Search results

“I believe you’ve left something unconsidered in attributing evil to two out of three unclaimed character. You are, however unintentionally, attributing the failed kill to the dog. If he’s the soldier, and believes himself to have been targeted by evil for his experience, he should have...

[[Oh, also, forgot to include this: No matter what the roles are under the hood, I firmly believe you're having a shit time of this. I'm sorry about, earnestly. I've felt similarly before, during the slow crawl towards an inevitable loss in Vanilla Mafia. It was the last game I played for four...

Morgan's eye lit up. "I forgot! Thank you, Rocky! That's incredibly helpful!" "It'd be like sitting down at a poker table, getting dealt a pair of aces, and folding to convince everyone you have crap. It'll technically be persuasive, sure, but you'll have forfeited the advantage of having a...

[[It had yet to occur to me that if you’re a demon you have worse luck than me at this point, not that I’m gonna go do a gambler’s fallacy about it.]]

[[It is possible that I was poisoned N0, aer/Elegym N1, and I was protected/evil stumbled into an unrelated killblock but given the obscurity of my claim I don’t think I’d be the top protection candidate and targeting a clear power role would be the least random explanation for the no kill. It’s...

“Quite the other way around: I think I was poisoned because Elegym was meant to die. In other words, I expect we were both targets, and that this is the explanation for there being no kill tonight. I was far less likely to have been protected, so they would’ve otherwise had to get unlucky and...

[[mmm fair yeah I shouldn’t do that]]

[[If anyone wants to follow up or wants to make sure I’m not misinterpreting, here’s the exact exchange for transparency: “[I quote myself from here earlier] I should check that this is true bc the intro post just says evils win if they control more than 50% of the vote with no elaboration. Is...

[[Primarily, I don’t know how that affects ghostvote strategy since they matter a lot less now that they don’t prevent evil vote majority.]]

[[I have checked with Inke and been told that we lose if the living evils can outvote living town, ghostvotes (on both sides?) being able to change the outcome doesn’t matter and the game will be ended anyway. A little odd to me, but unlikely to matter too much? We still just have to get the...

[[I’m not sure exactly what some of the stuff after my quote stops means means, but I can answer this: While there shouldn’t be duplicate roles (iirc Inke has confirmed this?) in a game of this size the Storyteller usually exercises their discretion to ensure a Scarlet Woman is in play alongside...

Morgan gave a curtsey to the oddly charming rock creature. “A pleasure to serve, Rocky, and my thanks for your assistance in helping me to get accurate results. If I may offer a note: I can only spot the demon, not minions. If I’m right, Shuppet is the demon, and would’ve had to direct an...

[[If there’s one townie left to ‘nominate’ the demon and enough ghost votes to convict, it’s game on!]]

[[Nope! They win only when there are ZERO townies (in the physical game only living players can ‘nominate’ a player to vote on) or their voting power outweighs the town’s counting ghost votes, which should never happen unless people blunder their ghost votes en masse. Meanwhile if there’s no...

Pausing using Morgan for a post since she’s abrasive and I don’t want to come across genuinely rude: You couldn’t be saved, they had doubts about their info, and the vote created role ambiguity after what’d be a pretty obvious softclaim otherwise. Checks out to me. It was a bit late to go...

[[Re “Death is trivial here. Roll with it.” in specific bc I think it sounds harsh: Your power was not going to activate any further. The evil team will be no closer to controlling the vote unless you spend your ghost vote. You can still talk and share your opinions. Your death had several...

[[Tbc Undertaker who saw Drunk is a pretty safe claim rn, especially when claiming to see an Imp death tomorrow is also going to be expected, so I can’t quite townlock Chibi right now (although I lean positively on them) but no matter what the reading is at least extremely likely to be true...

[[I do not intend to come across as attacking you personally but I do believe you’re reading people based on not saving you, when I think doing so would have been a mistake. I’m afraid I’ll have to hold firm on that. It’s an in-character way of noting that you have a long list of suspects based...

Morgan raised one tendril, like a schoolchild volunteering to be picked. "Hey, where's my Hard Sus read? I did this too! I'm feeling excluded~" [[In all seriousness, if you stopped trying to enact retribution over people failing to save you, you'd be a live witness to all the benefits of doing...

"Oh, you heard correctly~ I knew that if I didn't get Elegym's eyes on you, I'd never know for sure if you were the demon, or my false positive. You'd have claimed to be my false positive, and frankly, it could easily have been true. If I'd heard they got a 0 again despite reading you as a...