Search results

"Technically Rui could've been poisoned the first night, and Morgan could be the Drunk. Everything still lines up that way. I think." Dave had a pounding headache at this point. What he wouldn't give for a fucking drink. "But I'm not wildly inclined to assume that's what went on here. I still...

[[Perks of being in Spain: realizing when I get up that it's not actually mafia EoD yet]] "Well, in the Elgyem is mafia scenario obviously Elgyem was neither Drunk or poisoned at any point. Morgan could be Drunk, but that has basically the same relevance as Morgan being poisoned every night...

Dave frowned. “Thinking about evil Elgyem does make me wonder what actually happened with the mafia’s poison in that scenario. Elgyem’s reads in that case are designed to confuse us about poisoning, but surely they must’ve actually poisoned somebody each night. N0 it could’ve been Rui, N1 it’s...

[[I’m traveling today so I’ll be a bit scarce, but I’ll try to get some posts in.]]

[[I think I'm going to have to call it here for tonight. Not wasting my ghost vote either way so at least I don't have to figure that out. Would have liked to get into some proper close reading, but the past couple days have not been kind to me in terms of free time to play mafia.]]

"The problem is then once again there aren't a lot of possibilities, are there? I think I'd have to be looking at either Spectrier or Malachai plus Elgyem, unless it's like, fucking Hareta? But also, if Elgyem is scum that changes shit about all the poisoning logic. "I was pretty sure Malachai...

"I'm also disinclined to believe Rui is scum, even if Spectrier were. The indignation seems genuine, but also, she spent a lot of time adamant that it would've been stupid to claim Investigator as scum due to the risk of counterclaims, despite that fakeclaims were guaranteed unique. You could...

Dave furrowed his brow as he reviewed Rocky's notes. "I think I would've figured a scum Spectrier wouldn't have had any particular plan behind trusting Rui's information initially. That's just kind of what you'd normally do if someone comes forth with information until there's evidence to...

[[I know that was Chibi's result - Shiny Phantump was talking about a hypothetical possibility that Drake had actually been Poisoner and Chibi read him as Scarlet Woman instead because they were poisoned, but that is impossible because if Drake had been the Poisoner, then they would not have...

"Isn't that fucking impossible? Like, if Drake was the poisoner and died yesterday, then he can't also have poisoned the fucking horse last night."

"Hang on, I'm not following. You yourself got a result saying Rui was innocent on N0. Now you're saying you ended up voting for Rui on D1 because her intel got somebody killed, because of some chain of logic revolving around Morgan being poisoned? But from your point of view, the only way Rui...

Dave sighed, looking at Odette. "No offense, but I think you're a down in a tunnel. A lot of what you're pointing to is just Morgan changing her mind in light of new relevant information, which is generally a good thing. "I have trouble believing Morgan is scum because of how yesterday played...

[[I’m at work but I’m ambivalent about Spectrier at the moment and will try to respond to Rocky later.]]

[[The way I’ve been inclined to interpret the info disruption in this game so far: - Rui was Drunk. - Mafia poisoned Morgan N0. This just kinda makes sense for them to do, I think? She’s obviously the player with the most experience playing this particular game, which makes her a sensible...

[[Fuck it, I’m just voting for the person I trust least right now. Need to sleep, won’t be here for EoD. Fingers crossed. @Inkedust Vote: Drake]]

[[I don't know that I like that we're turning on Spectrier here, a role that if town is actually very useful. At least Madeline would be a clean loss of nothing but a town slot, at this point.]]

“God fucking damn it. I keep forgetting the fucking seating order. If Madeline was evil it’d be really actively weird for them not to try to do anything about Elgyem, because if Elgyem was Empath she was definitely going to get info about Madeline. They’d have to not have a Poisoner, or Elgyem...

Dave grimaced. "I'm not completely sure we trust any of them. The simplest solution is it's Malachai and Drake and possibly Madeline. Morgan's play hasn't felt like it made sense for scum, doing a whole thing about Madeline definitely being the Demon that'd obviously call Morgan into question if...

"Close, it was that between Madeline and Watt, one was the Demon specifically." "Morgan's N1 result was that between Rocky and Madeline neither was the Demon. She thinks she was poisoned last night and thus that her N1 result was wrong."

"I--" Dave squeezed his eyes shut. How fucking old was Rocky? "It's a swear word. Something you say when you're pissed the fuck off." "Because I protected Odette, and then nobody died. The only other possibilities are that either Malachai or Drake is a Soldier and they went for him for some...