Search results

[[I think someone else replied to this but just in case: no, we know with 100% certainty that Free was town because GM posts never lie, as per the rules.]] [[At the end of the night. Actions have to be resolved after the deadline, once they've all been submitted. I mentioned it to emphasise...

[[Regarding Tetra: I've been reading over the Motivator page and Tetra's ostensible flavour. I think it tracks. I think her play is consistent with her previous play with allowance for poor decisionmaking while frazzled, and that her brazen, superlative confidence that I'd eat crow only to be...

[[There have to be scum, because I got a Mafia ping when I targeted you last night. Tautological!]] "I'm sure that's because they weren't expecting me to claim my power. If the Mafia thought me and Flygon Hana would spend all day arguing and one of us would go, they might not have had a good...

[[I'm saying I believe the best explanation why there's no pushback right now on me and Tetra is because while mislynching the cop or a motivator would be great for scum, anyone caught pushing a mislynch on us will immediately come under enormous scrutiny, and a small scumteam can't afford to do...

[[Yep! So if Tetra was hit by a deflector, and the second target was scum, it would ensure a cop would see Tetra as guilty. I would pay money to see scumchat right now, tbh.]]

[[No, that sounds about right, actually. Roleblocker can be town but is usually scum. Classic scum role, actually. If someone had their night action blocked, they won't necessarily know unless they have an inforole that normally returns a result, so we can't evidence it.]]

[[Just regular Cop. I can't see roles, I see alignments.]] [[Regarding scepticism about the Jackie-Tetra flailing – if Tetra is also innocent, the scumteam has a lot to gain by getting one of us mislynched, but a lot to lose if they are too obvious about trying to get it to happen and then...

"I have a really good feeling about Mimikyu Loïc! This is a lot of effort, and really good observations and questions! I don't think it makes sense for a killer to behave like he does." [[Sind is my firmest Townread right now, honestly.]]

"I'm too curious for my own good and I'm small and flexible enough to fit into tight spaces! So I've been crawling around the ventilation ducts in this place and going to where I think people's room are, to listen to what they do during the night!" [[I don't think Inke's read DE but this is...

[[I haven't seen anyone defend Gojira, and I think if they were scumteam they'd be receiving more help. My concern right now is directed not at the quiet newcomers, but at the helpful-but-not-too-helpful players. Really hope to get enough time today to figure out a favourite pick for lynching. I...

[[Actually, yes. 3/7, or 43%. It's slightly worse than a coinflip if chosen randomly, but we can choose judiciously and improve our odds.]]

[[Well, what would a TP Deflector's wincon even be? TP usually has a built-in wincon. That feels bizarre to me bc redirect powers are useful only to team players.]]

[[No, I've been Town Doublevoter, Jack Of All Trades, Doctor, Telemarketer (Random Innocent-only Delayed Cop) and finally Cop.]] [[I think the scumteam believed either I or Free was cop, and figured that killing Free and deploying a redirect would make us spend all day fighting. Which it nearly...

[[Excuse me, just woke up from a nap. The point of posting that was to emphasise that it would be weird and unusual and also pretty unfair if any redirection roles of any name had one target be random. (I know Humble Vale had some RNG but that's unusual for Mafia and it worked really well under...

[[Emphasis mine. We are in the dark, here.]]

[[Tetra may have had the most heat on her but I got strong pro-Tetra vibes off Yellow, to the point I was considering gunning for her conditional on securing the Tetra lynch. Still, Mafia Deflector seems more likely to me than Bus Driver or Town Deflector. I just hate the idea of making firm...

[[Wait hang on. If we have a town deflector who targeted Tetra, (and there's no scum deflector, and tetra is innocent), knowing who they deflected to gives us a scum ping. 👀 ]]

[[There's another possibility I just thought of after reading the wiki page on Deflectors. What if we have a Town Deflector as our protective role? They would want to shut the fuck up about their role today, obviously, but the wiki page says it's a role appropriate to either faction. We still...

[[If I hadn't claimed cop, the worst case scenario was mislynching innocent!Tetra and then me getting mislynched the following day in retaliation and us losing. I just didn't have the mental energy to fight through that in isolation. Anyway, if we're lucky enough that the scumteam have a...

[[Whoops. This is what happens when phoneposting late at night]]