Seventh Anniversary Mafia

[Chibi Pika]

If Rui was really Drunk (or Poisoned) then Spectrier wouldn't know what she'd claim in advance. When she claimed that Hareta/Watt was Scarlet Woman, Spectrier would know that was untrue and vote for Watt anyway.

Glastrier let out a whinny like a howling blizzard. "It is rather convenient that you present evidence to suggest that believing the Investigator would be a sign of foul play!"

[[Glastrier's being dramatic, but I honestly stand by voting for Watt. We had no reason to think Rui's intel was wrong yet, and I figured that even if we were wrong, I'd be in the perfect position to clear him after death, and that because of the way voting works in the game and the lack of flips, mechanically-clearing someone after death was waaaay more valuable than not, especially since it'd implicitly give us a three-for-one special with Rui and Hareta.]]

 

[windskull]

[[Wanted to be active but haven't had time to be, life got in the way. I still maintain that the best elimination is one of Chibi/UA, but I need to reread the thread before I make a decision on which.]]

 

[aer]

I also really don't trust the gambit to force a tie. Seems way too likely that if they get to be last post of the day again they could flip the result.

[[I mean it's possible for me to have snipevoted you at the last second, but wouldn't you all just vote me out the next day? Because that'd be a really sketchy thing to do. I really just meant for a tie.]]

 

[unrepentantAuthor]

i was thinking phan/rocky/horse

[[If it's Rocky, where's our second Outsider? Now that I know for sure the game rules mean there definitely are two Outsiders, that's as good as hard confirmation Rocky is Butler to me. Otherwise we have a secret Outsider somewhere who could blow the game wide open but is refusing to and doubling down on a fake claim.]]

 

[aer]

[[Also I voted Rui D1 because I thought she was scum because her intel got Watt killed. Which might be because Watt was evil? ... but, no, that couldn't have happened, because Watt has to be innocent because Watt was killed by the Virgin, a sure sign of Virginity I mean Innocence. So then Phan had to have got an evil result for Mimikyu, or was poisoned, or was drunk, or was lying. But if Phan was drunk, then Rui couldn't have been. But if Rui is drunk, then Phan had to be poisoned. Or lying. But there's probably no spy, which would mean that Elgyem wasn't poisoned N0, because then Hareta and Rui wouldn't have been innocent.]]

 

[unrepentantAuthor]

"It is rather convenient that you present evidence to suggest that believing the Investigator would be a sign of foul play!"

[[Well, no. I'm not arguing that you're scum because you voted for Watt. I'm arguing that you voting for Watt doesn't prove you're not scum. That's a different thing.]]

 

[unrepentantAuthor]

@aer you may find this post helpful in working through the inforole tangle

 

[aer]

[[If it's Rocky, where's our second Outsider? Now that I know for sure the game rules mean there definitely are two Outsiders, that's as good as hard confirmation Rocky is Butler to me. Otherwise we have a secret Outsider somewhere who could blow the game wide open but is refusing to and doubling down on a fake claim.]]

[[I mean... if it's the game rules that there's only 2 outsiders (1 drunk and 1 Butler), then yeah... If everyone's claimed and there are no other outsiders, then there's probably no one holding out as a secret drunk, I think. I don't know. Because everyone has claimed, there has to be someone lying.]]

[[Something tells me Hareta is gonna completely lose his shit soon and kill everyone]]

🤝

 

[unrepentantAuthor]

there's probably no one holding out as a secret drunk, I think. I don't know. Because everyone has claimed, there has to be someone lying

[[The Drunk doesn't know they're Drunk. We don't know which inforole is Drunk, but one of them is most likely Drunk. Three players are lying if every Good player is telling the truth. I expect 1-3 of our supposed inforoles to be Evil. If one of the inforoles is Drunk, and Rocky is Butler, that tells us who the Outsiders are. There are no other plausible Outsiders. Therefore we can trust Rocky. Rocky is not evil, with almost as much certainty as Odette.]]

 

[Panoramic_Vacuum]

Because everyone has claimed, there has to be someone lying.]]

"Rocky agree!" He stomped the ground and then pointed to his diagram. "Maybe this help."

Rocky grunted and grumbled to himself, scribbling again on his diagram in the dirt. Now every character had some kind of marking over them, all Gs. He stomped his foot in frustration when he finished.

View attachment 21226

"Yes yes, need three Evils. Rocky know that this diagram wrong. Too many Good guys. New Good guys today need to start poking holes in other Good guy claims." He stared hard at Drake with his ear holes. "You keep telling everyone else how they wrong. Lots of what if. Don't need to brain galaxy. Start small. Need to start finding lies of others instead of saying no to everything."

"Rocky previously say anyone with semi-rough texture (yellow) G could be lying! Need to find liar in that group of players."

[[Only mechanically confirmed Town are: Odette, Watt, Dave. I am an Outsider, aligned with Town. I have Rui listed as Drunk (pink G) but that could be off the table.

Keep in mind some of these yellow Gs are conditional. If one is lying, a good chance their partner is also lying. We need to find 3 bad guys in the bunch.

I believe Drake was one of them, but nothing is 100% confirmed about that. If I'm correct, that leaves is with two more liars to sniff out in the bunch who would also be in cahoots with Drake.

I have a (too long) list of possible scum pairs on my laptop at home. Will post when I'm home from work with hopefully a few more crossed off by then...]]

 

[Sinderella]

[[Currently doing a Morgan play readthrough, then I’m gonna hit Tetra and then either Chibi or uA. Stay tuned]]

 

[unrepentantAuthor]

[[I keep refreshing for posts. The eternal curse of mafia.]]