Search results

[[Another thing I think suggests that this is a solved game where they were hoping I would do something other than redcheck Elegym: The entire proposed scumteam has MIA since I redchecked Elegym over 24h ago. Aside from one post from aer with their expected result 3m after daystart this has just...

[[I looked into this yesterday, but not only does it invalidate the demon ping I had on Maddie that started all this but also I saw Chibi as nondemon on the same night aer greenchecked Maddie. (I assume this is bc it was the day after they lost their poisoner and wanted the one night lapse in...

Morgan sighed and pressed a tendril to her chin as if holding up her head with a hand. She was ready for the game to end. "Well, the way I see it, I just saw Elegym as the demon twice in a row, both times alongside someone I've seen as clean before. If you wanna argue we should kill Maddie...

"Ah, it was you again, of course~ Same as last time I wanted to check one person!" [[Apparently I've been wrong about the false positive being a random townsfolk, it's any random good. I have no idea where I got that in my head? So I've been overconfident until I checked a moment ago that it...

Morgan held up the tendril with her looplet affixed to it for inspection. It was, miraculously, intact. She gave it a little kiss, just for dramatic effect. The amount of people openly declaring trust in her should have been a death sentence— It wasn't everyone, but it was enough people to swing...

Morgan giggled to herself. "Great, glad we've reached the point of collective insanity where we're not just heavily scrutinizing each other's actual or possible actions, but also writing alternate universe fan-fiction about each other and scrutinizing each other's hypothetical in timelines that...

Morgan grinned at the new arrival. "Ooh, I like this dog. And not just because he agrees with me~" That much was true. He had a conviction and a dedication to the way he presented himself that she simply didn't believe existed outside personas. Which made him a bird of a feather, in a way...

[[Although to be clear if Elegym is Demon then my (and JFought's) current understanding appears to be that Chibi is Scarlet Woman which'd render the whole voting Elegym first gambit pretty redundant, so I'm firm on Honse first. Wish SW was disabled at ELo but oh well.]] [[Sympathies. Heat waves...

[[JFought is subbing in for ZRD/Hareta (not aer) and is the Washerwoman. aer is Elegym, our claimed Empath.]]

[[Yeah sure why not]]

[[That is indeed how it usually works, although I wrote up and deleted something about recalling someone saying it was randomized when I couldn't source the quote, so I wonder where both Wind and I got that impression... Worth asking Inke about it probably? At worst she can't answer which'd be...

[[Even Chibi's posting isn't positing that we're at Elim or Lose right now if they're town. I don't think this is a concern I can understand, sorry.]]

[[*through]] Morgan tried her best to lock eyes with Rocky, although she wasn't sure if those really were eyes on the front of his head. "I'm serious here. I've humoured your complex about the horse so far because you don't seem to be plausibly evil. But if you really want to try to pull our...

"Okay, yeah, that's why I'm voting for them. I mean, what possible two-person evil team do you see that doesn't include them? They're all pretty far-fetched. The only one I can see is Maddie and Elegym, which'd be bizarre given the claimed redcheck. If you called it as Elegym and I then you have...

[[uhh disregards this subsentence it's absolute nonsense, a Minion Horse is more likely in either evil pairing. I'd later realize this— I started this post incorrectly assuming I'd come to a different conclusion before I wrote out the tables and changed my answer... I wrote that sentence in an...

"Now that's what I call simplifying the game state~ Although if Elegym was our only scum, then both minions, poisoner included, are dead. So if the Horse was good here, I'd think the poisoner'd had flipped still, and I don't know who that'd be. So I think we could simplify it further, from where...

[[Phrasing correction: possibly drunk, my intended point being that they're not speculating that they're poisoned by a poisoner that'd almost certainly be dead due to that being logically impossible.]]

"Eh. I don't feel the need to put too much stock in that. Horsie wouldn't wanna tie themself to the rat's sinking ship. Rat's gotta act appropriately pissed about being flipped evil in turn or they've got no reason to exist. Evils'll bicker with each other on the regular to create distance. I'll...

[[This is not relevant to this game but the hypothetical where I ended up the killing role, with Perse on my team being scumread to filth and surviving by way of us having higher priorities, while we struggle to kill before the third night is hilarious bc it's just reverse-engineering the events...

[[You can fake it, and nothing will happen. The main caveat there is that nobody's considering a Perselyn mafia bc we're neighbours and were fighting for a while there.]]