Recent content by windskull

[[Not feeling well so I'm going to wait to cast my vote or do a deeper read, but at this point I feel like it's a matter of deciding who we trust more out of Perse and Aer. Given that the only scum left is the demon, Phant logically cannot be the demon. If Phant were the demon, Perse has to be...

[[If that's the case, how do we explain the differences between Aer's result last night and the night before? I'm trying to wrap my head around that. Because for that to work one of the following scenarios would have to take place, right? 1. Aer is lying - in which case we should be gunning for...

[[Looking at this again. Short of hardcore bussing, I don't think Aer/Persephone is a likely pairing based on the D2 gameplay. Because of that, the list is really more like... -Chibi/Phant (Phant is not the demon) -Chibi/Aer -Chibi/Persephone -Aer/Phant(Phant is not the demon) Or I was...

[[Or maybe they'd have like a 5% chance as being right if Jackie is town? Either way like. That's weird. Either chibi is not poisoned/drunk or they're lying I think. And given player composition I'm inclined to believe the latter]]

[[Hey hold on a sec. Given that drunk, as I understand it, would have gotten a random result... If Chibi was drunk/poisoned, that would be a 1/22 (or 1/21 given their own presumed undertaker role?) chance that they'd read Jakie as the ravenkeeper role, right??? It's not impossible, but it is...

[[I'm going to come back to try and detangle my thoughts on all the info thus far but for right now I do want to at least put some thoughts out regarding the remaining living players that aren't more or less townlocked. Namely, if UA wasn't the demon, which they obviously werent, and Chibi...

[[Although not rocksolid, I do think it's the most likely scenario. Elgyem got conflicting answers on N1 and N2. That means they're either lying, poisoned, or drunk. While lying or drunk are TECHNICALLY possible, poisoned makes the most sense. Its just a matter of which day they were poisoned...

[[Wanted to be active but haven't had time to be, life got in the way. I still maintain that the best elimination is one of Chibi/UA, but I need to reread the thread before I make a decision on which.]]

{{One thing I want to point out: if Morgan is scum, then Madeline is almost certainly not, and could only be scum of one of them is a spy. This seems unlikely when the setup of Demon/Scarlet Woman/Poisoner seems far more likely. And given the conflicting results Elgyem got, there is presumably a...

[[Quick point of clarification - It's not Dave that Chibi would get a read on, assuming they're being honest, it's Drake. Chibi would get the role of the day elimination, not whoever the demon killed. More thoughts later bc I'm at work and we're busy lol. Will be poking in on the thread to keep...

[[Fwiw, I don't see any universe where she is anything other than drunk, poisoned or scum. And I think drunk tracks more with her play. Her claim was that Hareta or I was the scarlet woman. I can't be the scarlet woman because I wouldn't have died to Odette. If I understand order of operations...

"Well shit, short of a counterclaim from the rat guy" —Watt jabbed a paw over his shoulder— "that pretty much solidifies Dave's claim, doesn't it? Not many alternative options. Malachai already confirmed he's not a monk or a soldier."

[[Man if I was poisoned fuck me I guess lmao]]

[[Fair point that I overlooked. Thanks.]]

Name Claim Read Notes Dave/mighteyena None Neutral Neutral but leaning sus. Again, I struggle with reading Free. That said, based on current information I feel pretty confident that one of Dave or Drake is scum, but not both. Drake/Rattata None Mild sus Current gameplay feels in line with...