Search results

Personally I don’t think I’d be able to join a game where you play other people’s characters. Anonymized out of character could be sort of neat to try but I can’t help but think people would be kind of recognizable unless everyone like, actively tried to mask who they are…? Trying to encourage...

[[End day early]]

[[Vote: Archie]]

[[Okay, yeah, that makes sense to me, I think. We're never going to have a foolproof plan but whatever, my eyes are leaking out of my skull. Been looking through Starlight and I'm increasingly convinced it just is Starlight. We'll see tomorrow.]]

[[Pano confessed]]

[[Even if we assume one mafia left, then if mafia!Starlight (probably most likely scenario), Starlight killing Bench would be indistinguishable from the scenario where somebody else kills Bench to frame Starlight, which is probably not good...? Might be better if Starlight mails somebody who is...

[[Specifically I was imagining my hypothetical of mafia Chibi and Dawning, where Dawning redirects me at somebody else and Chibi shoots Inke, but that would be four mafia total which is not very likely]]

[[In order to actually verify Chibi’s role we would need them to track somebody whose target is not predetermined (and who is definitely not mafia with Chibi).]]

[[Hrmm, this does not actually prove anything about Chibi. If Chibi is set to track Bench who is set to protect Chibi, Chibi can say they tracked Bench to Chibi whether they did or not.]]

[[For what it’s worth I’m paranoid all the time. At the start of this day I expressed significant paranoia about Chibi; I’m kind of surprised neither you nor Starlight took an interest in my thoughts there. I’m not remotely certain about Chibi or DW and part of my brain is still preparing to...

[[Well, let’s back up a bit, away from the weird self-referential maze of “townies should do things that are not scummy”. Trying to do things that are not scummy is fair, we all do it, I’ve done it in this game. But. The actual objective of the game, for town, is not to not look scummy. The...

[[Why don’t you think it’s us, Starlight?]]

[[I'm not saying that can't have been your train of thought! I thought of something that could have made this make more sense, because I'd thought is, so I fished for whether that might have been it, but it wasn't. Something that could have been slightly exonerating evidence wasn't, that's all...

[[What I took away from that Inke post originally was actually that she might be bulletproof - specifically, because she put it in a context of “might as well claim since they’ve used the strongman shot”. If you had also thought that, it would have sort of justified town!you feeling more...

[[Read through Pano's posts. I noticed this post:]] [[wherein Pano urges Inke not to claim after Inke mentions her role doesn't explain any of the night's results. Isn't that kind of the style of hint that Pano would pick up on...? Like, enough to possibly notice that it might mean Inke did...

[[It's not impossible or unviable, but it's not really a good idea by default for everyone to reveal when they've been interfered with, especially when they are information-related roles. I don't think it's totally unreasonable to have thought they might, but you definitely shouldn't have taken...

[[There are more kinds of third parties than serial killer and winning with town! It's likely Karo was a custom; he may have had any number of win conditions, but that does not mean he was a serial killer who would've had to have gotten blocked.]]

[[I do want to review a bit more before making a vote but Pano as simply scum roleblocker definitely would explain a lot. I don't think it was really unlikely scum would've blocked Inke per se - exactly who would've been an obviously better target so far? Tetra was likely to shoot town so...

[[Honestly I think it's pretty probable there were only ever three mafia and one third party? Four mafia would already be >25% of the players and a third party on top of that is a lot.]]

[[Was this an exasperated copyka?]]