I’m here from Catnip! It looks like this is a special episode one-shot in the the Journey-verse, and centering around Tobias, too! I’m interested to see your take on him, since he didn’t get a lot of characterization in the anime, so there’s a lot of places you can take him. It’s also suitably spooky for Halloween even if I’m a bit late for that. Anyway, onto thoughts!
Thoughts on Nightmare
Overall, while I do have my complaints, it’s not that I disagree with any of your plot decisions. I actually agree with all of them, I think I see what you were going for here. I just think the execution was lacking. Even still, I like the ideas at play, I like a lot of the imagery here, I like the tension in the story, and I’d say I still enjoyed my time with it! The Rainbow Rocket stinger really gets me more interested in your stuff if it’s something your going to continue to explore. I see the potential for stories in this setting, and I'd like to see more of it!
Thoughts on Nightmare
- So this is set in Alamos Town from Rise of Darkrai? That’s a neat decision! It makes sense to tie together the two times Darkrai appeared in the anime together like this. We even have some of the characters! Alberto is there,
Tonio is dead,and Alice gets to cameo later. You definitely seem to be going for a medieval vibe, with the way everyone talks and the reserved use of technology in this story, which does lend well to the kind of tone you seem to be going for here.
- A simple thing, but I like how you set up Darkrai and Tobias' relationship in the beginning here. I get the feeling that they just spend their time vibing here, and they both really value this, hence Darkrai's protectiveness when Alberto accuses him of murder.
- Our villain, Alter!Tobias appears! I liked the way you built up to him, with Tobias mistaking him for Darkrai at first. The time the story takes to reveal who he is is well spent both on making him threatening and on really establishing what Darkrai is capable of. And I love the imagery of these two shadows duking it out in the shadows cast by Tobias’ lantern. In general Darkrai’s powerset as it’s established in this one-shot is really cool and fitting. Really leans into the darkness theme well while also leaning hard into the ideas M10 brought forth regarding how Darkrai might work.
- There are some points where the prose feels a bit repetitive. It’s kind of hard to put a finger on, since most of the instances are hard fixes, but to give an idea of what I mean:
Of course, tonight's particular brand of darkness had a strange quality to it. It shifted and undulated, morphing in the scant light cast by the sleepy rural town. Sinister shadow crept into Alamos on the wind, visible against the backdrop of the stars.
Tobias rose from his chair on the porch of his small home on the edge of the cemetery. He sat out in the dark every night the weather permitted it. He liked the simplicity of the night and appreciated the constellations as he watched the sky. He even liked the clouds at night, though he privately dismayed that they blocked out the stars.
Tobias did not like this strange darkness that slunk through the sky and blotted out the night. He scowled at the unnatural darkness and knew that something terrible had come to Alamos.
A shadowed figure sat perched upon the roof of his home, watching the moon disappear behind the darkness of an all-consuming night. Tobias felt unease as a cold shiver ran down his spine.
They were dressed in all black and a casket was sat upon their shoulders. A small procession walked behind them, all clad in black with their faces covered.
Cynthia gasped and bowed her head in reverence. She fell to her knees and lowered her voice in reverence.
- That isn't to say that every instance of repetition in this story doesn't work. I mentioned that I do think it makes sense to focus so much on the darkness due to the theming, and there are some passages where the repetition really works:
Darkrai knew at once that he had to rescue his friend. He knew that he would fall back into shadow and death without Tobias and he did not want to. He looked back at the small house, ignoring the corpses strewn about the path. He would save his friend. Darkrai would not fall. Not now, not ever again. He had a friend once more. He would save his friend.
- Darkrai gets provoked, and in his rage kills a bunch of people! I feel a bit mixed about this. On one hand, I think this makes sense. Darkrai’s super stressed right now and really doesn’t want to deal with these guys, and it’s established that he’s very dangerous to others and depends on Tobias to act as his anchor and keep him grounded. And at this point we’re supposed to be drawing greater parallels between Alter!Tobias and our main duo. Of course Darkrai’s mistakes would lead to problems later on, and of course Alter!Tobias would be the one to take advantage of them. But on the other hand, it was hard to feel that in the moment. Like, there was setup that led to this, and it sets up for something later on, but it doesn’t quite feel like it comes together. I think it’s because overall I’m wanting to see how this fits into Darkai’s arc, but the story doesn’t really dwell on this for as much as I’d like. The zombies end up being more of a backdrop to the climax than anything else and the idea that Darkrai is haunted by this is only acknowledged one more time, and it makes this scene feel inconsequential. It should be a big moment for his character that sets up for something important, but that “something” ends up being glossed over in the climax in favor of Tobias stuff. I don't know if I communicated that well, it was a bit hard to put into words, but it might make more sense later.
- We presumably meet Alice again for a short moment (I’m not sure why she’s here though), and then learn that Alter!Tobias’ goal is Oracion. It’s an interesting goal to shoot for, and plays into the M10 theming even harder, which I like. There’s this driving question of why he’s after Oracion, especially given that Tobias doesn’t seem to know what it is. At first I wasn’t sure what you were going for, but looking back now I think I like the way it was handled. We learn in the ending this is just a small part of a grander scheme, and the feeling that we don’t even know what Alter!Tobias actually wants lends to that intrigue really well. Like there’s something larger at play behind the scenes that could be motivating him.
- Damn, you really don’t like Alberto, huh?! We reach the climax, and things do get pretty tense! I did already say that the zombies feel like a backdrop for the most part, but for what it’s worth I do like the way they add to the stakes, I like how you described Alamos’ reaction to this, and the scenes here do have me hooked. I guess I just feel you could’ve done more with it, y’know?
- The Cynthia/Tobias relationship was an interesting direction. I like how Cynthia is to Tobias as Tobias is to Darkrai. Alter!Tobias happened because he lost his own anchor, and since Alter!Tobias was unhinged, Alter!Darkrai was also unhinged, leading to this. Again, I like the parallels you’re drawing here, they’re well done and help to get across the idea of them being two outcomes of the same character.
- The small tidbits of worldbuilding we get for Sinnoh plays into the medieval vibe, too. It does look like this is supposed to be modern day, just with a renaissance flair. The hints at wider politics with the Royal Congress and Cynthia being the Champion Queen seem like they mostly exist to establish some context behind Alter!Tobias’ outlook. I do wonder if this is expanded more in Journey proper, or if this is a separate universe in the wider multiverse and these are just quirks specific to it, but I guess I’m going to have to read more of Journey to find out!
- Cynthia borrows Cresselia’s power! I thought at first that they fused, but I think Cynthia is actually riding Cresselia? It is a little unclear, since I imagined it worked like Alter!Tobias’ fusion with Darkrai, but reading back it seems as if Cresselia is still separate. Still, I like all this as a climax, I think the moments just before build up to it pretty well and I like the descriptions used for the fight itself. The contrasting imagery feels powerful here, especially after how literally dark the rest of the story has been.
- Tobias fuses with Darkrai, and together they wish to sacrifice themselves to take Alter!Tobias down. Like the Darkrai scene earlier, I’m not sure how I feel about this, and I think here I can maybe put it into words a bit better. The crux of this one-shot is the parallel between Tobias, Darkrai, and their alter, and I’m starting to think that the real problem is a lack of development. Like, when Tobias says he can already feel the corrupting influence of power, I frankly don’t buy it. While Alter!Tobias is supposed to demonstrate that this is an aspect of Tobias’ character, this Tobias seems fairly well adjusted. His entire argument against Alter!Tobias is that he doesn’t need Darkai’s power, he just needs to be with him, to be together. And like, this highlights how Cynthia has had an effect on him and how her death really was the diverging point that caused their different paths, yet apparently in the end none of this matters? I still get you want to say that Tobias’ relationship with power is more complicated than that, but the story doesn’t set this up properly, the only setup we get revolves around Cynthia and making sense of the Alter. Maybe if another angle were established or something changes about his character to demonstrate how is he isn’t that different, I’d be able to make sense of his decision, but as is I’m not sold on it And with Darkrai, this is supposed to be his repentance for going feral and killing all those people earlier, and I guess I can see how his thoughts at the end of that scene are supposed to lead up to this? I mean he sure didn’t go back to shadow after THAT, that much is for sure! But it was established that this is why he relies on Tobias, and as I’ve stated, it doesn’t really feel like the story cares all that much about what he did in that scene. When I said earlier I felt you could’ve done more with the zombies, I mean it in that I feel you should've done more with the zombies. The consequences of Darkrai’s nature are right there but nothing is done with it, it's just set dressing. It doesn’t complicate the characters, it doesn’t really complicate the plot, and it doesn’t sell Darkrai’s decision either. None of this is to say that their story can’t end this way, I can understand why it did, it’s more that it doesn’t really feel like this was where the story was going. I can only guess that Tobias himself ended up being the weak link here that caused him to believe this was the only way, maybe Darkrai’s angst is influencing his thoughts, and I guess we get hints that there’s more to the world that he dislikes and would want to use his power to destroy? But he knows it’s wrong, and I don’t see why he can’t separate. I just don’t see his or the story’s logic, and it feels like I’m supposed to see it.
- Okay, the reveal of the Rainbow Rocket stuff was really cool. I imagine this is meant to tie into the wider Journey-verse, but even besides that it’s just a neat stinger that answers all of the lingering questions left by Alter!Tobias. The idea that all of this was just one small part of Giovanni’s multiversal plan really plays into the Rainbow Rocket concept in an intriguing way. Like I never paid Rainbow Rocket that much mind before, but honestly you just sold me on the sheer potential of the idea and it makes me want to see more, dammit! Which I imagine was the intended effect!
It persisted in the chill that froze the morning few to the windows of his home.
"Much better," Tobias "I find that a nice tea often helps clear my mind and your mind seems especially troubled today."
She swallowed the lump in her throat. "how long do you have?"
Last edited: