Search results

[[Just wanted to drop this quote in here as interesting potential evidence that elyvorg might be on to something with him having been a jack of all trades - asking for people to speculate about "what a person with this or that or the other ability might wanna do" could apply to anyone, but...

[[ANYWAY I am off to try to skim through the whole thread since D1 start to squint at Wes and Inkedust's posts in particular, as well as potentially a couple more people]]

[[Another wild hilarious what-if scenario that just occurred to me: what if Chappie is a town bus driver, and Rascal was also a town bus driver, who also swapped somebody with Lexx - either also Spark, or someone else that the mafia would want to target - and then Rascal died that night too for...

[[Just quickly acknowledging that yeah, Seren totally did have the arsonist theory originally! It was dismissed then because it was before Chappie's swap claim, so at that time, thinking it was the arsonist being that worried about being caught out by Lexx while the mafia targeted Rascal (or...

"And again, it's not that I think this is likelier than Chappie just being mafia, but it's something vaguely sensible to work with if she's not."

"I mean, if it was the arsonist, there's no possibility about it, he must have been primed on night zero, when the arsonist didn't know about Nefari yet. So obviously that would've been just as likely to be someone non-Nefari. And igniting N1 is suboptimal but if they saw Lexx as a serious...

Dave looked up at the air above the tree, scowling. He usually tried his best to ignore the fucking god-entities so they could just get on with it, but it was harder with these shitheads actually addressing him. "I mean, it doesn't, but we've got nearly twenty people in this thing and who knows...

"Or the mafia went for you, and Mewtwo healed you."

[[Oh no I've caught Negrek's unfinished sentences disease, I'm not even sure exactly what I was planning to write there]]

The Archopy had yet another confident theory about how he'd solved everything, and as irritating as he was, some of it did kind of make sense. Sure would explain that bizarre fucking swap thing. "Given it seems like swapper over here's just checked out altogether and is dramatically asking to...

[[No, elyvorg's logic is that if Chappie flips mafia, this may cast suspicion on Spark/Braixen. The basis for this is that if Chappie is mafia, the whole gambit where Chappie emotionally claims bus driver who swapped Lexx and Spark becomes sort of a funny thing for the mafia to pull - why draw...

[[Yeah, I wouldn’t want to treat Rascal being Hider as more confirmed than it is... there are other explanations for multiple kills on N1. I don’t think that changes much, though.]]

[[Yeah, Jesse having been the vigilante occurred to me as well. But I will also say I don’t think a vig should necessarily claim here? They’d be another very juicy town target, and all claiming the Lusamine kill would do is dispel the notion it was the arsonist, which I think is easily...

[[By the way, since the doctors have revealed anyway, it might be a good idea to hear who they targeted on the previous nights, to verify/illuminate things/uncover any other inconsistencies. @HelloYellow17 @Equitial ?]]

[[Oh, and the Lusamine arsonist kill theory also requires the arsonist to ignore the fact it appeared like we’d killed the arsonist yesterday, which would have been the perfect cover for them to keep dousing uninterrupted while DW picks rolestopper instead of firefighter, and instead announce...

[[I think it’s highly unlikely Lusamine was killed by the arsonist. Again, this would require the arsonist to have chosen not to douse the person who can become firefighter, and to choose to inefficiently ignite early after it’s been widely discussed in the thread that this would be suboptimal...

[[Assuming this means Dave, he is human here and would be positively incensed to know this alien thinks there is anything remotely doggy about him, what the fuck are you talking about]]

[[But yeah, Wes being a mafia doctor whose purpose is to cause healer clashes is also consistent! In that case the first post would have been made to plant the seeds of the claim while hoping for the town doctor to step forward.]]

[[Additionally: if Wes and Mewtwo are both mafia, it strikes me as surprising they'd even come up with healer clash as a convoluted explanation for this kill, seeing as the main wiki referenced for roles here doesn't mention healer clash, and my impression has been it's not really a common...

[[Okay this was a lot to read. Listen to elyvorg, I think she's got something very plausible going. Chappie's claim has been bugging me too and this actually does tie that up neatly with a ribbon. The one deviation from that is I actually completely believe Wes's healer claim now. The...