Search results

Malachai laughed indulgently. "Apology accepted, little being! No hard feelings over a mere game. I hope you'll forgive me in turn when I get to rub your face in this later on~"

"Spectrier isn't a source of information," Malachai muttered irritably, "they're an enemy who is lying to us. If I didn't know better, I'd think you were misframing this choice deliberately!" [[Please don't do this, man. Don't encourage other people to throw the game just because you're havng...

"Well, now... We can assume that Odette will die this night. I would surprised at any other outcome. If the game continues, then I would only consider voting for Morgan, Madeline, or Elgyem. Which of them first, I have yet to decide." [[mostly because Mafia is cognitively exhausting :'D ]]

[[i think someone already covered this but: if I was Librarian I would've revealed my info early, and if I was soldier I'd be sussing Free. I even already said I wasn't -- and that nobody else could be.]] "This is, essentially, why I am reluctant to believe in the ghost's guilt," purred...

yw <3

[[I am genuinely uncertain of this one. It meant we proved two players were Good early on and could probably trust some intel. It also means scum don't get caught out by voting virgin. I think on balance I think it's mostly bad with silver lining. I think Phan favours high-info play and is...

[[That's too much to respond to all of it all at once so I skimmed for stuff I can clear up easily.]] [[There literally can't be a Baron. We know this. Madeline is not for sure the Demon, but what Phan was saying here was that if Madeline is the Demon and there is a Spy, then there isn't a...

[[I keep refreshing for posts. The eternal curse of mafia.]]

[[The Drunk doesn't know they're Drunk. We don't know which inforole is Drunk, but one of them is most likely Drunk. Three players are lying if every Good player is telling the truth. I expect 1-3 of our supposed inforoles to be Evil. If one of the inforoles is Drunk, and Rocky is Butler, that...

@aer you may find this post helpful in working through the inforole tangle

[[Well, no. I'm not arguing that you're scum because you voted for Watt. I'm arguing that you voting for Watt doesn't prove you're not scum. That's a different thing.]]

[[If it's Rocky, where's our second Outsider? Now that I know for sure the game rules mean there definitely are two Outsiders, that's as good as hard confirmation Rocky is Butler to me. Otherwise we have a secret Outsider somewhere who could blow the game wide open but is refusing to and...

[[Sure, my D1 play could've been bolder. It's not really my playstyle, though. I'm also completely new to BotC roles and rules, and I had limited availability D1 in particular. I'm honestly not sure how I could even have made a big claim safely early on. I've never been good at softclaims, I...

[[dw about it, Mal's just grumpy and thinks he's right. I don't disagree you should want other takes!]]

[[If Rui was really Drunk (or Poisoned) then Spectrier wouldn't know what she'd claim in advance. When she claimed that Hareta/Watt was Scarlet Woman, Spectrier would know that was untrue and vote for Watt anyway. In that scenario it's just opportunism. I think opportunism is actually more...

[[I thought I'd check, and while Tetra hasn't been gunning for me very hard, I did find two other examples of her sussing me:]]

[[Also, once again, I can't stay up posting in this thread past 1am and I have a limited window in the morning to post. If I post in the morning it apparently doesn't matter because it's right before EoD. But if I don't respond to everything that happens in the night, then I'm "absent from EoD"...

[[Take a look at the following:]] [[Taken together, the meaning is clear: I believe Tetra is mafia. I then poked at Tetra a bit to see if she would give up on keeping her claim secret. I believed she would fold first if she was mafia. She did fold first. I then typed up most of the following...

"Very well," growled Malachai, his nasal crest dipping as his brows furrowed. "I shall unravel this." The dragon cleared his throat, and consulted his note-taking scratchings in the dirt. "You've made an argument about what Spectrier could have predicted at the time they made these statements...

[[because there can't be deaths N0 and Dave protected Odette N1. it's that simple.]] [[I'm still voting for Chibi, actually. I haven't backed off that train at all? I said briefly that Tetra's force of argument made me doubt myself slightly but I also said that she might be scum trying to juke...