hope it’s not completely out of the picture or regulated to the background, even if Yuna’s team was disqualified from the first event. Probably going a bit overboard with the HP comparisons here, but I’d like to see more exotic events with big buildup over the course of the cup’s duration, like the Triwizard Tournament had. Not to mention that these are pokemon we’re talking here, not boring old humans—IMO you should throw the most exotic/far out there stuff you have for future events. Take us on field trips to locations outside Horizon Academy, rearrange the school for challenges, maybe even try more unique challenges like an art/song/dance competition or a battle royale! Even if it looks like the Crowne Cup is a front for the real plot, I’d be disappointed if it fell to the wayside or went on in the background.
Wow, looks like Shimmer isn’t nearly as nice as his stage name suggests… I have no doubt he’s cheating tbh; it fits with his lackadaisical personality and would explain both why he didn’t know about the badge and why he’s so confident about winning the trial in a week. However, he does seem to know some stuff about the court, so I feel like ‘he’s a dirty cheat’ isn’t all there is to it.
Also, what is it with this fic and nasty horses? First Seifer, and now Shimmer…
Not sure what’s up with Dermerzel, tbh. He’s portrayed as Definitely The Villain and cunning in the prologue, and even though he’s perfectly kind here and the only one to treat Noctum and Baraz with any kind of respect when they meet I still get the impression that he’s not entirely what he appears—especially since he chose to read Vortex’s mind when they conversed. That tells me that at the very least, he doesn’t trust Vortex. Which doesn’t say too much to his allegiance, considering that Vortex is pretty darn shady and also a posh douche, but clearly he’s not patriotic to Horizon, even if he holds a top position there.
One of the clear themes here is discrimination, and we see it here with no punches pulled—on a schoolyard level, with Yuna and all her non-fairy students characterized as weak, villainous, and a bother to keep around, and on a background level with it being shown that the Aeons were driven into the mountains and don’t have access to the advanced Ether tech that the Horizon inhabitants do, and on a serious level with Noctum and Baraz being thrown around like they’re worthless and the overall elitist attitude of the fairies. Looking at it, pretty much every non-fairy in this fic is either cast in an unglamourous light or in a servant’s position (except for Seifer, but I guess he has exempt status or something?) Chiaki and the Radiant Beacon are unpopular and likely have assassins or hoodlums on their tail, Nikki is seen as the resident trouble student, Carpaccio and Greedent are beggars who turned to thieving and are trying to look cool (if the Phantom is to be believed), and anyone from Aeon is immediately hated. Meanwhile the fairies kind of just get free rides everywhere—as shown by Shimmer apparently cheating and getting away with it. I think it illustrates what societal discrimination looks like pretty well, and does an even better job of putting us in the shoes of those being discriminated against—what Yuna goes through isn’t necessarily pleasant, but watching Noctum and Baraz get shoved around and treated like trash breaks my heart ;-;
I also wonder what was going on with the song that made Yuna spazz out—I’m going to assume that had something to do with the Ether? Either that, or receiving a vision of Bahamut, which I could see, but I don’t get how a song composed by a nation that is actively Anti-Bahamut would trigger that. And speaking of visions, not sure what the five-headed dragon in Phantom’s visions is—outside of it presumably being "Natus", the only multi-headed dragon/dragon-like pokemon I can think of is Hydreigon, and that’s only got three heads. Also, no clue what's up with that weird pokemon that I'm pretty sure is either Null or Silvally at this point.
As for the characters… The kids/teens I don’t have much to say about currently. The ones I’m most interested in are Yuna and Shimmer, and seeing how they’ll work together, but it would be cool if Chiaki and Nikki stuck around and took a Ron + Hermione position to Yuna. Yuna herself reminds me a lot of Harry Potter—there’s not too much there right now, but that’s okay because she’s out of her element and she’ll grow and learn as we do. Shimmer gives me Malfoy vibes, all the way down to the rich backing, the snobbish attitude, and that he seems to have his own personal Crabbe and Goyle following him around, although I hope he’s a bit less villainous than Malfoy turned out to be. I think the HP comparisons end with the students, though—Chancellor Vortex is no Dumbledore and Prof Vegna has a shady backstory but isn’t mean enough to be Snape. I guess Cid is comparable to Flitwick? Kinda? IDK tbh
Wonder what Nikki’s hiding, especially since she has those one-of-a-kind goggles and is here on a government official’s payroll >.> Must be something big, since I don’t think she’s the bratty type to be a trouble student at an academy few get the privilege to attend for no reason.
This didn't quite make sense to me?
If this is the same Bahamut as the one in BLC, I’d imagine his last reaction would be to laugh :V
Pretty sure this is supposed to be “Crowne Cup”
Overall, this is a really well-written and entertaining romp so far! It drew me in pretty quickly and I never really felt too confused even though there’s a thousand things flying around at any given time. I also really like the dark Harry Potter vibe this fic has going, along with an in-depth look at how those that are perceived as “lesser” for whatever reason are treated. I’m looking forward to watching Yuna and co. grow as the fic progresses, and seeing what the Crowne Cup has to offer—as well as seeing more Horizon curriculum, which—if Vegna is anything to go by—is actually pretty hands-on and cool, and eventually finding out what the Phantom’s all about when he finally makes a move and reveals more about himself.
Thanks for the read, and I can tell you’re putting a lot of effort into this!
~SparklingEspeon
Listening to: JoJo
Why hello there
I’m here for the Blec Review Awards, and originally wanted to make this on the 31st, but that didn’t happen so this is a few days late. Sorry :unownf:
I know you’ve been working on this for a while, and now that it has enough chapters for me to get a good grip on everything happening I think I have a good idea of what this fic’s all about! Which starts with all the Final Fantasy references, because there’s a lot.
I think it mostly comes down to names—Yuna, Cid, Seifer, and Bahamut are all FF characters/running names, and I’m iffy on whether Noctum is a port of Noctis or if he’s just that way because his scales are black. And also the legendary birds are named after Guardian Summons. Some components of the plot may also be FF references—You are probably never going to convince me that Horizon Academy bears no relation to Balamb Garden, and I’m pretty sure Polaris/Ether can be equated to Shinra Corp and Mako (Or maybe that globe city thing from FFXIII?). The Aeons could also be an Al Bhed parallel, although that one I’m kind of iffy on. I’m also interested to see if you’ll be borrowing any components from the FF plots to make up this one – does Horizon Academy have a built in defense system like Balamb Garden? The Phantom has clear ties to the Ether—maybe his backstory is similar to, say, Sephiroth’s? I’m like 90% sure those legendary birds the Phantom took over are going to be used like the guardian summons they’re named after later on—will we see something similar from Yuna’s side of the equation, especially considering the character she’s named after?
But past all the obvious references and the fact that Vegna’s class is clearly taken straight from Ace Attorney, the real vibes I get from Path of Valor are Harry Potter. More specifically the Goblet of Fire—rising darkness in the background, foreign transfer students arriving at a magical academy, and a school-wide tournament are all components that this fic and that book share, and IMO the tone’s a bit more on par with GoF than it is with FF… if you ignore that it’s clearly high fantasy with fictional creatures in a world where this is the norm, but the vibe isn’t really FF to me is my point. Probably didn’t help matters that when we got to the opening event of the Crowne Cup, it was a maze just like the finale of the Triwzard Tournament. Granted, a much less eldritch maze, but even so
But tbh I think the Hogwarts vibe really works for Horizon Academy. I’d like to see all the ways a pokemon-run magic academy would differ from ours—more creative classes like Vegna’s, more petty dragon VS fairies rivalry, more interactions with other students like Yuna and Shimmer, etc. I’d also be interested in seeing more named students. Even if they’re one-note and don’t really do much outside of exist (like the ones in Harry Potter), it’d go a long way in making the academy seem lived in. Since right now what we have is pretty much Yuna, Chiaki, and Nikki VS Shimmer, Xander, and that other flunky I can’t remember the name of now. We need set extras!
If there was one thing I had to ding Path of Valor for, it’s that I’m very much more interested in one plot than I am the other. It’s like reading two separate books: On one side we have this small school drama thing where it’s Dragons VS Fairies and the stakes are winning or losing a sports competition, and on the other hand we have this epic plot with distortions, ether, political unrest in the Fairy parliament, and a mysterious Phantom wreaking havoc on the borders of both kingdoms. The school plot is mostly what I’m here for—Partly because it’s the A plot, but also because it has all the interesting characters and a conflict that I can attach to. Yuna is a fish (dragon?) out of water in a place she isn’t wanted, and there are kinds of personalities around to coax out the conflict surrounding that, as well as worldbuilding tidbits and plain fun scenes. The phantom plot is filled with assholes like Seifer, mysterious enigmas like Chancellor Vortex, and the Phantom and his flunkies haven’t done enough here for me to take an interest in his apparent villainy yet. It also clashes a bit in that we can jump from Noctum and Baraz being discriminated against and then having to fight off a distortion monster to Yuna and Shimmer being paired together for a cartoony ace-attorney class assignment. That’s not to say that they’re completely distilled, though—there’s very clearly larger darkness floating around in the schoolyard plot, and everything that’s going on in the Phantom plot is directly related to Horizon Academy, so it’s clear that you’re planning to merge the two soon. I just think that they should be blended together a bit more smoothly going forward/merge somewhat soon.
I’d also be remiss if I didn’t address the Crowne Cup! To be completely honest, for something that’s been built up as a big thing, I felt like the first event came pretty quickly and then was a bit of a letdown. I’m also not really clear on the details—how many events are there going to be? How many teams are there competing? I do hope it’s not completely out of the picture or regulated to the background, even if Yuna’s team was disqualified from the first event. Probably going a bit overboard with the HP comparisons here, but I’d like to see more exotic events with big buildup over the course of the cup’s duration, like the Triwizard Tournament had. Not to mention that these are pokemon we’re talking here, not boring old humans—IMO you should throw the most exotic/far out there stuff you have for future events. Take us on field trips to locations outside Horizon Academy, rearrange the school for challenges, maybe even try more unique challenges like an art/song/dance competition or a battle royale! Even if it looks like the Crowne Cup is a front for the real plot, I’d be disappointed if it fell to the wayside or went on in the background.
Wow, looks like Shimmer isn’t nearly as nice as his stage name suggests… I have no doubt he’s cheating tbh; it fits with his lackadaisical personality and would explain both why he didn’t know about the badge and why he’s so confident about winning the trial in a week. However, he does seem to know some stuff about the court, so I feel like ‘he’s a dirty cheat’ isn’t all there is to it.
Also, what is it with this fic and nasty horses? First Seifer, and now Shimmer…
Not sure what’s up with Dermerzel, tbh. He’s portrayed as Definitely The Villain and cunning in the prologue, and even though he’s perfectly kind here and the only one to treat Noctum and Baraz with any kind of respect when they meet I still get the impression that he’s not entirely what he appears—especially since he chose to read Vortex’s mind when they conversed. That tells me that at the very least, he doesn’t trust Vortex. Which doesn’t say too much to his allegiance, considering that Vortex is pretty darn shady and also a posh douche, but clearly he’s not patriotic to Horizon, even if he holds a top position there.
One of the clear themes here is discrimination, and we see it here with no punches pulled—on a schoolyard level, with Yuna and all her non-fairy students characterized as weak, villainous, and a bother to keep around, and on a background level with it being shown that the Aeons were driven into the mountains and don’t have access to the advanced Ether tech that the Horizon inhabitants do, and on a serious level with Noctum and Baraz being thrown around like they’re worthless and the overall elitist attitude of the fairies. Looking at it, pretty much every non-fairy in this fic is either cast in an unglamourous light or in a servant’s position (except for Seifer, but I guess he has exempt status or something?) Chiaki and the Radiant Beacon are unpopular and likely have assassins or hoodlums on their tail, Nikki is seen as the resident trouble student, Carpaccio and Greedent are beggars who turned to thieving and are trying to look cool (if the Phantom is to be believed), and anyone from Aeon is immediately hated. Meanwhile the fairies kind of just get free rides everywhere—as shown by Shimmer apparently cheating and getting away with it. I think it illustrates what societal discrimination looks like pretty well, and does an even better job of putting us in the shoes of those being discriminated against—what Yuna goes through isn’t necessarily pleasant, but watching Noctum and Baraz get shoved around and treated like trash breaks my heart ;-;
I also wonder what was going on with the song that made Yuna spazz out—I’m going to assume that had something to do with the Ether? Either that, or receiving a vision of Bahamut, which I could see, but I don’t get how a song composed by a nation that is actively Anti-Bahamut would trigger that. And speaking of visions, not sure what the five-headed dragon in Phantom’s visions is—outside of it presumably being "Natus", the only multi-headed dragon/dragon-like pokemon I can think of is Hydreigon, and that’s only got three heads. Also, no clue what's up with that weird pokemon that I'm pretty sure is either Null or Silvally at this point.
As for the characters… The kids/teens I don’t have much to say about currently. The ones I’m most interested in are Yuna and Shimmer, and seeing how they’ll work together, but it would be cool if Chiaki and Nikki stuck around and took a Ron + Hermione position to Yuna. Yuna herself reminds me a lot of Harry Potter—there’s not too much there right now, but that’s okay because she’s out of her element and she’ll grow and learn as we do. Shimmer gives me Malfoy vibes, all the way down to the rich backing, the snobbish attitude, and that he seems to have his own personal Crabbe and Goyle following him around, although I hope he’s a bit less villainous than Malfoy turned out to be. I think the HP comparisons end with the students, though—Chancellor Vortex is no Dumbledore and Prof Vegna has a shady backstory but isn’t mean enough to be Snape. I guess Cid is comparable to Flitwick? Kinda? IDK tbh
Wonder what Nikki’s hiding, especially since she has those one-of-a-kind goggles and is here on a government official’s payroll >.> Must be something big, since I don’t think she’s the bratty type to be a trouble student at an academy few get the privilege to attend for no reason.
Great, so the trespasser what a nutjob.
This didn't quite make sense to me?
"Oh no." Yuna's neck and chest constricted. Of course she'd get paired with that girl. At this point, Bahamut was probably rolling around the skies, roaring with laughter.
If this is the same Bahamut as the one in BLC, I’d imagine his last reaction would be to laugh :V
Grovyle groaned. "Lemme guess… nobody ever told you how the Crown Cup works."
Pretty sure this is supposed to be “Crowne Cup”
Overall, this is a really well-written and entertaining romp so far! It drew me in pretty quickly and I never really felt too confused even though there’s a thousand things flying around at any given time. I also really like the dark Harry Potter vibe this fic has going, along with an in-depth look at how those that are perceived as “lesser” for whatever reason are treated. I’m looking forward to watching Yuna and co. grow as the fic progresses, and seeing what the Crowne Cup has to offer—as well as seeing more Horizon curriculum, which—if Vegna is anything to go by—is actually pretty hands-on and cool, and eventually finding out what the Phantom’s all about when he finally makes a move and reveals more about himself.
Thanks for the read, and I can tell you’re putting a lot of effort into this!
~SparklingEspeon
Listening to: JoJo