Search results

[[I posted a theory earlier that maybe Mike thought he could get away with claiming town role cop, get a mislynch, and then get an automatic extra night to kill someone else. But yeah, it’s not exactly a solid plan—but have any of the options sounded solid? 😅 It’s a weird play no matter how you...

[[Exactly. Which is why I worry about abstaining because that just leaves everything in the mafia’s hands. Though I also don’t want to mislynch anybody either AGH I am not smart enough for this game]]

[[Oh jeez I really don’t know what to think. The more people say it, the more I have to agree that Mike probably isn’t mafia because the strategy doesn’t check out agh. Buuuut does anybody think it’s possible he’s the SK? I guess I just don’t want to believe he’s actually town LOL I don’t know...

[[I also sincerely apologize if I rubbed anybody the wrong way. Didn’t mean to be pushy but I realize it most likely came off that way. Sorry.]]

Wes folded his arms with a sigh. “All right. Fine. You have a point.” Gods, he just wanted to figure this out as soon as possible. But he supposed it wouldn’t do to be reckless about it. [[Aight, you make a good point. I think I’m just being too overeager and chomping at the bit for more info...

Wes raised his hands in a submissive gesture. “Easy, you—” he broke off into a squint as he took a closer look at who he was talking to. Was that a…humanoid feline Pokémon? Oh to hell with it, he’d seen enough strange things in this place. He shook his head and continued. “I’m only trying to put...

“Then why hold onto that info, then?” Wes said. “There’s nothing to lose by saying it right away…” he trailed off, remembering their tearful outburst. Okay, so maybe their mind was on other things, but still. He ducked his head away from Porygon and tried fo ignore the guilt gnawing at his...

“So basically, it would be vital to us to know right away if there was a serial killer among us.” Wes shot a wary glance at Porygon. He didn’t like to entertain the idea that they might be a killer, but…he couldn’t afford be too trusting. He then cleared his throat and addressed the group as a...

[[I mean I think there was a disclaimer saying not all the roles may be used but I could be misremembering things]]

[[Also just pulling this back up because it was oddly convenient that Bluwii only claimed to have info and reveal this after Homestar accused Abra of being SK! It’s a very safe bit of info that would allow them to fly under the radar. I’m not accusing them of being scum buuut I do find the...

[[the HECC The first part of my previous post was meant to reply to this LOL I promise Wes isn’t just speaking to the air hahaha]]

“Wes,” he answered. “And you?” He turned his attention back to the crowd. What a headache…Mike had been caught in a lie, which was certainly suspicious, but…what if he was just an idiot? After all, Wes had made some stupid decisions in this situation before… And then there was Kent. He...

Wes gave a start as Hana suddenly addressed him. He stared her up and down for a moment. What in the hell was she dressed as? Was that some sort of Halloween costume? He decided to keep any comments to himself for the moment. Instead, he simply nodded. “You seem to have an eye for analysis and...

[[Just a little more ooc from me and then I’ll get back to RP. First, here’s the link to the mafia wiki describing Serial Killer for anyone who wants to read it. It does explicitly say that a role cop would read an SK as town. Which basically condemns Mike as lying! But! One thing we haven’t...

[[Could be mafia OR a vital town role so let’s not be too hasty. Let it be known that even mafia goons will be given additional notes/info in their role DMs too, so just because someone has extra info to share, doesn’t mean they’re automatically trustworthy.]]

[[Wait wait wait is there a way to confirm this is how it’s working in this game?? Because if that’s true then that puts a TON of suspicion on Homestar.]]

[[I’m pretty sure SK would give an SK result, but a Goon might just read as vanilla maybe? Not sure, actually. Since a good is basically more or less vanilla mafia, right?]]

[[tbh I can’t even fault you for that lol. It did take us a while to get to the meat of the game, so. That said, the timing is kinda weird, but also I don’t blame you for hesitating on revealing that info since you’re a brand new player.]]

[[In fact, I’m gonna advise that if Homestar is lying and the real town role cop is out there somewhere…please stay quiet and don’t reveal yourself!]]

[[Well to be fair, if they are Mafia role cop claiming town, the real town role cop risks immediately putting themselves under fire for revealing themselves. So that doesn’t necessarily mean they will come forward. They might decide it’s safest to stay quiet.]] [[I agree here that regardless of...