• Welcome to Thousand Roads! You're welcome to view discussions or read our stories without registering, but you'll need an account to join in our events, interact with other members, or post one of your own fics. Why not become a member of our community? We'd love to have you!

    Join now!

  • Our "Weird and Wonderful" one-shot contest is now underway! Pokémon are strange and magical creatures, and for our writing contest this year, we want to see you higlight some of their oddest abilities and features! From stories about luxray thieves using X-ray vision to scope out targets to those about trainers bewitching opponents with their stantlers' mystic antlers, any sort of fic featuring a pokémon's unusual lore is welcome! See full details here.

Pokémon Trading Card Game 2: Doduo Adventures (Complete)

Chapter 1 - Part 2: Water & Fire

133TFR33k

Creator of the Doduo Alliance
Partners
  1. doduo
Chapter 1 - Part 2: Water & Fire

(17)

Upon entering, I noticed the floor was comprised of small seashells that had been flattened and presumably cemented to the floor. There were a couple large puddles in the entrance room.

I visited the lobby for my routine water. Apparently the water from this fountain directly connects to an enriched aquifer deep below the ground. This water was simply the very model of refinement! As for the rest of the lobby, it had a mixture of small blue tiles, yellow tiles, and brown tiles and a couple tiny pools with blue glass orbs with a black water energy symbol in them sitting on top of small pillars in each pool.

I then made my way into the main area of the fortress. The first room had a pool of water surrounding a raised platform connected to both the exit and entrance by wooden plank bridges. The floor was more seashells.

Doduo jumped into the water and began to swim around the perimeter of the room.

In the center of the platform was another fanatic by the name of Jacob. He had dark short hair, was wearing swim trunks, no shirt, and a pair of silver googles resting above his eyes on his head with big red letters on the lenses: 'G R'. He looked to be about ten years old.

TCG2_Senta_Win.png

The moment he began speaking, it became evident to me that his tedious tirade of how water energy is the best energy type would not be ending any time soon! Thankfully his eyes remained shut as he confidently droned on. In fact he was so distracted by his own speech that I was able to simply walk right past him into the next room! Thankful that I need not endure his inane ramblings, I made my way to the next chamber.

Doduo swam quickly leaping out of the water and onto the bridge as it followed.

The next chamber was massive and housed a glorious and impressive waterfall of epic proportions! The height of this room must have been upwards of fifty feet! Along the sides of the waterfall were natural rock cliffs! There was a large platform in the middle connected to the entrance and exit by small wooden plank bridges. The platform was surrounded by water except for the side near the entrance. The floor was more of the trademark seashells. There was a third bridge that connected to the waterfall which appeared to cover an entrance to another room!

Doduo ran full speed into the waterfall! It then began to run up the waterfall! Once it got to the top, it flung itself down onto one of the rocks below. It looked immensely painful. I honestly have no idea how it survives these things! Shortly after, it picked itself up and hobbled about with a look of pleasure upon its faces. It released an absurd amount of feathers during this stunt.

I would have loved to linger in this place but I noticed the all-too-excited gaze of another would-be duelist by the name of Cody. He wore a blue wet-suit and a black bandana with the GR logo. His skin was significantly tanned from sun exposure. He looked to be maybe seventeen.

TCG2_Miyajima.png

The vice imposed upon this fellow was such that he should glorify all things Magikarp! He insisted that a fabulous treasure lay beyond the bridge and cave behind the waterfall, but only those with four Magikarp in their decks may lay eyes upon it.

I glanced the other direction and noticed a sign that read "This way to the leader's chamber" I gave one look to the hopeful Magikarp fanatic and one look to the room's exit and quickly stepped away as he desperately spoke as fast as he can trying to sway my opinion on Magikarp. He then quickly began offering me many different things to stay and duel him, but the more desperate he became, the more suspicious I became.

He then started to try to give me pencils, hats, drink coasters and small car chargers - all of them Magikarp themed - but I knew the game; accept anything and it becomes a form of psychological entrapment meant to lure you in to listen to their supposedly short speech that would no doubt last hours! Once that happens its only a matter of time before they try reeling you in to purchase a questionable time share and running your credit without asking! Oh I’m sure his gift card for listening to his sales pitch would be real, but to a far greater extent would be my regret of the time wasted!

Fully expecting this used-car-salesman of a duelist to follow me throughout the entire rest of the fortress, I indicated to him that I might duel him on my way out if he waited patiently. Thank the stars it seemed to have worked! I quickly made my way deeper into the fortress.

The next room initially appeared to be unoccupied. It was a long room full of water, some small platforms, and long wooden plank bridges connecting them. Our of the water in several locations scattered about the room were rock pillars. The floor was the same as the previous rooms.

Doduo leaped to the nearest pillar landing on it gracefully. It then began leaping from pillar to pillar with great finesse. When it got to the final pillar, it failed, massively plunging headlong into the rock and sliding down into the water. I loomed over the edge to see it floating with several bubbles coming up. I considered jumping in to help it but it rolled over and let itself float around while it breathed. It looked satisfied, so I decided to ignore it.

Just as I was about to make my way towards the next room, A figure dramatically flipped from the depths of the water onto a nearby platform and with one of the most absurd poses I have ever seen, my foe declared himself as Alex. He wore a green wet-suit and a snorkel mask connected to oxygen tanks. He was wearing a black swim-cap and goggles for his eyes. He was a bit chubby. His gear made it too hard to guess his age.

TCG2_Aira.png

He boldly spoke, "I heard how you use your bench to power up your Voltorb, but I bet you can't beat me if you have two less bench slots!"

I inquired as to how much he would be willing to bet. He then pulled out his wallet and revealed his funds. Realizing that the amount of money needed to maintain my bribery of the gambling company was ever mounting, I wagered his funds would prove useful and thus our duel commenced!

How one such as he became someone who is popular here I will never know. His cringe-inducing actions ceased the moment my victory was claimed. It baffles the mind that he actually reasoned such a restriction would inhibit my ability to secure dominance in our duel. He laid his funds down and with overly dramatic posturing sunk himself back down into the depths.

I then proceeded into the central chamber. There were multiple waterfalls cascading into a pool in the middle of the room. Out of the pool in the middle was a large stone platform connected to the entrance by a stone bridge. The platform was at the stop of a set of wide stairs. the water from the pool in the middle spilled over the edge below into another pool that the bridge extended over.

Brooke the GR leader of the water stood atop the platform and greeted me. She wore a white swim cap with a red GR logo on it. She also wore a white bikini that left rather little to the imagination. She had brown eyes and very tanned skin. In fact, I could tell it was actually sun burned skin!

TCG2_Kanoko_Loss.png

Rather than discussion of the duel we would proceed to, she was preoccupied with how one ought to not use tanning beds too frequently and how it will make you look darker than you realize. She explained she was always kept indoors and unable to bathe in the warm rays of the sun, so she thought she could make up for it in the tanning bed, but the tanning bed was on too high of a setting. Her motions were stiff and calculated as she winced from the severe sunburn. She then commented that Bill's inventions are not all they are cracked up to be, especially Bill's Ultra Sun Tan Super Deluxe Bed! I instantly empathized with her as we began our cordial and respectable duel.

Our duel swiftly concluded. Water was no match for my Voltorb no matter who wielded it. She did notice how my Bill's Teleporter only seemed to function half of the time though and expressed her sympathies. After the duel, we compared our general grievances regarding Bill and that the marketing of his products far exceeds their benefits. She was impressed by my ability to draw eight cards with Gambler though and concluded it must be fated that the win became mine. I allowed her to draw her own conclusions on the matter rather than attempt to explain the benefits of bribery as I made a graceful exit.

As I made my way towards the outside I passed Cody who looked at me expectantly while approaching.

TCG2_Miyajima.png

I quickly explained there was an emergency and that I would be unable to duel after all and quickly left. Having a real emergency of kidnap and potential starvation was feeling pretty amazing right now all things considered!

Back into the initial room, it seemed Jacob was now concluding his thesis on all things water. As he opened his eyes, I paused for a moment.

He then exclaimed "I can't believe it! You're the first person to ever listen to me all the way through! I was going to duel, but just being listened to is more than I could ever ask for! Mark my words, friend, when the resistance rises, we shall set you aside and our wrath will spare you!"

TCG2_Senta_Win.png

I simply nodded and performed a slight bow as I exited and returned to the lobby for more of that exquisite water!

I then visited the counter with my newfound funds and gazed at the assortment of snacks they had for sale. I attempted to purchase one but the employee manning the lobby store refused to take them out for me to purchase stating that by order of Claire on behalf of the King, no one was to sell or provide food to me.

Well, it was worth a shot.

I then made my way out of the fortress.

The next destination would be the GR of Fire Fortress!



(18)

As I entered the fire fortress, I was taken aback at how they have literal lava flows inside the building! The only thing that struck me more than the unbearable heat was the absurd amount of money it must take to maintain such a spectacle!

Reasoning that I would be losing hydration quickly in this place, I made my typical stop to the lobby for water. The lobby was a fantastic and comfortable temperature. The floor was all what appeared to be black rocks, perhaps obsidian. After drinking more than I usually would, exited the lobby and made my way inside the main section of the fortress.

Lava pools lined most of the walls in the first room.

Doduo walked up to the lava and peered intently into it. Before long its feathers caught on fire as it ran around gleefully as its burning feathers started falling off.

Ignoring the insane bird I noticed the next member of GR waiting in the room: Jess. Notable was the mask upon Jess's face. When I inquired as to why, Jess simply replied ominously that one should never seek plastic facial surgery from Bill's discount doctor services. Not wanting to keep the matter focused on such a horrid topic, I quickly pulled my deck out for our assumed duel.

TCG2_Jes.png

I fought fire with fire as my Dark Rapidash clashed with Jess's Dark Rapidash. My Pokemon proved to be the greater of the two however! Upon the conclusion of our contest, Jess pulled up the mask to cover the eyes in shame. I then noticed the face appeared perfectly presentable! When I inquired upon this, Jess pulled the mask off and looked down to the left while admitting it was just a stunt meant to garner sympathy in the hopes of it affecting the duel. Having no clue how one should respond to such a revelation, I simply shook my head as I departed for the next room.

The next enclosure offered the same extreme in temperature. A raised platform of rock connected by a stone bridge on either side with a pool of lava surrounding the platform on all sides though the bridges were far enough above the lava for it to be safe to cross. How anyone could stand about all day in such places though was utterly beyond me. It had to be near 110 degrees here! Granted, even that seemed cool compared to what I would expect temperatures around lava to typically be. Even so, my poor suit will no doubt be unfit to keep wearing once I am done here!

As I tread into the tumultuous temperature torture, I noticed Doduo happily rolling along the floor to finally put out the literal fire in its feathers. I suppose it does need to put out flame because if all of its feathers burn away it won't have any left to leave about everywhere! Well, at least we will not need to tidy this place of feathers for a change!

(19)

I then noticed who appeared to be perhaps a little girl of age ten. She had light blue eyes with light blue hair to match. Kind of like the color of a blue flame. She also wore a blue shirt but had a light yellow apron on with the GR logo on it.

TCG2_Yuki.png

She then approached me and introduced herself as Kara and that she has been taught to duel anyone who desires, but only if they empty their entire deck of all energy except fire.

What is with this island that it has so many odd and varied fanatics?! The common-folk of TCG Island never took to tedium such as this! I braced my ears for what I assumed would be yet another hail of pointless monologue about how fire by itself was superior to all other energy types, but to my great surprise, she simply asked if I would be willing to duel under the conditions! When I inevitably declined, she simply curled up on the floor to nap speaking of how it was too hot to duel anyway.

It was at this point I realized that I still had that tiny Doduo fan that one typically acquires at theme parks! Reasoning that she will likely need it far more than myself, I presented it to her as a charitable contribution. GR member or not, this ten year old did NOT kidnap me and deserves kindness!

At this her face lightened mentioning she had never received a gift before and would always cherish it. She then activated the device and lay about content as I went about my way.

"I'll make sure to tell them you are good. Thank you so much Mr!" she called out as I made my way through the door.

Doduo followed. Its plumage mostly charred. It actually looked more black than tan at this point. I couldn't help but laugh at the absurdity of it. Doduo seemed pleased to be the focus of such things.

The next room was smaller but only a comparatively thin winding walkway separated the lava.

Doduo marveled at all the lava about this room but apparently decided it had enough fun with burns for now as it stayed fairly close to me patiently.

My next would-be opponent was on the far end of the room and donned the name of Ellen. She wore a yellow and red cap and had beautiful long brown hair with bangs that covered one of her eyes. She wore a tight red suit with yellow buttons. She looked to be about twenty-four years old. I noticed how she might be close to suffering initial stages of heat stroke as she attempted to explain why every deck should contain four Eevee.

TCG2_Shoko_Loss.png

I explained that she may need medical attention and should visit the lobby of the club where it is hopefully of more tolerable temperature. Clearly she wanted to speak further of Eevee but her weariness of the heat won out as she sauntered towards the exit muttering something about the regulatory body of the island needing to impose better workplace accommodations.

I decided to accompany her to the lobby for if she were to have a medical emergency, that would surely outrank some petty starvation of mine. I offered my arm to her which she accepted as I began to escort her to the lobby.

Doduo immediately began bouncing itself on the floor shaking off the charred bits of feathers. It now looked like it was having a bad hair day, or in this case feathers! It did remove most of the ash and soot from its feathers though.

Half way to the lobby she started having trouble walking. To my surprise, Doduo ran out ahead and lowered its body! I helped her on praying it wasn't about to jump into a nearby pit of lava. I would try to carry Ellen, but I do not lift weights and seriously doubted my ability to reliably carry anyone older than a small child. Doduo carefully lifted her and made its way to the lobby and cooperated in helping her into a chair!

TCG2_Shoko_Loss.png

I noticed that other than some feather ash, Ellen did not appear to have any of Doduo's feathers stuck to it. Hah! She must have got lucky since I supposed too many of its feathers fell out or burned recently!

I then purchased a water bottle and brought it to her. She thanked me and gave Doduo a pet on one of its heads. She then mentioned I should come back and see her once my business here was concluded. She explained that they have a shower here and a fast dry cleaning service usually reserved for employees but that she would let me use them.

What good luck! Here I was worried that a foul stench would linger upon me for the entirety of the remainder of my journey here!

I thanked her and once I was satisfied she would be ok, I noticed Jess and Kara sitting in some chairs.

TCG2_Jes.png

TCG2_Yuki.png

They looked pretty hot but Kara was still using the fan I gave her. I reasoned it must be one of several breaks they likely get during the day.

Kara looked up at me with her hopeful eyes and a smile. She wished me luck in my duel!

I thanked her as I placed an arm across my stomach and bowed.

I mentioned I would put on a special performance just for her.

As I turned to leave, I noticed Doduo appeared to be staying behind. Could it be that it wanted to keep an eye on Ellen, given her condition? Utterly perplexed, I made my way towards the furthest depths of the Fire Fortress.

(20)

In the final chamber, I noted there was even more lava than the other rooms! Lava below the bridge that connected to the central location. Lava above on a platform above spilling out onto the main platform before flowing further to meet the lava under the bridge. Surely just a few degrees hotter and the cards we dueled with would surely burst into flame!

I then took note of the opponent in the room, Bernard, leader of the Fire Fortress! I immediately noticed his pair of protective sunglasses as well as built-in fans to his apparel as well as what appeared to be tubes of some presumably cool liquid circulating throughout his unique apparel. Clearly this place of business operates as many businesses tend to: favoring those at the top at the expense of those beneath.

TCG2_Hidero.png

Indignant of such a display I announced my intent to duel with more than my usual resolve! He then explained that fire in this place will have no weakness to water and that was the reason for implementing lava in the workplace. He explained how he finds far less challengers to surpass him in such an environment. Little did he know, I possessed the ability to make his Pokemon weak to whatever strikes my fancy with Porygon!

I took down the tyrant with several zaps from my Voltorbs and switched his weakness to allow triumph with my Dark Rapidash. His Rapidash and Magmar presented the biggest obstacles but were unable to withstand my onslaught.

I then scolded the fellow explaining he should offer better treatment of his employees as he clearly has the means. As I made my way to the exit, he merely laughed indicating his defeat is all the more reason to continue in his ways.

I made my way back to the lobby and noticed Doduo performing various antics as Ellen laughed.

I went about showering and having my suit dry cleaned. Once I was done I began to leave the lobby and noticed Doduo trotted up to Ellen and nudged its heads affectionately on her arm. She smiled and gave each head a stroke. Doduo had a peculiar reaction to this. It seemed to hate it, perhaps, but appeared to be trying its best to convince itself of the opposite! Doduo then bowed to her before turning around and promptly trotting over to me.

As I left, I noticed Kara standing expectantly outside. I suppose she must have been waiting for me?

TCG2_Yuki.png

She was amazed by my duel and decided to give me a gift! It was in a little sandwich bag. It looked like a cabbage roll filled with... rice? Such a simple little thing! To my starving body though, it might as well have been gold!

I can't just accept this so easily though... Clearly the folk of this island fear retaliation from their King!

I asked her if it was really ok to give this to me and that I didn't want her to be in trouble.

She asked me to lean close so she could whisper.

I obliged.

She whispered that she will let me have it if I keep it a secret and that no one could know!

Finally someone on this island who ISN'T willing to watch me starve!

I gave her my solemn vow as a gentleman with my hand upon my heart.

She held it out for me again.

I accepted after first looking around to make sure no one was watching. I will not have her tarnished on my account!

Kara watched as I ate it. Her eyes lit up as I bit into it.

It tasted bland, but I didn't care. It was so nice to have something-anything else to eat!

After finishing, I reasoned that her food was more valuable than the money I had on me, so I emptied my pockets of every scrap of cash, every coin. I crouched down to her level, thanked her face to face, and gave the money to her.

I regretted that it wasn't much. Perhaps this small gesture would be meaningless to her, but honor would not allow for me to do any less!

Barely a second went by when, suddenly she was hugging me!

She wished me good luck in the rest of the duels here and that she would be rooting for me!

Far be it from me to coldly reject a hug from one such as this!

I gave her a hug back and lingered a little while for her before standing up.

Ah... a pity there are not more on this island like her.

I bid her farewell and took my leave.

With Kara's hopes and the ever-present Doduo, my next destination was the GR Fighting Fortress!



(21)

Upon my journey to the next fortress, I stopped at the GR Island’s Challenge Hall. Figuring it was a good time for a rest, I sat upon one of its many unoccupied stools. I reasoned that they must not have an event currently going.

It was then that my phone spoke to me again! Quickly I answered and found the other end was occupied by one who was not outsourced to Neo judging by the lack of a Neo accent! A tear came to my eye as I explained the entirety of events leading to this moment.

I then learned the harsh truth: Bill Incorporated has been navigating a particularly tumultuous bankruptcy thanks to the mismanagement of its gambling wing. Apparently the winnings have far exceeded the accepted perimeters and they had to relocate Bill's Teleporter to his home. I then learned that his nephew, Timmy, a toddler of the age of three, frequents his home and often plays unsupervised. Apparently his unfortunate penchant is to unplug the teleporter at every available opportunity! Bill is frequently too busy on calls with Lawyers regarding the bankruptcy so he has little time for supervision but plugs it back in from time to time. The rep apologized and mentioned he would hire an employee to protect the power cable, but lacks the funds.

I thanked her for the information and concluded that my bribery of the gambling employees is likely connected to the failure of the teleporter. I wasn't particularly sympathetic considering the abuse I suffered at the hands of their demented call center, so although I could stop the bribery, there was a certain sense of ironic justice in its continuation. The teleporter will remain inconsistent regardless at this point anyway, so I opted to continue the bribery knowing that both cards will continue to occasionally fail. I reasoned that my bribery was only a small portion of the overall unreliability of the teleporter and surely my bribery has been increasing my chances considerably more with the Gambler card!

Now that we have cleared up that matter, it's time to phone my good friend Ronald to arrange to leave this phony resort behind!
Ronald.png

I dialed the number, lifted the phone to my ear, and then... nothing? The horrible truth then dawned on me: my phone had now died and I was without the means to recharge it! I slowly and deliberately slid it back into my pocket with dismay as I set out for the next destination.

At least that horrible cacophony of terrible phone-filtered music ceased! I could take comfort in that. That Doduo was without cheer as a result of the departure of the infernal music that plagued my ears no more, was icing on the cake. Dumb bird! It would now have to find alternative sources of torture to placate its tendencies!

I then began the trek to one of the few remaining fortresses on this island: the fighting fortress!

(22)

When I arrived at the fighting fortress, I marveled at the stone architecture of the structure and the sections of marble flooring near the doors. It appeared to be oldest structure I had ever seen! The entrance was lined with several statues of people with primitive clothing. I also noticed to my dismay that this fortress doesn't have a lobby! What?! How do they visit the restroom and drink from water fountains with no lobby!? How do they buy snacks? What kind of place IS this?! I then resolved to be out of this place as quickly as possible.

The receptionist for the fortress was standing nearby and informed me that the leader became lost again in the maze below and that I would have to venture in to find him. My questions regarding this matter were many, but my task was clear! To the maze!

Upon entering the main hall, it became evident that the exit was up ahead which would lead to the remaining locations on my map of GR Island: the Colorless Altar, Psychic Stronghold, and GR Castle. As for the main hall itself, the stone architecture continued here but I noticed some of it had been painted with the path to the exit in red, and giant letters on the left and right sides of the hall: "G R". Near the exit, was two bronze pillars with some kind of old writing etched into them. On the left and right sides were doorways with stairs with signs above them that read "Maze". On the left side was another set of stairs with a sign that read "Exit From Maze" I then proceeded down the stairs into the maze.

The construction of the maze seemed relatively simple and judging from some odd outlines on the walls, it appeared there used to be metal fixtures for torches but they had since been replaced by standard lights. I also noticed the floor looked peculiar in some sections. After looking closely, I determined they had implemented trap doors in the floor to impede ones progress! I was not one to be hoodwinked by such measures so I simply navigated around them.

I soon found myself in a large dead-end chamber with a lady by the name of Grace. She wore tight fitting blue gym equipment and a black bandana tied around her forehead with big red letters on it: 'G R'. She had spiky orange hair and light blue eyes. She looked to be about twenty years old.

TCG2_Grace_Win.png

I had to take but one look, just one to know what was about to happen. You can always see the hopeful desperation in the eyes…

I made for a hasty exit as she began loudly proclaiming how fighting type energy is the best energy and all decks should only have that kind of energy in it. Clearly she has never seen what happens when you pit a fighting type against an especially dumb, lazy, fat, and masochistic bird or any other bearer of fighting resistance! No sir, i will not be making a fighting deck just so I can suffer a defeat at the likes of a creature like Doduo!

Thankfully the complexity of the structure allowed for my quick disappearance, but her insufferable monologue would continue without end for the entire exploration of the structure. If one ever needs to know if something is unpleasant, one need only look to Doduo. Indeed, its smugness suggested enjoyment. I simply must be rid of this place as fast as is convenient!

As I explored the remainder of this meandering mysterious mole-infested maze, I chanced upon a man by the name of Tony. He had pale skin and was bald and muscular with no facial hair.

He proclaimed we should duel but only if I were to downgrade my deck by removing the most useful common cards of all: Energy Removal!

"My good man," I scoffed, "I am already using a deck constructed completely of common cards and you ask that I debilitate it further? Why should you begrudge me what little advantage I can attain?"

He then began a tirade of how the cards are broken and should have never been invented and that they would be much better if a coin-flip was implemented for them to be successful. I then retorted that he was quite mad and that a coin-flip would render them pointless for all intent and purpose. Clearly he was not seeking refinement but rather oppression! It was already bad enough that Gamble and Bill's Teleporter should often fail and this clod wants to nerf my power further? I bid him farewell as I made my way to the exit of the maze. Perhaps the leader returned from the maze as well so I can get on with things?

Brooke in-game has an unusual skin color that i think is supposed to make her look tanned, but it just looks more like a sun-burn to me and was my inspiration for her sunburn in the story.
In the games, each island has a location/building known as a Challenge hall. Occasionally, there is a challenge cup held here where the player can participate in a mini-tournament against other duelists of the island to win a promo card if the player is undefeated after 3 or 4 opponents (I forget the exact number of opponents). Most of the time, a challenge cup is not being held so the building is typically relatively empty. Like clubs and fortresses, each challenge hall also has a lobby.
Ronald is the antagonist of the first game. Kind of like a counterpart to the rival from the mainline Pokemon games. Ronald's role in the 2nd game shifts to one that helps the player and scouts out Team GR.
 
Last edited:

ShiniGojira

Multiversal Extraordinaire
Location
Stranded In The Gaps between Multiverses
Pronouns
He/him/they/her
Partners
  1. froslass
  2. zorua-gojira
  3. salandit-shiny
  4. goomy
Hello, here's the review of Chp 3 and 4. Sorry if it's a little late.

Summary of Chp 3:

So Mr Nameless finds a note inviting him to GR island and this time, he's a lot more inclined to visit that place since y'know, no kidnapping.

He gets there, meets the king and after learning about this card dungeon thingy, he was immediately introduced to the horror that is gambling and understandably he was horrified.

After that, he meets the queen and learns that this dungeon thingy is apparently like chess or something.

Summary of Chp 4:

Mr Nameless talks to Pawn and asks to see the murals in which Pawn gives him a tour. And after a bunch of history stuff about the past heroes, we get some hints about Mr Nameless possibly being the next hero. After that, he beats Pawn, meets Knight and bears him too before meeting up with the Queen.

Chapter 3 Review:

It was a fun read. I can certainly notice the improvement compared to the previous three chapters. I don't think I have much I want to say here. The characters were fun, the receptionist especially was funny and I liked the gambling scene, kinda goofy that it took 'em this long to invent gambling but it's funny enough to imagine that the world would've been a lot happier if Bill wasn't such a greedy corpa guy.

The only real complaint I do have is Imakumi. Not his character per se, just his dialogue being kinda wonky. It kinda sticks out when compared to everyone else and I don't know, I just kinda hate it. I've put in more details about him in my line-by-line comments and I kinda don't wanna repeat myself so you can find it there.

Anyway, yeah it was nice chapter. I'm gotta head on to Chp 4 now.

Chp 4 Review:

So this chapter was rather interesting, learning about the history of the past heroes and stuff like that. Really weird implications of the world's current technology though. 'cause the exposition kinda makes it feel like the world is stagnate because people are too scared to advance their tech because they don't wanna destroy the world or something shit. Which is like super weird though because the world so far feels like it's like our modern era except a tinsy bit more advanced. I don't know. It really feels like the exposition is trying to tell me that the world is sorta in the medieval era or industrial revolution era but that obviously can't be true because of y'know, phones and stuff.

Anyway, aside from that. The history was nice to read through, I like seeing all the different heroes and how Mr Nameless is likely gonna be the next one. Lugia being possibly the next bad guy is super weird though but I'm guessing that's more of a game thing since I assume when they made the game, they had no idea what to do with Legendaries.

But I do have a tiny complaint and it's the exposition itself. While dedicating a chapter to just talking about the world's history isn't bad per se, since I did enjoy it. I'm not entirely sure other people will enjoy just reading through what's essentially a history book with barely anything in between. Like I'll be honest and say I did kinda nod off when reading halfway through the exposition.

I'm not particularly good at writing exposition myself but I can give some advice on making it more palatable. One being cut down the fluff, no need for more words than necessary, split the sections up into several smaller parts, maybe add some more interactions between Pawn and Mr Nameless or add more of Mr Nameless's thoughts on the matter. You could even just have a part of the history lesson be said before skipping past them and bringing it up later. Because it felt like the story kinda just stopped for a moment just to dump all of the history onto me before continuing.

Though it's probably better if you watch a video about learning how to dump exposition since I'm not super good at explaining things myself. So take what I said with a grain of salt.

Now let's head on to my line-by-line comments:

Chp 3:

thank you again for all the good you had done when last you were here.
While not grammatically wrong I think 'when you were last here' reads better here

our finest pretzel bakeries.
Lol, pretzel bakeries? So not only do these bakeries sell just pretzels but there are also several of them? Damn, maybe I should try a pretzel or something if it's this popular

I had expected I had defeated all the inhabitants unwilling to disgrace my deck with their rules,
I feel like replacing 'expected' with 'thought' or 'believed' would flow better here
As I crossed the threshold the doorman informed
Missing a comma between these
He also commented that the daycare does not have a door because trying to obstruct Doduo would just lead to broken doors if the Doduo become tired of it.
And they're sure they tried their all in solving this conundrum 'cause I feel like just replacing the doors for gates would work better unless like the daycare's similar to a kid's daycare or something instead of a barn
Perhaps it was in a molting season or something?
Shouldn't it be dropping more feathers during molting season or am I looking at this wrong?
Upon my arrival to the lobby, I noticed a rather strange man in a red suit. He bore some resemblance to the strange man in the black suit near the beginning of my common Pokemon card deck journey! What was his name again...? Ah! Imakuni!?

TCG2_Imakuni_Red.png
That's one ugly mofo.
He then announced "I'm going to take you out and put you on the clearance rack! Eh? I Lost? Well...that bites. When you see me next, I'll be even redder than I am now! I'm off to continue
Needs punctuation here.

So I'll be straight, Imakumi's dialogue feels very flat and I'm not sure if it's intentional but it's very game-y and unnatural like Mr Nameless just found a IRL npc or something. Having Imakumi perform some actions or have his dialogue fixed up would probably make him a lot easier to read. As it really does feel like he's reading off a script.
You have but to ask the receptionist here and she will supply you with some.
A random 'but' snuck in here
"Good sir, you will do well to remember to return these chips before you leave" she mentioned with a clearly fake smile on her face.
Dialogue needs punctuation here
She then leaned in close, the smile now dropped from her face as she breathed
Tag needs punctuation
She then glanced around to make sure no one was looking and then took her index finger and dragged it across her throat slowly and deliberately.
Ooh, I like her
He looked up noticing my bag of chips a
Needs a comma between these
As I tread,
Should be treaded
could feel the receptionists cold stare upon
Missing an apostrophe
As he mentioned it I inwardly cringed.
Need a comma between these.
Turning to another corner of the room, he continued "Ah, over here we have the coin toss combo! You know, at first I was going to install a VR game where you play as and explore the world as a Scyther, but it turns out the cost for a coin toss table was so much more reasonable that I just couldn't pass up the opportunity to save some money! A penny saved is a penny earned as they say!"
Tag needs punctuation
I would have loved to have played that!
A bit redundant to have two 'have verb' here, you should remove one so it's either 'i would have loved to play' or 'I would love to have played'
The King chuckled a bit as we continued."Ah, and here we have the Black Box"
A space got eaten here and dialogue needs punctuation
Our families records goes back many generations
Either missing an apostrophe or it should be 'family records'. Depends on if it has multiple families or just the one
The receptionist replied "aww thats so sweet Billy, you run along now!"
Tag needs punctuation. Also gotta capitalize the dialogue.
Even my late uncles blood money
if the mans soul
Missing an apostrophe
"WHAT?" Said the king in a loud voice.
'Said' shouldn't be capitalized here
she spoke:
Wrong punctuation here. Should be a period
I listened intently as she spoke: "Greetings friend! My liege the king Villicci has informed us of your impending arrival! Since your departure from our island on your first visit, he recognized that your ability to best everyone on our island with a deck full of commons meant that our common level dueling skills needed improvement! His first action was to create a core team of stronger duelists who's function is to gradually introduce more complex tactics and deck-building skills to the islands inhabitants. Our team still uses all cards at our disposal, and we are utilized for this attraction, but the majority of our time is spent refining our skills and testing our mettle against one another. After a most grueling training regiment, we can proudly state with confidence that some among us can now go toe to toe in matches with our king! As such, we believe we will provide ample challenges in our roles here! As this is our grand opening, the king wanted to make sure we were able to stand against more than just himself to prove that we are up to the task. For that, he could think of no better opponent for us than you!"
Massive wall of dialogue here. I think it's best if you either cut down some stuff or split them up with some movement or action tags since my first reaction to seeing was 'Geez, that's a lot'
"It gladdens me to see evidence of the kings reforms
Missing an apostrophe
the door re-opened inviting me inside.
Needs a comma between these

Chp 4
might I take some time to examine the fine painted stone painted murals of these ruins?
Think you got an extra painted slipped in there unless you're saying someone used a stone to paint the murals?
The king mentioned we would likely get folk
Should be 'folks'
Other than that, simply let me know when you are done!.
An extra period at the end there
Yes! I heard from Queen that the king hired an expert. He lives on the island in fact! Actually, he sometimes lives somewhere else too I have heard. I am unsure if he has decoded them, is working on it, or gave up though! The building was already constructed when I began my training here for the attraction, you see."
Imagine if the 'expert' is Bill. GR King be singlehandedly bringing Bill's company back from bankruptcy, bro.
Thank you my good fellow
Should have a comma between these
I found myself speaking without fully intending to do so, "fascinating..." I then regained my awareness. "Please do continue!"
Should capitalize this
The history books speak of a curse upon the land that caused roughly half of the entire world to get sick and die!
Lol, so the whole world's Europe?
Well maybe your right! I don't know! Its not like I could do anything about it anyway if Bill
Wrong form of "you're" and "it's"
the more poor the inhabitants of our island became
Should be 'poorer'
don't think its wise to underestimate the indifference of billionairs to human suffering."
billionaires' Also true AF, Mr Nameless
Still, if Anna's story shows anything, its that there is always a way to overcome human greed
Again, "it's"
Lugia helped create Neo island but Lugia is also wanting to destroy the world?
'Lugia also wanted to' flows better here
think its likely we will find out who this person is very soon. I assume this will be either the next or the final hero."
Its a question archeologists have long wondered about
Should be "it's"
Either that or he had extremely well tones muscle
Should be 'well-toned'
The delay was of my own making my good man.
Not entirely sure if you know about this, since I keep finding this issue but I'll say it just in case. Whenever you're writing something and mentioned someone's name in dialogue, you should put a comma before said name. Ex: "How do you do, fellow guy?" Or "That's super cool, Nathan." The only time you don't put a comma between a name is if you introducing them. Ex: "This is Mikey." or "My name is Faye."
With that we began a series of duels but not in the manner I had expected!
Oh and also this. If you have something preceding a subject and verb, you put a comma before the subject. Ex: 'After this, he put it down.' or 'With everything that's happened, he should...' etcetera etcetera.

Anyway, sorry for the wait and I hope you have a great day. Thanks for the fun chapters!
 
Chapter 5 - Part 2: Encryption of The Future New

133TFR33k

Creator of the Doduo Alliance
Partners
  1. doduo
Chapter 5 - Part 2: Encryption of The Future

And with that, my third duel with Axel resulted in yet another loss on my part!

Axel continued immediately from where he left off. "So I don't want us to run out of time, but I ask that you believe me that I am Axel and that our foe returns every hundred years. You can think of what I am currently doing as possessing Queen, but it will not hurt her and the only way it will affect her is that her memory of me being here and the events that happened while I am here will be gone.

"I don't like taking away the will of someone else without their knowledge or permission. I truly wish I could apologize to Queen!" Axel said with tears forming in his eyes.

I nodded. "I am choosing to believe you at least for now. Please continue."

(49)

Axel brought both hands together under his chin. "Thank you!! Ok so, the stone murals in these ruins are mysterious in origin but always come from the high priest of the Third Eye which can be a man or woman. This high priest has an uncanny connection to our nexus separate from the Progenitor but it is a connection that can only be used to glimpse into our future or to obtain information from outside of our world. Even I don't know everything about the murals. You should seek out the high priest to learn more. I can tell you what little else I know though. The significance of Lugia, for example."

I nodded.

"You see, the Lugia card does, in fact, exist. It is the property of our foe and the instrument of his ultimate goal. Lugia is not meant to be here. Neither in our world, nor the original world line. Due to this reason, the card has its own connection to the nexus. Through this connection, if it interacts with the Progenitor, it can become any card. I don't mean any card from our world. I mean any card in the Pokemon Trading Card Game. Any card from our nexus!"

At this revelation, I began to realize the implications.

Axel held up a hand with his palm up as if he were holding a small ball in it. "Those shadowy cards behind the foe in the mural showing the duel below the colorless energy symbol? They represent all the things Lugia could become. The symbol is colorless because Lugia itself is colorless. At least, the version we have here in our world is. If what Lugia could become has a limitation, I believe it would have to be a card already inside our nexus, which is immense!"

My thoughts began wondering at the possibilities.

Axel crossed his arms. "The Lugia card also has an additional function: it acts as a key to the door of the sealed fortress that I have been locked away in with the other Ghostmasters! It is able to function as a key only because it is a unique card. The only unique card to currently exist, in fact! Finding it is impossible though. Our foe keeps it close at all times and would never willingly part with it. I'm sure he also hides it well. Before the end of our last battle, the foe used Lugia to seal himself inside the our fort in an attempt to prevent us from disrupting his plans again in the future. Before the door could close, he tossed the Lugia card outside for a member of his cult to carry away."

My jaw dropped. "My word! That's even more insane than the things Doduo does! And you say there is a cult involved?"

"Doduo huh..." He turned away deep in thought.

TCG2_Queen_Loss.png


"Erm, yes? But what has you distracted by those bumbling birds?"

Axel then snapped himself out of it and looked up at me. "Sorry... every time I think of Doduo, I can't help but think of one of the times we were unable to completely stop the foe. I believe Doduo was an experiment he had in tampering with our reality. Ever since then, the only actual Pokemon to inhabit our world has been Doduo."

"What?? Those birds didn't used to be here at all??"

"Yeah...," he mentioned with a look of shame while averting his eyes.

TCG2_Queen_Loss.png


He then looked back towards me. "Can't slow down though. Regarding the cult, you have a leader that returns every hundred years in a way that can easily be misconstrued as a miracle. You have his knowledge and manipulation of the Progenitor, which has god-like powers. You have the phantom card Lugia, which there is only one of in the world. There is a lack of any distinct deity or figure of worship in our world, which seems to have been the case for about a hundred years now. The foe has used his cult for hundreds of years as well as the Scions of the Deep, before they were defeated and disbanded, and he will continue in his ways unless we stop him! He doesn't tend to stick with one particular plan. All of us ghostmasters have thwarted his various plans so far to varying degrees of success."

I crossed my arms. "And yet, to such a large extent, it seems your efforts are largely unrecognized!"

Axel looked up. "Yes... well with the fortress having been sealed for so long, I'm not too surprised our deeds have faded from the public mind with time... Anyway, when he sealed us in the fort, we had not anticipated he would sacrifice the life of his host like that. Because we were unprepared, his plan succeeded. Though the high priest has powers of insight beyond our comprehension, the power is not unlimited and does not see all there is, thus we were unable to be warned."

TCG2_Queen_Loss.png


"So what happened to the foe once he was sealed in the fort? I assume he did not last long without food..."

Axel placed his hands on his hips. "The foe did pass away from this life in our fort along with the most recent hero, Mary, but death does not stop our foe and he always returns once every one hundred years. His current host is likely connected to the cult of Lugia. It likely does not operate in the open though, so I doubt it would be called the 'religion of Lugia,' for example. So, even if you could find his cult, it would be difficult to determine who in the cult our foe is. Even if we know who the foe is, we have no way of knowing where the Lugia card is kept. Thus, our only option is to create a new key. The only problem with that is all the cards in the Progenitor have already been created multiple times."

I then started to wonder if there was no way to unseal the fort!

Axel peered into my eyes. "There are none other than Lugia that can act as a key... except for one card that has never been created by the Progenitor but lies within the depths of its database... The high priest of that time disclosed it to us to be used in the time we now find ourselves in. The name of the card is 'Here Comes Team Rocket'. It is the final phantom card of our world."

(50)

I held my hands together and towards Axel with my palms up. "So then, I realize you are locked in the sealed fort but you have not starved! How are you still alive and what is the point of unlocking the fort in the first place?"

Axel looked up and to the side as if staring at something far in the distance. "We ghostmasters no longer die in the traditional sense. You can think of our current existence as ghosts. As for why you should unlock our fort, that is so that we can help prepare the final hero to defeat the foe for good this time. That final hero is you!" He turned and pointed to me.

I placed both hands upon my chest. "So you are telling me that a high priest from 1,000 years ago was able to know I was going to come about to save our world?"

Axel nodded with his eyes closed. "That is exactly it, Mr! Regarding preservation, the way you stick to a deck full of common cards is even more us than we are! What better way to keep the old cards alive than to self-impose a challenge as you do?"

TCG2_Queen_Win.png


Hearing this from Axel filled me partly with pride but also embarrassment since my original motivation for the challenge was due to lack of funds...

Axel placed a hand upon his chest. "I am ten years old even though I have been ten for 1,000 years and have not aged a single day. I've often wondered what it would feel like to experience growth beyond what I've been, but the way I inhabit others such as Queen does give me some semblance of what it would be like. Any of the ghostmasters could be here in this way but only one at a time. Due to that, and because I never got to grow up, the others always insist that it be me who goes out here. Unfortunately I never know for sure what kind of body I end up borrowing before it happens..."

Axel closed his eyes with a nervous smile.

I placed both palms on the duel table. "To live for 1,000 years as a ghost with no real body and at the age of ten? I understand why the other hero's allow you to be the one to come out here! I surely would as well!" I stood with my hands still on the table.

Axel gave himself a hug but then looked away in shame. "I wish I felt as good about accepting the privilege as everyone else does about giving it to me."

TCG2_Queen_Loss.png


"That's not to say I'm not grateful though! Thank you Mr!" Axel looked at me with tears forming in his eyes yet again.

I walked to him and placed a hand upon his back. "No need to worry, I happen to think the ability of empathy is one of the most important abilities in our world! I see no reason you would receive any negative judgment from me."

After a pause, Axel looked up. "I still need to explain how to get the key to our fort, but before that, we still need to duel again Mr!"

I walked back and took my seat again. "Very well then! Duels with you are entertaining anyway, win or lose!"

And with that, what would be our final duel began.

The duel ended. In victory!

Axel was quick to comment. "Woah Mr! That was incredible! You used up all the useful cards in your opening hand and used Gambler to replace them all! After that you got successful coin flips on two Bill's Teleporter and then played two Bills! Your hand was enormous with so much potential! Its no wonder I was unable to beat you that time! I love playing high level games like that, but its so rare for me to lose! Thanks Mr!" Axel gave me the most pure and innocent smile I had seen from him yet.

TCG2_Queen_Win.png


I smiled. "Happy to oblige and equally happy to establish a win!"

Axel dived right back into things. "OK, so now I will tell you how to get the key. Please make absolutely sure you visit! In the writing carved into the stone walls in the ruins, are the instructions for how to access the hidden function of the Progenitor to cause it to create 'Here Comes Team Rocket'. If you can't read it, you should seek out an archaeologist to help. Even if you ask the current high priest, they would be unable to read it, so they would be unable to help. Once you have the instructions, you need to find the Progenitor. Do you have any idea where it is already?"

I held a hand to my chin. "Actually... I walked by an interesting machine called the black box on the way to the ruins here. It had the ability to transform five cards into another card and then to mail that card to the one that input the cards."

Axel slapped both his palms upon the table. "YES! That is it! But why on earth are they using the Progenitor for such a lousy basic function?! UGH! Whatever! Yes, that is the Progenitor!"

I placed my hands on my hips. "Good! At least one aspect of this was simple!"

Axel looked me in the eye. "Now that we have that out of the way, the reason you need to visit the sealed fort is twofold. One: we need to train you to be the best duelist you can be! The enemy might not match our strength but the last high priest I spoke to mentioned it is essential that we train you. For that, you will need to win in a duel against each of us one time! It doesn't matter how many times you lose. The duel you won against me here doesn't count because I was not able to play at my best with the cards I had here."

I crossed my arms. "My word! If that was you holding back, how should I expect to win a duel against you for real? I suppose it will be time for me to gather rare cards to stop holding back!"

Axel waved his hand dismissively. "Don't you worry about that, Mr. You just do what you do best and struggle against seemingly impossible odds with that cool common deck of yours! Besides, the training will go better if its harder and using commons will certainly help with that!" He added with a wink.

"The second reason we need you to meet us, is to acquire the ultimate means to fight back against our foe. I don't think you are going to like it, but the high priest said that you cannot even hope prevail without it! That comes after your training though! Before that, no touching!"

(51)

Axel's eyes went big as his gaze appeared to be on nothing in particular. "Wow! I actually got through everything I needed for the plan! In that case... Mr.... can I be selfish with these last moments?" He pleaded with his hands at his chin with big doe eyes.

"Well! I would certainly think you have earned it!"

TCG2_Queen_Loss.png


Tears started forming in Axel's eyes. "Oh Mr! Its been so hard! I've been locked away with no body and can never make new friends... and... and..." He burst full on into tears while running towards me "I miss my moooom!!!! WHAAAA!!!!!"

I found him clinging fiercely to me with eyes that could probably be used in place of water energy. Poor lad. Unable to take any other course of action, I embraced him back to help him make the most of his remaining time in a body.

"There there" I said as I patted his back.

"Its ok. You're a good kid you know?"

Axel looked up at me eyes still watering and a very UN-blown nose. "Thanks so much Mr! I can feel my grip here fading though... I can't wait to see you again!"

After a duel in the first or 2nd game, the opponent gives a line or two of dialogue.
In the game, there is a sealed fortress that you cannot access on the initial story run. To access it in the game you need to win a duel with the king again and he unlocks it for you. Inside are several additional post-game opponents known as ghostmasters! To duel them, you approach a statue that looks like the one you want to duel and select to agree to the duel. They have the most powerful decks for the AI in the game and they are basically without any backstory at all! Axel is one of those Ghostmasters who uses a Wigglytuff deck which is based on one of the most powerful pvp decks in the old metagame. Axel also cries immensely when defeated in a duel. If you lose to him, he comments that it is "only natural".
In the games there are various NPCs that don't have specific names. These characters are never duelists and typically only have dialogue you can read when talking to them. I forget if they can do anything more than that. I think some can trade you cards in the game. This story assumes that they never trade cards.
 
Last edited:

133TFR33k

Creator of the Doduo Alliance
Partners
  1. doduo
Hello, here's the review of Chp 3 and 4. Sorry if it's a little late.
No worries and thanks for getting a review in for 2 chapters! :veelove:

Summary of Chp 3:

So Mr Nameless finds a note inviting him to GR island and this time, he's a lot more inclined to visit that place since y'know, no kidnapping.

He gets there, meets the king and after learning about this card dungeon thingy, he was immediately introduced to the horror that is gambling and understandably he was horrified.

After that, he meets the queen and learns that this dungeon thingy is apparently like chess or something.

Summary of Chp 4:

Mr Nameless talks to Pawn and asks to see the murals in which Pawn gives him a tour. And after a bunch of history stuff about the past heroes, we get some hints about Mr Nameless possibly being the next hero. After that, he beats Pawn, meets Knight and bears him too before meeting up with the Queen.
In a nutshell!

Chapter 3 Review:

It was a fun read. I can certainly notice the improvement compared to the previous three chapters.
Thanks! This is when I started taking more creative liberties with things and wasn't following a strict gameplay route.

I don't think I have much I want to say here. The characters were fun, the receptionist especially was funny and I liked the gambling scene, kinda goofy that it took 'em this long to invent gambling but it's funny enough to imagine that the world would've been a lot happier if Bill wasn't such a greedy corpa guy.
I'm glad you enjoyed the characters and that won't be the last time you see the receptionist either. :mewlulz:

Yeah! Down with the capitalistic scum of Bill! :screm:

The only real complaint I do have is Imakumi. Not his character per se, just his dialogue being kinda wonky. It kinda sticks out when compared to everyone else and I don't know, I just kinda hate it. I've put in more details about him in my line-by-line comments and I kinda don't wanna repeat myself so you can find it there.
You are super spot-on about Imakuni. I just took his in-game dialogue almost verbatim and inserted it right in. I think you are right that I could do a lot more with this.

Hah! Done! I didn't add very much to it, but it should be an improvement over what it was before.

Anyway, yeah it was nice chapter. I'm gotta head on to Chp 4 now.
Glad it went well!

Chp 4 Review:

So this chapter was rather interesting, learning about the history of the past heroes and stuff like that.
The vast majority of the details in this chapter were things I invented for the story. I'm very glad to hear it!

Really weird implications of the world's current technology though. 'cause the exposition kinda makes it feel like the world is stagnate because people are too scared to advance their tech because they don't wanna destroy the world or something shit. Which is like super weird though because the world so far feels like it's like our modern era except a tinsy bit more advanced. I don't know. It really feels like the exposition is trying to tell me that the world is sorta in the medieval era or industrial revolution era but that obviously can't be true because of y'know, phones and stuff.
So, technology in their world HAS stagnated. The ancient past actually has levels of technology beyond what they currently have in their world. They still have higher levels of technology than we do though.

Anyway, aside from that. The history was nice to read through, I like seeing all the different heroes and how Mr Nameless is likely gonna be the next one.
I'm glad I was able to make the history/worldbuilding/lore interesting. It sets up massively for things concerning the remainder of the fic.

Lugia being possibly the next bad guy is super weird though but I'm guessing that's more of a game thing since I assume when they made the game, they had no idea what to do with Legendaries.
Lugia being ominous was entirely my idea. You will learn more about Lugia's involvement in things very soon... in the next chapter, in fact.

But I do have a tiny complaint and it's the exposition itself. While dedicating a chapter to just talking about the world's history isn't bad per se, since I did enjoy it. I'm not entirely sure other people will enjoy just reading through what's essentially a history book with barely anything in between. Like I'll be honest and say I did kinda nod off when reading halfway through the exposition.
Yeah... dealing with the amount of exposition was a big struggle for me in this section of the fic. Unfortunately the next chapter (which I split into 2 in order to help preserve reader sanity) continues this trend. I've done several things already to make them easier reads, but not matter what I do, it's very difficult to completely overcome the massive dump of exposition.

I'm not too sure what I would realistically add in between.

I'm not particularly good at writing exposition myself but I can give some advice on making it more palatable. One being cut down the fluff, no need for more words than necessary,
I've already made some cuts to wording, but maybe there are ways I can try to cut it further. I'll see what I can do.

split the sections up into several smaller parts,
This I can probably try to do more of. The fact that you are bringing it up means I should try to break things up more than I already have.

maybe add some more interactions between Pawn and Mr Nameless
I'll see if there is anything I can do here, but I'm not too optimistic on this idea...

or add more of Mr Nameless's thoughts on the matter.
This might be easy to do.

You could even just have a part of the history lesson be said before skipping past them and bringing it up later. Because it felt like the story kinda just stopped for a moment just to dump all of the history onto me before continuing.
Yeah... its a bit odd on the pacing. I can't think of a way it would make sense to bring these things up later though, so its probably all going to stay in this chapter.

Though it's probably better if you watch a video about learning how to dump exposition since I'm not super good at explaining things myself. So take what I said with a grain of salt.
Perhaps. I don't mind getting ideas from reviews for editing though. Even small gradual improvements over time are fine with me. Less to do all at once that way.

Now let's head on to my line-by-line comments:

Chp 3:


While not grammatically wrong I think 'when you were last here' reads better here
Sure, why not? Edited.

Lol, pretzel bakeries? So not only do these bakeries sell just pretzels but there are also several of them? Damn, maybe I should try a pretzel or something if it's this popular
I don't know, while I was writing it, I just named the first random snack that came to mind for what the Undersiders fed the gentleman. Ever since then, I decided that GR Island takes it's pretzels seriously lol...

I feel like replacing 'expected' with 'thought' or 'believed' would flow better here

Missing a comma between these
Suggestions taken. Thanks!

And they're sure they tried their all in solving this conundrum 'cause I feel like just replacing the doors for gates would work better unless like the daycare's similar to a kid's daycare or something instead of a barn
Its like a kid's daycare. If they put gates that you push to get through, the Doduo's would probably play with the gate and break it.

Shouldn't it be dropping more feathers during molting season or am I looking at this wrong?
Ok I clarified some. The gentleman's Doduo doesn't seem to be losing many feathers lately and has been keen on improving or maintaining it's appearance. The other Doduo at the daycare seem to be losing feathers with reckless abandon and paying no mind to their appearances.

That's one ugly mofo.
Sure is!
:ROFLMAO:

Needs punctuation here.

So I'll be straight, Imakumi's dialogue feels very flat and I'm not sure if it's intentional but it's very game-y and unnatural like Mr Nameless just found a IRL npc or something. Having Imakumi perform some actions or have his dialogue fixed up would probably make him a lot easier to read. As it really does feel like he's reading off a script.
Yep you caught me. Per section above, I think I fixed it now (or close enough).

A random 'but' snuck in here

Dialogue needs punctuation here

Tag needs punctuation
Fixed! Thanks!

Ooh, I like her
Me too. That's why this won't be her last scene. 😁

Needs a comma between these

Should be treaded

Missing an apostrophe

Need a comma between these.

Tag needs punctuation

A bit redundant to have two 'have verb' here, you should remove one so it's either 'i would have loved to play' or 'I would love to have played'

A space got eaten here and dialogue needs punctuation

Either missing an apostrophe or it should be 'family records'. Depends on if it has multiple families or just the one

Tag needs punctuation. Also gotta capitalize the dialogue.


Missing an apostrophe

'Said' shouldn't be capitalized here

Wrong punctuation here. Should be a period
Fixed thanks!

Massive wall of dialogue here. I think it's best if you either cut down some stuff or split them up with some movement or action tags since my first reaction to seeing was 'Geez, that's a lot'
I reworked it a bit to split it up. Thanks for mentioning it!

Missing an apostrophe

Needs a comma between these
Done!

Chp 4

Think you got an extra painted slipped in there unless you're saying someone used a stone to paint the murals?

Should be 'folks'

An extra period at the end there
Fixed. Thanks!

Imagine if the 'expert' is Bill. GR King be singlehandedly bringing Bill's company back from bankruptcy, bro.
:mewlulz:

Should have a comma between these

Should capitalize this
Fixed! Man you have a great eye for picking all these things out! :wowzard:

Lol, so the whole world's Europe?
The bubonic plague was an obvious inspiration for this part, yes.

Wrong form of "you're" and "it's"

Should be 'poorer'

billionaires'
Fixed!

Also true AF, Mr Nameless
:okgon:

Again, "it's"
Fixed!

'Lugia also wanted to' flows better here
Yep, I agree. Edited!

Should be "it's"

Should be 'well-toned'
Fixed!

Not entirely sure if you know about this, since I keep finding this issue but I'll say it just in case. Whenever you're writing something and mentioned someone's name in dialogue, you should put a comma before said name. Ex: "How do you do, fellow guy?" Or "That's super cool, Nathan." The only time you don't put a comma between a name is if you introducing them. Ex: "This is Mikey." or "My name is Faye."
I do know this, but I'm really really bad at catching it... 😅

Thanks for pointing it out!

Oh and also this. If you have something preceding a subject and verb, you put a comma before the subject. Ex: 'After this, he put it down.' or 'With everything that's happened, he should...' etcetera etcetera.
I always feel like I do such a great job editing... until someone else reads and finds things lol...

I am aware of this too, but appreciate you looking out for me on it! Another thing I can't seem to catch nearly often enough...
Anyway, sorry for the wait and I hope you have a great day. Thanks for the fun chapters!
I hope the next chapter goes ok... I think I might want to try editing it more before you read it. I already split it into two separate parts to try to help. I think I need to break the dialogue up more though. You wouldn't believe what it looked like in its original form BEFORE I did all the edits I did so far! I'm glad you seem to be able to deal with exposition... 😅
 
Last edited:

matt0044

Junior Trainer
Pronouns
He/Him
I have seen Chapter 1's changes and I will say that I like the additions you've made in terms of worldbuilding along with Billy's questions. Like it comes off as an aristocrat who's use to the world as it is and won't question a status quo that benefits him. The Mission Reports also give a good impression of the antagonist the come. While I might've "fallen off" this story due to my card game blindness, I did want to remark upon the changes.
 

133TFR33k

Creator of the Doduo Alliance
Partners
  1. doduo
I have seen Chapter 1's changes and I will say that I like the additions you've made in terms of worldbuilding along with Billy's questions. Like it comes off as an aristocrat who's use to the world as it is and won't question a status quo that benefits him. The Mission Reports also give a good impression of the antagonist the come. While I might've "fallen off" this story due to my card game blindness, I did want to remark upon the changes.
Wow hey Matt! Glad to see you pop in!

Card game blindness shouldn't matter too terribly much for the fic. I think you could enjoy it much more than you are thinking you might.

I'm glad the changes are to your liking so far!

I'm also working on a total overhaul revamp to my prologue which will split it into multiple parts (separate posts, chapters essentially). I'd definitely love some feedback on that at some point. Prologue revamp is not complete yet. It's not quite halfway done yet I think. I've only been working on it a week so far though and I haven't been dedicating 100% of my time to it, so it takes some time.
 

candycanearter07

Goomy Appreciator
Location
us
Pronouns
he/him
I really like the framing of it being a diary, but the phrasing to me feels a bit stilted..? Maybe it's just from being not used to reading a lot of fanfiction..
After proving my worth as a card duelist on TCG Island by winning games against a slew of people who live on the island, I was able to gain a substantial amount of money and am now the rank of champion!
I like how it's starting off at what could be considered the "end" of the adventure, its a neat subversion of the whole "going through the game linearly" structure. That being said, from a character angle I am kinda confused why they specifically started writing in it starting at that time.
I believe my late grandfather would approve! He always did stress speaking well, dressing well, manners, and kindness. I don't plan on failing the expectations he had for my life!

Speaking of expectations, this is my first time writing in this Diary. My grandfather had mentioned this is a family heirloom and that it is meant to be used. As it is now mine, I will carry on the tradition and shall keep it with me at all times! I even plan to include some pictures!
Oh. Dead grandpa. What exactly is the tradition, keeping a diary of everything you do? Keeping a diary after you become champion? If it's the former, was the grandpas death coincidentally when they won and became champion, or is it less of a coincidence than you'd think..
Billy leaped up from his seat and stamped his feet. "I WANT HOLOGRAMS! THAT'S HOW YOU PLAY CARDS!"

I had not anticipated teaching a child to be this difficult... Billy and I had to have a long chat about expectations but he eventually calmed down and understood the game is played with actual cards.
Great dynamic with the young kid being inexperienced with the mechanics and stubborn. Holograms would be sick, though. (is there TCG media that uses holograms? im not super familiar with the card side, so if its a reference than sorry)
Billy crossed his arms. "Doesn't our world seem kinda small to you?"

"Compared to what? It's not like we have other worlds to compare it to!"
Does the world not have ANY kind of story telling? Books? Games (besides the card one?) Maybe try to establish that a bit.
"It must mean you ARE a champion though! If you beat everyone easily, that must mean you are amazing!" he said with eyes full of wonder.

Amazing? Is my skill at the game really that hard to attain? It's almost as if the other duelists are just there for kids to craft decks against and beat. They all seem to have at least a basic knowledge of the game, but their tactics are predicable and limited. They also don't seem to grasp the concept of optimizing their decks. Such a perplexing phenomenon...
Slight lampshading about the games being easy? I do like how it establishes characters for the MC being naturally gifted and humble.
"There is one species of Pokemon that actually lives in our world with us instead only being in cards!"

"OOO! What is it? What is it???"

I replied with a confident grin, "That my boy, would be Doduo."
Wait, where do the cards come from then?
I tilted my head. "I don't know what you mean by our world since there should only be one world! Regarding your question though; everyone important plays the Pokemon Trading Card Game. Do you know how you stop a bully from picking on you?"
see above about the multi world comment
Good thing paying off a home lets it permanently belong to you! Could you imagine having something like a real estate tax but having no money to pay the tax so the government just comes and steals your entire house away just from you failing to pay a tax that was only a small fraction of the total value? What a horrible world that would be to live in!
see above about the multi world comment
May 1st
After pondering things for a while, I came up with a plan: from now on, I will only use common cards in my decks! No one will refuse to duel me if they know I am using all common cards! It was starting to get boring winning with fully powered decks anyway... This challenge should prove most stimulating!
Problem solving skills! The gimmick of the fic being something character driven is nice.
May 7th
In my most recent duel, I seem to have caught the eye of a Doduo! It just keeps following me around everywhere!

I tried to communicate that I do not have the funds or the inclination to keep it as a pet or feed it, but it follows me anyway! From its general behavior, I can already tell that it is lazy and gets its feathers everywhere!

On the other hand, if it causes people to take duels with me less seriously, it will likely reduce my chances of opponents refusing to duel me! Since I stand to benefit from this arrangement, I suppose I can tolerate it.
Yayy doduo pet :D


I'm going to stop around here bc of how long this first entry is, but I'm enjoying it so far
 

133TFR33k

Creator of the Doduo Alliance
Partners
  1. doduo
Hi candy!

Thanks for the first review!

I really like the framing of it being a diary, but the phrasing to me feels a bit stilted..? Maybe it's just from being not used to reading a lot of fanfiction..
So... I don't see specifically what you are referring to here and the way it is described makes it hard for me to tell what I could do to improve it...

Clarification here would be helpful.

I like how it's starting off at what could be considered the "end" of the adventure, its a neat subversion of the whole "going through the game linearly" structure.
Thanks! :veelove:

That being said, from a character angle I am kinda confused why they specifically started writing in it starting at that time.
Good thing I had an explanation not long after!

Oh. Dead grandpa. What exactly is the tradition, keeping a diary of everything you do?
Good point! I went ahead and clarified the tradition. Thanks!

Keeping a diary after you become champion? If it's the former, was the grandpas death coincidentally when they won and became champion, or is it less of a coincidence than you'd think..
So in this case, becoming Champion and grandfathers passing happened around the same time. I added a line in to explain that his grandfather got to see him become Champion.

Great dynamic with the young kid being inexperienced with the mechanics and stubborn.
Thanks! :veelove:

Holograms would be sick, though. (is there TCG media that uses holograms? im not super familiar with the card side, so if its a reference than sorry)
It is a reference. It's a reference to Yu-Gi-Oh. No worries that it was missed. It's an extremely minor detail in the fic.

Does the world not have ANY kind of story telling? Books? Games (besides the card one?) Maybe try to establish that a bit.
Hmm... good point. Of course it has storytelling. It already made a Yu-Gi-Oh reference after all. Perhaps I should just take it and run with it. Very well then! I edited those parts to refer to the unamed 'show' that Billy had seen (aka Yu-Gi-Oh)

Slight lampshading about the games being easy? I do like how it establishes characters for the MC being naturally gifted and humble.
Yes on both counts, really.

Wait, where do the cards come from then?
Ooo... you stumbled on a question that has an extremely specific answer much later! You are also the first person to ask that question so early! :eyes:

The cards come from booster packs, but where the booster packs come from... that is something divulged much later.

see above about the multi world comment
Took this out since i fixed it with the example of the 'show' Billy watched.

see above about the multi world comment
Regarding property tax, what kind of sick twisted individual would even create a story with such an abhorrent aspect in a world where that actually didn't exist?

Problem solving skills! The gimmick of the fic being something character driven is nice.
So this is an odd case where you are paying a compliment and it feels good, but I'm not totally sure what you mean. In my mind, aren't all fics character driven?

Yayy doduo pet :D
Yep and this bird aint going NOWHERE. :mewlulz:

I'm going to stop around here bc of how long this first entry is, but I'm enjoying it so far
So... you delved much farther in than I was trying to initially ask... It's my fault. I should have said "Introduction. Not to be confused with the Prologue. For the Prologue, you should stop at the May 5th diary date." Instead I just said "Intro". *Beats head on wall*

I'm glad you stopped here because you overlapped into part of the Prologue that I am in the middle of revamping! Also, it would be unfair for you to do more than that at this point since I should first do more for you!
 

candycanearter07

Goomy Appreciator
Location
us
Pronouns
he/him
So... I don't see specifically what you are referring to here and the way it is described makes it hard for me to tell what I could do to improve it...

Clarification here would be helpful.
I'm not sure exactly how to put it into words, and its probably more my subjective preference, but like having sentences flow into each other a bit more? sorry
So this is an odd case where you are paying a compliment and it feels good, but I'm not totally sure what you mean. In my mind, aren't all fics character driven?
Well, again I haven't read a lot of fics, but like the gimmick being something reasonable for the character to WANT to do, instead of something being forced onto them by another character/plot contrivance, or it just "being how this world works"
So... you delved much farther in than I was trying to initially ask... It's my fault. I should have said "Introduction. Not to be confused with the Prologue. For the Prologue, you should stop at the May 5th diary date." Instead I just said "Intro". *Beats head on wall*

I'm glad you stopped here because you overlapped into part of the Prologue that I am in the middle of revamping! Also, it would be unfair for you to do more than that at this point since I should first do more for you!
sorry ^^"
 

133TFR33k

Creator of the Doduo Alliance
Partners
  1. doduo
I'm not sure exactly how to put it into words, and its probably more my subjective preference, but like having sentences flow into each other a bit more? sorry
Yeah... I'm still not sure. I appreciate you trying to explain though. Don't worry about it.

Well, again I haven't read a lot of fics, but like the gimmick being something reasonable for the character to WANT to do, instead of something being forced onto them by another character/plot contrivance, or it just "being how this world works
Ah ok! That makes sense.

sorry ^^"
Eh, It's my fault and it worked out anyway. Don't worry about it and thanks for the review! :veelove:
 

Umbramatic

The Ghost Lord
Premium
Location
The Yangverse
Pronouns
Any
Partners
  1. reshiram
  2. zygarde
OK here for the next chapter of our review exchange!

This poor, poor receptionist.

Another Doduo. We're doomed.

B-but Scyther is your favorite Pokemon! (hopefully you know this meme)

Doduo's mental health is simultaneously fucked and kinda chill.

At least he's not the masochist Doduo.

THE ALTAR OF THE LACK OF COLORS

Get yourself a Mach Bike, protagonist-kun.

DODUO IS HELPING! SOMETHING IS VERY WRONG!

So it's not actually colorless? False advertising, I want a refund.

Doduo is the most important colorless Pokemon of all!

I love Avery's Pikachu hat.

It's a classic case of Anime Closed Eyes, he can see fine.

I love the absolute silence followed by total gibberish.

Awwwww the Pikachu hat's backstory is actually cute.

Escaping in the midst of an argument, of course.

He hides his eyes because he can see why kids love the taste of Cinnamon Toast Crunch. Truly a terrible power.

Hooded purple robes, my favorite.

Love the Great Rocket hairclips.

Mmmmmm, Auntie Anne's pretzel.....

That's a lot of Gastly and Haunter. And no Trainer cards??? What about my blorbos?!

Yeah I don't think actual competitive TCG decks have that kind of build.

Protagonist-kun has to sit at the unpopular table

Aw, Doduo likes Ellen.

REVOLUTION! REVOLUTION! REVOLUTION!

Oh no. The protagonist is their chosen one. We're doomed.

Aw, Doduo and Ellen are cute.

A stream IS a good place to contemplate Water energy

Yeah fuck your crap Jacob

So Lugia is a deity they worship. Are there any Lugia cards?

KARA DOING THE FUCKING GENDO POSE

70 degrees is a normal temperature for a duel I think

A single solitary fan..............

That said I question the practicality of an entire barrel of fans

The World's Most Unfortunate Girl

Awfully specific foretelling....

Oh there ARE Lugia cards. Are they in the actual game?

Sometimes you just gotta squint man.

LMAO protagonist-kun beat his ass

Lmaooooooooooooo Jacob getting screwed over hoodie-wise

Oh my god Doduo is their mascot. Perfect.

I don't blame protagonist-kun for bribing them for pretzels.

ELLEN GETS A DODUO RIDE!!!!

Very interesting notes at the end about the cards!

----------------

The protagonist's quest is going RELATIVELY smoothly. He's even found some unlikely allies! Will said allies be reliable? Probably not.But I guess we'll find out. Thanks for posting!
 

133TFR33k

Creator of the Doduo Alliance
Partners
  1. doduo
Reply To Review For Chapter 2 - Part 1: The Undersiders

OK here for the next chapter of our review exchange!

This poor, poor receptionist.
One of my favorite lines in the chapter. :mewlulz:

B-but Scyther is your favorite Pokemon! (hopefully you know this meme)
Unfortunately I do not, but it certainly sounds relevant!

Doduo's mental health is simultaneously fucked and kinda chill.
A very true statement...

At least he's not the masochist Doduo.
All Doduo have maschocistic tendencies, but the Doduo who follows the Gentleman indeed is the one we care about.

Get yourself a Mach Bike, protagonist-kun.
Sure, let him just take out his wallet so he can- oh wait, they stole it from him. He can't.

DODUO IS HELPING! SOMETHING IS VERY WRONG!
Indeed. This is quite weird. What does it all mean?

So it's not actually colorless? False advertising, I want a refund.
Its the inside that matters.

Doduo is the most important colorless Pokemon of all!
Lugia disagree's, but I agree with you.

I love the absolute silence followed by total gibberish.
I was hoping you might like it! :mewlulz:

Awwwww the Pikachu hat's backstory is actually cute.
Indeed.

He hides his eyes because he can see why kids love the taste of Cinnamon Toast Crunch. Truly a terrible power.
This. One of your best reactions yet! :mewlulz:

Yeah I don't think actual competitive TCG decks have that kind of build.
No... No they most certainly do not. This is a very awful deck. A beginner would likely make a better one BY ACCIDENT.

Aw, Doduo likes Ellen.
That indeed seems to be the case.

Oh no. The protagonist is their chosen one. We're doomed.
I don't know, he has been winning an awfully large amount of duels so far...

Aw, Doduo and Ellen are cute.
Good, I was hoping to make it sufficiently memorable.

Yeah fuck your crap Jacob
:mewlulz:

A single solitary fan..............

That said I question the practicality of an entire barrel of fans
Shhh... it doesn't have to make sense. It just needs to be endearing.

The World's Most Unfortunate Girl
Yeah, pretty much.

Awfully specific foretelling....
I couldn't resist...

Oh there ARE Lugia cards. Are they in the actual game?
They ARE! In this fic though, there is only ONE Lugia card in existence...

LMAO protagonist-kun beat his ass
Yeah Seth had no chance with a deck that utterly weak that the rest of the Undersiders made him use...

Lmaooooooooooooo Jacob getting screwed over hoodie-wise
Another one of my favorite parts of the chapter! :mewlulz:

Oh my god Doduo is their mascot. Perfect.
Could it honestly really be anything else?

ELLEN GETS A DODUO RIDE!!!!
That won't be the last one either.

Very interesting notes at the end about the cards!
Glad you found them interesting!

----------------
The protagonist's quest is going RELATIVELY smoothly. He's even found some unlikely allies! Will said allies be reliable? Probably not.But I guess we'll find out. Thanks for posting!
They can at least be relied on to carry him and provide pretzels.
 

Spiteful Murkrow

Busy Writing Stories I Want to Read
Pronouns
He/Him/His
Partners
  1. nidoran-f
  2. druddigon
  3. swellow
  4. lugia
  5. growlithe
  6. quilava-fobbie
  7. sneasel-kate
  8. heliolisk-fobbie
Heya, coming right in for my Catnip review. Though a Pokémon TCG video game fic, huh? I don't think I've ever seen one of those in the past, so let's just jump in right at the first chapter as you requested as part of your submission and get rolling:

Chapter 1

When I awoke woke up, I found myself on an unfamiliar island with a folded note-card set underneath my deck of cards laying nearby:

"If you wish to return to your island, you must seek the king of this land and earn his favor! To do so, you must defeat all willing opponents using nothing but common cards. Unwilling opponents are those that require you to change the cards in your deck. If they do this, they are unpopular social outcasts whom no one likes but merely tolerates. Their favor is meaningless. Oh, and don't count on any booster packs to help you either. Instead we will be giving out IOU's for you to claim if you can defeat the king. If you do not seek the favor of the popular folk of this island, you shall simply starve as the inhabitants of the island (both popular and unpopular) find amusement in your suffering. -GR(aka Great Rocket) Psychic Leader Claire"

escalated-quickly-anchorman.gif


Though I kinda wonder if it’d have made sense to format the note to offset it a bit more from the surrounding text. e.x. If using [ indent ] [ /indent ] blocks (minus the spaces):

"If you wish to return to your island, you must seek the king of this land and earn his favor! To do so, you must defeat all willing opponents using nothing but common cards. Unwilling opponents are those that require you to change the cards in your deck. If they do this, they are unpopular social outcasts whom no one likes but merely tolerates. Their favor is meaningless. Oh, and don't count on any booster packs to help you either. Instead we will be giving out IOU's for you to claim if you can defeat the king. If you do not seek the favor of the popular folk of this island, you shall simply starve as the inhabitants of the island (both popular and unpopular) find amusement in your suffering.​
-GR(aka Great Rocket) Psychic Leader Claire"​

Though I can’t tell if the extent to which the note is on the nose is a feature or a bug here. Since it definitely feels more than a little meta.

Attached to the note was a brochure map of GR Island detailing numbered locations and various duelists, kind of like what one might pick up at an amusement park. It even had an x drawn on it with a note labeled “You are here”!

View attachment 19175

Huh. Neat little touch there working in the map like that.

Doduo, of course, was nearby.

I'm sure my assailant could have sold it, but the way it spread its feathers about likely made it more trouble than it was worth. Apparently the bird finds the prospect of starving amusing. I suppose I shouldn't be too surprised. That bird regenerates at an incredible rate. Even if knocked out in battle, it wakes up shortly after, picks itself up, and follows me no matter how swiftly I may walk. With it able to do that, I imagine it can go an incredibly long time without food…

Okay, I know that we’re basically starting in medias res in this story reviewing Chapter 1 without the Prologue, but I do wonder if there should’ve been a bit more “right, Duduo, he’s a thing” in this chapter than what’s presently here.

Doduo rolled around in the grass littering its feathers about. But feathers, however irritating they may be, were the least of my concern in such a situation...

(12)

Oh hey, the links are to music. Though I wonder what this numbering system means since I noticed that you didn’t put the links over actual text terms in this story.

I checked my pockets but confirmed I was now missing my wallet, so I knew I would be unable to continue my bribery of the gambling establishment. Perhaps they will accept IOU's? I chuckled to myself a bit.

I feel like there’s something the underlined is referring to that we’re missing a bit of context on. It might’ve been worth referring to what that was alluding to in a bit more detail.

Hopefully my time on this island would be shorter than the amount of time I had set up to gain from my prior bribery. I did still have my other common cards with me, but I had already created the strongest all-common deck I could think of. The only one that who seemed elated by this overall situation was that bumbling bird. Because of course it would love this.

Threw in a few more wording tweak suggestions, though I don’t really know what the underlined is referring to. If it is an event from the prologue, describe it in some clearer terms than what you’re presently using here. Even for readers not picking things up in the thick of things, it’s a handy reminder for if they’re coming back after a bit of a hiatus from your story.

To get out of this mess, I knew I would have to do exactly what the note said: win duels against the duelists of GR island. Checking the map, I saw that the first location was the GR fortress of grass. As I was not keen on starving, I reasoned the best way to proceed would be to play all worthy opponents in each fortress culminating in winning a duel against the leader. There would simply be no time to travel about dueling only basic members of a fortress and then traveling around all over again just to challenge the leaders.

I was glad I had a hearty victory meal prior to my kidnapping. At least the note said nothing about dehydration, so I can would presumably have water, at least.

Wait, I’m just realizing, but what do our protagonist’s surroundings look like anyways? Like does everything look like a normal island to him? Is he in some sort of freakish pixel plane? I don’t feel we have an awful lot to work with at the moment, since if this looks like “real life”, it might be worth playing up the whole “this is absurd” angle of being in a position where you have to play card games for sustenance.

Before I began traveling, I reasoned that I might need the teleporter to be operating at peak efficiency as I had never been to this island before and had no idea how strong the opponents here could be! I pulled out my phone and dialed the number for Bill’s company.

(13)

… Yeah, this is another thing where having more description of relative surroundings at some point would’ve helped a lot, since this whole ‘teleporter’ and ‘Bill’ thing is coming really suddenly right now.

Though nice chiptunes, there.

As I painstakingly navigated through a tangled web of phone prompts, Doduo decided to frolic in a nearby field spreading its feathers about. I suppose an experience of being stranded with the threat of starvation like this is exactly what that bird dreams of…

Didn’t you say something that was almost just like this a few paragraphs ago? Since I could’ve sworn you just made a joke about Doduo being a-OK with watching the protagonist starve.

After selecting a total of no less than forty-six phone prompts, the line finally went to a queue to be answered!

An automated voice played: “Please hold while we work to connect you. Your estimated wait time exceeds what we have been programmed to say. We value your time and thank you for your patience.”

IMO, this would probably have been a bit more interesting to actually see a couple attempts by the protagonist to reach this phone line only for things to not work out before doing this whole “46 attempts later” thing.

What kind of purgatory is this? If this is what happens when they value my time, I don’t think I would EVER want to find out what the opposite looks like!

Is this meant to be something the protagonist actually says? Since the formatting is a bit strange compared to the narration up to this point, which was formatted as a series of recollections.

Then it came spouting forth. Oh it sounded pleasant enough at the time, but little did I know just how long this hold time music would be playing… Refusing to have my phone blare what would soon become my absolute least favorite string of notes and sounds, I decided to use my earbud headphones instead - just one though! To use two, I would have to be quite mad indeed...or a Doduo I suppose.

I think that it probably makes sense to describe in a bit more detail what the hold music is like, especially if it’s meant to be something from the TCG2 game.

I then found myself thinking of Doduo... its rotund body looked like it could make a reasonable mount and its legs were surprisingly sturdy and limber... But those feathers... if I should try to ride it, those feathers would infest every inch of my suit pants! Dare I befoul my precious attire with a plague of its detestable feathers? If I ride it though, I can conserve energy and reach destinations likely far faster than I would on foot…

It wasn't long until I found myself attempting to ride the dumb bird.

Your verb tenses are a little wonky here since some parts are being narrated as “after the fact” things while others are very “ongoing events”. I would strongly suggest picking one or the other and sticking to it as your default perspective.

I confirmed it could support my weight rather easily, much to its dissatisfaction. It clearly wanted to be crushed, but at 170 pounds and at a height of 5"11, I simply just didn't have what it took to measure up to that dumb bird's aspirations.

Wait, how does the narrator know that? Like was there something specific about Doduo’s reaction that made him think that? Though all this time, we’ve heard a lot told to us about how Doduo was reacting, but not really seen it in much detail.

Since I had come this far, it was time to start moving! Right now. In that direction. Over there! The bird simply stood there... I spent the next five minutes trying to get it to move when it finally started to go! In the wrong direction!

I mean, yeah. That feels pretty par for the course for our narrator’s luck at this rate.
803821849384583219.webp


I waved my arms around gesturing as overtly as possible. "No! Not that way! Turn over here! This way! Please?"

At that, Doduo stopped, tilted one of its heads, and then started pecking the ground with both heads quickly forming a hole. It then plunged one of its heads in, scooping up some worms in its beak. Mortified, I watched it feast on something so unpalatable that I would rather starve than eat! As it ate, the faces it made suggested it was objectively disgusting and yet it just couldn't seem to get enough of them! Well, at least my appetite won't be bothering me for a while now!

Okay, so it’s kind of a general trend in this story, but we’ve had a lot of high-level “telling” of events that are happening in the story, with not much shown in the way of details for how things play out. Even if you’re going with a “memoir”/”epistle” format, you ideally want to show more of the process play out. e.x. a throwaway example of what that could look like:

I waved my arms around gesturing as overtly as possible. "No! Not that way! Turn over here! This way! Please?"

At that Doduo stopped, tilted one of its heads, and then started pecking the ground with both heads quickly forming a hole. It then plunged one of its heads in, and I wasn’t sure what to make of it until I saw it pull the head out, with worms wriggling about in its beak. I instantly heaved as it threw its head back and swallowed the disgusting things before throwing its other head back to gather more. Go figure, the only food that my newfound companion could find was something so unpalatable that I would rather starve before eating it!

It just couldn't seem to get enough of them and brought its heads back one after the other for more and more of its meal. If there was any silver lining at all from that disgusting display, it was that my appetite didn’t bother me for a long time afterwards.

Or something like that.

Having seen enough, I dismounted and confirmed the horrible truth looked down to see that my worst fears about riding this foul fowl had come to pass: I was now covered in its feathers of the foul fowl.

[ ]


I then had one more idea: with a long nearby stick, I stabbed a worm and remounted the fat bird. I then held the stick out ahead just out of reach of its long necks. Doduo looked at me. It then looked at the stick. It then made an expression of... amusement mixed with...smugness!? It then used one head to grab the stick from me and the other to eat the worm!

[ ]

"Why?!" I grabbed my head with both hands in frustration.

These sections here feel like you’re skipping ahead of some transitions showing off your protagonist’s inner thought process about Doduo and trying to wrangle it a bit more.

So apparently it has some modicum of intelligence, yet it uses it only for the purposes of driving one mad! Clearly, relying on that bird for travel was far out of the question! I then began my trek on foot to the GR Grass Fortress while meticulously plucking feathers out of my suit the majority of the journey! I wondered to myself just how that bird can seemingly be molting at all times everywhere it goes... The bird of course made sure to follow, often running ahead only to circle back as if to tell me just how ineffective my poor excuses of legs were to its own…

There’s quite a bit going on here at a fairly high level. I would strongly recommend pushing some of this into dialogue (e.x. the observation about intelligence), showing more of the process of the narrator’s thought process and decision-making play out (e.x. His “screw this, I’m outta here” where he tries to bail on Doduo), also we are seeing some details here that feel like they’re brought up in a very “after-the-fact” fashion such as the ‘molting’ angle. Ideally you want that to be a thing acknowledged earlier as well if this is something that just keeps happening.

(14)

After finally arriving at the GR Grass Fortress, I noticed the entrance was full of grass with bushes in the corners with vines growing on the walls! Some random sections of grass was left longer. Normally one would have to go outdoors to experience the outdoors, but not so in this place! There was a doorway to the right leading to the lobby and a doorway dead ahead leading to the depths of the fortress.

Wait, wait, wait. Our protagonist is already at the first fortress? We didn’t see anything at all of the journey over there and there wasn’t really much acknowledgement of it even in an after-the-fact fashion. Like how is our protagonist even functioning at the moment if he’s doing this on an empty stomach?

First, I paid a visit to the lobby and of course it had a restroom and one of the best inventions of mankind! A water fountain! Ah, to be able to drink as much fresh water as one desired free of charge was a dream come true on an island bent on my starvation! After I drank my fill, I made it a point to stop at the water fountain at every future fortress I would travel to. I also noticed Doduo using the Doduo water fountain nearby as well.

Wait, but wouldn’t a water fountain not fix the whole ‘starvation’ angle given that water hydrates but has little to no caloric value?
701429736290910228.webp


Like I get what you’re going for (even if we haven’t seen much of it onscreen), but you probably want something more along the lines of “bent on killing me” or something like that.


The lobby was very much like any typical fortress or club lobby with its own nuances. For this one, I noted the hardwood floors and flower beds in the corners. It had the food and snack counter too as well as along with the typical PC in the corner. In the center, of course, was the duel table. No proper lobby would be complete without that! Feeling refreshed, I then made my way inside the main section of the fortress.

Was… there a fortress / club lobby depicted in the prologue? If not, this means exactly nothing to your readers who didn’t play the PTCG games. You probably should spend a bit more time sketching things out and showing the protagonist reacting to his change of fortunes here.

I entered the first room and took note of the dim lighting in the place. All of it was coming from patches of some kind of bioluminescent moss that grew on and around the various rocks and boulders! There were also several mushrooms. Most of the floor was simply dirt.

… Wait, how on earth does this place even have functional electricity if the first room outside of the lobby is like that? :copyka:

Doduo began jumping around the room ramming itself into the moss covered rocks. Some of the luminous moss was getting in its feathers which were scattering about the place in typical Doduo fashion. Since the place was mossy with an outdoor feel, I felt no obligation to pick up Doduo's feathers, for once.

Doduo was not acknowledged as being with the protagonist until just now. You probably want to have more of one than what you presently have up to this point.

Standing in the center of the room in foreboding dim lighting was my first opponent from GR Island according to the brochure: Melissa. She wore a large straw hat with the GR logo on it, a white shirt and a pair of blue overalls. She was blond with freckles and had her hair in pigtails. I guessed her age might be sixteen.

View attachment 18974

I’m going to guess that ‘Melissa’ is the name of this character in the fan translation, since I didn’t think that PTCG 2 had a non-Japanese release, and the name of your embedded picture is different.

She noticed my approach as she just finished yawning. "Maaaaan, its so boring here. The king ordered everyone at their posts ages ago. What took you so long to get here?"

I was rather annoyed. "Apologies if my kidnapping has inconvenienced you. I'll try to be kidnapped better next time."

This is also something that I’m really lost on coming into Chapter 1 without the Prologue. It probably would’ve been worth giving reminders as to the protagonist’s present predicament a bit more via his internal thought process.

She then laughed. "Wow! I thought the kidnapping was just a rumor! So they really did do that? Finally something interesting around here!

[ ]

You know what's more boring than watching grass grow?"

My expression was blank. "Watching moss grow perhaps?"

Her jaw dropped. "Woah! How did you know I was going to say that? Are you a psychic?!"

IMO, Melissa’s line works better in two parts with a moment for the protagonist to react to things, especially since I would assume he’s a bit opinionated about her lack of concern about his problems.

Protagonist: “(Is everyone on this island like this?!)”
659983090747441181.webp


Noting that her reply was too genuine to be sarcasm, I gave my reply: "No, I am not psychic."

She was clearly impressed. "Wow, you must have amazing intuition!"

I sighed. "You wouldn't happen to have any food would you?"

Some more spots where you’re a bit far into “tell and not show” territory. I would suggest showing a bit more off of the two’s reactions and especially of the protagonist’s thought process here.

She then put her hand in her pocket and began speaking as she started pulling out an individually-wrapped large chocolate-covered pretzel!

"Oh well sure! I have this- WAIT A MINUTE! The King decreed that NO ONE is allowed to give you food!"

Wow, someone was certainly petty there.

I remained calm. "Did the King give you the name of the one you could not give food to?"

She then blinked and stared blankly for a moment. She then opened her mouth as she took a balled fist and smacked it into her other open hand.

"...No! He didn't, but he said the gentleman would be wearing a red suit! That means you!" She pointed at me.

Time to take your suit off if you want to eat, buddy. Even if I’m a little surprised that the protagonists isn’t having more of a reaction to all of this.

I placed a hand upon my chest. "Oh this suit? Why this is a crimson suit my dear! Why would you think it is red?"

She then stared hard and suspiciously at my suit and then at me. I gave her my most convincing confident smile before she spoke again.

"Iiiiive never heard of crimson before. I think you're making up colors! Nice try, bucko!"

This is another spot where you probably want to show off more of Melissa’s mood, since I didn’t get a solid read on her intended vibe/demeanor here.

[ ]

"Bollocks!" I snapped my fingers as I looked down and to my left before looking back up at her again, "well, if you are unwilling to believe me, then perhaps you would care to wager your food in a duel?"

She confidently crossed her arm with her eyes closed. "Nope! I don't need to do that! Our leader, Parker, said that your only way off this island is to duel us! So, you're going to duel me anyway!"

Another spot where it probably makes sense to show off more of the protagonist’s thought process here, especially if Doduo’s getting up to anything.

Protagonist: “Lady, are you freaking kidding me right now?!”
476586337689141257.webp


View attachment 18974

I lamented how close I was to that pretzel she had in her pocket, but proceeded to duel her.

My Dark Rapidash made short work of her. As expected since this is the grass fortress.

She threw her arms up in frustration. "Wait what? That's it?? Nooo! My shift isn't even close to being over and the King had us clear our entire schedule just to duel you!

I began gathering my cards.

I’m… not really feeling this battle format that you have here, since we literally just cut ahead without any real acknowledgement of what the card battle between these two looks like. Like I get that doing a blow-by-blow narration of turns in a card game could get old if it dragged on, but I think that showing something of it would be more interesting to read than this.

[ ]

"Say... you wouldn't want to maybe duel me again would you?" She asked as she batted her eyelashes.

I crossed my arms. "Not at this time unless you are willing to part with food."

I would recommend adding added description here which should probably be taped to the “I began gathering my cards” paragraph from earlier.

She sighed. [ ]

"Aww... alllllright... just be sure to come back here if you ever want to play again, okay?"

I tilted my head. [ ]

"After being kidnapped and starved, I should think the chances of that are quite low indeed!"

What is with the people on this island? The King orders a kidnapping and they simply find it interesting? They don't seem particularly willing to part with any food either!

Some more spots where it probably make sense to expand on things in terms of reactions there.

Finished with its unique form of 'fun', Doduo trotted along with me as if it hadn't just spent the last good while ramming itself violently into glowing moss-covered rocks and boulders…

Wait, but we didn’t see Doduo do any of that up to this point. It probably would’ve made sense to give more of an acknowledgement of what Doduo was doing earlier on.

I then passed through the doorway and unlit hall to the next room which contained proper lighting.

The room was roughly half the size of the previous one. The floor was covered in straw with bales of hay stacked in all the corners. In the middle of the room stood my presumed next foe, James! He wore the same getup that Melissa had but had his hat angled in a way to cover one of his eyes while exposing his blue hair on one side and the back.

View attachment 18975

I wasn’t expecting this to be an E4-style gauntlet. Was that how things worked in PTCG 2? If so, you probably want to take some time to explain that somewhere, or else if this is brand-new for the protagonist and he’s learning in live-time, show him reacting a bit more to what’s happening here.

Noticing the hay, Doduo immediately leaped into the pile in the back and began rummaging about in it. [ ] I imagined this would make for quite the mess…

You should show off the mess that Doduo is making a bit more, since it’s also a bit of an “informed attribute” at the moment.

James didn't notice though since it was behind him and he was confidently staring right at me.

"So! You managed to defeat Melissa did you? Well too bad you have to get past ME!"

Doduo leaped out of one pile in the back. It looked more like a straw-duo by this point. It immediately jumped into another nearby pile to repeat the process.

I grinned. "Do you use grass types my good man?"

He proudly declared, "I sure do!"

I… don’t really feel that we are getting much of an introduction of James at the moment. Like Melissa’s introduction earlier was already fairly light, but this is even moreso here.

"Oh good, this will be quick then."

I noticed the confusion on his face as we began our duel.

James fell easily to my Dark Rapidash.

He clasped his head in both hands as he stared intently at the cards I had already begun to pick up. "Noooo! Why did you have to have a fire deck!?"

Once again, this is suffering from the same “cutahead and skip over all the actual action” issue that the battle with Melissa did. Since it feels a bit strange that we’re having a PTCG story and that specific card games aren’t a bigger deal in how things are playing out.

I corrected him, "Actually, it's a half fire deck, but of course I would favor the fire side of it against you."

Which again, we haven’t gotten to see at all since we’ve just been told that it’s a Dark Rapidash deck without any information about the other supporting cards.

He crossed his arms and looked up and to the right with his eyes closed.

"Ha! Well you just got lucky! There is no way you will beat the others on our island! I wonder how many it will take for you to meet your match?" he smiled cruelly at me.

Protagonist:
o-ok-62340ab844c0b0e5caeaf227ca6763b9-meme.jpeg


I rolled my eyes as I made my way to the hall towards the next room with Doduo now trailing behind me. Hay had now worked its way into almost all of its plumage. It's true I am very far from my goal and I am indeed benefiting from type advantage here, but it's not like I have a choice! I must press on if I am to avoid starvation!

As I walked down the hall I could hear James in a loud voice: "My hay! What happened to my hay?! This is going to take HOURS to clean! NoOoOoO!!!"

I… feel that the narrator’s thought process is inconsistent a bit. Like the whole “avoiding starvation” thing has been repeated a few times, but we haven’t actually really seen hunger affecting his thought process all this time, since you’d think that would also impact stuff like how well the protag can stay on his game or stuff like that.

I couldn't help the smile that worked its way onto my face. I had a good chuckle as I walked down the rest of the hall.

In the next room it had neatly trimmed grass with some small flowers in it as well scattered about. The walls were lined with shelves, some with orange flowers and others with purple.

Oh, so another card battle, huh? Let’s see who we’re up against here.

Doduo looked rather bored in this room as it yawned with both of its heads.

I then encountered Liz who was watering flowers...alone... in a corner. She was wearing another one of the straw hats with the GR logo but she had on a green shirt. She had freckles, blond hair, and looked to be about twenty years old.

View attachment 18976

Oh, hello there, third person whose name I’m assuming is fan translated.

The moment she caught sight of me, she started spouting some such nonsense as that about how she would be unwilling to duel me unless I change my deck to suit her fancy! Clearly she was one of those unpopular folk of the island. She then started her drivel of how no one ever wants to play with her and how she just wished everyone would only use grass energy in their decks!

Unswayed by her pleas, I declined to debase my deck in such a fashion purely for her entertainment. She then muttered something about how the masses of the downtrodden shall overthrow the yolk of the popular as she resumed watering her flowers with the intense look of one who had been denied for the very last time... Not wanting to linger there, I walked away as fast as I could farther in to the fortress!

I… was not really feeling this sequence. Since this would’ve been a lot more interesting to see play out in an actual exchange instead of it being summarized in two paragraphs like this. Especially since unlike the first two card players, we don’t really get a change to hear Liz in her own voice. Like if the idea is that the protagonist is starting to zone out and phone things in because he’s hungry, you have some room to gloss things over, but this feels like a bit much.

I finally made my way to the deepest reaches of the fortress. It was a massive indoor garden! The floor was all grass with some patches that were allowed to grow longer and some small patches of flowers here and there. Shortly past the entrance was a wood log bridge over a small stream right inside the building! It looks like it was constructed over a real stream from the outside. I noticed some fish swimming in it as I crossed. In the center of the room were hedges trimmed to the shape of giant letters "G R". Further ahead was a hardwood platform which was up against a bed of purple flowers along the back wall. It was flanked on both sides by small pine trees which extended into the corners. Standing on the wooden platform was a man.

I feel like this paragraph is at once overly long, while it’s kinda lacking in detail. I would suggest splitting things up into at least two paragraphs and describing the surroundings and the protagonist’s reaction to things a bit more.

With all the space, Doduo began running about the room kicking up small amounts of grass and flowers that mixed with the straw and feathers dislodging from it. It was quite the impressive mess.

The man on the platform introduced himself as Parker and smiled at me as if I was a guest and was not actually kidnapped and being forced to duel my way through the island to avoid starvation!

The mention of Doduo and its antics here feels like kind of a non sequitur with what’s going on with Parker. I would strongly suggest tying the two into each other more. e.x. if Parker has any commentary about Doduo being Doduo there.

I spoke first. "Good sir, while I can appreciate the virtue of manners, I think the kidnapping puts a bit of a damper on it, wouldn't you agree?"

His smile became a nervous one. [ ]

"Well... yeah... sorry about that! I personally was against it, but when our king wants to do something we don't exactly get to tell him no..."

[ ] I brandished my deck.

"Enough pleasantries. The clock of my starvation ticks and I'm ready to be done here. En-garde, sir!"

Would recommend showing off more of the characters’ reactions and especially the protagonist’s inner thought process. Especially at Parker’s attempts at deflecting things.

With the Fire and Lightning types of my deck, it was perfectly suited to counter Parker's deck. He did not last long. I swiftly turned to leave once it was done as he stood there with with his awkward nervous smile after he lost so badly.

View attachment 18979

Doduo, of course, trailed me on my way out.

See the remarks about how the past card battles were handled, since this one is suffering from the same issue of not being able to see how the actual process played out, so it was not really interesting to see play out.

As we passed by Liz, she was watering flowers but was smiling as she did and looking directly at me the entire time. So unsettling!

As we passed by James, he was hard a work piling up hay. One of the piles nearby had yet to be tied. I caught sight of Doduo pausing and looking at James, presumably to make sure he was distracted.

I didn’t realize “way out” meant backtracking past the earlier card players. You probably want to explicitly state that at some point, since I’ll admit that I was doing a pretty strong double-take at them showing up again.

View attachment 18975

It then kicked over a nearby hay pile as it quickly scampered away to catch up to me. As we walked further away, I heard James call out again.

"Not agaaaain! HOW does this keep happening?!"

Hellraising bicephalic ostriches, of course.

Chuckling again as I made my way down the hall, I thought I had caught Doduo... snickering? When I took a closer look though, its face was as dumb and vacant as usual. Odd.

Oh, so Doduo’s dumbness is all an act. Duly noted there.

I soon arrived at Melissa's room again as I noticed she was closely inspecting her surroundings.

As I walked by, I heard her muttering. "Now where did I put that pretzel! My special chocolate covered pretzel! Where did you go?"

[ ] Before leaving I stopped by the lobby again for more water.

Given how the protagonist hasn’t eaten all this time and was already feeling very hungry before this card gauntlet. I’m surprised that he’s just brushing off the “where’d I leave my food?” comment and not trying to find it before Melissa does.

(15)

Before I could make it to the water fountain, I finally heard a voice from the earbud! After being held in a form of torturous stasis for what felt like an unimaginable vast eternity to reach the Bill's Incorporated company, a clearly outsourced representative with a thick Neo Island accent asked for my name!

I quickly took a seat at the duel table, switched to speakerphone and announced my identity and scope of my inquiry to discover why Bill's teleporter so often finds itself unplugged despite my prepaid services! I awaited the next words with baited breath but the representative disclosed to my abject horror that I had reached the incorrect department for my inquiry, despite the fact that I had already been transferred twice!

Quickly, I attempted to explain the situation thus far, but as I laid out my case the representative spoke with greater haste than I and announced I would again be transferred! As the abominable music from my phone resumed its tortuous melody, I felt my heart sink in despair.

Will no one solve this mystery?!

This entire sequence here would’ve worked a lot better if we got to see it play out more along with some of the actual dialogue from this phone exchange playing out. Since you’d think there’d be some prime comedy to be had with the whole protagonist’s frustration over getting jerked around by crappy customer service while he’s stuck on an island in the middle of nowhere and going hungry.

Just when I imagined it could get no worse, my fat lazy bird of a Doduo began to dance to the tune of my misery as it littered the floor with more of its precarious plumage! Of course that bird would prefer like this ghastly torturous track!

This feels like a moment that would’ve been funny to see during the background of the actual call, since there are moments where the protagonist is on hold for a while, and it feels like a more organic way of integrating things together.

Had I the free use of my communication device, I might even find a way to escape this island, but the prospect of a disconnection of the current call after my incalculable getting disconnected yet again and suffering at the hands through another gauntlet of phone prompts, absurdly long hold times, transfers, and monotonous low quality sound attempting to pass itself off as music, is just the deterrent to keep me from reaching for it. proved to be an even greater penalty than Death by starvation almost sounds like a relief in comparison, so I elected to remain in the current state of things opted to leave my communicator be...

Made some suggested rephrasing for this section here. Though this is part of the reason why showing off the protagonist’s thought process more throughout the chapter would help quite a bit.

With a heavy heart and the constant noise of what should’ve been a useful device, I embarked on my next quest to the GR club of lightning... but not before Doduo poked me with its beak.

I whirled around tilting my head as I went. "What?!"

It simply stood there with a dull vacant look in its eyes. I was about to turn back around when I noticed on the duel table behind it was an unattended packaged large chocolate pretzel! What luck! I hastily shoved it in my pocket and embarked to the GR club of lightning savoring my pretzel as we journeyed there.

… Wait, just how far have we gone again? Like if the protag teleported from one location to another, you should probably still work in a sequence showing off the whole “oh, that’s new”-ness of his present surroundings since I actually didn’t get a firm vibe of what embarking on his “next quest” looked like.

Under normal circumstances, I would have inquired as to the pretzels owner, but with kidnapping and the threat of starvation, all bets were off!

Whelp, at least the protag has finally gotten to eat something there.

(16)

When I finally found myself fixed inside the fortress of lightning, I feared my feet may give in to fatigue so I floundered to the lobby in search of a chair to flop upon to rest my weary legs.

This lobby had large pipes made of glass with visible electrical current along some of the walls. The floor was large steel tiles.

IMO, it probably makes sense to frontload the description of what these forts look like as early as possible. e.x. Mention what the fort looks like on the inside and then bring up the protag flopping over into the chair.

I discovered the only open seat was at a duel table with a man sitting on the other end!

The man introduced himself as Peter.

He looked to be about twenty-four years old and wore a striped red and white shirt with a black undershirt. He had short brown hair and a small goatee.

View attachment 19170

Peter, informed me that in order to sit, I must be willing to duel him.

I’m not really sure why we’re not having any of this being handled in dialogue, since we’re not really getting a good feel for what Peter is like as a personality as a result.

I could understand that, as it was a duel table after all. What kind of monster would just sit down at one taking up space like that when there are always so many people looking to have a duel? No. Such manners would be far beneath my upbringing. I of course agreed to the duel as my primary mission required me to anyway.

My Voltorb made quick work of him and for the spoils I was able to enjoy the seat a while longer.

Once I was refreshed, I made my way to the water fountain, drank my fill, and then made my way to the interior of the seemingly experimental facility of lightning.

I… am not really feeling the one-liner battle here. Like I suspect that this is a meta choice to try and keep your chapter shorter but it suffers from the same issue as the earlier card battles done in this style where we don’t get a chance to actually see much cardplay or have one or the other side quip about things.

Also, with how glossed-over these card battles have been, I’m surprised that you haven’t just been fast-forwarding everything except one very standout one (which you’d think would be one towards the end).


The first room had a pit so far down that I could not see the bottom. A steel bridge connected the entrance to the other half of the room which was lined with construction fences presumably to keep people from falling to their deaths. The floor was composed entirely of more large steel tiles. There were a couple machines, one in each corner. They looked like old-style very large computers. At one of them was another member of team GR.

I… think that you probably want a bit more of a transition going from the lobby into this new room here, since this felt really sudden to me.

Doduo was looking excitedly over the edge into the dark abyss below. It looked so badly like it wanted to jump right in but was seemingly restraining itself.

Never change, Doduo.
803821849384583219.webp


The GR member introduced herself as Cassie. She had a protective helmet with the GR logo on it and wore glasses, a black shirt, and yellow overalls. She looked to be about ten years old.

View attachment 18981

Before I could even begin to greet her, she waylaid my ears with praise and adoration for Pikachu cards and of her firm believe that all duelists everywhere should have decks that contain 4 of them. I wished to pass by, but of course the button for the door to proceed was located directly behind her. All attempts to pass by were met with an and equal and opposite reaction as she continued her declaration of all things Pikachu! I was suddenly starting to sympathize with the staple status citizens as she droned on and on for what must have been 30 minutes! Finally she asked me if I would duel her with her conditions.

I replied back the moment the last single syllable of her silly sentence was complete: "No thank you."

At this she wailed the wail of a thousand tortured souls.

Once again, the over-summarizing is kinda killing things here, since there’s a lot of character and lulz to be had from actually showing Cassie gush about her Pikachu cards which isn’t coming through from the present format.

View attachment 19173

As she was finally distracted by her own distress, I dodged to her side and found my hand upon the button of my salvation! With the door now open, I quickly retreated to the next room. On my way out I heard the onset of a call to an apparent acquaintance of hers: Liz of the GR Grass club. Wanting to be about my way, I tarried not a moment longer.

Wow, so our protag’s actually just straight-up skipping card battles now. I wasn’t expecting that. Is that something you can actually do in PTCG 2?

Doduo followed me but looked longingly back at the abyss of doom from the previous room. I reasoned that bird must have the survival instinct... of a spoon.

Alternatively, he knows it frustrates you and finds it funny. Since we did get a not-so-subtle hint that Doduo is smarter than he lets on.

As I entered the next room I found a massive red pipe-shaped machine that took up the entire right wall. On it were large letters: GR. In the far left corner were a couple other smaller machines Presumably intended to monitor the large red monstrosity. At a small control panel on the monstrosity was another member of team GR.

Doduo looked crestfallen with the room as it continued to look longingly back down the hall towards the previous room.

Protagonist: “Doduo, seriously! Stop thinking about the stupid bottomless pits!”
476586337689141257.webp


As I approached, the member of GR turned around revealing himself to be an elderly chap named Chip. He wore a protective hat with a welding mask that was turned up so he could see normally. He wore a yellow suit and brown tie. His hair had all turned white with age and his eyebrows were very bushy.

View attachment 19172

It turns out he was completely obsessed with lightning energy.

I attempted to explain to him that with the addition of another energy type to a deck, it is more adaptable and less prone to weakness, but he adamantly and stubbornly refused to listen stating that with a strong enough will, the power of lightning can overcome all odds. I resonated somewhat with this as Voltorb does indeed seem to make a case for such things, but never in isolation. The efforts of its allies are what allow it to triumph!

Which again, would’ve probably been more interesting to see play out had we actually seen more of the actual back-and-forth between these two.

I offered to demonstrate the deck I displayed, but he would have none of it and demanded I debase my deck to that of only lightning. When I refused, he became obstinate and ornery indicating that any who had not attained an age such as his was of lesser intelligence and was unable to understand the insignificance of all other energy types when compared to that of lightning. I left the man of questionable sanity to his ramblings as he hobbled away to the prior room in a hurry calling out to Cassie.

Ditto here.

Protagonist: “So, uh… this counts as forfeiting and me winning by default, right?” ^^;


Doduo let out what sounded like a sigh as it followed along.

I now entered the final room of the fortress and found myself quite shocked that there were no popular duelists to stand between myself and the GR leader of lightning, Catherine!

Wow, so Chip really did just straight-up forfeit over “use lightning”. I wasn’t expecting that to work since you’d think that these card battlers would be the ones who would be able to set the rules of the battle.

You probably want to communicate more as to why the protagonist was able to get away with this and not forced to fight his way through anyways, since I’m not sure why he’s able to just go:

Creating_Bugs_Bunny%27s_%22No%22.jpg


at special conditions in this complex when he had to fight through four card battlers in the last one.


The room had a large GR logo stamped in the middle of the floor and a large control panel with all sorts of flashing lights just past it and attached to a massive machine with large pipes and chambers or sections. Lining the room were glass pipes with visible electrical current running through them!

Doduo looked like it was considering a criminal charge of property damage to get its kicks from the electrical currents in the glass pipes but it seemed to be restraining itself again.

That sounds more like a recipe for a Darwin Award considering Doduo’s typing. ^^;

Catherine wore the same style of welding cap that Chip had as well as a yellow suit white dress shirt underneath and a blue tie. She had long blond hair and deep blue eyes. she looked to be roughly age 14. She spoke.

View attachment 19171

"Oh wowza! Its the gentleman!" She hopped up and down a couple times. "You look like you might be fun to duel! Come on! Fight! Fight!"

Protagonist: “Wow. You’re the first person in this fort who’s actually gotten a proper line. So you all can speak.”
684293502049320970.webp


I replied with a confident grin. "Very well, lets see who's lightning is stronger, shall we?"

Amusingly, Catherine's specialty was to induce absurd amounts of power into lightning Pokemon increasing their damage by ten. To her abject horror, this worked very much against her as my own electric attacks ripped through all of her defenses with incredible ease!


Upon losing she remarked "Oh no! I've been beaten with my own rules!! Bzzt!"

With another leader down, I deigned to declare my next destination as the fortress of water!

See the notes: re: card battle format that I’ve brought up a few times up to this point here.

Any reference to “Neo” is referring to the Pokemon Trading Card Game Neo rom-hack. It came out recently and uses cards that came out just after the original sets.
Certain opponents in the game change or add a rule to any duels played against them such as Catherine's ability as described in the story above.

Huh. I didn’t know that the PTCG Game Boy games had ROMhacks to support later cards. TIL.

So, uh… that was definitely one of the more critical reviews that I’ve written in a while. Though for what it’s worth, there were some things about this story that I still thought were pretty neat. First and foremost is the sheer uniqueness of its premise, since I don’t think that I’ve ever seen a fanfic based around the PTCG Game Boy games, so you get some points for doing something different there in my book. I also thought that there were some flashes of humor in between the protagonist’s flailing over being stuck in a strange place where he’s forced to play card games to go along while being stuck with a doofy bird that seems to love nothing more than to get under his skin. The music links were also fun, since there were definitely a lot of nice tunes that by and large matched up well for the moments you assigned them to.

That said, I feel that your story is currently suffering from a number of structural issues at the moment. There was… uh… a lot to cover, but I’ll leave that up to the line-by-line and focus on the most standout issues for this summary. First and foremost is that the story suffers heavily from “tell and not show”, where we’re told a lot of things such as how the protagonist feels at a given moment, or how a given opponent is reacting, but we don’t really see it for ourselves in more detail. In fiction, it is almost always more interesting to see things play out than have them told after the fact. There’s a few formats that straddle the line like journal-format narratives, but this story isn’t really written with that in mind at the moment. I also felt that it was a bit strange that in a story built around the Pokémon TCG video games, that we didn’t actually get to see any card battles play out and basically got a paragraph about the general deck the protagonist used and a mention that he won. Like you actually have quite a bit of content in this present chapter that only fits in its current format by virtue of skipping over a lot of stuff that you’d expect to be a bigger deal in a TCG-focused story (you have 8 battles across 2 forts, mostly compressed in the second half of the chapter). Lastly, I didn’t think that Doduo was really well-integrated into the story. Like yeah, he’s funny to see flail around and give the protagonist a headache, but his antics are basically always background events, and he doesn’t really ever have a moment where his presence or activities interfere with something major in the plot such as the protagonist’s card games or even the process of getting him actual food that isn’t worms. (e.x. what if Doduo made a grab for that pretzel the protag finally gets towards the end?)

Sorry if that feedback wasn’t quite what you were hoping to hear, @133TFR33k . I think that you have a neat idea here, though from the version that I read, it didn’t quite stick the landing in its present format and likely needs a good amount of structural work to pull off the narrative that you were going for.

Hope the feedback is helpful, and I hope to see you around again sometime in the future.
 
Top Bottom