Search results

"All right, I went back through all my notes on Phoebe to see if anything stuck out in light of her claim. Let's see..." "Just stopping by the softclaim again, I found it kind of noteworthy that she said specifically only after the night happens. That's something that very specifically implies...

Jack blinked hard. What had just happened? "Okay, so. Phoebe says she's vigilante, only a variety who has to shoot someone every night, and she's the one who killed Cygnus. Isaac says that he's PGO, but I guess hasn't caused any kills yet? Like I said I'm kind of skeptical of the concept of...

[[Wait, no, Gun-Crazed Redneck is vigilante, Trigger-Happy Redneck is PGO. I was confused on what Pano was actually claiming. Goddamn it Sind]]

(Oops posted early, hang tight)

Jack pinched the bridge of his nose. "Okay, uh... Sorry, what?" "Paranoid gun owner is normally a passive role. You'd just kill whoever targets you in the night, automatically. Usually you wouldn't know who you shot.

Jack waved awkwardly at the gathered players. "Yeah, uh, hi. I'm a doctor too, who could've guessed." He threw a small smile at Stracion. "I healed her both nights. Like I said, we just kept vibing. Last night, I was already pretty sure she was also a doctor and that the mafia might've figured...

Oh noooo, Kierannnn. All of these three are very much tackling his issues in full force during the DLC story, which gives them a fun sense of overarching thematic connection - though it will be fun to also see the others cover some broader ground! :unquag: Oh no. I enjoy the progression and...

Jack was getting a headache. "So... yeah, if we're really dealing with something like everyone's a doctor or a PGO, and the setup allows revealing your role PM, it kinda would make sense the mafia would've had to get fakeclaim role PMs, because otherwise they're just at an inherent disadvantage...

"Hmmm..." Jack frowned. "I'm looking back at what Victoria's been saying again and realizing technically she just talked about 'multiple people working against us' originally, which could have just meant multiple parties? It was Sriracha who explained the mafia team normally only kill one player...

Jack took a deep breath, rubbing his temples. "Okay, I'm still not totally sure about Anubis. Doctor's not a bad fakeclaim for mafia, other than the possibility of getting counterclaimed, and in a game where there can be multiple doctors, it's not really a counterclaim. And it looks like Anubis...

Jack remembered something suddenly. "Hey, Stracion. You went 'Wait a sec' like you'd just realized something after Anubis's doctor claim but before Sriracha's counterclaim. Is that anything relevant, or something better not said?"

"That'd be the point, yeah. There's a possibility that someone's a watcher or paranoid gun owner and could falsify the claim if they claim wrong. Good odds that nobody could falsify it either way, though."

"If there are multiple doctors, then that pretty much guarantees that the mafia has something like a strongman kill, right? Because otherwise the two doctors could just heal each other every night and be invincible. Strongman is on the role list, so that probably makes sense?"

[[Posting your PM or quotes from your PM is almost always forbidden because it'd be a really cheap way to verify someone for sure. I couldn't find a reference to it in the signup rules but I highly doubt it'd be allowed.]] "I think it means that if a mime gets nightkilled, then all the mimes...

"Uhh, okay. The game setup described duplicate roles as a thing that can happen in it. So honestly I don't think it's impossible there are two doctors. So maybe they just are both docs? If one of them were lying, it'd probably be more likely to be Anubis, because like people have gone over...

Jack returned from a quick trip to the bathroom. "Wait, what."

Jack shifted on his feet, uncomfortable. "Honestly, Anubis, if you're really a town power role the damage is already done. Mafia already knows you're apparently super valuable to town, and can probably make a pretty good guess as to how, and if their guess is wrong it's probably because they...

"Okay, so here are my thoughts on everyone so far." Derek - Not feeling amazing about him, if I'm honest? The only thing he said yesterday was sort of suggesting that we should eliminate somebody, but then he never showed up to vote or anything, and then first thing this morning just sort of...

"As I understand it normally a paranoid gun owner would die if they're shot, yeah, just also kill the person who targeted them." "If there's one mafia team I'd say that's likely to be three people here. That'd be about normal proportions. If there were two mafia teams they'd probably have to be...

Jack thought back to everything he remembered Cygnus saying yesterday, cross-referencing with a small notebook. "Hmm... Cygnus didn't say all that much yesterday, did he. But thinking about it, while we were thinking the preoccupation with the idea of a third party might have suggested he was...