Spiteful Murkrow
Busy Writing Stories I Want to Read
- Pronouns
- He/Him/His
- Partners
-
Heya, swinging by for a story that had caught my eye in the past but I’d just never gotten around to in the past. I know nothing about this one other than that it apparently used to be part of Envy of Eden before getting spun off, so let’s just jump right in and see where things are going:
first gift
Alright, made it to the end. Just need a moment to get some sand out of my eyes…
Okay, we’re good, let’s get right into highlight reel. The long and short of things is that I liked this piece, it’s a touching and haunting story where we see a child having to grapple with the consequences of a rash choice. Like yeah, the specific backdrop is quite alien and fantastical relative to everyday life or even the present day in Pokémon’s setting, but the actual emotions are still relatable and it’s surprisingly easy to put oneself into the shoes of the protagonist and let the second person PoV do its thing. The Unovan folklore you cooked up for this chapter was also top notch, like it feels very “yes, people would actually tell stories like this in pre-modern Unova”, and I hope that we’ll get to see more now that the protagonist is going to be spending at least a year chilling with Krookodile in the desert. I was also impressed at the sheer amount of information that you managed to communicate, both directly and in between the lines in a little over 5000 words. Also, while I might be a little biased, but I thought that your use of second person perspective for the narration was particularly well done.
Honestly, there were not a lot of things that stood out to me as weaknesses with this chapter. Like yeah, a part of it was me just getting really into things, but it was just genuinely a very polished chapter. If I had to force myself to pick things that I’d disagreed with, I noticed that there were some paragraphs that felt really, really long in this chapter. To the point that they made me question if they needed to be delivered in a big, continuous block like that, but there’s some degree of “my story, my style” to be had from author to author. A part of me also wonders if we should’ve seen more of the protagonist’s thought process in the sequence where his father is relaying the tale of Little Sister and the Sun to him, but I can understand the argument for not doing that in a second-person PoV story. While it makes the protagonist fade out from the chapter for a while, if we’re going full “the protagonist is you”, it does allow us to fill in the blanks ourselves in the protagonist’s place. I suppose it’s basically all a function of the extent to which you intended for the protagonist to exist as a distinct personality outside of the reader that’s sharing his/her eyes.
As you can gather from the above commentary, but I quite liked this opening chapter, @kintsugi . Like it’s obviously not a happy story at the moment, but it had a lot of love and thought put into it and it didn’t take particularly long before I started getting really engrossed into the story.
I honestly regret waiting this long to finally take a plunge on this story, and I hope to have the time to come back for the rest during this event. But until then, Happy Blitzmas, and best of luck with your continued writing endeavors.
first gift
Also, FYI but your linked art is down and you should update the link to point to a fresh image host whenever you have the chance.
Well, I see that our protagonist is doing well™ at the moment. Though has he been sentenced to bake to death under the desert sun, or…?
The ‘Southern Stones’, huh? Given the title, I wonder if we’re somewhere around Route 4 right now and if so, if that’s the place that Castelia used to be.
Whelp, I think that confirms that we’re on Route 4 right about now.
So our protagonist is human, or…? Though if nothing else, there’s definitely a human accompanying him right now.
Okay, our protagonist is human. Though I never considered how long Maractus could live, but the “only fifty” would indeed check out with some cacti species like saguaros where they can casually live to be triple that age.
Well, time to find out whether or not this protagonist is going to be a fakeout one, since… uh… yeah, I’m pretty sure that this isn’t a good sign for his life expectancy at this rate.
Oh, so Samira is the equivalent of an Alpha Krookodile. I didn’t pick up on that one, but I suppose I should’ve realized something was up when Samira’s jaws were described as big as the protagonist.
Oh right, there’s multiple languages that are used by Pokémon in EoE. A little surprised that the sanhim can hold a conversation in this fashion, but I suppose that N’s ability to comprehend Pokémon is a bit more widely distributed in this setting. Maybe.
I do think your paragraph is a bit dense, to the point that it likely makes sense to consider whether or not to format it as two smaller ones.
Protag: “Er… I could kinda use a reminder right now.” ^^;
Samira:
Protag: “... Right, of course she wouldn’t appreciate that.”
I’m going to guess that the underlined is supposed to be stuff from Relic Castle. Does that include the Tao stone that’s in there, or…?
Another paragraph that seems too long. Though the protag’s misdeed was catching a Sandile without its consent, wasn’t it?
Yup, feeling pretty confident about that prediction right about now.
I take it that this happened well, well before the events of EoE given how much control the Pokémon have over whether or not they get trained by humans, which I understand they… uh… don’t have in EoE proper.
Oh, so that’s what our protagonist’s big no-no was. Yeah, this is really different from how I understand EoE’s state of affairs to work.
This place totally is paved over in the present day because ‘Lmao, tradition, who needs that?’, isn’t it? /s
Oh, so the Tao stone is a part of these rites. Though things are sure looking grim for our protagonist right now. Especially with how I’m sure death sentences are handed down among Sandile line ‘mons considering how their IRL counterparts deal with each other…
Oh hey, it’s like that anime episode with the Kangaskhan and that one kid raised by them, except not played for laughs.
Oh, so that’s who the sanhim is here. I have to wonder how the sanhim truly feels about all of this at the moment.
Yeeeeah, I can already tell he feels different internally but is going along with this because “something, something duty”.
Well, that’s quite a downer opening right there.
Ah yes, when kindness wraps right around into unintentional cruelty. I get the feeling that will be happening a few times in this story since… yeah, humans are a bit different from Krookodile in natural needs.
Yeah, I’ll just take that as a sign that daddy’s also feeling torn up over leaving his kid to a bunch of sand crocs for at least a year.
I mean, the alternative is being at war for a while with the desert crocs at minimum, so… yeah, daddy has some good reasons for going along with this, even if it hurts.
Samira: “No, no, just because he’s not getting the fullness of what his deed deserves and becoming lunch doesn’t mean that this isn’t a punish-”
Sanhim: “Samira, please.” >.<
Wait, I just realized, but little flurry? Did the protagonist’s people originate from up in the mountains up north, or…?
Once again:
Oh, so that’s why the Sanhim is addressing his child as ‘little flurry’, since based off this backstory, I take it that he used to live someplace up closer to around Icirrus, which would explain the whole ‘black stone’ bit there.
Though is there a Meinfoo/Druddigon/Golett flavor of this story somewhere up north as well, then?
I feel as if that’s a bad sign for how Little Sister is faring nowadays given that she’s being spoken of in past tense repeatedly. Though I’m just realizing that this is essentially a much more dramatic and less willing version of the whole “10-year old going off and seeing the world” arc that’s omnipresent in Pokémon media.
She’s dead in the present day, isn’t she?
Oh, the Dragonmother is the Original Dragon of this world, huh? Another one of those things that I’m very belated realizing right now.
Oh, so Little Sister is the originating figure for the protagonist’s tribe or whatever, huh?
Did the protagonist’s people migrate from Icirrus to around Route 4? Since they sure have a lot of things about their culture that vibe as Icirrus-isms, while at the same time, they have a mythos that I’m pretty sure is going to enumerate the various Pokémon that live around them in the desert and how they came into being.
Ah yes, our first Krookodile Tear of the story. Considering the title, I can already tell that we’re going to be revisiting this tale a few more times in the future.
This is a myth about that Volcarona that served as a surrogate sun during a volcanic winter, isn’t it? Since that description definitely sounds similar there.
Sun:
Even if I’m going to go ahead and guess that this is going to turn into a Volcarona origin story in like two paragraphs.
Little Sister:
Background Darmanitan: “Wait, what? No, we can produce fire perfectly fine without sunlight-”
Sahnim: “Shut up, you’re ruining a heartfelt moment with my son right now.” >_>;
Oh, so this is the episode that the protagonist was referencing when he was wondering if he’d break down like Little Sister.
Is this an “origin of the sunrise/sunset” story? Since this feels like an “origin of the sunrise/sunset” story.
Also, you sure have a knack for writing convincing-sounding folklore. Since if it weren’t for the namedrop of Pokémon species in Sahnim’s tale, it’d sound like an actual folktale from IRL.
Yeah, I knew it. Though cute story there.
Aaaaaand right back to depression-land we go. Even if a part of me wonders if we should’ve seen a little more of the protagonist’s inner thought process a bit more as the story was being told. Maybe. I can understand the argument that it might have taken us out of the whole “you are hearing a story relayed to you” vibe that the present version has.
I take it that this story was also meant for the Sahnim’s self to some extent since… yeah, that’s definitely also applicable for him at this moment.
D’aww, how sweet-
Samira:
Right, time for that parting of ways bright and early the next day, huh?
Oh, so protag has also wrecked his chances of being a future sahnim from his earlier transgressions. We’re just piling on all the knife twists in this story, huh?
Cue the theme music:
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hoKluzn07eQ
Samira: “Was the depressing pop music in the background really necessary right now?”
Protag: “Look, can we just get this over with?”
Well, not like it hasn’t already been obvious since the sequence with their last night together, but I suppose that’s a sign that for as painful as this all is, that the sahnim genuinely loves his child. I’m honestly impressed at how much you managed to communicate in between the lines in a relatively short chapter like this.
Hey, look on the bright side, protag, you get to be a badass sand croc rider for the next yea-
Protag: “Not helping right now!” >.<
They don’t bind you when they take you to your judgment, and you’re grateful for the dignity that affords you. Besides, you know that even if you wanted to run, there’s nowhere for you to go. Without Nali you would stray from the path and quickly fall to the sun, no doubt. Without the sanhim, you would surely be able to live, but the shame would fester at your insides until the day you died.
Well, I see that our protagonist is doing well™ at the moment. Though has he been sentenced to bake to death under the desert sun, or…?
The sun had just been peeking over the horizon when your group had started, and as the grasslands turn to sand beneath your feet, the shadows grow long and the winds slow. Despite your apprehension, despite your shame, it’s impossible to see these lands as anything but beautiful. Beyond the Southern Stones where you’d been born, the river washed into the grasslands; thick marshes buzzed with life. The landscape was broken up by craggy, overturned stones, but beyond that, the land was flat to the horizon, like a river’s stone run smooth.
The ‘Southern Stones’, huh? Given the title, I wonder if we’re somewhere around Route 4 right now and if so, if that’s the place that Castelia used to be.
This far from home, the ground forms dunes undulating across the horizon, looming ever-larger as they snake into the distance. The land beneath your feet is ground to a fine, orange powder that shifts as you stumble through it. The land that holds your judgment feels softer somehow, even as shame curdles in your chest.
Whelp, I think that confirms that we’re on Route 4 right about now.
Nali croons something to the sanhim, pointing with one spike-studded arm towards the horizon. The sanhim nods and adjusts course in response to the maractus’ advice, and the two of them plod on in shared silence. You trail behind them, hunched against the bright sun. The sanhim’s ceremonial cloak is a deep red; as the grass becomes more and more sparse and the oranges of the desert are all the remain, he remains the lone flower. Your gaze traces downward, to where his staff makes circular imprints, in even sync with his footprints, and then further down the line to Nali. The maractus bobs evenly, the swings of her arms almost exaggerated, placing one stubby foot in the direct center of the sanhim’s sandalprint each time.
So our protagonist is human, or…? Though if nothing else, there’s definitely a human accompanying him right now.
Nali you have known your entire life. She’s young as far as maractus go, only fifty and barely up to your waist. You’ve been told stories of how she taught you how to walk—the bright pinks of her flowers were too tempting, and she would proudly take one step backwards and another until you finally crawled after her.
She watched you when you were young. You swallow past the uncomfortably tight knot in your throat. She didn’t have to come here today. The sanhim knows the way, even if Nali knows the shortcuts. And between you and the sanhim, you could’ve carried enough water for the both of you. But you suspect she came for you, and that knowledge gives you the strength to keep walking after her.
Okay, our protagonist is human. Though I never considered how long Maractus could live, but the “only fifty” would indeed check out with some cacti species like saguaros where they can casually live to be triple that age.
The dunes grow taller and closer; they cast long shadows and tower over you by the time you finally reach your destination. Lost in a walking trance, you don’t notice when Nali chirps something, and you crash into the sanhim’s extended arm. And then you look up. What you thought was a great dune shifts and sways, and then sand begins to cascade down its base as the peak stirs. Red shards flash silver in the sunset as the earth stirs to life, and with a lazy tailflick the biggest krookodile you’ve seen in your entire life emerges, the gap between her yawning jaws as large as you are tall.
Well, time to find out whether or not this protagonist is going to be a fakeout one, since… uh… yeah, I’m pretty sure that this isn’t a good sign for his life expectancy at this rate.
“Samira,” the sanhim says solemnly, while Nali bows low next to him. “We have brought Baku of the Southern Stones for your judgment.”
The sands around Samira’s legs shiver as well, and another krookodile emerges, staring haughtily down at you. This one is closer to regular size, its wedged head as large as your torso and its body twice your height, but your heart still catches in your throat—when you cast your gaze around the dunes, you see dozens of pairs of beady black eyes peeking back from the sand. There is a low, vibrating hiss. You can’t tell from where.
Oh, so Samira is the equivalent of an Alpha Krookodile. I didn’t pick up on that one, but I suppose I should’ve realized something was up when Samira’s jaws were described as big as the protagonist.
“His tongue is heavy and his ears are young,” the sanhim explains in response. “As such I must use the dancer’s tongue for him to understand in full, and he must do the same to be heard. Forgive us the disrespect. Were it anything but asking your judgment, we would make do without it, but I fear he will only feel like justice is dealt if his words are also heard.”
He waits for a moment. Another hiss, this one higher-pitched; the sanhim’s head tilts to the krookodile on the left. “Yes. That is likely part of why this happened. I cannot disagree.”
Oh right, there’s multiple languages that are used by Pokémon in EoE. A little surprised that the sanhim can hold a conversation in this fashion, but I suppose that N’s ability to comprehend Pokémon is a bit more widely distributed in this setting. Maybe.
I do think your paragraph is a bit dense, to the point that it likely makes sense to consider whether or not to format it as two smaller ones.
Samira does not look at you. Slowly, impassively, she turns her head to the krookodile that emerged beside her and growls something in a low, vibrating note. The smaller krookodile’s claws twitch in a short, gesticulated response, and then Samira turns to the sanhim and hisses. Nali chimes in then, and you watch mutely as the maractus waves her arms and chirrups in turn.
Finally, the sanhim turns to you. “She wants to hear your words, Baku,” he says. His face is unreadable. “She wants to hear why you did such a thing.”
Protag: “Er… I could kinda use a reminder right now.” ^^;
With trembling legs, you walk forward until you’re standing before Samira. Each of her inhalations is large enough to pull your hair forward; each exhale cloaks you in a warm, moist breeze. You manage a shaky bow.
What you want to say is, I’m sorry. What comes out instead is: “Greetings, oh great one, Samira of the Sands.” When you pull up the respectful greeting that the sanhim passed to you, your voice finally quavers.
Samira:
Protag: “... Right, of course she wouldn’t appreciate that.”
Samira blinks back, unimpressed.
Why you did such a thing.
It isn’t an answer that you’d like to admit.
On the winter solstice of each year, the peoples of the desert gather in your home in the south, along the banks of the river. From the northern foothills marches the darumaka troop; from the eastern plains comes the sonder of maractus. The krookodile must come from the western dunes, although the way they rise and vanish into the earth makes their movements impossible for you to track. The solstice is a time for coming together and growing apart: two of the desert peoples bring the relics of the Dragonmother, which they have safeguarded throughout the year; when the night is over, the relics are passed to their neighboring peoples, to be guarded for the next year. The same, too, is done with the desert’s children—those who wish to take a companion and stay in the oasis of the Southern Stones are invited to do so.
I’m going to guess that the underlined is supposed to be stuff from Relic Castle. Does that include the Tao stone that’s in there, or…?
This was your tenth solstice. You were old enough. So when the sun touched the edge of the sky and it came time for the children to gather, you stepped forward alongside the other children of your clan with pounding ears, trembling hands clutched around a berry. You waited as two darumaka toddled past, their footprints briefly glowing orange in the sunset sands, and your excitement slowly faded to dread as they paired off. Mila beamed, bending down and offering her berry to a sputtering darumaka; when the two young maractus filed past solemnly, they went to Aruno and Harana while you stood still like a statue, your unclaimed berry suddenly like a stone that threatened to pull you under. Then came the sandile—just the one this year—and you were the last child.
The other five were already sharing their meal together; there was just you left; there was no one else for it to choose. It slipped close to you, its short legs wobbling as if overcompensating for the firmness of the ground, and you saw its nostrils flare as it inhaled the scent around your hands. The sandile leaned in, dark eyes gleaming—
—And then it turned away.
Another paragraph that seems too long. Though the protag’s misdeed was catching a Sandile without its consent, wasn’t it?
You took half a step after it, but the sanhim’s hand was on your shoulder, firm. “This was her choice,” he said, a pang of regret in his words. Was that pity? “You must respect that, Baku.”
Yup, feeling pretty confident about that prediction right about now.
The rest of the celebration felt grim. You watched the familiar sight as an outsider while everyone chattered and danced and ate. Utamo, the weaving elder of your village, cracked his stern lips into a smile as one wizened hand roved over the silvered hide of a darmanitan, marveling at the new rivers that time had carved in both of their skins. Nali grabbed Harana and her newfound maractus by the hands and introduced her to the other maractus, and four of them marveled at the stack of fruits laid out on the festival table. Your aunt Livari, toddler on her hip and Mila at her side, translated the desert tongue for her daughter from the darumaka who had chosen her.
And all the while you festered, silent, while one thought crystallized: that sandile hadn’t known what it was doing. That was the only reason it hadn’t chosen you. And it had been close—it’d leaned in, after all. As the night wore on, the pit in your stomach only grew. Could you be lonely like this for an entire year? When the sun rose, your clan would return to the south, with five new children. Five, not six. Everyone was already whispering, surely, about foolish Baku who couldn’t even get a pokémon if he was the last boy in the plains.
No. It had been so close. It hadn’t known any better. If you just could make it see—
I take it that this happened well, well before the events of EoE given how much control the Pokémon have over whether or not they get trained by humans, which I understand they… uh… don’t have in EoE proper.
The courage finally filled you when they were gathering themselves to leave. You chased after it, feet pounding on the reeds by the bank. It moved with an almost exaggerated slowness through the river, trailing behind the adult krookodile; together, their scales formed a glistening streak of red that moved upstream.
“Wait!” you shouted, and then a krookodile’s head snapped towards you, beads of saliva dripping from its maw. And in that moment, despite the enormous creature in front of you, you noticed the lack of stones beneath your feet, the trampled grasses around you, and you realized what you had done.
Oh, so that’s what our protagonist’s big no-no was. Yeah, this is really different from how I understand EoE’s state of affairs to work.
Your arms fall slack to your sides now as you look up at Samira. You had miles and miles of desert to plan your defense and this is all you can think about. “I don’t have a defense,” you say quietly. “I didn’t realize I had left the Southern Stones. I didn’t realize I had set foot on the Dragonmother’s Gift.”
The words come more easily than you’d expected, once you understand what actually must be said. It had all happened so quickly: the sanhim had declared that because the lands were guarded by the krookodile, they would be your judge instead of him. The other humans you could convince, maybe, but not this ancient creature who stands before you, already older than you’ll ever be. Your only defense is the truth, and for you it is paper-thin.
Samira shutters one red eyelid solemnly, and then the other, and then turns her head back towards the krookodile at her side—that one must be the one who found you, you realize belatedly. At one point, Nali puffs up her chest and chimes in; both of the krookodile turn to look at the maractus with ponderous eyes. They converse too quickly for you to understand, and finally, Samira straightens and hisses back at the sanhim.
The sanhim’s shoulders seem more slouched than usual. You imagine for a moment that it’s from the solstice ceremony, when the leader of the darumaka pressed the Dragonmother’s white relic into his hands. Surely the stone was so heavy that it began to press him into the earth. All that’s left is for you to wait with bated breath before the sanhim passes back the translation. When he does, it is like his face is carved from stone.
“They have heard your plea. The grasslands beyond northern banks are sacred grounds, the last gift from the Dragonmother to the desert peoples. Among the krookodile, to tread on them means death, but Samira recognizes that the old stories may have been forgotten for us in the south.”
Oh, so the Tao stone is a part of these rites. Though things are sure looking grim for our protagonist right now. Especially with how I’m sure death sentences are handed down among Sandile line ‘mons considering how their IRL counterparts deal with each other…
Your ears burn with shame: that is a kindness she assumes of you. You’d learned the lessons when you were young. The Southern Stones were for you and yours, but every child knew not to cross the river.
“That much is understood when considering what must be done next.” The sanhim swallows, and even through his stern mask you can see the beginnings of anguish. “To Samira and her kind, it is clear that we of the Southern Stones have failed in raising you to respect the ways of this land. So she proposes this: they will raise you instead, and teach what we could not.”
Oh hey, it’s like that anime episode with the Kangaskhan and that one kid raised by them, except not played for laughs.
The weight of his words crash in on you all at once, and your composure drops immediately. They will take you? But you need your home, and your friends, and—“Father, please,” you croak.
Oh, so that’s who the sanhim is here. I have to wonder how the sanhim truly feels about all of this at the moment.
The sanhim’s face wrinkles, but he does not falter. “You will be permitted to visit on the solstice, and at that time your judgment will be reassessed, but your lesson must be learned.” He swallows once again. “She will return for you at sunrise. So shall it be.”
Yeeeeah, I can already tell he feels different internally but is going along with this because “something, something duty”.
All eyes turn to you. Your eyelids suddenly sting when you blink, and the dunes blur.
“So shall it be,” the sanhim repeats expectantly.
You shouldn’t have done it. That much is clear. You want to scream and beg for your innocence, to explain to Samira that the people of the Southern Stones were not to blame. Your father, the sanhim, please, spare him the humiliation of having to return home to the people he leads empty-handed, because his own son could not follow in his footsteps.
“So shall it be,” you echo instead.
Well, that’s quite a downer opening right there.
You would later realize that Samira offered you a kindness—krookodile prefer to travel at night, when the baking sun could not pierce their scales and warm their blood. But they waited to set out until sunrise. Perhaps the kindness was for the sanhim instead, but all you know in the moment is that the two of you can spend one last night beneath the stars.
Ah yes, when kindness wraps right around into unintentional cruelty. I get the feeling that will be happening a few times in this story since… yeah, humans are a bit different from Krookodile in natural needs.
Nali has wandered off into the moonlight; you can only barely see her hazy outline, silvery and lilting against the dunes. So that just leaves you and the sanhim.
Here, in the firelight, with his cloak draped across both your shoulders, he’s just your father again. He twists his fingers around one another like he’s trying to tie a knot with his knuckles, and he stares into the fire even as you tend it with a small stick.
Yeah, I’ll just take that as a sign that daddy’s also feeling torn up over leaving his kid to a bunch of sand crocs for at least a year.
“I didn’t mean it,” you say at last. Your voice cracks. He has to know this, if nothing else. You can’t imagine what he thinks of you now, and you don’t want to, but you need him to understand: you know you shouldn’t have done it. You know you did something monstrous. You can be better. You will be better. It wasn’t his fault.
“I know, little flurry,” he says, and he pulls you a little closer. “I know.”
The fire pops and shifts. You don’t have anything else to say. Everyone knows you didn’t mean it, and yet here you are.
I mean, the alternative is being at war for a while with the desert crocs at minimum, so… yeah, daddy has some good reasons for going along with this, even if it hurts.
A weak smile cracks his lips and he says, “This is a lesson. Not a punishment.”
Samira: “No, no, just because he’s not getting the fullness of what his deed deserves and becoming lunch doesn’t mean that this isn’t a punish-”
Sanhim: “Samira, please.” >.<
You stare glumly at your knees. Even with the fire to your front and his warmth to your sides, you still feel cold.
His grip tightens encouragingly on your shoulders when he continues: “Samira is an old friend. I have known her since I was younger than you are now. She once took your aunt Livari as her companion, and journeyed across the sands into our stones each week to see her and seek her company. Did you know that?”
He’s prodding you to answer, but you can’t make the words come.
Not to be discouraged, he continues: “She will be kind to you, little flurry. She will make sure you do not melt. And she taught my sister so many things. Imagine all the sights you’ll see with the krookodile, Baku. When we meet again you’ll have so much to tell me! The dunes are a beautiful place, and you’ll have so many adventures.”
Wait, I just realized, but little flurry? Did the protagonist’s people originate from up in the mountains up north, or…?
“I don’t want adventures.” You sniffle. “I want you.”
His smile fades, and he grows silent. Then, wordlessly, he pulls you into his arms and holds you close to his chest. His chin presses your curls down tight to your head, and you grab his forearms, clutching them fiercely against you. You bury your face in the insides of his wrists, inhaling his scent with shaky gasps, and bite back tears.
Once again:
“Oh, little flurry,” he whispers huskily into the crown of your head. When he swallows, you can feel his throat contract. “Do you know when I first fell in love with your mother?”
Wordlessly, you shake your head.
“We were so young, barely your age. On the winter solstice, during the night, it snowed. It was a truly beautiful sight to wake up to in the pink sunrise that followed. Everything was so soft, and the air was so still.” Dimly, you’re aware of how he’s gently rocking you back and forth, marking the rhythm of his words between you. “I found her in the dawn with her hands cupped around the Dragonmother’s black heart, the stone covered in snow, her body angled so her shadow could hide it away from the sun. She turned to show it to me, and when she did she was so gentle that not one flake melted, or even moved. I remember the way her voice lilted when she said that the way the stone embraced the snowfall made her think the white and black could be reunited, if only for a moment.”
Even though you can’t see his face, you can hear his smile. “I was foolish even then, Baku, though as a boy I thought I was wise. I proudly asked her if she knew that the snow would melt no matter where she put it, that this stone would always be black. Instead of scorning me where I stood, she told me the story of Sun Sister and the Three Gifts. Do you remember that one?”
Oh, so that’s why the Sanhim is addressing his child as ‘little flurry’, since based off this backstory, I take it that he used to live someplace up closer to around Icirrus, which would explain the whole ‘black stone’ bit there.
You remember it. You even remember when your mother told it to you herself. And you shouldn’t be wasting time on stories now, not when the time you have left is so strictly measured. But an aching part of you wants to hear the familiarity of the words, to curl up and close your eyes and lose yourself like Little Sister almost did. So instead you ask, “Could you tell it again?”
If he’s surprised by your answer, he doesn’t show it. Instead, he smiles, and begins speaking with the same ceremonial cadence with which he spins the solstice retellings. This time, the story’s just for you:
When the world was younger than you are now, Little Sister opened her eyes, and for the first time she was alone. She shivered; there was an emptiness in her side and a coldness in her palm. For as long as she could remember, she had held her twin sister by her side. Although the two of them had known nothing save for one another in the darkness before the world, she had been content, for there was nothing else she had known.
I feel as if that’s a bad sign for how Little Sister is faring nowadays given that she’s being spoken of in past tense repeatedly. Though I’m just realizing that this is essentially a much more dramatic and less willing version of the whole “10-year old going off and seeing the world” arc that’s omnipresent in Pokémon media.
But this time, she opened her eyes and saw a brilliant light in the sky. For a moment, she hesitated. If she chased this light and her sister returned while she was gone, would her sister then wander off to look for her? Was it not more pressing to find her only companion? But the light was so unlike anything that she had ever seen, and even as she took a step into the darkness to see where her sister had gone, she could now see her shadow cast ahead of her, framed by that light.
Perhaps, she reasoned, her sister would also seek out the light. And then the two of them would be together once more.
She’s dead in the present day, isn’t she?
So she braced herself, and for the first time, she began to walk with direction. Before long, she reached a vast chasm, one that she could not possibly cross. Seeing this, she hesitated. When the Dragonmother had given all the peoples of the world gifts, Little Sister had been forgotten. Her oldest sister had always protected her from the dark, and Little Sister had always been afraid to venture out of her sister’s shadow. But she could not hesitate now. Kneeling down, she dipped her head to the grass beneath her feet, and she closed her eyes, and she whispered, ‘Please hear me, oh great grass. I need to reach the light beyond you and use it to find my sister. Could you lend me your aid?’
Oh, the Dragonmother is the Original Dragon of this world, huh? Another one of those things that I’m very belated realizing right now.
The grass stirred at her words, and a great spirit emerged: Aranu, the First Maractus. Aranu smiled kindly at Little Sister and then plucked a flower from his head and threw it to the ground. Immediately, it sprouted into an enormous branch that grew and grew until it spanned the chasm, sturdy and strong enough for anyone to walk upon it. Thus Little Sister and the First Maractus planted the First Seeds.
Oh, so Little Sister is the originating figure for the protagonist’s tribe or whatever, huh?
She walked further, and the grasses guided her, and soon she reached a dark tunnel that even the brilliant light above could not penetrate. Her frail eyes could not guide her through the darkness, and though she strained and strained, she could see nothing. Kneeling down, she clasped her hands to her heart, and she whispered, ‘Please hear me, oh great warmth. I need to reach the light above you and use it to find my sister. Could you lend me your aid?’
The air rumbled at her words, and a great spirit emerged: Melai, the First Darmanitan. Melai smiled warmly at Little Sister and exhaled a puff of embers for her to cup in her hands. When she held it, it burst into a bright light that she could carry with her into the dark. Thus Little Sister and the First Darmanitan tended the First Flames.
Did the protagonist’s people migrate from Icirrus to around Route 4? Since they sure have a lot of things about their culture that vibe as Icirrus-isms, while at the same time, they have a mythos that I’m pretty sure is going to enumerate the various Pokémon that live around them in the desert and how they came into being.
So she entered the darkness, with the fire to light her way, until she came to a vast plain. The horizon seemed to stretch on endlessly, and yet the light was further ahead still, and plunging out of sight. Little Sister felt desperation fill her—if she lost the light now, all this would be for nothing. Kneeling down, she bowed her head to the earth, and she exhaled, and she whispered, ‘Please hear me, oh great earth. I need to reach the light in you and use it to find my sister. Could you lend me your aid?’
The earth trembled at her words, and a great spirit emerged: Zaathi, the first Krookodile. Zaathi smiled widely at Little Sister, and a tear slipped from her enormous snout. When it hit the ground, it blossomed into an enormous flood of water, so vast and powerful that it cut through the parched earth and surged towards the horizon. Thus Little Sister and the First Krookodile bounded the First River.
Ah yes, our first Krookodile Tear of the story. Considering the title, I can already tell that we’re going to be revisiting this tale a few more times in the future.
So she was borne, and at long last, she reached the end of the world. She had drawn close enough to the light that she had to thrust an arm up to shield herself, for it was brilliant. As she grew closer, though, she lowered her arm—the sound of her sister’s voice was unmistakable.
‘Sister?’ asked Little Sister. ‘What are you doing here?’
‘I realized,’ replied Sun simply, ‘why we were made.’ And for a moment her sister’s brilliant light faded, and her form was revealed a little. Radiant white wings glowed brighter than anything Little Sister had ever seen. Sun smiled sadly. ‘You were made to do great things, and I, to illuminate you.’
This is a myth about that Volcarona that served as a surrogate sun during a volcanic winter, isn’t it? Since that description definitely sounds similar there.
This did not make much sense to Little Sister. ‘Can I stay with you?’ she asked.
‘Look at all the beautiful things you have seen and done.’ Sun pointed at the beautiful world that was beginning to form below them. ‘All of that without me.’
‘Beautiful things that I could not see without your light,’ Little Sister replied petulantly. ‘We should be together. That is how we were always meant to be.’
‘But if we are always together, how could you do so much? How could my light guide you?’
‘Come back with me,’ Little Sister pleaded. ‘We belong with one another.’
Sun:
Even if I’m going to go ahead and guess that this is going to turn into a Volcarona origin story in like two paragraphs.
Sun was brave and strong, but she never had it in her heart to refuse her younger sister. So she alighted. No sooner had her feet touched the earth than the radiance faded from her and her wings fell away. Little Sister was overjoyed, and held Sun close to her, and the two of them slept soundly.
For a few days, all was well. Little Sister was happy. But in the darkness, she heard a great cry of anguish. Little Sister looked back to where Sun slept, but Sun did not stir. The crying continued, and finally, Little Sister braced herself and felt her way back through the darkness again.
Little Sister:
Soon, she stumbled across a desiccated husk. She felt leathery bark crumble away beneath her hands, and she sensed Aranu’s presence beside her. The First Maractus mourned the dying of the First Tree; his sorrow was so great that all the grasses had withered away as well.
Melai soon joined them, although her face was shrouded in her shadow and even her gleaming eyes could barely illuminate the dark and the cold around them. Without the brilliant light above to guide her, the First Darmanitan could not produce flames.
Background Darmanitan: “Wait, what? No, we can produce fire perfectly fine without sunlight-”
Sahnim: “Shut up, you’re ruining a heartfelt moment with my son right now.” >_>;
But Zaathi was nowhere to be found. In the silence between Aranu’s cries, Little Sister could still hear the rushing of the river.
Heart heavy, she trudged home, and shook Sun to rouse her.
‘Sister,’ she said. ‘You were right. The world needs you. You must go be who you were meant to be.’
But Sun, tightly curled, did not stir. She had spent too much time in the earth’s embrace, and the darkness had sapped her strength. She still glowed faintly, but her body was like it had turned to stone. Little Sister shivered. The darkness was growing only colder, and Little Sister’s mind was numb with despair.
Oh, so this is the episode that the protagonist was referencing when he was wondering if he’d break down like Little Sister.
The thought of the river bearing her to the horizon, never faltering, ever constant, gave Little Sister strength for what she needed to do next. Sun would need to be returned to the edge of the world, and Little Sister would need to be the one to do it. She could not ask the others, who had already lent her so much.
So, with her sister on her back, Little Sister climbed across the vast chasm and felt her way through the dark tunnel. It took nearly all of the strength she had to reach the river, where her hardest task awaited her:
Arms trembling, Little Sister hugged Sun close, and then cast her into the river that led to the edge of the world.
Is this an “origin of the sunrise/sunset” story? Since this feels like an “origin of the sunrise/sunset” story.
Also, you sure have a knack for writing convincing-sounding folklore. Since if it weren’t for the namedrop of Pokémon species in Sahnim’s tale, it’d sound like an actual folktale from IRL.
“Little Sister and Sun love each other very much. Their cyclic dance gives us everything we know. In that moment where the sun embraces the horizon, the world is full of their color, their beauty, their joy. But it is not like that forever. That was when I understood why your mother cradled the snow.”
Yeah, I knew it. Though cute story there.
You choke back a sob.
Aaaaaand right back to depression-land we go. Even if a part of me wonders if we should’ve seen a little more of the protagonist’s inner thought process a bit more as the story was being told. Maybe. I can understand the argument that it might have taken us out of the whole “you are hearing a story relayed to you” vibe that the present version has.
“Little flurry, the things we love are only ours to hold, not to have,” he whispers into your scalp. “One day, we must let them go.”
I take it that this story was also meant for the Sahnim’s self to some extent since… yeah, that’s definitely also applicable for him at this moment.
In response, you clutch him tighter.
At some point, you fall asleep in his arms.
D’aww, how sweet-
Samira:
Right, time for that parting of ways bright and early the next day, huh?
When you awake, your father is breaking down the remains of your camp, scattering the burnt scrub brushes into the dunes, folding his cloak back up around his shoulders. He stoops carefully, slowly, but eventually his work is done. Wearily, he picks up his staff, and he is the sanhim again. “It’s time.”
What you want is to run away. Not even to save yourself; just anything to save your father the shame of having to accept this judgment you have brought upon yourself, upon him. You knew long ago that you would have big shoes to fill, but now with this stain you know you’ll never fill them. But that should be your shame to bear, not his.
Oh, so protag has also wrecked his chances of being a future sahnim from his earlier transgressions. We’re just piling on all the knife twists in this story, huh?
What you want to do is tell him all the things you wish a son could say. You want to reassure him that this isn’t his fault, that you’ll learn his lessons well, that one day he’ll be proud of you again. There’s a hollowness in your heart, but it can’t stop you from seeing the way the shame you created craters his shoulders.
What you do instead is echo, “It’s time.”
Cue the theme music:
Your face is like a mask. The rest of the morning blurs. Samira emerges from the sands. She exchanges quiet words with the sanhim. Nali throws her arms around your leg, her spines carefully withdrawn. You do not cry when the sanhim bids you farewell; all your tears came the night before.
Samira: “Was the depressing pop music in the background really necessary right now?”
Protag: “Look, can we just get this over with?”
The sanhim shakes his cloak out and wraps it around your shoulders. Your heart catches. This is a gift you are not meant to receive until you are a man. You look up, mouth cracked open in protest, before he says, “This cloak is not what makes me sanhim to our people, Baku; nor will it make you a leader to theirs. But what it will do is keep you warm, little flurry, and it will keep us with you.” He finishes arranging the cloak around you and takes a step back. “May the sands be kind.”
Well, not like it hasn’t already been obvious since the sequence with their last night together, but I suppose that’s a sign that for as painful as this all is, that the sahnim genuinely loves his child. I’m honestly impressed at how much you managed to communicate in between the lines in a relatively short chapter like this.
Samira circles in front of you, the fins on her back rippling in the sunrise. You look to the sanhim before you can stop yourself, and he jerks his chin forward in response.
You shouldn’t have asked him. Soon you won’t have him to fall back on. Carefully, you swing one leg over the krookodile’s waiting back—the gap between her fins is large enough for you to lay down in, so you kneel unsteadily on the slow-heaving scales. It’s cooler than you expected, rows and rows of rippling muscle, and then she plunges forward, halfway submerged in the sands. Her tail swishes out a low, sweeping rhythm.
You keep your back straight and your eyes straight ahead.
Hey, look on the bright side, protag, you get to be a badass sand croc rider for the next yea-
Protag: “Not helping right now!” >.<
Alright, made it to the end. Just need a moment to get some sand out of my eyes…
Okay, we’re good, let’s get right into highlight reel. The long and short of things is that I liked this piece, it’s a touching and haunting story where we see a child having to grapple with the consequences of a rash choice. Like yeah, the specific backdrop is quite alien and fantastical relative to everyday life or even the present day in Pokémon’s setting, but the actual emotions are still relatable and it’s surprisingly easy to put oneself into the shoes of the protagonist and let the second person PoV do its thing. The Unovan folklore you cooked up for this chapter was also top notch, like it feels very “yes, people would actually tell stories like this in pre-modern Unova”, and I hope that we’ll get to see more now that the protagonist is going to be spending at least a year chilling with Krookodile in the desert. I was also impressed at the sheer amount of information that you managed to communicate, both directly and in between the lines in a little over 5000 words. Also, while I might be a little biased, but I thought that your use of second person perspective for the narration was particularly well done.
Honestly, there were not a lot of things that stood out to me as weaknesses with this chapter. Like yeah, a part of it was me just getting really into things, but it was just genuinely a very polished chapter. If I had to force myself to pick things that I’d disagreed with, I noticed that there were some paragraphs that felt really, really long in this chapter. To the point that they made me question if they needed to be delivered in a big, continuous block like that, but there’s some degree of “my story, my style” to be had from author to author. A part of me also wonders if we should’ve seen more of the protagonist’s thought process in the sequence where his father is relaying the tale of Little Sister and the Sun to him, but I can understand the argument for not doing that in a second-person PoV story. While it makes the protagonist fade out from the chapter for a while, if we’re going full “the protagonist is you”, it does allow us to fill in the blanks ourselves in the protagonist’s place. I suppose it’s basically all a function of the extent to which you intended for the protagonist to exist as a distinct personality outside of the reader that’s sharing his/her eyes.
As you can gather from the above commentary, but I quite liked this opening chapter, @kintsugi . Like it’s obviously not a happy story at the moment, but it had a lot of love and thought put into it and it didn’t take particularly long before I started getting really engrossed into the story.
I honestly regret waiting this long to finally take a plunge on this story, and I hope to have the time to come back for the rest during this event. But until then, Happy Blitzmas, and best of luck with your continued writing endeavors.