Search results

“…Yeah. I’m aware,” Wes said wearily. “But, hey, that makes two of us who did stupid things during all of this, right? You understand better than anyone what it feels like to be so certain about a theory, only to be completely wrong.”

[[Fair, I can see why withholding this information would be beneficial to town and unhelpful for mafia.]]

“I’ve said it a thousand damn times, but I’ll say it again, nearly all of my suspicion of Anti was from Bart defending him out of nowhere while acting suspicious as hell. Looking back, I realize it was a flimsy argument. But that’s where my suspicions came from.”

[[….then why, on multiple occasions, did you refuse to reveal it? Were you hoping to fool the mafia somehow into thinking there were more OSBP players? Because I don’t think anyone was actually considering that possibility anyway.]] Wes let out a weak laugh and ruffled a hand through his hair...

“That’s…totally fair, to be honest,” Wes said, a little sheepishly. “I outlined my suspicions of you many times, and I really, truly did think I was on to something. When Anti flipped innocent, I realized I’d wasted so much of my time and everyone else’s time. I don’t have anything better to...

[[Just pulling this up as well; Tetra brought up two sets of lovers briefly iirc, but other than Tetra, Free was one of the first to bring up the possibility of two lovers. Which is an interesting assumption to make in a vanilla game! You just ignored the fact that I said I didn’t know who the...

[[Now this is amusing! Because I only tunneled on the lovers before they made their claims. Kent made an early soft claim, but nobody believed him and was prepared to lynch him anyway because of the suspicious play style. I tunneled on Clovis after Hana’s claim because I was SURE that, at the...

The last two quotes were before the lover claims. The last one in particular, of my reads, was being typed up WHILE Tetra posted her lovers claim, so I didn’t see it until after I posted and I feel like I made that pretty clear. I changed my reads list after that. Nice try with pulling my words...

[[Just gonna pull up a few quotes for everybody to consider! Dragonfree was the first to directly hint at Clovis’ lover role. Clovis originally only stated that he knew who the lovers were, not that he was one. Also pulling this up, in which Dragonfree defends Phan. I understand that it might...

[[Hecc this was my bad, Espy is also lumped in with Astrid in that we don’t know their alignment. BUT I’m with Chibi on everything they said and I just can’t convince myself fully that Espy is scum.]]

[[lol well if that isn’t a punch to the gut. 🙃 Let’s see: on D1 I begged the real cop to stay silent and not reveal themselves. I also very adamantly told everyone not to vote for either lover pair, despite the fact that there was tons of suspicion directed at any of them that I could have...

[[I find this extremely odd that you’re suddenly throwing suspicion at me when I’ve been playing town aggro af. What do you base your suspicion on? Also I wanna clarify that at no point did I push to kill lovers, I only speculated at the possibility of mafia lovers existing. Even if they do...

[[idk I’m just very very not convinced that Espy is scum because of all the misplays, and her innocence doesn’t prove your innocence because you could still be scum lovers.]] [[This is admittedly my biggest hang up. But what if?? They tried to vote Pixie and planned to jump ship all along just...

[[OH RIGHT. Thank you for clarifying!!]]

[[wait shoot we don’t get an extension, it’ll just be a coin flip with a tie. Extensions are only for D1 if I’m remembering correctly. So @Homestar! or @Fusion your votes will be the deciding ones!!]]

[[YEP OKAY WE ARE DOING THIS]] VOTE: HAZEL

[[ALSO Pixie voting for Espy right out the gate today and Hazel also voting for Espy has me extra suspicious now. Oh no oh no oh no oh no]]

[[I am losing my mind, y’all. But there’s no chance of me changing the vote train rn…unless? @Fusion what are your thoughts on Hazel? I’d ping Homestar but he said he’s taking a break. AGH. I’m still gonna keep my vote on Astrid for now because I think Espy is innocent and Jean tried really hard...

[[This would explain why Jean and Hazel defended Clovis and Pixie so adamantly, explains Hazel’s very random vote switch, and explains why the other pair of lovers died first.]]

[[Ok I just did a quick skim of Hazel’s posts aaaaand now I’m paranoid. Both Hazel and Jean very fiercely defended Clovis and Pixie during the D1 shenanigans. Hazel also stated many many times that she thought scum lovers was dumb, made no sense, and that she wasn’t even willing to consider the...