Hello, I’m here from the Review Blitz. True confession, I saw this story on FFN a long time ago, read a few chapters and really enjoyed them, left a tab open forever thinking "I should leave a review," and never got around to it (this happens to me occasionally, not just with this story). Anyways, no time like the present?
This review is for chapters 1-4.
Overall, I don’t think I ever really expected to see a story told in second person that works this well . . . thinking about the parts in chapter 2 about toenail polish and bikinis, I suppose a male reader might find it a bit jarring, but for me, I felt it gave an intimate feel to this (mostly) solitary journey.
Chapter 1 (Rte 119)
This first chapter is most definitely my favorite of the chapters of this story I’ve read; it’s fascinating to see the Pokemon world fleshed out in a more realistic manner with things like beef jerkey and trying to keep the rain out of one's poncho, and the imagery, the strong nouns and verbs, the actions of the pokemon, and the onomatopoeia are all terrific. The herd of tropius taking off from the cliff was an image that really stuck in my mind for a long time after reading this story. It definitely creates an awe-inspiring mood, and the tropius rising and falling and wheeling in the air makes me suspect I’m not the only person who likes to watch flocks of crows play around in the air on a windy day. ;)
If I were to pick at something, it would be that the phrase "the clouds" is repeated twice in the first two sentences without much space in between, though this is really a nitpick. Also, “immobilizes you with awe” is straying a bit into telling, rather than showing, but what you do show the reader in this chapter sufficiently portrays the majestic, awe-inspiring nature of the scene that it’s easy to pardon.
Also, upon rereading I noticed the change in the narrator's attitude from being irritated at the damp, in the beginning, to not noticing or caring at all, which gives this vignette a nice sense of having a bit of a story arc from beginning to end.
Chapter 2 (Rte 34)
I hadn't recalled this one quite so well, but actually, it's hilarious. The parts about the narrator's mental justifications of purchasing a swimsuit are easy to relate to, as I'm sure everyone has had that sort of indulgent purchase: you come up with some reason you "need" this thing, and tell yourself how much you're going to use it, and then you don't.
There's some nice onomatopoeia in this one, too, with the squelching mud, and some nice spot-on descriptions of the smell and feel of the salt water, and the various bites and cuts and bruises on the narrator's body. The sense of reaching a point where you just don't care about certain things anymore is another experience that's easy to relate to.
The narrator's flusteredly grabbing her pokeball (in the nude) to recall her furret is amusing, but also an interesting bit of world-building in that the possibility of using a pokeball's button to recall a pokemon when they're in danger is something that never occurred to me.
Chapter 3 (Viridian Forest) and Chapter 4 (Rte 204)
Combining my comments on these two. In chapter 3, I felt that the part about the second-person narrator’s team being leaner and stronger with her friend around rang true, and that was what I found most memorable about this chapter, along with the overall dynamic between the two trainers.
My other comment about this chapter (and the next) is something I find really hard to verbalize, but for me as a reader, I find that when it comes to stories that try to add more realism to the Pokemon world, there’s kind of a spectrum from things that introduce more mature, or realistic elements, while still feeling (to me) like something firmly set in the Pokemon world, to ones that seem like regular stories about the real world, but with pokemon thrown in. Of course this is a subjective thing, and it’s really hard for me to define what exactly makes that difference. I suppose it has something to do with making things in the story come across as intrinsically different from how they are in the real world. For me, your first two postcards come across as really firmly in Pokemon-world territory. The continual presence of both the trainer’s pokemon and wild pokemon helps a lot, but perhaps maybe part of it is also the fact that although people do go backpacking in the wilderness in real life, they usually don’t go backpacking along with a group of animals, for the purpose of training those animals, so those chapters come across as a fleshing out of what a “trainer journey” (which is the quintessence of pretty much any non-PMD Pokemon media) would be like.
The parts of chapter 3 that started talking about the choices the narrator would have in a city—about things to do in a bar, or leaving the bar to go somewhere else—start to feel to me like this is some real world atmosphere that has crept into the Pokemon world. Again, it’s hard to say exactly why—it’s not because there are bars, but maybe because there’s nothing in that brief paragraph that really makes me envision anything about how the experience of being in a bar, in the Pokemon world, would be any different from being in a bar in real life.
I feel like it is incredibly picky to say this (given how short that particular passage is), but this is my attempt to try to put my finger on why the atmosphere and world in chapter 3 starts to feel different to me than they did in previous chapters.
Chapter 4, on the other hand, comes across to me as completely and utterly a chapter that’s not really about pokemon (or the Pokemon world) anymore, it’s a chapter that’s about the experience of living off of rehydrated meals, and it happens to have some references to pokemon thrown in here and there. Now, that said, it was a very well-written and fun chapter about rehydrated meals, and I enjoyed lines like “flecks meant to represent vegetables” and the one about those meals being “designed,” not “cooked,” which is a great comment not just on rehydrated food but on how we as a society, largely, approach food nowadays. There was also that line about sitting and staring for a half hour, which I’m sure anyone (or, at least anyone sufficiently old to have had that experience) can relate to. And, overall, this chapter (and the other chapters I’ve read) are so specific in their depictions that I can’t help but imagine that all of the details about backpacking and what that experience is like are based on your own personal experience. (If I’m wrong, though, you’re doing a great job of faking it!)
So, the real-world-ness of those two chapters doesn’t make them bad chapters, per se. I’m just trying to put my finger on what I perceive as a kind of drift from a very Pokemon-world atmosphere to what seems to me like more of a “real world with pokemon” atmosphere; feel free to take that or leave it, as you see fit.