Search results

[[Fwiw, this was advertised as a basic game, so no, there’s no world where there are zero scum unless Inke lied about this being a vanilla setup and this game has what is called a “bastard mod” where the mod can straight up lie to people in-game. If this was a game of no scum, it would have been...

[[Anyway “scum Rui” is freaking INSANE to me. Ngl fam, I was tempted to just step out and not participate much after I got voted out, because not only am I town and I did literally NOTHING wrong, I got screwed over by the setup in the most infuriating way possible, was dogpiled for being...

[[I’ve been on the scum Jackie train since the BEGINNING lol, there’s no “snapping around” going on here. Sorry but this doesn’t read as anything other than flailing to me. And given the wincon settings for this game, the role of Mayor just…doesn’t make much sense? I guess this could be an...

[[Y’all the tunneling on “scum Rui” is laughable and makes me convinced more than EVER that Tetra and Jackie are a scumteam. I’m at work so it’ll be a bit, but I will elaborate later.]]

[[I’m confused, what was the lie you caught? You can’t just say “You’re lying and I caught you in a lie!” Unless I’m missing something?]]

[[Woahhhh there, take a deep breath. The good news is, we’re entering the night phase, which gives you some time to sort things out. I totally get feeling overwhelmed. Mafia is A LOT, especially with this many players, and especially when dead players can still post, so the number of people...

[[Going to spend the night phase rereading and digesting everything so for now I’ll just post my new readlist and the votes as they currently stand for everyone’s convenience: VOTES: Chibi/Glastrier: 2 (Aer, uA) Tetra/Drake: 5 (Free, Pano, Phan, Perse, Chibi) Perse/Madeline: 2 (Tetra...

[[Not going to use my vote today but if we’re not going to abstain (which, fair enough, at the time I proposed that, not many people were talking and now everyone is talking lol), then I think Drake is the safest vote. I stand corrected on Tetra not pushing for D1 eliminations—I feel like in...

[[Once again I really appreciate you answering my questions and outlining your thoughts for me, it’s so helpful for my sanity! 😂 It’s a good learning opportunity for me too. You’re right that there’s no one way to play, but I can always learn better ways for future games. @ everyone else, I’m...

[[Fwiw I very much relate to this mindset and this was where I was at end of D1. And wouldn’t you know it, I was right! Because eventually a point is reached where nothing you do or say is going to be taken in good faith, and that’s incredibly frustrating. That’s why I want to hear you out, so...

[[At this point I share the same paranoia. Since this is a numbers game after all, I reaaaally don’t want to eliminate another town today. It’s possible Persephone is scum and Free is her scum buddy, but that doesn’t really track to me—I think Free would have spoken up much sooner, in that case...

[[I would also frankly really love more input from the hard/soft confirmed town members! (Though I understand life is busy and it’s a weekend. 💛) @Sinderella would love to hear more thoughts from you! A readlist, maybe? @Zdrmonster You’re honestly doing fine! You haven’t made any misplays and...

[[Call me a softie, but y’all, this really reads as genuine frustration to me, and I sympathize. Persephone, I think a large part of the problem is that you haven’t contributed too much to the scum hunting discussion until after you spent your shot on Morgan. It would have been helpful to lay...

[[I haven’t had the wherewithal today to articulate this other than “slightly off vibes” but you described it perfectly, bless. I feel like I’ve known Tetra to be busy and less present in other games in the past, but I feel like I recall her being extra absent the one time she was scum…and I...

[[Thank you for clarifying that, I’m missing a million details today. That helps me understand a bit better. I’m so sorry, I wish I had it in me to do RP right now. But this is so sweet 😭 ILY Rocky]]

[[Except it’s not? If I were scum, I would have played it safe and kept the cards close to my chest. I would not have risked getting counter-claimed on day one. At most I’d have hinted at a soft claim. I refuse to accept “Rui being scum was the most plausible reality” as a justification that...

[[Thank you for this, that genuinely means a lot to me. There is nothing more frustrating than feeling like you’re talking to a brick wall in these games. 😅 I would genuinely like to know what I could have possibly done in this situation to not be suspect. I tried to be as calm and level-headed...

[[Okay, phrasing it this way does put it in a much different light. I’m still very much operating off the traditional mafia “we can’t afford meaningless losses” line of thought and didn’t fully realize just how differently that applies to BotC. Let it be known that I’ve played this game exactly...

[[Oml thank you. 😭 I think it’s insane that people are trying to spin two town deaths on day one as a positive. I’m sorry but that has never been the case in any mafia game I’ve played. Sure this one is different but the core of it being a numbers/game of elimination is still the same. I feel...

[[Sincere question, what are the beneficial effects? I guess I don’t really see how me dying was more beneficial than trying to see who is scum? Again, maybe I’m being shortsighted here, but I don’t see why voting out someone that you have good reason to believe as innocent is preferable to...