Search results

Dave grimaced. "I'm not completely sure we trust any of them. The simplest solution is it's Malachai and Drake and possibly Madeline. Morgan's play hasn't felt like it made sense for scum, doing a whole thing about Madeline definitely being the Demon that'd obviously call Morgan into question if...

"Close, it was that between Madeline and Watt, one was the Demon specifically." "Morgan's N1 result was that between Rocky and Madeline neither was the Demon. She thinks she was poisoned last night and thus that her N1 result was wrong."

"I--" Dave squeezed his eyes shut. How fucking old was Rocky? "It's a swear word. Something you say when you're pissed the fuck off." "Because I protected Odette, and then nobody died. The only other possibilities are that either Malachai or Drake is a Soldier and they went for him for some...

[[If this was scum Phan deliberately trying to fish the claim out of me by being sufficiently infuriating, then congratulations on some extremely devious scumplay. (I'm not mad mad, though, please don't take Dave's expletives the wrong way. Just admitting I had meant to shut up and see what...

"For the love of fuck. Yes, I'm the fucking monk, and I protected Odette, because of your helpful fucking analysis about how it's actually often better for scum to kill ironclad confirmed innocents and poison inforoles instead. Fucking--" "It resulted in me visibly believing that the mafia was...

"Just going to mention again that Morgan would not have to be scum for Madeline to be innocent. If Elgyem was poisoned N1, then Morgan could have been poisoned N0, or you could've been Morgan's designated false positive, to explain Morgan's result then. It's still more moving parts than just...

"Thinking about Rocky... Back at the beginning he had this understanding that the Investigator, and other roles that get info with their role at the very start, probably couldn't be poisoned. I assumed the same myself, as town, until apparently there was confirmation otherwise, because the only...

"Okay, hang on, I just looked at the fucking seating arrangements again and I see what you mean, since the two of you are sitting next to each other. Cool, then the two of you can't be on a team together. Point in Spectrier's favor."

"Spectrier wouldn't be scum instead of you. He, or Rocky, would be the third scum instead of Madeline. I mean, I guess maybe it could be Madeline and Drake and Spectrier or some shit, but that's not what I'm looking at right now. I'm looking at you, Drake, and a third person who could be...

[[This sort of thing is honestly always pretty vibes-based, and also very prone to confirmation bias. Once you think someone's scum, stuff they do seems scummy even if they did in fact do it perfectly innocently and aren't scum at all; happens every game to everyone. The manner of how you were...

Dave exhaled a long breath through his nose. "Yeah. I've also been running the numbers game since I voted. From where I'm standing, it looks almost inevitable Malachai and Drake are both scum. The problem is at this point I'm really not sure I'm buying Madeline is, so if the assumption of a...

[[Right, right, I misread what you said. Sorry!]]

Dave squinted at Morgan... and then sighed. "Okay, I can see it. I still think it's a whole lot more uncertain than you made it out to be, but fine. We don't have a better lead than Madeline at the moment, it's simplest mechanically, and if Rocky can't vote either without me, fine, I'll throw my...

"Elgyem did come in and actively vote Rui at the end of the day, rather than just letting the vote pass and flying under the radar. That's the thing that's kinda weird."

Dave sighed, shaking his head. "Okay, so. Our first piece of info is this: on night zero, Elgyem says she was told she had zero evil neighbors. Her neighbors at the time were Rui and Hareta. On night one, Elgyem was told she has one evil neighbor, and now her neighbors are Hareta and Madeline...

[[Just a quick note: aer did in fact make a softclaim post which it sounds like you missed: So Elgyem did explicitly claim info on Hareta's innocence. The post was more ambiguous about what she knew about Rui - I interpreted it at the time as saying she could back up what Rui was saying, not...

[[This is not really relevant and I should be actually sorting out my thoughts on the Madeline situation properly so I can vote, but I do want to engage with Yellow because I can get being frustrated in a game like this when you feel like your posts are not being engaged with. Here is what I...

[[For what it's worth I am also very inconveniently timezoned for this game. I made my post where I voted for you (at which point only Zdrmonster was voting for you) at nearly 1AM my time and by that point had been up longer than I wanted. The day ends at 9AM my time, which is just about or...

"After the Virgin reveal, Malachai voted Hareta, Drake did some waffling where he voted you initially, then Rocky voted Hareta, then Drake also moved to Hareta instead. After that I voted for you, then even after that Odette voted for Hareta, although obviously she was doing it for innocent...

[[Oh, I missed that :unquag: The Virgin's role description just says "if the nominator is a Townsfolk" with no caveats! Neeeever mind I guess]]