Seventh Anniversary Mafia

[Chibi Pika]

[[I'm working on other responses but I want to flag that the Undertaker can be Drunk according to the wiki, not sure why they wouldn't be. Like so:]]

Glastrier stomped a hoof. "No, I refer to the fact that as I believe Drake must be evil, and therefore the intel I received this morning was accurate. It would be strange if, as the drunk, I received accurate information one night and inaccurate information the previous night. Therefore, I am not drunk."

[[Alright, upon rereading, technically there is no rule that says the storyteller can't sometimes give true intel to the drunk but it feels... weird? Idk it just doesn't feel like a useful train of thought.]]

 

[Chibi Pika]

"Unless you are suggesting that, as the drunk, my information could be wrong because Drake was actually the poisoner, and not the scarlet woman?"

[[Okay I admit I'd been assuming that incorrect intel would be across alignment lines, but I guess that's not actually a hard rule either. Still doesn't feel likely though.]]

 

[Shiny Phantump]

“Phew. We got one. Maybe. At least, I hope so. The horse’s information aligns with mine reasonably well. I inspected them alongside the rat, since I expected to be told that either a minion or demon died no matter what and wanted to see if my results lined up. They do! We’re all clear~”

Of course, the fact that everyone’s info lined up and seemed true kind of posed it’s own little problem, didn’t it?

“However, given that Elegym serves as rock solid proof a Poisoner is in play, and most likely has backed off targeting them, the new question becomes: Who was more important to target than her?”

Morgan fought off the urge to visibly grimace. After yesterday, she’d prefer to get to talk about literally anything else today. But there wasn’t much choice.

“It doesn’t make sense to poison a passive role. Either it’s the horse, and we just killed our mayor, me and the horse is a probable demon and the Scarlet Woman thing is called into question anyway, or it’s actually the Elegym this night and not last night, in which case what the fuck. I don’t like any of these options, frankly, they all suck ass. I don’t want any of these to be true.”

 

[Shiny Phantump]

[[Tbh when I say “is in play” I mean “is in the setup” and not “is currently alive” so I could toy with the odds of Drunk Honse and dead Poisoner leaving us in a state with no poison (but a drunk honse) although I don’t think that’s our most realistic line.]]

 

[unrepentantAuthor]

I inspected them alongside the rat, since I expected to be told that either a minion or demon died no matter what and wanted to see if my results lined up. They do! We’re all clear~”

[[Please clarify. Are you saying you targeted Drake/Honse last night and were told neither is the Demon?? Also, why would you inspect a dead player??]]

 

[Shiny Phantump]

Please clarify. Are you saying you targeted Drake/Honse last night and were told neither is the Demon?? Also, why would you inspect a dead player??

“Yep! I thought about doing the same Rocky test as yesterday but it felt like a waste of my second target. I thought about you but once I thought about how I and everyone else would interpret the results I realized it wasn’t going to be very useful. I considered a pure test of poisoning with Rocky and Rui since I figured a town horse would be a higher priority to poison than me. But I settled on this, because being able to check which kind of evil Drake might be and compare it against what type of evil Horse might be would make it harder to fabricate information.”

 

[Shiny Phantump]

[[Dead demons should still ping as demons. If a demon dies and a Scarlet Woman inherits then both just ping as demons. Wiki states this clearly and I see no reason Inke would change that.]]

 

[Shiny Phantump]

what type of evil Horse might be

[[Fucking. Says they might be. I slept like garbage and am tired.]]

 

[aer]

[[ughhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh]]

 

[unrepentantAuthor]

[[ughhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh]]

[[Welcome to Mafia! :D ]]

 

[Flyg0n]

[[Also the scum need the mayor to be executed during the day so while not defending isn't a guarantee of sus, it is worth considering that someone gunning for the mayor figured out who I was and pushed for my execution. That would be... Dave and Phan who first joined

I'm feeling less and less keen about you. If you're scum that means chibi is, and probably... One of either Phan or Perse, we can't have both. And we never did actually clear Rui imo-

ARE YOU KIDDING

FREAKIN NVM GOTCHA

"It is a waste of time to listen to the rat. He was the holder of the Prolong Emera

Vote: Chibi

We'll THIS means Jackie isn't it and chibi also probably lied about freakin Rui what the frick? I suppose a scum undertaker would tell the truth st least once to garner that but frick no I'm not buying this garbage after yesterday
]]

 

[unrepentantAuthor]

make it harder to fabricate information

Dead demons should still ping as demons.

[[Oh okay this makes enough sense to me, I guess... In your position I would've been more interested in narrowing down our next target by finding a ping somewhere, but this is valid too I think? So we believe quite firmly that Drake was either SW or Psnr. Which I already believed. But more interestingly, dead honse isn't the Demon, so. That pretty much rules out the possibility that my preferred 'world' is real...

What were the odds on Morgan being Drunk, btw? Does that check out in any version of a scum!Rui world...? Hhhhhh.]]

 

[unrepentantAuthor]

Vote: Chibi

@Inkedust bc Tetra didn't ping you

[[also holy shit i need to think about what this post/vote means]]

 

[Flyg0n]

Glastrier stomped a hoof. "No, I refer to the fact that as I believe Drake must be evil, and therefore the intel I received this morning was accurate. It would be strange if, as the drunk, I received accurate information one night and inaccurate information the previous night. Therefore, I am not drunk."

[[Alright, upon rereading, technically there is no rule that says the storyteller can't sometimes give true intel to the drunk but it feels... weird? Idk it just doesn't feel like a useful train of thought.]]

IM NOT LETTING THIS GARBAGE SLIDE

And I'm not letting this drunk nonsense slide with blatant lie that I know is a lie.

Of course you're not drunk when you're lying and covering. This probably means
... Scum Perse given the red check, unless Phan lied good, and we actually DID get Rui and scum undertaker lied to make it sound like we didn't get scum]]

Frick frick I gotta go for a bit back to work stuff. Work always getting in the way of mafia]]

 

[Flyg0n]

"Unless you are suggesting that, as the drunk, my information could be wrong because Drake was actually the poisoner, and not the scarlet woman?"

[[Okay I admit I'd been assuming that incorrect intel would be across alignment lines, but I guess that's not actually a hard rule either. Still doesn't feel likely though.]]

[[EASY ANSWER HORSE IS LIAR

A LIAR WHO COVERED FOR RUI

Real convenient that if after everyone came out after the first night and we killed Rui we just straight on the drunk Rui theory and good chibi. Of course you cleared Rui the first night because we GAVE you plausible deniability with the drunk theory]]

 

[Flyg0n]

[[Anyways I have to go for real but Arceus himself and mega flygon won't convince me you played yourself and I've caught you, it'd too late for you to be anything but scum]]

 

[HelloYellow17]

[[Anyways I have to go for real but Arceus himself and mega flygon won't convince me you played yourself and I've caught you, it'd too late for you to be anything but scum]]

[[I’m confused, what was the lie you caught? You can’t just say “You’re lying and I caught you in a lie!” Unless I’m missing something?]]

 

[HelloYellow17]

[[Y’all the tunneling on “scum Rui” is laughable and makes me convinced more than EVER that Tetra and Jackie are a scumteam. I’m at work so it’ll be a bit, but I will elaborate later.]]

 

[Chibi Pika]

Glastrier was unimpressed. "It is interesting to me that you are so certain of this, when in the world where you were innocent, you would want to be sure that there were no other explanations of why my information was wrong."

[[If Drake isn't scum then I literally don't think there are any scumeams that would even work anymore considering that I think Morgan/Madeline and Mal/Morgan are impossible. Sorry, but no. I think this is just flailing.]]

 

[unrepentantAuthor]

EASY ANSWER HORSE IS LIAR

Malachai chuckled, his laugh reverberating with infrasound.

"I love the passion in your arguments, little rat. Such conviction! I must say, I would be willing to credit a scenario in which the horse covered for the Leafeon... but that leaves the matter of our third villain, if it's truly not you... but at least we both agree that the horse must go. Hmm. I would be astonished if you were a villain wasting your final deathless vote on your ally, but it is not impossible..."

[[We've never played with ghost players before, so I don't know whether this level of fire is what you'd expect from either a dead townie or dead mafioso. I'm genuinely excited to find out. I don't like the look of this Drake-on-horse vote, it makes me wonder whether I'm being juked by scum!Tetra or whether she actually was town somehow and if so who the fuck is the third mafia?? God, this fucking game.]]

makes me convinced more than EVER that Tetra and Jackie are a scumteam

"Well, that makes no sense to me at all. I tried very hard to get the rat killed, and it's not as if it even bought me any real credibility. Personally, I wouldn't favour an elaborate strategy of killing my teammates and getting killed in turn when coordinating against threats bears out better in the long run. Readily throwing one's evil teammates under the motor carriage seems too costly a stratagem in this game for my liking."