Search results

"Though if Dave is the final Mafia member... what do we do next?" Cabot asked. "How do we get everyone back who disappeared?"

Cabot blinked and stared blankly at Dave. Throughout most of his stay here he was convinced Dave was innocent, yet he turned out to be as crazy as Psyduck! Had he been like this the whole time? Did the Mafia brainwash him on the third night? Regardless of what had happened, it was obvious who to...

“I’m just so confused…” Cabot murmured. ((It’s not any easier for us authors either I’m afraid. After you got accused it seemed obvious that Hecto was the last Mafia member, but I’m honestly not sure anymore.)) “Well… maybe you could say what my role is then?” the Cranidos asked. “I’d still...

((Now that we're theorizing, I think there's something important I want to share that I initially wanted to bring up while cross examining Hecto. Namely why I don’t believe in the possibility that Hecto is a Naive Cop. I did some research into the role myself, and it seems to be rarely present...

"I mean, I'm not sure how much better I feel if you're still suspicious of me Hecto... but thank you for not voting for me at least." ((And I suppose I can see the argument Noah is making, or at least regarding this particular question. I still have other reasons to be skeptical about whether...

Cabot looked at Loki and Lachlan in confusion. “Wait, so is one of them a member of the Mafia after all…?” ((I’m… admittedly not sure myself. I certainly didn’t expect this twist, but I agree that it’s doubtful we have two doctors. Dave might have a point that Loki is neither with the Mafia or...

“I mean I don’t think I gained any special powers since I got here,” Cabot murmured as he fidgeted with his claws. “I just go to sleep every night like I thought most people did…” ((You do have something though.)) “Wait, really?!” ((Everyone got a fancy role here, so of course you’re not...

((We never were given a solid number, however I theorized a while back that there were only two Mafia members plus one that would get recruited, which I still stand by. That said, I’m glad you accept my terms Hecto, and I think we’re ready to begin in that case.)) Cabot looked down and let out...

“W-Wha-?! M-Me?!” Cabot spluttered. “But I’m not part of the Mafia!” The Cranidos nervously looked around the room and noticed to much of his horror that instead of the skeptical faces he had expected, most seemed intrigued by Hecto’s arguments while some even nodded along in agreement. How...

"Well... I didn't know for sure if anyone was guilty, so I didn't want to vote for anyone. But like I just explained, it feels different with Mia." ((Sorry if that line felt a little short, but just imagine Cabot repeating some of the stuff from my previous post if it does. Today's gonna be a...

Cabot carefully listened to Starr and Lachlan’s arguments as to why Mia was guilty. He had to admit, they did make sense. It was true the way Mia defended Dave and talked about the Mafia earlier seemed genuine… but so did Psyduck when she told her story, yet she turned out to be a Mafia member...

Cabot blinked at Dave's words. "Actually... I think you're right about the Mafia going for Infinite themselves. Didn't Psyduck say that she was the one who made Infinite disappear and tried to do the same to Fish? If she tried to target me or Dave, and Infinite only disappeared because of Dave's...

"I mean... I guess?" Cabot said, putting a claw to his mouth as he thought over Starr's explanation. "But... if on the second night me and Dave were swapped, and he directed any attack to Infinite... does that mean the Mafia originally tried to attack me?"

Cabot gave Mel and Repeat a blank look as he tried to wrap his head around what everyone was saying. So Dave could redirect an attack to someone else... but Mel could have Repeat do effectively the same by transforming? "I... don't get it. If Repeat goes out and acts like a decoy, wouldn't that...

"So... you're saying that if someone gets attacked, you can make it that someone else gets hurt instead?" Cabot asked Dave. "But how can that possible when you don't even have to be attacked yourself? Is it some sort of human magic like how you use deeanay?"

((Not sure what I'm more surprised about: The Doctor not protecting Karo or the Mafia not choosing someone else because they anticipated for the Doctor to protect Karo.)) Cabot blinked in surprise and repeatedly shifted gaze between Starr and Dave. "Huh?! What do Karo and Dave have to do with...

((Alright, thanks for clearing things up qva! It’s kinda late now so I won’t be able to respond to your post in detail, but I feel a lot better about things now. With that in mind, I’m quickly gonna vote before I head to bed.)) Cabot blinked at Mia’s response. “Huh, what do you mean?! I told...

((Whew, things sure are getting spicy in here! I sure hope nobody is taking anything personal, since that would be rather silly, now wouldn’t it? After all, we’re playing a party game where suspecting and accusing each other is the whole point! Now then qva, lemme get to your post first. To be...

Cabot listened to Mia’s story, and while the idea of there being two versions of her sounded a bit peculiar, she did sound genuine. Besides, given everything that already happened, was it really that strange? Though there was something he still wondered… "So… if you and Dave are from different...

((Nah it's definitely not stupid, but I personally don't think qva's post about being surprised/impressed to no nightkill on N0 means anything. It's something that could easily be faked and pretending to not know that well how the game works does seem like a good strategy for a Mafia member...