Search results

[[...Okay but Pano is confirmed mafia, so that scenario doesn't work.]]

[[Uh, I mean. If I were mafia, why would I need to be a tracker because Pano just could have told me. Because we'd be scumbuddies.]]

[[But one of the protected people is Inke, and the whole solve falls apart if Inke is mafia anyway. I don't think it's possible for a solve to not involve at least one person we're assuming is town.]]

[[Ah, I see, I was focused too much on Inke's inspection, yeah. Hm. I admit I'm struggling to come up with a watertight plan if Dawning is mafia, since they could change anyone's target. I admit it's not a scenario I considered likely.]]

Jet paused for a moment before extending a paw to the human with the silver hair, before the floor could melt and pull him away. "Hey, you ain't half bad."

[[I think I've said everything I need to. The last thing I wanted to do was come up with a night action plan. How does this look? - Dragonfree heals Inke - Inke inspects Chibi - Chibi tracks Bench - Bench protects Chibi - Starlight mails Bench - Dawning forces someone's target? I thiiiiink...

[[I thought of something else that might help. There are a couple reasons why the same action take by two different players might imply very different things: - Gamestate - Information level - Player temperament There is no such thing as "X action is scummy" or Y action is towny" because it...

Jet looked down. She'd been expecting this moment to feel cool and triumphant. It didn't feel triumphant at all. [[I wanna kinda step back from the game a bit and say that you're not a shitty mafia player at all Pano. To the contrary, I think you played quite well. There's been a huge amount...

[[The problem isn’t that it’s impossible for a town Pano to have had that train of logic. The problem is having that train of logic, and being a confirmed roleblocker in a game with little other disruption, and already being a suspect from earlier, and the unfortunate process of elimination...

[[This is pedantic, but I do want to correct the misconception that so many roles might get feeback if they were blocked: Absorber - passive, you might simply assume no one targeted you Bus Driver - You can only know you were blocked if other people disclose their action log, by spotting a...

[[Town roleblock isn't even that weird--Dawning was one in Fall Mafia and Yellow was one in Role Overdrive, and several town Jacks have had a oneshot roleblock. I just find mafia!Inke a much taller order than mafia!Pano. If Starlight is scum, then the scumteam better have 4 members because a 3...

"My voice was an idiot and made this mistake before! The only ones who'd ever know are the one who got Info."

"Maybe not if the Nosepass wasn't tryin' to kill us, though. We don't know what he was plannin'." [[I might just have ptsd from 2nd anni. Three mafia seems too easy, but maybe it would've been harder depending on who rolled what. It could have just been extraordinary bad luck that the...

[[Preeetty sure we have a game solve. Steven's flip will clear Inke, Dragonfree will obviously protect Inke, Inke can cop either one of the remaining suspects or me, and I can track a suspect (thus Inke can prove my intel is good.) Oh, and Dawning can make one of the suspects target the other...

"Bahaha of course! I shoulda known! Welp, that settles it!" [[Negrek games always have a Backup, and Inke has been hinting Backup for quiiite a while. Even if Inke was like, a Mafia Rolecop who'd checked Qitlan's role, softclaiming Backup so early when Negrek always includes them would be...

"Right, yeah. We know the Nosepass prolly wasn't killing anyone, unless he tried to and got stopped. So only one of us havin' a brand-new power would make sense."

"I just thoughta somethin'. The rules book says that two people got brand new powers not listed anywhere. But no one's claimed anything like that." [[Negrek explicitly said two custom roles. We've seen zero. Wind as a modified watcher matches the "may have additional modifiers applied"...

"Yeah, turns out after all that, none of this was useful anyway," Jet grumbled. [[From the moment Steven claimed, I knew my track log was going to be useless. Steven already all but said he blocked Altair every night, so that rules out catching either of them in a lie. Burhalla already...

"I tracked Steven Night Zero, Dorien Night 1, Altair Night 3, and Steven again Night 4. No drawbacks cuz it ain't as good as a watch power."

Jet sighed exaggeratedly. Of course she should have expected him to tell the truth about his power, even if he was a bad guy. "That makes sense," she grumbled reluctantly. "But it don't mean anything about what side you're on!" "He's tellin' the truth about always goin' for the same...