• Welcome to Thousand Roads! You're welcome to view discussions or read our stories without registering, but you'll need an account to join in our events, interact with other members, or post one of your own fics. Why not become a member of our community? We'd love to have you!

    Join now!

Pokémon Those Who Will Inherit the Earth

kintsugi

golden scars | pfp by sun
Location
the warmth of summer in the songs you write
Pronouns
she/her
Partners
  1. silvally-grass
  2. lapras
  3. golurk
  4. booper-kintsugi
  5. meloetta-kint-muse
  6. meloetta-kint-dancer
  7. murkrow
  8. yveltal
  9. celebi
Makes sense! It was hard for me not to see their compromise as anything but fraught in the context of all the other failed compromises that came before—which may have been both of our points and we’re just talking each other in circles now, haha.
 

HelloYellow17

Gym Leader
Pronouns
She/Her
Partners
  1. suicune
  2. umbreon
  3. mew
  4. lycanroc-wes
  5. leafeon-rui
Hey, hi, hello! I’m here for catnip, and I was so intrigued by the premise of this that
I read the first two chapters!

First of all, your prose is absolutely lovely. It’s so vivid, and I love how you utilize all kinds of senses to bring it to life. Taste, touch, smell, all of it. I really felt like I was there with each scene.

Second, I love how OUTDOORSY this is! I felt like I was on a camping trip! I gotta say, I love being out in nature, on hikes, camping, etc and experiencing all the sights and sounds and smells. You really nailed all of that.

My only criticism is that, after two chapters, there’s a lot that I don’t really know about. And, of course, that’s to be expected because it is only two chapters. However, I’m not even sure what Lavender and Poppy’s motivations are. What were they doing in the wetlands? On the cliff by the sea? What is their purpose? Are they scouting territory? And for what? They didn’t seem to be on a rescue mission, and they were in fairly dangerous parts for it to simply be a nice little hike. So, while I don’t expect answers to all my questions so early, I do find it hard to get fully immersed into a story if I don’t really know what’s happening or what the plot is supposed to be. Something about nature restoration, but it was all so vague I really wasn’t sure.

That said, this was still really enjoyable to read. It makes me want to either curl up in a blanket with a cup of tea or go on a hike and hammock near a remote lake. It was comforting and refreshing in the same way that standing in the middle of the mountains without a soul around, feeling the breeze, can be. :D really nicely done!
The frilly flowers of liatris tickled Poppy's nose as the leafeon rooted about the marsh grasses. There was a hint of musk amongst their honeyed scent---nidoking, maybe---but the scent was old enough that it wasn't worth worrying about. Lavender's voice came from Poppy's right, a kind of undulating cadence to it like a whistling thrush. "...while they had been fortunate enough to survive their last encounter, it was with heavy hearts that the old ones gathered their allies and told them the news- Oh, you're not listening anymore, are you, Poppy?"
Well if THIS ain’t some delicious scene setting right here! Wow, just one paragraph in and I am immediately sucked into the scene. :D

She dashed to the right, broke off the stem of an herbaceous plant nearby, and presented it to Lavender.
Okay, this is like the nitpickiest nitpick, but I gotta say, as someone who does not read much PMD fic, things like this throw me for a loop because I get hung up on how these actions are done. Did she grab the flowers in her mouth? Her paws, did she use her vines? I know it’s such a small thing but even just throwing in those tiny details would help my brain picture how she’s grabbing, holding and handing out things.
She took in the landscape for a moment---the rocks that studded the ground as though they had rained down from above, the smooth ridges that encircled the marsh and the little pockets of snow that had accumulated in the depressions near the peaks. Poppy could visualize how the ancient ice must have flowed as it carved swaths out of the earth, and the chunks it left behind that had melted into glistening kettles. She took a moment to describe these things to Lavender, who listened carefully. "...So, knowing that this is a freshwater wetland, what kind of plants might we expect to find?"
Hi, yeah, I’m just writing out more love letters over this. This brought back some very distinct memories of camping trips and hikes and beautiful places and now all I want to do is go on a hike immediately.
"Oh, sorry, I might have come on a little strong there." Poppy was quiet for a moment as she stepped around a puddle. "Anyway, you were talking about that book of yours---The One Whose Name Was Lost to Time?"

Lavender's ears twitched. "Oh, that's right! The old ones are finally preparing to confront the enemy of life, but the best they can hope for is to seal it away for a little while... It's a bittersweet prospect. But what makes this part fascinating is the characterization of the antagonist..."

Lavender went over her favorite parts of the myth at length, and Poppy was happy to listen; she liked the way her partner told stories. As Poppy gazed up at the sky, she imagined the clouds as titans engaged in an epic, turbulent battle.
Aww, I love how wholesome and healthy this relationship is. Poppy rants about plants and Lavender is probably barely keeping up, but she still listens in good humor and doesn’t get annoyed despite the fact that she isn’t as invested in the topic as Poppy is. And then, likewise, Lavender tells her all about her book and goes into great detail, and Poppy returns the favor by listening intently, even if she might not have a personal interest in it.

And the fact that Poppy spaced out at the beginning, but Lavender took it in stride and wasn’t offended by it at all. Just—lovely! We love healthy dynamics like this. Give me more.
The ground cover was thin and wispy, like an infant's hair, and the wild trees had hardly grown past 3 meters.
So while I love the comparison to an infant’s hair, I feel like this doesn’t actually hold up in a PMD world because “infant” could apply to a HUGE variety of species. Infant pidgey? Zigzagoon? Sewaddle? This would fit better if you compared it to a specific Pokémon’s fur texture, I think.
I know we're not really monitoring, but at this rate we might start to see the fish come back soon..."

"I hope so," said the lycanroc. "I think there's more already, but it might just be my imagination. I would be lying if I said I wasn't tempted to catch some..."
Oooh, I love this little worldbuilding bit about normal animals existing! It sure does take care of any alternative explanations for food sources, which…can get messy real quickly. Especially in PMDverse.
The call of eagle-owls seemed to reverberate into infinity, and she could no longer tell where, exactly, the trees ended and the vast starry sky began.
Oh, eagle-owls, even! I don’t know why I was so surprised. I guess I expected only relatively small animals to exist in this world, but it sounds like you really do have all kinds.
One wouldn't think a normal-type's eyes could look so steely.
Heh, I thought this was clever.
At least the weather was nice.
Bless you, Poppy.
"I doubt they'll be too bad. They outrank us, you know."

"All that really means is that the guildmaster likes them more."

Lavender laughed. "You're so cynical sometimes, Poppy. Just because you don't get along with him... Just stock up on restorative stuff if you're really worried about it."
I dunno, I’m with Poppy on this one. It’s a shame, because one would hope that a PMD world would be more idealized and possibly free from political shenanigans in guilds, but. Well. I guess that wouldn’t be very realistic, hah.
Poppy started slightly when she felt something cool touch her flank. She looked over to see Lavender laying her book on top of her, a mischievous smirk on her face.
While this is pure and wholesome, I’m once again wondering how this movement was executed between two quadruped Pokémon. Like, are they anthropomorphic? I wouldn’t think so, but the lack of clarification just kind of leads my mind to view it that way. Which I don’t think is your intention?
Poppy closed her eyes again. At the end of the day, she couldn't complain---the weight of the book was hardly unpleasant, and every once in a while Lavender would pause her reading in order to give her a quick lick or a nuzzle. Lavender's scent was a bit different from her namesake---sweeter, a little more forward, like sugary tea---but it was soothing all the same. From outside Poppy could hear the dusty creaking of carriages, the occasional bit of banter or argument between two pokemon, but it was only when she was with Lavender that these noises ever seemed relaxing.
These two are simply precious. Their relationship is so warm and safe feeling, like a soft blanket.
Poppy emerged from the nook in which she had slept and looked out at the ocean. The water here was cleaner than on the shore they had departed from; Poppy could see the bottom, the cobalt pockmarks on the ocean floor where the rock and sand had been worn away.
This sudden scene change did throw me for a loop a bit. I know there was a line break, but we went from Poppy dozing off in the apartment to her waking up from a nap elsewhere and in a completely different environment. It just felt a tad abrupt to me.
"I hate to say that I agree. We should start designating points of reference."

Poppy nodded. "Good idea." She gestured to a boulder nearby. "That'll be twelve o'clock."
So, uh. I’m probably just dumb but I didn’t understand the whole points of reference thing and how it was supposed to work. Is it a system to prevent them from getting lost while they’re defending themselves?
"Yeah, not a bad idea. It's not worth using the oran, though." She nosed through her bag and produced a plant with small white flowers and lacy leaves. "Here's some yarrow I picked earlier---you can make a poultice out of that. It'll help with the bleeding."
Well if THIS didn’t take me back to my Warriors days, haha! I love it! Also, did you read Warriors ever? I can’t help but feel like you may have drawn some inspiration from them, but I could be wrong.
 

love

Memento mori
Pronouns
he/him/it
Partners
  1. leafeon
Response to @HelloYellow17

Regarding the confusion on what is happening, I am thinking of ways to make it clearer without adding bloat. I do have a scene planned to take place before Poppy wakes up beside the ocean. The quick band-aid summary is that they were harvesting chesto berries that day for their own use/to sell, so they were not on a mission, but they are part of the guild. She wakes up beside the ocean because she had just arrived at the island for the rescue mission mentioned in the previous scene.

Okay, this is like the nitpickiest nitpick, but I gotta say, as someone who does not read much PMD fic, things like this throw me for a loop because I get hung up on how these actions are done. Did she grab the flowers in her mouth? Her paws, did she use her vines? I know it’s such a small thing but even just throwing in those tiny details would help my brain picture how she’s grabbing, holding and handing out things.

I can make it a little clearer. By default, I'd assume they use their mouths.

The ground cover was thin and wispy, like an infant's hair, and the wild trees had hardly grown past 3 meters.

This is unacceptable human bias; my PMD license will surely be revoked. I have not been able to think of a really good alternative, so I will remove the simile for now.

So, uh. I’m probably just dumb but I didn’t understand the whole points of reference thing and how it was supposed to work. Is it a system to prevent them from getting lost while they’re defending themselves?

It is used as a reference point for directions, the reasoning being that "twelve o' clock" relative to a fixed object is less ambiguous than an unqualified "twelve o' clock" (your twelve or mine? Before or after I did that spin?). North, east, south, and west are also viable, but less precise, I'd imagine.

Well if THIS didn’t take me back to my Warriors days, haha! I love it! Also, did you read Warriors ever? I can’t help but feel like you may have drawn some inspiration from them, but I could be wrong.

I did read Warriors, but this was inspired more by a general interest in herbs. Poppy is the sort who would know just what to use.

Anyway, I am very glad that you are having a good time with the story. There's plenty of nature to go around in this one. It's a world worth caring about.

Once you are done with this story (whether you actually choose to finish the whole thing or not), you would probably like Earth at Peace; it's basically 360 words of imagery.

Anyhow, thank you for the review.
 

Panoramic_Vacuum

Hoenn around
Partners
  1. aggron
  2. lairon
Hello hello, I'm here to dive in to TWWItE properly, after having read Earth at Peace ahead of time. I will say having read Earth at Peace first gives a lovely air of tension to this fic even before I got very far into the narrative. There's a lot of lovely similarities, like the lush description of the natural landscape; they definitely feel like stories cut from the same cloth. And I kind of like the idea of Earth at Peace serving as a non-linear piece of TWWIhE to open the story. It made me more aware of the environmental cues in this fic as I read, and since I am a sucker for prequels (especially when the outcome of said prequel is already known), it gave TWWItE a prequel-vibe. If Earth at Peace is the "end", I was reading this fic on pins and needles to see how it came to pass, what landed us in this future situation of a quiet, empty planet save for the flourishing verdant life and one very content Leafeon? This question keeps me reading on, and I'll admit I didn't want to stop. This review will cover Chapters 1-6, as I finally managed to pry myself away at what I expect to be some kind of tipping point for this fic (and a delightful stopping point to have Earth at Peace at the forefront of my mind.)

One small note before I dive in. I'm not usually one to jump on things like this, but given your proficiency with describing the flora and fauna of this world, (and how often the natural descriptions are so important to the story), I wanted to point this out:
The chesto trees were only a couple hundred meters away now; the flaky bark and long leaves made their species clear even before Poppy could see the small red fruits with curled stems.
The description of the chesto berries sounds an awful lot like cherri berries instead. Not sure if this was just a mix up or something missed in editing. (Or chesto berries look different in PMD than they do in the mainline games?) Either way, this is super nitpicky, but it caught my eye given that you've got me hooked on your plant descriptions.

First, though, let me start with the things I loved most, particularly foreshadowing from having read Earth at Peace first, and then the strength of this fic: your characters.

"Excellent," Poppy said. "This stream will really benefit from the shade and organic matter. I know we're not really monitoring, but at this rate we might start to see the fish come back soon..."
This passage caught my eye especially because of this mention in Earth at Peace. At first I thought maybe it was the same situation where other animal life was already gone from the planet, but I realized that this is a rehabilitation effort on Poppy's part. There are some fish, but not many, and she's doing her part to let nature restore itself and allow creatures to flourish.

Even without reading Earth at Peace first, there's very strong tones of naturalism and environmentalism in this fic. There's clear contrast between Poppy's love of nature and her disdain for city life. She's working together with lots of friends and her partner, but it's clear that her love and care for the natural world is not shared by the majority, and especially not with the governing party in this fic, the guild. There's a lot of focus on pokemon being civilized and living in a modern world, but for Poppy, that's not what she enjoys the most. Mix that with Earth at Peace, and it's a lovely recipe of anticipating tension and conflict within an otherwise peaceful and successful society.

I'll touch more on this later in the review, because I think while the theme is strong throughout, the plot stumbles a bit in places. However, I want to gush about your characters first, because they are the real anchor of this fic, and I cannot get enough of Poppy and Lavender.

Lavender cleared her throat and looked away for a moment. When she spoke again, her voice was a little softer. "Sorry... But look, I'm not letting you do this again. I'm coming with you if you go out here in the evening again. Even though I shouldn't really have to." She shook her head and grimaced. "It's like I can trust you with anything but yourself..."
Boy I love this kind of character. Poppy is so lost in her quest to take care of the life all around her that she ends up neglecting herself. It drives home the point that she is a very mindful and empathetic person. She cares so, so much. It's not even that "oh grass types like to take care of plants", this goes way beyond that. I like the little differences between her and Lavender used to illustrate this point.

Lavender as a "city-mon" where she's used to the amenities of modern life, and has a hard time imagining life without them (like in their conversation with Xerneas on the island). She's quickly bored without stimulus around her (save for Poppy's company), like the night on the boat. She can and does appreciate the little moments of beauty, like constellations and the flowers and plants Poppy points out to her, but it's clear that her priorities and interests are not the same as Poppy's. This is okay, though (and in fact it's great!), as I like that Poppy and Lavender are a loving couple while also being different people.

I especially love the way you let them express their partnership through small, simple touches. There is love here and it's not because they hugged or kissed or did anything else that might be used to overtly signify romance.
Poppy smiled a little and briefly brushed her cheek against Lavender's.
"Sounds good." Lavender rubbed her head against Poppy's briefly. "I'll be waiting for you. You'd better come back this time, alright?"
It's lovely to read these little subtle moments between them, because for how small they are, they speak volumes without needing any more words.

Speaking of love, I really loved this exchange between them. It's so sweet and delightful, the gentle teasing, Lavender's "oh my god" moment followed by the sheer happiness in Poppy's laughter. They're such a great couple and I can't stress enough how much I love the way you write these two.
"Oh, an 'L'? I don't know if that really helps. Hm..." She scrutinized her companion's face as though she might find a hint there. "Poppy, you aren't messing with me, a—" She froze. "Oh," she said flatly. "It's lavender, isn't it."

Poppy laughed loud enough to flush the nearby bluebirds.

This passage also highlights Poppy's characteristics in contrast with Lavender's. Poppy doesn't just like plants, she loves them. And again it's not just "grass types like plants", it's so much more intimate than that. She is delighted by every new piece of life she discovers, finding plants and animals fascinating and joyful. Sharing this world with other living things literally brings her happniess. This is so wonderful, as is her penchant for finding beauty in the natural world around her. Poppy finds so much peace in the quiet solitude that ends up boring Lavender half to death. She can watch the sky and be perfectly content. It's hinted that because Poppy is from a different continent that she's from a different way of life or cultural background that's less urban and modern as the place she lives and works now. It's presented teasingly from Lavender's point of view as her partner, and Poppy is never looked down upon because of it. It's a nice positive presentation of different interests and goals while highlighting those differences as possible points of conflict.

One quick little miscellaneous quote that I'm not sure where it fits in the grand scheme of this but:
Poppy sighed. "Lavender, please. You only know five sea shanties. You've sung them all. Many times."
I laughed at this. Sea shanties ahoy!

Speaking of conflict, I think the weak point of this fic is the plot advancement, namely the overarching plot of the fic and how it took quite a bit of piecing together on my part to understand why things were happening. The chapters and scenes themselves work well on their own, but trying to figure out why certain scenes were included has me a bit puzzled.

The incident at the chesto trees with the "ferals but not really" left me confused. There's other mons out there besides Poppy and Lavender's guild, but Poppy is upset at her guild for some kind of civil rights related to these characters? There's no real build up that there are even tensions within the guild and any neighboring factions, nor does Poppy seem strained in doing missions with her guild in the first place.

I'll admit, I'm very PMD blind, but for how central this conflict with the guild is to the story, I wish there was a little more backstory here, at least enough to connect the dots between the scenes and events of the chapters.

As for the missions, I was also a bit lost as to what sent Poppy and Lavender on their boat ride to the island. There was some narration that they were taking a job. Then they finished the job. Then they were on a boat? Then they went to sleep on the boat but woke up on the island? And then they were on a rescue mission? It felt like some story was missing somewhere along the way. Character motivations and scene changes kind of caught me by surprise. The overall arc of Poppy's conflict and the environmentalist themes were strong, but this passage:
The two looked at each other, and then Poppy glanced away awkwardly. "I mean, I know it's technically the job, but I can't help but think something that powerful should be left alone."

"The opposite could be true, too, don't you think? If we don't know what's causing this, it could bite us later."

"I guess," Poppy said, and then frowned. "I'm just worried about the guildmaster. You were there for our last conversation. I don't trust him with... whatever we find."
made it feel like there was something left out about the guild that felt important, and the threat of the guild to not only Poppy's happiness but also directly conflicting her values and goals in life only really was realized when she returned from the trip to find her land destroyed by the guild's callous expansion. Until that point, though, the guild never felt detrimental as an organization, simply that it was run by a jerk. It's clear, though, that it's some kind of central institution to civilized life, and Poppy was a part of that until one day, she wasn't.

I'll admit, this passage highlights the main conflicts of the story that I felt were never really presented before this. I had a sense of tension with the guildmaster, and that they were clearly headed to the island to investigate something? But I never knew what. Was the guild after more energy? More land? What is the purpose of the explorer's guild? I never really picked up on that from the context of the story, so I never really knew why Poppy and Lavender went to this faraway island. It turns out to be some kind of rescue mission, but again I'm not sure why the first exploring party went there either?

I enjoyed the events of each chapter as scenes on their own, but I never had a clear sense of the character's goals or motivations, so I never knew what they were working toward. It left me feeling a bit aimless in terms of trying to anticipate where the main conflict was going to come from.

The exploration of the island and the build up to the discovery at the end was a treat to read. Again your natural descriptions shine, and I can clearly picture this strange and fantastical land of gigantic trees and lush, verdant foliage, all larger than life. You can feel how bountiful the land is here and it instills a sense of wonder, which leads fantastically into what the explorers eventually uncover:
Azure and cobalt highlights on black fur. Antlers as tall as Poppy herself, spread wide like the mouth of a goblet. This island wasn't even that far from the guild; had Xerneas really been here the whole time?
👀 I love how this explains so much about the amazing properties of the island! I wasn't sure if this was going to be some kind of artifact or something else, but the presence of the life-bringing Legendary means they've stumbled upon something of great importance. I also really like Xerneas and find its presence fitting for a story with such strong naturalistic undertones, even though its appearance did surprise me (in a good way!)

Yes. Though it is especially strong here, it actually permeates the entire planet. And pokemon, by nature, can harness it in myriad ways. Xerneas looked up to the sky. In the past, pokemon were far more powerful. You may have heard stories about it; about how skarmory used to be able to fly, for example. It pointed at Scotch. But populations have grown, meaning that there is now less of this power for each individual to draw upon. I bring this up to illustrate that the planet’s energy is a finite resource that warrants protection. I am here to provide that protection and ensure that it remains freely usable by all.
What an interesting take on what makes pokemon special. There's a lot to unpack here, namely that the planet's magic-imbuing power is a finite resource (very akin to our real-life situation with using the planet's fossil fuel energy to further modern needs and energy), but that this power is tied to the very lifeforms that use it. How interesting that it seems like with so many pokemon living all over the planet, they're dividing the planets power amongst each other, thereby diluting it.

Had Poppy not been paying attention, she might not have recognized the place. The soil was barren, dry enough that a gust of wind blew dust into the air. The branches had been cleared from the river, and the riparian trees and saplings replaced with ornamental species that left the water exposed to the sun. A few hundred meters away, pokemon were pouring a foundation beside stacks of neatly cut lumber. And even from atop the hill, Poppy could recognize the purugly—that pudgy gray blob—that sat beside the site, surveying it with critical eyes. The guildmaster.
Oh. Oh no. This hurt to read, to realize what had happened to the place that Poppy was bringing back to life. Oh man, this hurt a lot.

The turning point of this fic, with Poppy destroying her guild badge and storming off on this life she's been living with the partner she loved? Wow. Even with some of the plot-confusion on my part, this still hit like a ton of bricks. The raw emotion from Poppy, the absolute breaking point in seeing her land turned into this monument to the falsehood of progress, it hurt to read, and I do not blame her reaction one bit. I feel terrible that Lavender had to witness this and bear the brunt of her anger. After everything they had been through, it's a real dagger to Poppy's soul that even Lavender couldn't understand her pain. I didn't realize that Poppy had entirely left the continent after this event, and wow that hits even harder. She's completely written off anything and everything the guild touched, including her partner. (This is how villains are made, btw. Poppy oh no don't do it)

(Except, uh, I think Poppy's gonna do it. See: Earth at Peace)
And here's the lovely foreshadowing at work:
"Despite my mediocre healing skills, I'm quite strong in... other areas." Ann sighed. "See, back in the day, I could have just gone right ahead and put the fear of god in those meddlers myself. But, long story short, I kind of got in trouble for doing things like that. Kind of got... banished to another realm, in fact." It laughed awkwardly. "So, as you might imagine, it takes most of my strength just to project this avatar here." It gestured to itself. "But if, say, there were someone else who already had a body in this realm, and they were willing to channel my power..." It leaned toward Poppy conspiratorially.

"So, you want a servant, then?"

"I'd prefer the term 'partner.' I don't intend to make you do anything you don't want to—and in fact, I'm not really sure I could." It waved its paw. "Oh, but I'm just speculating here. I'm not even sure that idea will work, anyway. Still, if you want to give it a try..."

Even if Ann was lying, Poppy thought, she would gain nothing by refusing. "Assuming you're telling the truth, I'm not opposed—but there's something I have to ask in return. If your motivations are pure, I'm sure you'll be glad to accept."

"Mm, I have a feeling I know what you're about to suggest."

Poppy closed her eyes. "I want to take back my land."

Ann smiled as it entered the clearing nearby. Its fur gleamed, eyes sparkled in the sunlight. "Poppy, if you're willing to help me, I'll let you do that, and so much more."
I cannot help but think this strange avatar, Ann, is related to the counterpart of Xerneas's life-preserving presence... The avatar itself doesn't offer a lot of hints as to the identity of this powerful individual, but knowing where Earth at Peace lands us after the end of this fic, I'm wondering if Yveltal is trying to weasel its way back into the world... Otherwise, I don't really have any guesses as to what poke-deity this could be. And boy, what an ominous ending line. Funny that for as long as Ann has apparently been watching Poppy, they couldn't be bothered to approach Poppy until she was fueled by anger... Ominous indeed.

Apologies if this comment got a bit long-winded. I couldn't put this story down, though. Also apologies if my thoughts here got a bit meandering, I tried to organize them as best I could, but I think I jumped around too much (even for me!). I am really looking forward to reading more. Consider me more than intrigued!
 

love

Memento mori
Pronouns
he/him/it
Partners
  1. leafeon
Response for @Panoramic_Vacuum

That's a good catch with the berries; I *did* mean to make them cheris.

I think some background knowledge of pmd probably helps because in pmd fic, hopping from continent to continent to explore new places for a guild is sort of taken for granted. They aren't looking for something specific, though the guild may exploit whatever they find. I can see how more guild backstory would be beneficial, so perhaps another prequel is in order. If I could figure out what it would be about. Any moment now...

Anyway yeah this story is a mess, and I have always been better at writing scenes than stringing them together. I still love it and love when people read it. It is fortunate that the characters are memorable because I've never considered character writing to be a strength of mine. It kind of feels like lightning in a bottle.

It sounds like Earth at Peace has not harmed your enjoyment of the story so far, and given the sort of nebulous beginning, it may have been beneficial to have some sense of where things are heading.

Also apologies if my thoughts here got a bit meandering, I tried to organize them as best I could, but I think I jumped around too much (even for me!)

I find that fitting for such a disjointed story, and what matters most to me is that you got your thoughts out and posted them. I do hope you'll stick around for the conclusion so we can see how much of your speculation proves true. I will at least say that the creature depicted in Earth at Peace is Ann, not Poppy. I tried to indicate that with the "rabbitlike" description, but I guess leafeon is kind of rabbitlike too?
 

Spiteful Murkrow

Busy Writing Stories I Want to Read
Pronouns
He/Him/His
Partners
  1. nidoran-f
  2. druddigon
  3. swellow
  4. lugia
  5. quilava-fobbie
  6. sneasel-kate
  7. heliolisk-fobbie
Heya, dropping in to leave a review for your story since it got the spotlight from an offsite review event. Between seeing you float some pretty great-sounding ideas for PMD settings in the past on the TR Discord, and hearing some positive word-of-mouth about this story… I decided to just take the plunge, read a bit, and see how I felt about things afterwards.

Chapter 1

The frilly flowers of liatris tickled Poppy's nose as the leafeon rooted about the marsh grasses. Musk lingered beneath their honeyed scent—nidoking, maybe—but it was old enough that it wasn't worth worrying about. Lavender's voice came from Poppy's right, a kind of undulating cadence to it like a whistling thrush. "...while they had been fortunate enough to survive their last encounter, it was with heavy hearts that the old ones gathered their allies and told them the news—Oh, you're not listening anymore, are you, Poppy?"

Poppy jolted a little and turned toward her addresser—a neatly groomed delcatty, and none other than her faithful partner. Lavender walked with a bubbly sort of spring in her step, jostling the exploration team pouch slung around her shoulder. "Er, sorry, I'm trying... I just noticed there were some interesting plants here."

Sure is a great time to get distracted there right in the middle of a story that’s about to get to the part where it’s talking about an untimely death.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Though great use of senses for this opener. Scent is one of those senses that doesn’t really take up a huge amount of mindspace for humans, while it logically would be a bigger deal for a lot of Pokémon.

Lavender raised her eyebrows. "Mm hm, more interesting than your old pal Lavender. I see how it is."

Poppy grimaced, but there was a smile behind that grimace. "Ah, jeez, I'm sorry. But uh, look." She dashed to the right, bit off the stem of an herbaceous plant nearby, and presented it to Lavender. The leaves were egg-shaped with ridged edges and a hint of fuzz, and the claw-sized flowers looked like open mouths with lolling tongues. "I found some lemon balm. We can make tea out of it when we get home. You'd like that, right?"

… I’m now curious how on earth this cat knows how to make lemon balm tea, let alone how she does that without thumbs. Though given the title, I suppose that we’ll be finding that out in relatively short order, huh?

Lavender's gaze softened. "I would, yeah, though I worry there won't be any cheri berries left for us at the gorge if we're too slow. Just because we're not on a mission..." She trailed off as she took another look at the plant in Poppy's mouth. "Hm, that looks an awful lot like... mint, I think?"

Poppy nodded effusively, the green tuft at the crown of her head her head bobbing. "Right, same family, just a bit of a different taste. Good eye."

Small bit of unintentional repetition there, but I like how much you’re showing off how foraging for herbs works, since it’s one of those things where you have to be able to tell between different plants lest you pick up something inedible. Or worse, poisonous. You definitely don’t see too many other stories doing this as part of the plot.

Lavender chuckled with a little shake of her head. "It's pretty amazing how you know all the plants, even all the way out here."

Don’t you kinda have to if you’re planning to go foragi-

"It's just a matter of knowing what to expect, based on the environment. For the sake of practice, let me ask you: how would you describe this ecology?" She gave a sweeping gesture with her tail.

Yeah, that.

Lavender scrunched up her face the way she often did when she was thinking. "Hm... it's definitely wet." Lavender lifted her paw, which was mud-stained and matted with moisture.

"Right. And you may remember there's a special term for places that are always wet."

"Uh... Wetlands?"

Poppy nodded again. "Right. This one is particularly interesting; you can tell that glacial influence played a role in forming it." She took in the landscape for a moment—the rocks that studded the ground as though they had rained down from above, the smooth ridges that encircled the marsh and the little pockets of snow that had accumulated in the depressions near the peaks.

P
oppy could visualize how the ancient ice must have flowed as it carved swaths out of the earth, and the chunks it left behind that had melted into glistening kettles. She took a moment to describe these things to Lavender, who listened carefully. "...So, knowing that this is a freshwater wetland, what kind of plants might we expect to find?"

Part of me wonders if this paragraph would’ve functioned better divided up into two smaller ones to make it easier to follow. But eh. That’s ultimately a stylistic choice to be made as an author.

"Um, I don't know, like, ones that enjoy water?"

"Such as?"

Lavender drew back her head a little and made a desperate sort of noise. "Uhhhhhhh... I don't know... Cattails, I guess?"

Lavender’s not really good at this, is she? :V

"Sure, there's cattails. There's also sweetflag, milkweed, fox sedge, boneset..."

Lavender laughed anxiously. "Okay, okay Poppy, I can't remember all those at once. We'll have to go over it sometime when I can actually write things down."

"Oh, sorry, I might have come on a little strong there." Poppy was quiet for a moment as she stepped around a puddle. "Anyway, you were talking about that book of yours—The One Whose Name Was Lost to Time?"

Wait, is that a legit title, or is that an epithet referring to this book? If the former, it might make sense to render it in italics like The One Whose Name Was Lost to Time.

Lavender's ears twitched. "Oh, that's right! The old ones are finally preparing to confront the enemy of life, but the best they can hope for is to seal it away for a little while... It's a bittersweet prospect. But what makes this part fascinating is the characterization of the antagonist..."

… Boy that conversation sure took an ominous turn from a happy scene of foraging for herbs.
:uhhh:


Though I wonder what on earth is that enemy of life that can only be sealed away but not defeated. Since the track record for myths in Pokémon settings is such that I don’t believe that that’s a mere story there.

Lavender recounted her favorite parts of the myth at length, and Poppy was happy to listen; she liked the way her partner told stories. As Poppy gazed up at the sky, she imagined the clouds as titans engaged in an epic, turbulent battle.

Ah yes, cue the mood music:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=erKkWGfEW9U


The chesto trees were only a couple hundred meters away now; the flaky bark and long leaves made their species clear even before Poppy could see the small red fruits with curled stems. Her mouth watered a little; they were just as abundant as the other guild members had told them. They'd be worth two, maybe three times as much as a successful rescue.

Wew, so life is cheap enough in this setting for it to be more economical to pick berries and take them home than to bail someone out of a Mystery Dungeon (assuming they exist), huh? It’s subtle, but it’s definitely a hint I noticed that things aren’t all sunshine and rainbows in this setting. ^^;

Something rustled up ahead. Poppy turned her head—a group of three pokemon were talking to one another a little farther off. Shinx, raichu, and servine. They didn't have badges, and their leather pouches were rugged, like they had been crafted by hand. They turned toward Poppy and Lavender with faces darkened by ashen markings. Poppy thought to pick up her pace, to greet them, but their sharp expressions made her hesitate.

The raichu turned to the side and shouted something which sounded like a foreign language; someone called out a response from behind a hill to the left. Then his group prowled toward Poppy and Lavender. Jagged yellow bolts flashed around the pokemons' heads, accompanied by the mounting hiss of static.

Getting Rebirth!Teutonii vibes from this sequence, though nice to see another writer who didn’t instantly assume that all Pokémon share a mutually intelligible language with all others. It’s not that common a take in the fandom.

Though what sort of foreign localization language should I be imagining these forest ‘mons as speaking anyways?

Poppy took a step back. "I hate to say this after we just got here, but we should leave."

Lavender nodded, face tense. "After you."

Lavender: “Gee, whatever tipped you off there?” >_>;
Poppy: “Well, the looks of those ‘mons faces was already a big red flag, but it was the telegraphed Thunderbolt that sealed the deal. Anyhow, let’s move on.”
:fearfullaugh~1:


By this late in the day, mud smeared the guild headquarters' floor in whispy trails like cirri. The marble walls were lined with fraying tapestries that depicted explorers from a time long since passed. The pokemon gathered around the main room tapped their feet or leaned over to look out the main door at the sky; they were eager to get home after a long day of walking, and Poppy didn't blame them. But there she stood, delivering her message regardless.

"...To keep it short, we're not the first team to have encountered tribal pokemon in that area, but as far as we know we're the first to have been threatened. Therefore, I felt it important to let everyone know as soon as possible."

… Perhaps it’s just an artifact of me reading this after Rebirth, which had a midstory reveal about its own analogue to “tribal Pokémon”, but considering the rating and content warnings in the first post, I’ve got a very bad feeling about where this conversation is going to wind up going.
:uhhh:


From across the room the guildmaster, a purugly, shrugged through a layer of fat as thick as winter snow. "Very well," he said in a stuffy voice. "I will be sure to inform those that were not here so that they will know to exercise caution in their harvests."

"Best if we cut it out altogether. That's what's got them so bothered, don't you think? They probably see those trees as theirs."

"I don't suppose it matters. Either way, it would be a stain on our legacy to bend to the will of ferals."

Uh… yeah. I had a feeling that this conversation was going to go places. I was admittedly worried that things were going to get a bit more openly exterminatory than “lol, screw you, you’re inferior, we’ll do as we please”, but I suppose there’s plenty of room for things to go in that direction given that there is no way that this guildmaster’s decision-making isn’t going to result in violent conflict.

Poppy bristled a little. "Hold on, ferals? With bags and body markings and language?" She shook her head. "Never mind, that's not even the issue. We don't even know how many pokemon we're stepping on here. Do you want this to become a war? We need to stay out of there, or get ourselves a mediator. I know the language barrier is an issue, but—"

The guildmaster wrinkled his nose. "That's enough, Poppy. Unless you have any new information to add, I think we can conclude this announcement."

Poppy snarled. "You're ridiculous."

"Let's limit ourselves to productive comments now, yes?"

Poppy: “Guildmaster, we literally have no idea how many of those Pokémon are there! For all we know, we could be outnumbered 10 to 1-!”
Guildmaster: “Again. They are ferals. We do not let ourselves get pushed around by them. That will be the end of the matter, thank you.”

Poppy shoved her way past a mienshao and bibarel as she stormed out of the headquarters. She was greeted by a view of the city below, its glowing windows and smoggy haze from distant smokestacks, and shortly after she heard Lavender's voice behind her.

Huh. I didn’t peg things as having this sort of tech level given the first two scenes, but it’s definitely a very different from the fandom norm PMD-wise. It gives me a bit of a FF6 vibe, and it definitely helps the setting stand out quite a bit.

"Hey! Poppy!"

Poppy stopped, and she waited for Lavender to catch up before proceeding briskly down the steep path to the left.

"I know that didn't go so well—" Lavender began.

"I'm going to write the Alta Civil Rights Union. I doubt they'll take my side, but... the only way to get that jerk to listen is if someone threatens him with legal action."

‘Alta’ huh? So that’s what this place is called? Though somehow I doubt that Poppy is going to really get that much interest in her case if seeing forest tribals as nuisances to run over and dealt with as pleased is a normal enough sentiment for a Guildmaster to openly air.

"Poppy—"

Poppy grimaced. "Lavender, I swear, if you're about to tell me I'm overreacting—"

Lavender shook her head vigorously. "No no no, it's not that, I just wanted to remind you that we don't have any paper left at home, so if you want to write the union, we need to get more."

Poppy gave a growling sigh and looked over at the sun, which wasn't even two paws above the horizon. "Of course."

Poppy: “Are we really not able to just buy some paper from the entire rest of the town here?” >_>;
Lavender: “Given that we spent the entire day foraging and bailed before we could get those Cheri Berries… I’m pretty sure we don’t have any money to work with right now. If it even exists in this setting.”
720106605982646283.png


Lavender frowned. "Sorry. You were hoping to visit the crew today, weren't you?"

Poppy nodded. "Not going to have time to at this rate..."

"Listen, I'm fine with going out and doing some shopping for you if it helps. I can make sure we have all the stationary we need to write a letter tomorrow while you go out and check up on everyone."

inb4 the Guildmaster literally provokes a war with those tribals overnight and makes all of this horribly moot.

Poppy's expression softened, and she looked into Lavender's eyes. "Really? You wouldn't mind doing that?"

Lavender laughed. "Not at all! I know you get really busy sometimes, so I'm happy to help out a little. It's really the least I can do. It's late in the day to be doing this, though, so make sure you get back home before dark, okay?"

Poppy smiled a little and briefly brushed her cheek against Lavender's. "Thank you. I'll be sure to hurry." Then she turned around and trotted downhill as fast as she safely could.

Ah yes, such hope. Such optimism. And considering the stakes that were just established earlier in this story, I’m fully expecting them all to get smashed into a million pieces in short order.

By the time Poppy arrived, the sunlight had already taken on a tangerine hue. Still coughing from the city's pollution, Poppy followed the river nearby, looking as far ahead as she could. Just when she was beginning to think everyone had gone home for the day, a familiar peal of laughter rang out up ahead. Her anger began to fade away as she picked up her pace.

Wait, if the city’s air is that bad, just how bad is its water?
:fearfullaugh~1:


A lycanroc came into view, chasing something playfully in circles while the others—a dragonite, bayleef, and tranquill—looked on in amusement. The tranquill turned his head.

"Oh, hey guys! Poppy's here!"

I’m assuming the Dragonite’s the leader of the gang, since the others feel a lot lower on the totem pole power-wise than it.

The lycanroc stopped his pursuit, and he and the others followed the tranquil's gaze. Poppy slowed down a little as she drew near the group and smiled.

"Greetings." Poppy saw a little blue streak as someone dashed behind the dragonite. The stranger peeked out from behind his guardian's thick tail. The flipper on his head marked him clearly as a mudkip.

"Oh, who's this?" asked Poppy.

The dragonite looked back and smiled reassuringly. "It was so cool, Poppy—we were setting up branches to catch the silt, and this little feral guy just joined in and started helping! Like he was part of the team all along!"

Oh, so there is Pokémon recruitment in this setting. Maybe. Can’t tell yet. Though I wonder if based off Poppy’s objection regarding the Guildmaster’s plans for the tribals, if he can speak a coherent language or not.

Poppy smiled. "Is that so?" She leaned over to get a better look at the mudkip, who was already getting over his initial surprise to eye Poppy curiously. "Well, I appreciate your support. Here." She reached into the pouch slung around her shoulder, pulled out a pear, and left it on the ground in front of the mudkip. "It isn't much, but here's a small token of my appreciation. Even if you're not hungry now, it'll keep for a while. Come back tomorrow and I might have something better for you."

The mudkip ventured out toward the pear and investigated it. Meanwhile Poppy addressed the dragonite again. "Anyway, that's a pleasant surprise. Has everything else been going well?"

The dragonite nodded. "I'm surprised at how fast we were able to narrow the channel back there already—" He gestured behind Poppy, where they had laid out fallen conifer branches so that they stuck partway out into the water. In some places, they had already been partly buried by silt. "And we've made good progress around this general area too, so I expect we'll see similar results again soon."

Wait, are they setting up a dam for the stream? Or else what is it that they’re attempting to do with the silt-catching there? Since I’m not sure if I picked up on the significance of it.

"And we got a lot of the new transplants in the ground as well," the bayleef added, nodding toward a line of young dogwoods and winterberry shrubs.

"Excellent," Poppy said. "This stream will really benefit from the shade and organic matter. I know we're not really monitoring, but at this rate we might start to see the fish come back soon…"

"I hope so," said the lycanroc. "I think there's more already, but it might just be my imagination. I would be lying if I said I wasn't tempted to catch some..."

Ah. So the answer is ‘ecological restoration’. I have to wonder if that’s from the city’s first-order effects given that it’s still actively spewing out air pollution in the present day, or if that’s from lingering damage that predates it.

Poppy laughed. "I guess you'll just have to hold off for a bit longer. Hopefully a good population gets established in a couple years. After what this place used to be, it makes me happy there's anything at all…" She looked around at the area, which was still in an awkward adolescence between grassland and forest. The ground cover was thin and wispy, and the wild trees had hardly grown past 3 meters. But such things couldn't be rushed.

… Did this place use to be a toxic waste dump or something? Since from the way that Poppy is talking about what it used to be…
:fearfullaugh~1:


"By the way, Poppy," said the tranquill, snapping her out of her reverie. "If your estimate is correct, and we finish up by the end of next month... Do you have any plans in place to keep this area protected? I mean, I know we have the deed and all, but..."

Poppy's expression grew sober. "Right. So that should protect us from anything like... last time. But I was thinking it would be a good idea to enlist a couple pokemon from the crew to serve as rangers once we're done. Prevent any unscrupulous activity. But we only have enough money left in the fund to pay a few pokemon, so if anyone in the crew is really eager to sign up, let me know."

Everyone nodded.

… I suppose “place that got rekt by Pokémon” is also an option for what used to be here prior to the restoration, especially since I suppose it wouldn’t take all that much for a particularly strong one to wreck a forest. ^^;

"Good then. Anyway, I don't mean to hold you all up, especially after everyone else has already gone home." She bowed. "Thank you all for another hard day's work."

The four pokemon smiled and said their goodbyes to Poppy and the mudkip. Poppy smiled bittersweetly as she watched the little feral follow them for a ways.

I feel as if the ‘bittersweetly’ is meant to hint at something, but I’m not really sure what. If it’s not too spoilery, it might’ve made sense to give more of a hint as to why poppy feels bittersweet here.

Poppy's exhaustion hit her like a weighted net now that her day was properly done. She slumped to the ground and took a few deep breaths. It probably wouldn't be wise to rest here for too long, but she wasn't eager to head back to the city. She preferred to watch the feathery grass sway, to listen to the chorus of cicadas and crickets like a thousand spectral bells scattered across the sanctuary. As the sun dipped below the mountains, and the orange sky turned to murky blue, she began to forget how small this little plot of hers was. The call of eagle-owls seemed to reverberate into infinity, and she could no longer tell where, exactly, the trees ended and the vast starry sky began

Insects visited Poppy from time-to-time. She tried to guess their species without looking. That one on her shoulder felt big, maybe a blowfly? But it flew away too quietly. A couple of smaller ones too, here and there, ticklish, barely perceptible. Maybe some kind of gnat. She closed her eyes and imagined they were checking up on her. Like old friends.

Hm, dunno how it took me so long to realize that there were also normie animals in this setting, though I suppose it would help explain a few things about how at least some Pokémon have taken to civilization so quickly.

Chapter 2

"Poppy."

Lavender's voice was frigid, reminding Poppy of the times her mother had scolded her. Even before she opened her eyes, she knew from the bright red beneath her eyelids that the sun was already shining at full strength.

"Ugh..." Poppy croaked as she raised her leaden head. She tried to talk but wound up coughing.

Lavender rolled her eyes and shoved her bag in front of Poppy, positioned so that the nipple of the water pouch inside was accessible.

Wait, did Poppy pass out in the woods or something-? .-.

Poppy drank enthusiastically, even though the cold water stung her throat. She sputtered out an apology as soon as she was done. "Sorry, I didn't mean to fall asleep like that..."

"Poppy, you're an adult, and this is the third time this has happened. You shouldn't just be nodding off in the middle of the wilderness. It's not healthy. I was worried, you know. You could have been eaten. And I spent at least an hour just looking for- for heaven's sake, Poppy, look at me!" Her hackles raised slightly along with her voice.

Uh… yeah, that sounds like a very good reason to not fall asleep in the boonies, even if instinct might be telling you that “hey, this is fine”.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Poppy obeyed, though she was sure her discomfort was evident. One wouldn't think a normal-type's eyes could look so steely.

Oh honey, you’ve seen nothing. :V

Lavender cleared her throat and looked away for a moment. When she spoke again, her voice was a little softer. "Sorry... But look, I'm not letting you do this again. I'm coming with you if you go out here in the evening again. Even though I shouldn't really have to." She shook her head and grimaced. "It's like I can trust you with anything but yourself..."

Poppy stood up stiffly, trying not to make it too obvious that her leg had gone numb. "I'll make it up to you. I just felt bad going another day without checking up on those guys."

"Well, you should have just sent them something, or... I don't know. This is clearly not the answer. It's irresponsible." She sighed, signifying the end of her admonishments. "Anyway, there's an easy job on the board today no one else seems interested in. We can take that. You can worry about apologizing later."

Given how viscerally Lavender is reacting to Poppy conking out in the boonies, I can already tell that at some point, someone is going to get seriously messed up while out there in this story.
:uhhh:


"Understood," Poppy muttered. "I'll need to get some supplies first though. I think we used our last cheri berry on that chespin."

"Don't bother," Lavender said dryly. "I already took care of it while I was waiting for you."

"Oh..."

Lavender started toward the guild, Poppy following sheepishly behind at a distance.

At least the weather was nice.

Lavender: “You’re welcome, by the way.” >:|
Poppy: “Lavender, you don’t need to rub it in...” >_>;

The sun was still a good few paws above the horizon by the time Poppy and Lavender had filled out the paperwork officiating the completion of their most recent job. The entrance to the guild was bustling with activity, so the two of them walked a ways down and perched themselves on an out-of-the-way rock. That Poppy always saw new faces along this path never failed to impress her; there were the common species today, like golem and axew, but also a few that were more exotic. A goodra glanced remorsefully over his shoulder as a pair of luxio tried to avoid his footprints; Poppy couldn't help but smirk at that. Didn't these city folks know a little slime wouldn't kill them?

I like how the relative time of day is being measured by distance from the sun to the horizon as like a quite literal back-of-the-hand measurement. It feels like a very ‘Pokémon’ way of keeping track of the passage of time.


"So, Poppy," said Lavender casually. "When was the last time you took a bath?"

Poppy grimaced, suddenly aware of the matted clumps of fur on her chest, and recalled that it was possible to be too lax about hygiene. "Too long, I suppose. Guess I know the first thing I'm doing this afternoon."

Yeah, considering how scent is much more important for Pokémon and how the last scene very strongly implied that some Pokémon eat others… you probably don’t want to go strutting around with a strong, musky odor in some places.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Lavender smiled wryly. "Good, then. Any other plans?"

"No. I'll just head straight home."

"Sounds good." Lavender rubbed her head against Poppy's briefly. "I'll be waiting for you. You'd better come back this time, alright?"

578077337728450560.png


Getting major “something terrible is about to happen” vibes from the way this conversation is going.

"Heh heh... I will. I promise."

Poppy headed off, grateful that Lavender hadn't given her a harder time.

de7.png


Poppy was laid down in the patch of sunlight that shone through the apartment window, looking over the request letter before her one last time.

"What do you think?" asked Lavender as she looked up from her book.

"Exploring a new island sounds fun, but the escort part might not be. Depends on how good the team that got there first is."

"I doubt they'll be too bad. They outrank us, you know."

"All that really means is that the guildmaster likes them more."

That… doesn’t bode well at all for on-the-job injuries and mortality at this guild if that’s genuinely a non-trivial part of how team ranks get assigned in this town.
:uhhh:


Lavender laughed. "You're so cynical sometimes, Poppy. Just because you don't get along with him... Just stock up on restorative stuff if you're really worried about it."

"Mm hm." Poppy looked at the letter again. "Still, that's decent pay. We could afford to take some time off if we completed this one, maybe work on sorting out that chesto berry situation. And I need to start saving for another parcel, too."

"Oh, is there already another one you've got your eye on?"

"Well... Got a couple ideas. There's certainly no shortage of wastelands around here. That defunct mill in Laurel Valley wouldn't be a bad place to target. If everyone in the crew put aside, say, 150 poke a month..." She closed her eyes and rested her head on the floor. "But to be honest, I'd rather not worry about it right now."

I wonder if it’d have made sense to make it a bit more obvious that Lavender’s talking about a parcel of land there. Like the paragraph after Poppy’s follow-up question clears it up, but for a second, I thought that Lavender was talking about mail. Something as simple as “parcel to clean up” might have made it unambiguous.

Though there’s just a bunch of wastelands nearby, huh? That… makes me curious as to what on earth the backstory of this place is, since it sure sounds like things used to be quite a mess in the past if there’s land in bad shape commonly enough such that ‘land reclamation’ is a semi-mainstream profession. .-.

Lavender nodded. "Fair enough. But before you get too comfortable, I don't want to let you take up all the good reading light."

"Oh..." Poppy began to stand up, but Lavender stopped her.

"No, that's fine. You can stay where you are." Lavender walked over to her. "Just let me..."

Poppy started slightly when she felt something cool touch her flank. She looked over to see Lavender laying her book on top of her, a mischievous smirk on her face.

"There," said Lavender. "Much better."

Poppy laughed. "Silly cat."

These two are like this to each other a lot, aren’t they? :V

Poppy closed her eyes again. Ultimately, she couldn't complain—the weight of the book was hardly unpleasant, and every once in a while Lavender would pause her reading to give her a quick lick or a nuzzle. Lavender's scent was a bit different from her namesake—sweeter, a little more forward, like sugary tea—but it was soothing all the same. From outside, Poppy could hear the dusty creaking of carriages, the occasional bit of banter or argument between two pokemon, but it was only when she was with Lavender that these noises ever seemed relaxing.

Can’t tell if the relationship between these two is meant to be platonic or romantic, but it’s certainly a cute note to end the scene on there. Certainly hope we won’t have to see what’ll happen if something breaks these two’s bond sometime later down the road.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Compared to the sloop rigs Poppy had grown used to, the gaff cutter's sails had seemed redundant, its rigging gratuitous. But her opinion softened after a few hours of swift downwind cruising, the boat heeling over from its own power, casting intermittent spray on deck.

Ah, so another setting that has sailing ships, huh? Boy you sure know how to press my buttons for getting me interested in seeing more of this story and its setting, huh? :V

None of that spray touched Lavender, whose voice rang clear from atop the boat's mast:

"...He left his home behind him, sailed for fifty days and nights,​
"with pictures of Miro in mind, that verdant paradise—"

Poppy sighed. "Lavender, please. You only know five sea shanties. You've sung them all. Many times."

822923369149890622.png


I’d recommend doing something to offset Lavender’s singing from the rest of the text though to make it stand out more from the normal dialogue. In this case, I suggested an indent block, but something like italicizing the lyrics would also be serviceable.

Though ‘Miro’, huh. Wonder if we’ll get to see that later on in the story, or if that’s just a background detail to help fluff out the world.

Lavender pouted. "There's nothing else to do on this boat."

"Then perhaps I'll have you try a game of 'don't get smacked overboard by Poppy's vines.'"

Lavender withdrew her head, eyes wide with exaggerated surprise. "You wouldn't!"

"I won't—if you stop singing."

Lavender: “That’s the definition of an unfair bargain there!”
915392763036594216.png

Poppy: “Yeah, well it’s the one you’re getting. So… sound good?”
720106605982646283.png


The boat barely rocked when Lavender dropped from the mast with a huff. "How come you don't get bored, huh?"

"I never heard of boredom before I came to this continent. You city folks just don't know how to relax."

"And how, pray tell, does one learn how to relax?"

An idle vine trimmed the mainsheet; the sails, which had begun to flutter, swelled with wind once more. "I don't know, now that you mention it. Maybe try looking at the sky; that's what I've been doing."

Poppy: “It helps if you can imagine soothing music play in the background and giants duking it out up there.”
Lavender: “... What. Though in case if you haven’t noticed, that doesn’t exactly come naturally for me!”
:what:


Lavender craned her neck. "Well, there she is. Good old sky. Yippee..."

Poppy rolled her eyes, chuckling. "The stars will be out soon, too; maybe I can show you some constellations."

Lavender's ears perked up, and she oohed as though she had just remembered something. "That's right, there's a bunch that originated from that myth I was talking about, and I've been meaning to find them. In a clear sky like this, it should be easy."

"There you go, then. Something to do. In the meantime, would you like to take over the sails?"

Huh, I didn’t realize that these two were piloting the ship directly instead of relying on a supporting crew. These two sure are well-rounded in terms of their skillset given that they know just about everything they need between the two of them to get about anywhere. Though I suppose that would be par for the course for a proper Exploration Team, huh?

"Might as well!"

Poppy retreated to the stern and curled up beside the tiller. She watched Lavender swiftly wind the ropes, turning the winch handle with her tail. "Are you sure this is only your third time sailing?"

Ah, so it’s an old-timey ship given that they don’t have a wheel mechanism for turning the rudder. Can’t fault it though, since it’s definitely mechanically easier to assemble, and seems more up the alley of a society where thumbs aren’t necessarily commonplace.

Even with a mouthful of rope, Lavender flashed Poppy a smile. "I'm hardly better than you, you know."

"That's because I have vines."

"Perhaps." She padded toward the stern and eased the backstay with her rear teeth. The sails billowed with a crisp ruffle, and the boat surged forward; Poppy spread her front paws on instinct, but Lavender didn't seem bothered. "You must pity us mortals, relying on mere teeth and claws."

Poppy gazed at her weaponless paw. "Claws. I do wonder what those would be like."

Poppy: “Not that I’d exactly want the downgrade right here and now. I’ll stick with my vines for actually tending to this boat, thanks.” ^^;

"You're not missing much; knowing you, you'd probably let them grow out too long."

"Touche."

As Lavender settled into the routine of sailing, Poppy daydreamed of what their destination might look like. Gradually, the horizon turned from daffodil to tangerine to murky turquoise.

Lavender let out a loud yawn.

"Time to call it a day?" Poppy asked.

"Yeah."

Poppy dropped the sea anchor and watched it billow in the waves. By the time she had turned around, Lavender had laid out a blanket. "You know, I feel kind of naughty stopping," the delcatty said as she curled up. "It would be faster to keep going and take shifts."

… Wait a minute, how do they know that it’s safe to just stop in the middle of the ocean like this and that their gaff cutter isn’t going to get holes chewed into its hull while sleeping from the likes of a Feral Sharpedo? Since if it was a risk that was serious enough to worry about on land... [sceptical]

"We'll have to sleep in shifts soon enough, once we reach the island. I can only handle so much disrupted sleep." She lay down beside Lavender.

"Mm." Lavender began to scan the sky. "Now, constellations, constellations..."

She knew more than Poppy had realized—Mew's tail, Hoopa's ring, Latias' wing—and each had a story behind it.

"Oh, and I think those are Xerneas' Antlers." Lavender pointed her paw. "As the enemy of life's counterpart, Xerneas is one of the most important characters in mythology. It's said that its power waxes and wanes in cycles, signified by the brightness of that constellation."

Oh, so that answers what the ‘enemy of life’ from the prior chapter is. And given how common wastelands are in this setting… that isn’t a good portent for what happened the last time it woke up.
:fearfullaugh~1:


"Must be long cycles. I've never known stars to dim or brighten."

"Me neither. But thousands of years ago, they say they used to outshine all the other stars. I guess Xerneas has been getting weaker."

:uhhh:


Well that’s totally not ominous considering the track record of Pokémon myths having large kernels of truth to them. Nope, not at all.

"Interesting. We can only hope no new death gods show up."

Narrator: “One’s totally going to show up later on in this story.

Lavender turned her face away.

"Hm? What is it?"

She gave a short chuckle. "I know this sounds silly—I mean, these are myths, who knows if there's any truth to them—but sometimes that thought does scare me a little."

How on earth is a ‘mon this adept at staying alive in the boonies and the voice of reason this genre blind to the sort of story and setting she’s in? >:V

Poppy smiled wryly as she leaned against Lavender—it did, indeed, sound silly. The real threats to life on earth, she knew, were far more immediate and familiar than any god.

Again, not ominous at all there. o3o;;

Though now I’m curious as to what these more immediate threats are, since I hadn’t been able to get a solid hint from the prior scenes in the story thus far as to what the ones Poppy is referring to might be.

Poppy emerged from the nook in which she had slept and gazed out at the ocean. The water here was cleaner than on the shore they had departed from; Poppy could see the bottom, the cobalt pockmarks on the ocean floor where the rock and sand had been worn away. Jagged stone jutted out from parts of the shore, and though the waves looked gentle, the sound when they crashed against these ridges was powerful and expansive.

Poppy walked up to Lavender, who was poised on the tip of one of the taller rocks with characteristic feline grace. "Fancy a swim?" she joked.

Lavender: “Poppy, I’m a cat.” >_>;
Poppy: “... Is that a ‘maybe’?”
720106605982646283.png


Lavender cocked her head; she hadn't heard Poppy's question over the sound of the surf. Poppy repeated herself a little louder and elicited a chuckle from her companion.

"I'll admit I'm tempted," Lavender half-shouted. "Did you sleep well?"

Well, that’s a better reaction from Lavender than I was anticipating. :V

Poppy nodded. "How'd your shift go?"

"Nothing of note—was a little hard to hear over the water, though." She gestured to the right, toward a rockier part of the shore where most of the noise was coming from.

"Right. Let's start heading up, then!"

You’d think that these two would keep around a slate or something for when they had trouble hearing each other considering how much trouble they’re having right now. o<o

Lavender jumped down from her perch and walked inland with Poppy. There was no clear path up the steep slope ahead of them, but there was plenty of sturdy mountain laurel to grab on to. Poppy used her vines to help her, bounding upward almost as fast as flight. From time to time she reached her vines down to Lavender to help her catch up.

… Wait a minute, I just realized that these two aren’t on their boat anymore while the prior scene ended with them stopping at sea to rest for the night. While after double-checking, you can subtly piece together that they made it to shore from the way things open from the shoreline, it might have made sense to explicitly say that in a sentence or two in passing as part of the first paragraph of this scene to make things unambiguous.

"Whee!" Lavender smiled as Poppy pulled her up. "You know, I bet we could use those vines as a makeshift swing set. You ever try that?"

Poppy chuckled as she sidled between two rocks, a mossy scent filling her nose. "For someone else? Can't say I have. Used to swing around with them when I was younger though."

"Aw, really? Why'd you stop?"

[ ]


"I don't know. Guess I just forgot about it."

[ ]


"You forgot? Aw man, Poppy. Sounds like you've been missing out."

"Heh. Maybe."

In my opinion, it might make sense to show off Poppy and Lavender’s body language a bit more here since something about this bare dialogue sequence feels like it’s a little hazy to visualize. I recommended to spots to drop something in, one for Poppy first and then one for Lavender, but you could potentially get away with just one descriptive paragraph being dropped in somewhere in this scene.

The two continued on for a while, until eventually the incline leveled out. Then they took a moment to rest, taking in the sunny, open space ahead. It probably would have been a proper grassland but for the rockiness of the terrain; nonetheless, the sparse patches of soil present played host to smaller flowering plants like butterfly weed and aubrieta. Though the ground may have seemed cold and gray from a distance, there was color if one knew to look for it, spots of violet and coral orange like flecks of paint. Oh, and that plant looked interesting. Was it...

"Poppy," Lavender reprimanded, stamping her paw.

Poppy stopped mid-step with her nose almost flush with the ground, suddenly aware that she had veered off-track in her eagerness to smell the flowers. "Er, sorry Lavender. But you ought to take a look at this plant, at least. I think you'll like it."

Lavender raised her eyebrow and walked over. "Is that so?" She beheld the plant to which Poppy had gestured. Its small, rounded flowers formed clumps at the tips of its protruding stalks, like little purple cattails. "What is it?"

Poppy rolled her eyes. "Come on now. Surely you know this one." She tried to hide her smile as she watched Lavender scrunch up her face in contemplation. "Maybe try smelling it."

Lavender: “B-But I was hoping that you’d just tell me it.”
Poppy: “You’ll never get better at this if I do. Now come on, out with it.”

Lavender did so tentatively. "Hm... I don't know that I've seen this back home. I know I've smelled it somewhere, I just can't quite remember."

"It starts with an 'L'."

"Oh, an 'L'? I don't know if that really helps. Hm..." She scrutinized her companion's face as though she might find a hint there. "Poppy, you aren't messing with me, a—" She froze. "Oh," she said flatly. "It's lavender, isn't it."

>when you can’t identify your own namesake plant in a field

Poppy laughed loud enough to flush the nearby bluebirds.

"Alright," Lavender mumbled as her ears drooped. "I admit that may have been a little stupid."

Poppy patted her on the back. "You'll get the hang of it one of these days, dear."

More like ‘half past never’ at this rate. :V

"Ugh." Lavender looked to the heavens, as though to plead for their mercy. [ ] "O-Oh, but by the way..."

"That braviary, right?"

"Yeah. I don't like the way it's circling. I was beginning to think you hadn't noticed."

I think it might have made more sense to show off the mood change and sighting of the Braviary a bit more than what happened here. Since something about the way things are presently handled feels really sudden and out of left field.

Poppy followed Lavender's gaze and watched the creature. Even from far below its size was impressive; Poppy imagined all 90-or-so pounds of it streaking toward her at full speed and felt a chill run down her spine. "I don't like to say it, but we should be ready for an attack soon. With this terrain, I don't think it's really practical to try and avoid its territory. We're just as likely to run into another one trying to do that, anyway."

Er… yeah, from the way that Poppy’s reacting to the Braviary there, I really am morbidly curious as to what regular attrition for the local guild’s teams from on-the-job injuries and the like is.
:fearfullaugh~1:


"I hate to say that I agree. We should start designating points of reference."

Poppy nodded. "Good idea." She gestured to a boulder nearby. "That'll be twelve o'clock."

"Got it."

The two proceeded onward, the braviary hanging over them like a stormcloud. Poppy harvested useful plants occasionally, but she resisted the urge to bury her nose in the ground. She had to keep up with Lavender's brisk pace anyway; the delcatty was certainly the faster of the two on flat ground.

Thaaaaat isn’t exactly a good omen there. ^^;

"That shrub'll be twelve now... Ugh." Lavender looked up for the umpteenth time after maybe ten minutes of traveling. "If he's going to attack us, I wish he would just get it over with alre—"

Her complaint was interrupted by the braviary's shrill, hawk-like screech. Poppy and Lavender both winced, ears ringing.

"I think it heard you," Poppy grumbled. "That's probably our last warning."

Er… yeah. Given that big eagles and cats/foxes don’t mix well, you two probably want to get out of dodge right about now. ^^;

Lavender sighed. "Swell. I see it gearing up. I'll use swift when it dives and then get out of the way."

"Okay. Shrub is still twelve, yes?"

"Yes."

… Or you can do that. Hope that Braviary in this setting don’t follow canonical strength scaling.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Poppy assumed a fighting stance and narrowed her eyes as the braviary dove. As it closed in, it became clear that it was targeting Lavender first. That was fine by Poppy; she hated fighting flying types, and it gave her time to prepare her attack.

Lavender waited a split second, then opened her mouth to unleash a torrent of golden stars. But the braviary anticipated the swift and rolled out of the way in the blink of an eye. It changed its trajectory to target Poppy instead.

Poppy unleashed her energy ball as soon as she saw where the braviary dodged. She noted, with some degree of satisfaction, that she had timed the attack well; the sphere collided with its target before it could redirect its momentum, and burst into tiny green fragments like shredded leaves.

Huh. Things seem to be holding up decently alright thus far. Well, so far so good-

Poppy's satisfaction was quickly extinguished, however, when she realized that her opponent was barreling toward her as stubbornly as before. The braviary's talons glinted in the sunlight like obsidian as it extended them toward Poppy, and she did the only thing she could think of: duck.

The talons sliced through Poppy's skin like a razor, and stinging pain followed a moment later. Nonetheless, she knew she had gotten off easy. A slower reaction, and she might have been carried off.

663472557499875330.png


Uh… yeah, I take everything that I said earlier back about things going well.

Poppy whipped around to look for her attacker but saw only a clear blue sky. She turned immediately toward Lavender.

"Where'd it go?"

"Four o'clock," Lavender said as she trotted toward Poppy. "Dipped below the ridge."

That fast? "Let's head toward nine, then. Give us some room when it comes back up."

"Got it."

Poppy: “In retrospect, we probably should’ve done this before I got a new set of gouges ripped into my pelt, but hey. Better late than never.” >_>;

The two proceeded, keeping a look out behind them.

"You alright?" Lavender asked as they wove between rocks.

"Just a scratch. It won't impair me."

578077337728450560.png


Can’t tell if she’s being earnest and Pokémon are just built tough in this setting, or she’s lying to keep Lavender calm. Since that description earlier did not sound like ‘just a scratch’.

"Good. Now look alive." She gestured forward and slightly to the left.

The braviary peeked its head above the ridge for a moment before properly rising above it. Seeing that its prey was too far for an ambush, it began instead to flap its wings and regain its lost altitude.

"We should attack it before it can dive again!" Lavender charged toward the braviary, and Poppy followed close behind.

Or, hear me out. You can cut and run from the giant angry bird that is trying to turn you into lunch. Especially if you happened to pack something like a Totter Orb to pop the moment it comes into range.

The braviary dodged Lavender's next swift easily, but it was forced to slow its ascent. Poppy lashed out with a vine while it was distracted and grabbed its ankle.

The braviary cried out; Poppy flinched. Her face contorted as she strained against it, but she may as well have been pulling at a tree. Her front legs lifted off the ground, so she quickly lassoed a second vine around a nearby boulder to stabilize herself.

Poppy cried out for Lavender, but the delcatty already knew what to do. While the braviary contorted its body to try and peck and scratch at its restraints, Lavender closed her eyes and focused. Yellow sparks flashed around her mane as she prepared her next attack.

Right, Delcatty can learn Thunder/Thunderbolt via TM. Completely forgot about that one.

Though the attack itself—a jagged yellow bolt—only lasted for the blink of an eye, its effects were immediately apparent. The braviary made a guttural sound as its wings twitched and then froze up. It fell to the ground with a low thud, and Poppy wasted no time in subsequently wrapping up its wings and feet. She tied off the vines once she was done, and then detached them from her body.

"There," she exhaled, suddenly aware of her heartbeat pounding in her chest. "Happy holidays, I guess."

Lavender: “... Are we supposed to just leave it here like this, or…?” .-.
Poppy: “Oi, considering how I have cuts in my pelt right now, I’m not untying it.”

Lavender raised her eyebrow. "I still don't know if that joke quite lands."

"It'll be funnier when I learn how to make bowties." She shrugged, then winced at the pain in her shoulder. "Anyway, I'd suggest we move him somewhere safer while the vines degrade, but for two things. First... for a bird, he's heavy as all get-out. Second..." She watched the pokemon as it twitched and flopped around, trying fruitlessly to regain its footing. It struck her just how big it was, dwarfing her size even with folded wings. "That thunder wave is going to wear off in a minute, and frankly I don't even want to be around it when that happens. So long as its beak isn't bound, I doubt anything's going to try and eat it."

… I did not pick up at all on that being a T-Wave. It seemed a lot more visually impressive than I was expecting for a move like that. ^^;

"Fair points both. Let's move on, then."

They proceeded, but Poppy was slower than usual. Lavender looked at her back. "That cut looks a little deep, Poppy. You want to put something on it?"

"Yeah, not a bad idea. It's not worth using the oran, though." She nosed through her bag and produced a plant with small white flowers and lacy leaves. "Here's some yarrow I picked earlier—you can make a poultice out of that. It'll help with the bleeding."

Ah, so normal plants have practical uses in this setting as well. That’s definitely something you don’t see every day in Pokémon fanfic. Kudos for that there, especially for the implication of how even though the outright game items work better than them, that circumstances don’t always justify using them.

They stopped for a moment while Lavender did as suggested. Her teeth were not made for chewing leaves, but she managed well enough.

"Smells like licorice," Lavender said as she applied the treatment.

"It is actually edible—if you're omnivorous, anyway. Either way, I prefer to keep it for... Well, stuff like this." Poppy sighed. "Anyway, if the pokemon here are really this tough, I can see why Team Chlorosteel called for backup."

That… doesn’t bode well for how Team Chlorosteel is doing right about now.
:uhhh:


"I know, right?!" Lavender exclaimed, as though she had been waiting this whole time to say it. "I know everyone's gonna say 'type advantage' or whatever, but it's one thing for a pokemon to take an attack like that and stay conscious, and another thing entirely for it to just... plow right through it."

Poppy chuckled. "I'm glad you think so too. Caught me completely off-guard. Took your thunder wave pretty well, too."

… Oh boy, these two sailed off to their setting’s equivalent of Zero Isle or something absurd like that, didn’t they?
663472557499875330.png


"True. Let's hope it's just an anomaly." Lavender stepped away from Poppy. "Anyway, you were right about that herb. Seems to have stopped the bleeding. Just take care when you're climbing so that wound doesn't reopen."

Poppy nodded. "Will do. Thanks."

Narrator: “It wasn’t an anomaly.

Though that’s definitely quite the ominous note to end on. Like I’d been constantly getting “something terrible is about to happen” vibes through this story, though this seems like a situation where Lavender and Poppy’s luck might legitimately be about to run out if their first hostile encounter on this island got them into this much trouble.

Alright, and as for the final recap of everything:

I really, really liked what I read of this piece. And I can understand why it’s got such good word of mouth surrounding it. Even in just 6400 or so words, there’s a lot of hints about this setting and how it works that come out, along with a strong sense that something was deeply wrong in the past, and from the hints of present-day dealings, likely still is deeply wrong that does a great job at selling a sense of wonder and mystery that makes you want to keep going and find out more about things.

As for things I wasn’t a fan of… there’s honestly not a whole lot. There’s a few bits where I felt that the description was a bit rushed or lacking, but the vast majority of the story was put together extremely solidly. And I’m honestly a little envious at how much you managed to accomplish for framing your story in fewer words than the prologue of my most recent non-rewrite story.

Kudos, @love . Though I doubt that this will be the last time that I cross paths with this story, since you’ve legitimately made me curious in seeing where you’re going to take things with it.
 

Spiteful Murkrow

Busy Writing Stories I Want to Read
Pronouns
He/Him/His
Partners
  1. nidoran-f
  2. druddigon
  3. swellow
  4. lugia
  5. quilava-fobbie
  6. sneasel-kate
  7. heliolisk-fobbie
Heya, back with another review of your story for a mix of Reading Rookidee and some priorities from an offsite review event. I was quite taken by the world you depicted last time around, and these next few chapters were pretty short, so I did a bit of a longer review than normal chapter-wise.

Anyhow, carrying along:

Chapter 3

The island's vegetation grew gradually denser as Poppy and Lavender neared their destination. By now oak trees too thick to embrace towered over them, filtering out most of the sunlight.

… Not that that isn’t a neat visual, but wouldn’t those two have issues with just about any tree since they’re a Leafeon and a Delcatty?
720106605982646283.png


"I know I'm not the ecologist here," said Lavender as she slipped between the branches of a serviceberry shrub, "but this doesn't seem natural."

"You can say that again," Poppy agreed. "The soil here shouldn't be able to support... all this. And check this out." She grasped the branch of a blueberry bush between her toes and bent it hard. The leaves rustled, but the branch held despite its thinness. "These plants... I'm not sure it would even be possible to cut down one of these trees."

I kinda wonder if it would’ve made sense to show something unnatural about the vegetation prior to Lavender’s line somehow. Maybe hammering home something more about how the oak trees are unnatural or something like that.

Though the indestructium blueberry bush does do a good job at selling the sense that something’s up. Even if I haven’t figured it out just what could be causing this yet.

"Maybe it's the same reason why the pokemon here are tougher, too. There's something going on we don't know about."

"Yeah. Hopefully we'll learn something from team Chlorosteel. Speaking of which..." Poppy took a deep breath. "Laurie! Scotch!"

"You've got to be louder than that," Lavender teased. She turned her head forward. "Like this—Laurie! Scotch!" She looked back at Poppy. "See, they'll have a much easier time—"

Lavender was interrupted by a distant but piercing screech—if a chunk of metal could crash to the ground and shatter like glass, that's probably what it would have sounded like.

Well, that certainly ain’t good.

Lavender: “... I’m pretty sure that that wasn’t supposed to happen.”
:uhhh:


"Huh, good job," said Poppy. "I haven't heard any skarmory on this island so far, so I'm willing to bet that's our quarry."

Lavender smiled. "Thank goodness. Let's get over there!"

Waaaaaait, isn’t quarry something you hunt? As in prey? I was under the impression these two were supposed to rendezvous with Team Chlorosteel under friendly terms. ^^;

Not a huge nitpick, but a more neutral-sounding term might have leaned into that a bit better.

Poppy and Lavender threaded their way through the understory, until they saw a glint of steel through the bushes.

"Scotch!" Lavender picked up her pace. "Is that you?"

The skarmory's head peeked through the leaves of a sumac. "Hey, Lavender!" he called, his voice rough like grinding stones. "It's good to see you."

Rough like grinding stones, huh? Somehow I always associated Skarmory with shriller voices thanks to the anime, but you can’t say that it’s not a fitting cadence for a Steel-type.

Poppy and Lavender closed the distance between themselves and Scotch and gave their greetings. Poppy gave Scotch a cursory look and was relieved to see he seemed uninjured. It took her a little longer to notice the comparatively diminutive lurantis that stood behind him, a little off to the side. The way she held herself, with her legs close together and arms half-hiding her face, suggested she was someone introverted.

"How are you two doing?" Lavender asked. "I got the sense, from what we were told, that you had had some trouble dealing with ferals around here."

Poppy: “Also, the feral Braviary that just cut a few chunks out of my pelt about 30 minutes ago, but let’s not talk too much about that right now.” >_>;

Scotch nodded. "That's right. Laurie was injured badly by an arbok earlier. Wasn't poisoned, thank goodness, but we took it as a sign that we should call for help."

Laurie, the lurantis, stepped forward and held out her arm. There was a jagged spot of swollen flesh there about as large as a coaster, resembling a burn.

Yeesh. Though what is that injury that Laurie has there? An acid/poison burn?

"Heavens." Lavender clucked her tongue. "That must have been really bad. How long ago was it?"

"Well, that's the thing... It's only been two days. I mean, I thought... I thought she was gonna die at first when we were treating it, but... she's already fine."

Wait. What? But how does that even-?

Lavender frowned and looked Scotch in the eye. "Two days? You're sure?"

"I mean, I was there."

Lavender shook her head. "Not that I'm unhappy to hear it, but even with good treatment, it's hard to believe. Unless..."

[ ]


Scotch nodded. "We're thinking it has something to do with this place. If our guess is correct... All of us could be passively benefiting from the power that permeates this island. Just like all these plants here." He struck the tree beside him hard with his wing; the sound reverberated across the forest like a gong. But he didn't so much as chip the bark. "And maybe the feral pokemon are strong because they've been here for longer. Just a thought. But either way, things keep getting crazier as we move further inland. If we keep going, we might be able to find the source of it all."

I kinda wonder if it would’ve made sense to soak in the moment and have some sort of “wait wut” moment before taking in the surroundings and realizing “... it’s because of this place”. Maybe it doesn’t have to happen, but this sequence did feel a bit fast for how they put two and two together.

"Sounds exciting!" said Lavender.

"Sounds dangerous," said Poppy.

why-not-both-why-not.gif


The two looked at each other, and then Poppy glanced away awkwardly. "I mean, I know we're here to explore, but I can't help but think something that powerful should be left alone."

"The opposite could be true, too, don't you think? If we don't know what's causing this, it could bite us later."

[ ]


"I guess," Poppy said, and then frowned. "I'm just worried about the guildmaster. You were there for our last conversation. I don't trust him with... whatever we find."

I kinda wonder if it would’ve made sense to stop and slot in some description describing the gears turning in Poppy’s head there or something. Maybe it’s an artifact of this section only being dialogue and dialogue with embedded actions, but something feels like there’s a missing sense of time passing and the characters stopping to wonder about things or the like.

Though considering the last we saw of that Guildmaster, I think I’m on Team Poppy here for not wanting to get him involved. ^^;

Lavender nodded. "I understand that, Poppy. But it's too late to pretend this doesn't exist, so we may as well finish this mission and get paid."

[ ]


"You're right," Poppy mumbled. "We still have to keep going, so... we may as well be optimistic about it."

Poppy began to walk, but her gait was slow, and her chin was a little lower than usual. The others followed shortly after and soon overtook her.

Same deal here regarding a section where it feels like there ought to be some hesitation or sense of time passing brought up by narration or the like, that doesn’t quite come through at the moment. My recommendation if you do opt to go back and change things is much the same as in the last block.

The irony in having a strong, four-pokemon team is that it made having a strong, four-pokemon team unnecessary. Even the more threatening ferals like rillaboom and arcanine recognized they were at a numerical disadvantage and scrambled off through the bushes when the explorers neared them.

M
eanwhile the vegetation around Poppy, Lavender, and team Chlorosteel continued to grow to more extreme—if not frightening—proportions. There were paw-sized serviceberries and tree trunks nearly large enough to live inside, like something out of a fairy tale. Poppy was covered in itchy scratches where she had tried to push through a patch of brambles only to realize that the stems and thorns were as rigid as steel. Lavender seemed excited ("Look at how big that flower is!" "Poppy, try this dandelion!") but Poppy just felt like she was somewhere she didn't belong.

Maybe I’m tripping, but this opening paragraph feels long and idea-dense enough that it might be worth considering hacking into two.

Though brushing through thorns as hard as steel sounds like a very [grimacing] experience. Surprised that didn’t turn out like trying to go through concertina wire for Poppy there.

After a few days, an unusually steep ridge appeared on the horizon—a nearly perpendicular slope that led to an ashen, volcano-like crater.

I… didn’t get the sense that the gang had been going at this for multiple days up until this point. Maybe it’d have made more sense to include a passing mention of this in the first paragraph somewhere, since it presently reads very “30 minutes later, and then 3 days later” within the span of two paragraphs.

"We might want to go around that," Poppy suggested.

Lavender gestured with her tail to the tip of the crater. "But look, Poppy, there's something glowing at the top there. We should check it out!"

de7.png


Scotch: “Uh… Poppy. Just saying, you might want me to do a flyby and see what’s going on up there first before the rest of you go.” ^v^;

Poppy, along with Scotch and Laurie, looked up. It was faint, but there was indeed a strange white glow coming from the center, like moonlight.

"Lavender is right," Scotch said. "That might be the source of all this power."

"I see," Poppy replied. "Then here we go..."

Wow, not even bothering to do aerial reconnaissance, huh? This Leafeon’s certainly a bold one. :V

The teams picked up their pace slightly, though it was still slow going with all the foliage. Scotch led the way, flattening the shrubs where he could, while Laurie slipped through gaps in the branches like water. Lavender wrinkled her nose as she emerged from under a burdock shrub.

"You smell that too?" Poppy asked.

"Yeah," Lavender said as she picked a burr off her flank. "You don't know what it is, do you?"

Poppy shook her head. "Never smelled anything like it. Sweet, but not floral... I don't think it's botanical in origin."

Poppy: “Wait a minute, what does smell sweet that isn’t floral anyways?”
:what:

Lavender: “... A Pokémon using Sweet Scent? Though actually…”

"I think it smells more like a pokemon... Maybe it's a species we haven't seen before!"

Indeed it is.

The psychic voice was floaty, ethereal, like the sound of rubbing a wineglass. Everyone started. "What was—"

Light flashed in the corner of Poppy's eye, so she whipped her head around to look, and then did a double-take.

Azure and cobalt highlights on black fur. Antlers as tall as Poppy herself, spread wide like the mouth of a goblet. She scrutinized every feature, looking for the telltale shimmer of a zoroark's illusion, the misshapen artifacts that would signify a transformed ditto, but found nothing. This island wasn't even that far from the guild; had Xerneas really been here the whole time?

Well, that’s certainly quite the entrance there. Like I had a feeling that Legendaries were going to come into play from the folk story that was told in the ship sequence, but I didn’t think that they’d come into play this soon. ^^

Poppy: “... How on earth did we not hear you approaching?” .-.
Xerneas: “It’s soft ground and my hooves are spears? Sounds like a good enough way to not make a ton of noise getting around.”
720106605982646283.png


Xerneas' gaze swept twice over everyone gathered before it, and the air seemed to chill several degrees. I do not know why you all are here, but unless it is something pressing, I implore you to leave.

"O-okay," said Lavender, blinking like she'd got dust in her eyes. "Can I ask why? We came all this way to explore the island..."

Lavender, I don’t think you want to argue with the Legendary Pokémon there, especially when your own myths see them as gods. Like I know what the batting average for myths in Pokémon settings being true is, and I’m pretty sure that Xerneas is about one of the last Pokémon you want to make angry with you.
:fearfullaugh~1:


To explore the island? Xerneas tilted its head and examined Lavender's pouch, with its guild badge affixed to the front. Its eyes narrowed fractionally. Guild members. I see. I am distantly aware of your organization.

Poppy: “Wait a minute. You… are? But how?

The ensuing silence was long, but Poppy didn't want to speak up. Eventually Lavender opened her mouth, but Xerneas interrupted her. "Leave no stone unturned." A common saying amongst your ilk. Tell me, if you return home without having completed your exploration, what do you think the guild will do?

"They'll send someone else," Poppy said. "They'll send fliers too high for you to reach, or psychics."

Xerneas nodded slowly. I think so as well.

Lavender: “... Poppy, I don’t think I like where this conversation is going, since I’m pretty sure that it’s going to involve us not being allowed to leave this island alive.” O_O;

It was silent yet again. Scotch and Laurie shuffled their feet as crickets' calls sizzled throughout the understory. Xerneas stood still, statuesque, and stayed that way even as it resumed speaking.

I would prefer to keep this place secret, but I know that to be a naive prospect. As a gesture of goodwill, I will tell you what lies at the center of this landmass—and I hope that information inspires you and your ilk to act responsibly.

The explorers nodded.

Again:

de7.png


Lavender: “I mean… at least Xerneas hasn’t ruled out allowing us to leave the island alive? So we’re on a better track than I thought?” ^^;

Doubtless, each of you has already realized the unique qualities of this island’s lifeforms. And, as you have speculated, they arise from that source over there. It gestured with its head to the top of the crater. That crater goes far underground, nearly to the center of the planet. It exposes the planet’s energy itself, which bubbles up like a spring.

Lavender spoke up. "I don't get what you mean by 'the planet's energy'"

Nearly everything I know about it is in the name. But surely, at some point, you must have wondered about how us pokemon acquired our power. About what separates us from animals.

"Are you saying it's because of this energy?"

… Wait a minute, is this the Dragon Force from the anime or something like that? Like I’m getting very strong “Lifestream from FF7” vibes here, though I’m tripping up over what, if anything, would match up with something with this description from a branch of canon.

Yes. Though it is especially strong here, it actually permeates the entire planet. And pokemon, by nature, can harness it in myriad ways. Xerneas looked up to the sky. In the past, pokemon were far more powerful. You may have heard stories about it; about how skarmory used to be able to fly, for example. It pointed at Scotch. But populations have grown, meaning that there is now less of this power for each individual to draw upon. I bring this up to illustrate that the planet’s energy is a finite resource that warrants protection. I am here to provide that protection and ensure that it remains freely usable by all.

… All this time, I didn’t notice that Scotch couldn’t fly. I wonder if it would’ve made more sense to call attention to that as a passing remark in the narrative or something like that, since that feels like a pretty big setting detail.

Though I have to wonder if the diminishing of this power is really from mere population growth, or if it’s a symptom of something far more serious and terminal such as the overall power and sharable pool shrinking. I mean, I remember that bit on the boat with the myth about Xerneas’ constellation dimming… ._.;

"That's interesting," said Lavender. "But a power source like that could be put to a lot of different uses, don't you think? Maybe pokemon could get together to harness a bunch of it and make, I dunno, lights that stay on all the time! Or like, superpowered carriages that can transport things really fast!"

Poppy: “Lavender, I thought you were worried about being allowed to leave this island alive. Don’t give Xerneas reasons to think about not allowing that!” >_>;
Lavender: “... That wasn’t canon to begin with? Plus you can’t say doing stuff like that wouldn’t be cool…” ^^

Poppy stepped forward, into Lavender's view. "I would just like to quickly say that I do not endorse these ideas."

Lavender pouted at Poppy. "Aw, why not? Otherwise all that energy is mostly just going to be used for fighting, and that kind of seems like a waste."

Poppy: “Lavender, I’m pretty sure that that energy’s going to wind up turning out to be needed for something like us being able to live. You don’t want to mess with that for the sake of keeping lightbulbs on.” >_>;
Lavender: “... Even if it only requires messing with it a little?”
720106605982646283.png


"It’s more than just fighting. For example, if that power were depleted, I might not be able to use my vines as effectively. That would affect a lot more than just combat."

Lavender frowned. "Pokemon are smart. It shouldn’t be too hard for us to invent a way around—"

Poppy: “Lavender. Stop. Talking.” >.<
Lavender: “What? We are!

"Just because there might be a way around it doesn’t mean it’s okay to curse every pokemon on the planet with unnatural deficiencies." Poppy's face grew hot. "And what about pokemon with healing abilities? Should we contrive replacements for them as well? Sounds like we're well on our way to creating a solutionist dystopia."

A what dystopia now? Not sure if I’ve ever heard of that concept before.

Poppy: “Also, I’d just like to remind that if Xerneas’ power weakens… who exactly is going to hold back Yveltal’s power?”
:fearfullaugh~1:

Lavender: “... Yveltal would since its power would also be weakened by virtue of also being a Pokémon?”
720106605982646283.png


I agree with the leafeon, Xerneas said. The natural order is too important to be tampered with.

Lavender wrinkled her brow. "But for emergencies? If we had an influx of refugees, say, and had to provide homes or heating? Could we use it somehow then?"

Poppy: “Again. Lavender. Stop. Talking.” >.<

There is no use that will not harm others. The answer is no.

Lavender turned toward Scotch and Laurie. "And you two? I take it you feel the same?"

"Er..." Scotch shuffled his feet. "I don't know. I didn't expect something like this; I just wanted to explore the island. I'll have to think about it."

Meanwhile, Laurie just held still.

Scotch: “I mean, I do want to say that I didn’t exactly sign up for having to think through ethical quandaries right about now.” ^^;

"Fine." Lavender turned and stomped away, crushing the fallen leaves beneath her paws. Scotch and Laurie followed shortly after.

"Lavender..." Poppy took a step toward her partner, then stopped and turned toward Xerneas. "I'm sorry about that. Good luck."

Xerneas simply bowed its head.

I’m a little surprised that Xerneas is just letting them go given that it could very clearly hear that one of the four Pokémon that encountered it isn’t reasonably trustworthy with the information that she just found out, and the stakes of this source of power being misused aren’t exactly trivial.

I mean, as much as I’d love to think that Lavender would sober up… there’s another 9 chapters of this thing, so I’ll take the under on her being responsible and deciding that some knowledge is just better left alone here. ^^;

Chapter 4

The sun was low in the sky, and the docks were quiet this late in the day; just the sounds of water lapping at the shore. Lavender stretched as she stepped out of the boat. She had already apologized for her anger earlier, unprompted, and by now she seemed to have forgotten it. "Thank goodness... It's good to be home, eh Poppy?"

Oh, so they did just turn around and leave the island. I mean, I’m not convinced that Lavender isn’t going to make things go horribly sideways in short order, but at least they passed step one. :V

Poppy chuckled quietly. "Yeah... Didn't feel like a month, though, did it? Oh, that reminds me, since we're close by anyway, I'd better go check up on the crew before it gets dark. I'll meet you at home."

All of the last two chapters happened over the course of a month? Was that island subject to time dilation or something? .-.

Lavender shook her head. "No, Poppy. Remember last time? I'm coming with you."

"Oh." Poppy looked down. "Right. Sorry."

The two of them trotted along. It always felt a little strange to bring Lavender with her to her little sanctuary, but a part of Poppy was excited. Lavender hadn't been there in a while, so Poppy bet she would be impressed. They just had to crest this last hill, and then they would be treated to a panoramic view...

Had Poppy not been paying attention, she might not have recognized the place. The soil was barren, dry enough that a gust of wind blew dust into the air. The branches had been cleared from the river, and the riparian trees and saplings replaced with ornamental species that left the water exposed to the sun. A few hundred meters away, pokemon were pouring a foundation beside stacks of neatly cut lumber. And even from atop the hill, Poppy could recognize the purugly—that pudgy gray blob—that sat beside the site, surveying it with critical eyes. The guildmaster.

That… doesn’t exactly sound like a sanctuary there. And that can’t possibly be good for the land there. .-.

Poppy's face flushed, and her hackles raised. Her heart pounded as she descended the gradual slope toward the construction site. She didn't notice how fast she was running until she heard Lavender call for her to wait up.

The soil beneath Poppy's paws was hard and warm from its exposure to sunlight. Like asphalt. Poppy tried not to think about this, or about the workers whose heads were turning toward her, or about anything, as she approached the guildmaster.

I mean, as much as it sucks that your little patch of heaven got proverbially paved over, if the guild had the rights to the land there...

The guildmaster turned toward Poppy and gave her a smile and a nod as she approached. "Ah, Poppy," he said in a saccharine voice. "How was your trip? You'll have to tell me all ab—"

"What. The fuck." Poppy's voice was strained, her throat constricted as she tried to stop herself from growling.

The guildmaster cocked his head innocently. "Excuse me?"

Poppy's ears started ringing. "I own. This land," she said, nearly spitting each word. Her voice, and the sounds of the workers around her, slowly grew muffled, as though buried under a sheet of snow.

Oh, well scratch that, then. One would think that a guild would be above stealing land from its own members, but considering how this guy was just ready to run over tribals living in the forest, I guess I shouldn’t be so surprised.

"Ah, oh, of course! You must be a little confused." The guildmaster reached into his pouch and produced a small sheaf of paper. "Here, I figured you might want to review the guild's special privileges. Since this land is not in use and has not had plans for development for over two years, we are, because of amendment 14, legally entitled to purchase it- Worry not! You should have received a check by now reimbursing you for—"

"I want. The land." Poppy glared and lowered her stance.

To be fair, considering the absolute state that the land is in already, you might be better off just taking the money and buying new land, Poppy. And using the rest to hire a lawyer and sue this guy into the poor house. ^^;

The guildmaster gave a confused look. "But after all that work you did to clean things up, was your intention really just to leave this parcel sitting there? As a guild member, surely you must understand the importance of public service."

Poppy heard a crackle of electricity, no louder than static, right as she summoned her vines to attack. Her legs buckled beneath her, and she fell awkwardly to the ground. A tingling sensation like pins and needles pervaded her body.

Thunder wave, of course.

I mean, did you really think that taking a swing at a Guildmaster was just going to be tolerated, Poppy? I mean, even if the guy himself is a pushover, he does have the rest of the guild to hide behin-

"I-I'm terribly sorry for my partner's behavior," Lavender stuttered as she nosed under Poppy and slipped the leafeon onto her back. "The last trip was very stressful for her, and she needs some time to rest..."

… Oh.
:uhhh:


That’s… significantly worse than I thought would’ve happened. And I can’t imagine Poppy is going to take this well.

Poppy could feel Lavender trembling beneath her.

"So, um, w-we'll just be heading right home..." Lavender bowed awkwardly and turned away before the guildmaster could comment. She walked briskly, but stiffly, clearly holding herself back from breaking out into a run.

Poppy: “Lavender. What. The. Hell?!
915392763036594216.png

Lavender: “Poppy, trust me, it was for your own good!” O_O;

To Poppy, it felt like sleep paralysis. Adrenaline surged through her veins, dizzying her with each concussive heartbeat. The sounds of Lavender's footsteps grew distant, spectral, drowned out by the rush of her shallow breaths. Poppy prayed that she would faint; anything to save her from this sickening anxiety, this contempt that had wrapped its gnarled claws around her heart.

But it was not to be so. Poppy was still conscious as Lavender dropped her off behind a boulder, even if her vision had narrowed to a paw-sized tunnel. She tried again to move and was able to at least curl her paws.

"Okay..." Lavender took a deep breath, and Poppy only just noticed how hard the delcatty had been panting. "Poppy, you need to calm down. I get that you're upset, but let's talk about it before..." She tapped her claws against the ground. "...I mean, I know this was unexpected, but in a sense it's your goal, right? The land is clean enough for other pokemon to use, and, well, this isn't a bad use. I think you should still be proud."

Poppy: “Did you just huff catnip?! Like hell this was my goal!
915392763036594216.png

Lavender: “... Maybe try taking a deep breath first before saying more?” ._.;

Slowly, Poppy loosened up her limbs and rolled onto her belly. She did her best to steady herself as she got to her feet. Still so stiff—it felt like she was standing on stilts.

Lavender looked anxiously into Poppy's eyes. "Does that make sense? I mean, if there's something I'm missing, we can talk about it..."

Lavender, that’s not how any of this works.

Poppy nosed through the old, dried-up leaves in her bag until something cool touched her nose. Her guild badge. She glimpsed the design—an emblem that looked like the sun, and a pair of unfurled wings. She grabbed it in her mouth and bit down on its unyielding surface as hard as she could. She heard something crack as she whipped her head around and hurled the badge onto the ground, right by Lavender's feet.

Lavender jumped back, startled; Poppy heedlessly summoned one of her vines and smashed it into the badge. The impact sent specks of dirt into the air and left a mark on the ground like a scar.

Then Poppy turned around and staggered away. She did not look back.

I mean, I kinda expected Poppy to go on more of an extended rant there about ‘how could you?!’ and part of me thinks that this might have been more effective with at least a line of dialogue from her to the effect of “Save it!” or something like that, but… yeah. After getting T-Waved by your own friend who took the side of the guy who stole your land out from under you, I’d be pissed enough to just walk from the team we were on too.

Chapter 5

Thud. Thud. Thud.

Numbing pain shot through Poppy's body as she threw herself at the beech tree for the umpteenth time. A stinging sensation confirmed that the wound on her shoulder—acquired from a fight with a feral scyther—had reopened, but she persisted anyway.

… Why are you even doing that with that sort of wound unhealed on your body? That can’t possibly be healthy there.” .-.

"I don't think that's how you're supposed to learn tackle."

Poppy started and whipped around to face the source of the androgynous, child-like voice that had interrupted her. The speaker stood out starkly against the ferns, its pure white fur out-of-place in this wild setting. Poppy squinted at it for a moment—it was about half her height and vaguely rabbit-like, with long ears and a short snout and tail. When it leaned forward, its eyes iridesced like mother-of-pearl, such that Poppy couldn't distinguish an iris or pupil. It didn't look like any pokemon she had seen or heard of.

"Who are you?" Poppy asked, a little more rudely than she had meant to.

"You can call me Ann. And while I hate to intrude, you seem a bit upset." Ann batted its eyes.

… Wait, what am I looking at for a Pokémon here for ‘Ann’? Since that physical description there isn’t really ringing any bells.

Poppy's fur was knotty, more brown than cream, and smothered with fern fuzz; she could feel the bagginess in her eyes, the matted spots on her muzzle where tears had soaked in. She looked more than just "upset". But she held her voice steady nonetheless, if only to change the subject. "You don't say," she said as she brushed a chip of bark off her shoulder. "It's rare to meet another non-feral out here. What's your story?"

Yeesh, Poppy didn’t take that moment with Lavender well at all there. Not that I’d expect ‘my friend helped my boss steal my land’ to be taken well.

"Well, I don't have a home, so I guess that makes me a wanderer." It shrugged. "But I'm not one to talk about myself. I would rather hear about you."

"About me, huh?" Poppy scoffed. "Hate to say it, but I'm not in the mood to talk about myself, either."

Ann: “Er… yeah, I kinda gathered that from your appearance. But maybe try anyways?” ^^;

Undeterred, Ann gestured to Poppy's bloody shoulder. "How about that injury, then? It's not good to leave something like that untreated. Will you at least let me heal it?"

Poppy considered. She had to admit it would be reckless to say no—if her wound got infected this far from civilization, it could be dangerous. "I guess you have a point." She frowned. "Rare to see a pokemon around here that can heal. What species are you?"

"Don't know about my species—only my name. But I can heal as well as anyone, I promise!"

578077337728450560.png


Though I mean, I suppose if Ann had untoward intentions, she could’ve already acted on them right here and now, so…

Poppy shrugged. "If you say so. Go ahead, then, I guess. Just don't strain yourself."

Ann approached Poppy with silent footsteps. Poppy stiffened as it touched her wound, but only for a moment—she was surprised to find that Ann's paw was as soft as a kit's, as though it had never touched the ground.

A couple seconds passed as Ann wrinkled its face in concentration.

"You okay there, Ann?"

"Mm, just give me a moment..."

At length Ann removed its paw, and Poppy looked down at herself. Aside from a nearly imperceptible bald spot, it was as if the wound had never been there. She observed that the foliage by Ann's feet was wilted now—had it been like that before?

Wait. What?

Just what sort of Pokémon can do that as a power? .-.

"Phew..." Ann put a paw to its forehead and giggled woozily. "Okay, I may have forgotten how difficult healing really is. You'd think it would be harder to warp around the continent, but not for old Ann..."

… At first I thought Ann was Mew, but that doesn’t check out with the rabbit-like ears. I’m… admittedly stumped on this one.
720106605982646283.png


Poppy wasn't sure what to make of Ann's remark about 'warping', but she was more worried about its condition. "Do you need to lie down?"

"Thank you for your concern, Poppy, but I'll be alright. I'm just a little out of practice."

Poppy's blood ran cold. "Who told you my name?"

Ann scratched its head bashfully. "Ha ha, oops. Here we are. This had to come up at some point, but I have a bit of explaining to do... But this might turn into a bit of a long conversation, so why don't we take a moment to relocate? I've been meaning to get some sunlight."

Poppy: “Great, so I’ve been being stalked by a mysterious stranger with healing and teleporting powers. Who knows my name without me ever having told her it. That’s not suspicious at all.” >_>;
Ann: “... I’d like to remind you that I did all of this for you while we were out in the boonies, so I think you can afford to be a bit more trusting.” ^^;

"Very well." Poppy's voice was prickly.

Poppy and Ann continued talking as they waded through the ferns. "So, look..." Ann glanced away for a moment. "I'm privy to a lot of things. Think of it like I have a crystal ball, or something like that. I do a lot of observing. It passes the time, you know?"

Poppy narrowed her eyes. "You must have observed me from across the ocean. I haven't spoken to anyone since I got here."

:uhhh:


Wait, did Poppy go back to Xerneas’ island there, or…?

"You're correct. And, while it feels a little awkward to be getting right into this, this does lead into what I've been meaning to talk about. The circumstances behind your return to this continent."

Oh. So she did go back to Xerneas’ island. Considering her state of mind, I’m not fully convinced that her being here is a good thing. Or that she’s come here with innocent intentions. ._.;

Poppy sighed. "Oh boy. This should be good."

Ann smiled reassuringly. "Sorry. I don't mean to bring up bad memories—I simply wanted to point out that we might have a shared goal. I think it's fair to say that we're both feeling a little disillusioned with the guild, yes?"

"You don't really need me to answer that, do you?"

"Fair enough, Poppy. Anyway, you're also one of the only pokemon right now that knows about the planet's energy, and we both know the guild isn't going to let all that potential get... 'wasted', so to speak. If they really want it, then frankly, I don't think even Xerneas would stand a chance. Not with how the stars are now..."

I… really don’t like where this topic of conversation is going right about now.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Poppy tried to keep her voice steady. "So, what's your plan?"

"Despite my mediocre healing skills, I'm quite strong in... other areas." Ann sighed. "See, back in the day, I could have just gone right ahead and put the fear of god in those meddlers myself. But, long story short, I kind of got in trouble for doing things like that. Kind of got... banished to another realm, in fact." It laughed awkwardly. "So, as you might imagine, it takes most of my strength just to project this avatar here." It gestured to itself. "But if, say, there were someone else who already had a body in this realm, and they were willing to channel my power…" It leaned toward Poppy conspiratorially.

This is an absolutely terrible idea and the proper response to this is to run off screaming ‘nope nope nope’ right about now, Poppy. Even if I have a feeling that she won’t have the mind to do so. ^^;

"So, you want a servant, then?"

"I'd prefer the term 'partner.' I don't intend to make you do anything you don't want to—and in fact, I'm not really sure I could." It waved its paw. "Oh, but I'm just speculating here. I'm not even sure that idea will work, anyway. Still, if you want to give it a try..."

796822964019527760.png


… Why does this sound like the sort of ‘exact words’ statement that is going to lead to Poppy causing mass death in like a chapter?

Even if Ann was lying, Poppy thought, she would gain nothing by refusing. "Assuming you're telling the truth, I'm not opposed—but there's something I have to ask in return. If your motivations are pure, I'm sure you'll be glad to accept."

Oh hey, I figured out Ann’s identity:

iu


Really, could the “deal with the devil” vibes here be getting any stronger right about now? There is exactly zero way that agreeing to this is going to turn out well for anyone.

"Mm, I have a feeling I know what you're about to suggest."

Poppy closed her eyes. "I want to take back my land."

Ann smiled as it entered the clearing nearby. Its fur gleamed, eyes sparkled in the sunlight. "Poppy, if you're willing to help me, I'll let you do that, and so much more."

663472557499875330.png


This is not going to end well. There is exactly no way that this is going to end well. Especially with phrasing as deliberate and carefully chosen as that involving a plan that requires you to be a vessel to an otherworldly power.

Chapter 6

Poppy opened her eyes for the first time in what felt like hours and squinted against the sunlight.

How are you doing?

"Still not used to hearing your voice in my head," Poppy muttered as she stretched. "Other than that, I'm a little frustrated."

Oh. Oh dear. I mean, I had a feeling that Poppy was going to accept Ann’s offer given that we were less than half of the way through the story, but there is no way that this is going to end well.
:uhhh:


Sorry, this is the only way I can communicate without that avatar. As for your frustration... Hm. Don't be too discouraged. I was expecting this to be challenging, since it's the first time I ever tried it. Tell you what, why don't we take a break and continue our journey west?

I mean, you’ll only be dismissed as crazy if you talk too openly about the voice in your head, but considering those vibes Ann was giving off, maybe her staying safely in your thoughts isn’t a bad thing.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Poppy stood and wandered out from under the overhang. The mountains were too steep for her to see very far—while "claustrophobic" would have been a strong word, Poppy would have preferred a more open setting. It was easier to read the landscape that way.

"I'm getting curious as to where exactly you're leading me. You've been very tight-lipped about it."

Which is usually a really terrible sign when dealing with beings of great power who need others to channel them. But I think it’s a bit late to do take-backsies here, Poppy. ^^;

I don't want to ruin the surprise, Poppy. I know you'll like it, just bear with me for a little longer. Tell you what, if we keep going the rest of the day, we should be able to make it there before sundown. How about we do that?

796822964019527760.png


Okay, Ann.

"Alright. I've been getting tired of all this practice we've been doing, anyway." She turned her head. "Lavender, are you good to—"

There was nothing but empty space and ghost-white lichen between Poppy and the rocks. She scoffed at herself before proceeding.

… Oh, so part of her still misses Lavender in spite of everything that’s happened. I… can already tell that that’s going to go to some really unhappy places given that one of the things that Ann promised Poppy was a chance to get revenge on the guild. ._.;

The terraces along the mountainside were wide and lush with vegetation that seemed to mimic early successional forest habitat. Brambly blackberries and gooseberries sprawled over a carpet of thyme and geranium, and demure little peach and pear trees thrived wherever they found a solid foothold between the rocks and shrubs. Further inspection revealed a number of narrow footpaths that wound through the landscape like rhizomes, in some places overgrown.

Poppy felt a twinge of nostalgia. She noticed movement near the bottom of the valley and squinted. Was it the valley's caretakers?

Oh. So it reminds her of her little plot before the guild took it over and bulldozed it. Some lovely imagery here, though the comparison’s a bit sad. I assume that’s very much the point, though.

Here it is! Ann announced. Go on down and say hi! No need to be shy!

As Poppy made her way down, she began to recognize the specks below. Their coloration—white, green, and red—seemed ornamental to her somehow, an impression which may have been helped by their whimsical patterns of flight. The way they darted about the air reminded her of schools of fish.

From time to time, the shaymin would turn their heads to look at Poppy, but it was not until she was near the bottom of the valley that a small group broke off and approached her.

Wow. Here I was expecting that it’d just be some normal Grass-types, but Shaymin are definitely the types to leave an awe-inspiring first impression when you meet them. Especially multiples of them.

"Hello?" the one toward the front said, maintaining a cautious distance. "You don't seem like the wild type... Can you understand me?"

Poppy blinked. "Um, yes, I can." She paused awkwardly for a moment, realizing that by now she had seen two—maybe even three, depending on whether or not Ann counted—so-called legendary pokemon species in the same month.

Poppy: “I get the feeling that I should be taken aback right about now, but this is admittedly kinda getting a bit old hat for me.”
720106605982646283.png

Shaymin: “... We’ll just take that as a ‘yes’ there.”

The shaymin who had addressed Poppy opened his eyes wide. "Wow, cool! I'll have to tell the others—just give me a sec!"

He flew away, leaving one of the other shaymin to scratch her head. Her voice was clear and confident, with a subtle lilt. "Silly boy—he didn't even remember to introduce himself." She bowed her head toward Poppy. "My name is Holly, and I hope you are doing well. Is there anything you need?"

Somehow I didn’t pick up on the first Shaymin being a Skymin. Maybe it’d have merited repeating the bit about them flying or describing the greeting Shaymin’s appearance a bit more, since at first, my assumption was that he was in hedgehog form while talking to Poppy.

"No, I should mostly be alright..." She checked her pouch. "Maybe a little water, though."

Holly nodded. "We'll show you the stream nearby—you'll be able to drink your fill there. Anyway, what brings you here? We don't get many visitors."

Poppy was unsure how to answer the question. "I've just been... Wandering around, mostly. Trying to... figure out my life, I guess."

Uh… yeah, even if saying ‘a voice in my head led me here’ wouldn’t make these guys think you’re crazy, I get the feeling that they wouldn’t react well to finding out about Ann.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Holly chuckled. "Trying to figure out your life? What is that supposed to mean?"

Before Poppy could come up with a response, the rest of the shaymin—perhaps a dozen, all told—surrounded her like bees that had discovered a new flower. "What kind of pokemon are you?" one asked. "I mean, she has to be grass," another said. "But I don't know the species. How'd you find us? Was it an accident?"

[ ]


Holly addressed the other shaymin. "Slow down a little, guys... Let's not overwhelm her." She turned toward Poppy. "First thing's first, stranger—why don't you tell us your name?"

Part of me is wondering if it’d have made sense to stop and drop in a paragraph of Poppy squirming and starting to get overwhelmed by the attention like that. Like what’s there works, but it does feel like there wasn’t a whole lot of time for a reaction to suddenly being crowded by a dozen Shaymin to sink in.

"It's Poppy, and I'm pleased to meet you all. I saw the, um, gardens? I'm very impressed with what you've all done with the place, and I commend you for it."

A number of the shaymin smiled. "Aw, shucks," Holly said. "You're gonna make me blush. We just have a knack for livening things up, is all."

I get the feeling that Holly meant that in a more literal fashion than Poppy would initially assume there. Especially given the sorts of antics Xerneas is pulling on this same rock.

"Well, all the same... Anyway, um, how long have you all been living here?"

Holly laughed. "Who knows? You might as well ask me how old the planet is. None of us can say for sure."

… I didn’t peg these guys as a bunch of old geezers, but I guess that’d be par for the course for Legendary Pokémon that are framed as divinities.

Poppy was taken aback. "Oh... But you can fly, can't you all? You don't move around at all?"

"Ah, well, we venture out from time to time, if that's what you mean, but this has been our home for generations. We have everything we need here."

"I see."

Ask them if they'll let you stay for a while! urged Ann.

578077337728450560.png


Everything about this totally not suspicious voice in Poppy’s head encouraging her to hang around these cute little grass hedgehogs has me really skeptical about how much longer their bucolic little Eden is going to last.

"Um," Poppy began, "I've been traveling for a couple weeks, and I don't really have a proper home... Would it bother y—"

Holly gave a shushing gesture. "Say no more, Poppy! It's been a long time since we've had a chance to practice our hospitality. You can stay with us for as long as you want!" She turned to the rest of the shaymin. "I mean, tell me if you guys have any objections, but otherwise let's go ahead."

The other shaymin assented.

Er… yeah, clearly these guys aren’t used to getting burned by their guests given that they didn’t make any attempts at even token background checking. ^^;

"Excellent. Why don't I show you around a little, then, starting with the stream?"

Poppy was taken aback momentarily by Holly's openness. "Um, alright then. That sounds good. Lead the way."

I mean I’m a little taken aback too. And I’m wondering just how soon this is going to backfire on Holly, since… yeah. That seems to be where the story is very strongly hinting things are going, especially in light of the summary.

Poppy may as well have been trying to catch a speck of dust; no matter how she lashed her vines, Holly would twist her body and flit out of the way, summoning speed as though controlling the wind itself.

Poppy paused for a moment and thought. She was tiring herself out more than Holly at this rate, but she didn't know what else to do. Projectiles hadn't fared her any better so far. She tried to recall if she knew anything good for flying-types—

:uhhh:


Poppy, what did you do?

Then the wind changed, carrying the scent of violets to her nose, and at once she envisioned the glade in which she and Lavender used to train. Oyster-shaped mushrooms fed on the sprawling roots of a fallen oak; moths and butterflies fluttered between scattered wildflowers; grasshoppers and katydids hid in the tall mugwort at the fringes, dappled by shade.

Come on, Poppy, Lavender had once chided. If I can learn swift, I'm sure you can, too. Just give it a little more practice! Then Lavender had bumped shoulders with her, but in a gentle way that felt more like an affectionate pat than a shove. Her mane, warm from the summer sun, had brushed against Poppy's neck. The scents of dandelions and violets and vetch blended with Lavender's, forming something soft and richly sweet…

IMO, this paragraph is dense enough that you might want to hack it into two. Though Poppy’s reminiscing of Lavender really gives some
401083507872366598.png
vibes. Like it’s one of those things where it makes you want to scream back at the text to “go back to her and try and work things out”, even if instinctively you just know that there’s zero reason to expect that’ll happen without something going horribly wrong at some point.

"Something on your mind?"

Poppy looked back up at Holly, who was hovering stock-still in the air as though suspended by strings. "Sorry," she said. "I realize the middle of a sparring match isn't the best time to get contemplative. Still, I've got an idea—something that might work."

Oh. Thank goodness, Poppy didn’t get on Holly’s bad side already. I was getting worried there for a second.
401791663531491330.png


"Ooh, that sounds exciting. Feel free to give it a try." She winked.

"Heh."

Poppy tried a few more times to strike Holly with her vines, and then once she felt ready, she opened her mouth and launched a stream of glowing stars toward her target. She noted the surprise on Holly's face with some satisfaction; the shaymin slipped past the first few projectiles in the group, but a stray star caught her a moment later.

"Ah!" Holly corkscrewed theatrically toward the ground. She landed on her back and stretched a paw feebly toward the sky. "I have been defeated," she proclaimed, then let herself go limp.

Poppy: “... Wait, did I actually defeat you, or are you just rolling over on me?”
:what:

Holly: “Are you implying there’s a difference?”
720106605982646283.png


Poppy walked toward Holly, smiling. "I see. The proud legacy of Poppy the Explorer shall be passed down through the generations, and legends will tell of the day she slew the great and powerful Holly."

Holly chuckled. "You really were an explorer, you said. You don't talk about it much, though."

[ ]


"No. I've never been much good at telling stories. And there are some memories I would rather not bring up."

"Mm hm. And I'm guessing that has to do with why you don't explore anymore."

Given that Poppy’s mind would really obviously be going towards Lavender in response to Holly’s question, part of me wonders if this sequence would’ve had more punch if you stopped and described some sort of reaction from Poppy’s part there.

"And you would be right." Poppy looked around at the wide buildings nearby, places where the shaymin took shelter from storms and spent cold nights. Even if those buildings lacked foundations, the way the rocks in the walls fit together like puzzle pieces suggested an impressive level of craftsmanship, and Poppy knew firsthand that they were as warm as anything with a dozen shaymin packed inside. "But really, why would I want to go back now? This place is far better than that dumb city ever was."

"I don't know what a city is, Poppy."

Poppy: “... Honestly, considering everything this story has described about its environment and overall culture there, that’s probably for the best.” ^^;

"Nor do you need to." Now that she was close to Holly, Poppy looked her over. "Anyway, I'm guessing that attack didn't hit too hard, did it?"

Heh, I see that I wasn’t far off from the mark there.

"Mm..." Holly shrugged. "Might leave a bruise, but it shouldn't be too bad."

"I see. Here, I'll put some pressure on the spot..." Poppy placed her paw just in front of Holly's shoulder. "It was about there, right?"

"Ah, yes, you've got it." She smiled and put her own paw over Poppy's. "Your paw is so big, Poppy, he he. I feel very taken-care-of."

… Wait, did Poppy just use Ann’s same healing trick on her own there?

"Well, Lavender always used to do this for me whenever I..." Poppy sighed and looked up at the sky. "There I go again..."

"Hm... You know, it might make you feel a little better if you talked about the things that are bothering you. I'm all ears."

I mean, yeah, that probably would be a bit healthier for you than bottling things up like this, Poppy, but…

Poppy smirked despite herself as she stroked the velvety fur of Holly's ear. "Did you mean that literally?"

Holly narrowed her eyes. "Do you mean to mock me, ground-dweller?"

Holly: “Also, you were very obviously dodging my suggestion there.” >:|

Poppy's smirk became a proper smile. "No, I would never do that, Holly," she said in her sweetest voice. "Your ears are lovely."

Holly raised an eyebrow. "Mm hm. You'd better mean that, too." She yawned. "So, for the time being... all that sparring's got me kind of hungry, so what do you say we get some fruit?"

Ah yes, the “dinnertime” excuse for dodging uncomfortable topics of conversation. Though hey, if it works, it works.

"That sounds good to me. You think your shoulder's good?"

"Oh, I don't know..." Holly put a paw to her brow as though she felt faint. "I might need you to carry me for a while, Poppy."

Poppy rolled her eyes and took her paw off Holly, who sprang effortlessly back to her feet.

"I bet I could have got you to do it if I'd tried," Holly teased.

"I bet you could."

D’aww, these two make a cute pair. I mean, I still am not convinced that this isn’t going to somehow end horribly in like a chapter or two. But hey, they’re being cute now.

The two of them made their way across the valley floor, careful not to trample the aster and gracidea that freckled it. The damp soil squelched beneath their paws. They said hello to the other shaymin as they reached the terraces and ascended the overgrown paths, squinting against the sun.

It was no surprise, but the blackberries here were some of the best Poppy had ever tasted. Already her nose was scratched up from when she had tried to eat too fast and got careless around the thorns, but she was ready to dive back in nonetheless.

… Rats, now I’m hungry for blackberries. Though lovely description there. It really sells the sense of a “bucolic village” quite well.

However, before Poppy could begin eating, her eyes were drawn to a rustle in the grass beside her—normally an animal wouldn't let her get that close. She carefully lifted a branch and revealed a patch of mangy, dust-colored fur.

The squirrel looked at Poppy as though half-asleep, its eyes glassy and half-closed. Its labored breaths reminded Poppy of the time when she had tried to leave the city on a smoggy day and instead wound up sprawled on the floor of the local library while she waited for her head to stop spinning. It felt like wearing an overtightened vest, she remembered.

Yeesh, just how bad is the air in the city? I’m pretty sure that smog that can do that is literally going to make some ‘mons keel over like the pea soup fogs of historical London.

"You find something?" Holly followed Poppy's gaze, then frowned. "Ah, I see. He's not doing so well, is he?"

"Shall I euthanize it?"

"Poppy!" Holly bumped her companion with her shoulder. "I don't know how you explorers handle things, but we valley folk don't just kill someone once they get sick. We're going to care for it."

Poppy shook her head. "Sorry, just... wasn't thinking. I never had time to consider taking care of an animal before." She also didn't think this particular one had much chance of survival, but she kept that to herself.

… That was Poppy’s own thoughts there… right?
:fearfullaugh~1:


Since that… admittedly didn’t sound at all like something I’d have expected Poppy to have suggested based off her past interactions.

"Hm," Holly said, her voice softening somewhat. "I suppose an explorer would be busy. But we've got time, Poppy. It'll be fine. In fact, I'm pretty sure someone made a pen for the last animal we took in—it should still be around. Come on, let's check."

Poppy picked up the squirrel as gently as she could with her vines and followed Holly downhill. Even though she was no longer part of the guild, it felt a little like a rescue mission.

Aww, how cute-

The squirrel died. Despite Holly's insistence on taking it in, she accepted the outcome calmly. Poppy and Holly dropped the body off away from the village and resumed their usual routine—for Poppy, that meant training with Ann for as long as she could stand before indulging in the shaymins' company. The squirrel soon became a distant memory—a pointless diversion, in retrospect. Poppy had yet to realize what its illness signified.

916590486356131850.png


Wow, and I thought Chapter 5 ended on an ominous note. That certainly is a terrible omen for the future.

Alright, onto the customary postmortem that I like to do:

The world you’ve built for this setting is top notch like always. For the stuff that you do describe, it all feels very alive and vivid. Like the descriptions of the different hinterlands that Poppy goes through all feel idyllic and almost edenic, which is something that I don’t think that I’ve seen too many other stories pull off for the likes of clearings that would be described in much blander terms. The aftereffects that this setting’s civilization have been leaving behind are also particularly memorable, both in stuff like description of the city’s smog and the particularly wince-worthy sequence where we see Poppy’s land getting bulldozed, but it also reflects in things like the mindset of characters who are in tight orbit around civilization. Like how Lavender’s immediate thought after hearing about a potential mystical source of power being how to use it to do things like making lights that will never go dim. It sells a strong sense of this civilization getting detached from reality and even when well-intentioned, repeating the follies of the past.

Really, my main complaint that I do have is that I wish you were a bit more generous about description in some parts of these chapters. Bits that currently feel like they’re on speedrun mode that IMO would have benefitted from stopping to sniff the proverbial flowers with description, since hey, every single chapter in this block was less than 2500 words long. If you did feel like going back to add a bit more description in parts, you’d certainly have the space to do so.

Once again, great work on the story thus far @love , even if part of me is waiting for the other shoe to drop. Since if there’s one thing that I could consistently pick up from these chapters, it’s that you’ve very effectively sold a sense that something is about to go very seriously wrong. And I’m at once dreading and eagerly awaiting to find out what will happen next.
 

Spiteful Murkrow

Busy Writing Stories I Want to Read
Pronouns
He/Him/His
Partners
  1. nidoran-f
  2. druddigon
  3. swellow
  4. lugia
  5. quilava-fobbie
  6. sneasel-kate
  7. heliolisk-fobbie
Heya, back with a fresh review for this thing, since I’ve kinda gotten hooked from past reads and want to see where this thing winds up shaking out. This time I’ll be tackling a duo of chapters, since hey, they add up to about 5000 words, and that’s a nice and digestible read for a worknight.

Alright, onto the real show:

Chapter 7

The river was a sickly, pus-like yellow, and in some places dead fish had begun to pile up against the rocks. Poppy clenched her teeth. She wanted to look away, but something wouldn't let her.

424925435651031049.webp


Well that’s certainly a vivid paragraph of opening description there. Though is this in the Shaymin’s village? Or…?

"You ready to go?"

Poppy turned toward Holly, who was shouldering her bag. The shaymin looked fine as far as Poppy could tell, and Poppy gave silent thanks that she hadn't used her water pouch since she had first filled it up at the shaymins' village. Its contents were the only reason that she could keep anyone healthy enough to stay with her on this journey.

Oh, so they aren’t in the Shaymin village. That’s a relief. Maybe. Since I’m admittedly not sure where the lot of them are right now in this case.

"Yes," Poppy said. "How have you been holding up?"

"I'm fine." Holly drew closer. "I know I'm not an explorer, but I can get around alright. I think you can relax a little."

578077337728450560.png


Have Holly and the other hedgehogs even experienced conditions like these? Since from the way that their village was described last chapter, I’m… doubtful that they had, or that Holly’s being fully honest here.

"Sorry. I know you could probably travel faster without me. It's just, if anything happened and I wasn't there to help, I'd feel kind of responsible." Poppy looked up to the cloudy sky. "And I have a feeling the pokemon responsible for the pollution are going to... present some problems."

… Not sure if I like where that tone of Poppy’s is going there, since that’s certainly a new tone towards pollution-causing Pokémon.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Guess getting your land stolen (and indwelt by Ann, of course) is bound to shake up your perspective a bit.

Holly nodded. "Don't get me wrong Poppy—I'm glad you're with me. I'm impressed with how strong you've become. I don't know quite how you did it, but it makes me feel a lot safer."

>implying that’s her that became strong-

"I just made a deal with the god of the underworld, is all," Poppy said, only half-jokingly.

Yeah, that. Though I guess that’s confirmation that ‘Ann’ is Yveltal, huh?
:uhhh:


The duo continued their journey, following the river uphill. Poppy leaped over boulders, scrambled up slopes, and bolted across plateaus so quickly that Holly frequently had to take flight to keep up with her. And all the while Poppy never felt the slightest hint of exhaustion—evidently her training with Ann had yielded better results than she'd realized. Speaking of which...

Have you reconsidered just teleporting us? Poppy asked Ann.

Wait a minute, Ann can do that? I mean, I always got strong “Yveltal” vibes from her, especially with the way she sucks out life to restore it to another, though I’m not sure how I’d square that one away. Unless if Cutscene Teleportation is a thing like it is with a huge swath of Legendaries in canon PMD.

At this point it would probably work, but like I said, if I turned out to be wrong about that, you would end up dead. It's not worth it at this point—you're almost there anyways. In fact...

A distant boom, like thunder, reverberated across the mountainside. Holly froze for a moment, but Poppy changed direction right away to head toward the sound. "That must be them!"

Ohhh boy, time to see where this is going in short order.

The terraces at the bottom of the pit were as long and wide as roads, and about as colorful. Poppy had never seen so much bare stone and dirt in her life. All around, a number of pokemon—largely ground types—were busy chipping away at whatever soft spots remained, some with implements, some with claws.

Another boom rang out as a claydol exploded on the other side of the pit, spewing dust into the air. Holly flinched, and when Poppy turned toward her her face was tensed up in something like a grimace.

"This is it," Poppy said. "Remember what I told you? This is a mine. It's doubtless the cause of the pollution." She proceeded. "Stay close to me."

Are- Are we about to see Holly pull a redux of that one moment of S5E3 of Rick and Morty? Like I know that these ‘mons are causing some side effects, but I get the feeling that things are about to go in a really uncomfortable direction in short order.
:uhhh:


It felt surreal, walking through the pit. As Poppy lost sight of the shrubs and trees behind her, she felt like she was setting foot on another planet. But there was something familiar about the perfunctory manner in which the workers regarded her—for a moment, Poppy felt like she was out on the city streets again.

It was easy enough to find the overseer—Poppy just had to look for pokemon that weren't doing any work. One sandslash looked particularly clean, so she approached it and interrupted its conversation with a tired-looking excadrill.

"Excuse me."

Uhhh… yeah, you probably want to be running away really fast right about now, Mr. Overseer. ^^;

Both ground-types looked surprised when they noticed Poppy, and then even more surprised when they noticed Holly behind her.

"Can I help you?" the sandslash asked, its voice more professional than its appearance would suggest.

"Yes. We come from a village downstream. The acid mine drainage from this pit has poisoned our water, so we would like you all to stop." The sandslash seemed a little incredulous, so Poppy had to repeat herself a couple times.

… Oh. I didn’t peg them as having been that close to the village from last chapter. That’s certainly a mood, and it certainly puts that dying squirrel from last time into perspective.
:uhhh:


Holly: “Uh… Poppy? I think he heard you the first time.”
Poppy: “Well he hasn’t been showing it by giving a response.” >:|

The sandslash scratched his head. "Okay. Well, I don't know how much you know about remediation, but even if we stopped working today, the acid mine drainage won't just go away. I don't know exactly what plans we have once we're done with this site—that's up to the company. I'll certainly bring this up with the powers that be, and in the meantime maybe we can provide you with some clean water... How far away is this village, exactly?"

"A few days—well, for you, probably more than a week. But either way, we insist you all stop mining right away. Shaymin"—she gestured toward Holly—"are more skilled remediators than any of you. If you provide our village with clean water for a few months and let us get our strength back up, we'll get the job done."

Sandslash: “... Hon, you do realize that this is our livelihood, right?”
Poppy: “Yes. Your livelihood which is poisoning our village.” >:|

"Hold on." Holly stepped forward. "If they're saying they'll supply us anyway, then wouldn't it be okay to let them finish what they're up to first?"

Poppy addressed her companion. "I'd rather not give them the chance to make things any worse. We haven't been able to keep up with their pollution so far, so we need to address it at the source; otherwise we're putting ourselves at their mercy. And it's not like they're stupid. They knew they'd be killing anything downstream when they did this." She turned to the sandslash and locked eyes with him. "Have I made myself clear? I need you to stop all this right away.”

… Oh boy, we really are going to see Poppy pull a take off that one moment of S5E3 of Rick and Morty, aren’t we?
:fearfullaugh~1:


The sandslash grimaced. "Dear, if I did that, I could be fired. I want to work with you, but we need to go through the proper channels—"

"Then get someone to do that and stop in the meantime. Tell the 'higher-ups' whatever you have to. Say we threatened you. I don't care. I won't give you the chance to stall this out."

Holly: “Uh. Poppy, I just want to point out that I was willing to take the water for the village. And whatever the damage they did, we really could restore it-” ._.;
Poppy: “Oi, I’m not just going to let them kill all the forest between here and the village for the sake of a daily wage!”
826550123924029450.png


The sandslash took a deep breath. "I'm being as fair as I can possibly be. If I tell everyone to stop working, that would be thousands of work hours wasted while we wait for a messenger. There's no way we could have known pokemon were living down there, so—"

"Of course there are pokemon living downstream," Poppy growled. "There's feral pokemon living everywhere." Her hackles raised, and her heart began to race. She had hoped to never feel this way again...

But this time it could be different. This time there was no Lavender to stop her.

Holly: “Uh… Poppy? You’re kinda scaring me right now.”
:uhhh:


Poppy turned to Holly. "Get away from here," she ordered.

"What? But Poppy, this concerns me as much as—"

"Then watch from above. I just need you to stay out of danger."

:uhhh:


Well, that’s a sign that things are going to get really dark really fast if I ever saw one.

Holly: “Poppy, what are you going to do?! You’re really worrying me right now!” O_O;
Poppy: “I’m going to make it so that way you, no your village, will never need to worry again.”

Holly looked like she wanted to say something, but she obeyed, ascending like a leaf caught in the wind.

"What's this about?" The sandslash asked as he narrowed his eyes and ever-so-slightly widened his stance.

Poppy turned toward him. "I understand your position. I used to be a city dweller. Worked for the guild. Didn't have to take orders often, but when I did, I hated it."

I… didn’t think much of those tendencies back in those earlier scenes, but looking back at it… uh… yeah. They suddenly read much harsher in hindsight.
663472557499875330.png


"Where are you going with—"

A flash of green from Poppy's vine, and the sandslash was on the ground. "Maybe your superiors will be more sympathetic if you come back with scars? Regardless, you need to understand you're not in a position to negotiate."

Well this scene is going places already. I’m holding out a few reeds of hope that things can come to a relatively peaceful resolution, though I’m fully expecting everything here to go down in a fashion that’s going to scar Holly for the rest of her life.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Holly: “Poppy, what are you-?!” O_O;
Poppy: “I know what I’m doing, Holly! Just stay up there!

In an unexpected act of courage, the excadrill charged Poppy, but she downed it just as easily. It called feebly for help as it struggled back to its feet.

Whether or not they had actually heard the excadrill, the pokemon around the mine were taking notice of Poppy; she watched as they rallied each other, and before long a few groups rushed down to confront her. Poppy swatted her new attackers away like balloons. Weight didn't matter; golem were sent flying as easily as gible. Poppy's biggest challenge was staying on-balance with each impact.

Wow. Ann’s power really is quite something there. Though at least she’s not painting the mine red… yet, anyways.

"Get back, everyone!"

A loud, rumbly voice; Poppy looked above just as the flygon spewed a torrent of flames from its mouth. It put a lot into the attack; for a good few seconds, Poppy was enveloped in blinding scarlet. As soon as the onslaught was over, she reached out to grab the flygon and slammed it so hard into the ground that she could feel the shockwave under her paws. Since it could fly, she wanted to make sure it wouldn't get the chance to chase after Holly.

The pokemon surrounding Poppy flinched and backed up as the dust from the impact settled. A few lycanroc and diggersby stared at her disbelievingly, probably looking for burns that didn't exist. Poppy stepped forward to attack again, but stopped herself.

Wait, is that Ann regenerating her wounds? If so, where’s she drawing the life to make that happen from? Since I saw what happened with the grass when she healed Poppy’s shoulder originally in Chapter 5 and all of that surely required a lot more life juju to pull off. .-.

"You can't hurt me. I'll keep fighting until none of you can get back up. Or"—She scanned the crowd and made eye contact with every pokemon she saw—"or you can all go home right now and never return. That's all I want."

Poppy waited patiently while the workers mumbled to one another. It took a while for the first pokemon—a scrawny-looking marowak—to walk away, but soon after the others followed suit. As though inspired. Poppy looked up and was relieved to see Holly still there, though her teeth were bared in a grimace as she watched the workers disperse. When she caught Poppy's eye, she gave her a concerned, almost pleading look.

… Okay, maybe Poppy did paint the mine red with that sort of reaction. Since if she got her shoulder torn open from a nick from a Scyther a couple chapters, that ground slam had to have left a mark on that Flygon earlier.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Poppy's heart was racing, but this time she didn't mind it. She gave Holly a reassuring smile, which quickly turned into a grin.

I… don’t think that was what Holly was worried about there, Poppy. ^^;

Poppy's exhilaration still hadn't worn off yet, and it was all she could do to refrain from running ahead.

Holly was noticeably more sober. "I don't know if I like the way we handled that," she said, not making eye contact. She shifted the pouch around her shoulder, now stuffed with canned water.

"Listen, I know how those kinds of pokemon think," Poppy assured her. "I could have talked to that sandslash until I was blue in the face and it wouldn't have made a difference. Anyway, you deserve to have the same clean river you've had for however many generations. The fact that we even have to try to justify that to someone is degrading."

Poppy, you do realize that this is literally just the mirror image of what your guildmaster was getting ready to do to those forest tribals, right? Like you didn’t even try to come to a middle ground there.

"Well, degrading or not..." Holly frowned. "They seemed willing to compromise. Are you really sure we couldn't have trusted them?"

"Never mind that; what difference does it make? Why take that chance to start with? They're the ones who need to appease us, not the other way around. This isn't a matter of life and death for them."

I mean, for all you know that mining company is a state-owned entity or else was pursuing a strategic interest on behalf of someone with an army. And… yeah, I don’t think you want one of those cruising through the neighborhood out for your blood.

Also, throwing hundreds of Pokémon out of employment in a setting where for all we know there is no social security net and no alternative jobs for them to take… can get into "matter of life and death" territory pretty quickly. ^^;

"Hm." Holly was silent for a while. "I'll have to think about this some more."

"That's fine. Anyway, we'll need to head back there soon. We need to bring as much clean water back to the village as possible so the others can get their strength back. Then we need to bring as many shaymin as we can up to the mine. The most important thing is covering up all that exposed rock. Then we'll have to restore the vegetation so the topsoil stays in place..."

Ah yes, I see Poppy’s inner land reclaimer is still kicking around alive and well in her. Though Shaymin do seem like the type to have a leg up on cleaning up the nasty side effects of a (forcibly) retired mine.

Holly's expression was distant as the clouds cast fitful shadows across her face.

"Hey, Holly." Poppy leaned in a little. "Keep your chin up, eh? We'll get it done. Soon this will all just be a distant memory."

Holly nodded solemnly. "I hope so. Thank you, Poppy."

796822964019527760.png


Yeah, I don’t believe that for a second there. And surely you wouldn’t believe it either if you stopped to think things through, Poppy.

Soft green light glimmered from behind Poppy, intensifying the hues of the foliage around her. She glanced back at the shaymin once more, in time to see a brand new tree rise from the ground and weave its roots through the soil. The shaymin responsible exhaled as the light died down, then he headed over to the foot of the terrace to rest with the others.

The villagers had put in a good effort, Poppy thought. By now the outside of the pit was encircled with shrubs and conifers, some of which's seeds had been carried over from the village. The plants splayed their lush leaves as though with pride. It particularly satisfied Poppy to see edibles growing here now, nourishing food in a place that had once been so barren.

Poppy: “Ah yes, I love happy endings.” ;<;
Holly: “Poppy, you realize there’s another 6 chapters after this one, right?”
Poppy: “Wait, wha-? We have to get through those?”

But, Poppy reminded herself, now was not the time to celebrate. She returned her gaze to the horizon and scanned for any sign of movement. Nothing but birds, so far as she could tell. She started to circle the pit, a now-routine activity. She wasn't sure it was necessary to keep watch, given that she had Ann's help, but she couldn't do much to contribute to the restoration, and she liked to think her patrols helped the shaymin feel safer.

Well, that’s certainly presumptuous if I ever heard it. You’d think you’d actually ask the Shaymin if they felt safer from your help instead of just assuming.

Mm, interesting, said Ann.

What is it?

Looks like those jokers have got themselves a new scheme. There'll be a shaymin coming from the southeast who's actually a zoroark. Guess they realized brute force wasn't working and decided to try infiltration.

… How on earth does Ann know this? .-.

Poppy snorted. How far is this one?

Maybe five miles still. You want to head him off?

No, I don't want to get drawn away from the group. Let me know once he's close enough to see.

Very well.

Why do I get a good feeling that it’s a very good thing that Holly and the Shaymin couldn’t hear any of that and that they’d be extremely worried if they were cognizant of Ann, her powers, and this little convo?

Also, I kinda wonder if it would’ve made sense to break up this internal back and forth with at least one block of description for variety, something like Poppy looking off at the treeline warily or something like that.

The wait was a little awkward, but by now Poppy was confident she could trust Ann. Thanks for keeping an eye out, she said in the meantime.

de7.png


Yes, well, I suppose it has become necessary, Ann said tiredly. If you ask me, I'd say things were complicated enough for us before all this mining nonsense started. Anything I can do to help us get through it... Ann sighed. By the way, the zoroark is close, but he seems to have spotted you. He's going northeast to try and circle around. If you look a little to the left, you should be able to see him.

Poppy squinted and looked out to the horizon. She saw some far off movement but couldn't tell what it was. Is that him?

Yep. Good eye you got, there.

Mm hmm. Well, now that he's seen me, I think it's time to say hi.

Oh yes, this won’t get creepy and concerning at all considering how Poppy chasing everyone off from the mine went down.

Poppy stepped down from her perch and trotted toward her quarry. It took a while to get near him, but he wasn't running away. Perhaps he knew it was futile, or he was just that confident in his disguise.

… Poppy, you’re scaring me there.

As Poppy drew closer, she could make out the "shaymin"'s features. The tufted ears, the scarf-like flower petals, the socks with rounded edges. The fact that it looked so convincing only enhanced Poppy's disgust.

Huh. Wonder what this guy had to do to get a visual reference to pull this off.

"Drop the charade," Poppy demanded. "Lest I make you."

The "shaymin" shimmered like a mirage and turned tail to run even before it had finished reverting to its true form.

Poppy leaped after her prey, and the ground below became a blur. She came within striking distance just seconds later and lassoed her vines around the zoroark before she had even touched the ground. She saw the shock on his face for a moment, but before she could celebrate her success, her front paw caught on a rock, and she tumbled head over tail. She watched the sky and ground trade places a few times, making sure to keep her grip on the zoroark throughout it all. Eventually she rolled to a stop and stood up, slightly dizzied but no worse for wear.

Though wait a minute, how good is Ann’s sense of perception anyways? Since she spotted this Zoroark, but I’m wondering if it’s actually possible to get anything past her.

I like the enthusiasm, said Ann with a giggle.

Hmph. Seems I have to work on my control.

Poppy lifted the zoroark and drew him toward her. His face was sheepish, and he struggled against his restraints seemingly more out of nervousness than any expectation that he might break free.

I mean, I’d be nervous too if I just resoundingly jobbed to a little fennec fox less than a quarter of my size and want to be just about anywhere other than next to said fennec fox.

He stopped struggling when Poppy struck him across the face. Blood streamed from his nose a moment later, and his expression darkened as he turned his head back toward her.

… Ouch. That doesn’t bode well for what happened to any of the others that Poppy fought off prior to this.

Poppy looked the zoroark in the eye. "Just what, exactly, were you trying to pull?"

The zoroark's voice was hoarse, as though he hadn't slept in days. "Don't take it personally, now—"

"I asked you a question."

Blood bubbled around the zoroark's nostrils as he took a breath. "My orders were to persuade you to leave this place alone. Obviously, just going right after you wasn't going to work..."

Poppy slammed her captive into the ground, and his gasp was like a sheaf of paper being torn in half. Poppy stepped on his chest and looked into his eyes, her nose almost touching his.

… Probably a good thing that Holly isn’t here to see this. ^^;

"Listen," she said. Her voice was soft, but she enunciated every word carefully. "I'm going to let you go, because I am a very merciful pokemon. But I see I have been too merciful. I need you to relay this to your employer: the next thug sent here will be swiftly killed. I'm done playing games. You understand?"

The zoroark nodded.

"Good. You're free to go."

A really good thing that Holly didn’t see this. Though I see Ann’s been taking Poppy down the slippery slope at alarming speed.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Poppy slowly retracted her vines, and the zoroark stood up and limped away. Poppy sighed.

"You must be frustrated."

Poppy started and turned toward her addresser. That look of concern might have seemed patronizing, had it come from anyone other than Holly.

… Oh, well never mind then about Holly being in the dark about what’s going on.

"How much of that did you overhear?" Poppy asked.

"Most of it." Holly looked away and batted her ear.

"I see. I guess those ears aren't just for show, after all." Poppy began to walk back to the pit, but she stopped when Holly spoke up again.

"Poppy... Do you really think it's right? To threaten them like that?"

Poppy: “... It’s not threatening if it’s a promise?”
720106605982646283.png

Holly: “Poppy, that’s literally the exact opposite of what you should be saying if you’re trying to reassure me here!” >_>;

"Yes. I might be powerful, but I'm not infallible. If I keep cutting them slack, then sooner or later they're going to outmaneuver me. And they won't hesitate to kill one of you if it gets them what they want. At least this way, I'm giving them a chance to back off before things go too far."

More like they’ll do something like torch the entire forest with something like a squadron of Salamence and then mine the smoldering ruins at this rate. You don’t want to get into an escalating game of chicken like this unless if you’re deadly certain you know what the other party is capable of and willing to do, Poppy. And sending ‘mons home dead is a fast way to keep this from just being a dispute with a private entity.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Holly sighed. "I wish it didn't have to be like this. Isn't there some way the rest of us could become stronger, like you? So you don't have to do everything?"

"I'm sorry, but no. My power comes from a finite source. It can't be shared."

Translation: Exactly none of this is sustainable for the long term.

Holly's eyes fell. "Then I guess that's that."

The two were silent as they walked back to the pit.

I have to wonder whether or not the thing that breaks this happy(?) equilibrium is ultimately going to be Poppy horrifying Holly and the others after they get a good look at what this power of hers actually is, or if the forest really is going to get nuked from orbit at this rate with how quickly and dramatically Poppy is raising the stakes for that mining company and anyone who has interests associated with it.

Since she was ahead of the group, Poppy paused to scan for any sign of movement. She didn't like how the breeze rustled the foliage below; it made it look like someone was trying to sneak up on her.

"Poppy," said one of the shaymin as he caught up to her, "I think we're alright. They haven't sent anyone else in weeks."

"I know, but it never hurts to be careful. I'll relax once we're all done with the restoration."

>implying you can relax after that with how much you’ve stirred the pot with that mining company

The shaymin nodded vigorously. "You'd better! You need a break after—"

A sharp cry rang out from behind them. Poppy whipped her head around in time to see a single image—a gallade holding Holly in his arms. Restraining her limbs. Her look of confusion and anger.

Wait, what? But how on earth did-?

Poppy instinctively struck for the gallade's head, but as soon as she did, his body broke up like a mirage—along with Holly's.

So that was their game.

Leafeon, if you want your friend back—

Poppy's response was simple, automatic. Is that what we've come to? Blackmail? You've made a mistake. Keep your hands off her if you want to live.

Poppy: “How on earth did you even manage this? Ann, how did you not see this coming?” >_>;
Ann: “... I needed a breather and wasn’t paying attention?”
720106605982646283.png


While the shaymin scrambled in all directions to see where Holly might have gone, Poppy stood still, in a sort of limbo. She tried to think about solutions, to keep her mind off the implications of what she had just said. Then her eyes went wide as revelation struck.

I’m… not sure if I follow what the revelation there was exactly. It might have been a bit more effective to spell things out a little more explicitly as to what Poppy realized.

Ann. Teleport me.

There was silence for a few moments. Ann? Ann?!

Sorry, Poppy, I had to look for him for a second. I could try to teleport you there, but are you sure? I'd say the odds it works are about—

I don't care, do it.

Again:

de7.png


Ann laughed—an unfittingly sonorous sound.

Which is as good a sign as any that this is a really, really bad idea here.
:uhhh:


What's so funny?

I'm just not used to being ordered around, is all. But fine. I'll comply. Just don't blame me if... Well, I guess you can't either way.

Oh yeah, this totally isn’t going to end terribly. Totally. Since everything about that manner of speaking just screams “Faustian bargain” there.

Poppy: “I feel as if I should be stopping and worrying about this a lot more right now, but Holly is going to die if we don’t do something. So yeah, chop chop.”

Poppy nodded. I am in your debt. She turned her attention to the shaymin around her, who had scattered about like leaves in a gust of wind as they searched for their friend. "Everyone!" she shouted. "I'm going to rescue Holly!" Her body started to glow white. "Stay together and wait here for me until I get back! Assume there will be more of them!"

As soon as that last word left Poppy's lips, she vanished.

… The mining company did this intentionally to bait her away and they’re going to do something like sack the village while she’s gone, aren’t they?

Poppy took in the scene around her as quickly as she could. Before her was a shadowy overhang—probably meant as a sort of hiding spot, but she didn't have time to think about that right now. Her eyes were drawn to a glimmer of jade-colored light just to her right.

It was Holly. She had freed herself from the gallade's grasp, and now her paws were spread in a fighting stance as she prepared an energy ball. Poppy's heart sank when she noticed the blood running down her flank, but she forced herself to disregard it and follow her gaze.

Oh, well that’s going to bode well for that Gallade’s life expectancy considering how Poppy was already mentally ready to outright kill the mining company’s operatives back when she ran into that Zoroark.
:uhhh:


A pale green smear—the gallade was charging. Poppy struck hard, and he was on the ground. She was taken aback—she didn't know if the crunch she heard was from grinding rocks or his bones.

701450038513238106.png


Whelp, I doubt we’ll ever see that guy again with that description.

Holly started and whipped her head toward Poppy. For a moment, before she recognized her savior, her eyes were wide and bright with terror.

"O-oh, Poppy! How did you get here? Where are the others?"

"The others are..."

About a ten minute flight south.

:uhhh:


Yeah, I’m starting to think that the Shaymin village really is going to get napalmed out of existence and this was all a giant feint.

"...About a ten minute flight south. You're not hurt too badly, are you?"

Holly checked her flank. "N-no, I don't think so."

"Good. You should head back now, if you're able—as long as you stick to the air, you should be safe."

youre_serious_futurama.gif


Again, why would you assume that when the mining company is this determined to get at their land, Poppy?

Holly moved as though to take off, but then she looked back. "Poppy..."

Poppy followed Holly's gaze to the gallade. His limbs were splayed out at strange angles, like a squashed bug, and though he breathed, he was too limp to be conscious.

… Yeah, I’ll really take the under on ever seeing this guy again.

"Don't worry about him," Poppy said.

But Holly hesitated. "Poppy, you said earlier... Are you really going to..."

"Am I really going to what?"

Holly grimaced. "To kill him."

Poppy: “I mean, if we turn around and leave like this, he’s most likely going to die anyways in this state, so killing him outright and more quickly would arguably be merciful?”
720106605982646283.png

Holly: “Poppy!” O.O
Poppy: “What, it was just an observation!”

Poppy took a deep breath, and a pit formed in her stomach as she spoke. I said I would, didn't I?" She glanced at the gallade once more. "What do you expect me to do with him? Apologize for the inconvenience and haul him all the way back home? Or were you thinking you'd rather let the wolves take care of him?"

Oh, so Poppy actually does make the argument ‘he’s gonna die like this anyways, so might as well’. Though uh… yeah, everything about this just screams ‘terrible idea’ right now.

"Poppy..." Holly's gaze fell, and her drooping ears framed her face. "There has to be a better way..."

Though her voice trembled, Poppy's resolve did not falter. "There is," she said, "and that would have been if they had gone and left us alone when they had the chance. Don't think for a second that this is our fault."

Holly: “Uh… I’d just like to point out that you were the one who kept violently escalating things with those mining Pokémon, Poppy.”
Poppy: “Well they could’ve taken the hint and stopped. It’s not my fault they kept going!”

Holly glanced up at Poppy's face for a moment. "It's not about whose fault it is. Do you think his life is worth less than ours?"

Poppy stepped toward Holly, who shrank before her gaze. "I don't think that, Holly. I know it. These miners risked lives to get their way—because they think they have to, or because they're greedy. They're below us in either case. They don't know how to live peacefully like we do, and I can't make them try."

Wow, she really has become the mirror image of that Purugly guildmaster who stole her land out from under her. Though I have to wonder how much of this is Poppy being influenced, and how much of this is just Poppy all along, just with her inhibitions removed from having been granted massive power.

[ ]

"...Okay." Holly's voice quivered as she stepped back. "If you feel that strongly, then I guess I can't convince you..." She turned away as the clouds cast shadows over her face. "I just hope both of us can sleep at night after this." Holly stood still for a long time, as though trying to think of something to say, but in the end she took off without any further remarks.

I kinda wonder if this scene would’ve been more effective had it stopped and dropped in some description showing Holly wavering a bit, but ultimately relenting and conceding Poppy’s point. Since something about the current delivery feels a bit rushed.

Poppy watched Holly fly until she was nothing more than a dot on the horizon. Only then did she realize her limbs were shaking. She stood up to pace around, hoping to relieve some tension, and as she turned she saw smog-shrouded silhouettes in the distance like a mass of shadow. Buildings. The sight made her feel strange, like visiting kindergarten as an adult.

He was close, Poppy thought with a shiver. A little bit farther, and he might have lost himself in the city...

Wait, who is the ‘he’ referring to? The Gallade? Or is this someone else from Poppy’s past on her mind, since I’m admittedly not sure if I can tell.

Poppy heard a groan and turned to look at the gallade. He was conscious now, unluckily. His breaths were sharp, pained.

:uhhh:


So much for a quick and quiet mercy kill.

"Guess I'd better get this over with," Poppy mumbled. "I'd ask your last words, but I doubt they're worth hearing."

Poppy closed her eyes and struck one last time; the sound was like stepping on wet twigs. She realized she wouldn't forget it for a long time. She turned away from the gallade—or rather, his two halves—as her body began to glow white.

916590486356131850.png


Oh yeah, this totally will be a one off fluke and everything will just go back to be happily ever after. There’s absolutely no way this could have any negative repercussions. None at all.

Chapter 8

Poppy's eyes traced the silver ridges of the clouds above. The sky never got this dark near the city, she remembered. It was like an ink painting.

You made the national news, you know, said Ann. Not headlines, quite, but at this rate it won't be long.


Poppy, what did you do?
:uhhh:


Was it that big of a company?

I think when a teleporting leafeon threatens the members of a steering committee, that's going to make a splash regardless of the company's size.


Ann chuckled. I almost think the absurdity of the story makes it more believable.

Uh… yeah, I kinda figured that that Gallade wouldn’t be the end of things. And this is the point where you now get state powers hunting after you, Poppy. Since… yeah, I highly doubt that Gallade was the last Pokémon you brutally murdered since the last chapter. ^^;

Hm.

Poppy frowned. Well, so long as they don't know who I am...

You worried about your reputation?

Just don't want the folks back at the guild finding out. Though they'll have cause enough to hate me soon, I suppose.

A bit late for that when you’re now national headlines, Poppy. Since everyone’s going to find out about you eventually.

Hm. Speaking of which... Well, there's good news and bad news on that front. The good news is that Xerneas hasn't acceded to the guild's demands to access the planet's energy. The bad news is that they're preparing to take it by force.

Oh yeah, that totally isn’t going to result in a boatload of dead and maimed Pokémon just attempting to do that. Not at all.

Though I suppose that’s a sign that Lavender in the end wasn’t able to keep her trap shut about that discovery she and Poppy made.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Poppy stifled her sigh so that she wouldn't wake the shaymin behind her. Of course they are. I should have never thought so highly of them.

I know, right? Anyway, here's the bottom line. We have a week until they make their move, maybe less. If we want to be effective guardians, we'll have to train as much as we can until then. Your recent actions should be enough to ensure that the shaymin remain unmolested, so I think it's safe to focus on improving our skills.

794.jpg


>implying you can train for anything effectively in a week

I mean, I get that Ann has godlike powers and is probably Yveltal at this rate, but still.

Are they really going to be that tough? I mean, I took down everyone that mining company sent after us.

Only because the mining company apparently doesn’t believe in “take off and nuke the site from orbit”. Since that would’ve likely given you some issues if there was anyone who could effectively play keepaway while raining death from above.

You should know as well as I do that the guild has access to a lot of talent. The pokemon you fought this week were strong, but they can't compare to the opposition you'll be facing alongside Xerneas. They're taking this seriously, Poppy. They think what they're doing will change the world—and they are, admittedly, correct.

Oh boy, so what is Poppy’s confirmed kill count at this point anyways?
:fearfullaugh~1:


Poppy shook her head. Ugh. That makes sense, but... I'll just say I can't wait for this to be over with.

>implying it’s ever going to end short of the world going through an apocalypse

I mean, that’s what happens with escalatory cycles of violence, Poppy. Once you start them, they’re very hard to stop after the fact.

Poppy heard footsteps and turned her head. She hadn't noticed Holly approaching her until she was less than a meter away.

"You look troubled," Holly said.

"I suppose that makes two."

Holly sat beside Poppy. "It's been a lot, this week." She exhaled. "I still haven't told anyone about... that gallade."

"It's best we forget about him. It's not like he would have cared if we died."

Holly: “Poppy, that doesn’t make this any better! Are you just going to be doing this with every Pokémon the mining company sends here?” >_>;
Poppy: “... They’re bound to run out of takers eventually?”
720106605982646283.png


"A part of me envies your pragmatism." She looked away and batted at her ear. "But still... I'm not proud of how things have gone. I'd have liked it if we came up with a solution that satisfied everyone."

Holly: “Especially since I’m pretty sure the current one’s going to come back to bite everyone in the ass at some point. It’s how stories like these usually work.” ^^:

"Sure. But that would have been up to them to figure out—and they weren't willing or able."

"I guess I'll trust your judgment on this. It is... your domain, in a sense." She sighed. "You know, if you lived with pokemon that were really that bad, I can see why you wouldn't want to talk about your past."

I mean, they weren’t all that bad. Though… uh… yeah, there were some pretty rotten Pokémon in civilization, and Poppy has gone full ‘accentuate the negative there’.

"Well. Some of them were worse than others. But that's neither here nor there."

"Fair enough."

Holly: “... Isn’t that all the more reason to err on the side of caution when dealing with the Pokémon that come here, Poppy?”
916590517268144138.webp

Poppy: “Holly, that Gallade was ready to kill you. There is exactly zero reason to think that any Pokémon dispatched here by the mining company is going to be one of the ‘less worse’ Pokémon.” >_>;

For a while it was silent, but for the whispers of the wind. It would probably rain tomorrow, Poppy thought. Just as well. She could train under shelter if she had to, since most of the work was mental.

"...So, your deal with the god of the underworld," Holly said. "How's that been going? He treating you well?"

Poppy smiled. "Why in fact, he is. Fine fellow, really. I'll have to introduce you to him sometime."

That… sounds like a really terrible idea for multiple reasons. Though I suppose that really is something tilting the identity of ‘Ann’ towards being Yveltal. ^^;

Holly smiled back. "Sounds good. Maybe we can all spar together."

"Yeah."

Okay, that’s an even worse idea there. ^^;

It was quiet again. Ordinarily Poppy wouldn't have minded that, but now she felt the need to say something.

"Thanks for taking me in. And remind me to tell everyone else the same. It's really made a difference."

Whether that difference has been a net positive or a net negative remains to be seen. Since I’m not convinced at all that your little war with the mining company that just made national headlines isn’t going to eventually blow back horribly in some fashion, Poppy.

"Don't mention it, Poppy. We're all glad to have you around. Especially now."

Poppy nodded. "I know it's difficult, but we should try to get back to sleep. I'm sure we'll get through this faster if we keep up our strength."

"If you insist, then; I'll get right to it." Holly curled up right there, pressing her back against Poppy. Poppy smiled and followed suit, resting her head on her companion's shoulder.

I mean she’s only killed and maimed a bunch of Pokémon at this point, but hey, Poppy does still have some flashes of cuteness left in her. Or at least for now.

The oppressive din of the rain drowned out all other sounds. Flecks of water tickled Poppy's paws from splattered drops. The ground was soaked even beneath the overhang.

Clear your mind, said Ann.

Poppy sighed. Look—

If you're talking, then your mind isn't clear enough. I'm not expecting anything, but you need to keep trying.

Poppy: “... How is this supposed to be effective training again?”

It's not that. It's just... I've been thinking about it. If we really wanted to screw the guild over, we could just teleport beneath their ships while they're sailing to the island and strike the hulls from underwater. Even the strongest pokemon are going to have a hard time crossing the ocean when the ship goes down.

Yes, that's clever. I was thinking we should do something like that as our first course of action.

But...
Poppy opened her eyes and watched sheets of rain slowly beat the soil into a turbid slurry. There will be healers on those ships, and innocents. I saved lives while I was in the guild. I protected pokemon. It was a pain sometimes, but I did a lot of good, and I knew it was the right thing. And I refuse to... to let a mass murder be the culmination of all those years of effort. She realized that her internal voice had become loud. She took a deep breath. So. Ever since my dealings with the miners, I've been thinking there might be another way to convince the guild that we mean business.

I mean, alternatively, you could just sink the ships while they’re in port. It sense a message, it gets around the little problem of ‘mass murder’ if you time your attack for when the ships aren’t packed with passengers, and if you can repeat the process a couple of times, you’d literally bankrupt the guild. If the first strike is big and effective enough, you could potentially do it on your first attempt.
720106605982646283.png


What would that be?

We've seen that it doesn't matter how many weaker pokemon I have to fight, or what type they are. Unless an opponent is near my level, they may as well not be there. And the most powerful pokemon at the guild, the ones who will lead this... crusade, they probably know that too. In other words, if I arrange to fight the guild's most powerful pokemon in a duel and win, I can prove that they don't have a chance. They would have to give up at that point. So...
Her voice grew hollow. I might have to kill one pokemon in the process. Fine. It's better than killing the rest of the guild, and the pokemon I've worked with and said hello to every day.

Translation: Poppy wants to blip to the guild, and act out her sick and twisted revenge fantasies on the Purugly Guildmaster in full view of everybody to send a message and hopefully scare everyone into submission instead of gunning after her to avenge him.

I mean, it’s definitely cathartic, but you might want to not write off the ship idea so fast as long as you can make a few tweaks to adjust for collateral. Especially since I’m pretty sure that this idea has decent odds of spiraling into ‘mass murder’ in its own right since I doubt the guild members are just going to take their Guildmaster getting ganked lying down. ^^;

Ann was silent for a while. When it spoke, its voice was grave. I think your logic is correct, Poppy; if I thought numerical advantages really mattered, I wouldn't have been so focused on you. However, this idea is very risky. I know you might be willing to play fair, but the guild—

But that's why I have you, isn't it? You're nearly omniscient. If they don't play ball, we'll know, and then we can try other tactics. But we may not need to. You'd be surprised at the guild's confidence in its elites.

Oh boy, I can already tell those ‘other tactics’ are going to be quite something.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Ann was silent again. At least take just the top five or six most powerful pokemon and kill them in their sleep before going through with that idea. That way you'll tilt the odds in your favor.

Ann, stop trying to channel Dagda from SMT4A, “Hey, kid. Kill your friends.” is weird and creepy even when you’re deeply estranged from said friends. ^^;

Whelp, so much for ‘avoiding mass murder’ there.
663472557499875330.png


I... Poppy frowned. How much more likely is it that I would win if I did that?

I couldn't give you an exact number.

Then I won't consider it.

...Ten percent.

What?

I said... Maybe ten percent. Could be fifteen. Based on who I think the best fighters are and what I've seen of their battles, that's the best guess I could give you.

Poppy: “Hold up, you expect me to kill six Pokémon for the sake of only modestly increasing my odds of being able to pull off a successful duel? Ann, what the hell?
:what:

Ann: “Bold of you to think that I was talking about a relative increase of your odds of success.”

And how would you place my odds at winning in general?

You're not going to like hearing this.

Well, say it anyway.

I'd give you about a fifty percent chance.

Ann: “See, the ten percent chance would matter, Poppy.”
Poppy: “... This isn’t some sort of gambit to get me to ask what a ‘hundred percent chance of success’ strategy would be, is it?”
Ann: “No, because such a thing doesn’t exist.

Poppy scoffed. Ann was right—in a way, hearing "fifty percent" was worse than hearing "almost zero." Fine then, she said. In that case, I'll just have to train harder. Poppy took a deep breath and tried to clear her mind once again. Gradually, the sound of the rain faded away.

… I can already tell that Poppy’s return to the guild is going to be quite the episode whenever the story gets there. Especially if she’s openly contemplating killing off former colleagues as part of it.
916590486356131850.png


Alright, onto the postmortem:

I liked the chapters I read, if in a very “screaming at my screen ‘no wait, don’t do that’” since of liking. Since these chapters do a very good job at selling the sense of Poppy transforming from the initial plucky and headstrong explorer into a sinister figure that’s now weighing “what’s the least amount of murder do I need in order to get my message across in the way I want it”. I can’t tell whether or not the story’s building up to it being revealed that Poppy’s losing herself to Ann, or if this has always been her making these decisions all along, and she’s just now empowered to consider the unthinkable, but it’s a chilling process to watch unfold either way.

I didn’t have a whole lot of complaints with these two chapters, though I did notice that there were a couple parts that felt like they played out faster than they needed to, or else could’ve had more oomph if they had a bit more description woven in. Fortunately, the bits that I saw that I had quibbles with all seemed like they fundamentally were additive tweaks, though I won’t fault you for opting to let sleeping dogs lie for your story to move onto newer pursuits.

All and all, I’m having a great time with this story @love . It’s a neat piece that deals with themes that aren’t super common on the PMD scene, and the way that things have been building up more and more to a spectacular shoe drop (even if it’s arguably already started grazing the floor at this point) have kept things gripping and suspenseful the entire time I’ve been reading.

Til next time! Not that I expect to keep you waiting for too long before getting another one of these.
 

Adamhuarts

Mew specialist
Partners
  1. mew-adam
  2. celebi-shiny
  3. roserade-adam
So, I just read the first chapter of this story I decided to pick up at random, a decision I did not regret. Owing to the fact that there's a couple chapters already and you've probably received enough feedback on the first chapter, I'll provide only my speculation filled first impressions here.


To start off, the first scene does quite a decent job at telling us a bit about these characters and showing us what their main interests are. Poppy, fittingly a leafeon, is much introduced showing a lot of interest in the environment to the point where she zones out of a conversation she's in. Lavender clearly isn't as savvy in that area of expertise, but still willing to indulge her partner a bit. We also see that the two clearly share a good enough understanding of one another that Poppy could tell she's overwhelming Lavender and change the subject back to their previous conversation. That was good to see.


The second scene has them encountering a group of tribal pokemon and judging by the reaction they got, it's clear that they're not welcome there. In the following scene we also get hinted to the fact that there might be some food insecurity going on, or just that whatever city the guild operates in is expanding outward. Yeah I can see where this is going, provided things don't change directory. When a more affluent nation covets resources a native population has, it rarely ever works out for the natives. The following scene also clues us that there's also a bit of an environmental problem going on, what with fishes growing scarcer and the potential upending of the status quo Poppy and her crew's efforts have built.


I'm curious if that's what the main conflict of this story will be exploring in the next couple of chapters. This is a thematic that's pretty close to home for a lot of people who read this story I bet, and it's a subject matter that's delicate to handle well. I'd say my intrigue has been piqued so far and I'll probably peek back in another time to check out the rest of it.
 

Spiteful Murkrow

Busy Writing Stories I Want to Read
Pronouns
He/Him/His
Partners
  1. nidoran-f
  2. druddigon
  3. swellow
  4. lugia
  5. quilava-fobbie
  6. sneasel-kate
  7. heliolisk-fobbie
Heya, back for another one of these, though this time around, I opted to just go for a big bang and plow through the rest of the story. Since I was enjoying things quite a bit from my past tranches, and with just over 10,000 words to go, I think that I can stuff that and a review into a good night’s worth of action.

Chapter 9

Poppy had arranged the battle to take place on the island, under the pretense that she had been guarding the planet's energy with Xerneas for some time. In reality, of course, she could teleport there whenever she pleased. The real reason was so that, if she lost the fight, Xerneas might stand a chance at finishing off her opponent while he was weakened.

… Oh. Well this chapter is going to go places, I can tell. Since I’m pretty sure that that’s her former guild mates she’s talking about there.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Either way, the clearing before the crater wasn't the worst place to wait. Dragonflies' wings flashed amber as the sun moved in and out of clouds, and the scent of goldenrod was sweet on the wind. White-throated sparrows filled the air with their song like carefree whistling. Hello, little ones, Poppy thought, her paws shaking (it was a waste of effort to try to stop them, she realized some time ago). Today might be my last day alive. Would you still be singing if you knew that? I wonder...

Poppy: “I mean, you probably would keep singing anyways since nature can be a bit indifferent and uncaring like that, but let me have my moment here.” >_>;

From beside Poppy, Xerneas tossed its head and issued forth a wave of sparkles like dyed stars. Whatever technique it used had a calming effect—Poppy's pulse steadied, and for a moment today didn't seem like such a big deal.

Poppy looked up at Xerneas' face. "Thank you."

Think nothing of it. I do not know how you became so powerful, but right now you are my best ally. For the sake of our future, you must defeat this opponent.

Boy is it such a mood to see that Poppy’s managed to get Xerneas to join forces with her. Since considering the trajectory of the past few chapters, in all likelihood, that means that she’s also motivated Xerneas to be ready to kill whoever she’s about to face down if she falls short.
:uhhh:


Poppy nodded. She had tried a couple of sparring matches with Xerneas an hour ago, and they had proved to be shockingly one-sided. The fate of the planet's energy really was up to her.

909223973412290560.png


Well that’s not concerning at all there. Though I’m pretty sure that given that background folklore of what would happen if Xerneas’ energy were sapped beyond a certain point, that’s a really ominous sign for the future of your planet and life on it in general.

If you change your mind, Poppy, just let me know... Ann's voice was quiet, as though it were nervous, too.

Can’t tell if Ann is legit nervous here or if she’s mindgaming Poppy. I honestly could see it going either way, since she’s given some massively “totally legit” vibes off in the story thus far.

I won't, but... If I don't survive, tell the shaymin what happened. And Lavender.

You have my word.

And Lavender, huh? So she really hasn’t fully let her go as a companion. Though considering the overall mood of the story and how rapidly Poppy’s been going down the slippery slope, I’m pretty sure that she and Lavender are going to trade blows at some point before curtain call. And… I’m pretty sure it’s not going to end well for Lavender.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Footsteps rustled in the distance—the cadence was too deliberate to be ferals. Poppy grabbed the face mask from her bag and slipped it on. She didn't know if it would work, but she had asked Ann to get it for her anyway. Anything that might conceal her identity.

578077337728450560.png


… Aren’t they very obviously going to put two and two that it’s the same Leafeon that crashed the board meeting of that one mining company? There’s only so many Leafeon out there with sufficient strength to body a Flygon or bisect a Gallade.

Poppy's opponent—Thorn—was the first to come into view. She had never seen a lucario before, but for some reason, she had always imagined them as being larger. Thorn was only a paw or two taller than Poppy herself. He stood as still as a statue, barely even seeming to breathe. His scarred face betrayed no emotion.

Poppy: “... Boy am I glad that I’m getting help for this fight, since there is no way in a million years I could take this guy otherwise.” ^^;

Thorn was followed by a number of other pokemon—a mix of spectators and medics—who fanned out in the clearing, as far away from the combatants-to-be as they could get. Poppy forced herself not to look at them; she didn't want to see anyone she knew.

"Are you ready, leafeon?" Thorn asked, his voice like a growling bear.

Poppy: “... How on earth is your voice that loud and low?” .-.
Thorn: “Thematic effect. Gotta give off a vibe before I punt you halfway across the forest.”

Poppy took in the nourishing feeling of the sunlight on her back and tried to burn it into her memory. She nodded.

"En garde."

Poppy opened with an energy ball. It was the fastest she had ever performed the move—the sphere was at full size in the blink of an eye and rocketed toward her opponent like debris from an explosion.

Spectators:
701085210766344223.png

Poppy: “What, did you really think that I’d take on this challenge if I didn’t think I had a shot at winning?”

Yet her opponent was faster still. His aura sphere collided squarely with her attack; cyan light flooded the clearing. Unfazed, he launched a second projectile as the spectators shielded their eyes.

Poppy leapt aside. Brilliant cobalt light burned its afterimage into her eyes as the sphere flew past; a cold, spectral sensation sent a chill down her spine. She forced her focus back to her opponent.

>Poppy manages to successfully dodge an Aura Sphere

That must be some power of Ann’s there given that I’m not even sure if it’s possible for Aura Sphere to miss mechanically without some sort of hard-blocking move like Protect in-game.

Thorn: “... I call hax.”

Thorn launched a third aura sphere—Poppy was better prepared this time, so she sidestepped again and retaliated with swift. The stars spread across the whole of the clearing as though to form a galaxy, forcing the spectators to take cover.

Can’t tell if Poppy’s trying to be merciful there by using a type-resistant move, or if Ann has just souped her up so much that it just doesn’t matter anymore. Either way, I wouldn’t have expected that to get picked for fighting against a Lucario.

Thorn emitted a beam of aura from his hand and slashed. The stars before him disintegrated; he dashed through the opening.

Is that supposed to be Force Palm or Bone Club there? Since I admittedly had a bit of trouble telling what the intent was supposed to be.

Poppy grimaced—she didn't want Thorn to get close. She struck with her vine and sharpened her senses to try to catch his reaction.

Thorn did not dodge, as Poppy had expected—perhaps he wasn't quite fast enough. Instead he whipped around and grabbed the vine between his paws, leaning into the attack to keep his balance.

Poppy: “Er… pretty sure that’s not good there.”
Ann: “With my power at your back? I’m sure you can turn this around on him in short order.”

That was fine by Poppy; she simply struck with a second vine. It was a solid hit—the shock passed all the way through the vine and rattled Poppy's bones. Thorn flew backwards while Poppy prepared an energy ball to follow up with.

Ouch. That’s gonna leave a mark.

But, to her surprise, Thorn had not lost his grip when she struck him. Using his hold on the first vine and the momentum from Poppy's attack, he twisted his body and pulled hard. By the time Poppy felt the slack on the first vine run out, it was too late.

Poppy: “See, I knew that him grabbing onto my vine wasn’t a good thing!” >.<
Ann: “... In my defense, I was expecting him to lose his grip. Lucario are apparently great at latching onto things, who knew?”

Thorn hurled Poppy across the clearing. She flew too quickly to orient herself. She reflexively wrapped herself in vines to try to soften the impact with whatever she was bound to hit.

"Agh!" Poppy cried out as the wind was knocked out of her. A loud crack reverberated across the forest as the tree snapped from the impact, and Poppy's momentum carried her into a second one. She sank slightly into the wood, but this time the trunk held.

Yeah, Poppy is really fortunate she has the power of totally-not-Yveltal backing her up, since I’m pretty sure she’d be very, very dead right about now considering those trees were described as being as rigid as iron back in her first trek through this island.

Poppy peeled away from the tree and tumbled toward the ground in agony. It felt like she had been crushed against a bed of thorns, and when she inhaled it was like pressing shards of glass into her lungs. It was all she could do to keep her eyes open.

As Poppy made her second revolution in the air, she glimpsed Thorn. His stance was wide, and yet another nascent aura sphere glowed between his paws.

Poppy: “Oh dammit, seriously? Ann! A little help now would be nice!” O_O;
Ann: “Look, I’m doing my best, alright?”

In spite of the pain, Poppy did her best to clear her mind and waited. She tracked Thorn as she spun, kept her eyes on his paws. Maybe it was just her anticipation, but the moment seemed to stretch on and on for seconds, as though Thorn were delaying his attack on purpose. The aura sphere grew larger and brighter, gradually obscuring his figure. Just looking at it made Poppy's eyes tear up. Maybe that was his intention...

Finally, Poppy saw it—that now-familiar motion as Thorn thrust his arms forward. Right as he released his attack, Poppy reached out with a vine and pulled herself toward one of the tree branches below. The aura sphere passed just above her; she felt its cold on her tail before it hit the tree with a deep thud.

Lucky save there.

Thorn: “I. Call. Hax.” >.<
Poppy: “Look, we live in a setting where Aura Sphere isn’t a guaranteed hit, okay? Cry more.”

Even though it felt like tearing herself in half, Poppy twisted her body and managed to land on her feet. She ignored the shock that passed through her and took a ragged breath as splinters rained down on her from above.

So is she going through some sort of freaky Baccano thing right about now where she’s coated in obvious wounds that are sealing up in live-time right now? Since I saw what happened with that Flygon earlier, and it’s hard for me to imagine that isn’t happening right about now.

Kinda wonder if it’d have made sense to at least hint at what was going on with Poppy and the state of her body via description, though.

Thorn was wounded too—there was a gash in his flank where his fur was stained crimson. The wound was deep but, to Poppy's dismay, not fatal.

:uhhh:


Boy, she’s definitely changed as a ‘mon. Not even trying to give Thorn a chance to retreat with his tail between his legs, huh? Though how on earth would she expect that to play in front of the crowd of like 20 other guild Pokémon who would be strongly motivated to just rain seeds and Wonder Orbs on her afterwards if they could after seeing her kill off one of their more beloved members.

Thorn once again summoned a beam of aura from his paw and rushed toward Poppy. She tried to strike, but Thorn anticipated the attack—he cut her vines in two with the beam before they could reach him, and as the severed halves fell limply to the ground, Poppy suddenly felt very vulnerable.

Wait. Do those things not have nerve endings? Since Poppy sure isn’t reacting much to getting what are arguably limbs of hers severed. Like it’s not necessarily a wrong take, per se, just caught me a little off guard since it’s a bit alien to think of appendages that can pick up objects that wouldn’t have some sort of link to a nervous system.

In the heat of the moment, and without enough time to try a ranged attack, Poppy tried to catch her opponent off-guard. She rushed toward Thorn just as he neared striking distance, then turned to slash with her tail.

It was pointless. Thorn parried effortlessly, throwing Poppy off balance. His own slash grazed Poppy's neck and head as she jumped back. Poppy seethed—it felt like a shard of ice. Her mask, now cut across its length, fell to the ground, and she felt the open air on her face.

Spectators: “...” O.O
Poppy: “... Well crap. So much for being able to keep my identity a secret.” >_>;

Then Thorn jumped back himself, toward the center of the clearing, and stepped away from Poppy. She studied his face, trying to discern his intention. His gaze seemed... softer, than before.

… Poppy is about to take advantage of this just kill Thorn right then and there, isn’t she?” ^^;

The chill along Poppy's neck quickly yielded to a lingering, burning pain. She felt something wet the fur right around her collar—something warm. The feeling came in intervals, like...

Well. It was like a heartbeat, wasn't it. Poppy glanced down and saw bright red.

Ann...

Poppy, I'm trying, but... that's beyond healing. I... I'm sorry.
Ann gave a trembling sigh. It's over. You deserved better than this. You really did. I promise I will remember you for as long as I live.

I… can’t believe that I’m about to say this, but Poppy’s not actually just going to die here with like a third of the story left to go, is she? Like, she’ll pull through this somehow… right?
663472557499875330.png


The moment was surreal. Poppy stared at Thorn and at the spectators as their faces turned from anxious to pitying. She sat down slowly and summoned a vine—this time not to attack, but so that she could press something against her wound. Her artery had been cut lengthwise, she realized, and blood had already begun to stream down her chest and soak the soil below.

Okay, I suddenly feel a lot less judgemental about Poppy attempting to kill off Thorn given that he was ready and willing to do the same from the jump.

Just try to stay calm, she thought, as the beginnings of dizziness began to manifest. You'll only bleed faster if you get nervous...

But then, what difference does it make? I'm already dead. I should just ask Thorn to finish me off.
She clenched her jaw. God damn it, if I'd just—

"Poppy!"

Oh, boy Lavender’s here to see all of this, isn’t she?
:fearfullaugh~1:


Poppy's thoughts were interrupted by a mournful wail, like a suffocating loon. Her eyes went wide, and she froze. Carefully, she turned her head to her right.

The sight of Lavender's face stung more than Thorn's slash had; her teeth were bared in an ugly grimace, her snout so twisted and wrinkled she was almost unrecognizable. It was the first time, as far as Poppy knew, that her partner had ever looked old.

Poppy: “Uh… hi there, Lavender? How have you been doing?” ._.;
Lavender: “Poppy, you’re dying right now!”
:uhhh:

Poppy: “I mean, yeah. Barring a really lucky development in about 30 seconds, this is kinda it for me.”
- Poppy looks down at the pooling blood by her feet -
Poppy: “I… just wish that we didn’t have to meet like this again.”
401083507872366598.png


Poppy took a ragged breath and blinked away her tears as her friend took a tentative step toward her. Slowly, she stood and did the same. Laurie was there too, just behind Lavender, and the lurantis bowed with sorrow in her eyes.

At least I can be with Lavender, Poppy thought as she took another feeble step. Maybe she'll understand. And even if she doesn't...

inb4 something ruins this sad, touching moment in about 60 seconds.

Maybe it was a sense of acceptance, or maybe it was her consciousness slipping, but Poppy's anxiety began to fade. She imagined Lavender's warm embrace, her sweet scent. Soon, she would...

She stopped. Laurie. Seeing the lurantis sparked a memory. That scar... Her wound, that had healed so quickly. [ ]

Ann. Can you teleport me into the crater?

Yeah, I kinda figured that the plot was going to do something to keep Poppy from shuffling off the mortal coil, or at least not at this point in time. I wonder if this sequence would’ve worked better if there’d been some sort of “if only she could somehow get back to the crater where they’d first found her” to hammer it home that that’s Poppy’s brilliant plan for how to cheat death right now, since it took me a while to put two and two together as a reader.

It takes about five seconds for me to do that, Poppy, and it's far too obvious. They'll strike you down before you get the chance. Please, just be with—

Try.


Ann paused. It's been tried before, Poppy; to withstand direct contact with the planet's energy would be practically im—

I don't care, do it!
She commanded as she sucked in a breath. Now!

I—
Ann's voice cracked. ...As you wish, dear Poppy.

>when the sus voice in your head that’s totally not Yveltal all but screams at you that this is a terrible idea and you just press along to do it anyways

de7.png


Poppy's body began to glow white. As Ann predicted, Thorn realized what was happening and dashed toward her. Poppy tried to lift her vines, but she was too weak. The most she could do was stagger dizzily away, trying to put some distance between herself and her assailant. Judging by Thorn's speed, she had maybe half of a second.

I'm am an idiot, aren't I... Poppy braced herself for the inevitable.

inb4 Lavender charges in to save the day right about now. Since I kinda doubt she’d just be okay with watching Thorn kill off her friend from the way that she reacted about 10 seconds ago.

A brilliant, pink streak slammed into Thorn's side, right in the same place Poppy had wounded him earlier. Thorn staggered, nearly falling over, and looked back up to see Xerneas place itself between Poppy and him.

Oh. Well, guess someone else will be doing the honors there in that case.

"Out of the way!" Thorn growled as he launched an aura sphere. Xerneas tried to defend with another moonblast, but the aura sphere passed through it and knocked the legendary away like a toy.

Thorn: “Wait. Was- Was that supposed to work that well on a Xerneas? I thought they were supposed to be these super-powerful Pokémon of myth.” ._.

The exchange took about three seconds. Not enough. Poppy clenched her jaw as Thorn turned toward her again.

"Stop!"

A familiar bolt of lightning flashed from behind Thorn. He twitched from the thunder wave and then whipped around to face his assailant—none other than Lavender—just as she let loose with swift.

Oh, there’s Lavender coming in with the save. Wasn’t expecting her to come in after the almighty deer god, but I just knew that she’d come barreling in at some point.

Poppy's eyes went wide. "Lavender..."

Poppy didn't have time to see the rest of the exchange play out. Her body flashed, and she found herself tumbling into the mouth of the crater that had just a moment ago seemed so far away. She looked down; blinding white light greeted her. Even when she closed her eyes, the brightness made her head ache.

Well that’s certainly going to be good for Lavender’s job security right about now. Assuming that she doesn’t just get summarily ganked by Thorn and the other higher-ups for helping what I’m pretty sure is a known serial murderer by this point escape.
:fearfullaugh~1:


Am I stupid? asked Poppy as the wind rushed by, splattering her blood onto her chin and face.

Look... If I thought there were no chance of this working, I wouldn't have done it. It's true that no pokemon has survived this before, but then again, none of those pokemon had my help.

Poppy: “... Not the most reassuring thing I’ve ever heard, but hey. Considering the alternative’s death, I’ll take it.”

So how would you place my odds?

Less than one percent,

Ann said reluctantly. But, then again, that's just the kind of chance an explorer would take, isn't it?

Poppy smiled weakly. Goddamn right...

That was the last thing Poppy thought before the light swallowed her.

Well, you know how these teeny probabilities work in stories. “1%” might as well be “99%” in most stories where such odds come up.

Chapter 10

A droning sound like a million insect wings all beating at once, or a million voices all crying out. It was neither harmonious nor discordant.

Poppy's body seemed to vibrate, pervaded by an electric, tingling sensation. She grew numb to everything but pain.

Poppy: “Wait a minute, is this a good thing, or really, really bad? Since I can’t exactly tell right now.” ^^;

While the pain elsewhere had begun to subside, the ache in Poppy's head only grew more intense. It didn't matter how hard she shut her eyes; the light may as well have been inside her skull. Her eyes were tearing up—she thought? It was hard to tell.

The ache in her head spread down to her neck, then out to the rest of her body. It drowned out any other sensation. Poppy tried to move her limbs, but felt nothing. Tried to open her eyes again, but nothing changed. Tried to contact Ann, but heard no response.

The droning was so loud, the light so bright... Poppy almost wanted to return to the surface, to just bleed to death in peace. She tried to remember the warmth of the sun but found she was no longer able. She couldn't remember what anything felt like, anymore.

Poppy: “Uh… yeah. Bad, I’ll very heavily take ‘bad’ there.” o_o;
Ann: “Not so fast, Poppy. Let things play out a bit.”

For a long time there was nothing but pain, noise, and unbearable light. Just let me die, Poppy thought. Ann, if you can't get me out... Please...

Gradually, the space between Poppy's thoughts grew, like a fading heartbeat. Stretches of oblivion. The pain, the noise, the light, all merged into a single sensation. And over time, in the same way that she had grown numb to her own body, Poppy grew numb to that sensation, too. She perceived neither light nor darkness, neither silence nor noise. It was empty.

Po , c n y t f r ?

Poppy: “... Not sure what on earth just happened there, but I know that that isn’t a good sign. Especially if I can’t hear Ann right now.” .-.

Poppy was roused by a voice in her head, and she mentally winced as she became conscious of the light again. Ann? Is that... you?

Y s. I n ed you t pu l yo r v ne for me.

To... Pull my... vine?
Poppy tried to move, and felt nothing. I can't. I don't under—

No, you j st did i ! Again! Ju t try!

Poppy: “Ann, what even is going on right now?” O_O;
Ann: “Ju t d it a r dy!”

O-okay... Though it seemed fruitless, Poppy tried again to pull, and lost consciousness a few seconds later.

C me on P ppy! D n't give up!

Poppy wanted nothing more than to do just that, to fall asleep to all this overwhelming stimulus. But she mustered her will and tried again, with Ann cheering her on all the while.

Yes! y can do t, P ppy!

This is a real touching and uplifting moment here. And then you remember that it’s Ann that’s cheering Poppy on and everything wraps right back around to it being creepy and concerning.
780304054227435550.png


It was only after what seemed like minutes that Poppy began to notice any change. The noise and light began to fade, and she felt her body again—it was like blood flowing back into her limbs. The rush of the wind slowly returned, but this time, she wasn't falling—she was rising. Pulling herself up.

Oh, so like Baccano after all then, huh? Except with less spectacular and creepy visuals involved.

Poppy soared above the mouth of the crater, and for a moment, she seemed to hang in the air. The treetops looked soft, almost cloud-like from above, leaves trembling in the breeze as though with anticipation. Poppy's body tingled as though charged with electricity, and for a moment, as she looked out to the clear horizon, she felt like a kid again. Ready to romp around in the grass and play with endless exuberance. She turned her gaze to Thorn and Xerneas and all the other pokemon who were turning in shock to face her. From this height they seemed as small as insects.

Poppy: “Wait a minute. They could all see me from all the way down there? How brightly was I glowing, Ann?” o_o;
Ann: “Pretty sure you would’ve been a decent substitute for a sun for a few moments.”
720106605982646283.png


Poppy felt no pain when she hit the ground in front of Thorn. The lucario put his hands out in front of him in a gesture of surrender and backed away, the aura sensors on his head rising as he did. The spectators gasped.

Thorn: “Y-Yeah, screw this noise, I’m out of here. I didn’t sign up for this!”
916590486356131850.png


Y u are so luc y, sighed Ann, not even trying to keep the relief out of its voice.

Poppy grinned. Glad to be back, she thought. Though you're still a little hard to hear.

It t ok all I had to ke p you from evapo ating. I c n b rely talk to you r ght now.

I’m not convinced that there isn’t some sort of terrible side effect that’s going to come about as a result of-


Then in that case...

You'r running off the p net's energ , in essence. But... It's onl tempor ry.

:uhhh:


Okay, there absolutely has to be some sort of horrible side effect from doing all of this. There is exactly no way that that can possibly be a good thing when this planet’s lifeforce is weak and waning and Poppy picked this fight precisely to keep other Pokémon from thrusting their grubby little mitts all over it.


Poppy's face fell, and her blood ran cold. She didn't want to believe it, but the truth was that she could already feel her vibrant energy beginning to yield to exhaustion like the light of the setting sun. She didn't have long, she thought—seconds, at best. Can I just kill Thorn? How powerful are the other—

N t as str ng as you, but th y're powerful enough to k ll Xerne s. I'm s rry, Poppy. We c n't be selective th s time

Ann, what the hell?

Poppy. You don’t have to do this, you can tell Ann ‘no’ for once. Your own best friend is down there!
916590486356131850.png


...I see. She looked back up at the baffled Thorn. So be it, then.

Poppy's vine pierced Thorn's heart and retracted in the beat of a hummingbird's wing. She rushed toward the spectators before Thorn's body had even started to crumple, and lashed out. Her vines bisected her targets as if they were made of sand, splattering blood onto the grass. Blissey, illumise, miltank, beautifly, sylveon, oshawott, aromatisse, volbeat. She turned and found five more to strike. Dustox, sandslash, zoroark, espeon, delphox. So far, no one had had the chance to react, and it helped that Poppy was determined not to give herself time to watch her victims die. Already her limbs were beginning to ache, as though cramping, and flecks of black swam at edge of her vision. She rushed to the next group of pokemon.

Whelp, too late. Guess we’re finally getting that Rick and Morty S5E3 moment now. If Lavender somehow survives all of this, that friendship with Poppy is just never going to recover afterwards.

Also, perhaps I’m just jaded, but this feels surprisingly tame for M-rated violence given that as brutal as it is, it’s not really dealt with with much description.

Lopunny, breloom, infernape, drifblim. Gardevoir, hatterene. Zangoose, drapion, kricketune, audino, krokorok, togekiss. Poppy's heart was racing now, straining to meet her demands. Her vision began to narrow, but instead of giving in to the urge to stop and rest, she whipped her head around and honed in on the last group. They had finally realized what was happening but only had enough time to express their shock as Poppy sprinted to them.

Swampert, conkeldurr, armaldo. Luxray, sableye, torkoal, goodra... lurantis.

Whelp, that’s one ‘mon that Poppy explicitly knew well enough to be on a given-name basis that she’s axed by now. I… get the feeling that it’s not going to be the last.

Poppy: “I feel as if I should probably be a lot more worried by how naturally this is all coming to me. But meh, saving the planet here. Gotta break a few eggs.”

Poppy turned her head to look away from the carnage, only to lock eyes with Lavender. The delcatty was frozen—not even so much as a twitch from her tail.

Lavender: “P-Poppy?! W-What are you doing?! Wh-Why would you-?!”
916590486356131850.png

Poppy: “... Crap. I forgot she was here for all of this. Hey, Ann, are you sure that everyone needs to die right now?”

Poppy glanced away, staggering. Her legs were shaking now, and her hearing was beginning to fade. The sound of nature around her—the wind and cicadas and panicked birds—grew muffled by an ever-loudening white noise, like blood rushing through her head. Even if I can muster the strength, I will not hurt her. I will not stoop that low. I will not stoop that low...

Poppy closed her eyes and hit the ground.

I mean, I’m pretty sure that you’ve just permanently destroyed your friendship with Lavender and traumatized her for life by massacring at least half of the guild’s expeditionary force in about 15 seconds, but… at least you managed to stop yourself eventually? Better late than never, right?
:fearfullaugh~1:


Chapter 11

A dull, dead ache pervaded Poppy's muscles; she felt like a corpse. She caught a whiff of yarrow as she slowly opened her eyes, almost scared to try to move lest she find she couldn't. Before her was a patch of black fur with a metallic, powder-blue trim. A moment later Xerneas lowered its head, and Poppy found herself looking into its royal blue eyes.

Are you in pain? it asked.

"Some," Poppy muttered. Her throat felt like she had swallowed sand, and her voice reflected that.

Poppy: “Wait, where are we right now and where is everyone else?” .-.

Xerneas moved out of view for a moment, then returned with a familiar-looking pouch, which it dropped in front of Poppy. Lavender left this for you. It has some water in it.

Poppy raised her leaden head, feebly grabbed the pouch with her mouth, and accessed the water pouch inside it. While the fluid felt good in her throat and stomach, she felt a sort of uncomfortable nostalgia as she drank; the pouch had Lavender's scent all over it, mixed awkwardly with the bitterness of the old leather. She noticed, too, that Lavender's guild badge remained pinned to the front—had she not thought to take it with her? Or—

I mean, I wouldn’t want to still be in a guild either after watching dozens of my friends and colleagues get brutally murdered by my former best friend. Like that’s the point where you just nope out, retire, and get into the equivalent of flipping burgers for the rest of your life instead of going back on the job that’s almost certainly going to attempt to mount a punitive expedition of some sort.

Poppy: “Wait, did you see how she left it? Was it out of concern? Or more ‘oh gods, just take it’?” ^^;

Xerneas interrupted Poppy's thoughts. Lavender helped treat your injuries while I was unconscious. Before she left, she told me to relay something to you. She said she would tell the guild that you won and that there is no point in trying to fight you.

Xerneas: “... Least of all since they absorbed casualties that were borderline exterminatory in scale. Since… you know, no point in sending more ‘mons to their deaths pointlessly.”
Poppy: “Er… well on the plus side, I guess Ann’s idea worked? Even if I didn’t do it as completely as she wanted me to.” ^^;

Poppy rested her head on the ground once more. "I see... Then I suppose we win." She closed her eyes for a moment, but she couldn't stop seeing the patterns beneath her eyelids as pools of blood. "Did she say anything else?"

Oh, so cleaving up a good 20-or-so ‘mons in a fell swoop did get to Poppy. Or at least for now, since if she gets used to this...
:uhhh:


That was all she wanted me to tell you.

Poppy grunted. The evasive answer stung, but she didn't press the matter.

Translation: “She was really shaken up and taken aback by you, but let’s not get into that right here and now.”

Is there anything I can get for you? Xerneas asked. Are you hungry?

"A little. If the clouds clear up, though, I should be fine."

I will get you some food. It is the least I can do. Xerneas turned and walked away. I will only be gone for a moment. The feral pokemon stay away from this place, so you will be safe.

- Beat moment -
Poppy: “... Wait, are all those bisected Pokémon just chilling around in the background somewhere right about now?” .-.
Xerneas: “I… think that that’s best not thought about too hard, really. Let’s just assume that Lavender and her surviving colleagues took them back for burial, since I’m not sure if I need to see their bloody messes all over again.” ^^;

Poppy didn't relish the thought of being left alone, but she supposed it was just as well. Though they were on the same side, she didn't know Xerneas well enough to feel particularly comfortable around it, and she had a feeling it might be a problem if it knew about Ann.

Speaking of which...

Ann? Poppy thought.

Poppy: “She… didn’t ghost me over not going through with her instructions all the way, did she?” ._.;

No reply. Despite Poppy's exhaustion, her heart began to beat faster, and a too-familiar dizziness pervaded her head.

Please don't be gone, Ann. If you're not there...

Poppy summoned her will and sent the most forceful transmission she could. Ann!

Ah... Our hero is awake,
came Ann's tired reply. And now I am too.

Poppy: “Oh thank goodness, I was worried that she’d left me high and dry over backing down over Lavender for a second.” [blazisweat]


Ann! Poppy let out a breath and smiled. At least you're still there... I was beginning to think you had forgotten about our promise.

Ann chuckled. Perish the thought, dear Poppy. I just had to rest for a while, so I couldn't keep you company. I hope you're feeling okay.

Well, I'm... I'm alive. Thank you for helping me earlier.

Poppy: “I mean, I still say we could’ve gotten away with just killing Thorn to send a message, but given that I’m not cold and dead right about now, I won’t complain too much about things.”

Ann laughed. That sure was a crazy stunt, huh? I'm glad everything worked out. I'll be sure to help you take back your land soon, too; it'll just be a little while before I get back in tip-top shape, is all. I hope you don't mind.

663472557499875330.png


Oh, yeah, that’s going to be lovely if Poppy actually goes through with it since there’s now hundreds of guildmons residing on it, and with the way Ann “helped” resolve the whole thing involving Xerneas and the whole “protecting the planet’s lifeforce thing”... I don’t think that land will be habitable for a while after Ann helped “get it back”.


No, to be honest, I'm not too worried about that right now. I just... I want to see Holly and the others again soon. I know they'll be happy to see that I'm okay.

I'll get you to them as soon as I can. For now though, we'll just have to rest.

Right.
Poppy sighed, relaxing. Something about having Ann around seemed to help assuage her guilt, she realized.

Because she literally validates the side of you that’s increasingly viewing Pokémon that are harming the environment as the Pokémon equivalent of subhumans to be brutally put down as one pleases? Not too hard to figure out why you suddenly feel less guilty around her.

The sun shone through the clouds a moment later, and it made Poppy smile, if only because she had thought she would never feel its light on her fur again.

… How much of a bloody mess was she right after the last chapter anyways if she was feeling like that. .-.

Poppy burst through the door to the guildmaster's lavishly furnished office with his bodyguards wrapped up in her vines. She tossed the two pokemon—a makuhita and venasaur—onto his mahogany desk, and the wood split in half with a gruesome crack. Glass figurines fell to the ground and shattered like they had been waiting to for all their lives.

"Happy holidays, asshole."

… Oh, so she did decide to go back for her land after all. This is going to be just… wonderful.
780304054227435550.png


The guildmaster recoiled and almost backed into the windows behind him. Poppy looked into his wide, sickly looking yellow eyes, and though she hadn't relished the thought of going through this trouble initially, the look of terror on his face brought a smile to hers. Oh, and he was already audibly hyperventilating.

I’d say “Poppy, you’re scaring me”, but that ship sailed a few chapters ago.

Poppy's laughter was dark, raven-like, and she was sure the pokemon on the other side of the hall could hear it. "So frightened! Oh, that's precious. Precious." She walked between the two halves of the guildmaster's desk while he stood trembling. She wouldn't be surprised if he dropped dead from a heart attack right now.

"
Listen, you miserable sack of lard. You should be thanking your lucky stars—I'm not even going to kill you. I do have a couple demands, but they should be easily met." She smiled. "To begin with, guild fees are a little high. I say we lower them by ten percent, and maybe be more austere to compensate. Canceling construction of that new building would be a great place to start; I'll even give you a head start on demolition.

Okay, now Poppy’s scaring me. Since this entire time, she just hasn’t had an obvious malicious streak like this when indulging that baser side of her.
663472557499875330.png


That does not bode well for the lifespan of anyone on Poppy’s land right about now. I do feel like this one paragraph is idea-dense enough that it probably makes sense to hack it up, though.

"I would also demand that you put half of the guild's income toward ecological restoration and land conservation—like that fund I used to manage. I put Daisy in charge of it—bayleef. She's a member. Talk to her. Your first project will be to restore the land you stole from me.

… Wait, did Poppy just straight up take over the guild and murder anyone who got in her way, or…? .-.

"That is all for now. I'm sure I don't need to remind you, but of course, you should also make good on your agreement not to let anyone near that island again. I did win the duel, after all. Have I made myself clear?"

"Er..." The guildmaster made a sort of strangled sound and nodded. His eyelids fluttered as though he were about to faint.

"Good. If you fail to comply, I will know. You won't get any second chances."

… That sounds like a good argument to resign and nope out of your position if I ever heard one. Since I would not want to be so much as on the same continent as a ‘mon that killed 20 of my subordinates with a hate-on for me and the strength to kill me in painful, horrible fashion if it ever struck her fancy.

Poppy turned around and walked a few steps away, but she stopped when she reached the doorway. Before proceeding, she lowered a vine and flicked a splinter into the guildmaster's face. The way he stumbled backward, almost tripping over himself, made her smile.

That can’t possibly be a good omen for where Poppy’s going to be going in the remainder of this story, since if she’s ready to act this like this to one ‘mon she hates, it’s not hard at all to imagine her indulging her inner sadist towards others with increasingly little provocation.

Wooden crates larger than Poppy herself lined concrete walls, lit dimly by the bunker's skylight. The air smelled of dust and old wood. A dreary place to die, Poppy thought.

In the center of the room, the guildmaster stood facing an abra. A moment ago the two had been talking about how they were going to blow Poppy up, but they were silent now. The guildmaster turned toward Poppy with a sort of frozen expression, a little different from their last meeting; his fear seemed muted by disbelief, and perhaps also by knowing that there was nothing he could do to change his fate. His eyes in the feeble light were the color of leaves long since fallen. The abra teleported away, which Poppy didn't mind.

"You didn't keep your word," Poppy said.

Should’ve resigned and cut-and-run while you could’ve, bro. Since you were very, very obviously not going to come out on top of a dispute with her. ^^;

She wrapped a vine around the guildmaster's neck; he lost his footing trying to pull away and hit the ground with a dull thud. "Poppy—"

Poppy didn't like hearing the guildmaster say her name, so she tightened her grip. He gurgled and widened his eyes, twisting to bite Poppy's vine. Poppy let him. It didn't hurt. She summoned two more vines and bound the guildmaster's legs before approaching.

… Is this ‘mon about to draw and quarter this guy? Since that definitely would be a solid candidate for more brutal M-rated violence there.
:uhhh:


The guildmaster released the vine in his mouth and tilted his head, possibly to let more air into his throat, and possibly to look at Poppy. His abdomen shuddered as he fought to breathe, and his eyes were glassy. He might be blacking out already, Poppy thought.

Poppy: “I feel like I ought to be getting more creative with you right about now. Seeing as. You know. I literally just caught you plotting to murder me.” >:|

Poppy needed something more sensitive than a vine, so she loosened her grip around the guildmaster's neck slightly and slipped a paw underneath. His flesh yielded like rotting fruit as she probed with her paw. His pulse, when she found it, was rapid and feeble.

I’m… going to take the under on his skin not already having broken from that.

Poppy turned a little so that she could reach her tail to the guildmaster's neck. He thrashed like a beached fish. His hip and shoulder slammed loudly against thick concrete, which looked painful. Poppy looked around briefly for something sturdy to bind him to, but she only saw crates. In the end, she simply cut him right then and there.

The guildmaster let out an infantile whimper, and Poppy felt warmth on her flank. She glanced down and saw bright red. Blood spurted from the guildmaster's neck, saturating his fur and hers. It pooled quickly on the impervious floor and crept between Poppy's toes and under her paw pads. The scent of iron filled her nose.

Oh thank goodness, for a second I thought we were going to see Poppy torture this guy to death. Like this is still a pretty brutal takedown there, but considering the way she conducted herself in his office, I was expecting worse. ^^;

The guildmaster grimaced, baring antique-yellow teeth. His breath smelled like must and decay, and his tears stained his fur the color of wet pavement. He gently rocked his head back and forth as he sobbed, as though to try to comfort himself.

Poppy didn't like what she was doing. She felt disgust. She felt pity. She felt sick. But despite her best efforts, there was something she didn't feel, even as she watched the guildmaster rock and spasm and cry, and that was guilt.

Poppy: “... I mean, I only have killed like 20 other Pokémon at this point who probably didn’t deserve it anywhere near as much as this guy, so… yeah. Even if I was kinda hoping he’d keel over a bit more nicely, I’m not sorry this guy’s biting it.”
720106605982646283.png


The guildmaster was probably nauseous by now, Poppy thought. If he opened his eyes, he might find that his vision was fading. Poppy unwrapped her vines and stepped back. Then she raised a vine above the guildmaster's head and struck.

Poppy had seen rodents run over by carriages, their flanks split open and organs squashed against the pavement. This wasn't any more gruesome than that, she thought. Just a bigger rat than she was used to.

498ed76be651cffb6bb9bac6a9bb75c3.jpg


Yeah, this is the point where if you’re in this guild, you just cut and run and very heavily insist “Iwasneverpartofthatguildpleasejustgoaway” if anyone asks you about it. Since… yeah, if Poppy sees her deal with the guild as null and void, I’d be very worried as a lower member about my near-term survival. ^^;

The stones to Poppy's right had been carved into smooth, sculpturesque shapes by the force of the river. A fine mist floated slowly downstream; millet-sized droplets had formed on Poppy's fur, glinting colorfully in the sun like gossamer. Red clouds swirled around her paws as she held them in the water. Ann, say the guildmaster got his way. He had that abra teleport the bomb to the island, and he blows it up in my face. Would it have killed me?

Months ago, when we were newer to this, it might have. Now, no. Your ears would have rung for a while, though. Bombs are unpleasant like that.

701085210766344223.png


Wait, what? How?


What of the island? The plants and animals?

Would have killed hundreds, maybe thousands.

Poppy shook her head. Then I can't feel bad for him. He got what he deserved. She removed her paws from the water and inspected them—they were still tinged with reddish brown. She sneered. I shouldn't have waited so long. Now I can't get these stains out.

I mean, if you hadn’t brutally murdered all those other guild randos for the crime of just being in proximity to you, I’d… honestly be tempted to agree and give you a pass there, since Guildmaster Purugly wasn’t exactly a nice Pokémon in life from the little glimpses we got of him.

Why don't you just use your tongue?

Poppy shivered with disgust. Ann...

Oh. I guess I can see how you wouldn't want to.

I’m a little surprised that Poppy is so disgusted at the idea of lapping up the blood of someone she hates and savoring her accomplishment. But I guess there’s just some lines she’s not ready to cross just yet.

Poppy sighed and stuck her paws back in the water. Anyway, I've been thinking, the guildmaster wouldn't have gotten away with the things he did if there weren't so many other depraved pokemon out there. I'd like to give them a similar ultimatum and see how they respond. Maybe make a movement out of it.

909223973412290560.png


I like how there’s blood still on her paws, and Poppy’s already plotting out her next mass murder. I’m not convinced that this is just Ann’s influence prodding her along there, since at some point, Poppy’s desires wrapped around to become in sync with hers.

Ann chuckled. He he he. Well, if that's what you want to do, then I would be happy to support you. Just let me know when you decide on our next target.

Poppy cocked her head. Really? That easily? You're not going to say 'on one condition...'

Ann laughed again. No, not at all. I've got nothing better to do, and frankly, this is a cause I can get behind. I'm all yours.

Poppy, if nothing else this should be the giant flashing red light that Ann isn’t a benign presence and you should want to get her far, far out of your mind right now. o_o;

Poppy smiled as she shook her paws dry. In that case, I'll be sure not to let your generosity go to waste.

… We’re gonna see Poppy do something like massacre that one city that was spewing out all that pollution earlier in the story to a ‘mon, aren’t we? .-.

Chapter 12

The rain roared hollowly against the roofs of buildings with signs too worn to read. Somehow the rain in this region seemed colder than the snow from whence Poppy came; it soaked her fur to her skin, burdened her. Her footfalls were heavy against the path, and the scent of young goldenrod underfoot mingled with scents of rotting wood and petrichor. The ground here had been a path, once, but now it was hardly distinguishable from the pale green foothills that encircled the valley.

A breloom chittered as it slinked between two buildings a few meters ahead. It's really just ferals here, now, Poppy thought. She walked up to the building to her right and peered through the rain-smeared window. It didn't look like anyone had bothered to move the furniture out, and nobody remained to right the toppled tables and chairs. The place looked like it might have been a bar or restaurant, but the only culinary items left were shredded grain sacks and scattered silverware. A mule deer was curled up in the far corner beside a shivering bulbasaur, under a table that looked like it had been made for some kind of ball game.

Well, that place has certainly seen its better days. Though I wonder where on earth this place is.

I thought civilized pokemon were smarter than this. I thought they could adapt. Poppy shook her head. I shouldn't have been so hard on Lavender. I'm as naive as she was.

Aw, don't get so down in the dumps, Poppy. Sometimes things get worse before they get better, you know?

Maybe.

Wait a minute. Poppy did this? I mean, I’d expected her to give a settlement a bad time, but this is making it sound like she just flatly deleted civilization from existence.
:uhhh:


Poppy watched the drops trail down the glass for a moment.

You know, they might still have some alcohol in there, Ann said. You wanna get smashed?

No. I've spent too long moping already. There's too much work to be done. After that... I'll think about what I want to do.

In that case, you should head to Sterlingtown. I think they'll need our help the most.

Uh… no, no they really don’t need your help, Ann. Not with what your “help” has entailed this entire story.

Our... help.

Ann said nothing.

Oh, so we are going to see Poppy raze a town to the ground onscreen. Wonderful.
780304054227435550.png


It was the same thing for miles—heaps of slate-gray rock like old wreckage. The plants that gripped the flatter parts of the ground resembled overgrown club moss more than plants, patchy like balding hair. Rue wondered if his fur would get like that if he kept going without food. He glanced back, at his black stripes and puffy (though drooping) tail that were characteristic of a growlithe. He wasn't exactly balding yet, but there was a certain dullness in his coat like it had been washed out with soap and dried in the summer sun. He felt colder than he would have a month ago, and he thought maybe that had to do with it. Or it could have been his flagging metabolism.

… Wasn’t expecting us to get new named characters introduced this late into the story, but hewwo pupper. Even if you’re obviously not doing well.

"You alright, man?"

Rue glanced at his partner, Plumeria. The shaymin had slipped beside him without him noticing—he had been staring at the ground too much, apparently. Rue gave a weak nod in response to Plumeria's question.

Plumeria: “... Okay, I probably should’ve been more specific with my definition of ‘alright’, since you… look more than a little terrible right now.” .-.

Plumeria frowned. "I don't think you really are. You want to stop for a bit?"

Rue didn't have the strength to say no. He dropped his pouch on the ground and took a deep breath as he leaned against a nearby boulder.

"There you go." Plumeria walked up next to Rue and leaned against him.

"A hundred and fifteen fucking miles," Rue breathed, his head swimming.

Plumeria: “... Wait, what? What on earth would compel you to travel so far?” .-.

"I know it's been hard, Rue, but we're almost at the end. You've really hung in there. I'm impressed by it—seriously."

Rue didn't try to stop his tears. He flung his forearms around Plumeria and squeezed him tight like a teddy bear. His companion's scent—fresh and grassy with hints of citrus and coconut—didn't belong in such a rugged place. If Rue closed his eyes, he could imagine himself on a tropical beach, basking in warm sun. A brief escape from the bleak chill of this northern climate, from winds that pierced his fur like a weavile's frozen claws. "Thank you, Plumeria," he gasped.

Only when he felt too tired to keep crying did Rue release his companion. He wiped his eyes as he took in Plumeria's expression—a painfully sympathetic one. He leaned in gently toward Plumeria, and the two of them closed their eyes as they touched noses.

Well, Rue’s certainly having a normal one there. Though what on earth did he go through on his journey to reduce him to a state like this? .-.

Then an otherworldly bellow rang out across the mountains, shaking the ground beneath Rue and Plumeria's feet. It sounded like a herd of tortured cows.

Plumeria whipped his head around. "What was that?"

Stars filled Rue's vision as he rushed to grab his bag, nearly slipping on the loose stones below. "I'd bet money it's our client," he said. "And by the sound of it, he's not doing so hot. Let's go!"

… What sort of client would you have that would make a godawful racket like that?
701085210766344223.png


The two rescuers hurried toward the noise. Running was painful for Rue in his current state, and if he had anything left in his stomach he might have vomited. If his legs hadn't been twice as long as Plumeria's, he'd have had no chance of keeping up.

Eventually, the crash site came into view. The raft's shattered logs were piled up like a haphazard dam, and mist sprayed into the air as water crashed against the wood. The river roared as though enraged by the foreign blockage.

Rue: “That… doesn’t look like a good sign for our client there.”
916590486356131850.png

Plumeria: “... Maybe he got off in time?”

Rue slowed, scanning the area as he approached the riverbank. "Aspen! Where are you?!" From the corner of his eye, he glimpsed taupe fur slinking behind a boulder. He glanced back at Plumeria. "Someone's over there."

"I saw. Let's check it out."

Rue and Plumeria approached, giving their target a wide berth. The first thing they noticed was the lycanroc, who, judging by his raised hackles and defensive stance, was not happy to see them.

"S-stay away!" the lycanroc growled, stepping back. His voice sounded young. "He's mine!"

Rue wasn't sure who the lycanroc was referring to—until he noticed the corpse beside him. A torso as thick as a tree trunk; fur of brown and cream; antlers wreathed in leaves, rusty red and withered along the edges. Flies buzzed around the sawsbuck's glassy eyes, eager to fill their bellies with carrion.

Oh, so things are desperate enough that townies in the setting are being reduced to feeding off each other’s corpses now like ferals. That’s… a lovely thought.

It couldn't have been a coincidence. It had to be Aspen.

Rue looked into the lycanroc's eyes; he shrank slightly. "Clearly you're no feral," Rue said. "Just what on earth happened here?"

"L-look, he was injured when I got to him—I thought he was just gonna die anyway, alright? I didn't realize a-a rescue team was gonna come for him..."

Scratch the ‘feeding off each other’s corpses’. We’ve moved onto straight up hunting each other. Poppy, what on earth did you and Ann do to reduce things to this state? o_o;

Rue glanced down at his pouch—the lycanroc must have noticed the badge pinned on the front.

"So you killed... our client..." Plumeria's gaze alternated between the lycanroc and the corpse.

"P-please don't arrest me! I'm just... I..." The lycanroc locked eyes with Rue. "Please, you're a carnivore! You have to understand! All of us are starving at home, and I came all the way out here just to find something to eat. None of us can afford to buy meat, so... so..." He looked away and shut his eyes, dropping his defensive posture.

Plumeria: “You do realize that we travelled 115 miles for this, right?”
Lycanroc: “I-I didn’t know, I swear!” O_O;

Rue didn't want to believe the lycanroc, but further inspection seemed to support his claims. His ribs and spine were visible even from meters away, and his waistline had begun its gradual retreat into oblivion.

"Let me take a wild guess here," Rue said. "Did it have something to do with a leafeon?"

The lycanroc's eyes snapped open wide, and he nodded vigorously. "Y-yes! She threatened us, said we couldn't mine anymore! She... she was scary. Nobody could stand up to her..."

You see, I knew that something like this would happen after Poppy smashed up the mine. Though how many mining towns has she destroyed at this rate? Since if she’s done enough in, then civilization as a whole has likely been unraveling from all of this.
780304054227435550.png


Rue nodded gravely. "Right. Same thing happened in our town. Trashed our whole economy..." He sighed. "Honestly, the only reason we took on this mission was because we were desperate. Something this long-range should have been left up to fliers. But we figured we might find some critters along the way that haven't already been hunted, and make at least some money..."

"B-but... How were you going to bring him back? Surely he's too heavy?"

Rue: “I mean, it’s kinda a moot point now, but…”

"Yeah. This was supposed to be more of a... I guess, guarding mission than an escort. Aspen was stuck out here alone, and the only reason anyone knew was because he sent out a carrier pigeon. We weren't supposed to bring him back, just treat his injuries and keep him safe until they could gather up some proper fliers to carry him. Awful lot of trouble to go through, but apparently his friends were really invested."

The lycanroc winced.

"Sorry. Look, bottom line is: I get what you're dealing with. We're not going to arrest you. Even if we wanted to, we couldn't haul you all the way back to town. So just... Hm..." Rue sat down and considered his options.

"We can't... just let him go," Plumeria said. "He... he killed a pokemon..."

Rue: “I mean, technically we can and just pretend that we never saw anything. Since… I admittedly don’t know how I’m going to feel ruining the life of the equivalent of a starving teenager.” ^^;

The lycanroc's wince deepened.

Rue shrugged. "What do you propose, then? We can't arrest him, and there's no point in charging a fine if he doesn't have any money. He's not even from our town. And Aspen's already dead."

Plumeria's horrified face gradually slackened, conveying sadness, then resignation. He sat down. "I... I guess you're right."

Rue: “See, like I said. Just pretend we never saw anything, Plumeria.”

"But, with that said..." Rue looked at Aspen again and swallowed.

"Rue? What is it?"

Rue looked up to the heavens, to the dark swirling clouds above, and grit his teeth. "Well... Aspen's, uh, pretty big. I mean, it's not like... you could just... um... finish him in one go..."

Plumeria: “Rue! What the hell?!
Rue: “Look, in case if you haven’t noticed, but I’m not exactly doing well in the ‘food’ department myself, civilization’s collapsing, and there’s meat literally just sitting here right in front of me. It’s unpleasant, but seriously, can you blame me here?”
916590528802480208.png


The lycanroc furrowed his brow, and then a look of realization passed across his face. "Y-yeah, I mean, if you want to share..."

Rue glanced at Plumeria, but the shaymin was looking away.

"I-I'll just, um, search the crash site to see if we can salvage anything, then..." Plumeria took a ragged breath, as though he were sick. "Just go ahead and, uh, let me know when you're... done..."

Plumeria: “I’m… just going to go off this way. And try not to have nightmares when I go to sleep tonight.”

Plumeria shuffled away toward the water, leaving Rue and the lycanroc alone. The two of them looked at each other with the same pained expression.

Then, out of nowhere, Rue felt something he hadn't felt in a long time. He shook his head, knowing it was too late to hide the smile on his face.

The lycanroc gave a quiet chuckle, and Rue responded in kind. It was the beginning of an absurd resonance, a mutual catharsis. The two pokemons' laughter slowly intensified until it became painful, and tears escaped their eyes. The sound was harsh, staccato, like a fragmented scream.

And then it wrapped back around to crying after they realized what a miserable, pathetic situation the two of them are in. Or at least that’s the vibe that I got from things.

Though it made him dizzy to even pick up his head, Rue looked out the window at the familiar, dusty road and the crooked, slapdash buildings that looked like cardboard cutouts. Hardly anyone was in town anymore, and those that remained were mostly grass types who could photosynthesize. The few carnivores were emaciated and shambled along the road like living corpses.

Wait, was this entire region based around a mining economy? Or did Poppy graduate on from kicking over mining towns to anything that so much as sneezed on the environment? Since you technically don’t need mined materials to run a civilization, so…


Rue was hungry. Ever since Aspen, he had been having fantasies. He imagined bursting out the door and sinking his teeth into one of those servine's throats, feeling the warm blood fill his mouth. They would be easy to eat, he thought—he'd hardly have to worry about the arms or legs. Just tear it open and get right at the organs. Then he would peel away the flesh, rib by rib, and swallow it down like jerky. It would be better than that, even; raw meat was so much softer, so much more mellow to the tongue. After Aspen, Rue had felt a sense of glowing satisfaction, of vibrant pleasure... Maybe it was just because it had been his first proper meal in weeks, but either way, he wanted to feel that way again.

Oh, so there were side effects to feeding off of Aspen’s corpse. Is that how ferals in this setting come about? Since maybe I’m reading into things a bit too much, but that last sentence there… .-.

Other carnivores in town had already given in to the temptation and killed a few on the sly. If Rue was going to do it, it would have to be now, before he grew any weaker... The thought tortured him. He wanted to hold out for as long as he could, but if it meant condemning himself to an agonizing death...

It was probably too late, anyway, he thought. He couldn't walk around outside for more than a few minutes without fainting—he doubted he could kill someone now, even if they were a grass type.

… Just how skin and bones is this Growlithe right now? How on earth is he even able to journey like this? ._.;

Rue's thoughts were interrupted by the sound of Plumeria's hurried footsteps outside. He turned toward the door as Plumeria opened it. He knew he would never eat his partner, but that didn't stop him from salivating at the thought.

Plumeria approached and dropped off his catch—a single mouse—by Rue's bedside. "I'm sorry I don't have more," Plumeria said as he shrank back. "If I could figure out how to fly, I know I could hunt farther out. The traps just aren't effective, since there's so little game left... so... I'm gonna stay out as long as I can and see what I can do." He turned around to leave.

… I’m starting to think that Poppy really did just destroy everything that so much as sneezed on the surrounding environment given that the amount of huntable game in the wilderness has apparently collapsed from what seems to be implied overhunting. .-.

"Plumeria."

He stopped. "What is it?"

Rue took a breath. "Can you come here for a second?"

Plumeria approached timidly, like a child expecting punishment.

Oh no. Rue, you can’t. You wouldn’t...

Rue looked into Plumeria's emerald eyes, which glinted with nascent tears. "Listen... This isn't working. It's the same thing for everyone." He paused to catch his breath—even talking made him dizzy now. "I'm going to die either way. It doesn't matter what we do. So I've been thinking... We may as well get it over with."

Plumeria recoiled. "Rue, what are you saying?! You can't just give up like that! I know it's difficult, but—"

"Plumeria. Please understand... It's just worse for everyone if there's more hunters, and I don't want to suffer anymore. Do you really think we have a chance of getting through this? Answer me honestly."

… That’s not what I was expecting, but that’s even worse. And that entire back and forth is just such a
401083507872366598.png
mood.

"I-I-I... If I just..."

"Plumeria."

Plumeria shut his eyes and shook his head. "I'm not giving up on you! I'll stay out and hunt all night if that's what I have to do. So just... just hang in there!" He turned around and rushed out the door, slamming it against its hinges. Rue didn't even have time to call out to him.

Rue curled up slowly, too exhausted to cry.

Yeah, I’ll heavily take the under on these two getting a happy ending together.

Hours passed with Rue in a dull haze, somewhere between wakefulness and sleep. When he saw a burst of light from beneath his eyelids, he wasn't sure if it was a dream or not.

An unfamiliar voice spoke, as soft and cold as falling snow. "Poor creature," it said. Not the worst words to hear before the end.

Rue: “W-Wait, where on earth am I? Who is that?”

Plumeria kicked up loose stones as he galloped down the mountain path, heedless of the steep drop to his left. His fur glowed green as he neared his target. The leafeon turned her head just a moment before impact and froze, her eyes wide as though with shock. If Plumeria hadn't seen her kill a sneasel just a moment before, he might have thought he had the wrong pokemon.

Despite his smaller size, Plumeria struck Poppy hard enough to knock her down. He quickly sank his teeth into her neck—or tried to, but for some reason he couldn't quite pierce her skin.

:uhhh:


Oh. Oh this is totally going to end well given that Poppy’s got the power of a death god coursing through her and can just casually hack just about anyone she comes across apart.

Plumeria reeled his head back and cried out as flecks of green light gathered around him. The flecks formed into crescent-shaped leaves and slammed into Poppy. All shattered as soon as they made contact, shrouding the area in a green mist.

"You monster!" Panting with exertion, Plumeria feebly slammed his paws into Poppy's face. Her expression hadn't changed since he had first seen it.

Poppy: “Monster? Is that what you call bothering to give a crap about the environment?”
796822964019527760.png

Plumeria: “This stopped being about the environment! Just look at the world that you’ve left behind around you!”

Plumeria began to prepare another attack, but then Poppy brushed him aside like a blanket and stood up. She looked straight into Plumeria's eyes, not bothering to shake the dust off her fur.

"Where did you come from?" Her voice was strange—severe, but tremulous.

Plumeria stepped back. "What? Who cares! You killed Rue—and I'm not going to let you just get away with it!"

401083507872366598.png


Oh, so that was the voice that Rue heard. I see Poppy has officially moved along to “whelp, they were gonna die anyways, time to move onto mercy killing” as the barrier for ganking Pokémon at this point. I mean, I kinda figured that things would be a slippery slope for her, but it’s still jarring to see just how far along she’s gone from the bright-eyed Leafeon identifying flowers in the field with Lavender.

Plumeria charged again, but this time Poppy sidestepped. Plumeria stumbled as he regained his balance.

"There's nothing I can do to bring your friend back," Poppy said. "You're going to have to move on."

Plumeria turned to Poppy again and bared his teeth. "Are you crazy? Just move on and let you have your way? As if!" He let loose with razor leaf, and the projectile burst apart against Poppy's head like a wave crashing against stone.

Plumeria: “Who the hell are you to decide that anyways? Who made you god here?!”
Poppy: “... I’m pretty sure that Ann has, but the story hasn’t exactly come out about who she is, huh?”
720106605982646283.png


There was a moment of silence while Plumeria tried to catch his breath.

"I..." Poppy started to say something, but then she looked away.

"What's wrong with you?!" Plumeria accused. "Have you nothing to say for yourself? Nothing to say after ruining so many lives?"

Poppy: “Maybe those lives should’ve tried not ruining the planet!
796822964019527760.png


Poppy sighed, deflating. "You've seen it yourself... Desperate carnivores preying on other pokemon. Even the more... self-sufficient species, like you and I. It's not right."

Okay, so we’ve officially graduated from “destroying mining towns” to genociding entire chunks of the food chain amid ecological collapse. That’s… quite the progression for Poppy there.
916590486356131850.png


"That's because of your actions!"

"I know. And I'm cleaning up my mess."

Plumeria: “Are you even listening to yourself?! How on earth is this cleaning up anything?!

Plumeria charged Poppy once more, only to be sidestepped again.

"Please try to understand," Poppy said. "I'm trying to make the world a better place, and violence is the only tool I have. I'm sure Rue was a good—"

"Shut up! You know nothing about him!" Plumeria hastily wiped his eyes, smearing tears and dirt across his face. "He was a beautiful pokemon! He took me in when I had no one else. He risked his life for me... So many times! We rescued dozens of pokemon together, and he never complained when I messed up, never asked for—"

Uh… yeah, you really didn’t know Rue, Poppy. So I’m not sure how on earth you could’ve ever hoped to make that appeal to Plumeria there and succeed.

"Alright," Poppy said. "I get it. I understand."

"—for anything from anyone!" Plumeria stepped forward, stomping his paw. "He took requests for free! And when we found someone too hurt to take care of, he stayed by their side until the very end, just to keep them company, and—"

"I get it," Poppy said, grimacing. "Look, str—"

I mean, really? What did you expect, Poppy?

"—And he slept beside me when I had nightmares, even when he didn't want to!" Plumeria's voice was hoarse from shouting by now, but it didn't stop him. "He made fun of himself to make me laugh! And when he was bedridden and starving—"

"Alright!" Poppy laid down and put her paws over her ears. "Shut up! I get it!"

578077337728450560.png


No, I really don’t think that you did get it, Poppy. Least of all from the way that you’ve basically set a rolling ecological collapse in motion and are going around haphazardly trying to shore things up in ways that will just kick the can down the road.

"—he wanted me to kill him, so there would be more food left for everyone else! That's the pokemon you—"

"Shut up!"

Plumeria didn't see the attack that sent him flying, falling upside-down off the side of the mountain. His mind and body froze. He watched the ridge above fade into the distance, eyes wide with terror, even as the sun burned its image into the back of his skull like some celestial cattle prod. Seconds passed as the mountainside sped past, rocks and shrubs and grasses blurring together. Surely he should have hit the ground already. It should be over. He didn't want to die, but anything would be better than this interminable wait…

… Oh, so Poppy’s now moved onto “you annoyed me too much” as sufficient grounds to kill others, huh? .-.

Out of the corner of his eye, Plumeria saw something—a vine—extend toward him and wrap around his waist. He felt tension, and his descent began to slow. He couldn't see how far he was from the ground when he finally stopped falling, and he was too afraid to check. The vine gripped tightly as it raised him up, but even so, he was terrified to move lest he somehow break loose. He let himself breathe again when, after what seemed like minutes, Poppy finally deposited him back onto the mountain path.

Poppy slumped against a nearby rock, her eyes out of focus. She looked shell-shocked. "God... I thought you could fly…" She put a paw to her head.

… I just realized, but Skarmory couldn’t fly earlier because the planet’s energy had weakened. Poppy has taken from said energy at least once.

… Was it really just once that she took from it? Or has she been hitting it up before every one of these missions of hers?
909223973412290560.png


Plumeria had forgotten about his mission, about vengeance. He gasped for breath in a trembling heap. Was he crying? He wasn't sure. He was a victim of his own body, his own racing heart and clenching muscles. All he could do was plead silently for them to calm down.

They did eventually, of course, but it was slow going. When Plumeria finally stood up, Poppy turned to face him again.

"Are you okay?" The sincerity in Poppy's voice was uncomfortable; Plumeria felt like his insides were squirming.

"I'm fine," he said as he stepped back.

Plumeria: “I-I mean, I’m obviously not. B-But there’s nothing that I can do here. For gods’ sakes, just go away and leave us all alone here!”

"Good. I'm sorry about that. It's best I go." Poppy closed her eyes as her body began to glow.

"No you don't!" Plumeria charged Poppy once again, and this time he caught her off guard and brought her to the ground. Her glow faded away.

"For heaven's sake," Poppy said with a joyless laugh. "Just what exactly is it now?"

"I can't figure out how to stop you if I can't keep track of you. I can't just let you run away."

Poppy: “... Do you have a death wish or something? In case if you haven’t noticed, but you’re not exactly going to beat me in battle here.” >:|
Plumeria: “Look, I’ve been tracking you for weeks. Rue died for this mission! I can’t just go back with nothing to show for it!”

Poppy hesitated for a while, then gently brushed Plumeria off. She turned around and headed in the opposite direction as before.

"Huh?" Plumeria said as he began to follow. "Where are you going?"

"I know a place you might like."

… Wait, is that the Shaymin village? Or…?

Long stretches passed with Poppy seemingly lost in thought; she spoke up only to ask if Plumeria needed to stop for rest or water. Even the birdsong was hushed, as though afraid to disturb her deliberations. At first Plumeria didn't like the silence because it gave him time to think. But he slowly grew numb to it, and at times he forgot he was traveling beside the person who had killed Rue.

Days passed until the duo reached their destination. The terraces along the mountainside were wide and lush with unfamiliar vegetation, reminding Plumeria of just how far he was from home. He could see specks of movement near the bottom of the valley, where there seemed to be—of all things—a little meadow peppered with orchid-pink flowers and small straw huts. In the center was a small, clear pond.

"We're here," Poppy said. "Let's go say hi."

… Wait, that is the Shaymin village. So have they just all been happily oblivious to their defender causing societal collapse off away from home all this time, or…? ^^;

The two descended, until eventually Plumeria saw that the specks below were in fact shaymin like him, gliding about near the ground. One of them noticed the duo and flew swiftly toward them. He seemed interested in Poppy.

"Poppy!" he exclaimed, grinning. "You're back! And you brought a companion? Anyway, come on down—I'm going to go tell the others you're here." He turned and departed as fast as the wind.

"Poppy?" Plumeria said to her. "Is that your name?"

"Yes." Her voice was quiet.

Plumeria: “... Our entire civilization has seriously imploded because of a ‘mon named after a flower?
Poppy: “Look, you can stop being so judgemental, okay?” >_>;

When they reached the bottom of the valley, there were at least a dozen shaymin waiting for them, land and sky form both. They swarmed Poppy as soon as she was on level ground, nuzzling her, hugging her, all but inundating her with affection. A chorus of "How are you"s and "We missed you"s that lasted for minutes.

"I'm fine," Poppy said. She nuzzled one of the shaymin back gently, eyes closed. "It's good to see you all again."

Plumeria wanted to believe Poppy was being insincere—that she didn't really care about the shaymin here, or about anyone. But as a shaymin himself, he sensed her overflowing gratitude, as warm as the blood in his veins. Nor did he think she could feign the fragility in her voice as she thanked each of her companions for their effusive regards.

Plumeria: “... None of them know about what’s going on outside of this forest, do they?” .-.
Poppy: “Why should they? This place is paradise for them. Why would they need anything from outside of it?”
476581281094828033.png


One of the unoccupied shaymin noticed him. "How are you doing?" he asked, a little concerned. "You look like you've seen a ghost."

Plumeria opened his mouth and found he didn't know what to say. "It's... It's been a long trip, I guess..." He couldn't take his eyes off Poppy. "Did she, uh, used to live here?"

The shaymin laughed. "She didn't tell you? She found us by accident a while ago, stayed a month or two, but she helped us tremendously with some pollution problems we were having at the time."

Plumeria: “She… didn’t tell you about what she did to solve those pollution problems, did she?” >_>;
Shaymin: “Wait, you mean there was more than her just shutting down the mine upstream?” ^^;

"But shaymin can cleanse pollution, can't th- can't we?"

The other shaymin nodded. "Well, sure, but this was something else—you wouldn't believe how bad it was. We had to-"

"Hey, Clover!" another shaymin interrupted. "Is that Poppy's friend?"

A group came up to introduce themselves, and before he knew it, Plumeria was too busy with small talk to worry about Poppy. The shaymin of this valley were apparently very curious, and their interest in him only seemed to grow when he explained that he had forgotten most of his past.

So Plumeria’s an amnesiac, huh? Wonder what the story behind that one is, since as late into the story things have gotten, this is a story that vibes heavily after PMD… so…

Then Poppy spoke up. Her eyes were wet when Plumeria turned to look at her. "Everyone, um, if I may, I would like to take a moment to talk to my acquaintance in private before we get settled in."

The shaymin who had not yet talked to Plumeria turned now to look at him. "Oh, who is this? Is he your boyfriend?" one asked teasingly.

Plumeria: “Pls no.” >.<
Clover: “Hey, don’t knock it! I think you two would be great for each other!” ^^;

Poppy's laughter was muted but deep, and it disturbed Plumeria because it sounded sincere. Like a real pokemon. "No," she said. "I was actually hoping he could live here for a while, if that's alright—but we'll have to talk about some things first." She gestured toward Plumeria. "Come on."

The shaymin made way for Plumeria, and he followed Poppy to a small cave on the other side of the meadow. The sounds of the villagers' cheery conversations grew muffled as they stepped into the shadows.

"Do they know that you're... killing pokemon?" Plumeria asked.

"They don't need to," Poppy said as she situated herself. "Though I can't stop you if you decide to tell them. Anyways, listen." She looked into his eyes. "I... like this place, so I'm going to be visiting from time to time. If you stay here, you'll see me again soon enough—you won't have to keep following me. You'll have all the time you need to think of a way to kill me or whatever, and you'll have a chance to make some friends in the meantime. The shaymin here are very kind." She exhaled. "It's the best solution I can think of for both of us. What do you say?"

Plumeria: “... Okay what’s the catch here? Since there is no way there isn’t some sort of horrible trick to all of this.” [what]

"...I don't trust anything you've said."

"Why not?"

"Well, you did just admit to lying to those shaymin..."

"Do you think I shouldn't have?"

Plumeria: “Yes, obviously.” >_>;

The way she just... stared into his eyes was unnerving. "Uh... Yeah, I guess I do. You ought to be held accountable for your actions."

"If I tell them the truth, it benefits nobody." She shook her head—was that contempt in her voice? "But whatever. I know of nothing I could say that would change your mind." She walked past Plumeria. "I'll be staying the night," she said as she left the cave. "So you have until morning to decide whether or not you'd like to stay here."

Plumeria: “Poppy, this entire bucolic paradise is literally built on lies along with mass death and suffering!” >.<
Poppy: “Well, it keeps a village of cute Shaymin protected and happy, I’d call that a fair trade, really. So, are you going to take me up on my offer or what?”

For the first time in days, Plumeria was in no rush to follow Poppy. He thought for a while. Poppy was a bad pokemon, but she didn't hate him. The thought made him uncomfortable, but it occurred to him that to some degree, maybe he was being unfair to her.

:uhhh:


Is there some sort of mental suggestion field around this place or something that gets others to let their guards down around Poppy? Since, I’m more than a little bit concerned that this guy is suddenly feeling this way about a ’mon that killed his best friend in cold blood.

Plumeria wished he could talk to Rue about this. He... Maybe he wouldn't know what to do, exactly, but at least it would give him something, some point of reference...

Plumeria heard footsteps and realized he had been lying in this cave for a while. He looked up to see a shaymin approaching.

"Ah, hello, Plumeria," the shaymin said cautiously. "Poppy said you might be upset, so I decided to come check up on you. Are you alright?"

Plumeria: “... Okay, seriously, what’s in the water here such that I’m suddenly not thinking about how much I hate Poppy’s guts right now?” .-.
Shaymin: “... Just pure water? That is what makes it healthy for you and me.” ^^;

"Oh, sorry if I worried everyone. I'll be okay. I need to think for a while."

"Okay—I can show you some good thinking spots that would be more comfortable, if you like."

If he wanted to, Plumeria could tell this shaymin all about Poppy right now. It was a tempting prospect, if only because it would free him from his deliberations. But something in the shaymin's face stopped him. "Thanks," he said. "Just anywhere quiet would be fine."

701085210766344223.png


… I have no idea what on earth is going on, but I really don’t like it.

The next morning, Plumeria found Poppy gazing into a stream. She dipped her paw in and then watched it drip dry, as though fascinated by the look of the water.

"Hey, Poppy..."

She started, then turned around. "Oh, Plumeria. Have you made your decision?"

He gave a downcast sigh. "Yeah. I mean, I guess I never really thought I could stop you anyway. So I'll just stay here..."

… Plumeria, what are you doing?

"And you've decided not to tell them about me after all?"

He grimaced. "I know I really ought to. But..." He shook his head. "I don't know why I can't. I'm just a coward, I guess."

Poppy looked at him critically. "Don't say that. I don't think you're a coward."

whywouldyoudothat.jpg


Plumeria, even if there’s nothing that can be done to stop Poppy, those other Shaymin deserve to know what on earth is going on out there.

Plumeria looked at Poppy with bewilderment. "Poppy, I just..." He frowned. "I don't know what you'll make of this, but I think there's a good pokemon inside you somewhere."

Yeah, no. I’m sorry, that ship sailed back in Chapter 10. Poppy is literally causing long-term ecological collapse right now. Whatever her intentions, she’s stopped being a good Pokémon a long time ago.

"I know that. That's why I'm changing the world."

Plumeria sighed. "Right. Of course. But..." He slumped onto the ground and put his paws over his head defeatedly.

"I think I had better go. The sooner you forget about me, the better."

Plumeria: “... So that’s really how I’m going to let things go, huh?”

Poppy's body began to glow, and this time Plumeria just watched her vanish. He felt like there were a dozen things he should have said, should have done, but he didn't know what they were.

"Hey! Plumeria!"

Before long one of the shaymin called his name, which made him chuckle despite himself. Were they worried about him again?

Plumeria took a breath and stood up. "I'll be right there!" he called, and trotted toward the village.

Plumeria: “... You know what? Yeah. Screw it, I’m staying in my happy little bubble here. Not like there’s anything else I can do anyways.”

Chapter 13

Patches of rusty red and mossy green patterned the base of the butterfly wing like shrubs reclaiming a mountainside; a line of white, like clouds along the horizon, preceded the gradient of honey yellow and tangerine scales that lined the edge. Poppy cocked her head at the two tailed pasha as it landed on a nearby cinnamon fern.

"Surprised to see you all the way out here, little one. Have you strayed from home as well?" She reached into her pouch with her vines, pulled out an apricot, and squished it. Juice dripped to the ground as she gently placed the fruit near the butterfly. "Here's something you might appreciate. I have no need of it, myself, so don't feel bad."

… Boy is that a dark reprise of the first chapter, knowing that Poppy’s at the very least destroyed civilization at this point to get to this cute little moment with her butterflies.

She watched the butterfly feed for a while before turning her gaze toward the marsh beside her. Red winged blackbirds perched with grace on spindly reeds, and the water reflected the sky so clearly that Poppy could see individual clouds. Spring peepers chirped away invisibly, like a chorus of newborn chicks, and the shelducks honked and purred as though with laughter caught in their throats. Poppy admired the birds' autumnal plumage and the graceful curve of their necks. She didn't mind that her fur was damp.

Would now be a good time to catch up? asked Ann.

Why is she still here?! Seriously, go away already!
401076862924750848.png


Yeah. I guess so.

Ann—its avatar, rather—materialized next to Poppy and laid down beside her a couple meters away. "So, how are you?"

"Genuinely, I'm happy for all the destruction we've averted, but... this whole thing has got me thinking about carnivores. The civilized ones, anyway. They were hit hardest by my... policies. Ethically sourcing food for such pokemon is a real challenge, and I'm not sure how to approach it. But it makes me wonder..." She sighed. "Um..."

794.jpg


I’m sorry, seriously. Sod off, Poppy. You don’t get to cause mass destruction and dismiss it as “oh, we stopped even greater destruction”.

"What is it? I promise I won't make fun of you if I think it's silly."

She sighed yet again. "Let me put it this way. If I were to recreate the world from scratch, I'm not sure I would have any reason to include carnivores at all. I just..." She shook her head. "I don't know. What would you do in my place, Ann?"

Poppy, oh my god. Can you not right now?

Ann nearly buried its face in the fur of its chest as it laughed—or perhaps 'chittered' would be more accurate.

"Hm? What are we so coy about?"

"Sorry. Listen—I find joy in simple things, like watching the tide, or feeling the breeze on my face. I think we're quite similar in that way. But the phenomenon that we call 'life,' I think you'll agree, is far from simple. I would find the world so much more agreeable if it were removed, and in my true form, I could easily achieve that. But that would hardly be fair to you, now would it?"

Oh, so Ann really is Yveltal there. Since there’s only one Pokémon that’s that related to death in the franchise.

"Either way, it's not possible, right?"

"Presently, no. But there's something worth bringing up. As I mentioned, the realm in which I reside now is not natural; it was created to contain me. But the ones who did so are long gone now, and the bars of the prison are rusting away, so to speak. The deaths of pokemon accelerate the process, since they return energy to the planet for me to draw from. At this rate, I'll soon be able to break free and manifest my true form." Ann winked, and for an instant its eyes seemed to change to a bright, vivid blue—but then it blinked again, and the effect was gone.

Yuuuuuuup, Ann is indeed Yveltal there. So all this time, she was manipulating Poppy in order to help speed things along so that she could get out of her prison.

"Oh. I see." Poppy took a deep breath. "Should I be scared?"

"You? No. Remember, I think of you as my partner. So, while my preference would be to purge the world fully, I recognize that's not what you want. However, we can both agree that some pokemon should not remain. So I think we can easily reach a compromise. Maybe we get rid of everyone who pollutes, or who lives in a city. Maybe we add carnivores, too. Maybe we get rid of all the other species and let shaymin rule the earth." It smirked. "It won't necessarily be fair, but if we do something like that, the world should come out more peaceful in the end. And that would be enough for me."

I’d scream at Poppy that she’s very obviously being mindgamed here, but I think she is way, way too far gone to be worth the effort here.

Poppy nodded faintly. "Yeah... As long as we can look back and be proud of the result..."

"That's what I've been thinking. But that's still a couple years off, so don't worry too much. In fact, I'll tell you what—why don't we do something fun tomorrow to unwind? Anything you want."

… Oh, so Poppy has singlehandedly put the world in a state where it’s got maybe a couple years of life left. And Xerneas is too weak to do anything about it. That’s just… wonderful.

"I don't know. I'll think about it."

Ann smiled. "Alright. Take your time."

Neither spoke for a while. The call of a bittern floated through the air, low notes like distant splashes.

"Ann..." Poppy said. "Thanks for being my partner."

Ann smiled again. "It's been an honor."

With nothing left to say, the two lay beside one another as the sun kissed the horizon.

And thus we have an answer to the question of the title: “Yveltal, along with Yveltal’s buddies that it feels like making exceptions for with that whole ‘scour the planet clean of life’ thing”.

Alright, time for the obligatory recap that I do for these things:

Well, I certainly wasn’t expecting that to be the ending note that things left on. It’s definitely one of the darker pieces that I’ve read since the fundamental narrative is a well-meaning Pokémon getting manipulated by a death god into getting her wishes to right a pervasive injustice warped into something much more sinister. But at the same time, as bleak as the ending was, and as much as Poppy wound up making me scream at the screen towards the end as she just gets more and more permissive with who she’s willing to consign to death to the point where she’s ready to genocide entire species, including those of most of her one-time friends, for the crime of being carnivorous and unable to sustain themselves in the world she created through her actions. At the same time, I can’t say that it didn’t feel like the final destination of the story wasn’t earned.

The main things that I didn’t like about this block basically boil down to a couple bits where I thought that there could be a bit more description, and that it might have been interesting to see a bit more of Poppy in her “I am become death, destroyer of worlds” phase which felt like it was handled in a very accelerated fashion in Chapter 12. I also wonder if it’d have made sense to hint more in the story as to what extent Poppy’s transformation is from things that part of her genuinely desired all along that she is getting empowered to pursue, and how much of it is from Ann’s influence and Poppy being unwilling to push her away. The story’s vibes change a bit depending on which of the two is the driver for that transformation, since on one end you’d have “Poppy was just a monster all along, and just needed power and an excuse to become one” and “Poppy was a well-meaning Pokémon, but got corrupted by a bad influence who stepped into her life at a bad moment”.

Either way, even if it was a bit disquieting, it’s definitely a really memorable short piece for those looking for a PMD-themed story, and I’m glad that I spent the time to read this story.

Congrats, @love . And good luck with your further writings.
 
Last edited:

love

Memento mori
Pronouns
he/him/it
Partners
  1. leafeon
It is review response time for @Spiteful Murkrow and @Adamhuarts

I still intermittently make changes to this story, but they're usually conservative. It will have the same fundamental problems for the foreseeable future, but I do still want to smooth things over where possible, and I think your review does help me there. Some day, if I get a big burst of inspiration, who knows what could happen.

I will post some changes to make it clearer that time has passed on the island and smooth some transitions.

The others don't notice Xerneas approaching because it teleported, so I will try to make that clearer. I think Lavender's irreverence toward Xerneas made more sense in earlier drafts, where her enthusiasm for myths wasn't firmly established.

The planet's energy took inspiration from Final Fantasy VII, but I'm sure the general idea predates both.

The ship destruction idea is an interesting one; I considered it while writing the first draft. I figured Poppy's reasoning was that that wouldn't send a strong enough message, which is sort of another way of saying that it wouldn't make for as satisfying revenge, like you said. But it would at least give her more time to buff up with Ann before doing something more dramatic. The only real reason I can give for why she didn't do it is that it wouldn't have been conducive to the kind of plot I want. Big Climactic Boss Fight(tm) was, at the time, the direction that seemed most workable to me.

Both swift and aura sphere miss more than hit in this story. So much for guaranteed hits.

I don't know if torching the forests would have been wise. Mining company et al. might suspect Poppy could detect the attempt remotely, and if she did, she'd warp over and shoot everyone down with swift and energy ball. I wonder how easy it would be to start a forest fire in a reasonably wet climate, anyway.

I always imagined that Poppy makes her own decisions without any mind control from Ann. I feel like it cheapens the narrative if she's being manipulated. If Ann could mind-control pokemon, it might have picked someone more powerful instead of someone who wasn't that strong but was already mostly aligned with it. Opinions are a little mixed on whether the story makes this clear. It's a little hard to prove that Ann *isn't* doing it.

I like to see Ann as a kind of subversion of the Faustian bargain trope—the reader *expects* the deal to come with strings attached, but it doesn't.

Anyway, thanks for reading the whole story. I am not good at review responses, but I have responded to the review. I have done my best.

I am glad that the basic stuff came across right in this first chapter. You have picked up on all the stuff I wanted to establish. I hope you like the rest of the story.
 

The Walrein

Vicinal Dragging for the Truth
Partners
  1. gulpin
  2. kricketot
  3. bulbasaur
I read this entirely in one sitting a few weeks ago - after I started, I felt compelled to see how it would end. The plot and themes were quite unique for a PMD story, and I enjoyed it! Poppy and Lavender's relationship was compelling, and I liked the segment from Rue's perspective in chapter twelve - it's rarer than it should be to explore the consequences of the protagonist's actions like that.

When it came, the ending felt rather abrupt - I was actually a little confused at first when I read past it and saw comments talking like the story was over. It felt like there was a still lot up in the air about what compromise Poppy would eventually reach with Ann, what would happen to Lavender, and if the rest of the world would have any more responses to Ann's genocidal ambitions. I suppose Earth at Peace does show us what eventually ends up happening, although it still leaves some questions about the ultimate fate of the world - are all the plants dependent on animals for seed dispersal or pollination going to die off? Will Ann or the Shaymin keep repeatedly smacking down the appearance of animals when they inevitably re-evolve from the remaining heterotrophic life?

There still felt like a pretty big gap between the two stories, though. Poppy's gradual escalation of violence felt pretty believable up until the end, but I'm not sure how she got from being fine with some predatory Pokemon dying to being ambivalent about the total destruction of all animal life modulo Shaymin. Also, it seemed kind of odd that Ann was apparently the only entity in the world capable of drawing upon the planet's energy to turbo-charge a bonded Pokemon - what happened to the beings which sealed Ann away in the first place? One of the key problems with the idea "What if I used violence to achieve my political goals?" is that you aren't the only person who's ever had that thought, and most likely a lot of value will be lost to negative-sum conflict if you go down that route. I think this would've gone down better for me if there was some explanation as to why Ann was the only one with this power, or if the epilogue hinted at some sort of lasting damage from the conflict over the fate of the world.

Also, you mentioned wanting to have Ann be a subversion of the faustian pact trope, but I think that subversions work best when there's a clear logic behind them, and in this case I really wasn't sure why Ann didn't simply betray Poppy and eliminate all life once she was out of her prison. Was it not possible for her to withdraw the power she'd already given Poppy, or was Ann just really into upholding her word, despite there being no evidence she cared at all about Poppy's extensive social contract breaking?

There were also a few details regarding the setting which were unclear. I wasn't sure why Xerneas' island had gone undiscovered up until the industrial era given the existence of flying and aquatic Pokemon, and the obvious nature of the unusual plant life there. I think it was vaguely implied that Xerneas had been concealing the island through some power which had now waned, but this could've been more explicit, given how important the question of whether the island's secrecy could be maintained was. Also, the planet's energy having a distribution of 'increases greatly near the source, but exactly equal everywhere else' isn't entirely natural-feeling, and I would've preferred some explanation on that.

Actually, it was kind of odd just how blasé everyone from the guild was upon first discovering Xerneas' island. You'd think that the question of "why are Pokemon powers slowly getting weaker over the years?" would be really important to these people, and that they'd be asking a lot of questions, but it seemed like they mostly just had a "huh, that's neat" reaction. In particular, one thing that they might want to clear up is whether there's a fixed amount of energy, like oil reserves, such that it'll all be used up eventually even with conservation efforts, or if it's a fixed power output, like the sun. I was pretty sure it was the latter, but it wasn't entirely clear. Lavender's immediate suggestion that they use the energy to make lightbulbs or automotives felt like something of a caricature of the 'technologist' mindset; you'd think she'd at least want to understand how exactly the energy works first! Those suggestions also don't feel particularly natural for this setting; given that the energy is known to fuel Pokemon powers, I'd assume the most obvious-seeming uses of it would be to do things like give Pokemon the powers of other species, or perhaps just restore lost abilities like Skarmory's flight. (Also, I suppose it's easy to be fine with the status quo of how energy is distributed when you're one of the lucky Pokemon with functional manipulative appendages, Poppy...) Another obvious avenue of investigation is whether it might be possible to generate more of this energy somehow, which I think would actually be the most stereotypically 'solutionist' thing to suggest. (I'm not very familiar with 'solutionism', but I think it means blindly assuming that all problems must have a strongly positive-sum solution?)

Despite my list of nitpicks, I did end up liking this fic. It has a haunting air to it, and I think I'll remember it for a long time. Unfortunately I think most of the fic's problems would require significant expansion to address, but it's understandable if you don't want to make any major changes to a finished work. Thanks for writing this, and I'll look forward to any new PMD stories you start.
 

love

Memento mori
Pronouns
he/him/it
Partners
  1. leafeon
@The Walrein

Thanks for reading, and I am glad that you enjoyed the story. Everybody seems to agree that this story needs to be expanded.

I like the idea of Xerneas concealing the island. I had not thought of that. At the same time, I'm not sure how improbable it actually is for it to naturally not have been discovered, given that pokemon are globally nerfed in this story.

I don't know whether I agree that technology isn't the first thing a pokemon in this story's world might think to use "magic" energy for—and I mean this in an "I *genuinely* don't know" kind of way, not in like a "I totally disagree but want to be polite about it" kind of way. It might make more sense for Lavender to get the idea of using the energy as a technological power source from a myth she read in which an ancient civilization did just that; I guess it would feel a little less out-of-the-blue that way. Regardless, I suspect, between your and Fobbie's feedback, that Lavender still acts too blase overall. It might go over better if I write her as excited to meet Xerneas and learn about the energy initially, but have her gradually sober up as she realizes that Xerneas—then later, Poppy—don't share her enthusiasm.

At first I agreed that the distribution of the planet's energy didn't make sense, but I don't know, maybe it does if you compare it to water flowing out of a geyser—the areas nearest the source will be wettest, but once you get far enough away, it doesn't make a difference.

I like to think that at least some of Ann's expressed attachment to Poppy is genuine, but I think it's fine if readers think otherwise. There are some arguments you can make both ways, but it doesn't feel like something you can prove conclusively, which is okay with me.

I made a slight change to the last chapter of the story (part of a batch of small changes I've been sitting on for a while and only recently posted) which exposits Poppy's feelings a bit—specifically, why she's basically okay with the apocalypse happening. Basically, it's relieving for her to hear that Ann is going to destroy most life, because it lets her tell herself that her fuckups don't matter so much in the end. That change might not suffice unless I also change the opening of chapter 13 to present her as more clouded by guilt. The current opening is sort of like "la la la, what a nice sunset, oh look, a pretty butterfly, isn't that neat"

Now I'm thinking it would be cool to make a oneshot from Xerneas' perspective that reveals stuff about the planet's energy in a less clumsy way. Bonus points if I somehow got backstory about the guild in there too, because that's one of the other gaping holes in this story. It's not that I don't want to expand Those Who Will Inherit the Earth—I think that would be pretty cool, actually—it's just that I never come up with good ideas (barring Earth at Peace, I guess), and also I just haven't generally felt like writing lately, and also have kind of been busy etc.

(Solutionism is the idea that technology can solve all problems btw.)
 

The Walrein

Vicinal Dragging for the Truth
Partners
  1. gulpin
  2. kricketot
  3. bulbasaur
Thanks for reading, and I am glad that you enjoyed the story.

You're welcome, thanks again for writing this!

I like the idea of Xerneas concealing the island. I had not thought of that. At the same time, I'm not sure how improbable it actually is for it to naturally not have been discovered, given that pokemon are globally nerfed in this story.

Hmm. I think how improbable it would be that no one's discovered the island yet depends on a number of factors:

1. How large are Pokemon populations? If they're roughly the same size as animal populations in our world, that would mean there's >=50 billion birds flying around, some smaller but still significant portion of which regularly fly overseas. And then if purely aquatic Pokemon or even just cetaceans can communicate with the land-living Pokemon, that's also a huge number of potential discoverers. If the total Pokemon population across all species is closer to that of the human population in our world, it's a bit more believable, although I still think the advantage of having access to transoceanic flight right from the start would mean things would get discovered a lot earlier than in our history.
2. How far away from everywhere else is the island? It would be easier to swallow that this land had gone unnoticed if it was extremely isolated like the Pitcairn Islands, but it's specifically mentioned that "[Xerneas'] island wasn't even that far from the guild".
3. How long have sapient Pokemon existed on the world for? Thousands of years? Tens of thousands? Hundreds? Millions? I took the existence of factories to imply that this was an industrial age world which has been around for at least as long as human civilization has existed in our world.
4. How severe is the 'nerfing'? It seems like even in the present day of the fic, avian Pokemon like Braviary are still capable of flight, even if some of the Pokemon for whom flight is less logical like Skarmory can't fly anymore. I think to make things plausible you'd actually need to nerf Pokemon to have worse capabilities than IRL animals, such as perhaps fliers simply not having the endurance for transoceanic flight because they have higher energetic requirements.

I think that just saying "Xerneas was concealing the island through some magic which has now failed" would be the easiest way of addressing the plausibility issue; the next-best alternative might be to just have the island be extremely isolated instead of relatively close to the guild, although you'd need an explanation of how Poppy and co. are getting there.

I don't know whether I agree that technology isn't the first thing a pokemon in this story's world might think to use "magic" energy for—and I mean this in an "I *genuinely* don't know" kind of way, not in like a "I totally disagree but want to be polite about it" kind of way. It might make more sense for Lavender to get the idea of using the energy as a technological power source from a myth she read in which an ancient civilization did just that; I guess it would feel a little less out-of-the-blue that way.

I'm also not really sure what the first purposes for the energy a Pokemon in this world would genuinely tend to reach for; I was less bothered by Lavender deciding that the energy should be used for technology in general so much as her choices being some of the exact same things that (widespread) electricity was first used for in our world (lighting and electric vehicles). Given that Lavender doesn't know anything about the energy indicating it would be more useful for such things than anything else, it feels like these are actually very specific choices, akin to someone responding to a question asking what superpowers they'd like to have with "spider-sense, being able to shoot webs out of my wrists, jumping really high and sticking to walls" without having ever heard of Spiderman before.

At first I agreed that the distribution of the planet's energy didn't make sense, but I don't know, maybe it does if you compare it to water flowing out of a geyser—the areas nearest the source will be wettest, but once you get far enough away, it doesn't make a difference.

I feel like this particular distribution model is one that could make sense if given a reason for it, but which is odd enough that it might be worth providing some explanation in text. If I had to pick something, I'd say that how much energy you receive depends on the amount and kind of material between you and the center of the planet, and that the rock directly beneath the island is of a kind that doesn't block the energy as much. I'm not sure a geyser is a great analogy, given that once you get sufficiently far away, you're receiving approximately zero water from the geyser, instead of a smaller but still significant amount, as in the fic.

I made a slight change to the last chapter of the story (part of a batch of small changes I've been sitting on for a while and only recently posted) which exposits Poppy's feelings a bit—specifically, why she's basically okay with the apocalypse happening. Basically, it's relieving for her to hear that Ann is going to destroy most life, because it lets her tell herself that her fuckups don't matter so much in the end. That change might not suffice unless I also change the opening of chapter 13 to present her as more clouded by guilt. The current opening is sort of like "la la la, what a nice sunset, oh look, a pretty butterfly, isn't that neat"

I do think this goes some way towards explaining Poppy's lack of resistance to the concept, and I think that presenting Poppy as being more guilty would also help. However, I think this is yet another thing that would work better if the fic was expanded, and we got to see Poppy gradually get more and more exhausted with repeatedly running around putting out fires created by her previous attempts to put out fires.

Now I'm thinking it would be cool to make a oneshot from Xerneas' perspective that reveals stuff about the planet's energy in a less clumsy way. Bonus points if I somehow got backstory about the guild in there too, because that's one of the other gaping holes in this story. It's not that I don't want to expand Those Who Will Inherit the Earth—I think that would be pretty cool, actually—it's just that I never come up with good ideas (barring Earth at Peace, I guess), and also I just haven't generally felt like writing lately, and also have kind of been busy etc.

I'd definitely be interested in reading that oneshot if you wrote it! Definitely sympathetic to never feeling like you have the time or motivation to write, and not expanding the story is very understandable.
 
Top Bottom