Search results

[[...Huh, that's some interesting/unexpected information. Some of the possible mafia compositions we've been discussing would involve them only having one or two goons, but then we'd have too many vanilla claims by now, right? So either the mafia has more goons than that (and thus either six...

[[Anyway I can finally go back now and reread this morning's posts properly while not groggy/trying to work, hang on]]

[[What Homestar's suspicion of Shiny Phantump is getting at is not that she edited something, but that in summarizing the roles she failed to mention something relevant (rolecop getting a vanilla result for serial killer) and added in information that wasn't known upfront (all the vanillas...

[[To be fair, Steven, who many of us believe was some form of cop, did just get killed. (By Altair according to his own account, granted, but suppose the mafia gambled on the serial killer going for him...?) Not at all sure I believe that's what happened, but it was one of my kneejerk what-if...

[[Yeah, this was a thing that stuck out to me this morning that I wanted to take a better look at on a reread... though I'm hesitant to consider it conclusive, since it depends on the GM how cop results work, and whether it's just innocent/scum, mafia/not mafia or full-on alignment.]]

Dave gritted his teeth at the Soda-shaped apparition. "Soda. Adne! Remember her?" Why would he? This was just random megalomaniacal villain #23557 for them to defeat. A parasite-hollowed thing that had once been a person. The name'd had power for Yellow, not for the fucking parasite. Shadow was...

[[...the town]]

[[Uhhhhh what? No? Namo said it's random? Two deaths would be entirely broken and give the power vastly more power.]]

[[just chiming in to say yes, absolutely let’s not kill the claimed cop without extremely solid evidence that it’s a fake claim]]

[[Yeah. I’m a little surprised Namo put that in this vanilla/beginner-friendly game, when there’s zero mention of it in the role descriptions or on the wiki! The only way for a beginner to be aware it’s a thing that exists was by hearing it from people who were in the previous game or on TCoD...

[[This strikes me as pretty weak? Namo wasn’t running the last game, so it’s not him using the same trick twice. He also expressly went for a more vanilla game here rather than trying to come up with some new setup full of new hijinks - it doesn’t really strike me as excessively unlikely he’d do...

[[Other barest thoughts: Homestar’s gambit with asking to be targeted by the serial killer relies on the notion that the people who suspect him will simply accept it if he claims his bulletproof was popped tomorrow, which seems a stretch; I am going to have to think through the Inkedust and...

[[Doctors don’t know if their target was actually targeted, Equi isn’t claiming you were attacked (unless I missed that on my skim of his post)]]

[[hi I am working and will not be able to make a real post until this evening but: oh my dear god how is day two already this much of a tangle with several more dramatic roleclaims ten hours in]]

[[stop breaking my heart that's not allowed]] Hazel seemed distant, quiet, restless. Not like she'd been yesterday. Jean watched her anxiously from Ebony's side, initially wrestling with her desire to keep warm and comfy with the Fire-type - but then moved over to throw her arms around Hazel's...

[[I need to go to bed, and will do some rereading and retrospectiveing tomorrow (didn't have much mafia time today at all), but this definitely strikes me as an interesting point. Still need to go back and reread to be sure what I think.]]

Jean shivered. It wasn't fair that she couldn't just make internal fire like a real Vulpix, and instead just had to feel extra miserable in the cold. She leaned against Ebony's warm Houndoom body and wrapped her arms around her. Ebony was good, and the people who were suspicious of her didn't...

Dave hadn’t slept much. Again. He listened to the debriefing, silent, until Pop brought up the Substitutes. “Excuse me, what? They’re coming along? Doesn’t that risk them, you know, just getting hit by a stray attack? All just fucking moonquaked into oblivion at the same time, before we get to...

[[newbie-friendly they said]]

[[mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmghhhhh I'm sorry Bluwii I hope you are scum]]