• Welcome to Thousand Roads! You're welcome to view discussions or read our stories without registering, but you'll need an account to join in our events, interact with other members, or post one of your own fics. Why not become a member of our community? We'd love to have you!

    Join now!

Pokémon Rivers of Asphodel

Chapter 1: Cross that Bridge and Start Anew

FennecWitch

Fiery Beacon
Pronouns
she/her
Cover PNG.png
Rivers of Asphodel:

Waking up in an unfamiliar body with no memories is hard enough on its own. It's even harder when the ones around you are so familiar you're sure you must have known them. And they can't remember their pasts, either.


Ensemble fic with a fair amount of POV switching. Pokémon Mystery Dungeon like world minus the mystery dungeons.


Major content warnings for body dysphoria and memory loss. More specific content warnings will be given at the beginning of each chapter.

A digital drawing of a Helioptile, a largely yellow lizard from the Pokémon series. She has a light blue cloth tied around her front left limb and is standing on her hind legs.
Helioptile Chloe

A digital drawing of a Brionne, a blue sea lion from the Pokémon series. She has a blue band around her right flipper and a grey stone on a chain hanging around her neck.
Brionne Daphne

A digital drawing of an Espeon, a purple quadrupedal mammal from the Pokémon series. He has a red bandanna tied around his neck, with an illegible nametag pinned to it, featuring a triangular insignia. His hind legs and tail are limp, and he is wearing a harness, attached to some poles that extend down to two wheels, on either side of his body.
Espeon Theseus

Nyx.png
Zorua Nyx

A map of a large, crescent-shaped island, with a few smaller islands surrounding it. Landmarks such as forests, mountains, and rivers are labelled with their names.
Landmarks of Asphodel

A map of a large, crescent-shaped island, with a few smaller islands surrounding it. Cities are marked and labelled with their names, and different states in the region are marked with different colours.
Settlements of Asphodel

Chapter 1: Cross that Bridge and Start Anew

Chapter title is from the song "Shine Through" by The Stupendium.

CW: Blood, body dysphoria, memory loss



In a very shallow part of the ocean, the fish swam. It was almost at the shore, not that it knew what that meant. What it did understand was that the water was growing quite shallow, and it needed to get back to deeper waters. Although its light, pale emerald scales almost let it blend in with the seawater itself, it was still alone, separated from its school. So it turned to make its way back out to sea.

A sudden rush of movement churned the water, sharp teeth closing around the fish's body. Sharp teeth sunk into its scales, dragging it back to shore before it could even process what had happened.

Pulling herself onto the beach, Daphne briefly dropped the wild Remoraid onto the sand, before grabbing it by the tail and flinging it into a nearby mesh bag, filled with similarly-caught fish. The fish was a bit smaller than she would’ve liked, but, then she supposed she was lucky to have found a lone Remoraid this close to shore. She didn’t have the time nor the desire to fight off a whole school of fish. And even if she did, there was no way she could carry that many back into town on her own. It would just be a waste of effort, unless she wanted to give the wild predators an easy snack. Besides, she needed one smaller catch today, anyway.

The Brionne turned back to the water, going far out enough in that she could wash around her mouth. She had mostly gotten used to the sight of blood over the past few years, but she still grimaced as she saw the traces of the red liquid around her muzzle. Her hair was thin enough that it wasn't too difficult to get it out, but most Pokémon didn’t like the sight of it. She got enough strange looks as it was from Pokémon unfamiliar with her species. Better to not give them more reason to stare at her.

Once she was clean enough to present herself to regular society, she went back to the shore and grabbed the bag full of fish. It wasn’t a particularly large bag, only able to hold about five fish Pokémon at most. But then, she wasn’t very large herself. This was about the biggest bag she could reasonably carry on her own.

Usually she'd take her wagon with her, but she'd managed to chip one of the wooden wheels on a tree root that she swore had never been there before. It shouldn't've been a difficult fix for the guild's carpenter, but they'd been apparently too busy working on things for the Legend Day festival and hadn't gotten around to it. Which was fine. Daphne hadn't exactly been catching enough fish to warrant hauling it around, anyway. She blamed the cold season starting.

She slung the bag over her shoulder, taking care not to disturb the smooth grey stone attached to a cord tied around her neck. She then checked to make sure the blue cloth band was still firmly attached to her flipper before heading to the path through the forest and back to town.

She turned to look behind her. The sun was getting low in the sky, the land below starting to be bathed in twilight. Daphne cursed under her breath. She definitely didn’t have enough time to get back before it grew completely dark. At least, not unless she skipped her detour, but that wasn’t happening.

Maybe she’d get some leniency on the curfew? Winter had now officially begun and the days were shortening so it wasn’t like she had as much time to get back as she would have in summer. All the same, she quickened her pace as much as she could while lugging a bag of fish behind her.

As she started to approach the edge of the forest, she turned off the main path, heading into an uneven area of brush. There wasn’t anything that could even generously be called a path. She moved around the thick plants on the ground in a practised route, until she reached a small cave.

Daphne could see fairly well in the dark, though the inside of the cave was dark enough that she could only make out vague shapes. She stopped outside the entrance, setting down her bag.

“Lily?” Daphne called out, softly. “You there?”

“Oh, um, just a second!” came a voice in return, before a somewhat disheveled-looking Lillipup slowly emerged from the entrance.

She looked up at Daphne. “You’ve got food for me?”

“Of course,” Daphne said, reaching into the bag with her mouth to grab the small Remoraid she had just caught and throwing it at the Lillipup’s feet. “Just the one this time, though. Since winter’s started it’s going to be harder for me to get them. But I’ll do what I can.”

“Thanks,” Lily replied, looking down at the fish, sniffing it cautiously. “I know you’ve said it’s fine for you to give up fish like this, but…”

Daphne snorted. “Hey, better this than you stealing from me again. Least like this I can plan for it.”

That had been an interesting day. She almost hadn't noticed the Lillipup secreting a fish out of her wagon until she'd disappeared back into the brush. A few streams of water in the thief's general direction had made her instantly drop the fish and start desperately apologising to Daphne. After realising how young and malnourished the Lillipup was, Daphne had decided she couldn't in good conscience let Lily starve.

Lily’s ears flattened against her head, her tail drooping. “I said I was sorry. I just… I needed food.”

“I know, I know,” Daphne said, sighing. “Besides, this one’s small enough that I don’t know if we’d even be able to sell it. You may as well take it.”

“Right,” Lily said, then looked up at the sky. “You’d better get back though, right? It’s almost dark.”

Daphne followed her gaze. It was hard to see much through the tree cover, but there was very little sunlight left by this point. Yeah, there was no way she was going to make it back before dinner ended. Unless she left right now, but she was pretty sure she was kidding herself.

She sighed, turning back to Lily. “Yeah, I should get going.”

“Okay. Thanks again,” the Lillipup replied, grabbing the Remoraid and starting to drag it into the cave.

“It’s nothing,” said Daphne, picking up her bag again. “If nothing comes up, I’ll see you tomorrow, okay?”

Lily nodded, her tail wagging slightly. “Okay!”

When she got back on the main path, Daphne moved forward, keeping her head down. It wouldn’t be that bad if she missed dinner for one night, right? It wasn’t like this was the first time it had happened, anyway. In fact, maybe she should just have one of these fish now, since there was no way she was getting back to the guild before dinner ended.

Probably better not to waste it, though.

She was almost out of the forest when her eyes happened to glance over at a flash of yellow on the side of the path. She blinked, then slowly approached it.

It looked like some kind of reptile. Yellow and black, which two long things that Daphne supposed could be ears coming off their head. She didn't see any clothing or a tag anywhere, so she might’ve just passed them off as a wild Pokémon. But she had a fairly good idea of the Pokémon that lived around here and this wasn’t a species she recognised at all. As she got closer she realised that they weren’t moving.

“Hey!” she called.

The Pokémon didn’t move.

A wave of dread washed over her, and she opened her mouth, letting loose a stream of water. The Pokémon began to move slightly and Daphne felt a weight come off her shoulders. What would she even have done with a dead body in the woods? Probably report it to someone, right? But there was no guarantee they’d get there before any wild predators would. Not that that mattered, anyway, because this Pokémon wasn’t dead.

Still, they hadn’t opened their eyes yet. Daphne set down her bag and touched the lizard’s back with a flipper. The Pokémon recoiled from her touch, letting out a strange noise as the things on either side of their head flared out. Frills, then. Daphne hastily withdrew her flipper.

“Hey, you okay?” Daphne asked.

The lizard’s frills began to retract as they shakily started to slowly open and close their eyes. The Pokémon left them half-open, and Daphne saw dazed blue irises looking back at her.

“You alright?” Daphne tried again. “What happened?”

The lizard just stared at Daphne, before opening their mouth. A shaky, wavering hiss was what emerged. “Daphne?”

Daphne pushed herself back, eyes wide. “What?”

But the Pokémon didn’t reply, their eyes having shut again. They were once again slumped on the side of the path. She couldn’t see any obvious wounds so that was a good sign. It was probably a good idea to take them to a healer, though, just in case. But she couldn’t just wait and hope they woke up. And it wasn’t like she could carry both the Pokémon and her bag into town.

Daphne hesitated, then cursed under her breath.

“Don’t go anywhere,” she told the unconscious Pokémon.

They didn’t respond.

Daphne picked up her bag and sniffed the unconscious Pokémon, before heading back into the forest. Moving as quickly as she could, she soon made it back to Lily’s cave.

“Lily!” she called out.

There must have been more panic in her tone than she’d intended, because the Lillipup came running out of the dark cave fairly quickly. She looked a little off, too. Was her fur a little darker than usual? Probably just the lighting. Daphne didn't have time to think about it.

“What’s wrong?” Lily asked, looking around frantically.

Daphne dropped the bag of fish outside the cave. “I need you to look after this until tomorrow. I found an injured Pokémon and I can’t carry them and this bag.”

Lily paused, then nodded. “Right. I can do that.”

“Thanks,” Daphne said, turning back towards the path. “Just don’t eat it all.”

Daphne was gone before she could hear the Lillipup’s response.


The sun had completely set by the time she left Lily's cave. She could still see fairly well, but her sense of smell was more useful for finding something even in the daylight. It didn't take long to track down the lizard's scent and find them again.

Carefully, she grabbed the Pokémon, lifting them up. She hesitated. They were almost as tall as she was and she wasn’t entirely sure how to safely carry them. After a pause, she decided upon sprawling them over her shoulder, keeping the lizard there with one flipper while pulling herself forward with the other. They weren’t heavy, far lighter than the fish she’d been carrying, but she didn't feel like it'd be a great idea to drag them along the ground.

She was on the path already, so the sun having set didn’t matter too much as long as she kept moving forward. And, though it took her much longer than it would have if she was moving by herself, she made it to the intersection of the forest path and the main road.

Since she’d already missed both dinner and her curfew, she decided to take a short break to catch her breath before she crossed the bridge into town. She really should've had one of those fish.

Idly fiddling with the stone around her neck with one hand, her mind lingered on what the lizard had said. Or at least, what she thought they’d said.

Her name.

Maybe she'd just imagined it. She was almost certain she didn't know this Pokémon. There was no way they could know her name. And even if she was wrong, and they had met before, she should have at least some vague sense of familiarity when seeing them, shouldn’t she? At this point, though, she didn’t exactly trust herself to be able to remember anything like that. Hopefully, when they woke up, this Pokémon could give her some answers.

The sound of approaching hoofsteps made her look up as a silhouette came into view in the distance, coming from the main road and heading towards the bridge. As they drew closer, Daphne realised that it was a Mudsdale, pulling a cart behind it. Not a Pokémon she saw a lot around here. Feronia was usually too wet for most ground types.

She looked up at the thick woolen rug on the horse’s back, with a logo on it that she thought she recognised as a delivery company’s. As the large Pokémon approached, Daphne's eyes scanned down to the piece of fabric tied around one of the Mudsdale’s front legs. She focused on the colour, which was definitely either red or green. She could count on one flipper the amount of times she’d seen a green tag, so it was probably red. Male, then.

“Hey!” Daphne said, a little louder than she intended.

The Mudsdale’s head tilted down towards her, and his eyes quickly glanced down to Daphne’s own tag, a solid blue band on her right flipper. “Well, hello there, lass. Are you alright?”

“I am, but this Pokémon’s hurt.” Daphne gestured to the unconscious lizard still slung over her shoulder.

“I see…” the Mudsdale replied. “I’m assuming you’re wanting a ride into town, then?”

“If that’s alright,” Daphne said, looking down. “Just to the Fishing Guild near the entrance to town.”

“No trouble, no trouble at all,” he responded. “I’m returning from a delivery anyway, so the cart’s empty. Hop on in.”

Daphne nodded, pulling herself up into the cart and setting the lizard down beside her. She felt a little wary of hitching a ride with a stranger like this, but stopping had made her realise how tired carrying the lizard Pokémon made her. They were close enough to town by this point that it shouldn't be for long. Just across the bridge.

“I’m Uma, by the way,” the Mudsdale said, as he started to pull them forward onto the bridge.

“Brionne Daphne,” she responded, trying to move herself into a more comfortable position.

“Pleasure to meet you. So, what happened to ’em?” Uma asked.

Daphne looked down at the unconscious Pokémon. “Don’t know. I just found them passed out in the forest.”

She paused. "Yes, I realise how weird that sounds. But I'm pretty sure they're not wild."

“Doubt a wild Helioptile would end up in Feronia. Especially not in winter. Wonder what brings ’em here.”

“Helioptile?” Daphne asked, tilting her head to the side.

“Yep,” Uma said. “Basic and lightning type, from back home in Erimos, usually.”

Well, that explained why Daphne hadn't seen this species before. If they were desert-dwellers, she doubted they'd want to come anywhere near a rainforest.

Uma was still looking at her. “Come to think of it, don’t think I’ve seen many like you, either. Brionne, you said? You don’t look like you’re much suited for land. What brings you here?”

Daphne closed her eyes. “I live here.”

Uma must have sensed the tinge of annoyance in her voice, because he went silent after that. It was probably a bit more than she intended, but she could almost ask him the same question! And it got kinda grating to be constantly asked why she, a Pokémon clearly more suited to the water, was living on land. She wasn't some curiosity to be interrogated and gawked at.

Daphne spent the rest of the journey staring down at the river below. Not that she particularly liked looking at it, but there wasn't much else in terms of scenery besides the big, fancy, metal bridge. Every time she went over this bridge she just remembered the guild members complaining about the bridge being built and getting rid of the need for the ferry service some of them had previously worked at. It was annoying. The bridge had been built before she even joined the guild; it wasn't like them still complaining about it was going to change anything.

Eventually they reached the town, and Uma stopped in front of a large limestone building on the main road. Daphne could see a few lights through the windows. Still Pokémon awake, then. Hopefully that'd include the guild's healer.

“Well, here we are,” Uma said, turning his head back to look at the Pokémon in his cart. "There a healer or something here? I can drop them at the hospital if you like."

Daphne shook her head, cautiously climbing down, then grabbing the Helioptile again. "There's a healer here, don't worry. Thanks for the ride."

“Alright, then. See you ’round,” the Mudsdale said, starting to pull away.

Daphne nodded again, going up to the large wooden doors. She hesitated, glancing up at the night sky, before shaking her head. After a few attempts, she managed to grab the large brass door knocker with her one free flipper and knocked on the door.

A few minutes later, the doors were opened from the inside and Daphne entered, finding a Feraligatr waiting on the other side, his eyes boring directly down at her.

She froze, glancing up at him, before quickly looking to the side after he made direct eye contact with her. “Guildmaster Sobek! I didn’t realise you were back today. Did you have a good Legend Day yesterday?”

Daphne could feel him staring down at her.

A deep, rumbling voice finally broke the silence. “Good evening, Daphne. I assume you have a very good reason for why you’re back so long after curfew, seemingly without any work to show for today.”

His gaze moved to the reptile slung over her shoulder. “And why you seem to have an unconscious Pokémon with you."

Daphne began fidgeting with her necklace again. “There is. I do have a reason.”

“Do you now?” The Feraligatr narrowed his eyes. “Daphne, unless you’ve deluded yourself into thinking that Helioptile are fish, I don’t see why you would possibly have brought one into my guild.”

“They were injured. I found them passed out in the forest. I had to do something,” she said, looking at the Pokémon on her shoulder.

“And yet,” he said, his tone still neutral, “Instead of bringing this Pokémon to the hospital, you brought them here.”

“The hospital’s on the other side of town!” Daphne said, gritting her teeth. “Besides, Cetus can heal them, right?”

The guildmaster let out a long sigh. “Yes. You are fortunate enough that Cetus is still awake.”

“Great!” Daphne said, starting to walk away. “I’ll go take them to her, then.”

“We’re not finished here,” he said sternly, and Daphne stopped in place, though she didn’t turn to face him. “You have a curfew for a reason, Daphne."

Daphne took a deep breath, ready to give one of the hundred counter-arguments she'd rehearsed in her head.

Sobek sighed. "But, your apparent disregard for your own safety aside, you had better get that Pokémon to Cetus. We’ll discuss this tomorrow.”

“Great,” Daphne said again. “Tomorrow it is.”

“Tomorrow morning,” the Feraligatr stressed. “I want you in my office first thing after breakfast.”

Daphne sighed. “Yep.”

She took the lack of any further interruption to mean she was free to go, making her way to the infirmary as quickly as she could while carrying the Helioptile. Fortunately, Cetus, or whichever healer before her had decided on the infirmary’s location, had made sure it wasn’t too far from the guild’s entrance. Daphne soon reached it, making her way through the doorway.

Inside, she found a Corsola standing at a short desk, carefully reading through papers. As Daphne came into the room, the pink coral Pokémon looked up, before hurriedly moving over to her.

“What happened?” she asked Daphne, as the Brionne lay the Helioptile down on one of the straw beds.

“No idea,” Daphne responded. “Just found them passed out in the forest.”

Cetus blinked. "And you thought you'd bring a random Pokémon here? Do you know they're not wild?"

Daphne gritted her teeth. "Yes! Apparently they're desert-dwellers so I don't know how a wild one would get here. And they spoke a little bit. I think, anyway."

The Corsola opened her mouth, then stopped, taking a deep breath. “Alright. Leave them with me for tonight. I’ll do what I can.”

“Thanks, Cetus,” the Brionne responded, looking down. “I’ll come check on them tomorrow morning.”

“Yes. You look like you need to get some sleep,” Cetus said, looking at Daphne with concern.

Daphne nodded. “I will. Thanks again.”

“It’s my job, Daphne,” she replied with a sigh.

Daphne nodded, then turned around. She moved all the way down to the end of the hall, pushing open the door to her room. It wasn't very big, and had apparently just been a storage room before she got it. But at least she didn't have to share. It was bare save for a straw bed and a window. There wasn't really anything she cared about enough to store in there, anyway, except for the grey stone that stayed firmly around her neck at all times.

Shutting the door behind her, she lay down on her bed and eventually managed to force herself to sleep.


When Chloe came to, she had a pounding headache, and her body was wrong.

The headache dulled a lot of the sensations of her body, but even still, she could tell that it was wrong. Still too exhausted to even consider opening her eyes, she tried to move an arm. But it didn’t move the way she expected it to.

She tried the other arm. Same thing. She tried a leg. It moved wrong, too. So did her other leg. It didn’t hurt to move them, they just… weren’t moving the way she knew they should be. They were bending in the wrong spots, and at weird angles.

She tried just moving her fingers. But even that was wrong. They didn’t spread the way she knew they did, and she couldn’t even seem to get them to spread apart into five distinct fingers at all.

Her skin felt dry, too, and she was cold, as well. Her body was resting on top of some strange uneven texture, too. A texture that was almost familiar, but not something she could immediately place. And parts of her felt heavy in a way that she knew wasn’t natural.

Something was very wrong with her body. She felt a strange crawling sensation on her skin, a chill running down her spine. Something terrible had happened to her. Some kind of accident? But what could mangle her body like this? What could completely destroy her joints to the extent that they didn't even bend the same way anymore? And why didn't she feel any pain? How long had she been asleep?

She really didn't want to open her eyes. She didn't want to see whatever mutilated wreck her body had become. She wanted to go back to sleep and wake up in her normal body. She wanted all of this to be a dream.

But she knew it wasn't. And she knew she couldn't just ignore it. The creeping feeling of dread inside her knew something wasn’t right, and she knew she wouldn’t be able to relax until she knew what. She needed to know. She needed to see it for herself.

So she opened her eyes.

And they opened wrong.

Everything was bright. She blinked her eyes a few times, trying to adjust to the brightness. She became aware that there was a bright light directly above her, casting everything around her in a warm glow. And she was facing up, directly at it.

She tried to look down. The way her head tilted wasn’t quite right and her vision felt weird, off in a way she couldn’t place. She cast those thoughts aside and focused on what she could see of her body.

For a moment, she wasn’t sure it was her body.

She saw a mess of limbs and claws and scales, a horrifying, inhuman abomination of a body. Yellow scales coated her torso, which continued from her neck with no separation. It extended out into two thin limbs that ended in black-scaled digits that were most definitely not fingers. As her gaze continued down, she saw what must have been legs, though they barely looked any different from her “arms”, ending in the same black-scaled digits. She became distinctly aware of a dull ache below her, and realised she must be lying on a tail. And there were two bulky weights on either side of her head that were far too large and heavy to be ears.

She wanted to scream, but her mouth didn’t move the way she needed it to. She wanted to cry, but tears didn’t seem to be coming to whatever eyes she had now. She wanted to run, but she couldn’t even move her mess of a form into a standing position, let alone try to walk.

She struggled uselessly, recklessly flailing her wrong limbs in whatever direction she could, as though it would do something. A strange, alien screech left her mouth, the only sound she could form in her desperate attempts to cry out for help. Not that it seemed to do any good. She was completely stuck, alone, in a terrifying foreign body.

She stopped trying to move, pretty quickly. It wasn't working, and every motion was a persistent reminder of her new condition.

In an effort to think about anything else, she tried to assess where she was. She'd fortunately ended up in a position facing out towards the room, and even though the colours she saw seemed distorted somehow, she was fairly sure she'd never seen this place before.

It wasn't the clean white hospital setting she would've expected to see with her body this broken, instead being a fairly old-fashioned room, with clay walls and a stone floor. Everything seemed huge, the wooden door stretching up incredibly high towards a ceiling she couldn't see in her current position. Big beds of straw were lying along one of the walls, spaced consistently apart from one another. She seemed to be lying in one of them, which would explain the uneven texture. There was a window against that wall, too, she thought, but there didn't seem to be any light coming in through it. Or at least, none that she could see past the glowing orange light that seemed to be coming from directly above her.

She tried to move her body to identify the source of the light, which was futile. It did seem to flicker a little, so maybe it was some kind of candle or something? It did feel very warm as well, though, which was nice. She wasn't sure why it was nice; she just got the sense that it was.

After a few minutes, she heard a strange sound, like rock scraping against rock. She hoped it meant there was someone else here. Someone who could help her. Or maybe that was just her hope talking. Maybe there wasn't even a noise. She couldn’t trust her body anymore. How was she supposed to trust her senses?

Her eyes slightly focused on the door to the room as something pushed it open, then slid inside with that same, scraping sound.

Whatever it was looked familiar, too. She focused. It was pink and looked like coral. But, she wasn't underwater. And coral can't move.

Wait.

She knew what this was.

A word came to her. Sunnygo.

Was that correct? It seemed right, but… No, wait. She should be using a different name. She should be using…

Corsola! That was it. This was a Corsola. Water-type Pokémon, from Johto.

By this point, the Corsola had reached her, and seemed to be looking into her frightened eyes.

It gave a small smile. “I see you’re awake. How are you feeling?”

Chloe froze. It had just… spoken to her. Pokémon couldn’t speak. Or, they weren’t supposed to be able to! Not usually, at least, she was fairly sure.

But, had it spoken? She’d heard a faint sound like scraping rocks, a sound that couldn’t have been any kind of language she recognised. So it couldn't have been speech. And yet somehow, she understood it. That didn’t make any sense. Noises didn’t carry understandable meaning like that, not in the way words did. And the Corsola hadn't used words. But, she still understood.

A little shaken, she tried to reply, knowing her mouth wouldn’t be able to make the right shapes to form words, not on her first attempt. “What’s going on…?”

But now she had done it. She knew that what had come out of her mouth, what she had heard, was just a noise. A hiss. And yet… that hiss seemed to have communicated a sentence, words, tone, and all.

And an understandable sentence too, if the Corsola’s reply, spoken in that same, scraping manner, was anything to go by. “You are in the medical center of the Ceres Fishing Guild. My name is Corsola Cetus, and I am the healer here. One of our apprentices found you unconscious on the side of the road last night, and brought you here to receive care.”

Still a little dazed, Chloe was barely able to focus on the Corsola’s words, and let out a questioning hiss. “How can I understand you?”

“What do you mean?” the Corsola asked, conveying confusion and concern.

“I…” Chloe hesitated. “What’s wrong with my body?”

The Corsola blinked. “My examination didn’t suggest anything was wrong with your body. But, I’ve never had to treat a Helioptile before, and I don’t have any resources on hand that cover your species. Why, what feels wrong?”

Species? Did the Corsola think she was some kind of Pokémon, too? She didn't look like any Pokémon she'd seen before, but she hadn't gotten a very good look at her body. Wait, what did the Pokémon call her?

“Helioptile?” Chloe asked. The word sounded familiar, but not overly so.

“Yes,” the Corsola cautiously returned. “Your species.”

“I’m not…” she replied, trying to put her frustration into words. “I’m not a Helioptile. I’m a human. This isn’t my body!”

The Corsola paused. “A… human?”

Even past her headache, Chloe was able to pick up on the sense of confusion tied to how the Corsola said the word “human”, like it was unfamiliar to her. That didn’t seem like a good sign.

“Never mind,” she said, with a small sigh. “Can you tell me about Helioptile? What sort of Pokémon are they?”

“You don’t know?” the Corsola—Cetus, she remembered—asked, staring at her.

Out of habit, Chloe shook her head. The weights on either side bounced around uncomfortably, distracting her for a moment. At least that had pretty much been the motion she'd been trying for?

Fortunately, the gesture did seem to convey a negative. The Corsola's eyes closed for a moment, before opening again.

Cetus began, shifting slightly. “Well, Helioptile are very rare around here, so I don’t know much. As far as I know they mostly live in the desert. But… they’re lizards, so they’re ectotherms, of course."

The Corsola suddenly shifted forward slightly, gaze moving up to the light source above Chloe. "Oh, sorry if the heat lamp’s set too cool or too warm, by the way. I wasn’t sure what your preferred temperature range was, so I did slightly higher than our Guildmaster’s preferred. I… believe Helioptile are lightning types, at least? I don’t know much beyond that, sorry.”

So, she was a lizard. A lightning lizard. She assumed “lightning” probably meant electric type. It almost seemed cool, like something out of a story, or a fantasy. She felt like she probably would’ve dreamed about becoming a Pokémon when she was a kid. It felt like the type of thing kids would dream about. Though… she couldn’t actually remember what she did dream about as a kid.

And, as she thought more about it, she wasn’t sure she could remember being a kid. Or… anything about herself at all. She couldn’t remember what she looked like, save for her certainty that it hadn't been her current body. Her friends, her family, her home: nothing. Just her name, and that she was a human.

She still knew what things were. Which she supposed meant she remembered them, but she couldn’t remember how she knew them. She could list out the eighteen Pokémon types, and their strengths and weaknesses, but she didn’t have a clue why or how she knew that.

She tried desperately to remember something, anything of her past life. What she'd been doing before she woke up here. Where she'd grown up. Who her friends and family were. Something, anything tying her to something or someone else. But there was nothing.

She began to shake. She noticed she was breathing unevenly, too. She hadn't even noticed herself breathing before, but now that she had she was thinking about how that shouldn't be how her muscles moved when she breathed which was reminding her about how she was stuck in a body she didn't know, in a place she didn't know, with no memories of her past.

And this just made her panic more.

Cetus noticed this shift, instantly alert. “What’s wrong?”

“I… I don’t remember. I can’t remember anything,” she blurted out, through wide eyes.

“Uh, shh… It’s okay,” the Corsola said, in a somewhat soothing tone. “Look, do you at least remember your name.”

She nodded. “It’s Chloe.”

“Okay, Chloe,” Cetus said, looking down. “Look, I’m going to get you sent over to the hospital in a few hours. They’ll be able to take better care of you there, and they’ll have psychics who can take a look at your mind. How’s that sound?”

“Good…” Chloe said, a little calmer.

“Great,” Cetus replied, face much calmer, smiling again, though only faintly. “I don’t suppose you remember where you lost your tag, then?”

“Tag?” she asked.

The Corsola nodded, motioning to a faded blue band around one of her branches. “Something like this. Something you wear somewhere on your body to show you’re not wild. The colour shows how you’d prefer to be addressed. Is ‘she/her’ fine with you?”

“Oh, uh… Yeah, that’s fine,” Chloe said.

“Good; I know where the spare blue tags are kept,” Cetus responded with a small smile. “Let me go and get you one now. Would you like some breakfast?”

Chloe blinked. She wasn’t sure she could even stomach the thought of breakfast now. Everything was still so disorienting and she just needed a minute to think. “I… I’m fine.”

Cetus nodded. Her smile did make Chloe feel a little better. She'd almost find it reassuring if she wasn't so disconcerted.

“Okay. I’ll be back soon if you need anything,” the Corsola responded. “Rest up, in the meantime.”

Chloe nodded, and Cetus turned to go. As she was making her way out the door, Chloe gave a somewhat louder hiss. “Thank you.”

The Corsola turned back, with the same small smile. “Of course.”

She left the room, and Chloe closed her eyes, trying to let herself process everything. It was so much. She was a Pokémon, in a body she couldn’t move, in an unfamiliar place, maybe even an unfamiliar world given how Cetus didn’t seem to know what a human was, with no memories.

Chloe didn’t think she could ever get used to this strange way her body moved, how it felt. Sure, it might’ve been cool to be a Pokémon in theory, but it felt awful. Did she have to walk on four legs? How did that even work? If she was an electric type, did she have to worry about her internal electric charge? How would she use attacks? What if she accidentally shocked someone? She wanted to run away, and not have to think about any of this. She wanted to go home. She wanted to remember her home.

And this strange new world. She was pretty sure that, wherever she was from, she hadn’t heard of the "Ceres Fishing Guild" Cetus had mentioned. And she’d definitely never heard of this tag system. The term “healer” felt new, as well. There were nurses and doctors and stuff, but she was pretty sure there weren’t just Pokémon working these types of jobs. Was this world only inhabited by Pokémon? That seemed strange.

Her memories were gone, too. She couldn’t remember anything that had happened to her before this point. And for some reason, her heart sank in her chest, and she wanted to cry. Could she be sad for losing memories she didn't even remember having? Memories of things she didn't remember doing, people she didn't remember meeting? Who had she been? What had she done? Who did she care about? Had she lost someone important? The possibilities seemed almost scarier than the idea of knowing.

What had happened to her, though? Why was she a Pokémon? Why didn’t she have any of her memories? Had she died, and this was her reincarnation? That didn’t seem right, unless something had gone wrong. Did someone do this to her on purpose? Maybe she was a chosen hero sent here by a powerful deity to save this world of Pokémon. But that didn’t seem likely. More likely, she was sent here to be tormented by this awful, uncompromising body and her empty, useless mind.

Her head was still pounding. Cetus had distracted her from it briefly, but it was back in full force. Forcing her eyes shut, Chloe tried to get to sleep. Maybe then she wouldn’t have to think about any of this.



Here it is: the original Pokémon Mystery Dungeon (minus the Mystery Dungeons) fic I've been working on for a long while.

Feedback is appreciated, as is assistance on how to post stuff here. It's been a while since I've used a forum.

This will also be crossposted to FFN and AO3.

Feel free to follow this story on Tumblr: riversofasphodel.tumblr.com

Chapters should come out every two weeks.

2024/11/12: Chapter has been updated and re-edited.
 
Last edited:
Chapter 2: Meeting in the Middle

FennecWitch

Fiery Beacon
Pronouns
she/her
Chapter 2: Meeting in the Middle

Author's Note: Chapter title is from the song "I've Been Searching For You" from Centaurworld.

CW: Body dysphoria, memory loss



Daphne had no plans of having breakfast that morning. So when Sobek said to her last night: 'meet me after breakfast'… That didn't really mean anything, did it? She could just avoid going to his office and being told that she wasn’t doing enough to support the guild.

Which she knew, anyway. It wasn’t like she needed another reminder. When almost the entire rest of the guild was going out on boats and using nets to bring back huge swathes of fish every day, and she was bringing back only a small bag of fish each day, it was easy to see who was being more of an asset.

So, really, there was no reason for her to go and see the guildmaster if all he was going to say was something she already knew. It’d just be redundant! A waste of time, really. Time she could be using helping the guild by catching fish.

Which would be a plan that would require not encountering the guildmaster and having him remind her to visit his office. Meaning, it would probably be best if she didn’t go down and have breakfast at all. Though, she hadn't gotten back to the guild until after dinner had finished last night. So her nagging stomach didn't seem to like that idea.

But, if she wanted to avoid Sobek, she could just wait until after he would’ve finished breakfast. He always woke up right at dawn—sometimes even earlier when the days were shorter—so he’d be eating breakfast pretty much as soon as it was ready. And he’d probably only be in there for like, an hour at most, before he had other stuff he needed to do. Stuff that was more important than trying to track her down. And since the time right now was…

Daphne looked out the small window, which was right at the top of the wall. Not a good angle for her, given her relative lack of height and placement of her straw bed right up against that same wall. But the window was east-facing, so she should be able to get some idea. Straining her eyes to try and get a glimpse of the sun, she noted that the sky was still very yellow, with only a faint ray filtering through the dirty glass.

Right. So, since sunrise had basically just started, and it was winter, breakfast should be ready in about half an hour at most. And, since she didn’t feel like she was going to be able to get any more sleep, she only had to lie awake here, hungry, for…

About an hour and a half.

Totally doable.

She sighed, and rolled over to her side, squeezing her eyes shut.


After she finished breakfast, Daphne went to check on the Pokémon she’d brought back to the infirmary last night.

While she did really need to get back to work after having nothing to show for herself yesterday, it wouldn’t take long to just check in on them. The infirmary was practically on her way out, anyway. Either the Pokémon was fine and she could feel reassured, or they weren’t and there was nothing more she could do about it.

So she made her way to the guild's foyer. She heard what sounded like two Pokémon talking as she approached the door, which was a good sign. One of the Pokémon definitely sounded like Cetus, at least, and she thought she heard a lizard-like hiss, which would make sense, though she wasn’t close enough to get a clear idea of what they were saying.

Daphne knocked, then pushed the door open. Cetus was standing beside one of the straws beds set up along the wall, upon which was that yellow and black lizard Pokémon, now awake, though looking to be contorted in a strange position. Daphne noted the lizard now had a tag; a torn blue cloth tied around one of her front legs.

Cetus seemed to just be talking to the Helioptile, which meant she couldn't be too mad at Daphne for interrupting. The Corsola turned to look at her as she entered the room, giving a nod of greeting, though her expression seemed a little tired.

Cetus' face shifted back to a smile as she turned back to the lizard. “Chloe, this is Brionne Daphne. She's the one who found you."

The Helioptile’s eyes widened a little, and she looked over at Daphne. Upon looking at Daphne, her eyes seemed to narrow again a little, in what Daphne thought might have been confusion. Or was it recognition?

“Oh, uh, hi. Thanks. And, um, nice to meet you? I’m Chloe.” She spoke up, her voice coming out in a strange hiss, not like the speech of other reptilian Pokémon Daphne had heard before. Maybe they had met before…? That name sounded familiar.

“Nice to meet you, too,” Daphne said, after a moment. “What happened to you? I mean, you don’t look that strong, but the Pokémon in the forest aren’t that tough.”

The Helioptile averted her eyes, though her head remained still. “Oh, I, uh… I don’t remember.”

Hold on. “You don’t remember how you got there?”

She shook her head. “No, I mean… I don’t remember anything before I woke up here. Just my name and, uh…” She trailed off for a moment, before resuming. “Yeah, just my name.”

Daphne felt her breath catch in her throat. “I… Right.”

She felt Cetus’ eyes on her, knowing the Corsola could see her freezing up. She heard the healer’s questioning voice. “Daphne?”

Daphne shook herself in an effort to compose her thoughts. She did not want Cetus to use this as another opportunity to get her to 'talk about her issues'.

She looked down at Cetus. “Could you… Could I talk to her for a bit? Alone?”

Cetus’ eyes narrowed slightly, but she nodded. “Not for long, though. Someone from the hospital should be here soon to take her there. And even besides that, she’s been under a lot of stress, and needs rest.”

Daphne blinked. “The hospital? Why’s she going there? I didn’t—”

“I can’t walk,” the Helioptile said, cutting her off. “My body doesn’t move right.”

“Right…” Daphne said, tilting her head to the side.

She didn't look injured. And Daphne hadn't noticed anything wrong with how she moved when she carried her out of the forest. Had Daphne dropped her, or pulled on something she wasn't supposed to? She didn't remember anything like that.

Cetus made her way out of the room, turning to Daphne as she left. “Don’t do anything to stress her out, okay?”

“I won’t!” she replied, rolling her eyes. “I’ll be fine.”

The Corsola gave her a long look, which Daphne ignored, then left the room, pushing the door shut behind her.

Leaving Daphne alone with the Helioptile.

Daphne turned to her, clapping her flippers together. “So. You can’t remember any of your past?”

“Uh, yeah…” the lizard replied. “I can remember facts. I know things, but…”

“But everything else is gone. You can’t remember your actual memories, and it feels like they’re just out of reach,” Daphne said, with a sigh.

Chloe blinked. Slowly. Her frills unfurled, too, though that didn't seem intentional based on how the Helioptile flinched. It was almost funny, seeing her so shocked.

Chloe stared at her. “Yeah, actually. It’s exactly like that. How did you…?”

“Because,” Daphne began, closing her eyes, “I woke up a few years ago with no memories except my name. Just like you.”

The Helioptile’s eyes widened. “That… Wait, there is something else I remember, too. I’m not a Pokémon. I’m a human.”

Daphne froze. “That… Humans aren’t real. Like, they’re not a thing that exists.”

“What do you mean?” Chloe said, nervous.

“I’ve never met anyone who’s ever heard of anything called ‘humans’,” Daphne replied, her voice hard.

“Then how do you know what they are?”

Daphne almost barked out a laugh. She'd like to know the answer to that one, herself. Instead, she moved on. There were more pressing things on her mind.

“When I found you,” Daphne began, taking a breath, “the reason I brought you back with me is because I thought I heard you say my name. Do you know me?”

Chloe was silent for a moment, her large blue eyes staring into Daphne's. The Brionne wondered if she'd seen those eyes before and focused, trying to see if they were familiar. Was Chloe doing the same?

Finally, Chloe broke the silence. “I… I don’t know. You seem… familiar, I guess?”

“So do you," Daphne admitted. "What would that mean, though? Like, if we did know each other…"

She looked down, gritting her teeth. She didn't want to be dealing with this. She'd moved on. She'd given up on trying to figure out where she came from, on why she'd forgotten everything. But now…

"I thought I’d just had an accident. That’s why I couldn’t remember anything, and why some of the things I knew were wrong. But…” Daphne trailed off.

The sound of scraping on the stone floor, joined by some heavy thuds, quickly getting louder, made Daphne look up. Cetus came through the door, followed by an Oranguru wearing a red tag, and levitating a small stretcher beside him.

Cetus' smile was apologetic. “Sorry. Time to go.”

No! She wouldn’t have time to go to the hospital today. She then reflected on that, and thought bitterly that clearly she hadn't moved on as much as she thought. One thread and she was right back to looking for answers.

Daphne sighed. “I, uh, I’ll see you later Chloe. Tomorrow morning.”

Chloe’s eyes briefly darted over to look at Daphne, before going back to focus on the Oranguru. She looked a little intimidated. Daphne didn't blame her. He was much larger than Daphne, and even larger compared to Chloe.

“Oh, uh… Alright,” Chloe replied, still looking at the Oranguru, as if sizing it up.

“You should probably be getting to work regardless, shouldn’t you, Daphne?” Cetus said, with a small smile.

“Yeah, yeah…” Daphne said. “I’ll get going.”

She turned to leave, placing a flipper on the door, before turning back. “Oh, uh, get well soon.”

Chloe nodded. “Thanks.”

Daphne nodded back, then left the room. Her mind replayed that conversation, over and over, trying to figure out what it all meant.


Chloe decided that she didn’t like levitation. Or telekinesis or whatever it was called. Or at least, she didn’t like it being used to carry her. Or anything she was on.

She supposed she was just grateful that they weren’t moving any faster through the town than they were. Sure, the stretcher she was being carried in felt fairly stable, but it was almost too stable. She felt like she should be feeling the bumps in the road, the unevenness of the ground. If she hadn't been able to see that she was moving, the faint breeze on her scales would've been the only sign that she was moving at all.

It didn’t help that something felt really weird with her eyesight. Everything felt like it was a weird colour. She almost wanted to say purple, but that wasn’t right. It had been weird inside, sure, but not this bad. Why had it gotten so much worse?

And the sun was beaming down, too. It was… Well, it actually felt nice. Nice and warm. Which was weird, because her body didn’t actually seem like it was warm. If anything, it felt colder than it should be. But the sun was still nice and warm, in some way she couldn't put into words. So she couldn’t complain too much, she supposed. She just needed to look on the bright side of things.

The breeze skimming the air carried with it the scent of the sea. Chloe had been taken aback by the smell when she was first brought out of the building. It was so strong, and it felt so familiar, as well. She’d felt a faint pang of joy at the scent, and it had felt like she could almost reach out into her mind and touch some faint memory. But, when she tried to reach it, she found it was always just out of reach.

At least this short trip through the town had been interesting. From what she could see past the stretcher, it was so strange. It felt so weird to just see Pokémon going about their business, like it was completely normal. Which, for them, she supposed, it was.

Flying-types flying through the sky, carrying bags; fighting-types lifting huge stacks of boxes through the streets; even some ghost types passing through walls, seemingly busy. She’d never seen such a big and diverse collection of Pokémon. It was incredible.

The sheer wonder and delight of seeing this all was almost enough to make her forget about her own situation. But a few of the passersby's stares made her shrink back down. They were probably wondering why a seemingly healthy Pokémon was being moved in a stretcher. After all, it wasn’t like she was actually injured, was it?

She stuck her head back down, hiding her face back down beneath the folds of the stretcher. She'd managed to figure out how to move her head with minimal pain and strain over the night and the morning. It hadn't exactly been a painless process, but Cetus had seemed pleased, telling her that recovery was always one step at a time.

It didn't help her frustration at being essentially paralysed, though. It was kind of ironic, actually. Paralysed as an electric type. If it wasn't so horrifying it might've been kind of funny.

The stretcher itself wasn't big. It was basically just a bit of cloth tied to two sticks of wood. But, as she’d soon realised, she wasn’t very big herself, now. She was pretty sure Oranguru were usually meant to be shorter than the average person. And this Oranguru was at least three times taller than her. She was tiny now, in addition to everything else wrong with her body.

Honestly, she wasn’t sure how the hospital was meant to help her. She doubted they were going to be able to give her old body back.

Especially, she thought darkly, since I can’t even remember what my old body looked like.

Which was terrifying to think about. But, now that the thought had entered her mind, it wouldn't leave. And she didn’t have anything to distract her from it. So short of poking her head out of the stretcher again, which did seem somewhat tempting, she wasn’t going to have much else to do for the next minutes. She could look at the ocean for a bit? She could see it fairly well past the buildings, and she felt like she liked the ocean.

But, no. She wanted to remember anything she could. And besides, maybe she’d be able to remember something that’d be useful for the Pokémon at the hospital?

Okay, what about height? How tall had she been? Obviously taller than she was now, given how short she felt, but that didn’t seem to help. She concentrated as best she could, trying to remember if she ever had to look down on people, or look up to them, to make eye contact. Which one of those did she have to do? Was she tall or short?

Nothing.

Okay, then… Maybe, what was her hair like? What colour was it? How long had it been? Was it straight or curly? She tried to imagine how it would feel to run a hand through her hair. There was… something there. She could almost imagine how that would feel. So maybe, she’d done that before? Which meant her hair was probably at least long enough at some point for her to run her hands through it. And… it felt smooth, she thought. Straight hair. That sounded right.

Maybe she was just making things up, but… She wanted to hope she was working out things about her past. Sure, her hair might not be what she most wanted to know about, but… she didn’t not want to know about it. It was still a part of her past. A part of her. And maybe, if she kept getting small things like this, it would help her work out the bigger things, too. She had to hope, at least.

Okay, what else? What colour had her hair been? It was long, so it must have gotten in her eyes sometimes. When she thought about brushing a hand in front of her face to move the hair from in front of her eyes, what colour were those strands? No, she couldn’t get anything. What about eye colour? She concentrated on that for a moment, trying to think of a way to work out what colour her eyes had been, but… Nothing on that either.

She let out a small sigh. Okay, well… What kind of clothes did she like to wear? Immediately, the thought of formal clothes repelled her, gave her a stifling feeling. So, not suits and dresses and things, then. Shirts? No objections from her brain. Pants? That seemed fine. Skirts? There was some more instinctive rejection on that one, but it felt more like her legs being itchy? Not from skirts, from… from leggings worn with a skirt. Jackets seemed fine, though, if… Yeah, a sensation of heat. Wherever she’d lived, it must’ve been too hot to wear a jacket at some point recently. Did that make sense?

Maybe she was just trying to convince herself she remembered something…

The stretcher stopped. Which didn't feel any different to when it was moving, but the building in front of them was tall enough to cast a shadow over her, and the sudden absence of sunlight was jarring enough that it jolted her out of her thoughts. It felt cold in the shade. She felt herself wanting the Oranguru to put her back in the warm light.

It seemed like they’d arrived, though, the building they were outside didn’t seem anything like what she’d imagined. It was a big building, with multiple storeys, at least, but was hardly the huge pristine prestigious medical facility she’d expected. Well, she supposed this had seemed like a small town, but she'd still expected something more polished. Instead, it was a simpler brick building, extending a decent bit back towards the ocean, but not hugely expansive in the way she’d imagined.

Instead of going in what looked like the main entrance, the Oranguru took her around the back of the building, to a door marked with some… Was that writing? If it was, it didn’t look like any language she was familiar with. Huh, now that she thought about it, she definitely knew how to read and write multiple languages. Probably speak them both, too, if she had actually functioning vocal cords.

Focusing on the world around her again, she was carried into the building behind the Oranguru, and taken down a few corridors. They looked clean enough, though not the pristine white she’d expect from a hospital, instead having what looked like stone floors. It looked like the inside of an old building, in the same way that the interior of the other place she’d been in had.

No other Pokémon passed them in the corridors, and the room she was finally brought to was empty, too. It was fairly spacious and round, rather than square, with what looks like some crates stacked on one side. On the ground on the opposite edge of the room were some beds of straw, like the one she’d been on earlier in the infirmary. Laid on top of the straw seemed to be some small pieces of cloth, similar in appearance to the one used for the stretcher.

Small windows looked out to a nice view of the ocean, and were open, letting in a soft breeze, as well as some sunlight, beaming down onto the beds of straw. She felt herself relax as the sunlight washed over her once again. Much better.

The stretcher was moved over on top of one of these beds, and then Chloe felt it be lowered slowly down. It was a weird feeling, like she was falling, but very slowly. Actually, that was exactly what was happening, wasn't it.

When the stretcher landed on the bed, the small glow surrounding it, a visual indicator of the psychic power that had been used to lift it, vanished.

“Wait here,” the Oranguru spoke up in a deep grunt.

“Oh, uh, okay,” she replied, with a nod. It wasn’t like she was going to be able to go anywhere.

He left, and she lay there on the bed, looking out the window at the ocean. Ocean air was meant to be good for the body, right? She was pretty sure she’d at least heard about sick people going near the ocean to recover. Not that she was sick, but that was probably why this hospital was so near the ocean, compared to the rest of the town.

While looking at the ocean, she idly thought it looked nice to swim in. Huh. That was interesting. Did she like swimming? She guessed the idea of going swimming seemed fun. So she guessed she did. Not that she was really going to be able to like this, though. She doubted the strokes she knew would work the same in this body. And since she was an electric type, she might end up accidentally letting out a shock and electrocuting everyone else in the water.

Actually, that could still happen, couldn’t it? She could just accidentally discharge some electricity in all directions and shock everyone around her. She felt a chill run up her spine at that thought. She didn’t have any idea how to control her new abilities. How would she even generate electricity in the first place, let alone use a move?

She was almost tempted to try at that point, but knowing her luck, the doctor would walk in right as she managed to summon some and she’d shock them. Better to just leave it for now. There had to be someone who could teach her, didn’t there? If it came down to that, at least. After all, there wasn’t really a reason she had to learn to use it.

Hearing small footsteps approaching her, Chloe looked up, seeing a small furry grey Pokémon walking into the room. The Pokémon also had white hair and a red band around his left arm, in which he was carrying a small clipboard. In his right paw, he was holding what looked like a metal rod. At first she thought it might be a walking stick or something, but he didn't seem to be using it like that.

Interestingly enough, he looked to be about the same size as she was now. Which is weird because from the little bit she recognised his species, she thought she remembered that being the fully evolved form. Maybe he was just small.

Though, in saying that, she wasn’t entirely sure, since his species wasn’t one she was familiar enough with for her to be able to remember the name of it. She wanted to say it was a Pokémon from Unova or Galar? Something like that.

“Miss Chloe?” the Pokémon squeaked, placing the metal rod down on the ground.

She nodded, snapped out of her thoughts.

“My name is Cinccino Bennett. I’m one of the healers here. You can call me Healer Bennett if you like, or just Bennett,” he said, walking over to her.

Cinccino! That was it. Normal types, she was pretty sure. And the pre-evolution looked like that but without the white hair? She couldn't remember the name of that one, but she was pretty sure she was correct.

“Nice to meet you,” she said, trying to focus. “I assume you know why I’m here.”

He hummed. “Not entirely. I am aware of some memory loss and lack of mobility, but beyond that I might need a helping hand.”

She sighed. “There’s not that much more to it. I can’t remember anything before this morning. Besides my name, that is. And I can’t move. Or, I don’t know how to move. I…”

She hesitated. “It’s like my body is completely foreign to me. I don’t know how to move it, or how to use any of my abilities. And I had a headache, but that’s mostly gone now.”

“I see,” the Cinccino responded, writing something down on the clipboard. “In that case, it sounds as though your problems are largely mental. Which I’m afraid I’m not qualified to really help you with. I can try and get in touch and see if we can get a mind healer sent over here, though, who should be able to help you more. How does that sound?”

“That sounds good,” she said, a little disappointed. “How soon could they be here?”

“I’m not sure. Best case scenario, before the end of the day, assuming we get one who can teleport. Worst case scenario, no more than a few days.”

“Okay,” she replied, looking down.

She wasn't really sure why she was disappointed. It wasn't as though she had anywhere to go after this even if they did fix her. And Daphne was coming here tomorrow morning, anyway, so she had to stay here regardless if she wanted answers.

“For now, though,” the Cinccino said, “I’m going to give you a few Oran and Cheri Berries to eat.”

“Oh! Because, uh, Oran Berries are good for general recovery, right? And Cheri Berries cure paralysis? Because… I can’t move?” she said, thinking it over.

“You’re fairly close,” Bennett replied. “The Oran Berry is for general recovery, and should help with pain relief for the headache you mentioned. The Cheri Berries are to stimulate your body’s lightning.”

“They can do that?” she asked.

“That’s how they cure paralysis. Generally, they stimulate a Pokémon’s nervous system which causes them to regain movement in a body that is otherwise unable to move. In lightning types, this also helps to give you a small spark to restore your charge somewhat. Speaking of which…”

He looked over to her. “I’m assuming you don’t know when you last discharged your lightning.”

“Discharge?” she asked. “Like the move?”

Discharge was a fairly advanced electric type attack, she remembered. She didn't even know how to make electricity! Surely he couldn't expect her to be able to use Discharge?

“Not quite, no,” he replied. “If a lightning type builds up too much lightning in their system, they can become overcharged and end up with lightning leaking out of their body, bursting out at random. To avoid this, lightning types usually need to occasionally discharge all of their lightning to reset their charge. For a Pokémon of your size, I would say you should do this at least once a week.”

Chloe blinked. “Oh. I didn’t know that.”

Images filled her head, of lightning bolts shooting out of her at random, in all directions. She shuddered, thankful that she was being told this before she hurt someone.

“Right. So, given that, I would like you to discharge your lightning here, just in case,” the Cinccino said.

“I… don’t know how,” she said, looking down. “And I don’t want to end up messing up and zapping you.”

“Not to worry,” he said, pointing a paw to the metal rod. “This is a lightning rod. All the lightning you discharge will be drawn to it and grounded. It’s perfectly safe. And as for not knowing how to do it… It should be fairly instinctual. But, try this. Close your eyes, and focus on your aura. Yours should be predominantly lightning and basic types. Feel the lightning, focus on it, and draw it out.”

“Okay,” she said slowly. “I guess I can try it. This won’t hurt, will it?”

He shook his head. “It won’t. You’ll probably be tired for the next few hours, but you should probably be resting, anyway.”

She nodded. “Got it.”

Chloe closed her eyes. Trying to find her lightning, she focused on her own body. She hadn’t really wanted to, and still didn’t. Because it wasn’t really her body. Even thinking about it that way felt wrong. She shuddered, but continued trying to focus on it.

There was definitely something there. There was a small hum within her that she hadn’t noticed before. She tried to focus on it, reach out and… There. Her eyes flashed open in time to see a small spark on the end of her claw disappear.

She blinked. “Did I do it? I don’t feel any different.”

“Almost,” the Cinccino said with an encouraging smile. “You found your lightning, now just do that again and don’t stop.”

“Right. I think I can do that,” she said with a nod.

She focused on the same energy inside her, and reached for the same hum, concentrating on it.

She felt it moving through her, reaching her finger, then leaving her body, and heard the crackling of electricity. The sensation was so unfamiliar that it almost made her lose focus and stop. But she managed to keep going until the hum was very faint and she felt like she couldn’t move any more energy out of her.

She opened her eyes, feeling strangely tired. “I think I did it that time.”

Bennett nodded. “You did indeed! Good work.”

“How did it look? Was it fine?” she asked, curious.

“It didn’t look as though you had too much charge in your body, but you’re small, so it was better to be safe,” he replied.

“So, how do I get charge back now? If it’s all gone?”

He smiled. “Your body should naturally recover it. I wouldn’t try using any moves for a few hours, but after that you should be fine until your next discharge.”

“Okay.” She let out a yawn unconsciously. “You were right. That was tiring…”

“Rest up for now. I’ll go and get you those berries,” he said, leaving the room.

Chloe nodded, and tried her best to move her body to get comfortable, closing her eyes to get some rest.



Author's Note: Not a good start for my upload schedule, especially since this chapter's been finished since November. Sorry about that. The next chapter will come out on schedule, though, so next week.

Hope you enjoyed!

2024/11/12: Chapter has been updated and re-edited.
 
Last edited:
Chapter 3: My Personal Disaffection

FennecWitch

Fiery Beacon
Pronouns
she/her
Chapter 3: My Personal Disaffection

Author's Note: Chapter title is from the song "Faust, Midas, and Myself" by Switchfoot.

CW: Memory loss, brief identity death



Chloe didn’t end up getting much sleep that morning. Or at least, if she slept at all, it wasn’t for very long. She had apparently already slept all night, though, so that wasn't much of a surprise. The berries had been nice though. Better than she’d expected them to taste.

Still, she did think she felt less tired than before. That could've just been her charge returning to her, though. Having to pay attention to her levels of electricity like that was a weird thing to conceptualise. There was nothing she could even really compare it to; it was just a completely new thing she had to do regularly in this body, apparently. She supposed she’d have to get used to it.

It was getting well into the afternoon now, from what she could tell of the time by watching the sun cross her window, slowly going from one side to the other. Healer Bennett had shut the windows earlier, using some sort of portable stool to reach the latches. That hadn’t stopped the sun from shining down on her, though, which was nice. Lying in a sunbeam just felt right.

If she closed her eyes, she could almost completely zone out and not think about the fact that she was alone in an unfamiliar world, in an uncooperative body, with no memory of her past.

She wondered what Daphne was doing. Based on what the Brionne had quickly said when leaving, it didn’t seem like she’d see her again until tomorrow at least. But, it seemed like they definitely had known each other at some point in their past. Was Daphne a human too? She hadn’t really answered when Chloe had asked her.

The place she’d been in when she woke up was called a Fishing Guild. And Cetus had said Daphne was one of the apprentices there. So did that mean Daphne worked as a fisher? Was she out fishing? Chloe tried to picture Daphne sitting on a pier, holding a fishing rod and laughed at the mental image.

A faint sound pulled her out of her thoughts. She’d heard footsteps outside her door a few times, which had presumably just been Pokémon going past on their way to see other patients. But this was different, like something was being wheeled in addition to the footsteps.

She looked over the door to her room. It wasn’t like doors she’d ever really seen before. Rather than any kind of handle, it was completely smooth wood, and pushed open, able to open in both directions. The other doors she'd seen since waking up had looked like this as well.

This time, the door was covered with a glow indicating the use of psychic abilities, and slowly swung open as an Espeon walked in. Instead of a cloth tied around an arm or leg, his tag seemed to be a red bandanna tied neatly around his neck. There was what looked to be a name tag pinned to it, with a symbol displaying three coloured triangles and a red circle in the center next to some writing she couldn’t read.

But the accessory that most drew her eyes was what had made the rolling sound she’d heard. His body was in some kind of harness, which was attached to some poles that went down to two wheels on the ground, on either side of his body. As he moved, she noticed that his hind legs didn’t appear to be moving, hanging limp behind him, along with his tail.

“Helioptile Chloe?” he said, looking down at her.

She blinked, taking her eyes away from his back legs. “Oh, uh, yeah. That’s me.”

He tilted his head down. “Espeon Theseus. I’m the mind healer that was assigned to you.”

“Nice to meet you,” she said, with a small nod back.

She paused, looking at him. She didn’t know why, but her mind kept wanting to focus on his hind legs. It was probably rude, but there was something about them she couldn't place. They seemed wrong. Like they shouldn't be paralysed like that.

She cast away those thoughts. What was going on with her? Of course they weren't meant to be like that, but this Pokémon had clearly had some kind of accident. Unless he was born like that. Either way, she shouldn't be staring.

But, for some reason… She really wanted to know what had happened to him.

“Sorry, um,” she said, managing to look away, and staring at the floor, instead. “This might be rude, but… Can I ask what happened to your legs?”

“Ah.” His eyes widened slightly. “There was… an accident. Years ago, now. I’ve adjusted to it, though.”

“I see,” she replied, looking back up at him, trying to gauge his expression, though he averted his eyes. “I’m sorry.”

He let out a small hiss, expression unreadable. “It’s fine. There was nothing you could have done.”

Neither of them spoke, and silence filled the air. The Espeon stared into her eyes, while Chloe just sat there, watching him, concerned. There was something in his gaze. Something… wistful?

It wasn’t long before he averted his eyes again. “Right, well. I’m here to help you with your mind. I understand you’re experiencing amnesia?”

“Oh, uh, yeah,” she said, with a nod. “And I can’t move my body. I don’t know how.”

“Well, I'm not sure about motor functions, but memory is a somewhat difficult thing to restore. I can try my best, but I make no guarantees. That is, of course, assuming you allow me to enter your mind,” Theseus said.

“What does that involve?” Chloe asked.

“At this stage, a small mental probe to see if I can gauge the severity of your amnesia. Don’t worry, it won’t hurt,” he said, his ears perking up a little.

“And what does that mean?”

“Well, your memories may be locked away, or they may be completely erased. If they are locked away, it will depend on the strength of the mental lock whether or not I am able to unlock them. Though based on what you have said, I believe the strength of the lock will be beyond my capabilities.”

“Right,” she said. “So if it is, we’d have to get a stronger psychic, then?”

“Very likely, yes,” he replied with a nod.

“And, when you’re in my brain, you’re going to be able to see everything?” Chloe said, with some hesitation.

Theseus nodded again. “Though, given your total amnesia, that won’t be much, I suspect. Some semantic memory at most. I will do my best to not intrude too much, however.”

“Okay,” she said. “And this just happens now? We don’t need to book an appointment or anything? I don’t have to fill out any, I don’t know, paperwork, or anything?”

“That should be covered by the hospital,” he said. “If you’d like, while I’m in there, I can attempt to temporarily strengthen your instincts to allow you to gain a better grasp on how to move your body. Regardless of your memories, there should at least be some instincts in there that know how to move your body.”

“That would be nice, actually,” Chloe said, with a nod. “Healer Bennett said I couldn’t move because of a mental block, so if you could fix that it’d be nice."

She paused. "It’s just going to work like that? Like you flip a switch and I can move? It seems almost too easy.”

“Well…” he began. “It’s not likely to be quite that simple. You may be a little overwhelmed and disorientated for a moment when I strengthen your instincts. As long as you regain your control over your mind, you should be fine. I will be right here with you, okay?”

“Okay…” she said, with a small sigh. “Sorry for asking so many questions, I just… I don’t really know how this all works.”

“That’s perfectly understandable,” Theseus replied, with an encouraging purr. “No more questions, then?”

She still had some reservations, like the fact that it seemed like he might find out that she was a human. But if humans didn’t exist here, that wouldn’t be too much of a big deal, would it? It should be fine. He might not even see it. And it’d be worth it if it let her move. And if there was even a small chance of her getting her memories back, she’d take it.

So Chloe shook her head. “I’m ready.”

“Very well then,” the Espeon said, moving over to her. “This will work better if we maintain physical contact.”

She nodded, and he hesitated, before placing a paw on her body, closing his eyes. “Right. This may feel strange.”

A psychic glow peeked out from behind his closed eyelids. Immediately, Chloe felt something in her mind. It was swirling around in her thoughts, moving around by her memories. She was almost scared to think in case it somehow interfered with the process.

And then the thing in her mind thought. It was almost like she’d thought the string of words herself, but she knew she hadn’t. Theseus was speaking to her through her mind. Strangely, this didn’t seem to disconcert her as much as she would have expected it to. It felt almost calming. The message itself faded quickly, Chloe too caught off-guard by the sensation to register the words.

It came again, and this time she got it. «Chloe, please stay calm. I would have put you to sleep for this, but I need you awake when I strengthen your instincts. Just relax your mind, and try not to think too hard.»

So she did so. She closed her eyes and did her best not to think about anything. Which was easier said than done. Easier thought than done? She shushed her drifting mind.

Another message came. «Okay, I was right. I unfortunately cannot unlock your memories. The psychic seal on them is far beyond my capabilities, as usual. Moving on to your instincts.»

As usual? She almost thought about what he meant by that. But she continued to focus on clearing her mind instead.

She’d focused so much on clearing her mind, in fact, that when the instincts kicked in, it came as a complete rush.

Helioptile’s eyes shot open, assessing the area. Where was she? There were walls all around her, trapping her. And there was something on top of her. What was it? Her eyes went wide. A dangerous beast had her in its claws.

She quickly wriggled out of its grasp and took a few quick steps back. As it opened its large eyes, she hissed at it, extending her frills to scare it away. Once it went away, she could focus on getting out of this strange place and find a tree to climb.

It opened its mouth, letting out a terrifying noise that she seemed to understand? “Oh dear. Chloe, your instincts are overpowering you. You need to take back control of your body.”

Helioptile understood the speech of this creature, but didn’t know what it was talking about. She focused on generating sparks along her frills, making a show of aggression in hopes of getting it to back off.

She looked around the area. The way out seemed to be between her and that creature. It looked like she was going to have to run past it. She began to cover her body in sparks, preparing to make a break for it.

It spoke again. Fear. Good. “Chloe! Please don’t attack me.”

Helioptile let out a hiss and began to sprint on all fours at the way out, charging past the beast. Yes! She was almost free! She was doing it!

She’d almost reached the way out when she was stopped by a strange energy, which grabbed her body and stopped her from moving. It lifted her back over to where she had started. She struggled, but it didn’t seem to do anything.

The beast moved over to her and she shook, trying to cover her body in sparks again before it ate her. It grabbed her again with its claws, and closed its eyes as she tried to muster some sparks.

A voice spoke inside her head. «Chloe! You need to control yourself. Fight these instincts.»

Control herself? Fight her instincts? What did—

Chloe blinked. What had she been doing?

She felt some strange urges still telling her to flee, to escape, but managed to push them down.

“Theseus?” she asked. “Did it work?”

The Espeon opened his eyes. “It… did, yes. Try to move.”

“Okay…” Chloe replied. She took a few cautious steps, and found that her back legs were moving along with it. “I can move!”

“Congratulations,” Theseus replied dryly. “I’m afraid you lost control to your instincts for a moment there, but it should have faded by now. You should be all better, in that department, at least.”

She had lost control, hadn't she. That had been weird. Like something else was moving her body while she was asleep. She didn't want to do that again. She didn't even really want to think about it. And besides, she could move now! The elation from finally having control over her body dampened any reflected thoughts spawned from that experience.

“Right, yeah,” Chloe said, looking back up at him. “I kind of remember. Thank you. I can’t describe how much this means to me.”

“Of course, Chloe,” he said, his ears perked up. “I’m happy to help.”

He paused, then continued. “Will that be all you need for now?”

“Uh, I think so?” she replied.

Theseus nodded. “Then I will take my leave for now.”

He turned to leave the room, then quickly turned back to her. “Oh, and… You don’t know how to read this writing system, do you?”

“No, I don’t,” she responded, looking up at him.

“Come by the library at some point within the next few days. I can help teach you. Please come alone.”

And with that, he left the room. The rolling of wheels echoed down the hospital corridors, before disappearing entirely.


The entire day, Daphne couldn’t stop thinking about Chloe. She tried to do her job, and mostly succeeded. Well, she caught three fish. Compared to the five from yesterday, minus the one she gave to Lily, that was pretty good, right?

She was even on pace to make it back before curfew. Not that she really wanted to see Sobek at dinner, but by the time she got there he probably wouldn’t have enough time to lecture her. She didn’t have enough time to make it over to the hospital, but she could stop in on Lily quick. The Lillipup probably deserved an explanation.

And a fish, too, probably. An explanation and a fish. Which would bring her down to an average of three a bag. That wasn’t bad, was it? Fairly good work for two days. At least, if you considered that it was winter now. Given that, she'd done pretty good.

She sighed, as she lugged the bag behind her through the forest. Who was she kidding? She wasn't contributing anywhere as much as she should be.

Whatever. It was fine. The worst that would probably happen would be getting another lecture. She could deal with that.

She turned off the main path, heading over to Lily’s cave. It definitely felt safer in the day time. Or at least, she was more comfortable moving through the brush when she felt like she wasn’t in a rush to get back. When she was rushing, she was way more likely to not look where she was going and potentially hurt herself. Not that that had happened. Much.

“Lily?” she called out, as she approached the cave. “You there?”

She heard a faint scramble of paws, before the Lillipup emerged. “Oh, um, hi Daphne. I have the bag for you, if you want? Um, I didn’t eat any, don’t worry.”

Daphne nodded. “Right, yeah, that’s why I’m here.”

She paused, raising a flipper to her face. “Wait, no. I don’t know how I’m gonna carry two bags. I was so distracted I didn’t even think to check if the wagon was fixed.”

And even if it was fixed, she hadn’t exactly been catching enough fish this week to warrant dragging a wagon behind her all the way to the beach.

“Oh,” Lily replied, looking down. “So… Do you want me to keep it here again?”

“Maybe? You’ve been keeping it somewhere cold, right?”

“Yep!” the Lillipup replied. “Or, as cold as I can. I don’t have anywhere specially made to be cold, but it gets pretty cold in this cave. Especially at night.”

Lily looked down, and Daphne swallowed. She had offered to try and find the Lillipup some place better to stay, but realistically speaking, Lily had been lucky to find this cave empty. Since she didn't want to stay in town, and likely couldn't afford to without getting a job or joining a guild… Well, this was probably Lily's best option, with how young Daphne thought she was.

“Right,” Daphne said. “Then, yeah, keep them here tonight as well. I’ll come and get them tomorrow.”

“Got it,” the other Pokémon replied, before tilting her head to the side. “Though, uh, why’d you need to leave them here? You just said something about an injured Pokémon? What happened?”

Daphne looked down. “Oh, right. So, when I was walking home, I found a Pokémon passed out on the side of the road, in the forest. She wasn’t moving, but she was still breathing, and she didn’t look wild, so I wanted to take her into town to get her some help.”

“Oh!” Lily responded, her eyes widening. “Is she okay?”

“Uh, yeah, I think so? She woke up this morning and I spoke to her a bit. But the healer at the guild got the hospital to come and pick her up to make sure. I’m probably going there tomorrow to see how she’s going,” Daphne said, one flipper curled around the stone tied around her neck.

“That’s good,” the Lillipup said. “Do you know what happened to her?”

Daphne sighed, pressing her flippers together. “That’s the thing.”

She took a deep breath. “Okay, I probably shouldn’t be telling you this, but I don’t know. I’ve been trying to work it out all day, and I have no idea what’s actually going on. This Pokémon—her name’s Chloe—she doesn’t remember anything before she woke up in the guild.”

Lily’s ears perked up. “Just like, um, like what you said happened when you first woke up?”

“Yeah,” she replied, with a nod. “And the weird part is, when I found her, I thought I heard her say my name. She doesn’t remember saying it, and I only spoke to her for like five minutes or so, but… She feels familiar. It’s weird.”

“What… what type of Pokémon is she?” the Lillipup asked.

Daphne blinked. “Uh, Helioptile, apparently. Lighting/basic lizards. Why?”

Lily’s ears flattened. “Oh, um, it’s nothing. I just thought for a sec… Never mind.”

“Okay… You sure it’s nothing?”

“Yeah! It’s fine,” the other Pokémon replied. “Um, I meant to ask if I’d be able to have another fish today? If not, that’s fine! I just… it’s getting harder to find berries, with the winter and all.”

Daphne sighed. “Go for it.”

Lily looked back up. “Thanks. And, um, sorry.”

“Don’t worry about it,” Daphne said. “I should probably be going now, though. I’ll be back tomorrow. Probably around this time.”

“Okay. See you then,” the Lillipup said, looking down.

Daphne picked up the bag of fish and turned to go. Lily retreated back into the cave, with one final glance back at Daphne as she walked back through the brush.


The last thing Daphne wanted to see when entering the guild was, of course, exactly what greeted her.

Her eyes widened. “Guildmaster! Shouldn’t you be doing some paperwork or something? You're a busy guy! You didn’t have to wait out here just for me.”

Sobek narrowed his eyes, staring down at her. “My office, now.”

“You know, I would, but I should really put this away, first,” Daphne said, and held up the bag of fish. "Gotta get them stored away, and weighed, and measured, and—"

The Feraligatr reached out an arm, ripping the bag out of her grasp and hurling it into the corner of the room. “Daphne.”

She sighed, looking down. “Okay, fine. Let’s get this over with.”

Sobek nodded, and she followed slowly behind him as they walked to his office.

The office wasn’t a very large room. At least, not compared to a lot of the other rooms in the guild. It wasn’t cramped for the Feraligatr or anything, but it wasn’t as grand and expansive as rooms like the foyer or the mess hall. Daphne would almost have called it modest, if not for the amount of decorations placed around the room. And unlike the stone floors of the rest of the guild, the floor was made from wooden planks. It was supposed to look like the cabin of a ship, as had been explained to Daphne on many of her previous visits.

Fishing nets and weapons were hung all over the walls, almost completely covering them. Around the room were wooden models of ships, placed on seemingly whatever spare desks and tables Sobek could find. Each of them was hand-crafted, and intricately detailed. Looking over to his desk, she could see a half-finished model sitting in the middle of a mess of paperwork strewn all over it. The paper had even stretched to the floor, covering the planks nearest to the desk. At the front of the desk was a polished golden nameplate reading “GUILDMASTER”.

Sobek didn’t seem to notice her discomfort as he walked behind his desk, sitting down on an uncomfortable-looking wooden chair. “Sit.”

Daphne eyed the other chair, on her side of the desk. Its seat was only just below her eye-level and she really didn’t want to relive her past attempts of trying to sit on it. “Yeah, I think I’m good.”

“Fine,” the Feraligatr responded, looking down at her from over the desk. “You know why you’re here, don’t you?”

She sighed. “Let’s see, uh… missing curfew, not coming to your office this morning, not bringing anything back yesterday, my general productivity being very comparatively low, and just generally being a poor excuse for a guild member? That sound about right? I think this is the part where I apologise and promise not to do it again. That all you needed?”

He let out a low growl. “Daphne. Do you remember our discussion a few months ago?”

“Remind me,” she replied.

He stared down at her with narrowed eyes. “The one where we agreed that, come winter, you would consider the idea of going out on a boat like the rest of the guild.”

“Ah. That one.”

“I’m sure you’re aware it’s now winter, Daphne?” he said, his tone tired.

“Mhm."

“We have a boat leaving after breakfast tomorrow morning. Just for the day,” Sobek said, his voice growing strangely warm. “If you are serious about wanting to do your part, be on it.”

Daphne looked down. “Ah, sorry. Bad time. I still gotta go get the bag of fish from yesterday that I, uh, left in the woods. And I want to make sure the injured Pokémon I brought back is okay.”

“Cetus told me that the hospital is taking care of the Helioptile,” he replied. “I’m sure she will be fine. And if you left a bag of fish in the woods, I will be very surprised if it was not devoured by wilds the second you looked away.”

“It’s in, uh, a safe place. They won’t have gotten to it,” she said.

“How many fish are in the bag, Daphne?” he asked.

“Uh, three?” she said, forcing the words out of her mouth.

“So, you could go out on the boat and bring in tens of fish tomorrow, or you could go to the beach and bring back three.”

“Sounds about right,” she replied.

Sobek scratched at his face with a claw. “Daphne, I want you to seriously think about what I am about to say. I agreed to take you in because you said you were going to do your part. Your little solo excursions were meant to be a trial run, before you went on to the boats. It has been a year, Daphne.”

“I don’t do well with others,” she said, wrapping a flipper around the stone around her neck.

“Then, I will remind you again, Daphne. I am not forcing you to stay here. No one is forcing you remain here in town. If you want to catch fish by yourself all day, you can do that. You can go and live in the wild, and catch fish to provide for yourself. You can even sell extras if you want, without needing to be part of my guild. So, answer me this:” he said, standing up, his gaze towering over her, “Why are you part of this guild, Brionne Daphne?”

Daphne looked down, saying nothing.

After a moment, Sobek sighed, and sat back down. “I will give you until the end of the week to give me an answer. Either you stay here and work with everyone else, or you leave the guild.”

She nodded, not saying anything more, before turning and hurrying out of the room.


That evening, Healer Bennett came into Chloe’s room. She began to stir, stretching her limbs as he placed down a small bag of berries.

Chloe let out a yawn, opening her eyes. “W-what’s going on…?”

Healer Bennett smiled. “Don’t worry, just bringing you some more berries. Go back to sleep; you can eat them when you wake up.”

“Oh… Okay,” she said, closing one eye.

He turned to leave, then quickly turned back. “Ah! I should let you know the good news, as well. The mind healer we called for you will be here tomorrow morning.”

Chloe blinked, suddenly a little more awake. “He’s coming back?”

Healer Bennett tilted his head to the side. “I’m sorry…? What do you mean?”

“Well, I didn’t think he needed to do anything else after today,” she said, looking up.

The Cinccino paused. “Chloe, we didn’t have any mind healer come in today for you.”

Chloe blinked again. “Then… Wait.”

She shook her head. “But, there was an Espeon who came in. He fixed my problems. I can walk now! See.”

She stood up, and took a few steps forward, moving around the room a little.

Healer Bennett took a deep breath. “Right. Okay. Well, while that is wonderful to see, that Espeon was not a registered mind healer. He was not authorised to be here.”

Chloe paused. “Then, why was he here? Why did he fix my mind?”

“I don’t know,” the Cinccino responded. “I’ll need to file a report about this. Can you describe him for me?”

“Um… He was an Espeon. He said his name was Theseus. His hind legs were paralysed and he was in this kind of wheelchair harness thing,” she began. “His tag was a red bandanna. Oh, and there was a kind of name tag thing on it, too.”

“I see…” Bennett replied. “I shall look into this. We’ll keep your appointment with Healer Doreen tomorrow morning just in case he did anything, er, else to your mind. I should go and report this, though… Oh dear…”

And with that, he quickly made his way out of the room, leaving Chloe alone and confused.



Author's Note: As I post this, it is about to turn midnight in my timezone, so Happy New Year!

2024/11/12: Chapter has been updated and re-edited.
 
Last edited:
Chapter 4: Why Little Alice, Where've You Been?

FennecWitch

Fiery Beacon
Pronouns
she/her
Chapter 4: Why Little Alice, Where've You Been?

Author's Note: Chapter title is from the song "The Girl That's Never Been" by Vixy & Tony.

CW: Body dysphoria, memory loss



Daphne had never actually been to the hospital before, so it took her longer than she had expected to find it. Sure, she’d had a vague idea of where it was, but she didn’t know her way around Ceres as much as she probably should after a year of living there. Fortunately, it wasn’t too hard to find, and she was soon pushing open the front doors and walking inside.

She found herself in a decently-sized room, with a few places to sit against the left and right walls, though there wasn’t anyone waiting there at the moment. The back wall held two closed doors, labelled “Hynei Wing” and “Keuppia Wing”, respectively. Between the doors, was a desk, with a Tangrowth standing behind it and leaning forward on the desk.

The Tangrowth looked up as she walked over to the desk. “Hi.”

“Uh, hi. Would I be able to visit my friend?” Daphne said, looking up. “Helioptile Chloe?”

Vines extended from the Tangrowth’s sides, pulling open a drawer and retrieving a sheet of paper. The paper looked to contain a list of names and rooms.

The Tangrowth moved a vine down the list, scanning it. “Room 6. Keppuia Wing.”

“Right. She’s fine to have visitors, then? She’s okay?” Daphne asked.

“I don’t know. You’d have to ask her assigned Healer,” the Tangrowth replied.

“Right. Well, I’m just going to go there and check, then,” she said, turning over to the door leading to the Keppuia Wing.

“Sure.”

Daphne pushed the door open and walked down the corridor, scanning the room numbers, until she reached the one labelled with a 6. She couldn’t hear any noise coming from inside, which could be either good or bad. Either way, there was no one around to stop her, so she pushed open the door.

Inside, the room was empty, save for a Helioptile lying on a straw bed on the floor. Her eyes were closed, and the sun was streaming down on her body through a window on the opposite wall. Daphne hesitated upon seeing this, unsure if Chloe was asleep.

She cautiously spoke up. “Chloe?”

The Helioptile slowly opened her eyes, blinking. “Daphne? Uh, hi.”

“Hi,” Daphne replied.

She watched as Chloe stretched her body, standing up on her hind legs and looking up at her. “What are you doing here?”

“Wanted to see how you were doing," she said, moving into the room. "You look better. I mean, you’re moving.”

Which was better than the alternative, she thought, as she pulled herself onto one of the beds.

Chloe nodded. “Yeah. It was kinda weird, actually. The, um, healer here, Healer Bennett, said that there wasn’t anything really physically wrong with my body and that there was some kind of mental block I needed to get over to be able to move. And he said he’d organise for someone to come and help me with that.”

She looked up at Daphne. “A few hours later, an Espeon came and said he was here to see me. And, he fixed my mind. Or, mostly. I didn’t get my memories back, but, I can move now. I don’t know how to describe it, but it’s like there’s these faint feelings in my head telling me how to move my body, how to use my abilities. Instincts, I guess. But it’s weird being aware of them like this.”

Daphne considered this for a moment. “Huh. I don’t think I’ve ever heard of anyone feeling like that. Or being aware of their instincts like that. I mean, I know that I have my instincts, but they’re never something I’ve really been consciously aware of like that. Maybe I’m just used to them since I’ve had them my whole life?”

“Maybe,” Chloe replied, flexing one of her front claws. “That’s not even the weirdest part, though. The Espeon: he wasn’t even meant to be here. He wasn’t the person they sent for to help me. This morning, the actual person they called, a Reuniclus, visited. From what she said, the Espeon didn’t seem to do any actual harm to my mind or anything. She said my mind felt different to what she would have expected but she didn’t know if it was due to my amnesia or if he’d used some strange method to fix it. It’s all fine, but, I don’t know… It’s weird.”

Daphne blinked. “Yeah, that’s really weird. Why would some random Pokémon just decide to fix your mind like that? How would he even know you were here?”

“Maybe it was something to do with something that happened before I lost my memories? I want to say he was kind of familiar, in the same way that you are. But I could just be imagining that. His name didn’t sound familiar, at least,” she said, with a shrug.

Daphne nodded slowly. “Yeah… But, it makes sense that they couldn’t fix your memories. Or, at least, when I went to a mind healer a while ago they couldn’t do anything about mine.”

The Helioptile looked up. “Oh, right! I wanted to ask about that. We kinda got cut off before. But, from what you said… You’re not human, are you?”

Daphne shook her head. “Nope. Or, if I am, I sure don’t remember it. I haven’t felt anything like what you’ve described though. I can’t really remember being a Popplio, but I’m pretty sure I’ve always been a Pokémon.”

Chloe nodded slowly, clasping her claws together, then frowning. “Yeah, I figured. It’d be nice to have someone to talk to about the ‘being human’ thing but somehow I don’t think that’s going to happen. Still, we must’ve known each other before this somehow, right?”

“Maybe?” the Brionne replied, tilting her head to the side. “I’m not sure on that. We just both lost our memories, and you think I feel familiar, that’s all.”

The Helioptile’s tail drooped a little. “Well, maybe… But, I don’t know. It makes me feel a bit better to think I’m not completely alone here. I’d like to be friends, at least?”

Daphne smiled faintly. “Yeah. I’d like that, too.”

Friends. When she'd first woken up, she'd had nobody. It had taken years of being alone until she found Lily. And she wasn't even sure if she and Lily were friends. The prospect of having Pokémon she could trust was… exciting.

“Maybe we can find out what happened to our memories, together,” Chloe said, quickly pushing her front feet together in what might have been a clap, though they didn’t seem to come together smoothly enough.

“I don’t think I’d even know where to start,” Daphne replied. “Do we even know for sure they’re connected?”

Chloe shrugged. “I mean, no. But they probably are, right? What’s the chances that we both lost our memories? You’re the one who found me, too. That can’t have been a coincidence.”

“We both woke up in completely different places, at completely different times. It’s been about three years since I woke up, I think,” she replied. “I’m not trying to be mean, I just want to be reasonable about this.”

The Helioptile paused. “I guess. Where did you wake up, though?”

Daphne flinched. “A long way away from here.”

“Okay…” Chloe said slowly, looking up at her.

“I don’t think it’d help if I was more specific, considering you have no idea where we are,” Daphne said quickly. “Like, if I said ‘south-east of Asphodel’, that’s not going to mean anything to you.”

“I mean, I guess,” she replied, her tail flicking behind her.

By this point, Daphne wasn't sure if she even wanted to remember her past. Whatever had led to her waking up alone… If she'd had friends and family once, that were now gone… Surely remembering would just cause her pain.

Chloe seemed so enthusiastic, though…

The Helioptile suddenly looked up. “Oh! We could try and find something at the library!”

“What?” Daphne blinked. “There’s no way you know how to read.”

“I can read! Just… not whatever everything I’ve seen here is written in,” she said hesitantly.

Well, it was better than her own level of literacy when she first woke up, which was non-existent.

“Yeah, that’s what I thought,” Daphne snorted. “How did you even know there’s a library?”

Chloe’s eyes lit up, and she smiled. “Because… that Espeon told me to meet him there. So we’re going to get at least some answers when we go there.”

“Ah,” Daphne said. “Wait, if he came in and did like an illegal operation on you, why would he tell you where to find him?”

“No idea! Guess we’ll find out,” Chloe said, smiling.

“Did you tell the healers this?” she asked, looking up.

“Nope. Right now, he’s the only way I have of getting answers on something. If I tell them and they arrest him or something I don’t know if I’m going to be able to talk to him,” the Helioptile replied.

That made a bit of sense, but surely this Espeon couldn't be banking on her desire for answers like that. There had to be something else going on here.

“Right… Well, I mean, I do have stuff to do today. I shouldn’t really just go running off to the library with you,” Daphne said, trying to offer up some defence against her own curiosity. “Are you even allowed to leave the hospital?”

Chloe shrugged. “Healer Bennett said I was free to go, but that I could stay for a while longer until I had somewhere to go. I’m sure if we let him know I’ll be fine to go. And please… I don’t know if I’m going to be able to find it on my own. Like you said, I can’t read. And you can. I assume.”

Daphne sighed. “I can read, yeah.”

Which had been a whole process of its own. Hopefully it wouldn't be nearly as difficult for Chloe to learn.

“So…” the Helioptile said, drawing out the vowel.

Daphne did consider it. She did want to meet this Espeon for herself, and figure out what his game was.

But Sobek's warnings from yesterday echoed in her head. She wasn't going to get on the boat. She was pretty sure she'd already missed that. But if she was doing at least something for the guild, he couldn't complain too much.

“I’ll take you to the library,” she replied, closing her eyes. “But I can’t go in with you. I really need to do my job. I’m losing time even coming here.”

She paused. “Actually, when you’re done at the library, take the main road west out of town. When you get to the crossroads, keep going into Feronia Forest. Either keep going until you get to the beach or I’ll meet you coming back. If you really want to try and figure this out, I’ll show you where I found you.”

Chloe nodded. “Sounds good. I’ll… try not to get lost.”

“If you do, just ask someone. It shouldn’t be hard to find someone. Just… don’t go off the path. I don’t know that I trust you to deal with wilds.”

“Wilds?” the Helioptile said, tilting her head to the side.

“Yeah, wild Pokémon. Like, Pokémon that aren’t, uh… intelligent,” Daphne said, with a nod.

Had Daphne known about wild Pokémon when she first woke up? She honestly couldn't remember.

“Oh, right. I think the Corsola said something about that?” Chloe replied.

“Just make sure you stay on the path and you’ll be fine,” she said, with a small sigh. “This feels like such a bad idea.”

“I’ll be fine,” Chloe said, with a smile. “Let’s find Healer Bennett and get going.”

Daphne nodded. “Yeah, alright. Let’s go.”

She stood up, stretching her tail, and Chloe followed her out of the room.


The library was pretty much what Chloe had expected, really. It’d seemed like the trip from the Fishing Guild to the hospital had taken her from one side of town to the other, so she had a decent idea of the town’s size. So she was expecting a small town library, a nice cozy one-room space that wasn’t too large. Nothing more than that. And from the outside, it seemed like her expectations had been about right.

"Well, here we are," Daphne said, spreading her flippers dramatically, then sighing. "Alright, I'd better be off. Good luck."

"Oh, um… Yeah!" Chloe replied. "You too!"

Daphne nodded, then quickly moved away. Chloe hesitated before heading into the library, watching her go. Realistically, she couldn’t really ask her to ignore her job like that. Besides, Theseus had told her to come alone. So as much as she wanted Daphne’s support, she’d have to do this on her own.

She readied herself, and pushed open the doors. They were huge, wooden doors, big even by human standards, but they seemed to push open easily enough. None of the doors she’d seen here seemed to have handles, but they all seemed easy to push open, even for her. She wondered how they worked.

Inside, she was met with a spacious room, with bookshelves against each of the side walls. Each wall had a few small, circular windows, giving the building plenty of sunlight. In the front of the room, in the left corner, there was a short counter, behind which was an Octillery, looking through some pieces of paper. The drawer of a filing cabinet was open behind them, displaying an assortment of paper within.

In the middle of the room was an area indented in the floor, with a small wooden ramp leading down to it. This carpeted area contained tables, a few with chairs beside them, though most without.

Standing beside one of these tables, a thick book open on the table in front of him, was Theseus. He looked just as he had the previous day. She paused for a moment, watching as his eyes reached the end of the page. His eyes glowed for a second, and the page glowed in return, turning over. He continued reading, seemingly unaware of her presence.

Chloe slowly moved over to him, moving around the edge of the tables until she got over to the table he was standing at. It would have been too tall for her to see over, had she not been standing on two legs. Her instincts didn’t seem to like her walking that way, but it was more comfortable to her. More familiar, at least. More normal.

“Um…” she started. “Theseus?”

The Espeon looked up at her, his ears perking up. A quick flash of his eyes closed the book in front of him. “Ah! Hello again, Chloe. It’s good to see you walking around.”

She nodded. “Yeah… Thank you, for helping me with that, I mean.”

“Of course,” he replied. “It’s my job. I assume you’re here to accept my offer on reading lessons?”

Chloe frowned. “It’s… not your job, though. The healers had no idea who you were, or how you even knew about me. They said there wasn’t even an Espeon named Theseus who was a registered mind healer.”

She watched him carefully, looking for some sign of shock or fear, like he'd been caught in a lie.

But his expression remained neutral. “Ah. I thought that had all been sorted out. I suppose I took the stone there, as it were.”

“What?” she said, tilting her head to the side. “What do you mean? Who are you?”

He sighed. “I am, as I said, Espeon Theseus. I was assigned to help you with your mental issues.”

“By who? Healer Bennett said—”

He cut her off. “Then clearly, they did not get the memo. As for my registration, it happened very recently. Ceres is quite out of the way. Their registry is likely just out of date. I’m sure they’ll receive an updated version soon enough.”

That… made sense, actually. Maybe she shouldn't have been so quick to suspect him. Her tail drooped behind her and she winced. She still wasn't used to her body moving on its own like that.

“Oh,” she replied. “I… Sorry, I just thought…”

“That there was something else going on?” Theseus said, with a smile. “I don’t blame you, Chloe. The circumstances you were presented with do seem very suspicious. But I assure you, my primary concern has been to help you, in any way I can.”

“Is that why you offered to teach me to read? Is that… part of being a mind healer too?” she asked.

“Somewhat,” he said, tilting his head to the side. “As it is, we were mostly just unsure of how long your case would take to resolve, so I was assigned to Ceres for about a week or so, just in case. I thought that since I was assigned here to help you, I could continue to do that. It does not have to be reading lessons, if you’d like. But I thought that would be useful to you, so I suggested it.”

“What else could you help me with?” Chloe said curiously.

“Anything you wish, within reason, of course,” he said, his mouth arching into a smile. “For example, I know a great deal about many different fields. I could provide you with information about this world, about your species, about anything else you should wish to know. All you need do, is ask.”

She winced. He was so willing to help her now, when she was so lost and she'd been suspecting him of lying and… medical mispractice? Was that what that'd count as?

“Okay,” she began. “Sorry, this seems, I don’t know, almost too good to be true. I’ve been feeling pretty lost since I woke up yesterday, though, so it sounds helpful.”

“Perfectly understandable, Chloe,” he said, and a sense of eagerness subtly crept into his voice as he continued. “So, shall we get started? What do you wish to know?”

“I don’t even know,” she said, looking down. “Everything?”

Which was, really, what she needed to know. It was like she'd started over from nothing, with the only things she did know apparently wrong half the time. It was a little frustrating.

“I think that might be a little beyond our time frame,” Theseus responded, with a smile.

“Right,” Chloe said. “How about my— about Helioptile? The doctors told me a bit, but they didn’t seem to know much.”

“I’m not surprised,” the Espeon said. “They’re not exactly common in this part of Asphodel.”

“Yeah, they said Helioptile usually live in deserts, right? And, I know they’re electric types,” she said, briefly forming a small spark in her claws.

It was still so cool that she could do that. If she ignored everything else about why she could.

“Mostly accurate,” he said, with a nod. “Helioptile and Heliolisk are native to deserts, though they also tend to live in savannas, and areas with at least some tree cover. As for typing, they are dual types, lighting and basic types. Which you would know as ‘electric and normal’, though those terms are not commonly used here. A decent number of types aren’t referred to with the names you’re familiar with, here.”

Chloe frowned. “How do you know what I call the types?”

“I was in your mind. Sometimes things… slip through,” he said, his voice level.

“Okay,” she said, slowly.

What else had he seen?

“It is alright. I did not see anything that seemed private in there,” the Espeon said, seeming to somehow still be reading her mind.

No, that was silly. She'd felt him in there last time. He'd definitely left. Only really powerful psychic types could read your mind without you knowing. Though how she knew that, she wasn't sure.

She nodded. “So, what are the types called, then? I’m assuming it’s the same eighteen types?”

“They are indeed the same types you would be familiar with, yes, just referred to by different names,” he said, smiling. “Let’s see… Rock and water are usually the same. Electric type is referred to as ‘lightning’, as established. Grass type is usually referred to as ‘plant type’. Psychic and poison are the same, though I believe some Pokémon call it ‘venom’ or ‘toxic’ type. Fire is the same, though ground type is called ‘earth’. In a similar, vein, flying is usually called ‘air’. Bug is sometimes called ‘insect’ but it is not common. Normal is ‘basic’, as we said. Ghost and fighting are the same, then steel is ‘metal’, and I believe the rest are generally the same.”

Chloe blinked. “Right. I should remember all of that, I think? It seems fairly self-explanatory, at least.”

Theseus’ eyes widened slightly. “Ah, right, sorry. That may have been a tad overwhelming. I will try to be more concise.”

“You’re fine, I just… It’s gonna be a lot,” she said, then smiled. “Like I said, I’m asking you everything.”

His ears flicked. “Well, yes. Let’s take it a little slower, though, at least. Did you have any more questions about Helioptile?”

“They have something to do with the sun, right? Or, I don’t know. Sunlight feels really nice, though. And my vision’s weird in the sun,” Chloe said, looking out at the sunlight streaming through the windows. There was still that weird purplish glow over everything when there was sunlight.

“Well, sunlight making you feel nice is likely at least in part due to being exothermic,” he began.

“Exothermic?”

“Ah, you might know the term ‘cold-blooded’. While mammals are able to produce our own body heat, reptiles such as Helioptile rely on the environment to regulate their body temperature. When it’s warm, their body temperature can be raised, stimulating them more. When it’s too cold, their body temperature will fall, causing them to become less active, and sluggish.”

“Oh,” she said, looking down at her body. “That… that’s why my body’s felt so weird.”

What did that even mean for her? Her body temperature would match the environment? If it was too cold she'd get slow? Not only was that completely different from how she was used to thinking about her body, but now her control would change depending on the weather?! She felt a shiver down her spine.

“I’ve also heard that Helioptile and Heliolisk are sometimes able to forgo eating and draw energy entirely from sunlight, though I have never met a Heliolisk so I cannot be sure how accurate that is,” he continued.

“Okay, not going to try that until I know for sure,” Chloe said, fidgeting uncomfortably. It did seem kinda cool, though.

“Probably for the best,” Theseus said, with a nod. “As for your vision, I would hazard a guess that that’s likely due to you having four colour cones. Most mammals only have two, like myself, though some have three. Birds and reptiles, on the other hand, have four, and are able to see in the ultraviolet spectrum. The sun emits ultraviolet light, along with visible light, so that would likely be why you’re experiencing that.”

He let out a small, almost kind, smile. “I imagine it’s likely a bit overwhelming. Humans only have three colour cones, so I can imagine getting an extra one would be disconcerting.”

Chloe blinked, her blood running cold.

She looked up at Theseus. “…How did you know I was human? I thought you said you didn’t see anything private in my head?”

Theseus’ eyes widened. “Ah. I… Well, I didn’t want to… I didn’t think it was important to mention.”

She tilted her head to the side, feeling the frills on the sides of her head flaring out. “It wasn’t important to mention? From what I’ve heard, humans don’t even seem to exist here! How do you know about them?”

“Well, I… I saw them in your mind. I saw that you were human in your mind. And I saw that your vision had three colour cones,” he said, after a moment, not meeting her eyes. “That’s all.”

If he'd lied about that, then, what else had he lied about?

“Theseus…” she began. “I don’t… I want to believe you. I want friends here, but…”

“Chloe, I swear,” he said, looking up. The calm tone his voice had carried was gone. He seemed on edge. She caught his eyes darting around the room. “I swear I’m not a danger to you. I don’t want anything bad to happen to you, either.”

“What? What are you talking about?” she said.

He took a deep breath, then sighed. “Look… There are things I can’t tell you. Please, just forget about it for now. It’s not important.”

“How is it not important?! You’re lying to me, again,” she said.

“I’m not lying!” he responded quickly. “There are just, certain things, that I can’t tell you, no matter how much I want to.”

“What do you mean? We only just met yesterday. Do you know something about me? Do you know why I lost my memories? Do you know why I’m like this?”

“I… You have to understand. I’ve already said too much,” he said, not meeting her gaze. “I should go. I still want to help you, Chloe. If you want to accept that help, come back here tomorrow. But you have to let this go. Don’t go around asking questions about any of this.”

He began to move backwards from the table, the wheels of his harness rolling behind him.

Chloe reached out a hand. He flinched when she touched his back. “I don’t understand. Please! Why can’t you tell me?”

Theseus was silent for a moment. “If I tell you, I can’t help you, Chloe. And I want to help you.”

“That doesn’t make any sense."

He nodded, turning away. She couldn’t see his face. “I know. Goodbye, Chloe.”

“Wait!” she said, as he began to move away, her hand falling off him. “Please, Theseus.”

“I’ll be here again tomorrow, if you need help.”

She dropped down to all fours and tried to run after him, but tripped over her feet, sending her sprawling against the wooden floor.

Stupid lizard body.

By the time she got up, he was gone.


When Theseus returned to his hotel room, he telekinetically slammed the door behind him much harder than he had intended. Breathing deeply, he closed his eyes, attempting to calm himself down. It was okay. He could still salvage this.

Still, how could he have been so stupid? Why had he even brought up humans in the first place? She knew that he knew about her now, and there was no going back from that, no matter how much he wanted to.

Of course she’d be suspicious of him; he’d lied to her face multiple times. What was he going to do? Go back to the library and, what? Just hope she came back and agreed to not broach the subject again? Like that was going to happen.

He sighed. It had just felt so easy talking to her. So familiar, and he’d… He’d just gotten lost in it for a moment. He’d missed her so much and it was like… He had her back, and part of him hoped that things could go back to how they had been, but… That was never going to happen, was it?

No, no, it was fine. He could still fix this. He could persuade her. There had to be some part of her, even past the amnesia, that still trusted him. He wanted to help her. He needed to help her, or… Well. That didn’t bear thinking about. He finally had her back and he couldn’t lose her again. No matter who was watching him.

Still… It had been three years. Where had she been? He hadn’t found any sign of any of the others in that time, so he’d almost given up on hope. He’d resigned himself to the fact that he was the only one of them who’d ended up in Asphodel and tried to put the past behind him. And yet…

He needed a distraction. He opened his eyes and began to move forward, before immediately stopping short.

“Hello, Theseus,” said the Meowstic sitting on the windowsill. “How was your day?”

His breath froze in his throat. “Dinah. How did you get in here?”

“Ariadne, please. We’re meant to be using our aliases, Theseus. You don’t want to make Midas angry, do you?” she said, a grin on her muzzle.

He noticed the open window behind her. So dramatic. She could easily have picked the door lock telekinetically.

“Midas isn’t here,” he responded coolly.

“Oh? Well, I’ll just have to tell him next time I see him, won’t I?” she replied.

“He barely even knows who I am,” he said, with a faint hiss. “Why are you here?”

She let out a small purr. “Well, ‘Theseus’, I couldn’t help but notice that you requested a week for this mission. And I thought to myself: ‘Why, isn’t that strange? A week? For an investigation into a possible Faller? Even he isn’t that incompetent.’ So I thought I’d have Epoch drop me over and see what the issue was.”

It was fine. Focus. Stay calm.

“As I said in my request, there were potential medical issues relating to this Faller’s condition that had required her hospitalisation. I wanted time to ensure that this had been resolved,” he recited calmly.

Dinah shook her head. “Oh, Theseus. No. I don’t want the fertiliser you served up in your report. Because you and I both know that we could easily deal with any medical issues back at base. I read the report you were sent, and it said she couldn’t move. Should have been easy enough for you to grab her, contact Epoch, and bring her in.”

She jumped off the windowsill, and stared up at him with cold eyes. “I want the real reason you’re dragging this out.”

“There have been… complications,” he replied. “She is able to move again, and I cannot take her without the hospital staff growing suspicions. They already caught me in the hospital, posing as a mind healer.”

“Is that so?” she said, her ears perking up, though her eyes remaining flat. “Easy. I’ll tell them she’s being transferred and take her now.”

“She’s not at the hospital,” he said quickly.

She gave an annoyed yowl. “Then I’ll grab her when she gets back. No big deal.”

“No!” he said quickly. Too quickly.

His eyes went wide as Dinah glared up at him. “Really? Why not?”

“I…” he began, trying to maintain his composure. “I can handle it. I’ll bring her in by the end of the week. I swear.”

The Meowstic cocked her head. “Really? I’m so glad to hear it.”

She stepped back, turning back towards the window and staring out through it. “Because you now how badly we need another Faller, don’t you? So if you, gods forbid, fail this mission…”

She looked back at him, eyes of yellow and red staring into his own. “I’ll bring her in myself.”

She grinned, before jumping onto the windowsill, then disappearing.

Theseus closed his eyes. What in the name of the gods was he going to do?



Author's Note: Story is now also crossposted to pmdfanfiction.com!

2024/11/12: Chapter has been updated and re-edited.
 
Last edited:

Spiteful Murkrow

Busy Writing Stories I Want to Read
Pronouns
He/Him/His
Partners
  1. nidoran-f
  2. druddigon
  3. swellow
  4. lugia
  5. quilava-fobbie
  6. sneasel-kate
  7. heliolisk-fobbie
Heya, dropping by as part of V-Wheel. I’d seen you around leaving reactions to the onsite version of PoV here, but somehow I never realized that you had a fic of your own. Though I suppose now’s as good a time as any to poke my head in and see what your story’s all about:

Chapter 1

In a very shallow part of the ocean, the fish swam. It was almost at the shore, not that it knew what that meant. What it did understand was that the water was growing quite shallow, and it needed to get back to deeper waters. Although its light, pale emerald scales almost let it blend in with the seawater itself, it was still alone, separated from its school. So it started to turn around to make its way back out to sea.

As the fish attempted this, it was intercepted by something it had failed to see. the water around it surged as from a sudden rush of movement occurred, and sharp teeth closed around its body as the fish was caught. It barely had time to process what had happened before its unseen attacker was dragged it back to shore, the teeth still sunk into its scales.

Made some odds-and-ends rephrasing suggestions here. Though as a general rule of thumb, most actions described happening tend to be a bit more exciting to read when they’re not described in passive voice (“was [verb]ing”, “had [verb]ed”, etc) but in something that’s more “actively unfolding” like some of the suggestions.

Fish: “... Ow.” X_X

Pulling herself onto the beach, Daphne briefly dropped the wild Remoraid onto the sand, before picking it up again near the tail and flinging it into a nearby mesh bag, filled with similarly-caught fish. The fish was a bit smaller than she would've liked, but then she supposed she was lucky to have found a lone Remoraid this close to shore. She didn't have the time nor the desire to fight off a whole school of fish. And even if she did, there was no way she could carry that many back into town on her own. It would just be a waste of effort, unless she wanted to give the wild predators an easy snack. Besides, she needed one smaller catch today, anyway.

Aha, so we have a setting where there’s a sapience split between “wild/feral” Pokémon and town-dwellers… or at least I hope that there’s a sapience split since otherwise this scene takes on a whole new light.
827659294400970753.webp


Though I see someone from your cover art, I’m guessing that this is one of this story’s protagonists.

The Brionne turned back to the water, going far out enough in that she could wash around her mouth. She had mostly gotten used to the sight of blood over the past few years, but she still grimaced as she saw the traces of the red liquid around her muzzle. It was a good thing her hair wasn't anywhere near thick enough to make it hard to get out. Most Pokémon also didn't like the sight of it, anyway, and she got enough strange looks as it was.

… Wait, implying that there are Pokémon considered normal that like the sight of blood in this setting?
994427253242990704.webp


Daphne: “Okay, not that I’m not naturally adapted to fish like this, but I really should invest in a set of nets sometime.” >_>;

Once she was sufficiently clean enough to present herself to regular society, she went back to the shore and grabbed the bag full of fish. It wasn't a particularly large bag, only able to hold about five fish Pokémon at most. But then, she wasn't very large herself and it wouldn't be do much good if she couldn't carry it. She slung the bag over her shoulder, taking care not to disturb the smooth grey stone attached to a cord tied around her neck, before heading to the path through the forest and back to town

Huh. I’m guessing that that’s some sort of personal effect since Daphne also has that rock on her on the cover art. Noted, though I suppose we’ll get the story behind that soon enough.

She turned to look behind her. The sun was getting low in the sky, with the land below starting to be bathed in twilight. Daphne cursed under her breath. She definitely didn't have enough time to get back before it grew completely dark. At least, not unless she skipped her detour, but that wasn't happening.

Besides, ... Maybe she'd get some leniency on the curfew? Winter had now officially begun and the days were shortening so it wasn't like she had as much time to get back as she would have in summer. All the same, she quickened her pace as much as she could while lugging a bag of fish behind her.

‘Curfew’, huh? Just how old is Daphne anyways such that that’s something she’s worried about?

Also, this paragraph felt a bit long and unwieldy, but I admittedly am not super sure how to divide it up. I left a throwaway suggestion in case you thought it worth your consideration, but can see the argument for just keeping everything together as well.

When she had almost reached the edge of the forest, she turned off the main path, heading into an uneven area of brush. There wasn't anything that could even generously be called a path. She moved around the thick plants on the ground in a practised route, until she reached a small cave.

Oh, so this fic’s written in Commonwealth English. Duly noted for the future, then.

Daphne could see fairly well in the dark, though by this point she couldn't make out more than vague shapes inside the cave. She stopped outside the entrance, setting down her bag.

"Lily?" Daphne called out, softly. "You there?"

That’s the Helioptile from the cover art, isn’t it?

"Oh, um, just a second!" came a voice in return, before a somewhat disheveled-looking Lillipup slowly emerged from the entrance.

She looked up at Daphne. "You've got food for me?"

… Or not. Guess we’ll be waiting a bit for our second protag to make his/her appearance in this story still.

"Of course," Daphne said, reaching into the bag with her mouth to grab the small Remoraid she had just caught and throwing it at the Lillipup's feet. "Just the one this time, though. Since winter's started it's going to be harder for me to get them. But I'll do what I can."

"Thanks," Lily replied, looking down at the fish, sniffing it cautiously. "I know you've said it's fine for you to give up fish like this, but…"

Daphne snorted. "Hey, better this than you stealing from me again. Least like this I can plan for it."

That… doesn’t sound super promising for what these two’s food security situation is like at the moment given that Lily seems to be implying that food is scarce enough for Daphne giving up part of her catch to not be a trivial matter.

Lily's ears flattened against her head, her tail drooping. "I said I was sorry. I just… I needed food."

"I know, I know," Daphne said, sighing. "Besides, this one's small enough that I don't know if we'd even be able to sell it. You may as well take it."

Yeeeeeah, I’ll just go ahead and mentally note that these two are food insecure. And probably tight on disposable income too based off Daphne’s dialogue.

[ ]

"Right," Lily said, then looked up at the sky. "You'd better get back though, right? It's almost dark."

Daphne nodded. "Yeah, I should get going."

"Okay. Thanks again," the Lillipup replied, grabbing the Remoraid and starting to drag it into the cave.

Thus far, you’ve had a pretty long streak of uninterrupted dialogue between this two. It might make sense to take some time to drop in a paragraph of either description of body language or else focusing on Daphne’s internal thoughts here. Since it feels like there’s a lot more about Daphne and her situation we could be learning about as readers, and it’s a convenient way to bring the readers a bit more up to speed as to Daphne’s situation while also adding some more variety in your prose.

"It's nothing," said Daphne, picking up her bag again. "If nothing comes up, I'll see you tomorrow, okay?"

Lily nodded, her tail wagging slightly. "Okay!"

When she got back on the main path, Daphne moved forward, keeping her head down. It wouldn't be that bad if she missed dinner for one night, right? It wasn't like this was the first time it had happened, anyway. Maybe she should just have one of these fish now, since there was no way she was getting back to the guild before dinner ended.

Mmm. Sashimi. I mean, unless those are some really shrimpy Remoraid, Daphne’s probably fine given that a Remoraid’s like 2/3 of the body weight of a Brionne, but…

She was almost out of the forest when her eyes happened to glance over at a flash of colour on the side of the path. She blinked, then slowly approached it.

It looked like some kind of reptile. It didn't look like they were wearing anything, so she might've just passed them off as a wild Pokémon. But she had a fairly good idea of the Pokémon that lived around here and this wasn't a species she recognised at all. As she got closer she realised that they weren't moving.

"Hey!" she called.

Ah yes, our Helioptile protag from the cover. Or at least I’m pretty sure it’s our Helioptile protag. It might make sense to be a bit more generous with the description (e.x. mentioning that the reptile’s yellow and black), though.

The Pokémon didn't move.

Great start already for our Helioptile buddy’s isekai journey!
401074247574880299.webp


A wave of dread washed over her, and she opened her mouth, letting loose a stream of water. The Pokémon began to move slightly and Daphne felt a weight come off her shoulders. What would she even have done with a dead body in the woods? Probably report it to someone, right? But there was no guarantee they'd get there before any wild predators would. Not that that mattered, anyway, because this Pokémon wasn't dead.

Given how tight Daphne is on food, I’m honestly a little surprised that in the absence of any sign that this wasn’t a wild Pokémon that the thought wouldn’t occur to her to scavenge the body to eat later.

… Though wait, how is she able to tell whether or not this probably not-quite-dead Pokémon is a wild or a town-dweller like her anyways? Since you’d think she’d have different reactions depending on what her assumption is.
636782104289476608.webp


Still, they hadn't opened their eyes yet. Daphne set down her bag and touched the lizard's back with a flipper. The Pokémon recoiled from her touch, letting out a strange noise as the frills on either side of their head flared out. Daphne hastily withdrew her flipper.

Yeeeeeah, it probably would’ve made sense to bring these details up at the part where Daphne comes across the body unless the idea is that she very specifically is just noticing these features. Like I figured that it’d be our Helioptile buddy, but that was admittedly a guess running off of story meta and not actually taken from the text.

"Hey, you okay?" Daphne asked.

The lizard's frills began to retract as they shakily started to slowly open and close their eyes. The Pokémon left them half-open, and Daphne saw dazed blue irises looking back at her.

"You alright?" Daphne tried again. "What happened?"

Daphne: “Well, okay, you’re rather obviously not alright, so let’s just focused on the ‘what happened’ part of that question there.” ^^;

The lizard just stared at Daphne, before opening their mouth. A shaky, croaky voice was what emerged. "Daphne?"

Daphne pushed herself back, eyes wide. "What?"

Daphne: “Wait, I’m sorry, how do we know each other again?”
701085210766344223.webp


But the Pokémon didn't reply, their eyes having shut again. They were once again slumped on the side of the path. She couldn't see any obvious wounds, so that was a good sign. It was probably a good idea to take them to a healer, though, just in case. But she couldn't just wait and hope they woke up. And it wasn't like she could carry both the Pokémon and her bag into town.

Daphne: “Especially since if these four Remoraid in my bag are full-sized, I’m literally carrying over twice my body weight already.” ^^;

Daphne hesitated, then cursed under her breath.

"Don't go anywhere," she told the unconscious Pokémon.

They didn't respond.

Daphne: “I’ll just take that as an ‘alright’ there. (Boy, this would be a really good time to have badges that can communicate over distances right now.)” .-.

Daphne picked up her bag and sniffed the unconscious Pokémon, before heading back into the forest. Moving as quickly as she could, she soon made it back to Lily's cave.

"Lily!" she called out.

Part of me is surprised that she didn’t leave behind the bag as well in order to move faster, but I suppose that with how precarious her implied diet is, that Daphne probably wouldn’t want to risk her catch getting snatched by wild Pokémon.

There must have been more panic in her tone than she'd intended, because since the Lillipup came running out of the dark cave fairly quickly in a flash, looking around wildly.

"What's wrong?" Lily asked, looking around frantically.

Daphne dropped the bag of fish outside the cave. "I need you to look after this until tomorrow. I found an injured Pokémon and I can't carry them and this bag."

Yeeeah, Daphne’s going to be getting back an empty bag the next day, isn’t she?

Lily paused, then nodded. "Right. I can do that."

"Thanks," Daphne said, turning back towards the path. "Just don't eat it all."

See the last cutaway gag. Though a part of me wonders if there should’ve been a bit more emphasis on some combination of body language or internal thoughts here since somehow this moment didn’t feel as tense as I think you were intending it.


Daphne was gone before she could hear the Lillipup's response.

Lily:
200w.gif

<><><>

The sun had almost completely set before she reached the unconscious lizard again. She could still see fairly well, but since she was had always been much more confident in her sense of smell. As in the past, it proved to be the more reliable guide, as she tracked down the lizard’s scent and quickly found them again.

Carefully, she grabbed the Pokémon, lifting them up before hesitating. They were almost as tall as she was and she wasn't entirely sure how to safely carry them. After a pause, she decided upon sprawling them over her shoulder, keeping the lizard there with one flipper while pulling herself forward with the other. They weren't heavy, far lighter than the fish she'd been carrying, but it was still awkward for Daphne to carry them.

Left some suggestions for a rephrasing, though the transition between the first paragraph and the last one is sudden enough and jumps ahead enough time-wise that it might make sense to put in a hard scene break here.

She was on the path already, so the sun having setting didn't matter too much as long as she kept moving forward. And, though it took her much longer than it would have if she was moving by herself, she made it to the intersection of the forest path and the main road.

The sun was described as still being in the process of setting earlier, so you probably also want to reflect that here in the narration.

Since she'd already missed her curfew, she decided to take a short break before she crossed the bridge into town. Idly fiddling with the stone around her neck with one hand, her mind lingered on what the lizard had said. Or at least, what she thought they'd said:

They’d addressed her by her name, even though they’d never met before.

C
ould s[/b]he wondered if she'd have just misheard the Pokémon? Even if she didn't remember meeting this Pokémon, she should have at least some vague sense of familiarity when seeing them, shouldn't she? At this point, though, she didn't exactly trust herself to be able to remember anything like that. Hopefully, when they woke up, this Pokémon could give her some answers.

It probably makes sense to explicitly identify what it was that Daphne found weird about her interaction with the Helioptile. I assume that it’s something roughly along the lines of the above suggestion, but feel free to change things up if it’s not.

The sound of approaching hoofsteps made her look up as a silhouette came into view in the distance, coming from the main road and heading towards the bridge. As they drew closer, Daphne realised that it was a Mudsdale, pulling a cart behind it.


She looked up at the thick woolen rug on the horse's back, with a logo on it that she thought she recognised as a delivery company's. Her eyes scanned down to the piece of fabric tied around one of the Mudsdale's front legs. She focused on the colour, which was definitely either red or green. She could count on one flipper the amount of times she'd seen a green tag, so it was probably red. Male, then.

Wait, she’s able to actually distinguish between red and green as a seal? /s

Though I suppose that this is the answer to Daphne’s “lugging along someone who weighs a nontrivial percentage of your own body weight” problems right now.

"Hey!" Daphne called out as the large Pokémon approached.

The Mudsdale's head tilted down towards them, and his eyes quickly glanced down to Daphne's own tag, a solid blue band on her right flipper. "Well, hello there. Are you alright?"

I feel like the bit in underlined could potentially be moved into the earlier paragraph with some sort of passing mention that the Mudsdale neared Daphne, since something about its placement feels very taped-on right now.

Daphne: “... I’m sorry, are you blind or do you not see the passed-out lizard I’m lugging around right now?” >_>;

"I am, but this Pokémon's hurt." Daphne gestured to the unconscious lizard still slung over her shoulder.

[ ]

"I see…" the Mudsdale replied. "I'm assuming you're wanting a ride into town, then?"

"If that's alright," Daphne said, looking down. "Just to the Fishing Guild near the entrance to town."

Oh, a Fishing Guild, huh? That one’s definitely different from what I was expecting. Though I kinda wonder if it’d have made sense to describe the Mudsdale reacting a bit more, since the lack of one that’s described gives him some unintentionally nonchalant vibes to a scenario that you’d think would strike him as strange or worrisome.

"No trouble, no trouble at all," he responded. "I'm returning from a delivery anyway, so the cart's empty. Hop on in."

Daphne nodded, pulling herself up into the cart and setting the lizard down beside her.

Well, I suppose that’s one way to tell that Daphne’s from a high-trust society if both she and this Mudsdale are comfortable with just casually hitchhiking like this.

"I'm Uma, by the way," the Mudsdale said, as he started to pull them forward onto the bridge.

"Brionne Daphne," she responded, trying to move herself into a more comfortable position.

Oh, so we’ve got HoC/PoV-style naming in this setting for the Pokémon characters, duly noted.

"Pleasure to meet you. So, what happened to 'em?" Uma asked.

Daphne looked down at the unconscious Pokémon. "Don't know. I just found them passed out in the forest."

[ ]

"Wonder what brings 'em here. Don't see many Helioptile in Feronia. Especially not in winter."

This feels like another moment that should have some sort of reaction by some combination of Daphne and Uma, given that Uma is explicitly pointing out how this is a weird situation at the moment.

"Helioptile?" Daphne asked, tilting her head to the side.

And apparently Helioptile are super-rare / nonexistent in this Feronia region or whatever it is. Noted. I take it that this is going to be one of those world-traveling stories since if our Helioptile buddy isn’t from around here, then…

"Yep," Uma said. "Basic and lightning type, from back home in Erimos, usually."

I can’t tell whether or not the “lightning”-type is a deliberate stylistic choice or not. Though Uma is also a stranger to this land, huh? I wasn’t expecting that one. Wonder if it could’ve been foreshadowed a little more by something like mentioning that he had an accent or else had some other tell-tale sign that he wasn’t from around here.

He paused. "Come to think of it, don't think I've seen many like you, either. Brionne, you said? You don't look like you're much suited for land. What brings you here?"

I didn’t see that one coming. Though you’d think that this would be less shocking given that they’re right next to the sea unless if Brionne are also Pokémon that normally are more tropical in distribution.

Daphne closed her eyes. "I live here."

Uma must have sensed the tinge of annoyance in her voice, because he went silent after that. Daphne spent the rest of the journey staring down at the river below. [ ]

Eventually they reached the town, and Uma stopped in front of a large limestone building on the main road.

"Well, here we are," Uma said, turning his head back to look at the Pokémon in his cart.

"You gonna be right carrying them?" he asked, seeing Daphne climbing down cautiously.

I feel as if there was a bit of a missed opportunity here to get inside Daphne’s head a bit. While I realize there might be some details about Daphne that you don’t necessarily want to blurt out to the world just yet story-wise, if “wait, how are you here?” is a common reaction that Daphne gets, detailing her reaction to it / any reflection to past incidents is a potential way of hinting a bit at her backstory and personality.

Daphne nodded, picking up the Helioptile again. "I'll be fine. Thanks for the ride."

"Alright, then. See you 'round," the Mudsdale said, starting to pull away.

I’m honestly a little surprised that Uma didn’t make more of a fuss about “wait, shouldn’t we be going to a doctor?” or else Daphne giving some reassurance that there’s a medic onsite at the Fishing Guild given that they’re lugging around an unconscious Pokémon in unclear condition.

Daphne nodded again, going up to the large wooden doors. She hesitated, glancing up at the night sky, before shaking her head. After a few attempts, she managed to grab the large brass door knocker with her one free flipper and knocked on the door.

A few minutes later, the doors were opened from the inside and Daphne entered, finding a Feraligatr waiting on the other side, his eyes boring directly down at her.

She froze, glancing up at him, before quickly looking to the side after he made direct eye contact with her. "Guildmaster Sobek! I didn't realise you were back today. Did you have a good Legend Day?"

Ah yes, getting in the Egyptian Mythology nods there. Though if Legend Day was meant to be sometime very recently, I’m a little surprised that it hasn’t reflected in the characters’ thought processes prior to this point at all. e.x. that sort of “blurgh, work” mood when having to go back to the grind after a holiday

Daphne could feel him staring down at her.

A deep, rumbling voice finally broke the silence. "Good evening, Daphne. I assume you have a very good reason for why you're back so long after curfew, seemingly without any work to show for today."

Daphne began fidgeting with her necklace again. "There is. I do have a reason."

… Wait, did Daphne stuff the Helioptile into her bag or something? Since you’d think that he’d be kinda hard to miss for Sobek right about now and his mood would be a bit more “Daphne, what’s going on?” at the moment.

"Do you now?" The Feraligatr narrowed his eyes. "Daphne, unless you've deluded yourself into thinking that Helioptile are fish, I don't see why you would possibly have brought one into my guild."

[ ]


"They were injured. I found them passed out in the forest. I had to do something," she said, looking at the Pokémon on her shoulder.

"And yet," he said, his tone still neutral, "Instead of bringing this Pokémon to the hospital, you brought them here."

hes-right-you-know-morgan-freeman.png


Though I’m already getting some iffy vibes right now from this guy’s attitude and his indifference over an injured Pokémon getting drug onto his proverbial doorstep.

"The hospital's on the other side of town!" Daphne said, gritting her teeth. "Besides, Cetus can heal them, right?"

[ ] The guildmaster let out a long sigh.

"Yes. You are fortunate enough that Cetus is still awake."

Whalemon detected with a name like that. Though I personally feel that it probably makes sense to dwell on these two characters’ reactions a bit more since it’s a bit hard to read their moods / personalities just from the provided dialogue. Especially if Sobek is meant to ultimately be a sympathetic figure in the end.

"Great!" Daphne said, starting to walk away. "I'll go take them to her, then."

"We're not finished here," he said sternly, and Daphne stopped in place, though she didn't turn to face him. "But it's past curfew. We'll discuss this tomorrow."

"Great," Daphne said again. "Tomorrow it is."

This isn’t the first time that Daphne’s come in past curfew, is it? Though a part of me feels as if there should’ve been a bit more established as to why there’s even a curfew in the first place.

"Tomorrow morning," the Feraligatr stressed. "I want you in my office first thing after breakfast."

Daphne sighed. "Yep."

Daphne: “Really, was it too much to ask for this to just get swept under the rug when I helped someone here?” >_>;

She moved to walk away again and took the lack of any further interruption to mean she was free to go and began to move along. She made her way to the infirmary as quickly as she could while carrying the Helioptile. Fortunately, Cetus, or whichever healer before her had decided on the infirmary's location, had made sure it wasn't too far from the guild's entrance. Daphne soon reached it, making her way through the doorway.

Just saying, it’s a bit hard for a seal to ‘walk’. Though I’m surprised that Sobek didn’t offer at all to help carry the Helioptile over given that it would be significantly easier for him to carry them along than it would for Daphne.

Inside, she found a Corsola standing at a short desk, carefully reading through papers. As Daphne came into the room, the Corsola looked up, before hurriedly moving over to her.

"What happened?" she asked Daphne, as the Brionne lay the Helioptile down on one of the straw beds.

Whelp, not quite a whale, but I wonder if this is supposed to be a normal or a Galarian Corsola since the description doesn’t really tip things off one way or the other.

"No idea," Daphne responded. "Just found them passed out in the forest."

[ ] The Corsola took a deep breath.

"Alright. Leave them with me for tonight. I'll do what I can."

"Thanks, Cetus," the Brionne responded, looking down. "I'll come check on them tomorrow morning."

I feel as if we’re missing a step here. Like does Cetus even know if Daphne brought in a non-wild Pokémon for her to treat? Like is there any superficial distinction between a sapient Pokémon and a wild in this story? If not, it might make sense to acknowledge that a bit with some sort of smoothing over / “I know this sounds crazy, but” either in dialogue, description, or both.

"Yes. You look like you need to get some sleep," Cetus said, looking at Daphne with concern.

Daphne nodded. "I will. Thanks again."

"It's my job, Daphne," she replied with a sigh.

Daphne nodded, then turned around and headed to her room. She lay down on her bed and eventually managed to force herself to sleep.

This feels really accelerated at the moment, partly because there was zero mention of Daphne having a room at the Fishing Guild or any relative location of it earlier, so we’re having a lot of new places getting brought up in a “by the way” fashion at the moment.

When Chloe came to, she had a pounding headache, and her body was wrong.

Oh, so Chloe’s our Helioptile protag, huh?

The headache dulled a lot of the sensations of her body, but even still, she could tell that it was wrong. Still too exhausted to even consider opening her eyes, she tried to move an arm, but And it didn't move the way she expected it to.

She tried the other arm. Same thing. She tried a leg. It moved wrong, too. So did her other leg. It didn't hurt to move them, they just… weren't moving the way she knew they should be. They were bending in the wrong spots, and at weird angles.

Cue the freakout about being a lizard in 3… 2…

She tried just moving her fingers. But even that was wrong. They didn't spread the way she knew they did, and she couldn't even seem to get them to spread apart into five distinct fingers at all.

Her skin felt dry, too, and she was cold as well. Her body was resting on top of some strange surface with an uneven texture, too. A texture that was almost familiar, but she couldn't immediately place it. And parts of her felt heavy in a way that she knew wasn't natural.

There was Something was very wrong with her body. And, though the headache made her not want to open her eyes, she knew she had to. Fears ran through her mind, racing, making her scared that something terrible had happened to her. The creeping feeling of dread inside her knew something wasn't right, and she knew she wouldn't be able to relax until she knew what.

IMO, the bit in underlined feels like it’d be a bit more impactful if it gave a couple of concrete fears, since at the moment, it feels a bit vague and hazy.

So she opened her eyes.

They opened wrong.

Chloe:
laughter-worried.gif


Everything was bright. She blinked her eyes a few times, trying to adjust to the brightness. She became aware that there was a bright light directly above her, casting everything around her in a warm glow. And she was facing up, directly at it.

She looked down, immediately needing to see her body. The way her head tilted wasn't quite right and her vision felt weird, off in a way she couldn't place. She cast those thoughts aside and focused, as she looked down at her body.

IMO, the underlined is a bit redundant since you talk about Chloe looking down to see her body just a couple sentences later.

She didn't recognise it. In fact, for a moment, she wasn't sure it even was her body. It sure didn't look like she thought her body should look. It didn't even look like a human body.

She saw a mess of limbs and claws and scales, a horrifying, inhuman abomination of a body.

I feel like the “human body” / “inhuman body” is a little bit too samey in feeling. I would suggest trying to communicate this same concept while only using one of human/inhuman in such close succession. One offhand suggestion that could also tee up how much if any amnesia Chloe has would be to turn the first “human body” into a description of some of the features her human body had (e.x. rough skin tone, limb arrangement, etc.)

Yellow scales coated her torso, which continued from her neck with no separation. It extended out into two thin limbs that ended in black-scaled digits that were most definitely not fingers. As her gaze continued down, she saw what must have been legs, though they barely looked any different from her "arms", ending in the same black-scaled digits. She became distinctly aware of a dull ache below her, and realised she must had to be lying on a tail. And there were two bulky weights on either side of her head that were far too large and heavy to be ears.

Chloe:
lisa-simpson-scared-screaming-fire-hell-8liojc9b6ssh1yp6.gif


She wanted to scream, but her mouth didn't move the way she needed it to. She wanted to cry, but tears didn't seem to be coming to whatever eyes she had now. She wanted to run, but she couldn't even move her mess of a form into a standing position, let alone try to walk.

She struggled uselessly, recklessly flailing her wrong limbs in whatever direction she could, as though it would do something. A strange, inhuman cry left her mouth, an alien, animalistic screech left her mouth. Not that it seemed to do any good. She was completely stuck, alone, in a terrifying foreign body.

For a second, I thought that we were going to do a redux of Quenched Torch’s setup, but then I remembered that Chloe specifically addressed Daphne by name earlier, so I guess we’ll see what’s going on between those two pretty quick.

After a few minutes, she heard a strange sound. Could it have been footsteps? Someone coming to help her, to free her! Or was that just her hope talking? She couldn't trust her own body right now, so how was she supposed to trust her senses?

Her eyes slightly focused on the door to the room as a shape came in. She was in a room. She hadn't even processed that.

The shape seemed to be familiar too. It was pink and looked like coral. But it was moving?

Wait.

Okay, now I’m really curious as to how Chloe apparently knows / recognizes Daphne, since this thought process feels very “isekaied human brought from another world” right now.

She knew what this was.

A word came to her. Sunnygo.

Oh, so Chloe is Japanese. Or else comes from a part of the world that uses Japanese names for Pokémon.

Was that what this was? It seemed right, but… No, wait. She should be using a different name. She should be using…

Corsola! That was it. This was a Corsola. Water-type Pokémon, from Johto.

Well, scratch that about her being Japanese. Though I’m not fully sure what was going on with the dipping into Japanese localization names, but I’ll certainly keep an eye on it since I feel like there’s a deeper story behind whatever just happened there.

So relieved in figuring this out, Chloe didn't even notice she'd stopped flailing her body, or that the Corsola had come over to her.

It gave a small smile. "I see you're awake. How are you feeling?"

Chloe: “I’m stuck in a body that I don’t belong in!
401076862924750848.webp

Cetus: “... I’ll just go ahead and take that answer as ‘completely off my rocker’.”

Chloe froze. It had just… spoken to her. Pokémon couldn't speak. Or, they weren't supposed to be able to! She knew that this, too, was wrong.

But, when it spoke, had it even been speech? She'd heard a faint sound like scraping rocks, a sound that couldn't have been any kind of language she recognised. But, somehow, she understood it. That didn't make any sense. Noises didn't carry understandable meaning like that, not in the way words did. And the Corsola had not used words. But, she still understood.

Oh, so Chloe is able to hear a disconnect between the actual sounds that the different Pokémon in this setting are making versus her brain auto-translating whatever the Pokémon are saying. That’s definitely a neat dichotomy that I haven’t seen done too often.

A little shaken, she tried to reply, knowing her mouth wouldn't be able to make the right shapes to form words. "What's going on…?"

Now she had done it. She knew that what had come out of her mouth, what she had heard, was just a hissing noise. And yet… that hiss seemed to have communicated a sentence, words, tone, and all.

Chloe: “... Am I going crazy? How on earth is this even possible?” O_o;

And an understandable sentence too, if the Corsola's next sentence, spoken in that same, scraping manner, was anything to go by.

"You are in the medical center of the Ceres Fishing Guild. My name is Corsola Cetus, and I am the healer here. One of our apprentices found you unconscious on the side of the road last night, and brought you here to receive care."

Oh, so Daphne is new to this place, huh? Part of me wonders if it should’ve been revealed as part of Daphne’s own thought process prior to this point, but I suppose it’s better to have that now rather than never.

Still a little dazed, Chloe was barely able to focus on the Corsola's words, and let out a questioning hiss. "How can I understand you?"

"What do you mean?" the Corsola asked, with speech communicating confusion and concern.

"I…" Chloe hesitated. "What's wrong with my body?"

Corsola: “... You’re a perfectly normal Helioptile? What, did you get hit with a Transfer Orb before passing out or something? (Even if I could’ve sworn that their effects are supposed to be volatile…)”
916590116670144542.webp


The Corsola blinked. "My examination didn't suggest anything was wrong with your body. But, I've never had to treat a Helioptile before, and I don't have any resources on hand that cover your species. Why, what feels wrong?"

[ ]

"Helioptile?" Chloe asked. The word sounded familiar, but not overly so.

It probably makes sense to dwell on Chloe’s reaction/thought process a little more, especially if some little voice in her head is going “Oh, I’m an Erikiteru” right about now.

"Yes," the Corsola cautiously returned. "Your species."

"I'm not…" she replied, trying to put her frustration into words. "I'm not a Helioptile. I'm a human. This isn't my body!"

The Corsola moved back. [ ]

"A… human?"

Even past her headache, Chloe was able to pick up on the sense of confusion tied to how the Corsola said the word "human", like it was unfamiliar to her. She didn't know what that meant, exactly, but it didn't seem like a good sign.

IMO, a part of the reaction that is being described in the last paragraph should be pulled forward prior to the point where Cetus speaks up and asks questions.

"Never mind," she said, with a small sigh. "Can you tell me about Helioptile? What sort of Pokémon are they?"

[ ]

"You don't know?" the Corsola asked, surprised.

Out of habit, Chloe shook her head. The weights on either side bounced around uncomfortably, distracting her for a moment.

Another spot where it might make sense to describe Cetus’
795119682369093724.gif
-tier reaction a bit more explicitly than you presently do.

Fortunately, the gesture seemed to convey a negative, however, and the Corsola began. "Helioptile are very rare around here, so I don't know much. As far as I know they mostly live in the desert. But… they're lizards, so they're ectotherms, of course.

[ ]

Oh, sorry, if the heat lamp's set too cool or too warm, by the way. I wasn't sure what your preferred temperature range was, so I did slightly higher than our Guildmaster's preferred. I… believe Helioptile are lightning types, at least? I don't know much beyond that, sorry."

Cetus’ dialogue is long enough that it probably makes sense to break it up into two smaller pieces with something in between them.

She was a lightning lizard… She assumed "lightning" meant electric type, unless she was wrong about what the types were, too. It almost seemed cool, like something out of a fantasy. She felt like she probably would've dreamed about becoming a Pokémon when she was a kid. It felt like the type of thing kids would dream about. Though… she couldn't actually remember what she did dream about as a kid.

Oh, so the “lightning”-type was a deliberate choice. Though that makes me wonder what the in-setting names of all the other types are now.

And, as she thought more about it, she wasn't sure she could remember being a kid. Or… anything about herself at all. She couldn't remember what she looked like. Her friends, her family, her home: nothing. Just her name, and that she was a human.

Waaaait, but if Chloe doesn’t remember what she looked like, how does she know that she had a human body? Is the idea that she didn’t remember the specifics of what she looked like?

She still knew what things were. Which she supposed meant she remembered them, but she couldn't remember how she knew them. She could list out the eighteen Pokémon types, and their strengths and weaknesses, but she didn't have a clue how she'd learned this.

So, did whatever presence brought her to this world just leave a Pokédex in her mind running? Or are we going to see Chloe at points draw blanks on what certain Pokémon she never saw as a human are called.

And as she began to realise this, that growing sense of dread returned. And she began to shake.

The Corsola—Cetus, she remembered—noticed this, instantly alert. "What's wrong?"

"I… I don't remember. I can't remember anything," she blurted out, through wide eyes.

I kinda wonder if the bit in underlined would’ve worked better if we saw more of this dread play out through Chloe’s own inner thoughts and feelings, since something about this feels very “informed attribute” even if logically Chloe should be freaking out hard right now.

[ ]

"Uh, shh… It's okay," the Corsola said, in a somewhat soothing tone. "Look, do you at least remember your name?"

She nodded. "It's Chloe."

IMO, this feels like a spot where it might make sense to dwell on some combination of these characters’ reactions or inner thoughts.

"Okay, Chloe," Cetus said. "Look, I'm going to get you sent over to the hospital in a few hours. They'll be able to take better care of you there, and they'll have psychics who can take a look at your mind. How's that sound?"

[ ]

"Good…" Chloe said, a little calmer.

I’m surprised that Chloe isn’t having any reaction to the idea of Pokémon running a hospital on their own given how the concept surely would sound super-alien to her.

"Great," Cetus replied, face much calmer, smiling again. "I don't suppose you remember where you lost your tag, then?"

"Tag?" she asked.

The Corsola nodded, motioning to a faded blue band around one of her branches. "Something like this. Something you wear somewhere on your body to show you're not wild. The colour shows how you'd prefer to be addressed. Is 'she/her' fine with you?"

… Wait, I just realized that Daphne’s tag was mentioned all of once earlier in this chapter and the significance of it was never communicated. It might at the least merit explicitly having Uma address Daphne with a gender to get an idea of what the tag system means (I’m guessing that the green tag mentioned in passing is supposed to be for non-binary address, but that’s supported by exactly nothing).

Though that must get super awkward for any Pokémon that are colorblind (or just blind) by species since they would literally not be able to identify how to address who they’re speaking to.

"Oh, uh… Yeah, that's fine," Chloe said.

"Good; I know where the spare blue tags are kept," Cetus responded with a small smile. "Let me go and get you one now. Would you like some breakfast?"

Okay, so blue tags are indeed for female address. Though I’m now curious as to what these Pokémon count as breakfast and if it’s going to make Chloe freak out a bit.

Chloe blinked. She wasn't sure she could even stomach the thought of breakfast now. Everything was still so disorienting and she just needed a minute to think. "I… I'm fine."

[ ]

"Okay. I'll be back soon if you need anything," the Corsola responded. "Rest up, in the meantime."

Chloe nodded, and Cetus turned to go. As she was making her way out the door, Chloe gave a somewhat louder hiss. "Thank you."

The Corsola turned back, with the same small smile. "Of course."

IMO, somewhere in this sequence, it probably makes sense to put in at least one paragraph stopping to slow down and describe the characters’ reactions and things going on. Though I’m just realizing that this whole time that we didn’t really get a solid description of the room. Like you can get away with it since we’re in a third person limited narration following Chloe’s perspective, so we see only whatever Chloe sees in the room, but it does make things a bit hard to visualize at times.

She left the room, and Chloe closed her eyes, trying to let herself process everything. It was so much. She was a Pokémon, in a body she couldn't move, probably in an unfamiliar world with how Cetus didn't seem to know what a human was, and with no memories.

inb4 Cetus is less ignorant about humans than she initially seemed. Wouldn’t be terribly shocked at things going in either direction.

She Chloe didn't think she could ever get used to this strange way her body moved, how it felt. Sure, it might've been cool to be a Pokémon in theory, but it felt awful. Did she have to walk on four legs? How did that even work?

If she was an electric type, did she have to worry about maintaining electric charges? How did she use attacks? What if she accidentally shocked someone? She wanted to run away, and not have to think about any of this.

Narrator:
the-simpsons-mr-burns.gif

Chloe: “... Oh yay, me.” ._.

And this strange new world. She was pretty sure that, wherever she was from, she hadn't heard of the places Cetus had mentioned. And she'd definitely never heard of this tag system. The term "healer" felt new, as well. There were nurses and doctors and stuff, but she was pretty sure there weren't just Pokémon working these types of jobs. Was this world only inhabited by Pokémon? That seemed strange.

I’m surprised that Chloe’s just reacting to all the obvious weirdness involving how these Pokémon live now instead of also having at least internal reactions as some of this information was getting revealed by Cetus.

Her memories were gone, too. She couldn't remember anything that had happened to her before this point. And for some reason, this gave her a deep sense of loss and sadness. Could you be sad for losing your memories, memories you don't even remember having, of things you don't remember doing, people you don't remember meeting? Who had she been? What had she done? Who did she care about? Had she lost someone important? The possibilities seemed almost scarier than the idea of knowing.

The bit in underlined feels like something that works better seeing come through in Chloe’s internal thoughts as opposed to being just said by the narration like this.

What had happened to her, though? Why was she a Pokémon? Why didn't she have any of her memories? Had she died, and this was her reincarnation? That didn't seem right, unless something had gone wrong. Did someone do this to her on purpose? Maybe she was a chosen hero sent here by a powerful deity to save this world of Pokémon. But that didn't seem likely. More likely, she was sent here to torment her with this awful, uncompromising body and her empty, useless mind.

Her head was still pounding. Cetus had distracted her from it, but it was back in full force. Forcing her eyes shut, Chloe tried to get to sleep. Maybe then she wouldn't have to think about any of this.

Chloe: “Maybe I’ll wake up and this will all turn out to be a bad drea-”
- Cue seeing the threadmark index with three more chapters after this -
Chloe: “... Fantastic.”
401074476474957834.webp

Alright, so if you’ve followed how I usually review stories on forums like this, you’re probably aware that I have a short recap at the end of these things giving a Cliffs’ Notes version of my feedback for people who can’t go through 20+ pages of line-by-lines immediately, so let’s just hop right into the highlight reel:

I thought that the characterization in this story was pretty fun. Both Daphne and Chloe were fun to follow and clearly have quite a bit of story behind them past what we saw so far. The supporting all also stuck out decently well, not sure if we’ll see them all again, especially Uma, but they did a decent job at making a first impression and sticking in my mind. I also thought that the worldbuilding that you had seemed interesting from what I could see of it, even if there were a few parts that made me wish we could get a bit of a better look at things since you’ve clearly built a big world for this story and there’s a lot that even with the little passing snatches we get, sounds like it’ll be a lot of fun to see.

That said, there were some flaws that I thought held things back a bit for your introductory chapter. The most immediate thing that I noticed was that there were lots of missed opportunities for description, both in of surroundings and things happening such as body language, as well as the internal thought side of things. While conciseness is a virtue in storytelling, sometimes there’s value in slowing down and smelling the proverbial roses, especially as a vehicle for getting to know the characters and the world better. Like there were a lot of little hints regarding Daphne’s background in particular that felt like they were missing context to link them together, something that wouldn’t have been the case had we gotten to see Daphne’s thought process bleed into the narration a bit more such as her reacting to going back to work after a recent holiday or selling the sense that even if she’s lived in the area, that she’s still a bit of an outsider.

I also noticed that you had a bit of a trend to tell and not show emotional states. Like it’s one thing to be told by the narration that a character feels sad, but it’s almost always more impactful to see it play out through their own reactions and their own dialogue. Consider showing some of those “told” moments off a bit more through your characters own proverbial voices. I also thought that some of the characters’ reactions strained suspension of disbelief a bit, especially in the sequences where everyone’s just not batting an eye or displaying any urgency to treat Chloe while Daphne is dragging her around. Like maybe it actually makes sense in their world since Pokémon shambling through the door or getting drug in passed out is another Tuesday, but if so, you ideally want to provide context for that either in narration or in characters’ dialogue since it won’t be what your readers reflexively assume.

But altogether, I think that even if this chapter could’ve used a bit more polish, that it had a pretty solid core to it, and seems like a promising enough hook. I’m not fully sure how I should be getting a read on Sobek, but you’ve certainly got me interested in finding out more about Daphne and Chloe along with their present neighborhood, and I certainly wouldn’t mind coming back to this story sometime @FennecWitch .

Thanks for the patience and hope the feedback was helpful for you.
 

FennecWitch

Fiery Beacon
Pronouns
she/her
@Spiteful Murkrow Thank you for the review! I've read a few of your reviews of other works (mostly PoV, to be honest) and find your reviewing process both entertaining and useful, so I appreciate this review. I won't respond to every point—just the cliff notes version—but please know I did very much read and enjoy your whole review!

Characterisation and worldbuilding are definitely my favourite parts of writing so I'm glad those came across well.

And yeah, description, my old nemesis. I always find that I've never ended up describing things, whether it be the setting or characters' thoughts, as much as I should be. Which is likely due to me falling into the trap of "well I know it so the reader probably does too". So I'll definitely be keeping an eye out in future for points where I can improve my descriptions.

Another reason my descriptions failed is that, especially for this story, I tend to lean very heavily into third person limited both to try not to reveal things to the audience and for the sake of 'realism'. For instance, you pointed out that I didn't describe the colour of the lizard when they're first introduced, so the audience didn't get a good picture of which Pokémon it was until later. I think my thought process there was that it was dark so Daphne wouldn't be able to make out the colour (which is ridiculous anyway—sea lions have great night vision) but there are definitely times where you should ignore things like that for the sake of audience understanding and I do not do that as much as I should. I think I was also worried about coming off too expository and overcorrected.

As for telling and not showing I'd certainly like to believe that it's something I've gotten better at since I wrote these first few chapters but I'm probably not the best judge of that. And the characters' reactions is something I'll admit I just didn't put as much thought into as I should have. Another thing I will definitely keep in mind going forward, thank you.

If I end up going back over these early chapters I will likely update a lot of this, but I'm a little worried of getting caught in the cycle of constantly updating early chapters at the expense of continuing the story >.<

Overall, I'm glad you found it interesting! And thank you for the review—it was very helpful in letting me know what I need to be focusing more on in my future writing.
 

Arukona

A Scribe Penning His Brainworms
Location
Ardalion
Pronouns
He/him
Partners
  1. aggron
  2. sceptile
  3. lucario
Hello, hello! Here I am to review this fic for a round of V-Wheel over at United, and for this review, I'll be covering the first two chapters.

First impressions regarding the cover, I see we have some rather uncommon choices for protagonists in having a Helioptile and a Brionne: certainly not two species choices you see every day as main characters in PMD fics. There is Ayza from PMD: Free Fiction, but she's a Salandit-Helioptile hybrid, so it's not quite the same as Chloe here.

Now into the chapters themselves...

Chapter 1
So we open on a beach, where Daphne is catching a Remoraid for their lunch. I see already that the inhabitants of this world aren't afraid to eat other Pokémon, so we can see which side of the meat debate this fic ends up on. And nor is Daphne fond of blood either; makes me wonder if there might've been an incident once upon a time that made her squeamish around blood.
She slung the bag over her shoulder, taking care not to disturb the smooth grey stone attached to a cord tied around her neck, before heading to the path through the forest and back to town
Huh, I wonder if the smooth grey stone is like the Relic Fragment from EoS at all? (Also minor grammar nitpick - there's no full stop at the end.)

Lilly's a cute one - I've always liked the Lillipup line for the cute puppers they are.

She was almost out of the forest when her eyes happened to glance over at a flash of colour on the side of the path. She blinked, then slowly approached it.


It looked like some kind of reptile.
I would think mentioning the bright yellow of the Helioptile, as opposed to 'a flash of colour', might be better here, given that it is the aspect of this which would draw attention. And also it might clue in the audience more and hint to them what species this might be. The descriptor of only 'the lizard' in the next few paragraphs doesn't give away much and could imply a lot more species given how many lizards are among the 1025 species in the collection of critters that we call Pokémon.
Daphne dropped the bag of fish outside the cave. "I need you to look after this until tomorrow. I found an injured Pokémon and I can't carry them and this bag."
Hopefully the fish doesn't rot in that time.
635766661743640596.webp


I can't imagine it would be easy for Daphne to get to and from town on solid ground, given their flippers. Still, I can understand why you choose not to mention it - it would make the story much more cumbersome to write if this issue was dwelt on all the time.
Basic and lightning type
So types go by different names in this universe...Interesting. I wonder what some of the others might be called.
You don't look like you're much suited for land. What brings you here?"


Daphne closed her eyes. "I live here."


Uma must have sensed the tinge of annoyance in her voice, because he went silent after that.
Ah, I see I'm not the only one who questioned Daphne being on land. The tinge of annoyance must mean she's asked this on a regular basis, although that does beg the question of how Daphne became a land 'mon and not a sea 'mon. Was it due to her parents being land 'mons as well? There'll probably be an answer to this in time.

Guildmaster Sobek seems quite the stern leader, and judging by the way he judges Daphne for not bringing fish, I'm willing to bet he doesn't fall into the 'stern but kind' trope that some folks of his ilk do.

When Chloe came to, she had a pounding headache, and her body was wrong.
Ah, here comes the "I'm a Pokémon!" moment that most fics have.
Her skin felt dry, too
It just occurred to me that having a Water partner in Daphne is going to prove to be a godsend for Chloe once the two get under way as partners. Because her Dry Skin's gonna prove debilitating early on, no doubt.

She wanted to scream, but her mouth didn't move the way she needed it to. She wanted to cry, but tears didn't seem to be coming to whatever eyes she had now. She wanted to run, but she couldn't even move her mess of a form into a standing position, let alone try to walk.
This captures well the struggles with body movement that most humans would no doubt have if they were in a Helioptile body. Good job on these descriptions.
A word came to her. Sunnygo.
Hm, using the Japanese name? Interesting...What could this imply?

I like the intonation used for each Pokémon with speech, like how Cetus communicates with 'a noise like scraping rocks', and how Chloe hisses, and yet this is all communication to them - they can still understand each other at the end of the day.

"You are in the medical center of the Ceres Fishing Guild.
Oh, so that was why they were so focused on getting fish, and why Sobek was cross at Daphne for not getting any.

Even past her headache, Chloe was able to pick up on the sense of confusion tied to how the Corsola said the word "human", like it was unfamiliar to her. She didn't know what that meant, exactly, but it didn't seem like a good sign.
So her amnesia goes to the extent that she forgets she's even human? Fascinating...I wonder how this amnesia's gonna prove to be - is it just a matter of wiping the slate clean, or will she regain some memories over time?

Ooh, neat that the tags hint at a 'mon's gender and preferred pronouns. Neat little worldbuilding detail. :quag:

Could you be sad for losing your memories, memories you don't even remember having, of things you don't remember doing, people you don't remember meeting?
This is admittedly a little nitpick of a personal pet peeve of mine, but the way how this line is with how it pivots to 'you' when the rest of the paragraph has 'she' used - it makes it almost feel as though the audience is being posed this question, and not Chloe asking this. I generally don't like it in writing when the question is worded as 'you' - it is something I'm not a fan of, personally. Maybe if this were reworded to the following:
Could she be sad for losing her memories, memories she didn't even remember having, of things she didn't remember doing, people she didn't remember meeting?
I feel this looks a bit better.

Chapter 2

that meant it was a good excuse for her to avoid having to go to Sobek's office and be told that she wasn't doing enough to support the guild.
No one loves punishment or reprimands, especially when they're time-wasting, pointless and undeserved. Can't say I blame Daphne for her attitude here.

"Oh, uh, hi. Thanks. And, um, nice to meet you? I'm Chloe." She spoke up, her voice coming out in a strange hiss, not like the speech of other reptilian Pokémon Daphne had heard before. Maybe they had met before…? That name sounded familiar.
Hmm, did they meet in passing pre-amnesia? Because the fact that Daphne didn't recognise Chloe through her appearance could imply that maybe she knew her through a different form, perhaps. :eyes:

"No, I mean… I don't remember anything before I woke up here. Just my name and, uh…" She trailed off for a moment, before resuming. "Yeah, just my name."
Not comfortable revealing her humanity, I see.

How did you…?"

"Because," Daphne began, closing her eyes, "I woke up a few years ago with no memories except my name. Just like you."
Huh...interesting. Very interesting. So both hero and partner are amnesiacs, except Daphne's been in this world for a good few years. I guess this would explain why she doesn't live in the ocean and lives on land instead, because that was the environment she would've settled in.

Just a note that some of the dialogue tags in this passage between Chloe and Daphne do get somewhat repetitive. For instance:
The Helioptile's eyes widened. "That… Wait, there is something else I remember, too. I'm not a Pokémon. I'm a human."

Daphne's eyes widened. "That… Humans aren't real. Like, they're not a thing that exists."
'Eyes widened' is used twice here. There's also other instances where dialogue tags are used when in reality, if it's a back-and-forth exchange between the two, you could drop some of those dialogue tags and descriptions and it would actually flow better. For instance:
Daphne's eyes widened. "That… Humans aren't real. Like, they're not a thing that exists."

"What do you mean?" Chloe said, with an undercurrent of nervousness.

"I've never met anyone who's ever heard of anything called 'humans'."

"Then how do you know what they are?"

"When I found you...the reason I brought you back with me, is because I thought I heard you say my name. Do you know me?"
As seen here, you don't necessarily need dialogue tags for everything. It also saves the repetition of names and species names, as well as the wrangling for epithets that goes on in some fics.

Daphne nodded back, then left the room, mind still reeling.
I feel an example of showing how Daphne's mind is reeling would be optimal, such as showing her thoughts reflecting on the exchange she had with Chloe just beforehand. As opposed to just 'telling' it through narration.

And now back to Chloe, who's not having a good time in this stretcher.

It didn't help that something felt really weird with her eyesight. Everything felt like it was a weird colour. She almost wanted to say purple, but that wasn't right.
And the sun was beaming down, too. It was… Well, actually it felt nice. Nice and warm. Which was weird, because her body didn't actually seem like it was warm. If anything, it felt colder than it should be. But the sun was still nice and warm.
I rather like these two lines here implying the lizard nature of what Chloe's become and how she's reacting to these odd changes to how she perceives things. Makes it feel much more animal-like, as opposed to some fics that would not touch on this and as a result would make the whole thing feel more like 'people in fursuits', so to speak. (I'm somewhat guilty of this too, I'll admit.)

Okay, what about height?
Well, whatever height Chloe was, she sure as hell won't redeem a similar height upon evolving due to Heliolisk being not exactly what you'd call 'tall'. :mewlulz:

Wherever she'd lived, it must've been too hot to wear a jacket at some point recently.
So she was isekaied at some point in the summer, presumably? That, or Chloe lives somewhere with a Mediterranean-esque climate like California.
It was a big building, with multiple storeys, at least, but was hardly the huge pristine prestigious medical facility she'd expected. Instead, it was a simpler brick building, extending a decent bit back towards the ocean, but not hugely expansive in the way she'd imagined.
What, was Chloe expecting this place to have an equivalent of the Mayo Clinic? A bigger medical facility would only belong in the larger towns, I'd imagine.

They looked clean enough, though not the pristine white she'd expect from a hospital, instead having what looked like stone floors.
A more primitive setting like most PMD fics are, by the looks of it.

And since she was an electric type, she might end up accidentally letting out a shock and electrocuting everyone else in the water.
Must be a bummer for Electric-types to figure out they can't swim in water as it would be a hazard to everyone else. That's gotta suck. :sadbees:

Also gotta approve of the whole 'lightning types gotta discharge every once in a while' worldbuilding tidbit.

Close your eyes, and focus on your aura.
Ah, I see aura's not limited to what this world's punchdogs can envisage through their senses.

Good to see Chloe succeed in her electricity discharge. One step towards becoming more in tune with this new strange body of hers.

Conclusion

And that oughta wrap it up for this review. To summarise: I was quite a fan of the way you elaborated the Pokémon in this as more animal-like creatures, particularly regarding the way they communicate, such as hissing on Chloe's part, as well as her feeling cold-blooded like lizards normally do. The tag system the inhabitants of this world use as a way to tell which pronouns they prefer to be known by was also quite a neat detail. The world of Asphodel also feels quite intriguing, based on the map, and I look forward to seeing more of the world beyond this small village that Daphne lives in. There's also the intrigue that Chloe and Daphne have similar circumstances in that both of them feel familiar to the other, and I look forward to seeing how that plays out.

As for the downsides, there were some issues I had with the prose that I've pointed out already, along with the need for greater description in some parts. But those are issues that can be overcome, and as this fic is still in its infancy, such mistakes are fairly common among fics at a similar point in time.

This was a good read regardless, and I wish you luck on your future writing endeavours.
 

FennecWitch

Fiery Beacon
Pronouns
she/her
@Arukona Thank you for your review! A lot of the prose issues are just down to me not having edited the earlier chapters finely enough, which I do need to go back and do at some point. The lack of description is definitely something I will continue to work on, since it's the thing I am most consistently bad at. I'm hoping that I have gotten better about that in the more recent chapters, but we shall see!

The animalistic nature of Pokémon being emphasised is something I'm glad came across well, as it's something I really want to emphasise in this fic, since I feel it leads to much more interesting stories and world-building.

Thanks again for the review!
 
Chapter 5: Gentleness of Light Escaping

FennecWitch

Fiery Beacon
Pronouns
she/her
Chapter 5: Gentleness of Light Escaping

Author's Note: Chapter title is from "That Distant Shore" from Steven Universe

CW: Blood, body dysphoria, memory loss, thalassophobia



It was nice, being in the water again. After everything that had happened last night and this morning, Daphne could just relax her mind and let her instincts take over. She could just lose herself in the hunt. No stress, no fear. Just calm.

She traced the trails of the wild fish through the water, slowly gaining on them, before finally pouncing on them. It was nice.

She'd actually been pretty productive, today. She'd almost caught more than the past few days combined. It was amazing how efficient trying not to think about something could make you. Good thing she'd brought a few bags with the wagon.

Resurfacing with her latest catch, she made her way back over to the shore, checking the position of the sun. Yeah, she should probably start heading back soon. She had plenty of time before curfew, but she needed to actually talk with Lily, and check on Chloe if she didn't show up soon.

She dropped the fish in her current bag, before sealing it up. Just get cleaned up, and… Oh, there was Chloe.

She waved a flipper at the Helioptile, who was currently looking at her feet with an odd expression as she moved through the sand. "Hey."

Chloe looked up, and her frills spread, her eyes widening, before she blinked. "Oh, uh, hi."

"Sorry, did I scare you?" Daphne asked.

"No, uh, just, um…" the Helioptile looked down, her frills retracting again. "More blood than I was expecting."

"Ah. Right. Sorry, I'll quickly get cleaned up," she replied, quickly turning her head away and moving down to the ocean.

A few minutes later, Daphne made her way back to Chloe, and picked up the bag of fish. She motioned for the Helioptile to follow her, and moved off the sand to where she'd left the wagon, throwing the bag into it.

"Perfect timing, actually," she said. "I just finished. So, uh, you don't have to wait for me."

Chloe nodded. "Oh, uh, yeah."

She looked down, then looked back up at Daphne. "You don't happen to have any water or anything, do you? I got really thirsty on the way here and, well, I don't have any on me. I saw a river, but it was really far down. And I don't know if it was salt water."

Daphne paused. "I don't have any, no. I don't really ever need it? Or, I can't really ever think of a time I've been thirsty like that ever. I do know where there's a small stream nearby, though? If you mean you can't drink seawater, that is."

"Oh, uh, yeah. That'd be nice," Chloe said.

"It's on our way back, anyway. I have to stop by to see a friend near there," she said, putting a flipper through the handle of the wagon.

'Wagon' was perhaps a generous term for what was essentially a small wooden box on wheels, haphazardly nailed together. The wheels were big wooden circles that had a tendency to stop moving every once in a while. The handle was wood, too, and stuck to the front of the cart. It had been sanded down, though, after Daphne had gotten sick of the splinters and angrily demanded the guild's carpenter fix it.

She started to wheel the wagon down the path, and the Helioptile moved up to walk beside her. Something was different about her, though… Daphne kept looking over to her, trying to figure out what it was. Eventually, she got it.

"So, uh," she began, tilting her head over to Chloe. "Any reason you're walking on all fours now?"

Chloe's eyes widened, her head tilting down. "Oh, uh… I started getting sore walking on two legs, so I decided to let my instincts take over, and, well… Yeah. It feels strange to walk like this, but it is a little more comfortable. Physically, I mean."

"Huh. Well, whatever's most comfortable, I guess."

She paused, softly guiding the wagon's wheels over one of the tree roots that crossed the path. The roots weren't large enough to be a huge issue, but the wood had come apart when she'd pulled it too roughly over one last spring. It had not been fun getting everything back to town after that.

"So, how was your meeting with this mysterious Espeon?" Daphne asked, looking up again.

Chloe tilted her head to the side. "Complicated?"

She quickly recounted her encounter with the Espeon.

When she had finished, Daphne tilted her head to the side. "You're not actually going to go back, are you?"

"I am," the Helioptile replied, with a quiet hiss. "Even if he doesn't tell me anything, I need to know stuff about this world. Or, I want to know things. I want to learn how to read, at least. So unless you've got time to teach me, he seems to be my best bet."

"Chloe, there are classes and stuff you can take on that stuff," Daphne said. "How do you think I learned how to read?"

Chloe lowered her head. "I don't know. It feels like it'd be kind of embarrassing. Wouldn't those classes be mostly for kids? Or are there a lot of adult Pokémon who don't learn how to read?"

She said it in a joking tone, but Daphne shrugged. "More than you'd think, honestly. Some Pokémon live in more wild environments. They usually don't learn to read or write or anything unless they decide they want to move to a more developed area."

"And that's common?" Chloe asked, looking up at Daphne.

"Eh… Not common enough for the classes to not be mostly kids," she replied, thinking back on the classes she'd taken; the annoying brats who'd bombarded her with questions, the instructors who obviously had not wanted to be there either, the frustration of trying to learn it as quickly as she could.

"On second thought, maybe this Espeon is a better option," Daphne finished.

"That bad, huh?" Chloe said, with a smile.

Daphne barked out a laugh. "Don't ask."

She closed her eyes. "Still, though. Don't trust this guy. Whatever he knows about you, whatever he's trying to do, it can't be anything good."

Chloe nodded. "I know. I'm going to be careful."

They continued on for a bit longer. Daphne noticed the Helioptile looking around at the trees, at how tall they stretched. She remembered the first time she'd come out here, how amazed she'd been at the size the trees stretched to, how you could barely see the tops of them. Even after walking through it almost every day, this place still wowed her.

The intricate patterns of the leaves' shadows on the ground, the soft sound of the wild birds and insects, the smell of the trees and plants all around her… It was beautiful. As much as she enjoyed swimming, the ability to move up and down, the way her body crested through the water… It was nothing like this. This wasn't a place she'd ever have been if she'd stayed in the ocean. Despite everything she'd been going through lately, being able to see places like this made it worth living on land.

Soon, Chloe glanced over to her again. "So is this what you do every day? Go out and, uh, catch fish here? On your own?"

Daphne nodded. "Yep."

"Doesn't it get lonely?" the Helioptile asked. "Oh, I guess you probably have friends at the guild and stuff… And this friend of yours we're seeing on the way back?"

Daphne shrugged. "I like it. It's peaceful. I'm… not really the most social Pokémon."

"You don't get bored, doing the same thing every day?"

"Nah," she replied. "I don't think I'd call it fun, but… It's something I like doing. It's something I'm good at. And it lets me provide for myself."

Or, it used to.

"What about on your days off? You can't work every day, right?" Chloe asked.

She shrugged again. "I mean, I get Platinas off."

Chloe blinked. "Platinas?"

"Yeah," Daphne said, then paused. "Ah. Right. Days in a week. Rubia, Emera, Dima, Perla, Platina."

"Wait, only five?" she said, looking up at Daphne.

Daphne nodded. "Five days in a week, four weeks in a month, four months in a season, four seasons in a year. Plus Legend Day."

Chloe sighed. "See, this is exactly why I want to talk to Theseus again."

She narrowed her eyes, looking up at Daphne. "You still didn't answer my question, though. What do you do on your one day off a week?"

Daphne shrugged. "Honestly, not much. I use it as a chance to sleep in? Rest my body? Relax?"

Chloe tilted her head to the side. "Right. Okay."

She didn't sound very convinced by that answer for some reason. Regardless, the conversation seemed to end there, as they continued in relative silence until they reached the way to Lily's cave.

Leaving the wagon half-obscured beneath a bush, Daphne turned to Chloe. "Okay, it's through here. There's not really a path or anything. So, just stick close to me. "

She looked judgingly at the wagon poking out from the bush. "Is it okay to leave that there?"

Daphne waved a flipper in the air. "Yeah, it's fine. I do it all the time. The wilds that live in this area mostly don't eat fish."

It was probably best not to mention the time she'd failed to fight off a wild Toucannon.

Chloe flicked her tail. "Well, okay then. So, who's this friend of yours?"

"Lillipup Lily," Daphne said, starting to make her way through the brush.

She heard Chloe stop behind her. "Wait, seriously? That's really her name? She's a Lillipup named… Lily."

"That's what she told me," Daphne replied. "I wouldn't be surprised if it wasn't her real name, but I haven't exactly asked."

"What do you mean?" the Helioptile asked.

"It's… complicated," she replied. "And 'friend' is probably a strong word. She's just… someone I help out. You'll see."

"Okay…" Chloe replied.

Daphne turned back to check on Chloe a few times as they moved through the brush, but she didn't seem to be having any difficulty. In fact, she seemed completely fine. Chloe even got ahead of her at one point before Daphne reminded her that she didn't know where she was going.

"Sorry," the Helioptile hissed, tail tilted down. "Got carried away."

It made sense. Her body was probably much better suited to this terrain. Although that was true about most terrain except underwater. Brionne were not really designed for land travel.

They soon finished making their way through the brush, arriving outside the small cave. 'Cave' was kind of a generous word, as well. It was tucked between a few trees, where the land inclined upwards. A small dirt hole in the side of the hill. Daphne hadn't actually ever been inside, but it seemed to extend down a decent amount, although whether that was natural or the result of the Lillipup's digging, she wasn't sure.

"Lily?" Daphne called out. "You there?"

She heard some faint sounds of movement from inside the cave, before a small Lillipup padded up out of the entrance. Her eyes quickly darted over to Chloe, and she froze for a second, before looking back at Daphne and relaxing a little.

"Oh, um, hi," she said, looking down. "Is this, um, the Pokémon you told me about, Daphne?"

Daphne nodded. "That's right. I would've warned you I was bringing her, but it was kind of short notice. And I needed to come see you today."

"N-no, it's okay," Lily said quickly.

She looked up at the Helioptile. "You're Chloe, right?"

"That's right," Chloe said with a nod. "It's nice to meet you, Lily."

Lily's ears twitched, and she nodded back. "Right. Nice to meet you."

"You're here for the fish, right?" she said, looking over at Daphne. "I, um, kept them as cold as I could? Which… wasn't very."

Daphne sighed, wrapping a flipper around the stone around her neck. "Not exactly. Or, not entirely."

Lily tilted her head to the side. "Oh? Then, why…?"

She felt Chloe's eyes also watching her. Probably just as curious as Lily, considering she hadn't said anything to her.

She sighed again, then swallowed. "Look, I… Last night, the Guildmaster spoke to me. He… Well, he basically said that I needed to either actually go out on boats to fish with the other guild members, or leave the guild. I have until the end of the week to decide."

She felt Chloe's gaze on her and avoided looking back at her.

She tried to ignore Lily's eyes looking up at her, too. "Which would mean… I don't know if I'd be able to keep bringing you food. I'm sorry."

Daphne didn't know what reaction she expected from Lily. Maybe for her to grow angry and lash out at her. Maybe for her to plead or beg with her not to do this. Maybe crying, though she'd never heard the Lillipup cry. She expected something dramatic, though.

Instead, Lily sighed, looking down. "Yeah… I figured something like this would happen sooner or later."

Daphne looked up at her. "Look, I don't want you to have to—"

"I know it's not your fault," Lily cut her off. "I… don't know if I could really stay here much longer anyway. The berry trees and stuff don't really produce much over the winter. Not the ones around here, at least. I just… didn't want to leave you, but…"

Daphne looked down. Chloe was silent. Daphne wasn't sure if she didn't know what to say, or if she was just staying out of it.

"Are you… going to be okay?" Daphne asked. "I know you weren't doing well before."

Lily looked up at her, trying to force her ears to perk up. "Yeah. I'll be fine. I'll head back down to Phaeton. I've probably stayed here longer than I should've, anyway. You said you have until the end of the week? And Legend Day was three days ago, right?"

"Yeah," Daphne said. "So, two more days to decide."

The Lillipup nodded. "I'll, um, probably leave tomorrow morning, then. So, I should say goodbye now."

"Right," Daphne replied. "I… Good luck, Lily."

"Thanks. You too," Lily smiled, before looking down. "I should also—"

Shaking her head, she cut herself off. "Nevermind. Hopefully we meet again someday, Daphne."

"I'm… sure you both will," Chloe spoke up, causing Daphne and Lily to both look at her.

"Oh!" Lily said. "Um, bye as well, Chloe, I guess? Sorry."

Chloe smiled. "It's alright. Good luck, Lily."

Lily nodded, her ears flattening. "Yep."

Daphne sighed. "We should be going, anyway."

"What about the fish?" the Lillipup asked. "There's still a few left."

"Keep them," Daphne said, with a small smile.

Lily paused, then nodded. "Thank you. For everything."

Daphne nodded back. "Stay safe."

With that, Daphne and Chloe left back through the brush, making their way back onto the path.



Chloe stared at her reflection in the stream. Or, as much of it as she could see. The movement of the water distorted it enough that it was hard to make out much beyond the colours. She hadn't really seen her reflection since she woke up like this. She hadn't really wanted to.

It was weird to see herself like this. Or, to see her body like this. Because despite everything that she knew, despite having accepted the fact that she was a Pokémon now, her mind still expected to see something else when she looked down into the water. She expected to see her human face, whatever that had looked like. And so seeing something different was jarring. Unsettling, almost.

She shuddered and turned away, closing her eyes for a moment. Her mind drifted over to Theseus. He'd known she was human, somehow. And he knew what a human was.

She wanted to trust him, she really did. But it was impossible to deny just how weird he had acted. She had caught him in a lie and his response to that had not reassured her of his intentions, no matter what he'd said. He said he wanted to help her, but she needed answers. And he didn't seem like he was going to provide any. And yet…

Chloe wanted to return to the library again the next day. Her interaction with the Espeon today had only reaffirmed her suspicions that he was the best way of finding out about her past. Even though he was being cagey, maybe if she talked to him for the next few days he'd eventually open up and tell her? Or slip up, again.

She felt a pang at the thought of trying to manipulate him like that. She didn't know why, but she felt bad for him. He'd seemed scared when she'd pressed him for answers. Though what he was scared of, she had no idea. What could possibly be so bad that he was terrified at the idea of helping her?

Maybe she shouldn't have called him out on his slip up. The things he had told her, even if not relevant to her past, were helpful. So even if he only gave her basic information like that when she came back the next day, it would still help. She still had no idea where she was, besides a town called Ceres in a place called Asphodel, but that didn't mean anything to her geographically.

And she had no idea what was going to happen to her. She couldn't stay in the hospital forever. Eventually she'd have to find somewhere to live. How would that even work? Could she really just move on from her past and just… start a new life in this world she didn't belong in, in this body that wasn't hers? It seemed impossible.

"You okay?"

The voice broke her out of her thoughts. Opening her eyes again, she saw Daphne looking at her, concerned.

Chloe nodded. "Yeah, I'm… I'm not as thirsty as I thought I was."

And that might not have just been an excuse, either. She really wasn't as thirsty as she felt like she should have been. Not as hungry, either. Was that part of being a Pokémon? Could they go for longer without food and water? Or was it a Helioptile thing? Something else to ask Theseus, she supposed.

Daphne tilted her head to the side. "You sure? The water's clean. Like, it is safe to drink."

"I know," she replied. "I just… Like I said, not as thirsty as I thought."

"Okay…" Daphne said, her eyes narrowing slightly. "You ready to keep going, then?"

Chloe nodded. "Yep."

She followed Daphne back onto the main path. They walked in silence for a few minutes, Daphne staring straight ahead, seemingly lost in thought.

The forest was beautiful. Chloe had seen it all on her way too Daphne but it was still incredible. She didn't remember if she'd seen trees this tall before, but these ones stuck out in her mind as being much taller than she'd expect trees to be. Sunlight shone faintly through the tree cover far above. A wide array of colourful bushes, flowers, and other plants covered the ground. Even the path itself wasn't a clear, straight line, slightly winding around the trees, with overgrown plants creeping into the edges of the dirt path.

As she walked through the forest, she could feel that same part of her that knew how to walk on all fours, that knew how to control her body. She felt her instincts, that part of her that Theseus had unlocked. She felt like… her instincts liked this place, somehow. Part of her wanted to climb one of these trees, curl up on a branch, and bask in the sunlight. It was an easy enough desire to suppress, but it was strange. She hadn't even realised her body would be able to climb trees, but now she knew exactly how to do it. Probably why she found it so easy to reach the cave, earlier.

It was an interesting feeling, being aware of her instincts like this. Had she had instincts as a human? She must have, right? Humans would have to have developed instincts at some point. Though, she didn't think she'd ever been aware of her instincts like this as a human.

"So, um," Chloe began. "How did you meet Lily?"

Daphne turned to her. "She tried to steal some fish from me a few months ago. It didn't work, but since she was just a kid, I decided to help her, instead."

"Right," Chloe said. "So you two were friends?"

The Brionne shrugged. "Of a sort, yeah. Why?"

"It's just…" she replied hesitantly. "You seemed sad, having to say goodbye to her."

Daphne sighed. "Yeah. But what can you do? Like she said, she would've had to leave eventually."

That was true, Chloe supposed. But Daphne did seem really sad about it. And from what she'd said earlier, she didn't really seem to have any other friends. She didn't even seem to really like working at the Fishing Guild. So maybe…

"Well," Chloe began. "I don't know what you've decided about the Fishing Guild. But if you don't want to keep working there, you could go with her wherever she's going. We could all go."

Daphne was silent for a moment, before letting go of the wagon, coming to a sudden stop. She looked at Chloe. "You're right. You don't know what I've decided."

Chloe blinked at the sudden harsh tone. "I just thought it might be nice… Since none of us really seem to know what we're doing—"

"You don't know that, Chloe!"

"Okay…" Chloe said, looking up at Daphne. "Then what are you doing? What have you decided?"

Daphne looked down. "I don't… It doesn't matter."

"That's what I thought," Chloe said. "You don't know what you're going to do, do you?"

Daphne glared up at her. "No. But I don't want to leave Ceres. I like it here. If you want to go off with Lily, go ahead."

Chloe frowned. "You just don't seem happy with your life. I thought—"

"You don't know how I feel," the Brionne replied. "I'll make my decision when it's time. But I'm not leaving."

"Why not?" Chloe hissed. She felt her frills flare out. "You do the same thing every day! You might be about to lose your job! Do you even have any other friends besides Lily? What is keeping you here?!"

Daphne doesn't respond, her head hung low. Chloe tries to look at her, to gauge anything from her expression, but it's just… blank.

She takes a few steps forward. "Daphne? I'm sorry, I didn't mean to yell, I just—"

"Do you know what a curfew is, Chloe?" Daphne finally said. Her voice came out as a harsh, gruff, bark.

"I… I do. But—"

"I have a curfew, because I am an apprentice at the Fishing Guild. As an apprentice, there's certain rules I'm meant to follow. I've never been good at following rules, and I've managed to get around most of them, but that one is something they won't budge on. And that's for my own safety, apparently. Because my body means I can't walk on land very well, they don't want something to happen to me at night, and for no one to be around to help me.

"They'd really prefer me not to go across land at all, to go out fishing on the boat with all of them. But I didn't want to, and was too stubborn, so this was their compromise."

She spread her flippers. "Really, I've not even been doing anything useful for the Guild since I joined. A few bags of fish a day at best is nothing compared to everyone else. I think they've only been letting me do this for so long because they felt bad for me."

Chloe looked up at her, her frills slowly retracting and her tail drooping. "Why don't you want to go on the boat?"

Daphne sighed. Her voice is quiet. "I'm scared of the ocean."

Chloe stared at her. "But… You're…"

"I know. I just… can't go out there, where it's far enough from shore that everything looks the same and it's so deep and it's so big and…"

She shudders, squeezing her eyes shut. "I can fish near the shore. That's fine. But if I go too far out, I just… I can't."

Chloe moved closer to her, sitting beside her. They were close enough to the side of the path that someone could probably still go around them. Not that she'd seen anyone going this way on her way here. It didn't seem like many Pokémon used this path.

"Why the Fishing Guild, then?" she asked.

Daphne let out a harsh bark. "I'm not made for much on land. And some of the things I could do, I'd have to talk to Pokémon. And I'm not exactly the best in social situations. It was this or the ferry, and that was getting shut down soon anyway by the time I arrived so…"

She clapped her flippers together. "It was that or moving somewhere else, and I didn't think I'd find much better."

"Do you know why you're afraid of the ocean?" Chloe asked, resting a clawed hand on Daphne's shoulder.

"The earliest thing I can remember," Daphne began, "is waking up one night on a rock in the middle of the ocean. Every direction I looked, there was nothing but ocean, forever. I tried to dive down into it, looking for something, but it was just so… big. I was stuck there for a while, scared to leave. When I got hungry I managed to dive in and catch a few fish, but it was horrible. I never saw anyone else who I could talk to until I worked up the courage to leave."

"What changed?" Chloe asked.

"One night, I saw this huge, bright light in the distance. It was like a star or a lighthouse or something, but even brighter. I'd never seen anything like it before, in however long I'd been there. I got off the rock and began swimming towards it, focusing on it and trying not to think about what was below me.

"Eventually, it disappeared, but by that point I could see land. I'd reached Ceres. I learned to read and write and stuff, then got a job with the Fishing Guild."

Chloe could feel Daphne's breathing becoming uneven. Her flippers were clutching the stone tied around her neck. "I'm… I'm so sorry that happened to you."

Daphne barked out a laugh. "Wasn't your fault. It's fine. I'm… over it now."

Chloe's frowned, tilting her head. "I still don't understand why you don't want to go with Lily, though."

Daphne shrugged. "I don't even know if I know. I think I just got comfortable. I don't want things to change."

She shifted her body, stretching her tail. "But, it looks like it's out of my control now. Gotta choose something."

"We can still go back to Lily, if you want?" Chloe suggested. "There's still time to go with her."

Daphne shook her head. "It's fine. I've already said goodbye. Besides, if we go with her, you're not gonna be able to see that Espeon again."

"We could ask if she wants to wait? Or you could go with her and I could stay here?" she said, looking up at Daphne.

She looked back at Chloe, a slight smile on her muzzle. "Nah. I'm not leaving you alone with him. It'll be fine. I'll work something out soon. Really, this time. I just wanna have a few more days of normal, I guess. Then we'll decide what to do."

"We, huh?" Chloe asked, smiling back.

Daphne snorted. "Yeah. I found you out here. Not leaving you alone until I'm sure you're all better."

"And here I was thinking you liked my company," Chloe said, her tail flicking into the air.

Daphne started to laugh, standing up. "Okay, okay. Still gotta get this stuff back before curfew."

Chloe nodded, going back to all fours. It was getting easier.

As Daphne grabbed the handle of the wagon again, and they began to move along, she looked over at Chloe. "Hey, uh, Chloe?"

"Yeah?" Chloe replied.

"Thanks."

"It was nothing," she said, looking down. "Just helping out my friend."



Once Daphne and Chloe were gone, she walked back into the cave. Taking a deep breath, Nyx let her illusion drop.

She lay down on the small pile of grass she'd dragged inside, and tried to push back the tears that came to her eyes.

Looking over at the bag of fish, she sighed. It was stupid of her to think she could stay here forever. She'd just felt so lucky to have found a cave, small as it was, and a friend, and safety, and… She hadn't wanted to give it up.

She closed her eyes, and thought back to just a few days ago, when Daphne had convinced her to take a trip into town with her, for Legend Day. It had been hard to keep her disguise up for that long, but it had been worth it to spend time with Daphne. And, with the celebrations and everything going on, no one had seemed to really notice her. Which was just the way she liked it.

Honestly, she'd never seen so many Pokémon in one place before. It had been scary, at first, but… In the end she'd had fun. Watching the performances, eating the food Daphne had bought her… She couldn't remember the last time she'd actually enjoyed herself like that.

She sighed.

She should've told Daphne. She knew she should have. Especially since it seemed like she'd just said goodbye to Daphne for the last time. Especially when Daphne had felt so familiar to her, since they'd first met. She didn't know who Daphne reminded her of, but it must've been someone. And Chloe… The name sounded familiar, but… She didn't know why.

But if she told Daphne then, if she knew she was a Zorua… How could Daphne still trust her? Especially when she'd been lying to the Brionne about her name, and about her species for the last few months. After she'd been lying to Daphne even though she'd had been so nice to her.

And she hadn't wanted to lie to her, it was just…

How could she tell someone something like that? That she isn't who they thought she was? That everything they know about her is a lie?

If she hadn't been in disguise when she met Daphne, or if Chloe hadn't been there just then, she might've… Things might've been different.

But they weren't.

It was probably for the best anyway. Daphne didn't need to worry about her along with everything else. Maybe she'd find something better in Phaeton. Or she could travel past it, maybe all the way to Theia. There had to be something out there for her.

There had to be someone out there, someone who knew where she came from. Or, someone who cared about her. Who would care about her even as a Zorua. She'd tried looking for other Zorua and Zoroark, to try and find her family, but… Her species didn't usually advertise themselves, something she knew very well. But still…

She didn't want to be alone forever.

Nyx sighed, resting her head on her front paws. She'd leave in the morning.



Author's Note: And we're back! I've been stuck writing this chapter for about eight months so I'm glad to finally get it out. Hopefully more to come soon!
 
Last edited:

Kiba Makuro

Junior Trainer
Pronouns
He/Him, They/Them
Hello FennecWitch I am here for an electric kettle or uh V-Wheel.

I'm covering Chapter 1 Cross That Bridge and Start Anew.
I have to say I enjoyed this first chapter, it’s a nice breath of fresh air for pmd er pokemon-centric fics, even with a slightly typical start. Not that the very beginning of the chapter is typical, starting from the perspective of who I assume is the partner, or at least not the former human lead of the story. There’s no rule saying that a former human has to be the most important character of course.

Right now since this is the first chapter there aren’t a ton of details, which is exactly well and fine. You don’t want to overwhelm the readers. Now I don’t think you necessarily need to change anything regarding the content, just keep in mind some things here and there. Unfortunately in my opinion there isn’t much of a strong hook for the story. Because, once again in my opinion right now the characters intrigue and chemistry is the only leading force .The Feraligatr Guildmaster Sobek being mildly suspicious of Daphne or just strict on his subordinates. But besides understanding why Chloe :A.was unconscious, and B.knew Daphne's name.

However, the little bits of details of the world we get from the characters are exciting, the hunting/fishing quota, Pokémon of this world, the Guild, and the tag system. In fairness of what I called “the lack of a strong hook”, even it doesn't seem that way every story is different. Of course not every story needs some crazy lore, mystery, combat system or characters. A focus on strong character interaction or what awaits does wonders.

We only get a little opening glimpse at Daphne and Chloe, well enough to gather a little bit of personality and maybe backstory for the two. It’s a shame that they don’t get to properly interact but I do understand wanting a setup before your hero and partner meet, as I’ve done it to varying degrees. At least Daphne gets to interact with other characters who bring up all sorts of different questions, Lily, Uma, Sobek, and Cetus. Of course Chloe, when they finally meet, will open up all sorts of doors.

I gotta say I really enjoy what's presented in this first chapter. The dialogue flowed well, not too long or too fast when applicable in my opinion. Scenes felt a little small, like you were holding things close to your chest at times, but I understand.
In my opinion the prose could be spiced up, particularly the descriptions of the environment, and characters actions. However, saving time for an opening chapter with beige prose is a moveI have done myself once, since before I overdid it with purple prose once too.

I’ve seen the nice maps you’ve made for Asphodel, which contain both the settlements, and the geography.To make your Guild dedicated to a job other than explorer is a unique choice, and well welcome at that. With the title of the fic being “Rivers of Asphodel” I can tell we are going to be in for a more watery adventure than most. We get mentioned the names of two areas, Fernia, where we are currently and Erimos, where Helioptile, and presumably Mudsdale are from. We can gather the climates of those areas from what Uma says, which definitely puts Chloe as a lizard out of sand.

Regardless of anything it’s promising that you have a few more chapters out already, many of which probably answer some of my impatient questions.

Sorry if I sound contradictory anywhere, I think the things I enjoyed the most could be expanded, but of course not immediately.I hope you continue with the good work!
 

Arukona

A Scribe Penning His Brainworms
Location
Ardalion
Pronouns
He/him
Partners
  1. aggron
  2. sceptile
  3. lucario
Hello! Back again for another review as decreed by the V-Wheel over at United. So let's leap back into things and see how our budding heroes are getting on with things...

Chapter 3
So we open with Chloe getting used to things, although she's still very much a fish (lizard?) out of water.
Was Daphne a human too? She hadn't really answered.
I'm beginning to wonder if maybe Chloe and Daphne were a human and Pokémon duo isekaied into the world of Asphodel. If so, that'll be an interesting revelation when they figure out that connection. Though jury's still out on whether Daphne is indeed a 'mon from the human world.
Rather than any kind of handle, it was completely smooth wood, and pushed open, able to open in both directions.
That sounds like it would be a great aid for 'mons that can't open normal doors efficiently. Another good example of implementation of more xenofiction-esque worldbuilding which I appreciated in my last review. :quag:
"Espeon Theseus. I'm the mind healer that was assigned to you."
Did he enter a labyrinth to slay a Machoke-Rapidash hybrid contained inside, by any chance? /j
"There was… an accident. Years ago, now.
I smell a backstory for later~

Good that there are questions about psychically investigating one's mind, because that would be a bit concerning if there wasn't.
«Okay, I was right. I unfortunately cannot unlock your memories. The psychic seal on them is far beyond my capabilities, as usual. Moving on to your instincts.»
Aw, bummer. Guess we're gonna have to wait a little longer to find that part out. :sadbees:

The scene in Chloe's headspace is pretty interesting, with her having to fight against her instincts and evading them for now. And judging by how it was abruptly cut off, I'm gonna reckon that this won't be the last time we'll see that big reptile. Could we possibly see an instance of Chloe losing herself to her instincts, or maybe her learning to live with them and use them to her advantage? :eyes:
"I can move!"
Good stuff, Chloe. :quag: Now to learn everything else that an amnesiac human has to go through.
"Oh, and… You don't know how to read this writing system, do you?"

"No, I don't," she responded, looking up at him.
Oh boy, illiteracy too? :unquag: That's going to be a tedious thing to learn, unless the alphabet here proves to actually be pretty simple. Hopefully that's the case, because illiteracy could cost her.
The entire day, Daphne couldn't stop thinking about Chloe.
I mean, you would. If you found an amnesiac Pokémon claiming to be human, that wouldn't exactly go forgotten the next day.
Well, given that it was winter so there weren't as many fish around. She thought that was pretty good, if you really thought about it.
The last sentence feels a bit redundant, and I think it could be reworded to something like this:
And a fish, too, probably. An explanation and a fish. Which would bring her down to an average of three a bag. That wasn't bad, was it? Fairly good work for two days. Well, given that it was winter, a time when there weren't as many fish around, that sounded pretty good.
Now moving on...
This Pokémon—her name's Chloe—she doesn't remember anything before she woke up in the guild."

Lily's ears perked up. "Just like, um, like what you said happened when you first woke up?"

"Yeah," she replied, with a nod. "And the weird part is, when I found her, I thought I heard her say my name. She doesn't remember saying it, and I only spoke to her for like five minutes or so, but… She feels familiar. It's weird."
Hmmm...totally holding onto my earlier hunch of the two of them being human and partner.

Now back to Sobek, where our resident Guildmaster proves to be a stern ol' Gatr, alright. Already not earning himself sympathy points with me.

Fishing nets and weapons were hung all over the walls, almost completely covering them. Around the room were wooden models of ships, placed on seemingly whatever spare desks and tables Sobek could find. Each of them was hand-crafted, and intricately detailed. Looking over to his desk, she could see a half-finished model sitting in the middle of a mess of paperwork strewn all over it. The paper had even stretched to the floor, covering the wooden planks nearest to the desk. At the front of the desk was a polished golden nameplate reading "GUILDMASTER".

Sobek didn't seem to notice this as he walked behind his desk, sitting down on an uncomfortable-looking wooden chair.
Well, I mean, given that this is his office, I'd imagine seeing all of this would be part of his daily schedule? I found this highlighted section a little odd in the context of the sentence before.
"I will give you until the end of the week to give me an answer. Either you stay here and work with everyone else, or you leave the guild."
So joining a team with Chloe as her partner will be how she gets out of this ultimatum Sobek's giving her, I presume. I guess we'll see how that unfolds in the next while. Though why exactly is Daphne reluctant to go out on a boat? Is it that she's an outcast among the Guild? Judging by the fact that she said she doesn't get on with others, that could be some evidence to back that up.

Now back to Chloe, and it turns out Theseus was unauthorised to mind read her? Oh dear, that doesn't bode well.
864557228606226442.webp
Looks like this Theseus person is gonna be quite the mystery to unravel...
As I post this, it is about to turn midnight in my timezone, so Happy New Year!
Happy New Year! (Never mind that it's October at the time of writing this.) :mewlulz:

Chapter 4
"Hynei Wing" and "Keuppia Wing"
Hmmm...some deeper etymological name behind the two of these, I wonder?

And now the two girls reunite, whereupon the mysteries are shared about that odd Espeon...
"Maybe we can find out what happened to our memories, together," she said, quickly pushing her front feet together in what might have been a clap, though they didn't seem to come together smoothly enough.
I like how the latter part here implies there's still some ways in which Daphne might act odd compared to the usual Brionne, reflecting her amnesiac status.
"We both woke up in completely different places, at completely different times. It's been about two years since I woke up, I think," she replied.
Nothing saying that the two of you couldn't have been transported to the world of Asphodel at different times and different places. That's something I'm planning to experiment with for a future fic project, actually.
"Like, if I said 'south-east of Asphodel', that's not going to mean anything to you."
Oh, but it'll probably mean something once the two of you go travelling to there. :copyka:
If I tell them and they arrest him or something I don't know if I'm going to be able to talk to him," the Helioptile replied.
So a bit of a balancing act between having suspicion about him, yet he holds answers for Chloe. Just who is this mystery 'mon?
581226968071274496.webp

I don't know that I trust you to deal with wilds."
Oh yeah, combat. Another thing on the growing list of things for Chloe to have to learn.
The library was pretty much what Chloe had expected, really. It'd seemed like the trip from the Fishing Guild to the hospital had taken her from one side of town to the other, so she had a decent idea of the town's size. So she was expecting a small town library, a nice cozy one-room space that wasn't too large. Nothing more than that.
Seems her expectations have been tempered now that she knows the kind of backwater part of Asphodel she's in. Rather different from her initial
loftier expectations from when she first arrived at the Guild.
Daphne left her to enter on her own, heading back over to the Fishing Guild in what seemed like a bit of a hurry. She was sad to see the Brionne go, but she guessed she couldn't really ask her to ignore her job like that.
I think an exchange of parting words in person might have been a better way to convey this part, as opposed to delivering it through narration.
None of the doors she'd seen here seemed to have handles, but they all seemed easy to push open, even for her.
Watch Chloe one day happen upon a building that does not have this kind of clean access, and that'll prove to be the ultimate enemy for her and Daphne: doors with handles.
1220916380468117705.webp

As for my registration, it happened very recently. Ceres is quite out of the way. Their registry is likely just out of date. I'm sure they'll receive an updated version soon enough."
Hmmm...really now?
1171865116095021066.webp
I know this place might be a bit of a backwater, but there's something fishy about that explanation of his.

On the other hand, if Theseus is meant to be an antagonist in this setting, he is more open than expected to be helping her in all manner of ways like this. Perhaps he's trying to co-opt her as a protégée of sorts? Or maybe he's aware that Sobek is rather evil in his own right, and is trying to get Chloe out of there as soon as possible.
"I don't even know," she said, looking down. "Everything?"
Alas, Chloe, your tutor is not an Alakazam.
1220916380468117705.webp

As for typing, they are dual types, lighting and basic types. Which you would know as 'electric and normal', though those terms are not commonly used here.
And why exactly would you know that, Theseus? The first indicator that maybe he could be a human too?
"I was in your mind. Sometimes things… slip through," he said, his voice level.
Suuuuuure.

And now Chloe has to learn how to be a lizard and do lizard things like how to get her blood warm.
"I've also heard that Helioptile and Heliolisk are sometimes able to forgo eating and draw energy entirely from sunlight,
Just like plants, eh? Well, that'll be convenient if there's ever a food shortage.
"Well, I… I saw them in your mind. I saw that you were human in your mind. And I saw that your vision had three colour cones," he said, after a moment, not meeting her eyes.
The mask begins to slip, and with that, the calmness of our resident sus Espeon (suspeon?) melts away into desperate protests. But alas, answers are not forthcoming here. :sadbees:
Still… It had been two years. Where had she been?
And there's the proof that he knows her. Perhaps he was isekaied two years earlier, but Chloe landed in a different time period instead. That seems to be what's going on, if I had to guess?
"Hello, Theseus," said the Meowstic sitting on the windowsill.
KITTY ALERT :veelove:
"Ariadne, please. We're meant to be using our aliases, Theseus. You don't want to make Midas angry, do you?"
We really are digging into the warchest of Greek mythology names here, aren't we? (On a side note, fitting that Ariadne's a helper of Theseus here, given Greek Myth!Ariadne's role in helping Greek Myth!Theseus out on his quest. Nice reference there.)
For an investigation into a possible Faller?
Oh, I see we're using that terminology to describe Chloe (and Daphne as well, when that's revealed. Maybe Daphne's the one he's looking for?).
"Because you now how badly we need another Faller, don't you?
For...what, exactly? By the sounds of it, these purposes sound a tad...nefarious.
635766661743640596.webp
Looks like Theseus could well be one of our fic's current antagonists.
She looked back at him, eyes of yellow and red staring into his own. "I'll bring her in myself."
Whether or not Theseus is, Dinah/Ariadne definitely comes across as more sinister, especially with those heterochromatic eyes of hers.

Conclusion
And two more chapters down. I rather liked these two chapters, where the introduction of Theseus as a well-meaning character at first that has darker intentions in the second provides some interesting intrigue that couples well with the confused amnesia of both Chloe, as well as Daphne's previous amnesia, and ties him well to their stories. I'm really looking forward to seeing how that end of things develops.

Meanwhile, Sobek proves to be Daphne's antagonist, though part of me wonders if he'll be an opponent in the first arc as an obstacle for Daphne to overcome and find her own path after defeating him. But he seems to be a bad apple whereas the others in the Guild, such as Healer Bennett prove to be nice folk. Hopefully there'll be a happy ending for those people if Sobek does get overthrown.

There weren't as many issues with the prose this time around, meaning that I do spot some meaningful progression on the writer's side of things. So good job there, and I look forward to seeing how things progress in the fic from these chapters. :quag:
 
Top Bottom