Search results

[[Where are the votes at rn? (Gonna ping @Inkedust in case she's got the official tally.) I want to double check I'm not causing a tie.]]

[[fcuked up and eivl that 3 good players left with all the minions gone is do or die, this is still throwing me for a loop. Anyway the more I think about it the more I lean towards sticking to my guns on Chibi. Not a very serious update, gotta step away for a bit though, but'll be back before...

[[wait no that last note is also dumb bc demondrake requires me and chibi to both be poisoned. I do not see how it was possible.]]]

"Would you not, otherwise? Could well happen otherwise, look two spaces to your right and see how much good it does you to call for the horse's execution when there's no one left who trusts you. You may yet have your satisfaction, but would we listen? Not even I, someone who already trusts you...

[[Seconding unrepentantAuthor there. This isn't anywhere close to the roughest social deduction game I've been in, not has it been very long. This is just how the genre works. Although the length aspect is unique to the asynchronous forum format.]] "I get what you're driving at, Rocky, I really...

Morgan shot the horse a grin. "If you wanna trade your life for his, then I'm game." It wasn't a given that killing an evil horse would end the game— Scarlet Woman, if alive, would be active. It wasn't implausible that Drake was a Poisoner, and them a Scarlet Woman, or that Drake had been the...

[[oop my b]]

Morgan winked at the Elegym. "Quite simple: Librarian is a start of game info role, and would have claimed early into the game. Soldier could contest the idea that the dog's Monk power blocked the kill, and both players had already tacitly accepted this fact. Especially the Noivern, who had...

[[While this is true of me even from a Clocktower perspective, I like info bc I don't trust my social/soft reading skills, I also think Clocktower privileges informed gamestates more than Mafia— unique roles with guaranteed alignments in an open setup alone can be powerful deductive tool, and...

[[I feel like the main takeaway here is "phan has to hedge all of her statements more" and like okay that's something I'm working on now bc it's bit me in the ass a few times. I mostly figured it'd be fine bc I expect people to take each other with a grain of salt but I've seen the light and the...

[[Okay I cannot read all of that and frankly don't care to much about the psychoanalysis of my early game because I think it's largely immaterial and I have better things to do with my time, but a few things that feel important:]] [[Nah, still sus of them, specifically bc they (seem to be?)...

[[Damn, Sind, get in here someone's counterclaiming demon. In all seriousness I'm too tired to weigh Mal vs Honse odds rn but my vote will inevitably land on one of the two tomorrow. Honestly I wouldn't be remiss to take out the other after if the game continues.]]

[[Inke's already addressed it as far as this game is concerned but if you're curious for academic purposes, a game with no scum would be still be declared up front as a "bastard game" with likely little to no elaboration— the world of bastard mafia is broad and dense, so the players wouldn't be...

[[You are, the key context being that I'm replaying to someone talking about whether Mayor, on account of being pretty bad in this format, is in the pool. The exact roles chosen are random. (i.e. Mayor is in the pool, we cannot discount its existence purely on account of it being adaptationally...

[[woah now lets not make any hasty assumptions here— we all trust Sind more than anyone else but have you considered how DANGEROUS this would make her if she WAS evil??? </joke>]]

"We got them on different nights, and I have a built-in false positive. My false incriminating result would be caused by either my being poisoned night 0 (y'know, the night you got clean reads on Rui and Hareta) or just Watt being my false positive. Yours was almost certainly caused by your...

[[It’s confirmed that they’re all randomized into the pool. This is also why Rocky/Pano can also be sparking vanilla townie. (Except better bc it also tells us where the Outsiders are.)]] Morgan rolled her eyes. “Would you like to explain how that is still possible? I feel like I took that one...

[[Fucking. Says they might be. I slept like garbage and am tired.]]

[[Dead demons should still ping as demons. If a demon dies and a Scarlet Woman inherits then both just ping as demons. Wiki states this clearly and I see no reason Inke would change that.]]

“Yep! I thought about doing the same Rocky test as yesterday but it felt like a waste of my second target. I thought about you but once I thought about how I and everyone else would interpret the results I realized it wasn’t going to be very useful. I considered a pure test of poisoning with...