Seventh Anniversary Mafia

[Shiny Phantump]

[[I feel like the main takeaway here is "phan has to hedge all of her statements more" and like okay that's something I'm working on now bc it's bit me in the ass a few times. I mostly figured it'd be fine bc I expect people to take each other with a grain of salt but I've seen the light and the problems that can come with overstatement of confidence. Is that a scumread? I have almost no town experience (esp early this game when it was just bastardafia, even my irl clocktower experience skews scum I rolled imp instantly bc that's just my luck.)]]

I understand that, but my whole reason for pointing this out is why are we assuming that it was Elgyem that got poisoned and not Phan, hence why I'm asking if I just completely glossed over something?

"Augh, did you sleep though yesterday?" [[Morgan's being rude. No judgement from me. We're on page 25 already there's a lot going on.]] "We did a lot of talking about me being poisoned night one. It was my main thesis for the day. It went poorly. Now we're pretty sure that it isn't the case, and I was poisoned night zero if at all... and maybe tonight, depending on how you feel about the horse."

I missed whatever the warning shot was

"Although they apparently didn't notice me voting for them for a bit last night, which is interesting."

 

[unrepentantAuthor]

[[Ahhhhh that's where I got twisted, thanks for clarifying!]]

yw <3

 

[Sinderella]

"Augh, did you sleep though yesterday?" [[Morgan's being rude. No judgement from me. We're on page 25 already there's a lot going on.]] "We did a lot of talking about me being poisoned night one. It was my main thesis for the day. It went poorly. Now we're pretty sure that it isn't the case, and I was poisoned night zero if at all... and maybe tonight, depending on how you feel about the horse."

[[No that's a valid question for her to ask, and the answer is yes and I'm just waking up

Right I KNOW that was your thesis for the day. I guess where my brain is getting so fried is that everyone's like "well I know for a FACT that X got poisoned" and "I know for a fact that Y is Drunk" (obv I am exaggerating here but you get the idea) when.......we don't?? Like simply put I cannot trust a goddamn thing any of y'all say because the points are contradicting each other and not, and reading everyone being like P SURE IT'S NOT THE CASE THIS IS WHAT HAPPENED has me like.............WE DON'T KNOW THAT CHAT. But that's also the point of the game obv, it's a matter of who is appearing more trustworthy around those claims (I promise I have a high IQ like honest to god)

I mean tbf I was squinting at Aer/Elgyem from the beginning because of the way their Empath reveal came out and everyone got on me for still dogging them, so if it turns out that they're lying after all of this, I will accept both my laurels and my crow.

Honse and Bigbat are the next two I need to look at but I admittedly fried all of my synapses combing back all morning so that's going to be for later, but I might only have time to do one. It will probably be Chibi.]]

"Although they apparently didn't notice me voting for them for a bit last night, which is interesting."

[[.....it's actually funny that they missed that you were gunning for them because I caught that, and I am fucking notorious for missing in-thread hints.]]

 

[Shiny Phantump]

I think Phan favours high-info play and is incautious

[[While this is true of me even from a Clocktower perspective, I like info bc I don't trust my social/soft reading skills, I also think Clocktower privileges informed gamestates more than Mafia— unique roles with guaranteed alignments in an open setup alone can be powerful deductive tool, and poison/drunkeness encourages collating multiple data points. D1 massclaim is niche but viable, while insane in Mafia. D1 no claims is really fucking scary, but normal in Mafia.]]

 

[Panoramic_Vacuum]

[[Also need to make it clear I didn't expect anybody to read all of that, it was for me to break everything down, so don't get your knickers twisted about it at first glance ]]

"No, this good! Is helpful! Rocky will read. Flashcards boring, read them too many times. This new, useful. Good good good."

 

[aer]

[[Because if Tetra is scum, scumteam already knew I had to be Ravenkeeper. There literally weren't any other things I could be! The only way scum wouldn't know is if Tetra was town and kept her role secret. Which she didn't, anyway. Which I was expecting her to do if she was scum.

So the logic here is that if Tetra is Mafia, the Mafia would have known the Noivern was the Ravenskeeper? Why not Librarian or Soldier?