Search results

i will restate for the how manyeth time that that still doesn’t make sense, because no one was scumreading me anyway, and unless i’m really misreading the room, they’re not going to suddenly start scumreading me if dw flips scum, because i’ve made other contributions to the game beyond being the...

wait, so... if dw is scum, they’re not a roleblocker, so a town roleblocker who hasn’t spoken up against dw must have blocked sike? or the mafia spent their strongman on chibi for some reason? i’m not sure i’m tracking... how do you think it elapsed? i’m can’t work out how dw not being swapper...

lol good point hahahaha i honestly can’t remember what i was thinking here. i think i thought dw was being much more vocal about their vote on persephone but it doesn’t look that way upon reread, hm. re: tanuki’s post that’s just quotes so i can’t requote it—not really a good point? a single...

it just bothers me because it makes literally negative sense and is about me and no one is saying anything about it. i should be ignoring it but it just bugs me a lot.

man can someone back me up that i’m not crazy and this is seriously weird. no one is engaging with this at all except me and i feel like i’m losing my sanity. idk why it’s bothering me so much but it really is.

* defuse?

if you are mafia, killing your teammate is inoptimal. you might be able to spin some advantage from it but it still makes the game harder to win and hurts your side overall. i’m not ignoring it—potentially being (unverifiably) targeted by the mafia doesn’t matter as much as 1) helping lead...

there’s also (probably) not a jester in this game.

i guess this isn’t really less optimal than scum-reading people for looking innocent, so i don’t doubt you did it, but if i was teaming with you in a game and you did that i would be pretty upset, and it’s definitely weird that you’re assuming someone else would do it, and basing reads on...

you’ve, as scum, killed your teammate that no one was suspecting for no reason other than to make youself look better even though no one was suspecting you?

yes, it’s a normal thing to do. it’s not normal to go out of your way to KILL your teammate that isn’t already on the way to death, especially if you already have decent cover.

such as...? [[ “A fine point,” Lauchs conceded. “Yet the raichu’s claim would be quite a bold one without the knowledge that no one could counter it. It’s possible he took a great gamble, but if he’s scum, I find it more likely he was simply claiming the role he truly had. The safest move for...

hahahaha omg good point

[[ Lauchselot clapped his wings in delight. “Yes, do go on!” ]]

good to know, although in this case "powerwolfing" refers to a proactive strategy of basically playing scum in a bold, confident manner that doesn't shy away from attention—definitely possible to employ even if it's your first time rolling mafia. i didn't even consider the possibility of a...

is this certainty an in-character thing, or

i have time to actually sit down and type out my thoughts now, so i'm gonna do a bit of sorting real quick. wallpost incoming. here's the final vote from yesterDay: given how close the final vote was, i think it's pretty much impossible that there was more than one wolf on the persephone...

i get what you're saying here, like, technically, but it's just... it's not good play. at the risk of maybe sounding a little harsh here, the entire object of mafia (if you are town) is to figure out who is innocent and who is mafia. taking someone who is by your own admission "impossibly...

[[ Lauchs nodded sharply. “Yes, three is the number I’m working with, but it’s nothing more than an assumption. It was the number I used in my calculations on our first day, as well. I will observe that when Ser Desper made the same assumption, he openly characterized it as something that might...

i just think they’re all telling the truth, and that sike was roleblocked. that’s why i didn’t want to vote for any of them and asked people to vote one of the nulls instead