ShiniGojira
Multiversal Extraordinaire
Hi there, Orion! Hope you're having a great day! I finally decided to pick this up and give it a read through the first 3 chapters.
A bit of an off topic thought here since it's not necessarily involved with the story but it does talk about what I think about grimdark as a whole.
So overall, pretty good stuff here. Would love to pick this up again when I get the time.
So take care of yourself, Orion and I wish you luck in escaping editing hell!
A bit of an off topic thought here since it's not necessarily involved with the story but it does talk about what I think about grimdark as a whole.
So as far as I could remember, I've never read a single grimdark fic or story ever. Mostly because I'm not usually interested or I thought it'd be too gritty and gorey for me (I'm more of a 'light-hearted adventure filled with small bits of deep thoughts sprinkled around' kinda guy. I do enjoy a good dark story though, think it makes a good way to spice things up.) Anyway, I'd always thought grimdark meant extra angst on top of extreme gore (Which again another side note, is a part of your fic). So I'm kinda surprised it didn't really get into the extremely disturbing side of humanity (Well other than racism of course), no doubt there'd be more darker things going on in the future of this fic, but I'm pleasantly surprised by how normal this fic felt to me (Hm, I think my perceptions of how dark something can be is a little twisted since I've read way too many dark as hell things when I was young)
Anyway with that little tangent done with, here's the main course you've been waiting for:
Starting off with the first chapter and already we get some blood and screaming, not too bad. (Reading way too many M-rated fics as an idiotic child can make you get use to the screaming) Then we're introduced to Orion, the main star of the show (And your name!). He's a badass, battle-hardened former-gladiator that had seen some things in his life (I have a character like that too!... except she's less edgy and more snarky instead) The scar on his body seems to be important to something, seeing as you drew attention to it about twice (or was it three times?) so far. I'm guessing the scar has something to do with his old cult? Maybe he was supposed to be some kind of sacrifice? Experiment? A trafficking victim maybe? Or is he the reanimated corpse of the burnt-alive Absol cub?
Anyway, moving on from Orion. We get some kind of shadowy figure, perhaps this dead deity that Orion's supposedly talking to? Then it talks about how everything is gonna die, and that Orion is the chosen one (with a catch to spice things up). Everything is all up to Orion and if he fails, the whole world is doomed and stuff. Typical prophecy-type things. Always an interesting trope, can't wait to see how you utilize it. (I'm expecting lots of death, gore, angst and bonding in between)
Then after realising it was all just a dream and he has to find a magical McGuffin, we get treated to a female Pidgeot getting chased and our first Shadow Pokémon. Your interpretation of Shadow Pokémon is a bit interesting in how it dies, getting turned to ash and dusted like it'd been Thanos'd. (I'm not quite knowledgeable about Shadow Pokémon other than the basic 'It's corrupted and evil!' so I can't really say much about them)
Anyway, Chapter 2 starts with the battalion struggling and nearly losing to the horde of Shadow. Then, our local badass jumps in, bargains with the captain and single-handedly turns the tides for the peacekeeper. During this chapter, we get some racism talk from a Croagunk, which by the way love how everyone knows he's a total dick but they have to deal with him regardless because he's a good soldier, a naïve and 'wishes to make daddy proud' Wartortle who also wants to help people and inspire others (Always a good thing to do, no matter what), and I know we're gonna get more of him later on (if only to traumatise him to the 'real world' of course).
Then the battle scene happens, and it was great. I think you captured the hopelessness and distress in the early parts really well. Orion comes in and do what all badasses do: kick some ass, look good while doing so, and having the knowledge that no one else knows about.
Chapter 3 happens and we get some backstory from our edge lord, Hesh does some digging, Croagunk guy bashes on Orion with more comments, Tulio talks about rumors of Absol and how they are hated because of their 'bad luck', typical Absol hate here.
Also here's some line-by-line thoughts:
Anyway with that little tangent done with, here's the main course you've been waiting for:
Starting off with the first chapter and already we get some blood and screaming, not too bad. (Reading way too many M-rated fics as an idiotic child can make you get use to the screaming) Then we're introduced to Orion, the main star of the show (And your name!). He's a badass, battle-hardened former-gladiator that had seen some things in his life (I have a character like that too!... except she's less edgy and more snarky instead) The scar on his body seems to be important to something, seeing as you drew attention to it about twice (or was it three times?) so far. I'm guessing the scar has something to do with his old cult? Maybe he was supposed to be some kind of sacrifice? Experiment? A trafficking victim maybe? Or is he the reanimated corpse of the burnt-alive Absol cub?
Anyway, moving on from Orion. We get some kind of shadowy figure, perhaps this dead deity that Orion's supposedly talking to? Then it talks about how everything is gonna die, and that Orion is the chosen one (with a catch to spice things up). Everything is all up to Orion and if he fails, the whole world is doomed and stuff. Typical prophecy-type things. Always an interesting trope, can't wait to see how you utilize it. (I'm expecting lots of death, gore, angst and bonding in between)
Then after realising it was all just a dream and he has to find a magical McGuffin, we get treated to a female Pidgeot getting chased and our first Shadow Pokémon. Your interpretation of Shadow Pokémon is a bit interesting in how it dies, getting turned to ash and dusted like it'd been Thanos'd. (I'm not quite knowledgeable about Shadow Pokémon other than the basic 'It's corrupted and evil!' so I can't really say much about them)
Anyway, Chapter 2 starts with the battalion struggling and nearly losing to the horde of Shadow. Then, our local badass jumps in, bargains with the captain and single-handedly turns the tides for the peacekeeper. During this chapter, we get some racism talk from a Croagunk, which by the way love how everyone knows he's a total dick but they have to deal with him regardless because he's a good soldier, a naïve and 'wishes to make daddy proud' Wartortle who also wants to help people and inspire others (Always a good thing to do, no matter what), and I know we're gonna get more of him later on (if only to traumatise him to the 'real world' of course).
Then the battle scene happens, and it was great. I think you captured the hopelessness and distress in the early parts really well. Orion comes in and do what all badasses do: kick some ass, look good while doing so, and having the knowledge that no one else knows about.
Chapter 3 happens and we get some backstory from our edge lord, Hesh does some digging, Croagunk guy bashes on Orion with more comments, Tulio talks about rumors of Absol and how they are hated because of their 'bad luck', typical Absol hate here.
Also here's some line-by-line thoughts:
Already starting with screams and death... Lovely.Pillars of smoke rose from the burning field and fed into the monstrous, muddy sky. Screams erupted from the nearby Pokémon village as dark creatures poured through the gates. The stench of ashes lingered.
A Shadow Pokémon?A shadowy figure hovered.
Oh wait, nevermind. Just a random deity.“Alas, you are far too weak,” the dark figure said. “The Mark must fall under the possession of one who can persist through hardship after hardship. Should you carry this burden, there is no turning back. You must see your task through all the way to the bitter end. The forces governing this world will attempt to stop you. You must not fail.”
Damn, that was dark.“Basil, why!?” she wept, her claws dragging against the dirt. “I loved you! You don’t have to do this! Please, don’t kill me! No, Basil! Basil!”
When she disappeared into the village, the Absol hurried after her. His heart stopped. The Nidorina’s final agonized scream pierced through the crackle of the flames.
The Liepard has been Thanos'd.The Liepard ceased, its legs growing flaccid, its bloodshot eyes dimming. Its black aura grew in size like a hungry flame and consumed its host.
The fur, the skin, the flesh, the blood and the bones. Slowly, all reduced to
Is that the same Nidorino from his dream?A Shadow Nidorino slipped through the debris.
Let the discrimination begin!Even worse, an Absol.
A daddy boy, isn't he?Where did this Absol come from? And why did the others fear him? Hesh had a weird gut feeling that he shouldn’t find the answers. But he wanted to know more. He wanted to know how he could fight like a true soldier.
Just like his father.
It's war. You signed up for this.Hesh followed the Absol’s voice and looked upon the Shadow Rhydon. He wasn’t sure what else he could do, so he spewed out a stream of water at the enormous beast. The Shadow Rhydon howled in pain and turned towards the Wartortle.
“Oh shit, what have I done?” Hesh whispered, stumbling backwards to distance himself from his massive foe.
This reminded me of a quote I've read but I'm not quite sure what it is. (Though the general message was that 'a great soldier can win a battle while a great commander can win the war', it was something along those lines)“I didn’t think one more soldier would make a difference, but you were something out there. Where’d you learn to fight like that?”
Damn. This is like the witch trial all over again.The Simisage tapped out the burnt remains inside his pipe. “There was a huge Shadow invasion at the time and much of the military had to be away on missions. But rather than taking responsibility for their poor decisions, the Sol Council decided to make this Absol child the supposed ‘culprit’ who summoned the Shadows to Lusang. He was just conveniently there, ripe for exploitation. There was no actual evidence.” He clasped his hands together. “They wouldn’t even let the child speak to defend himself. They... burned the poor thing alive…”
The Swords of Justice?“Have you heard about what happened with the Sacred Swords?”
Up to this point, I thought his dad was dead.You see, he’s an officer in the Peacekeepers. He didn’t approve at first, but decided that it might open up opportunities for me. Then a month of some physical training. And here I am, already out on the field. And I almost died today.”
For survival.“I honestly feel bad for him. I don’t think even he has anything good to say about himself. He has no one to rely on. I wonder how he survived out here. What he’s even fighting for.”
Early-century humans.The Wartortle stared at the campfire. He could imagine a smaller Absol burning in it, based on the Simisage’s story: a small cub screaming as his skin melted off. Who could watch such a monstrous act and be okay with it?
Congrats, Hesh. You're an empath.For some reason, Hesh felt responsible. Even if he was not involved in these events, he felt like he caused pain to someone who didn’t deserve
Definitely.“This has been one hell of a day.”
So overall, pretty good stuff here. Would love to pick this up again when I get the time.
So take care of yourself, Orion and I wish you luck in escaping editing hell!