Search results

[[Pano declined to offer an alternative vote to Shinji.]] [[Probably the same reason I did it as Jesse in Xmas and 2nd Anni. It's useful to town.]]

Retract Vote: MintyMimix @Inkedust

[[Gonna catch some shuteye and vote in the morning. Give me some compelling reasons, folks.]]

[[I think their playstyles are too unsynchronised for teammates, and I don't see any indication that they'd have been coordinating.]] [[If you tricked everyone intentionally, I'll be furiously impressed. I'll shake your hand, but also, crush your hand in doing so.]] [[I think tht's best...

CHARACTER SPECIES PLAYER SALEM'S THOUGHTS JACKIE'S THOUGHTS Loïc Mimikyu Sinderella He puts way too much effort into collecting information for everyone and figuring things out to be a killer! I'm pretty sure he's good. Pretty sure Sind's town. Diamond Sableye Seren He doesn't talk much...

[[Aight. Let's get to discussing the real votelist, since I'm not liking the Professor for one of our perps right now. Bigger readlist coming soon, I hope. I'm becoming... sleepy.]]

[[We have secured the extension. I summon Based @Inkedust to post the announcement.]]

[[As it happens, one of my strongest reasons for being suspicious of you was your insistence that people scumreading you were suspicious for targeting an innocent, without ever eating crow that you were wrong about Free. :P You're right now, of course. Nothing is ever certain except what you see...

[[Yes, I think Yellow's play is best explained by deliberately trying to stick to less-competitive catposting, whatever her alignment. Comparing it to previous play isn't that useful.]] [[Free is well-known to be one of the most experienced and genuinely incisive players in the community. She...

[[Oh lol yeah, that's right. Retract vote in case I crash for ages or something.]]

[[I'm pro-extension. I'm counting on windskull to make some bold analysis with the extension time. I will have time in the morning to make use of their analyses, and make a more informed vote.]] [[Therefore, @Inkedust, vote Minty. I intend to retract this the second we get an extension.]]

[[Call it learning from past mistakes. Also, it was after Humble Vale that I was introduced to the concept of 'dead air, dead town', a maxim that suggests if nobody cares about a townie getting nudged into a sacrifice, it means they're probably innocent.]]

[[Just finished looking over his posts. Combined with this gambit, I am now reading Minty as town with low-to-moderate confidence.]] "The Professor... I think he seems very much like a new, smart, but confused town player! I don't think I'm suspicious of him yet."

[[FASCINATING. Minty is trying to self-vote to extend. I would also like an extension, but it never occurred to me to try a self-vote. After all, if you're town, the only person you can know 100% for sure shouldn't be killed, is yourself. Town generally has good reason to try to extend, since it...

"I don't think Goomy Litno is part of the team of killers! I think they'd have more to offer than just readlists if they had secret meetings with other players, and that someone would have said something earlier to protect them... In a really small game, letting another killer get sacrificed...

[[While looking at these posts, I saw the word 'mastermind' come up a few times. I believe that most events in mafia are best explained by large sets of simple decisions made by a dozen confused people, not convoluted strategies. I believe that it's quite likely we have 2-3 mafia, who might have...

[[Took a look at Seren. Lots of flavour and not many posts total, but... It feels a lot like the townplay I saw from Seren in 2nd Anni, according to my gut. Putting him at just above 'null' in my reads. Worth keeping an eye on, would consider voting if someone spots an actual scumtell, but I'm...

[[Had a look over Wind's posts. Getting towny vibes, making a lot of observations I consider sensible, spotted that I might be a cop but said nothing, like a sensible person. Not hungry to lynch them.]]

[[Regarding ShinjiGojira: I'm unfamiliar with Gojira as they're a new participant with no play history, but I am reading them as slightly better than null. I don't detect an agenda in thier posting, and I think their decent-effort lists and scuh are an indication of trying to be useful with...

[[I don't think it's safe to assume they have a roleblocker. I'd give it really good odds, but it's not a safe assumption.]] [[Anyway... I'm not sure. We only have a couple hours to discuss and I want to spend them honing in on a better-than-coinflip lynch, and I don't want to go into N2 with...