Search results

[[Eh fuck it I really don't want a Maddie bus to win as my #1 priority. And I should give more consideration to evil Drake if I trust Dave now anyway, which I had not adequately considered. This will read as wishy-washy. Sucks to be me, I'm just gonna have to live with that reality. I still...

"Well, I fully understand the risk I'm taking of digging my own grave even deeper by asking for more claims, but I genuinely think we're best off with an open setup by now. The minor Monk ambiguity certain scumteams might've experience was the last bit of redeeming value there and, well..."...

"Well, I tried not to, and then I was pressed on why I trusted one and was being accused of being scum alongside the other two. There were three unclaimed players left. At least one of them is going to be scum, and I believed the dog could only be innocent if both were. As far as I understood...

[[phrasing correction: Innocent of being the demon. Still a possible minion.]]

[[No and no. It's if I'm NOT poisoned or lying that Perse is innocent. I was counting on my N0 redcheck being accurate and my N1 greencheck being poisoned. If I was never poisoned at all, am not drunk, and am not lying then Perse is innocent and Wind is my false flag. Abstaining is not the way...

[[I'm considering the latter two, they're the 'either reason'. Poisoned more highly than scum since she seems more like lying town unless Free's wiki playstyle theory is true. If we have a living drunk then that frightens me. It's not open and shut, though. But I don't want to kill Madeline...

[[hhhh fuck maybe I'm letting my 'what if Rui isn't drunk (for either reason that could be)' fear pull my reigns too much]]

[[Yeah, completely understandable. I feel like my trust in their results is gonna be pretty low no matter what, especially because we don't really have any disputed claims and even if they're town they'd just be a poisoner magnet the one or two nights when we hit scum. And if they say we hit...

[[Thank you. Barring the fucking insane negative utility play of poisoning their own demon N1 just to put Dave over, something that is wildly implausible, we can be certain they shot Odette and failed.]]

"It would give Elegym line of sight on me. Does that produce any interesting results? With all the options to produce false results in play, I'm pretty sure I'm the only one who'd have confidence in the results. I'm not sure how much good that will do us at this point. If we want a read on me...

[[tbc I think Chibi could be scum without Rui, especially if she was poisoned. Not vice versa, though. I'm not comfortable with the theory that they're both evil bc it feels a bit 'crackpot'. I have got to decide who to vote for. I don't think I can continue gunning for Madeline in good faith...

Morgan muttered a curse under her breath before forcing a smile. “Oh, whoops~ Damn, here I was hoping Noivern thought my reasoning bore their scrutiny because they knew their action corroborated it.” A mistake. Now she was blindsided and on the back foot. Did she still trust the Noivern? The...

[[*currently believed. Not beloved. Fear not there are no lovers in this game. Anyway, the crux of my argument is this: If the Flygon/uA scumteam hypothesis is to hold up to scrutiny, Free’s only viable claims are Soldier or Monk. I also believe the window for her to claim Soldier probably...

“I believe you’ve left something unconsidered in attributing evil to two out of three unclaimed character. You are, however unintentionally, attributing the failed kill to the dog. If he’s the soldier, and believes himself to have been targeted by evil for his experience, he should have...

[[Oh, also, forgot to include this: No matter what the roles are under the hood, I firmly believe you're having a shit time of this. I'm sorry about, earnestly. I've felt similarly before, during the slow crawl towards an inevitable loss in Vanilla Mafia. It was the last game I played for four...

Morgan's eye lit up. "I forgot! Thank you, Rocky! That's incredibly helpful!" "It'd be like sitting down at a poker table, getting dealt a pair of aces, and folding to convince everyone you have crap. It'll technically be persuasive, sure, but you'll have forfeited the advantage of having a...

[[It had yet to occur to me that if you’re a demon you have worse luck than me at this point, not that I’m gonna go do a gambler’s fallacy about it.]]

[[It is possible that I was poisoned N0, aer/Elegym N1, and I was protected/evil stumbled into an unrelated killblock but given the obscurity of my claim I don’t think I’d be the top protection candidate and targeting a clear power role would be the least random explanation for the no kill. It’s...

“Quite the other way around: I think I was poisoned because Elegym was meant to die. In other words, I expect we were both targets, and that this is the explanation for there being no kill tonight. I was far less likely to have been protected, so they would’ve otherwise had to get unlucky and...

[[mmm fair yeah I shouldn’t do that]]